SPEECH BY THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

21 September 2022 · Christchurch Call summit

Context
Macron addressed the Christchurch Call Summit on September 21, 2022, reviewing progress and outlining next steps to combat online terrorist content and misinformation.
Main themes
Christchurch Call, online terrorist content removal, digital public order, misinformation and propaganda, algorithmic transparency, artificial intelligence in content moderation, Digital Services Act, GIFCT governance, platform accountability, online radicalization, public research access to platform data, Ukraine war disinformation
Duration
~12 min
41st percentile
Words
1,386
41st percentile
Sentences
59
39th percentile
Readability
50
63rd percentile
Grade
12.1
46th percentile
Syntax
3.10
60th percentile
Vocabulary
1.95
6th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 45%42%
  • Technological 24%22%
  • Social 16%15%
  • Ceremonial 11%10%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

59 sentences in 9 paragraphs

Thank you, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern.

Thank you, ladies and gentlemen, for being here. This new summit of the Christchurch Call has indeed allowed us to advance behind closed doors, as is the rule, to discuss with major platforms and social networks what I will call the digital public order. I want to acknowledge the work that was initiated by the Aqaba process, particularly with strong involvement from the King of Jordan, which we launched in recent years with the Tech for Good summit. And indeed, as the Prime Minister has just reminded us, what we initiated after the terrible terrorist attacks in Christchurch, launched in Paris in May 2019 together, with the desire to involve states, NGOs, academic actors, and the companies most concerned with social networks, online services, and messaging.

This is a crucial debate, and fundamentally, the challenge we face is how to build a public order in this space where our children and we ourselves operate every day and increasingly. That is to say, rules that allow us to avoid hate speech, to prevent it from escalating to terrorist acts, and to protect. In this regard, this is what enabled the adoption of the Digital Services Act within the European framework to regulate digital content, create systems of accountability, and provide better protection. The context we are currently experiencing of war in Ukraine and its repercussions on all fronts, including the proliferation of misinformation and online propaganda, which are often the root causes of violence, shows how essential this debate is. Since 2019, as the Prime Minister recalled, we have made real progress and achieved real results. Since 2019, the Christchurch Call has demonstrated that it is possible to remove violent or terrorist content online. And this so-called "golden hour" works, and we have been able to test it. And so we have now established regulations in several of our countries to make this, I would say, a permanent fixture. But we have also seen proactive behavior from the platforms to help us technically remove online content, ensuring that this removal happens within the hour, and we saw this, for example, with the Buffalo attack. And all of this is what we learned from previous attacks, particularly right after Christchurch, where we saw millions of people trying to re-upload the most horrific scenes.

Furthermore, another real achievement is that we have truly established a governance structure, the GIFCT, which is functioning, on which we have secured more funding. We will continue to mobilize them because this is what allows us to make this rule effective, so to speak, with 24/7 monitoring, and thus a real mechanism of accountability. And then, our community is growing with more than 50 partner states, new partner digital platforms like Zoom, Clubhouse, Roblox, and thus a real advancement on new digital frontiers.

Now, we want to go further. The Prime Minister reminded us: to fight more effectively against misinformation and propaganda by multiplying positive interventions on networks. We want to go further with several axes. The first is to have this essential work on algorithms. We launched it a few months ago. The agreement announced with New Zealand, the United States, Twitter, and Microsoft is very important because, in particular, there are exchanges of algorithms and data that are confirmed by Twitter, and I want to commend their commitment. This is a step forward and a very important element. What we fundamentally want to do is to acknowledge that when we know nothing about algorithms, we cannot guarantee that they do not lead to behaviors that may be risky, where they may not be as effective as we would like in preventing. And so improving prevention means deciding to have a real partnership on algorithms, to share information, to succeed in having the most effective approach possible with all platforms. Many technical arguments had been raised against us until now. A lot of work has been done, and we will continue to do so to improve things.

The second key element is artificial intelligence. Whether it is social networks or messaging, whether they use algorithms or not, it is clear that with artificial intelligence, we can much better prevent what leads to hate speech, then online radicalization, up to risks of terrorist behaviors. And so, on this, we will continue to apply pressure to have very clear commitments on this subject. The third point is research and public research, and in this regard, commitments have also been made during this meeting. They are very important. We have done this, for example, in health, but we want to continue to develop a model of public research on these subjects. Why? Because I was talking about digital public order. It is very simple. Our partners, the platforms and social networks, must accept that researchers can have access for a given time to their data, to their information. So that they can conduct independent, transparent, and public research, which is the very nature of research, and thus it should not simply be proprietary, and it helps us to better understand and helps them to better prevent. And so, in this regard, we have also made progress on this point.

We have also discussed, and we wish to go further together, the issue of the dark web where it is clear that today, we have terrorists who are storing extremely problematic and dangerous content in our eyes and who are somehow using the lack of regulation in this space. And so, we want the Christchurch Call and our forum to also address this space. You understand well, we have succeeded, we are succeeding, there is still work to be done, we need to consolidate the resources we put into it, to remove so-called terrorist content much more quickly, to qualify it, to have a common definition, and to have monitoring mechanisms. We want to improve their effectiveness by asking social networks to invest more money. Now, we are putting all our energy into preventing radicalization, hate speech, everything that leads to terrorism, and thus to work on: algorithms, the dark web, artificial intelligence, and public research.

The last point is the protection of children. This is a very important subject that is twin to the one we are discussing. We have long discussed the fact that today, many of our children are exposed to inappropriate content, but especially that the development of many games and immersive spaces has impacts on our children and on their relationship to violence and behaviors that can lead to the worst. In this regard, the young age of many perpetrators of terrorist acts, everywhere in the world, cannot leave us without reaction. On this subject, as you know, we launched a call for the protection of children in the digital age almost a year ago now, at the Paris Peace Forum. We will continue this work in November in very close collaboration with the Prime Minister to strengthen the protection of our children against online harassment, against all, precisely, the content, games, and systems that are considered dangerous for our children. And in this regard, what we want to do is to see how the protocols we have developed within the framework of Christchurch can be applicable to the protection of children online. On this, it is clear that today, we must improve prevention and education for our children. We must improve our regulation, and we are doing this in several countries, but we need to coordinate. We must also improve moderation elements: platforms are not doing enough work to moderate content in our languages to protect our children. We also want to push for the consideration in the design of the architectures and systems of these different games, immersive systems, the consideration of the interests of our children, their protection, and the fact that sometimes they are addressing minds that are still developing and who do not have the codes, and for whom this can lead to choices, attitudes that can then feed this violence online and in reality. That was an additional axis I wanted to add to the work being done.

I want to thank Prime Minister once again for our wonderful cooperation, for the initiatives that we continue to relaunch, and I believe in the importance and strength of this Christchurch Call.