Press conference of the President of the Republic, Emmanuel Macron, during the European Council in Brussels.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

20 October 2017 · European Council · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Macron addressed press at the October 2017 European Council in Brussels, summarizing outcomes on defense, migration, and digital policy.
Main themes
European Council outcomes, European defense cooperation, migration crisis management, digital sovereignty and competitiveness, European civil protection force, permanent structured cooperation, European Defense Fund, asylum law reform, G5 Sahel and Africa strategy, European solidarity, Libya and Mediterranean migration route
Duration
~30 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,658
83rd percentile
Sentences
107
66th percentile
Readability
31
19th percentile
Grade
17.2
90th percentile
Syntax
3.54
95th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
42nd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 36%36%
  • Institutional 31%31%
  • Economic 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Technological 8%8%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

107 sentences in 52 paragraphs

Hello everyone. We have just concluded a European Council that was particularly rich in terms of themes, which allowed us to follow up on the proper implementation of several important initiatives, particularly in the area of defense, to advance files such as digital issues, and to discuss the future of the Union following our discussions in Tallinn.

First and foremost, I want to remind you – and this was the first main topic of discussion we expressed yesterday – around the President of the European Parliament – of European solidarity following the dramatic fires that have struck Portugal and Spain in recent days. We also mentioned the dramatic climate events that have affected Ireland and several Baltic countries; and I want to reiterate here that during this discussion, we collectively defended the idea of a European civil protection force.

This idea, which was proposed several years ago in a report by Michel BARNIER and then abandoned, I mentioned in my Sorbonne speech at the end of September, and then in front of our civil forces: it has found the support of several directly interested countries, but also of the Commission; it is supported by the President of the European Parliament. Messrs. TAJANI and JUNCKER have actively promoted this idea, and the Commission will make a concrete proposal within a month.

And so beyond the great collective solidarity that has been expressed, this Europe that protects, which we have been promoting since last May, also has concrete consequences in this area and, I hope, very soon advances.

Yesterday afternoon, the session was mainly devoted to the themes of defense, migration, and digital issues. On the subject of defense, we acknowledged the major advances made since the European Council in June based on our guidelines, to establish permanent structured cooperation.

There were several discussions, and as early as the month following the June agreement, France and Germany made structuring decisions in this area. We have made progress on these issues with several of our partners, and by the end of the year, permanent structured cooperation will be finalized.

At the same time, we must advance on the European Defense Fund, which allows us to pool funding for our research and equipment projects. And we have decided that an agreement should be reached at the Council on this fund by the end of the year so that projects can be concretely financed as early as 2019.

So, while cooperation has progressed very well since June, I personally wish that we can really finalize all the necessary decisions for the fund to materialize by the end of the year.

Regarding migration, we reaffirmed our commitment to manage this crisis together in all its dimensions, from the countries of origin to our borders. France, in this regard, has committed to tripling its contribution to the emergency trust fund for Africa by the end of the year; I have obviously reaffirmed France's commitments in the Sahel, which are already significant, both financially and in terms of military engagement, and which contribute to resolving this crisis. And I recalled the commitment for the period 2017-19 of 10,000 relocations to France in response to the Commission's call a few weeks ago.

More broadly, the debate focused on the strategy we must have regarding migration flows, whether they come from the Iraq-Syria region or from Africa. And I insisted on the need to have a fully integrated approach, meaning not only, of course, to have a very determined approach – and we debated this point extensively – regarding Libya, which is currently the key transit country on the central Mediterranean route, but also to have a very proactive approach with other transit and origin countries.

This is the approach we initiated on August 28 in Paris, which we will continue in partnership with the African Union and our African partners, but it is also the approach we are conducting throughout the Sahel-Saharan region through the G5 Sahel Force and the Alliance for the Sahel. This is also why I wanted to see both the Alliance and the G5 Sahel included in the reference elements for the work of the Commission and the Council; and this is also why it is important that the entire European Union is fully involved in this progress.

We also discussed in this context the reform of asylum law, on which we must advance more quickly, aiming for an agreement in the first half of 2018, because everyone agrees on the necessity today to finalize the agreements, our internal dysfunctions leading to a more difficult management of the migration problem today. I will return, if you wish, to all the topics in detail that we discussed during this discussion.

We continued the exchanges on digital issues, which are crucial for the competitiveness and sovereignty of Europe. We reiterated the necessity, which we had largely debated in Tallinn, to have an extremely coherent approach to digital matters. This means that digital technology requires a real strategy and a policy of transformation and investment in all European countries to foster the emergence of digital champions, but also to ensure the transition of all our citizens who will have needs for qualification or requalification.

This is what we are pursuing at the French level through the major investment plan and the transformation of our training policies. It is the requirement of fair competition among digital actors that must be one of the key principles of our digital single market. It is the necessity for digital giants to contribute to the financing of common goods and, therefore, to fair taxation because all these transformations involve financing training, transforming our economies and societies, and it is normal to call on the contribution of dominant economic actors who, today, primarily benefit from these transformations without financing them.

And finally, the necessity of security and trust in cyberspace, which requires us to protect data, to guard against cyberattacks, and to combat terrorist content online.

These principles were discussed again yesterday and reaffirmed, and in particular, we emphasized the importance for Europe to ensure leadership in innovation and to create a regulatory framework that builds trust, ensures compliance with data protection, and transparency of major platforms.

Our conclusions thus emphasized the need to develop 5G as quickly as possible, to launch new initiatives for funding disruptive innovation; and in the coming weeks, we will advance the idea of a European Darpa, mentioned a few weeks ago in Paris and widely shared with Germany and many other partners.

In terms of regulation, we clarified our commitment to the circulation of data within a framework that respects our essential rules, in terms of security or intellectual property protection, for example. And we also encouraged the Commission to present rules to increase the transparency of platform practices.

On the taxation issue, we had a debate since the interests of all member states are not the same in the current situation. It was important; we wanted to have this debate as clear and direct as possible with several countries. There is now a consensus on what has been established and discussed in Tallinn, namely that we need to advance on the subject of taxation.

The Commission is leading this, and our Ministers of Economy and Finance have also put forward an initiative. This is a necessity for the reasons I mentioned, because we have common goods to finance to which digital actors, particularly the digital giants who are subject to almost no taxation today, must contribute. There is today a wish expressed by several member states, which we fully respect, to see this work framed and informed by the debates we will have within the OECD; and for these OECD debates to inspire European solutions.

I am fully in favor of the OECD, which has made significant progress in recent years in combating tax base erosion, being able, with the determination it has shown, to inform our discussions on taxation. I am therefore in favor of this, especially since France will have a presidency to ensure next year at the OECD and will carry this subject at the top of the agenda.

We also reaffirmed, in this context, our desire to quickly define a European doctrine. That is why we asked the Commission, at the beginning of 2018, to inform the Council through the work it will provide on the subject of digital taxation.

There is a consensus to move forward, there is a necessity to advance, there are divergences that we know perfectly well are related to the economic models of different member states. And I believe that what is important to say is that it is entirely possible to combine our European competitiveness and our ability to create a digital taxation if we manage to find a collective consensus.

Today, the dominant digital actors enjoy a situation of unfair competition because we have very divergent models within the European Union; this subject is therefore an important one that we will need to advance in the coming months, but which led to very honest and direct initial discussions among us yesterday.

During our dinner, we had an informal discussion on the international situation. Regarding Iran, the European Council – following a debate introduced by Federica MOGHERINI – confirmed the commitment of all Europeans to the nuclear agreement with Iran and its proper implementation. In this regard, we had an exchange with Chancellor MERKEL, Prime Minister MAY, with very close coordination between our three countries on the Iranian issue. Our intention is indeed to do everything possible to maintain the July 2015 agreement.

Yesterday morning, I had the opportunity, and I reported to my colleagues, to meet with the Director General of the IAEA, who reported on the latest investigations and inquiries conducted on the ground in Iran. I wanted us to inform all our partners and also the upcoming decision-makers, namely the members of the U.S. Congress, about the reality of these investigations; and the meticulous work of the IAEA to monitor the proper conduct and compliance with the 2015 agreements.

I also emphasized the necessity at the European level to enable us to enforce all the terms of the agreement, that is to say, to reopen economic relations with Iran and to not succumb to any pressure of American extraterritoriality, if the American choice ultimately was not favorable to maintaining the 2015 agreement. We also decided to work actively with the United States to convince them of the necessity to grant all the procedures that will allow for the continuation of this agreement.

More broadly, I was able to share my desire to open a discussion with Iran also on ballistic activity and Iran's regional influence in several countries, which I believe is the subject of strong consensus around the table today. We were also able to have an exchange on North Korea, precisely illustrating the value of the agreement with Iran, as North Korea perfectly exemplifies the consequences of a total breakdown in discussions. And the European Council adopted very firm conclusions on this issue in line with the position that France has consistently held at the United Nations Security Council; and after the adoption of new European sanctions by our Foreign Ministers last Monday.

We then had a very rich exchange on Turkey. We agreed that we must both avoid a rupture and maintain a very firm and demanding dialogue. We must therefore adapt the content of relations between the European Union and Turkey to the evolution of Turkey itself, which shows worrying signs. The Commission will therefore examine the possible conditions of this evolution. At the same time, it is clear that these relations remain very important to face these common challenges, particularly the management of migration flows and the fight against terrorism.

We also made two more points during yesterday evening's exchange, one on Brexit in the presence of Theresa MAY, who was able to present her views; the other on trade, where I wanted to clarify the French position, reminding in this regard – as I had done in the Sorbonne speech – the necessity of a balanced policy between openness and protection, to rebuild trust in trade exchanges.

We indeed have an internal challenge: to recreate the trust of our public opinions in trade agreements, which practically no longer exists today, as we have seen and continue to see in the debates on CETA; and an external challenge, which is to have a growth agenda and to be able, at a time when the United States of America has an isolationist turn, to build strategic trade relationships with several regions of the globe.

In this context, I wanted to emphasize the necessity of reforming our European trade policy, which is based on trade agreements founded on fairness and reciprocity. And I will be very vigilant to ensure that in each of the agreements and in each of these discussions, the principle of reciprocity is well maintained, so that our stronger and more binding environmental requirements are also respected within the framework of these agreements; and so that our social criteria are also taken into account in these trade negotiations.

Finally, this re-founding of trade policy, in accordance with the wishes expressed by President JUNCKER in this area, must be subject to increased transparency in negotiations and a strict implementation of these trade rules, by quickly and firmly sanctioning dumping and unfair practices.

President JUNCKER has intervened on this subject to remind us of the strong commitment of the Commission and his personal commitment to move in this direction. And we will therefore have the opportunity in the coming weeks to have a broad discussion, based on the approach outlined in his State of the Union speech by President JUNCKER, on trade policy.

This morning, we debated Brexit with 27 members, with a very simple message in this regard: we all welcomed the unity of method and representation of the European Union behind a structured agenda and a single representative. And we all reconfirmed the desired method, discussed all the parameters of phase 1, and in particular the three structuring parameters that the negotiation mandate has given to Michel BARNIER; and to maintain a single channel of discussions around Michel BARNIER.

Recognizing the gestures of openness shown by Theresa MAY in recent weeks in her Florence speech or in her public speeches, we confirmed our willingness to engage in due course a second phase of discussions. But all this must be done in good order, fully respecting the determination that is ours, the unity that is ours, to have an extremely clear sequence of the different phases.

The report that Michel BARNIER provided on the current negotiations highlighted the fact that while these negotiations had progressed, there remained a significant financial effort to be made by the United Kingdom.

We are currently far from the mark in terms of financial commitments, and if we wish – as Prime Minister MAY committed in her Florence speech – to ensure that no one will have to pay more or receive less; and to ensure that the United Kingdom will honor all its commitments made as a member of the European Union, today I would say that we are far from having reached the necessary financial commitments to engage in phase 2. And so, while acknowledging the progress made, I want to reiterate our willingness to be extremely structured and all the work that remains to be done.

Finally, this morning before this discussion, we had an informal discussion with 28 on the agenda of the heads of state and government and the project to refound the European Union. I had hoped that we could have an initial exchange in Tallinn, which is what the Estonian Prime Minister had agreed to organize as part of an informal dinner. At the end of this dinner, President TUSK committed to providing us with an agenda, he had several bilateral exchanges in the weeks that followed, and he has today presented his agenda.

I am pleased that we can preserve the momentum launched a few weeks ago, with a reaffirmed willingness to move forward and address the issues to refound Europe. I believe that what is now proposed by President TUSK, with the support of President JUNCKER and which obviously finds support from the member states - the Chancellor reminded us on this point of our essential alignment - is to move forward in the coming months with several intentions that are perfectly reconcilable.

First, the concern for unity, we had this discussion with 28 and we must continue as long as all members wish to have this discussion together. To also have a discussion of ambition, too often in recent years maintaining unity has meant lesser ambition. And so the objective of these discussions, which must be discussions of re-founding and therefore of political ambition, should not necessarily be to agree on everything, but to accept that those who are the most ambitious can move forward while leaving the doors and windows open for others to join in due course, when they wish, the advances that will be made.

And I have reiterated this clarification of method which seems essential to me, we do not wish today to define a priori several circles but we wish that if ambition leads to having several circles, which is already the case with Schengen, with the eurozone, this should be possible. The least ambition, the definition of the greatest common denominator has never been the engine of our European Union. And so the ability to articulate unity and ambition is therefore decisive.

The innovation of this leaders' agenda is also that we can prepare in a very concerted manner each of these monthly sessions, which will be the subject of exchanges of strategic texts and not technical ones; and which will allow us to agree on the major strategic lines. And for me, what we must seek, month after month, is to agree not on texts of communiqués but on principles, on our agreements and disagreements.

And I think it is fundamental if we want to advance Europe and it is in line with the commitments I made since last May. You have just seen me transcribe the debates we had on digital issues, I did not come here to tell you "I won" or "such a state lost." On digital issues, we have agreements and disagreements, some states want to move more slowly than others, we must look at them in a very relaxed manner and at some point, we will make a decision. But we have talked about it frankly, I believe that on all subjects we must do this and at some point in the coming months, have strategic options and decisions.

As long as we keep our ambiguities, we leave the Councils saying "I am the winner and the other is the loser," each commenting on the amendment they managed to make, we do not advance, more precisely we create the cacophony that instills in our citizens the feeling that this Europe has become bureaucratic and no longer allows for a vision.

I would like to articulate the vision and concrete action, and the agenda presented by President TUSK (I believe) allows for that. So in the coming months, we will prepare each time clear and strategic texts, we will have an honest discussion and we will see what we can advance and decide at 28, with perhaps even concrete and legislative decisions during this Commission's mandate. I am hopeful, for example, that on migration we can do it, that on defense we can do it, on others they may come later; and that we can decide on each whether we are ready and able to move forward at 27 tomorrow or if we must acknowledge that because there are disagreements, some are ready to move faster than others, but leaving them the prospect of convergence.

This is the Europe I wish to advance and on which, I believe, this morning, the discussion allowed us to establish a method to keep this ambitious agenda in the coming months.

I will do everything on my part to ensure that by next summer, we have been able to decide on each of these strategic subjects, which will then allow us to advance on democratic conventions and have a clear framework for debates for the upcoming European elections. This is how we must democratically, reasonably approach these upcoming elections for our fellow citizens.

I have also noted that several member states, I think of Germany of course but also Finland or a few others, have shown interest in democratic conventions. This will be based on a voluntary basis, but we will make a proposal for a method that we are also ready to test in France, and the Commission is ready to provide its full and complete support.

As I mentioned yesterday, I confirmed on the occasion of this European Council France's attachment to European symbols such as its flag and its anthem, which are also part of our identity and which I claim on behalf of a France that is moving forward, that is leading, that is regaining its place in a stronger Europe.

Finally, I had several bilateral exchanges, particularly with the President of the Spanish Government, Mr. RAJOY: I was able to first reaffirm to him France's full and complete support in the situation he is in, and we were able to discuss and work together on an important element of the agenda that protects, on which I have committed since last May, namely that of posted workers.

That, ladies and gentlemen, is what I wanted to report from these exchanges during these two days, to tell you that in my eyes we have on this Europe that protects, this Europe of ambition and re-founding, all the advances that we have been able to discuss. I will now answer all your questions.