Speech by the President of the Republic at the opening of the International Humanitarian Conference for the Civilian Population of Gaza.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

9 November 2023 · International Humanitarian Conference for the Civilian Population of Gaza

Context
Macron addressed heads of state and ministers at the International Humanitarian Conference for Gaza's civilian population, held in Paris on November 9, 2023.
Main themes
Humanitarian crisis in Gaza, civilian protection, Hamas terrorism, Israeli right to self-defense, humanitarian pause and ceasefire, hostage release, two-state solution, Middle East peace process, counterterrorism coordination, Palestinian statehood, international humanitarian law, humanitarian aid mobilization
Duration
~16 min
55th percentile
Words
1,944
55th percentile
Sentences
96
61st percentile
Readability
36
28th percentile
Grade
12.8
55th percentile
Syntax
2.91
35th percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
49th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 41%39%
  • Ceremonial 24%23%
  • Social 21%20%
  • Institutional 9%8%
  • Economic 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

96 sentences in 46 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, heads of state and government,

Ladies and gentlemen, ministers,

Madam President of the European Commission,

Mr. President of the European Council,

Royal Highness,

Mr. Commissioner-General of UNRWA,

Mr. Under-Secretary-General, Emergency Relief Coordinator,

Madam President of the ICRC,

Ladies and gentlemen, directors and secretaries-general of international organizations,

Ladies and gentlemen, ambassadors,

Ladies and gentlemen.

On October 7, a terrorist group, Hamas, launched a massive attack against Israel and committed exceptionally grave crimes against its population. More than 1,400 people have died, and 239 hostages are still in the hands of Hamas. Our first thoughts are obviously with the victims of the Hamas attack, their families, among whom are many French citizens; I know that several of you also have many nationals affected.

In the face of terrorism, our unity, our determination, our compassion are complete, and the hostages must be released immediately and unconditionally.

When it attacked Israel, Hamas took responsibility for exposing Palestinians to terrible consequences. Today, it is the civilians of Gaza who are suffering. Nearly 1.5 million people have been displaced, thousands have died or been injured. The misfortunes of Israelis are now compounded by those of Palestinians. We cannot accept this because all lives are equal and because there is no double standard for us who uphold universal and humanitarian values.

Let us be clear: in the face of terrorism, Israel has the right to defend itself and the duty to protect its own. It also has a paramount responsibility, which is that of all democracies, to respect the law and protect civilians.

The fight against terrorism can never be without rules. Israel knows this; the trap of terrorism is the same for all of us: to yield to violence and abandon our values. However, we share values and have common commitments that lead us today, in agreement with the Israeli and Palestinian authorities, to be concerned about the humanitarian situation in Gaza.

Civilians must be protected, and this is absolutely essential. It is non-negotiable. It is an immediate necessity, and in the longer term, it is also a condition for the effectiveness of our fight against terrorists.

Today, the situation is serious and deteriorating day by day. Immediately, we must work on the protection of civilians. For this, a very rapid humanitarian pause is needed, and we must work towards a ceasefire. This must become possible. We need to create the necessary space for humanitarian actors to operate in Gaza. We will listen to them, and I hope that this meeting will allow us to be effective together in a spirit of consensus and with the goal that beyond the tragedy currently experienced by too many Israeli and Palestinian families, we can take a genuine initiative for peace and security for all in the Middle East.

This initiative is based, of course, on this humanitarian pillar on which we will advance concretely today. It is based on a second security pillar. We have managed to do this together against Al-Qaeda, against Daesh, against other groups that pose a danger to all. No one can say anymore that Hamas is not a dangerous group and a terrorist group. Measures must therefore be taken to cut off its funding, to sanction those who are closely or remotely linked to the attack of October 7.

I will also propose a series of actions to prevent other terrorist groups in the region from joining the hostilities, to cut off their flow of money, arms, and propaganda. Finally, but this will be for later, we cannot avoid a broader reflection on the evolution of terrorism today, and for that, we will need to coordinate again.

There is a second security pillar that is essential, but it must be targeted, precise, requiring close coordination between our intelligence services, which is a security action, but also financial, and which requires the involvement of all regional and international parties.

Then, the third pillar, even if it is difficult to imagine today, is even more essential: it is the political pillar. We must learn from our mistakes and no longer accept that peace in the Middle East is always postponed. We must therefore take the initiative now and find the strength to finally move towards the solution of two states, Israel and Palestine, living side by side, in peace and security.

Let us first demonstrate that the creation of a Palestinian state serves the security of Israel. Let us demonstrate that a Palestinian state is necessary and that a sustainable solution requires the realization of the Palestinian question.

These three aspects—humanitarian, security, political—are deeply interlinked, but our ambition today is to be able to provide part of this response through the coordination of all good wills. And I hope that we can identify the needs for money and materials for the populations, the very concrete elements of organization on the ground that we must have and that are acceptable, and the requests that we must make to the various stakeholders in a very concrete manner so that this aid can be delivered and so that we can prepare for this humanitarian pause, and then the ceasefire, which are, as I said, indispensable.

I therefore propose that, as a method, we first hear from the organizations and actors on the ground. I will first give the floor to the Commissioner-General of UNRWA, Mr. LAZZARINI, then to Mr. GRIFFITHS, and then to Madam President of the ICRC, Madam SPOLJARIC. Then two spokespersons from NGOs will speak, Mr. EGELAND and Madam DE FOURNY for the Norwegian Refugee Council and MSF.

Next, I propose that the heads of state, government, and organizations present be allowed to speak to provide their contributions, their convictions, and their assistance.

Mr. Commissioner-General, I give you the floor, starting by expressing our sincerest condolences for the personnel you have lost in recent weeks. The women and men who served the international community and served UNRWA have fallen in the Gaza Strip. They were women and men who helped, who taught, who cared. And I want, in giving you the floor, to have a special thought for your teams. Thank you.

***

Emmanuel MACRON

Before giving the floor now to the President of the European Commission, to the heads of government, to the President of the Council, I believe there is a consensus that is emerging very clearly from the remarks that have just been made.

First, I will reiterate here that, in speaking of humanitarian concerns, there is the issue of hostages, which you have all clearly reminded us, and the unconditional and immediate release of hostages is an absolutely key point. Then there is the possibility of allowing all those who wish to leave the Gaza Strip to do so safely and freely, which is absolutely key. There is also the protection of humanitarian personnel, and I think it is important to reiterate this, and we will continue the work that has been done for several years, but the protection of people as well as places is absolutely key in this kind of situation, and the guarantees for their safety, the issue of access, is absolutely essential.

Now, I believe that the remarks of the two NGOs that have spoken have made this very clear; it has been several weeks, to be very frank with you around this table, that we have been working, several around the table, to try to see how we can deliver aid in the most intelligent way to protect the populations.

We have had many discussions with President SISSI, who explained to me very well why it was a very bad idea to create a zone in northern Egypt, because it created a lot of imbalance. First, it did not put civilians in a position of protection, and then politically it was something that could be completely diverted. We do not have the conditions to secure well. You said it yourself, there have been several discussions about safe zones. And I speak, trying to reproduce what everyone has said today and what they have advised; it is not operational, it cannot be guaranteed.

Indeed, we already have a lot of bombings taking place in the south, and it turns out that, given the strategy that is also that of Hamas, to somehow cling to the areas that should be the most protected, that is to say, to position themselves on the power supply systems of hospitals, to hide behind schools, it will not work.

That is why I truly believe that an immediate humanitarian pause and the preparation of a real ceasefire, which indeed allows humanitarian organizations to work, seems to be the consensus of all international organizations and NGOs operating. And so, we must draw the consequences from this and face it squarely.

I think that the circumlocutions we might have about whether to create this zone are, as you have said very well, inoperative. And so, if we really want to protect lives, which should not prevent the possibility for Israel to defend itself and fight against terrorism — and we are all ready to contribute by sharing intelligence, information, and cutting off funding — must indeed go through the restoration of access to water and energy, and through this truce leading to a humanitarian ceasefire, which alone will allow us to respond adequately to the problem.

The United Nations has also published, and you have reminded us, Mr. Commissioner-General and Mr. Under-Secretary-General, the nature of the financial needs.

I would like to conclude on this point to try to recap this first round of discussions.

It is 1.2 billion dollars. I call today on all the countries present to increase their financial contributions to the Palestinian civilian population through the United Nations, including UNRWA, the ICRC, and NGOs.

Since October 7, France has announced an additional 20 million euros in humanitarian aid, and we will raise this effort to 100 million euros for 2023. So, this is a way to kick things off. Finally, I would also like to commend the various initiatives that have been launched by several around the table. The airdrop of health supplies to Gaza by Jordan, the establishment of a field hospital by the United Arab Emirates, the proposed maritime corridor by the Cypriot president, the airlift implemented by the European Commission, the Egyptian initiative to treat the wounded. I also draw your attention to the deployment of French maritime and medical resources, as well as our mobilization to welcome the wounded and severely ill children.

I hope that today's conference can also help us perhaps to aggregate all these efforts. Greece has also sent multiple vessels, and this is tied to the Cypriot effort. I think we could gain in collective efficiency and that we could set up a kind of very light operational secretariat at the end of this conference, to ensure that we aggregate alongside the competent agencies this operational effort and its initiatives.

What I propose now is to start this round of discussions, and I give the floor to Madam President of the European Commission.

Dear Ursula, thank you very much for being here.

***

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you, Mr. Prime Minister. Your presence here is enough to signify that the Palestinian Authority is the only legitimate representative of the Palestinian people and their cause. Hamas knew very well what it was doing on October 7. Its clear condemnation also distinguishes these points. And the Palestinian Authority has a paramount responsibility regarding the three pillars I mentioned to work with the international community and find a solution regarding the clear fight against terrorism, on the humanitarian issue we are discussing today, and on the political issue.