Speech by the President of the Republic at the General States of Food

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

11 October 2017 · General States of Food · Rungis, France

Context
Macron addressed over 900 stakeholders at the General States of Food in Île-de-France on October 11, 2017, to present interim conclusions on agricultural and food system reform.
Main themes
Fair agricultural pricing, food sovereignty, value chain dignity, food quality and safety, market imbalances, collective responsibility, agricultural reform, consumer purchasing power, food system transformation, producer livelihoods, European food policy
Duration
~87 min
98th percentile
Words
10,443
98th percentile
Sentences
313
95th percentile
Readability
38
31st percentile
Grade
16.1
84th percentile
Syntax
3.41
90th percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
39th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 59%58%
  • Institutional 19%18%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Environmental 6%6%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

313 sentences in 98 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

Dear friends,

A lot has been said, and you have returned, through – I thank you for this – your speeches and the reports from the various workshops, on many details that make up the daily lives of many of you. And I wanted to thank you not only for these presentations, for the welcome today, Mr. President of Rungis, for the welcome here in the Île-de-France region, but more broadly, for the work done over the past weeks.

Elected officials, union representatives, employers, professionals in the sector, you already have a very busy daily life, and more than 900 of you have agreed to work tirelessly for days, sometimes nights, so that this subject, these subjects that are ours and those of the General States of Food, to which I committed myself, can lead to concrete decisions.

I am aware of the tensions, disagreements, perhaps residual misunderstandings that may have accompanied these debates, but I know first and foremost that they are nothing compared to the daily lives of our fellow citizens, farmers, business leaders, and the anxiety they feel, the difficulties they face, that these tensions are nothing compared to those experienced by some of our territories that have to support this transformation and compared to the legitimate expectations of our fellow citizens who are also today concerned about the quality of their food.

But I also know that these debates have helped to resolve many conflicts, and you have said this several times, and I thank you all for it; they have allowed us to reconnect with a form of shared sense of responsibility. And I tell you here very clearly, it is my responsibility to deliver some interim conclusions from these General States, but these conclusions will mean little if they are not accompanied by a spirit of collective responsibility. It is all of you who will have to bring the results of these General States to life in your daily practices. It is you and each and every one of you, in your skills and qualities, who will have to make this work a reality.

The General States of Food have two objectives: the first, to allow farmers to live from the fair price paid, to enable everyone in the value chain to live with dignity; and the second, to ensure that everyone has access to healthy, sustainable, safe food. And what I wish for us to begin from today is not to implement a series of technical adjustments – we will go through that – but for us to collectively decide on a profound change of paradigm to build together, in light of your work, a mobilization of all and this new responsibility that I mentioned a moment ago.

What are our challenges today? We have the challenges of price that affect all actors in the chain. Today, producers in particular, but ultimately, everyone will be impacted. The challenge of food sovereignty, which is an objective we must pursue at the national level but, more broadly, at the European level. The challenge of the health of our fellow citizens as well.

We live, indeed, in a country where farmers can no longer live from the fair price paid. This observation, you have all clearly established, and not wanting to face it or draw all the consequences from it is – even when one is not directly concerned – to decide that, sooner or later, we will build the end of our own balances, the balance of some of our territories, our own independence, and even our distribution models that relied on our capacity for this collective organization.

I therefore wish for us to put a very clear end to what has become a drift. The decrease in prices is legitimate. It is expected by consumers and is legitimate when it is the result of innovations, productivity gains, an improvement in a collective process. And this is the very principle of the proper functioning of a market and the purpose, by the way, of free competition, which is to lead to the fair price, the true fair price, one that, allowing these productivity gains to be passed on to the final consumer, prevents the creation of rent effects in an economy.

But the market drifts and loses its own purpose when the price paid by the consumer decreases year after year, only following price volatilities linked to occasional global markets, but no longer reflecting productivity gains or collective innovations, but simply the imbalances of a market that, faced with 60 million consumers and several tens of thousands of producers and processors but a few purchasing centers. And so, yes, we are today not facing prices that are justly balanced for the consumer, but in many cases, prices that have become abnormally low.

We have a collective pedagogy to do on this subject. Everyone is attached to purchasing power. The government is every day, through the budget exercise in particular that it has to defend, aiming among other things at this goal. But I do not want to revisit the truisms of our collective economy for decades, even centuries. If purchasing power is achieved at the expense of the ability to hire, to invest, or to live with dignity, it is clear that it is not sustainable and not viable.

It is no longer possible today in France for a third of farmers to earn less than 350 euros a year, and I say it very clearly, we must ensure that farmers no longer depend on aid and, to do this, we must ensure that they are paid the fair price for their work. I have never heard a farmer, a peasant – because I proudly claim that word that I love – ask for aid; I have only seen women and men who did not count their hours but who asked to live with dignity from the hours worked. I have never seen a business leader or an employee of our 15,000 small and medium-sized enterprises that process these agricultural products ask for aid, but I have seen women and men who simply asked to be fairly compensated for the work done.

And so, for all these reasons, it is essential that we revisit our current balances because it is a matter of our country's ability to continue to uphold its food excellence. Because, behind the ability to sustain our farmers, there is the ability to sustain our processors, ultimately also our distributors, and all those who promote our products, our gastronomy, our craftsmanship, these international markets. Each and every one has their place, and there is a French artisanal and industrial excellence that is tied to these balances. That is why the fair price paid must be an objective and must accompany our decisions.

The challenge of food sovereignty is equally important; it is about supporting the transformation of our productive models throughout Europe, to be able to improve quality, to meet the food needs of our populations, to respond to their tastes, to meet international challenges, but to do everything in our decisions so that no sector disappears if it is still competitively viable in an equitable manner. Our food sovereignty is the possibility given to us over time to choose our model, and let us not lose sight of the medium and long term in this regard. Sometimes, by engaging in short-term battles, internal struggles, we weaken some of our sectors, taking the risk of making them disappear sooner or later and becoming completely dependent on neighboring countries, other sectors to which our constraints do not apply, which do not have our environmental requirements, which do not have our quality requirements, which do not have our organization.

What lies behind food sovereignty is the challenge of our economic and food independence, that of Europe, but also the credibility of the decisions we have to make today. And behind this food sovereignty, there are also our territorial balances because our farmers, because our agri-food companies, they are part of the balances and success of our territories. Of their balances because they maintain the landscapes, they maintain our lands – and this is where the beautiful word "peasant" comes from – and there are functions that are not just about production, and I will return to this. Functions of energy production, environmental services that we must better value but which also relate to the balances of our territories. And because behind agriculture and agri-food, there is a capacity of our territories to project themselves, to succeed in conquering the vast world. And from oilseeds to wine and spirits, meat, fruits, and vegetables, these are also our capacities to carry entire territories towards international conquests and to accompany our gastronomy, our know-how, our chefs. And all this French sector creates jobs in France; it is a capacity to give our young people expertise, a place in society. This is the policy that is tied to our ability to respond to contemporary challenges.

Finally, the health concern I mentioned, that of the health of our fellow citizens, is also one of the indispensable objectives of these General States, and on this point too, it is up to us to reconcile viewpoints. There will be no sustainable agricultural or agri-food model if we consider that environmental or health issues are someone else's problem, I tell you very frankly. I will return to this in a moment; the issue of glyphosate is everyone's problem, and it is primarily the problem of those who are in contact with this product every day. And all the problems we have in all sectors on these subjects are a shared problem, from the agricultural worker to the final consumer. And I would like that, on these subjects, together, because we will find the right organization and dare to talk about it, we can succeed in finding the collective organization that allows us to meet these challenges and not to pass on responsibilities in a sterile manner.

We will not succeed in building a sustainable agricultural model if we procrastinate because there will be health scandals, and because, sooner or later, it will be our collective responsibility. But we will not be able to translate these health and environmental challenges into actions if, at every moment, we consider that the enemy of these challenges is the industrialist, the entrepreneur, or the farmer because he is often the first victim and also the first actor. And so you will not find in me the will to sideline certain subjects or to postpone them, nor the will to stigmatize the agricultural world or the business world when we address these issues. Animal welfare, you know, the first to suffer is the breeder when it is not respected. I have never seen a breeder who did not love his animals, and a breeder, when the animal does not live well, is the first to be unhappy.

And so we must hear what some associations say, but we must also know how to support each and every one to translate it into actions. This is the spirit in which I would like us to be able to meet all these challenges, reconciled with one another, and this is how I wish we could provide a sustainable framework and clear decisions for your agenda.

So, to succeed in this profound transformation that will respond to the challenges I have just mentioned, we must make some decisions, I will return to this, which are the levers of the transition, some collective responsibilities, and succeed at the national, European, and international levels to commit to this path.

The priority – and this is the objective of this first step of the General States of Agriculture – is to ensure, as I said, that both to maintain our industrial and agricultural fabric, to meet the challenges of our food sovereignty, our farmers can live from the price paid and can transform the sector that is theirs. And for this, price and quality are the two levers of transformation. In the face of all these challenges, we all have a responsibility, and the very first is to put an end to this price war, as I mentioned. Stopping the price war means stopping the permanent devaluation of farmers' income, allowing them to live or rather to relive from their work. And when you have food prices, food products on permanent promotion, you no longer have the notion of price, and therefore nothing has value anymore.

To this end, I wish for us to be able to make some concrete decisions based on your work. The first is the establishment of a renewed contractual framework with a contract that would be proposed by the farmers rather than by the buyers, which is fundamentally important in my eyes. We will amend the law to reverse this price construction, which must be able to start from production costs. Negotiations will begin in a few weeks, and I wish for a clear commitment from all stakeholders in this regard to the ministers and without waiting for the law. This means that the proposal you just outlined is accepted; it will be translated into law, prices will be constructed based on production costs, and I want the commercial negotiations starting in November to reflect the spirit of the forthcoming law and to be subject to a commitment from all parties in these negotiations under the authority of the ministers.

But this new approach will not be sufficient because it will only be effective if farmers truly come together in producer organizations to have more weight in negotiations by taking advantage of the existing possibilities of competition law. I know the hesitations that some may have. I note that these grouping practices are not systematic. This is a mistake, and it is a profound mistake. And as true as it is that I want the State to take its responsibilities, I tell you, you must also take your responsibilities and group together much more quickly, much more massively around these producer organizations.

We will act strongly in this direction. We must have tangible results with real commercial producer organizations for milk, for example, which primarily needs it. To this end, we will condition certain aid measures on the size of commercial producer organizations. There will be a strong incentive for everyone to organize and for the irreducible elements, which sometimes persist and act against the interests of producers, not to be a fatality.

I do not want that in two years and in three years, we can continue to say: we cannot have these discussions because the organizations remain fragmented. Therefore, we will take measures to ensure that groupings take place. I want to professionalize these commercial producer organizations so that they can collectively set the prices and volumes they wish to negotiate with their buyers and so that they can work on their production costs. That is why, in order to enable farmers to weigh in on negotiations, market indicators, production costs, and standard contracts by sector must be defined. It is indeed necessary to objectify price formation in each sector. Strengthening the Price and Margin Observatory is also necessary to support them, and the sectors must allow all farmers to easily access this information.

What is behind the spirit of this reform? The desire, first of all, for a true commercial organization to finally be established so that a fairer negotiation can be conducted, but above all so that the decisions we are making are not there to protect production models that are sometimes no longer sustainable. And so I want there to be indicators by sector, by industry so that you yourselves can carry out the right regulations. There are producers today who produce under conditions that are not sustainable, who produce too little at too low qualities. They must be grouped together. And so these references will prevent maintaining abnormally high prices to protect those who do not reform. They will allow for organization at the level of each sector, to define the right reference price, and to encourage each and every one to take their responsibilities within the sector.

That is also why I want the essential contractualization I just mentioned to be done on a multi-year basis. This is a fundamental element of the transformation. You will have, depending on the sectors – and I will return to this in a moment – to decide on profound reorganizations, quality improvements, transformations to move towards more organic production or agroecology. Each time, these transformations require time and visibility. No one can transform their production model with only annual, sometimes sub-annual, visibility on purchase prices. And so I want commercial negotiations to be part of a multi-year contractualization that these contracts will carry, which will provide visibility to all actors in the chain and thus allow for the necessary reorganizations for each and every one.

We will therefore encourage multi-year contractualization over three to five years, which allows us to move out of uncertainty and to project ourselves, and this is indeed what some of you have already begun to do. When you, distributors and processors, decided to commit to either short circuits, organic products, quality improvements, or geographical indicators, you provided visibility to your producers, you contracted over the long term.

I have heard, to support this deep transformation, the requests made regarding competition law, and President CANIVET has just echoed this. Like you, I am attached to our French and European competition law because it is the framework for ensuring a fair functioning of markets, and everyone should be satisfied with it. It defines an economic public order within which the freedom of each and every one is respected, preventing the law of the strongest from sometimes prevailing. But I also know the misunderstanding that some may have when, in fact, the market is skewed by the law of the strongest and when there is a feeling of being pursued for the endive cartel or whatever, in terms of meaning, which sometimes has a somewhat absurd side when we know the reality of the economic stakes and the margins that those who have to operate today have to defend.

Therefore, for all this, I wish for the Competition Authority to be seized to provide a precise interpretation of competition law and to allow you to negotiate within a clear framework. Each time a sector seizes it, it will provide – and we will bring all the legislative clarifications to do so – the organizational framework of the sector that will allow for full clarity in the debate and legal certainty for these discussions. I also wish for the ministers to clarify in the coming weeks the possibilities that already exist in terms of competition law to discuss prices and volumes within commercial producer organizations.

Today, European competition law allows certain discussions and adjustments when they are justified by the objective pursued. Some – I think of those who, for Comté, had to regulate volumes in the markets because they defended excellence – have been able to advocate for such a cause. I want us to generalize this approach and already, under constant European law, clarify the framework within which you can organize these discussions, regulate volumes, further regulate prices, and protect the existing balances. And more broadly, it is this philosophy that will be defended in European texts, particularly the ongoing Omnibus directive and all those to come.

The State will take its responsibilities for the full application of the provisions of the law on transparency, the fight against corruption, and the modernization of economic life with effective control and truly applied sanctions. It is unacceptable that certain companies do not comply with the law by not publishing their accounts, for example, and thus distort the reality of the discussion in a sector. To this end, the administration will proceed with the injunctions and fines provided for by law.

We will also strengthen the role of the mediator for agricultural commercial relations. We must be able to act more quickly, more effectively with a real arbitration whose decision would be equivalent to an interim ruling. The Anglo-Saxon "name and shame" mechanism, which consists of publicly naming the actors who do not comply with these new rules, will be made possible, and this mechanism has been able to demonstrate its full effectiveness in other areas – I think of payment deadlines. It will also be retained for agricultural commercial relations.

Regarding commercial cooperation, we must also commit to its modernization, facilitate the departure of cooperators, renovate the governance of the High Council of Agricultural Cooperation, and encourage cooperatives to be more transparent in the redistribution of their profits to producers. These provisions guarantee respect for the values of cooperation, which are based on economic solidarity.

Finally, to combat abusively low prices and to stop the race to the bottom, I have heard your proposal to raise the threshold for resale at a loss and to regulate promotions. I am fully aware of the relevant debates you have had on this subject. We would not solve the collective challenge we face today with only the elements I have just outlined, but we must not collectively fall into any ease that would consist of reaching an agreement among producers, processors, and distributors while omitting the consumer.

That is why I am in favor of raising the economic threshold for resale at a loss for food products and regulating promotions, but in order to first guarantee a fair income for producers and that a higher quality of products for consumers can also be the collectively sought objective. And I believe that it is with this dual objective that we must approach the issue of raising the threshold for resale at a loss.

I am therefore in favor of the law that will carry these provisions and that will be presented to Parliament in the first half of 2018 and voted on in the first half of 2018 carrying this reform. But I do not wish for this reform to allow us to continue collectively as we have always done. It must also be the catalyst for a profound transformation, one that I will return to, but one of collective reorganization and organization by sector.

That is why I will ask you, by the end of the year, to work to provide full visibility on the objectives I have just mentioned, to ensure that these objectives are met, and therefore to conclude sector plans, sector by sector, by the end of the year.

The threshold for resale at a loss that we would raise alone without asking for any effort, any support, any transformation, you can see, is a form of blank check. I know that in some places, it would meet needs, but I also know that in many places where recent exchanges, the transformation of purchases from the Chinese, I will return to this, in recent months have provided oxygen, we have not made the reforms we needed to make, we have not changed the collective organization, and we will wake up in two months, in three months with the same problems, and it will end up with the Minister of Agriculture, as it has always ended, with requests for aid, restructuring, emergency aid.

If we are collectively responsible, you have your share of responsibility behind the reform that the government is ready to carry. This responsibility is also that each sector is capable of defining a productive dialogue for the future. And so, what I want is for these sector plans that you will have to prepare by the end of the year, which is a challenge that I do not underestimate but which we need, to allow us to say, sector by sector: here is what we need to be able to regroup, reconcentrate, invest in certain sectors because we must transform our offer to meet the tastes of our fellow citizens or the challenges internationally, here is what we must do to tackle the ecological and environmental transition head-on. And each sector will have to carry the transformation plan that is in a way its share of responsibility accompanying the contractualization and the increase of the threshold for resale at a loss.

I say this because the tensions of the last hours and days on this subject have shown the positional wars. The choice I want to make today is not to shift the front of battle; it is to move you from a logic of positional warfare against each other to a collective movement war where you will have to work together for the sectors to succeed. Everyone will have to make efforts, some on their margins, a little on prices, and others on their collective organization to be able to transform our sectors and our industries.

You understand, I am therefore ready to commit strongly to all the issues I have just outlined, and the minister will thus have to present to the Council of Ministers and have voted in the first half of 2018 a law that, because it must go quickly and because this commitment is as important as the one we have been able to make in other areas, may take the form of ordinances in order to indeed move faster and stronger because this commitment, you expect it and it is necessary and I owe it to you.

But in parallel, if we are ready to move quickly, to make unprecedented decisions, especially when considering the last decade, in terms of agriculture and agri-food, I also ask you for an unprecedented effort in terms of structuring sectors, deep transformation, and reorganization. These sector plans must ensure that the French can move upmarket around labels, quality signs, and organic products with quantified objectives over five years.

And so, what I ask of you is for each of you in your sectors to carry a strategy and not to wait for the strategy to be dictated by international competition, by the upcoming crisis, or, for some others, by the State itself. It is up to you to propose and carry it, and by the end of the year and at the beginning of next year, I will gather, with the ministers and particularly the Minister of Agriculture, all the sectors so that we can dedicate these documents, the strategy you will have proposed, and the transformations that accompany them.

Because beyond this price battle to which we respond with these strong commitments that mean I have heard your proposals and that I am ready for the government to carry them, it is the quality, the transformation of our sectors, and a deep transformation plan that I want us to be able to conduct together. These economic and regulatory levers will apply sector by sector, but each must carry a transformation project because I am not calling for uniformity, and on the subject that is ours, we must not have a uniform approach. There will be, there will continue to be, several agricultural models: agroecology, organic, short circuits, intensive models, export models, geographical indications.

There will always be productive plurality. There will be sectors, each with its own philosophy and its own challenges, and there will obviously be regional and local dynamics that must remain strong because the specificities are carried there. And I do not forget in this regard our overseas territories that we will support in this transformation, and agriculture and food will be part of the objectives of the Overseas Assemblies.

Each sector will have to face its own challenges, but I ask you this afternoon: even if we manage to decide on contractualization, on raising the resale price threshold, etc., do you think we can be satisfied with having 0.5% organic pork in France, 3% in Label Rouge, while we cannot meet the demand of our consumers? I do not believe so.

Do you think we can remain immobile, watching every morning the market price in Plérin, hoping that the Chinese continue to buy our products? I do not believe so, and I do not want that either.

Do you think we can reasonably continue to be organized as we are today and, in certain regions of France that are dear to me, as some of you, to watch our own exchange rate with the countries of the Near and Middle East to hope to export the chickens that we cannot or do not want to have consumed by our own population when we do not know how to produce to their taste?

Collectively, in all regions and all sectors, we have protected absurd choices. Absurd. And we have protected them because we could not solve the problem of price and economic balances. Just as I am ready to commit alongside you to solve it, I ask you to commit alongside the government to address the challenges of each sector and not to wait for the State to solve them. Solving the problem of pork, beef, milk is not about asking for the umpteenth crisis plan on the day it continues to go badly; it is about organizing yourselves in the sectors and in the territory to change the productive models.

What does this mean concretely? It means that we must look at and support export markets that will provide outlets, for example, for the fruit and vegetable sector. We know them; we are working to lift the constraints that have arisen in recent years. Continue to support the rise in quality, the rise in organic. Continue some other complementary models but have an offensive export strategy that the sector carries in which the State supports it. It means stopping productions, whether it is poultry or pork, that no longer correspond to our tastes, to our needs, and that mean we will launch competition in international markets against countries against which we can do nothing and we will be able to do nothing.

Neither against the Brazilians nor against the Russians or others on products of poor quality or average quality will we be able to reasonably support our producers in the long term, and you know it well, and we know it well. We will only give them prospects if we raise quality, if we support them. Some have already done so, and many in the territory, and I salute their efforts, but let us face each of our challenges. Each one.

And what I ask of the sectors is to consolidate all the producers who have already done this remarkable work – and there are many in our regions – who have been able to find labels, develop quality, rise with appellations, geographical indications, who have been able to consolidate and defend French quality. But also accept to look at our producers who are in a more fragile situation, who have put themselves in productive models where there is no future, and support them through investment projects, through projects where we must and where we will have to restructure sectors, it is evident.

And so all this work I invite you to do is one that consists of not promising to compete tomorrow with the farm of 100,000 cows in China nor, as I told you, with Brazil, Ukraine, or Russia on the range of frozen chickens; it is rather one that will lead us to support what has, as you have very well done in certain territories and in certain sectors, already been done very well but that we must today multiply. We must promote the Label Rouge, work on cutting, on transforming poultry in France to meet the demand of collective catering and that of processed dishes.

For the beef sector, we must develop initiatives that ensure a fair price paid to producers like "Eleveurs et engagés," remind the French through a policy that the State will support what beef farming is in France: the diversity of our breeds, the benefits of grass-fed farming, the animal welfare in which you have already engaged. And the reconquest of collective catering is also a priority for this sector in this regard.

We must rethink the slaughtering link by restructuring it, modernizing it, and relocating it in certain territories. The abattoirs of the future are a program already underway. I wish that we could accelerate it, but to support what, in the beef sector, is the place where we lose a lot of competitiveness compared to our competitors. And you can see it well, this essential investment work is what will allow us to be more productive, to go to the end of our efforts in terms of animal welfare, and that is what all those in the sector are looking for, and particularly all those who work in these abattoirs under sometimes unacceptable conditions for themselves.

And it is also perfectly coherent with the battle we are conducting at the European level to fight against illegal detached work which, particularly at the level of abattoirs, has created an unjustified French under-competitiveness.

We must cultivate our differences to evoke consumer preference. When I made the commitment during the campaign that the eggs sold to consumers would only come from free-range farms by 2022, it is also because we can together achieve this goal. It is not to stigmatize the farmers who have already made a lot of investment, but it is to say that within the framework of this sector plan that the sector will have to propose and lead, the State is ready to engage financially to support the restructuring of the entire sector through the investment plan, that large distribution must also provide visibility on volumes and a more rewarding price to allow farmers to reinvest, and that we must explain to consumers that paying a few cents more for their eggs allows for this transformation.

It is clear that if we remain in the current positional war, we will do nothing, and all those who produce eggs today consider it intolerable to explain to them that in 2022, we will only sell, for what is sold in supermarkets or retail, eggs from hens raised in free-range conditions. But it is possible if we enter this dynamic of progress movement to which I invite you all.

You understand, what I am asking of you is for each of you to do a little differently than what you have done in recent months and years. What I am asking of you – and I know you, as a candidate, I have committed to almost each and every one of you, I know what bothers you and what delights you – is to accept a little to give to the other, to make efforts because the other will also do so, but because in the end, we will have the capacity to have a stronger French model that will emerge.

These sector contracts must allow for setting objectives for internal restructuring within the inter-professions, objectives for upgrading in organic, in quality signs, environmental and societal objectives, agricultural research programs, targeting investments. It is up to the inter-professions that the State recognizes to work on this, to coordinate this work in relation to the Minister of Agriculture and Food by the end of December, and I also wish that distribution and industry participate in this. It is important for the commitment that will be theirs. We must work together on innovative investment approaches to accelerate this essential agricultural transition.

You understand, the objectives, ambitions, and support mechanisms will exist sector by sector, sometimes also territory by territory. But it is in this dynamic that I want us to engage collectively. There will be overall objectives, and I reaffirm them here before you: the commitment to reach 50% organic or local products in collective catering by 2022 is well confirmed and will allow us to rethink our food territorially and support the necessary restructuring of certain sectors; I wish that we precisely identify the missing links in production, transformation, or logistics, here too, sector by sector, territory by territory; the territorial food projects you mentioned, Mr. Deputy, must be presented to us, they will be supported, encouraged.

And you understand, the objective behind this is, in a very pragmatic way to support this determination, to be able to engage according to the sectors either in restructuring, or in productive investments for upgrading, or in investments to allow pivoting productive models, either towards short circuit models or towards organic models. It is to allow reinvestment in certain productive structures to maintain the current strategic choice but to face international competition. There will be as many responses as there are sectors and territories. This is the challenge that is collectively offered to us.

To support this transformation, the State has also made an unprecedented commitment, which is to reserve 5 billion euros in the large investment plan for the agricultural investment plan. These 5 billion euros will allow us to support these choices, sector by sector, which will be submitted and then validated, and the objective of these investments is to be able to support as closely as possible to the ground, in a pragmatic way, what will have been defined as a priority.

I will simply set a rule at this stage, which is that this aid will go to farmers and sectors and to all actors in the sectors according to what is relevant, but at most to the farmers themselves. I want them to be paid quickly, that is to say within the semester, in direct connection with the regions that know their territories and have rapid payment capabilities. And in this regard, and I know, Mr. Minister, how much you are working on this, we must completely make the agricultural world forget the past difficulties in terms of payment delays and the complexity of files to fill out. I want support in terms of investment that is simple, quick, and corresponds to the objectives determined by each sector.

To achieve this, there will need to be full accountability from all actors. That is why I want the new legislative framework to be put in place as quickly as possible, and as I said, including by ordinances, but because the State, as I told you, will not do everything; it is you who hold much of the outcome in your hands. You know, while preparing for these general states, looking at your work, reflecting on what I was going to say to you, I was recalling not only certain trips from a few months ago but also the exchanges I had with some of you present in the room or absent, which showed where solutions sometimes come from.

A few months ago, I was in Mayenne, and I remember very well a couple of young farmers, Mr. Minister, it is a good territory, who involved in the dairy sector told me all the difficulties they had to live with. They had just invested 700,000 euros, a young couple, saying, "You come back in 30 years, I will be in about the same situation because I may not even have amortized these investments, because when I am paid as I am today at - it must have been around 300 euros for 1,000 liters - you cannot live," he was not even paying himself the minimum wage! This couple managed to enter a "Who is the boss?!" approach and signed a tripartite agreement between producer, processor, and distributor.

This approach owes nothing to the State; it is one of those local initiatives made with actors who represent what you are, and they succeeded in a few months in completely changing both their perspectives and their daily lives! And we have a couple of young farmers who have visibility on their investments, earn about 1.5 times the minimum wage, and have managed to secure a contract that gives them visibility in terms of price and volume, and they have already started to move upmarket. And so they will seek, they told me, in the coming months a somewhat more specific designation, and they will be able to do like their colleagues in Salers or Comté have done to improve quality and never again be at the 300 euros I mentioned earlier.

All this to tell you that the solution is not only in a law, not only in a provision coming from above; it is also in the initiative that will be taken everywhere on the ground and by all actors. This approach, this concrete case I just mentioned, I hope you can collectively generalize it and enhance the 2.4 billion liters of drinking milk in France, commit to multi-year contracts, and the philosophy I just mentioned.

This is what I expect from you on this front; this is the collective productive transformation we must undertake. So I know there will be skeptics, there will be fatalists; you know, I have gotten used to it, more precisely, I have always refused to get used to it. So each and every one of you take your responsibilities; some will shrug their shoulders, will take on a look as if they have seen it all and will say, "We will never achieve all this," and will decide to fight as they have always fought, and then perhaps because there will be a majority of you who will have decided to take your responsibilities and that they will have by their side, as you have understood, a government that will do it, you will have changed things. I believe in the willing; I do not believe in the skeptics.

But beyond the transformation of the productive model and the shared responsibility that is ours, we must finally respond to the legitimate concerns of our fellow citizens in the face of health and environmental challenges. I told you earlier, there will be no sustainable, strong productive model for our territories and internationally if there is not a collective capacity to respond to these concerns and to have an agricultural model that meets health and environmental objectives. Our fellow citizens are primarily concerned in this regard by what I would call a new geopolitics of food, and it is up to us to provide very clear answers. I know all the concern that CETA or Mercosur can raise among the population, among certain associations, among certain producers in certain sectors; I think of beef.

I want to be very clear here; these trade agreements raise serious issues both for consumer protection and for producer protection. I had made a commitment regarding CETA, which was to entrust an independent expert commission with an evaluation of all the consequences. The report was submitted to the Prime Minister in September, all the conclusions are being drawn, and an action plan will be presented by the Prime Minister and all the relevant ministers next week with very clear measures for action, control, and regulation. In this regard, all the responses to the questions raised by the experts will be reported and translated into actions. In due course, France will have to ratify this treaty, but we will ensure that all recommendations are followed by actions based on what the report proposed.

But I also want to be very clear about the implementation of CETA; it will be, because it is thus by law and in fact, perfectly compliant with European standards on health and the environment to prevent any unfair competition in the European market. And so to be very clear, I sometimes hear talk of genetically modified salmon; if Canada wants to allow its commercialization in its own market, that is Canada's sovereign right! But insofar as French and European regulations prohibit the marketing of such a product, it will obviously prohibit it for all products imported through CETA, and controls will be stringent in this regard! And no trade agreement offers you a right that is inferior to what you impose on your own actors. There are therefore sometimes misunderstandings or falsehoods on this subject that I want to fully clarify here.

The conditions set by the expert report will be fully implemented starting next week, but all European law, all our environmental, health, and safety standards concerning all the sectors that are yours will obviously be fully defended and respected by all products imported under this treaty as under any trade treaty. I also want to complement CETA with initiatives that will ensure that French quality is recognized and valued at its true worth; the labeling of the origin of meats and dairy products must be strengthened, including in processed products, so that consumers can choose with full knowledge of the facts. I also wish to strengthen the requirements more broadly on production methods in trade agreements.

I have also understood the strong desire of the European Commission to complete ongoing trade discussions with Mercosur and more broadly to conclude and give a new turn to the European Union's trade negotiations with other regions of the world. I am in favor of fair and free trade, one that preserves the interests of each and every one, which corresponds to our own objectives and our own balances. I am in favor of making trade rules more transparent and more democratic. I have made clear commitments, and when I had to present the French initiative for Europe, I specified this.

The Commission will find France by its side when it comes to advancing in these areas, but I am not in favor of rushing to conclude trade negotiations whose mandate was given in 1999 before the end of the year. Because that is what it is about when we talk about Mercosur; it is about a negotiation mandate that was given in 1999, which was frozen for several years due to known difficulties, which then resurfaced and which we would like to conclude without any re-discussions around the table of the European Council, even though, as you all know in the sectors and concerns that are your daily life, our consumption perspectives, our industrial realities, our health and environmental knowledge have profoundly changed since then. It is therefore essential that these negotiations be updated if we want to continue them. And I will raise this issue at the European Council next week because we cannot embark on this matter in some sort of headlong rush.

Europe, food and health security are essential subjects for us to collectively succeed in the transformation I just mentioned. We experienced this last summer with the egg crisis, which showed that the challenge of food security is not just national, and only increased cooperation in the European market allows us to detect and sanction fraud. That is why I want us to collectively work towards a European investigation and control force in terms of health and food safety; this is the proposal I made, and on this aspect, I hope we can collectively advance at the European level.

The rejection of chemical products, the preference for natural food are social currents, and as I mentioned earlier, it is both the anxiety of consumers, the legitimate concern of fellow citizens, but also the concern of the entire agricultural world and their employees. That is why our agriculture must reduce its dependence on chemical inputs that pollute our soils, our waterways, and our aquifers. I know in this regard that much has already been undertaken and much has been done by the agricultural world in this area. I want to ensure that there are no shortcuts, and I commend your efforts made in this regard, but we must go further together; it is no longer a matter of spending our time contesting that the use of phytosanitary products threatens the health of consumers or farmers or biodiversity; it is a matter of seeing how we can collectively put ourselves in a position to address this problem!

I have heard the criticisms of our announcements regarding neonicotinoids, endocrine disruptors, or glyphosate; my responsibility is to set the course, this ambitious trajectory that I fully assume, but then that each and every one of us can also concretely and proactively outline the ways and means to achieve it. I will tell you frankly, the right debate is not whether to phase out glyphosate in 10 years or in five years; it is as if I were telling you that politically we can regulate the speed and reality of our technological innovations. I think the right debate is first to say at the European level that postponing the glyphosate issue to 10 years is not a good idea because it is taking responsibility in the face of history. Moreover, France has always held this position, which is consistent with our demands.

But then at the national level, we have only one collective objective, which is also to help farmers find the best organization, first to give them more independence regarding this issue. Many have also done this; considerable efforts have been made, but I have made a commitment, it will also be in the law, to separate advice from sales. For many phytosanitary products, there is still a linked sale that means that the advice is not independent, and the law will separate the sale from the advice.

Next, it is to look sector by sector at how we can better dose; some sectors are exemplary in this regard, and we will highlight the good practices that have been made and promoted by the agricultural world. But we must generalize them and look at what, without innovation, also allows us to reduce doses and improve working conditions for farmers and conditions for our fellow citizens. And then we will have a proactive investment program in research to enable each place, in each sector, to find the substitute solution.

What I guarantee you is that there will be no deadlock, nor the deadlock that consists of saying "we do nothing, we make no effort and we push the problem to tomorrow" because it is a moral deadlock to which we will all be led. Nor the deadlock that consists of saying "I will oppose farmers with a lack of solutions or substitute products but I will give them a goal without helping them." I also want there to be responsibility, that over time we work to find the right solutions, they will unfold, by looking at alternatives such as biocontrol, by supporting farmers in good practices, by quantifying costs and financing to support these transformations, by looking at the impacts also on labor and the constraints that this sometimes imposes, I do not underestimate them, and by supporting them and dosing as necessary the recourse deemed essential or without substitution, it is a pragmatism to which I invite us collectively. And here too there are no winners, there are no losers in this debate, there is a collective intelligence to translate into action in our country because you are collectively the first concerned.

I am not unaware of the upheaval of these commitments on your very way of working the land, its impact on yields, the extreme changes that we will have to face and that we need to rethink but what lies behind all this is that we must collectively rethink a new agricultural France because the model in which we have become trapped is not sustainable. So, you can see, from price to industrial transformation to the necessary transformation to meet our environmental and health objectives, it is the invention of a new agricultural France that we must collectively lead, we are here to transform together, to find the right solutions. They will also require that we can, in terms of research and training, make courageous decisions. I wish that everywhere on all subjects we can be exemplary in terms of expertise and independence of expertise.

Each of the subjects I have mentioned, and I am not exhaustive here, you know sometimes much better than I do, each of these subjects is the subject of rich and legitimate societal debates but each of these subjects also puts us in front of a democratic duty, that of enlightening the debate. Very often there is not one good decision to be made, there is a lesser evil to preserve and there is ultimately a good decision to support. I therefore wish that we can build the conditions for independent scientific expertise in France on each of these subjects and that we can have the same requirement at the European level. We have, on all these subjects, suffered too much pressure in recent years, too many hidden interests and industrial expertise that are in no way scientific expertise.

In this regard, we are collectively wasting time and we are also losing a certain democratic requirement that is that of our fellow citizens. We will therefore put ourselves in a position on each of these subjects to have independent experts on a scientific level, that is to say experts whose academic knowledge and international academic recognition we first know but also their financial independence from existing pressures, it is a reality, we must face the facts!

I sometimes see you express a form of dissatisfaction or doubt about what I am saying, perhaps it displeases you but I am not here to please, I am here to work with you. Because we need this otherwise we will be constantly caught in the stuttering of interests, one day we will follow one because he makes advertisements or because at a given time he says this then the next day we will follow the other, no, let us try to build a shared truth, collectively constructed, and it is essential that at the European level we have the same requirement. In the same way, I wish that we continue to preserve the model of excellence in terms of agronomic research that is ours, we have the first agronomic research institute in Europe.

That is why I wish for better coordination between INRA, the chambers of agriculture, and the technical institutes that must work together in a concerted manner at the national level but also regionally. The sector plans must also mention the priority research work to be carried out and the necessary investments. Here too we will have a proactive investment policy on the programs that are perceived as the most important to support each sector in its transformation.

It is also important to support the training of the youngest, the students of the Bougainville agricultural high school who are present with us are indispensable witnesses to this ambition but we must also adapt our training and continue to do so to the contemporary challenges that are ours and to the transformation that we are sharing and collectively supporting. It is also important to better value and remunerate the environmental services that farmers are capable of providing to the community by acting to preserve soils, waters, biodiversity and to fairly remunerate these services. I have made a commitment, it will therefore be followed by actions with 200 million euros for the remuneration of these environmental services.

And here, I do not want to reopen these well-known subjects between pillar 1 and pillar 2 which may not speak to many people in this room but which will evoke a painful past for others in this room, when I made this commitment I did not necessarily anticipate that there had been financial commitments and then that there had been commitments towards you and that one and the other were not totally aligned. So I do not want to reopen what has been decided in recent months, during the two years of this CAP I wish that on these environmental services we can support through the large investment plan these measures by making direct aid to farmers and that then we can integrate it into the budgetary framework and the new CAP to be in line with the commitments made and with what you legitimately wish to be able to support.

I also wish that we can fully support the agricultural world, in the productive, energy, and environmental model it carries today. Farmers today are actors of decentralized energy production and the transformation of our landscapes and our productive models. On this subject, they are confronted with administrative complexity and so if we want to support this transformation or in the law precisely and the ordinances concerning the transformation of the agricultural world and acknowledging your General States of Food or in the draft law on the right to make mistakes we will take drastic simplification measures to reduce the delays to which farmers are currently subjected when they want to carry out energy projects, legitimate valorization projects of their production on the ground.

I know the delays that are yours when you want to move to methanization, when you want to better valorize your production and produce energy. This was recalled earlier by several of you, it is a source of income, it is a source of productive balance and when I look at our German neighbors a significant part of their margin today comes not from the sale of meat but from alternative sources of income, particularly from the production of energy that they are capable of producing.

Here is what I wanted to provide as concrete responses on this subject by telling you that beyond these commitments we will collectively have to lead in-depth projects that will allow you to continue the work of these General States of Food beyond the second phase that you are now going to begin. First because, you have understood, I am counting on you to finalize a substantial work, I am counting on you to in this second phase go to the end of the industrial productive transformation but also the environmental transformation of our models.

But because we will also need to think in the agricultural and agri-food world about our entire prevention strategy, it is not just health and social, it plays out from agricultural production and the collective organization of the agricultural world. Because you have already been able to implement measures to combat waste but because we must also collectively act to combat food insecurity and food imbalances. In this regard, the Minister of Health as well as the Minister of State have strongly committed with the Minister of Agriculture to carry this vision.

You will also have to lay the groundwork for our new negotiation for the Common Agricultural Policy and I cannot conclude this speech, even if it is provisional on these General States without saying a word about this Common Agricultural Policy. I indeed wish that this agricultural policy can rely on the sector strategies that you will have to propose, that is how we must build it. I do not wish for us to defend it as a kind of retinal persistence of a model that is passing and that we want to change. I wish that we can carry a new Common Agricultural Policy that is up to the new French agricultural policy that we want.

That is to say that I wish that we can assume a real policy of quality and food sovereignty and fair pricing that I have just defended but also of aid and investments at the national level to defend our preferences. And that the Common Agricultural Policy can become, without any taboos, a real policy that will provide us with assurances, counter-cyclical guarantees and also with a sector-by-sector approach because the dynamics and realities are very different according to them, which will protect European agriculture from the shocks of global price volatility, imbalances and which will allow each country to pursue its sovereign choices, each territory to pursue its excellence and each and every one to pursue its objectives. I therefore wish that we can, in the perspective of this new policy that will have to be deployed after 2020, carry our own national ambitions and that your work can prepare this strategy that France will have to lead.

You will have understood, I expect a lot from these General States of Food and the work that you will have to carry out in the coming months because it is about our agriculture and that our farmers deserve it and that I will always be by their side to defend them. It is about our agri-food industry because there is a French excellence in this area. It is about our gastronomy, it is about our distribution, it is about our territories and their balances and therefore the strategy that we have to conduct and put into action from today is a profound challenge that is not just economic, it is a challenge of territories, of civilization for the country because it is what our fellow citizens are eminently attached to and I am attached to it like them.

That is why a law will be presented in the first half of 2018 to carry all these conclusions, that this law may take the form of ordinances to go faster and have a complete promulgation by the end of the first half of 2018 at the latest. That is why I expect from you by the end of the year the conclusion of these sector contracts and that is why at the beginning of next year we will meet to take a new stock of these General States of Food recorded in these contracts, define the strategy and establish an investment strategy to support the actions that will be yours, ours. And, you have understood, your work will continue to prepare this, the next Common Agricultural Policy, every year of the five-year term you will be brought together to evaluate the work and its implementation and I wish that at mid-term there can be a parliamentary evaluation in light of your work and in light of any independent expertise that parliamentarians wish to solicit so that, if necessary, the required legislative changes can be decided but in light of your actions, in light of our transformations.

What I expect from you, Ladies and Gentlemen, to conclude, is to recreate trust, trust among all actors, trust in our territories, trust in our country, trust with consumers and citizens because everything I have mentioned since the beginning of my speech, from prices to environmental issues, is a matter of trust. France will be strong in these territories as well as internationally if we can collectively restore it, collectively, and so, you have understood, you can count a lot on me because I have decided to count a lot on you. Thank you.