Opening of the Christchurch Call Summit to Action on Terrorism and Violent Extremism Online.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

10 November 2023 · Christchurch Call Summit to Action on Terrorism and Violent Extremism Online · Élysée Palace, France

Context
Macron opened the fifth Christchurch Call Summit to Action at the Élysée Palace in Paris on the sidelines of the 2023 Paris Peace Forum.
Main themes
Online terrorism and violent extremism, content removal and platform accountability, Christchurch Call commitments, multi-stakeholder approach, artificial intelligence and online regulation, child protection online, hate speech and propaganda, violence against women, algorithmic governance, international cooperation, Hamas content moderation, European digital regulation
Duration
~11 min
39th percentile
Words
1,318
39th percentile
Sentences
64
42nd percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
11.9
44th percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
12th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Ceremonial 35%34%
  • Geopolitical 30%30%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Institutional 14%14%
  • Technological 6%6%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

64 sentences in 20 paragraphs

Dear Jacinda, now Madam Special Envoy for the Christchurch Call.

Ladies and gentlemen, heads of state and government,

Ministers,

Ambassadors,

Business leaders,

Representatives of non-governmental organizations,

Researchers,

Practitioners,

Dear friends,

I am very happy that we can meet at the Élysée today where we launched the Christchurch Call four years ago with Madam Prime Minister at the time, Jacinda ARDERN, after the terrible terrorist attack that New Zealand suffered. I really want to thank you for your personal commitment and the mobilization that we have managed to achieve over the past few years to build results that are already tangible.

This is the fifth summit we are holding, which takes place on the sidelines of the Paris Peace Forum, which is meaningful because with the Christchurch Call, we have built a platform to contribute to a more peaceful world online and also by extension in real life, because we have seen that the services you provide can be used for purposes that are not those you advocate and share and thus diverted. We have somewhat, in a multi-stakeholder approach, as we say in good French, decided to aggregate governmental, non-governmental, and private sector actors' wills. And I think that today, we have already built significant results. We have placed at the heart of our community a very clear mandate, a firm and resolute intention to respond with the greatest efficiency to the spread of hate and violence.

Since then, we have unfortunately, if I may say, tested the Call: we have managed to obtain the removal of terrorist content. And I believe that we must not waver on the qualification; we must maintain a very simple approach, which has unfortunately worked every time we have faced this. During the assassination of Samuel Paty in France in October 2020, we were able to proactively obtain an immediate removal of content, including videos that circulated after the heinous assassination of Professor Dominique Bernard. So we have had several situations where we saw platforms fully engage in the approach of the golden hour and the very clear commitments to remove terrorist content.

Since our meeting in New York last year, we have a context that has obviously evolved, and we will return to that, first because we have very rapid progress related to artificial intelligence, and it is a privilege to have Greg [Brockman] among us today, and I thank OpenAI for being represented at this level; we also have Anthropic and others here, and that is very important; because we obviously have an international situation that has further tested our resilience on this issue, with Ukraine, the Sahel, and now the Middle East. We will return to that as well because the massive dissemination of videos from Hamas online, the instrumentalization to glorify or incite hatred and violence has also led to many removals.

If I were to give just a few figures, as of October 14, 2023, X had removed 100,000 pieces of terrorist content, 10,000 pieces of content for violent speech, and suspended 1,000 accounts linked to Hamas. TikTok had reported removing 500,000 videos and 8,000 live videos. So these figures show that there has been an effort made, that work has been done, but that we still have a collective journey ahead of us.

We also launched a very important approach on algorithms that I think is something that is extremely structuring for us and on which we are making good progress. In parallel to that, we have also seen regulations emerging and developing, particularly in Europe but in several other areas that have advanced on our issues. The Christchurch Call truly embodies the effectiveness of a method - and I think it is very useful - that must tackle new problems and other challenges online. I think of the protection of children or violence against women.

On the protection of children, I really wanted to emphasize this point, there was the initiative launched last year, several were also there, from the Laboratory for Online Child Protection, which aims to create with companies in the sector the innovative technical solutions that will better protect our children online. There is a point that was made in the context of the forum that also showed progress. I am pleased that the United States, South Korea, and several others are joining the initiative. This is truly an important change with experiments on age verification, the non-consensual sharing of intimate photos, the engagement of several of your platforms that have allowed progress, and what we must continue to do on cyberbullying.

So there you go, I think we have done very strong things on terrorism. We must still do more in the fight against hate content, propaganda, or anything that is a bit gray, we know that. We must continue to act against violence against women and children, and we must maintain this multi-stakeholder approach. I think Jacinda will return to this, but for me, it is important that we sustain this structure. She therefore has my full support for the developments of our structure, of the Christchurch Call, and France will be there for the long term, you can count on us.

I thank the countries that are also by our side. But I will be quite direct, as always. I am very happy, in this room, there are only people who are enthusiastic and who believe in it. It’s great that Greg [Brockman] is here, really Brad [Smith] has been wonderful from the beginning, at his level, he takes the time. In any case, I really want to say that for Meta and Google, we have received the message well. Because the fact that there were no top managers available, neither in New York in September, nor here in Paris, when there are heads of state and government who can travel, means that they want to play less. If they want to play less, I am the first to value actions, but I am also the first to really say when people are no longer playing.

When I am told that we regulate content, I have been given a very simple figure, it is the number of moderators in the languages that exist per platform and I will continue to follow things this way. But it is certain that when I am told that there are 52 moderators for X in the French language, I find it hard to consider that the content is moderated. French language, not France: There are 330 million speakers of the French language. These 52 people are geniuses or have a lot of work. There are 226 for Meta. TikTok is not here at the table because we need to clarify status issues, but they already have 687. I say this to create competition, good competition.

So, the Christchurch Call works only if there are people who collectively take it seriously. The moment people are no longer serious, we become less cooperative, at least as far as I am concerned. So I think that’s it, it’s a wake-up call. We want to continue to expand the field of the fight, to move forward with this multi-stakeholder approach because we believe in it a lot. I am fully supportive. I think it is a huge opportunity to have Jacinda ARDERN who will continue the work alongside us. I will always be there. But I consider that when companies that had committed, told us wonderful things, organize not to be there and do not do what they said they would do, trust diminishes, especially when others continue to do the work. I preferred to say it because otherwise the compliments I make have no value if I cannot say when there is no result. In any case, we are fully mobilized at work. We have results, but we still have a lot to do. I will not be longer. The floor is now to Jacinda ARDERN.