SPEECH BY THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC – MEETING WITH THE STATE'S LEADERSHIP FRAMEWORK

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

12 March 2024 · Meeting with the State's leadership framework

Context
Macron addressed France's senior state officials and ministers at a managerial conference in March 2024 to set priorities and mandate reforms for the coming period.
Main themes
Public administration reform, crisis management, effectiveness of public action, democracy and governance, economic challenges, geopolitical turbulence, climate change, national security, reindustrialization, public finances, digital transformation, social cohesion
Duration
~114 min
99th percentile
Words
13,622
99th percentile
Sentences
651
99th percentile
Readability
55
77th percentile
Grade
10.7
28th percentile
Syntax
2.99
46th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 67%64%
  • Social 14%13%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Not in focus 5%

651 sentences in 79 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister, Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers, Ladies and Gentlemen senior officials, Gentlemen Chiefs of Staff, generals, senior officers, all of you who make up the leadership framework of the State.

I will try here before you to set a course on the substance and also share some methodological convictions, and to give both the Prime Minister, the members of the Government, and the main architects of these reforms a clear mandate to move forward. And I know that we are both in this room, but also remotely, as they say now, with several of your colleagues. First of all, I find you again after the last meeting we held in another form, this one, I remember, in 2021, in a time that seems so far away, we were not yet out of Covid and we were launching an important modernization project. Much has been done, and I wanted to start my remarks by thanking you, all of your colleagues, your teams, and all of our departments, whether you are in the administrations or the operators; a tremendous amount of work, I do not underestimate it, has been done in recent years, and you are the artisans of that.

And I want to sincerely thank you for that. First, because a course had been set. To simplify it, in 2017, there were two priorities: fighting unemployment, fighting terrorism. Tangible results have been achieved, tangible, with a historic level of activity, an unemployment rate we had not seen in 40 years, a reindustrialization that has begun, the result of many reforms and effective implementation, and a safer country, with a lot of work done on the ground. I will not list everything that has been done here. I could enumerate all that has been deployed in education, from class size reductions to the first reforms in health, before and after Covid with the Ségur. But the results are there, and we have been able to report them to the French people. At the same time, you have had to manage a number of crises at a historic level: social crisis with the Yellow Vests, Covid, which hit our country like many others and was a real organizational challenge that you met, the return of war in Europe with its consequences, inflation, not to mention more local crises, whether environmental or others that we have had to face in recent years, which have disrupted your territories.

And so, over the past few years, we have managed crises at a level of intensity that is undoubtedly unprecedented, and we have seen it again in recent days with the attack on our interministerial network on the IT front, which shows that we will live in a world of multiple crises and that the forms, the hybridity of our attacks, whether they are real, informational, civil or military, will be present.

And you have done this while holding the objectives that are ours, and I believe, in making France stronger. For this, I want to deeply thank you. It is the fruit of your commitment, your work, that of all your collaborators. And we can never say it enough, but one of the strengths of our country is precisely to have this framework everywhere across the territory and this sense of commitment. These results are also due to the fact that the course has not varied, and I think it is very important that the objectives do not change every six months. That is why I want to clarify a few here, that there has been a fully mobilized team, with the will to face the crises, but to maintain the capacity to focus on the medium to long term. And this, I believe, is the strength that has been ours. Things will not simplify in the coming years. Climate change, climate disruptions and their consequences will intensify. The economic context is less favorable in our Europe. The priority given to reforms should not make us forget the responsible management of public finances. And geopolitics will not simplify. We are entering a zone of greater turbulence. We have seen it again in recent months. That is why we need, if I may say so, to double our efforts. And I come before you this morning, therefore the Prime Minister, the ministers, and all those who are expected for the work of this managerial conference do not come to detail these projects with a conviction deeply rooted in our bodies.

It is that the moment we are living, as I mentioned, the multiple and overlapping crises is also one of a crisis of democracies. We see it in our country, we see it even more harshly in many European countries, we see it across the Atlantic, no democracy is spared. And this crisis is primarily a crisis of the effectiveness of public action. That is why your role is essential. It is a crisis of the effectiveness of public action because, fundamentally, we have a divergent movement. Our compatriots are increasingly accustomed to the immediacy of social networks, and they are used to many actions that sometimes took time, required physical steps that could be lengthy, being resolved with just a finger on a screen. A wonderful innovation in our times. But consequently, the same relationship to immediacy is expected of us collectively. It is not always possible, and we must educate about it. Finally, we are asked to go faster. And at the same time, our public action, as we can see, is sometimes paralyzed by objectives that annihilate each other.

We want to go faster and simplify, but we multiply constraints because we want to do both economics, preserve our environment, and respond to applicants, and thus we have a public action that has become heavier, that takes more time, that has undoubtedly, not perhaps, certainly become more complex. And this gap makes people say to us: you are ineffective. We saw it again recently with the agricultural crisis. People tell me, this should be simpler, it should be resolved now; I need to see it, I no longer believe you. If it is not tangible for me, it does not exist. It is a crisis of trust that extends to politicians, but to the entire administration. And so, I believe that the main challenge we face is to have a few clear objectives, I will return to the substance, but above all to drastically change our method to be at the service of these objectives and succeed in gaining in efficiency, speed, and intelligibility of public action collectively, because otherwise, it is the trust in democratic life and in our State that will continue to weaken. I do not think this is a good thing, because we see it in times of crisis, where public action, through hyper-simplification of what it does, becomes tangible, it is acclaimed. Unfortunately, when an attack occurs, when a tragedy happens on the territory, when Covid was present, public action is acclaimed because it becomes very simple, very tangible, because what are daily barriers and overly slow procedures are suspended, and we move forward. It is exactly the same state of mind that we need to have, if I may express it this way, in times of peace.

So, to do this and on the substance, this action of the Government should be entirely focused around four very simple objectives that you should align with: the Prime Minister, the ministers who will return to this. I had the opportunity to revisit this in my press conference, and all of this is an element of continuity. Fundamentally, for me, the objective is to continue to make our country stronger, therefore more sovereign and fairer. To liberate, protect, unite, remains completely relevant. This course from 2017 is still there, and for me, it must be broken down into four projects. The first is to achieve full employment and continue reindustrialization. It is the first because if we do not create wealth, we cannot distribute it. I apologize for this common-sense remark, but we forget it too often, we have too often forgotten it. And so, we must all be at the service of this capacity in the country to create more wealth, to maintain or localize production capacities. And here too, I have often reminded you, we talk and we will talk again about public finances. If France had the activity rate and unemployment rate of Germany, it would not have public finance problems. So our revenues are parametric when they are very short-term or emergency brake. The right public finance response is a response in terms of reindustrialization and activity for sure. So for this, many things have been done. We must continue them. Obviously, the reform of unemployment insurance, the capacity to continue modernizing our economy, the texts that will come in this area to continue simplifying, supporting businesses, also strengthening all the work that is underway on training with the map of vocational training, the reform of the first cycle of higher education, which is also underway, which are essential elements.

And then, all the laws on industrial and digital sovereignty or simplification in favor of businesses that will arrive in the coming months. This work, which is legislative, regulatory, which goes towards simplification, acceleration, the continuation of what we have started, is thus complemented by a further strengthened pillar on training, which is essential, and innovation. And so, it is all the work of the SGPI of France 2030. It must be territorially declined, also through support for these reforms.

And I wanted to emphasize this first chapter on a few points. We must continue to go faster and reduce delays through integrated and very grouped procedures. The example of what has been done, for example, in Dunkirk, I think, is a good one, or what has been done for our Olympic and Paralympic Games. And so, it is possible, I will return to this, to group and go faster when we anticipate and simplify procedures. And then, there is the support for the France Travail reform and, fundamentally, there too, a capacity to integrate all actors to better train, support, and somehow resolve the problems that separate from returning to activity. That for me is the first axis. The second is to improve public services, particularly local services. On this aspect, much has been done. There is a historic reinvestment of public power being made in our major public services, whether it is the two LPMs, but also what has been done in the Ministry of the Interior, Justice, Education, Health. At a historic level, reinvesting both obviously in civil servants and collaborators, but in the investment strength of these major policies.

And so, in this regard, we must have simple objectives. For education, it is to improve the level of students and ensure that every child has the keys to choose their destiny. It is all that has been deployed with the reforms of the first five-year term, complemented by the shock of knowledge, the teacher pact, orientation and discovery of professions, the reform of vocational high schools and higher education and research, and all that will then unfold on which the minister will have the opportunity to return. In terms of health, it is to enable everyone to access care. And we know the double challenge of the hospital crisis and medical deserts. And there will be no miracle in the next three years. We will not have more doctors despite the opening of training, because these are results that will arrive in 2028. And so, the effort on which we must double down is to free up medical time, create territorial professional health communities, delegate acts, continue also to have practitioners qualified outside the European Union who settle in our territory. And there too, to win the shift towards prevention and better coordination between the city and the hospital. The minister will have the opportunity to return to this. But more broadly, what is expected of us is to be able to access public service everywhere, with a condition of real equality. The French are asking us for shorter deadlines, they do not want to be sent from one administration to another, and they want humanity, whether on the phone or in person. This is a managerial transformation on the ground that we have succeeded — I will return to this with the France Services houses — but that we need to systematize and that goes with precisely this capacity to improve our public services. It is all the effort that is also being made, to cite just one example in terms of proximity justice, which has led us to reinvest a lot of personnel on the ground.

The third axis is to plan and accelerate the ecological transition. I said it as early as 2022; it was a commitment. We have reorganized our work. A tremendous amount of work has been accomplished, and I thank the minister, the ministers, but also the General Secretariat for Ecological Transition under the Prime Minister, and we have truly, we are the first country to have this planning that explains in concrete terms how to achieve our objectives. And this work has been done through a maieutic process with all the services and articulates our national, European, and international action. This continuum is very important for our credibility and competitiveness because it is not about having a mismatch between what France does and what our neighbors do. In terms of ecological transition, we now have a challenge, which is to accelerate the implementation, and fundamentally, it is a mastery of transitions, sectors, and territories. We will have to break down, sector by sector, the economies what we have planned, and this is underway, sometimes with texts that include incentives, fiscal mechanisms, funding from France 2030, and at other times with European or national regulatory elements, and then a territorial approach and a management dialogue.

And the regional COPs have started to take place. The ministers announced them several weeks, several months ago. But now, they will allow us to break things down. Your role is essential in this regard. It will be that of a guide, a mediator who allows for support, for building solutions. And it is this French ecology that we believe in. And then, the fourth axis of action is to strengthen civic and republican order. The French rightly demand order, an order that serves our laws, our values. And that is the meaning of the resources we have allocated to our armed forces to maintain order at our borders and to have missions that also contribute to this within our borders. Reinvesting, as I said, in our justice system. By the end of this term, we will have increased the budget for justice by 60%, which is unprecedented in our history. Strengthening the resources of the Ministry of the Interior, whether it concerns our police, our gendarmes, or our civil security, with a very significant reinvestment that also needs to be implemented on the ground. But we now need to succeed in new challenges regarding civic and republican order. The better care of minors who are disconnected from society is one of the essential issues and one of the axes I have set for the Prime Minister. He will return to this in the coming months, which is also our response to the riots experienced last summer. The increase in the fight against drug trafficking is the second act of what we launched as early as 2018, with a national and international reorganization of our action that is yielding its first results, but which we are intensifying, the fight against radicalization and communitarianism, which since the Mureaux strategy in 2020 has also produced results but which we will intensify.

And then, the deployment of the Republican Action Forces or the Border Force, which are part of the commitments we have made. All of this, of course, we will continue to break down. But these are the four main axes of action that I am asking the Government and all our administrations to prioritize. And all of this is set within an increasingly complex international European environment where our vocation will be to continue to have a more sovereign, more united, and more democratic Europe. These were the axes set at the Sorbonne on which we have had results. But the months and years to come will require us to have an even more sovereign Europe. We see this in terms of defense, but also in technological and economic terms and the challenges of our defense industry, our ability to protect our own borders, but also our ability to develop our own artificial intelligence. Our digital solutions are there, and a more pragmatic Europe. We will need, at the European level, to succeed in converting methods that I am asking you to implement at the national level to better support our action and provide greater simplicity for our fellow citizens. These are the fundamental objectives.

But to succeed in such a transformation and respond to the democratic crisis of confidence that I mentioned, we need a transformation of the State that is essential. The agenda is dense, as you know, and I want us to carry these reforms through to the end. And I believe this must also involve changes in methods and organization that are ours. Since 2017, a lot has been done, and I want to sincerely thank you and defend this record. First, we started to put the State back at the heart of the territories. Our fellow citizens need this presence. It was the commitment I made after the yellow vest crisis. In April 2019, we collectively invented the France services houses, saying that people demand tangible presence. I made the commitment, which seemed outdated to some, to say there should be one France services house per canton. I believe this is not outdated at all because the canton is a human, intelligible, real scale for people, corresponding to the intimacy of the territories. We have done more than that since there are now 2,700 France services spaces. More than 9 out of 10 French people are within 30 minutes of one of these spaces. This is essential. We must continue this work, continue to innovate, to place France services houses in sub-prefectures, to succeed in linking even more with our justice system and everywhere across the territory, to enrich, to densify these France services houses and to have a complete offer. I believe this has been an advancement in recent years. It must be strengthened and not considered as acquired.

Next is the transformation of the public service. The so-called DUSSOPT laws have simplified and decentralized, in text, human resources and their management. It is very heterogeneous between ministries. I have asked the minister to provide the grid. There are ministries that have not applied it at all; I am not here to point out the bad students; it is public. The Minister of Public Transformations can share it; in some ministries, it is as if the law had not been taken into account; that is to say, everything has remained at the central level. There are others that have appropriated the law. Texts are only valuable to the extent that they are used. And the beauty of administration is that, fundamentally, if a central administration decides not to apply what has been voted for itself, it effectively sterilizes the said text. So I congratulate those who have done it. I do not think this is a good method. Therefore, I ask the minister to fully apply what has not been done today, that is to say, to decentralize the management of human resources, to fully utilize the levers given to public managers because I believe it is a good thing. But this was a first phase of reform. There was then modernization led by Minister DE MONTCHALIN. And now, a third phase of reform is being prepared, which is being finalized by Minister GUÉRINI and will provide a text that will also deeply reform our public service.

But this transformation has been made, and by assuming that the senior civil service is the first to be affected. This is an element of credibility, of legitimacy of our reform. And thus, the overhaul of ENA with the creation of INSP, the elimination of the exit ranking, and thanks to all the managers who have to manage this transition, which I believe is taking place and will allow us to improve collectively, the creation of more than a hundred preparatory classes to attract new profiles, the merging of bodies and the creation of DIESE, which has allowed for the establishment of a senior management of the State and its management. And fundamentally, to reiterate here, I had the opportunity to say it in front of several ministries, and to clarify what has never been a misunderstanding in my eyes, I have always been committed to the professionalization of all. But corporatism has never served any professionalization. It is something that blocks the circulation of talent, and therefore I am for functions, for professionalization, having applied it to myself, I am against corporatism. I believe it serves no talent, no form of recognition, and no recognition of merit. And therefore, this reform, which also concerns technical bodies, must be finalized this year, and it will be complemented. And these are also the same objectives of breaking down barriers, mobility, and valuing skills and professions that we will carry out across the public service around the bill that is being prepared by the Minister of Transformation and Public Service. With a key word, for me it is the most important, to trust those who are closest to the ground. And I will return to this in a moment, but it is the key: we must invert the pyramid. Invert. And in this regard, I really want to thank the DIESE that I mentioned and the DITP, which have been two spearheads of this transformation. And I know how much the Prime Minister can count on these two strong administrations, alongside his minister and all the members of the Government, to continue to support these essential transformations. And then, since 2017, we have simplified, improved the quality of service, in France and abroad. We have passed many laws. They all have acronyms, ASAP, ESSOC, etc. In any case, there was the "Tell us once" plan, the simplification project of 250 essential procedures most used by our fellow citizens, particularly to make them more accessible to people with disabilities. We have also simplified a lot on the consular level. Thank you to the services that contribute to this entire project that is currently completing its deployment. And then, there is the "10 life moments" project, which is very important, very concrete. The dematerialization of civil status, I mentioned, for French citizens abroad. And it is the right logic; we must continue it. But fundamentally, in terms of simplification - I defend our record, I am very happy with what we have started to do - but finally, lucidity leads me to say that the general perception is not that we have massively simplified. I believe that if we conducted a survey of the atmosphere in the country, even outside the Agricultural Show where I tried to advocate this theory, it is not perceived. So, that means we have not fully succeeded. So, I must say that when we delve into the details, it is the difficulty for a president of the Republic; we say something, and then — and it is normal, it is the separation of powers and others — at each level, we put brakes, and in the end, where you have put 100 in force, they arrive at 5 or 10.

And so, I said, we are going to do something that is wonderful, the right to make mistakes, because I believe it was a good idea. People agreed, by the way. Then, there was a law; the law already included many exceptions to the right to make mistakes. Then, after the law, the regulations added more. And then, there are administrations that implemented it, and others that did not. So, the right to make mistakes works in some places. Very well, then, I was given a collaborative file, as I express what I think and what I experience on the ground. Every time I see people, I tell them: the right to make mistakes has indeed changed your life. I said it in 2017, we did it. We passed a law. Either I have people who are angry and who say to me, "they think we are fools"; or I have people who tell me elsewhere: "he lives elsewhere," "he is disconnected," as we sometimes say. That is the reality. So, it is "Bibi" who pays. But it is our collective work, and it is not good, and it is not good for anyone because it means that we let the President of the Republic say something and make a commitment, and we accommodated ourselves, we said: we will do as we have always done, it is still simpler, and so at every level, we took a bit away. There are places where there is a right to make mistakes. You have to look for them well. In those places, it works fairly well. However, there are still many areas of public action where there is no right to make mistakes. So, I cannot tell you that simplification, in general, is a great victory of recent years, even if I defend it as part of the record. Alongside that, you also have, and I am talking about the past five years, to defend what we have done and the movement that is underway: adapting your administrations to the major digital, ecological, and social challenges, with a very significant change and really many elements that have been implemented, and I thank you for that. Whether it is about purchasing policy, whether it is about the organization, the adaptation of our services, it has been a movement that has started, which needs to be accelerated because it is one of the key axes of what we are conducting. So, now, based on this record, in terms of method, what do I expect from you collectively?

I think that all the intuitions, everything we have started to launch: transformation of the State, simplification, accountability of local managers, putting the State back at the heart of territories, these are good directions. That is to say, I do not think that, in recent years, we have done things that go in the wrong direction. If I thought otherwise, I would tell you and I would correct it. So I think that everything that has been done, the intention is good, the movement is good. Simply, it lacks intensity, it lacks strength, it lacks radicality to be perceptible. And I return to this crisis of confidence that I mentioned: If people do not see it, if things do not change radically, they are not considered real, and it is a race against time because otherwise, it is "the status quo" that returns. If you do not change things, people say: What is the point of making all these efforts? And it somehow mixes into the magma, and thus into the distrust. And so, gaining in intensity means taking some clear measures in terms of methods that serve the four objectives I just presented.

The first element is to carry decentralization to its conclusion. From where I am, one must learn to be either patient or stubborn. And I believe I said something like that to the Prefects at the Élysée in September 2017. It is like simplification, so there are things that have been done, but not everything. So here, I will not let you go collectively, we must decentralize. And when I say decentralize, the right level is departmental. Because regional decentralization in large regions is not perceived as decentralization by our compatriots. It is not true. When we put, for example, housing policies and placed them at the regional level, in our discourse, we say: "it is decentralized, at the regional level." Go ask someone who is processing. Because at the departmental level, we ask the Region. The services of the Region sometimes take as long as in Paris, then it goes back down. Where you do not have the ability to respond to your first-order interlocutors, a mayor, an entrepreneur, and you say: "I will ask for permission from above." The decision is perceived as distant. Our procedures are slow because all systems are congested. And so, I truly want us to go to the end of this territorial decentralization and give much more strength to our departments. I say this because they have been weakened, and you know it very well. When the RGPP was implemented, I am talking about a time you know, that we know, which goes back about ten years, the main effort on public service was made in the territories and it was made in the departments. Let’s take the figures, between 2008 and today, prefectures or departmental services, that is where the effort was requested. It was much less so at the central level, that is a reality. Now, who is in service, who asks, who innovates, who is in mobility? And this means that we continued to have central administrations that sometimes produce one to two instruction texts per working day. This is a reality I am talking about. Who speaks to decentralized services that have been weakened with citizens who are increasingly demanding and who ask for speed of execution? You do not ask why people are frustrated. And at the same time, a few years later, we created these large regions that distanced decision-making centers from the department. This double movement is terrible for the capacity to have public action that is tangible for our compatriots. Our compatriots, who can be good faith citizens, but above all, those who are our relays, that is to say, the mayors, that is to say, the entrepreneurs, the local decision-makers, and you know it as well as I do. And so, I want us to restore strength, both coherence of action and strength to our departments.

I ask for a massive movement under the supervision of the Prime Minister to decentralize. So, I ask you in all ministries to look at how to push, from the central administration and the operators. Because the issue we have in several ministries is that your capacities for action are weak because many of these civil servants are with the operators. But it is the same. And this movement has further increased what I mentioned, because moreover, when in the departmental prefectures or in the departmental services, you have calls for tenders coming from national operators that go over your heads, good luck. So, I ask you to make this movement, to restore resources. Then, the prefect must be the effective pilot of all public services of the State, including operators and agencies, at the departmental level because we need simplicity of command. That is why the prefects will give an opinion in the process of appointment, setting objectives and priorities for action, evaluation, and construction of the variable part of the remuneration of directors and territorial delegates. I think this is an important movement, and the Prime Minister will provide the complete list in his intervention. And for what concerns access to public services and its mapping, I wish that the prefects give a favorable opinion on the project of evolution carried by the State services: healthcare offers, school map, location of tax centers. The departmental prefect must be, in this regard, a head of the State. And let’s be clear, this prefect is not meant to deal with taxation or educational action or hospital management. On the other hand, he has full legitimacy in terms of spatial organization of services. This is the distinction that must be made, but it is the one that also allows for a somewhat restructured action of the State, if I may say so, at the departmental level and which - by doing so - is more coherent for everyone.

The services and operators of the State must also involve the prefects in the funding granted in their territorial jurisdiction. This is partly already provided for in the texts. It must now be applied and taken further. This right of oversight must allow for greater coherence in the investment choices of State action, to lead to, this may lead to reviewing and modifying the organization of the operators or the services concerned — and this is the work I wish for us to conduct — and to limit as much as possible the calls for national projects that I mentioned by reserving them for public policies that need to bring forth the most innovative projects, themes that are still poorly addressed that fully justify being treated at the national level; otherwise, everything must be treated at the decentralized level.

This renewed authority must translate into a managerial and operational evolution on the ground, and I expressly ask the prefects to concretely build these new expanded work collectives and guarantee a 360-degree vision of the action of the State on the territory. Likewise, at the central level, I invite all ministers to consider that the prefects are for everyone, if I may say so, and also their prefects, which is indeed the initial logic of our organization, they are representatives in each department. They work to implement all the policies that are entrusted daily by the Prime Minister and, in this regard, in connection with the Minister of the Interior. The ministers, in their areas, are fully able to solicit or mobilize the prefects at any time for the coherence of this action. Beyond the means, therefore, we must decentralize at the departmental level, beyond this clarification of responsibilities and command, the decentralization of human and budgetary resources must be completed. I mentioned it earlier. The Government will specify the modalities, but this will translate, for example, into a simplification of the budgetary architecture, the reduction of the number of programs, a possibility of strengthening the fungibility of envelopes, a limitation of the earmarking of decentralized credits, a possibility of multi-year commitments for the prefects to finance structuring projects beyond the calendar year, a management of the payroll and management decisions, etc., and an integration into the objectives of central administrations of the issues of decentralization. All of these elements are key to achieving what we have announced, done in a very heterogeneous manner, that is to say, an effective decentralization of our action. It is essential and will often help to clear up a misunderstanding. I tell you this here because when we hear about decentralization every day, it is because our compatriots mainly want action on the ground when we get into the details. Moreover, when we see the feedback, whether from decentralization or decentralization, it is very little readable for most of our compatriots. And the love of equality that the French have means that what goes with decentralization, which can be territorial heterogeneity, does not always please them. On the other hand, a real decentralization with an initiative power, a capacity to respond, and a responsibility on the ground, that is what they demand, and that is what we owe them. I believe this very deeply, and so that is what I ask of you. The technical modalities will be worked on under the authority of the Prime Minister by the Government. The necessary texts will be taken in the coming weeks, and regular updates will be made on the implementation of this decentralization, in addition to quarterly meetings around the table of the Council of Ministers. This, for me, is the first axis in terms of method in service of the action that I have asked of you.

The second point is to go much faster and stronger in terms of simplification, well beyond what we have done since 2017. So, to succeed in this simplification, there are several elements. First, produce fewer texts. This is what we are doing at the governmental level. This is what we will continue in the dialogue with, precisely, the Chambers. And this is a discipline of the legislator. It is essential. Next, it is to do the same at the level of central administrations, that is to say: you set yourself the objective of producing much fewer texts - and I invite you to look by ministry at the frequency of the texts you produce centrally - which lead, if we put it bluntly, to a taylorization of the agents on the ground, meaning that when you receive 1 to 2 instructions every day, you can no longer reflect on what you are doing. You are disempowered. And so I wish that the administrations, this is a second element of simplification, set clear and precise objectives: reduce deadlines, cut down on paperwork, decrease the number of controls, and question the relevance of any instructions that come from below. It is better to have a meeting where we share objectives, but leave freedom to the field, rather than a text that is not accompanied by any explanation, which comes out and lands in an inbox, which unfortunately is still far too often the way things proceed. An element of simplification: to stand alongside the end user, as in the consultation carried out by Bercy with businesses or around the life moments of the Ministry of Transformation and Public Service. This ability to put ourselves at the level of the individual, the business, the farmer, the community is, I believe, the right way to achieve good simplification. Next, it is to trust a priori. That is why I want us to reopen the right to make mistakes and to go all the way in the fields of public action where it has not been taken. What we are doing in a much more systematic way. I think, for example, of taxation; there are others where it has been done much less. We must be clear-eyed. And so I wish that wherever possible, we eliminate prior authorizations and offer optional regulatory rescripts, that we multiply access to these procedures to secure those who wish. That we replace an authorization with a declaration, which already saves time, and that the first controls are also accompanying and corrective controls, even if we have to toughen the sanctions during the second or third control if the mistakes are repeated. But this ability to trust is also another face of the administration that supports effective simplification. It is also about adopting a digital reflex for all procedures and going as far as possible in simplicity with pre-filled declarations, the elimination of attachments or supporting documents, etc., etc. In this area, artificial intelligence is, in my view, also one of the elements that will allow us to simplify.

It is an issue of economic attractiveness for France, as you know, one of the ways to build trust from civil society towards artificial intelligence is for the public sector to seize it. It is for us to develop projects that allow artificial intelligence to work for the common good and, in doing so, to move towards much more simplicity. Because on small procedures, small tasks, artificial intelligence is an element that can simplify the lives of our fellow citizens and users, as well as the lives of our agents by avoiding very repetitive tasks. And so, we need to embrace artificial intelligence and its use as a real lever for transforming the State and its simplicity.

We must anticipate upheavals in advance. When an actor is affected by multiple norms or has to implement a demanding new regulation, a good practice is to negotiate an evolution agenda that allows for anticipating and regulating the changes to be made over time. This is also an element of simplicity. And then, apply to our own agents what we ask them to apply to users and thus simplify our internal procedures which, otherwise, anchor our agents in the administrative culture of complexity.

I am struck to see that if we get our own agents used to spending their day filling out circulars, management controls, impossible things, we condition our agents to do the same with users. There is a form of collective administrative mistreatment that we inflict on ourselves. But I say this with great seriousness because I have seen it on the ground. We have collectively created a form of absurdity in daily life with the best intentions in the world, at every level. So, we must truly go into contact, as I said, invert the pyramid; that is how we will build this simplicity.

The last point in terms of simplification, which I believe in a lot, is the ease that we must give, further increased, to the power of derogation. Today, prefects have this power of derogation. They still use it too little, and it is very heterogeneous. This is partly explained by the heaviness of the procedure. A scope of application that is still too restricted. I want them to all take greater advantage of this capacity that is offered to them, perhaps through training, that good information be shared on this subject, and that the procedure be simplified and accelerated and the areas of intervention expanded.

On all these principles, work will be initiated by the government in anticipation of the next interministerial committee on public transformation. This is a key point. Decentralize, simplify, associate. This is, for me, the third lever in terms of transformation. And to associate, I will be very simple, it is also a change in administrative culture; it is the CNR, this famous National Council for Refoundation, which I believe in a lot. I have a flaw; I believe in what I say and in what I undertake, so I am also stubborn about it. This National Council for Refoundation has produced small miracles in many territories, not in others. This is normal, by the way, because when we innovate, we must accept that it works or it does not work. It has been embraced by some, in fact, as soon as we launched it, because it started with “Marseille en grand” in September 2021 — I see here Mr. the Rector; he was really supported with the Rector, the regional prefect, and many others, in a remarkable way. And we started this innovation.

These were my commitments of 2022 with “Avec vous.” We said: we will try to multiply it. There are places where we believed in it, there are places where we believed in it less. The CNR is not a waste of time, and I speak in front of the High Commissioner for Planning who has the responsibility for national coordination; it is a gain in efficiency and meaning. Our compatriots want to be involved. And here too, this is not an empty promise; it is a promise that we must not betray. They do not ask to participate; they do not ask to be vaguely consulted. They do not ask to be invited to a meeting where they are listened to without any consideration, and then we leave as if we had never done it.

They want to participate, and sometimes to do it with us. And I think that is very good. Because the mobilization of the Nation is this pact between its administration, its local elected officials, and the active forces.

The National Council for Refoundation and its territorial variations embody this principle: listen, be at the service of local initiatives, because many people on the ground, civil servants, associations, local elected officials, do and they do well and they innovate. They sometimes do much better than our collective organization because otherwise, we want to innovate, but we create texts centrally that descend to the ground. It is first too homogeneous. And sometimes, the people who create these texts centrally have never been on the ground.

You know, I was a young inspector of finances; I controlled people. I had never been on the ground. So, it was at the time the grammar. But, it exists, and it is the reality of our collective organization — well, we have people who create texts who have never been on the ground. Do you think this is the best way to innovate? There is no structure that wants to innovate that does it this way in real life. So, let’s look at innovation where it is. We have the same objective; we want our children to be well educated, we want to solve the problem of medical deserts, relieve emergency services, have faster justice, etc. The CNR is about bringing the actors to the table and building collective decision-making. And so, I ask for the systematization of these CNRs, at least for education and health, and I invite all other ministries to seize it. These CNRs are intended to bring civil servants to the table, to be supported by “national project” teams from the DITP - and others, by the way - who come to assist them in structuring, to have elected officials and all actors from a public field. And it must result in an action plan that can be multiannual, with resources that we commit to.

We will never solve the problem of inclusive education if we do not do this, to give you an example. And I say this with full knowledge of the facts. Over the past six years, we have increased the budget for inclusive education by 60%. We have created a public policy; we are putting 3 billion euros into it. Yet, there is not a department where I will go where someone will tell me: “You said you would pay AESH properly, so the support for children with disabilities is not true; you are not doing it.” Why? Because we still have places where we cannot agree between the Rectorate and extracurricular services, because you do not have a full-time support if you only take the school time. It is not the President who will solve it; it is not the Minister who will solve it; it is not a circular that will solve it. It is a form of common sense in action on the ground.

I apologize for saying things that may seem like truisms and bring smiles. I am not joking. It is an essential thing, and it is also a way to empower the actors on the ground. Put the elected officials, the actors of extracurricular services, the parents of students, and the educational community around the table. Do it in every living area or even every establishment. Life will change. First, meaning will be restored. Because you have people who become aware of what they have to do. You already resolve part of this democratic and trust crisis because they no longer have an administration dictating from above what they must do for their own good, saying: you have a problem; I will administer a solution to you. They are respected and participate in the solution. And this conversion of our collective action is essential, and it is what I ask of you because it will make you stronger and allow you to give meaning to your partners, to gain intimacy, trust with them, and to gain collective efficiency.

There will always be places where people do not want to cooperate. I am not naive. There are places where it will work less well, but you will be all the more legitimate at that moment to intervene, to explain that everything has been tried. But there are many places where we do not suspect it, where it will work much better, and where you will especially multiply your energy because we will emerge from a form of distrust that has been somewhat collectively that of the natural reflex of the State, which is “I know better than you.” People do not just want to be heard; they want to be involved; they want to participate; they want to do. And we saw this wonderfully during the Covid period, where many of our compatriots innovated. They created applications to know where the doses were, how we could get vaccinated better. Wonderful innovation; we were lucky. Here too, it must continue in peacetime. So I ask you to systematize...

In our territory, there are, fundamentally, 1,200 living basins, which are more or less our intercommunalities. For me, this is the right territorial scale. Within these 1,200 living basins, we need to organize a public action that is completely rethought, where methods change with regular permanences, but also with these CNRs that are multiplied and will allow us to have an action, I believe, that involves more people, and thereby will be more legitimate and more effective. And then, the fourth element I ask of you in terms of method is to have effective, clear, tangible results. This culture of results is essential. And I reiterate this here with great emphasis. For me, a good result is not a result of the administration for itself, that is to say, what I expect from agents, services, from each decision-making unit, is not to fill indicators that are made for the central office or for the region and that consist of saying: "I have done well for the level above." The ultimate goal, the only one that matters, is the lives of people.

That is why, since 2017, we have established these objectives and these everyday life objects through which we have set the priorities of the Government, which have now indeed become these priority policies of the government.

We have set up an application system that makes it tangible and visible, and I ask all ministers on the ground to go and measure these results that must feed the management dialogue. The management dialogue must be nourished by: "Are you responding to the priorities we have set at the national level within the framework of these four major projects I mentioned earlier? Has the life of people changed or not? If it has not changed, why? Is it a lack of resources, an organizational problem? Why, in the neighboring department, has it changed faster?" And there, I can provide you with these elements.

I strongly request that this culture of results spreads everywhere through these priority policies of the Government. Reviews on the ground, the use of the instruments that have been put in place for monitoring. And I will take up the quarterly points in the Council of Ministers in this regard, with a results-driven approach also at the highest level, just as part of the annual bonus for prefects should be indexed to the achievement of results.

I want us to fully live this doctrine regarding the executive leaders who contribute to achieving these 10 results. We must ensure the quality of services rendered, regardless of the administration, agency, or institution. You must strengthen the evaluation of public services, Public services + help with that. A service rendered, but poorly perceived, is a service not rendered. And so, there is the effectiveness - this culture of results - which I think will be reinforced by decentralization, simplification of the association. But in the end, the last mile must be completed.

This famous last mile that makes the change effective. As long as the last mile is not completed, the change is not effective, it does not exist. 99 kilometers out of 100 do not exist. It is thankless, but that is how it is. And at the same time, it must be perceived. And that is why we need to double our attention to support businesses and the smallest among them in all their processes, such as “France experimentation,” that we need to promote pedagogy, that we need to make our action readable, and that we must, this point may seem minor, but reorganize and simplify communication. The State is here.

I request, under the supervision of the Prime Minister, with coordination ensured by the Government Information Service, that the communication of public action be much simpler, clearer, and more readable. When in a territory, everyone communicates, no one communicates. When communication is too institutional, it exists little. But when, moreover, everyone does their communication for their own interests, between operators, decentralized services among themselves, good luck understanding what we are doing.

I have tried to provide 4 clear objectives. They are broken down into priority policies of the Government. The action must be clear, the communication must be clear for it to be tangible. All of this, of course - and this culture of results - goes through a culture and support of responsibility. I will conclude on this essential point, and the Prime Minister will return to it. I said it in front of the mayors, and I tell you the same way, because it is the same fight: I want to trust the field. I believe in the roadmap I just mentioned. And so, all of this will give much more responsibility to field decision-makers. This can only work if the accountability regime for civil servants allows for more risk-taking and a right to make mistakes. And when I say "civil servants," I also mean the main public decision-makers, and this applies to elected officials. We saw it after Covid, and we also see it in the issues related to climate hazards and ecological transition, for example, in Hauts-de-France or elsewhere.

We need a strengthening of functional protection, training, legal assistance. We need a framework of responsibility that is clarified and allows for simpler decision-making and risk-taking, because what inhibits a good part of public action today is the criminal liability regime. This is the purpose of the mission entrusted this week to Christian VIGOUROUX to assess the new challenges and propose new measures. Decisions will be made in the summer, and the Prime Minister will return to this in detail shortly, but it supports this culture of results, and it is essential.

So, Ladies and Gentlemen, this is what I wanted to tell you this morning, to thank you for having, over all these years, led collective action with strength, a sense of responsibility, and dedication. And I wanted to give you back, for the next 3 years, and until the last moment, the priorities of substance and the method, the transformation in terms of method that needs to be conducted.

There is a lot of work to be done, and there will be a lot of resistance to this. It is not always necessarily individual; it is collective. It is due to habit and, in a way, the imbalance created by such a change. I ask you to assume it with me. I ask you this because — and I will conclude on this — what I am laying out here, the reason for my presence this morning, is that I believe we collectively have in our hands an important part of the response to the crisis of democratic trust that all Western democracies are going through, and paradoxically, I think that France, due to the quality of its state structure, and the natural inclination, despite everything, that our compatriots have for the State and the responses it provides. If we know how to reform ourselves, if we know how to transform and change this culture I mentioned, particularly with the methodological axes I just detailed, we can be one of the first countries to respond to this crisis of trust. In any case, that is what I believe, that is what I want. And for that, I trust you. I will be there to support you, to provide the means. The Prime Minister and his Government will be there to drive and implement the major axes I just mentioned. And I will constantly be on the ground to engage alongside you. Thank you for your attention.

Long live the Republic and long live France!

Moderator

Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you also for agreeing to take some time for exchanges. As agreed, we will start with an exchange with the room. Please raise your questions by signaling to the hostesses, and please remember to state your position before addressing your question.

Anne BLONDY-TOURET

Mr. President of the Republic. Anne BLONDY-TOURET, I am the Secretary General of the Economic and Financial Ministries. Thank you for giving us the opportunity for this exchange, and I wanted to return to what you said about the last mile, the last mile for people, so that people see the effectiveness of public action. And I drew a parallel with the last mile for public agents. Because it is the public agents who are the artisans of the policies we implement, and sometimes the momentum of reforms that you wish for and that we all share is experienced as a challenge to jobs, practices, or even competencies. It takes time to change the administrative culture. And my question is, how do we manage this timing in changing the culture of the administration and the need for quick results? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. You are right. It is indeed a bit of the paradox I mentioned earlier when talking about this sovereign divergence. A world that is moving faster, citizens who want us to move faster. And then public action with its complexity. I believe that change is a managerial practice, and involving agents so that they participate is the key to success. Otherwise, there are these resistances that are there, even frustrations and resentment. And so, I think that the good instruments are: 1) to explain; I do not need to tell you this, and all the managers you are who have to lead changes, sometimes in significant administrations, if we do not explain, if we do not first share the observations and objectives, we do not engage people. And so, it connects to what I said, that I believe we need to move away from a culture that is still too much a culture of writing, of instruction, of verticality to, from the beginning of the requested changes, engage the administrations concerned to share the observations, the transformation, and involve them in very simple objectives to which they can relate. 2) Make the change visible. I think there is nothing worse when we engage in a change strategy. If we know that the final results will not be there immediately. But it is very important to have intermediate results and to show that there is progress. That is why I believe that the applications we have put in place should be instruments that you should seize. Perhaps sometimes, with adaptations made for the agents themselves. Some of these already exist for certain points, but they show that the change in which you have engaged them allows them to be more effective. And thus, make visible through a system that makes public action tangible, whether through regular managerial meetings or the application system we have set up for these priority policies and the everyday life objects, it allows us to engage people because things need to change on a daily basis. 3) Value. That is to say, I am convinced, you are perfectly right to say, a change is not a challenge to the people who are currently taking action because it is simply about re-establishing the priorities that are ours collectively, that we are at the service of priorities and objectives and our compatriots. If we somehow prioritize the preservation of jobs, agents, etc., that is where we can fall into corporatism and the preservation of the status quo. And so, we need to explain this, but also value their skills, and that is also important.

That is how we succeed in converting and bringing about change. And for example, with teams that have been used to systematic control or prior authorization, valuing their expertise and showing them that it is not devalued if we ask them to do rescripts, to provide support rather than immediate control, etc. And so, there you go, associate on the observations and objectives at the beginning, have regular points, and make the progress transparent, including it can be a management dialogue with your ministers; that is to say, to allow agents to see that things are progressing and that they are participating in a destiny larger than themselves. And three, fully value these jobs, I would say, especially since we are asking them to change their practice.

Moderator

We can take a second question from the room with many hands raised. Please go ahead, sir.

Benoît ELLEBOODE

Mr. President. Hello Benoît ELLEBOODE, Director General of the Regional Health Agency of Nouvelle Aquitaine. You have repeatedly emphasized the importance of involving local elected officials in public policies carried out by the State. You have also stressed several times the importance of building health policies at the level of living areas. However, it turns out that despite the fact that access to a general practitioner and primary care is the primary concern of our fellow citizens regarding health, relayed almost daily by local elected officials to the regional health agencies and even to the prefects, well, this is the only area of health policy where there is no space bringing together all the stakeholders: elected officials, health professionals, users, the State, and Health Insurance. For prevention, we have local health contracts, but liberal health professionals do not feel empowered because, and thus it mainly deals with prevention. For the medico-social sector, we involve policies with departmental councils. We thus have a guarantee that local elected officials participate. And for hospitals, we have the hospital supervisory boards that are chaired by mayors. But for primary care, there is absolutely nothing. We have tried, and you mentioned it with the local CNRs, but without legal basis regarding their composition, their missions, and the specific role of elected officials, we see that we struggle to get them to participate or at least there is a fatigue. There are also territorial health councils or territorial CNRs, but as you mentioned, the departmental level is not very conducive for local elected officials because it is too far from the ground.

I know, Mr. President, that creating new bodies does not solve problems, that would be known. But when there is absolutely nothing on such an important subject, do you not think it would be necessary to equip us to allow us to meet your legitimate demands to work at the level of living areas, with local elected officials, on a health project involving the main stakeholders, namely health professionals? It would involve discussion spaces, at the level of the CPTS that correspond to the living areas, which have been chosen by health professionals to organize themselves, which would be chaired by local elected officials, with representatives of health professionals, users, hospitals, nursing homes, and which could discuss MSP projects of CPTS or any other project that would improve access to a general practitioner or, more broadly, health pathways. It would mean a few more meetings for the agents of the regional health agencies, but I think we would survive. Thank you very much, Mr. President.

Emmanuel MACRON

I completely agree with you, but I think you have methodically described what I asked for the CNRs. So, I fully agree with you. I think we must not just take a text, we must implement it. And I think that we, here in this room, need to move away from this culture of norms. You cited dozens of consultation bodies that exist by texts and that are already dead letters.

And so we can create a 101st, 102nd. We are collectively exhausting ourselves creating norms at the central level, making the first two meetings happen, and bureaucratizing the third, and in fact turning it into a dead language that is no longer used. What you have described is exactly, precisely what I am asking for. I am asking you to do it in every living area for health and for schools. You know, when I wanted to do it for schools, I was told, "This will never work." First week.

Second week, I was told, "But it's an ass, it already exists, it's called the school project," I don't remember what, it has a more scholarly name than that. It existed so much that no one knew it the first week. Because, indeed, there is one in every school. But ask a teaching community if they know the project of their own school. Because they did not do it themselves, because it is a kind of thing that has been ritualized. What you have described is exactly what I want. Why? Because the solution in health, to relieve our emergency services as well as to address the problem of medical deserts, is to attract new doctors, it may be to redistribute our interns and externs differently. It is to delegate tasks between medical and paramedical professionals. It is to better collaborate between hospitals and liberal doctors, but also liberal paramedics who must not be forgotten. All of this, there is no body that allows us to do it well, neither the GHT nor the CPTS — we only have acronyms, and moreover, it's awful — hold a territorial meeting.

Do not create texts. The only thing, people do not want a text, they want to be taken seriously. And for you too. So what I am asking you is to do it at the level of a living area, to take the necessary time for a few weeks, to produce a roadmap and that this leads to a contractualization that we respect. The means and the commitments are worth all the texts. People will come to a meeting if they think that behind it, there is something tangible, there are real commitments and that we will not take this or that away from them later. If you commit to maintaining a certain service, a certain facility in a living area where the ARS has participated in work where there is a commitment from the medical community and elected officials to carry out such or such action, I can tell you that they will come to the second meeting, much more than if we had taken a national text. And fundamentally, your question is very valid. I fully agree with it, but the very fact that you ask it says something about what I described earlier. There is a collective inhibition to act and there is a collective expectation regarding the norm. Do it, you have the mandate, I give it to you! Do it, it’s territorial CNRs in every living area! For schools and health at least. If others are ready to take it up, do it everywhere. I want a systematic assessment, but do it by taking people seriously, that is to say by producing 4-5 commitments in each territory over 2 to 3 years that you will keep and you will engage people. You will transform the life of the country, I promise you, you will transform it.

Prefect

Mr. President, in a word, you emphasized the last mile and indeed, that is where we see the result, the efficiency of public action. In this regard, the departmental level, I say this with even more ease as a regional prefect, is truly essential. If we want, I would say, to succeed, to somewhat transform the outcome of this last mile, we nevertheless need, beyond the evolutions we are conducting in mission reviews, to be attentive to the adequacy of mission/resources, it seems to me to be absolutely essential. I remind you that to simply take the ATE perimeter, the territorial administration of the State, it is a small network, the network of prefectures, the network of the three DDI, I always cite this figure, about 52,000 agents, the equivalent of the city of Paris to situate, which truly constitutes the backbone of the State. So, I believe that if we really want this service, this last mile to be ensured, whether at the departmental level and sub-departmental level, particularly in living areas, many things are resolved at this scale. There will undoubtedly be, in the difficult budgetary times we will have to face and to which we will obviously have to participate, I believe, be attentive to this very particular issue of the adequacy of mission/resources. I just wanted to point out this fact, Mr. President.

Emmanuel MACRON

So, I completely share this and that is why I am asking you to massively decentralize resources, massively. That is to say, I think we need to put civil servants who are currently in central or operator positions back on the ground, to return agents who are in regional capitals to the ground, I think that is essential. We have often redone recognition, first because I say it, we have borne the budgetary efforts and reductions in resources at the departmental level and we have often done it to create centers of expertise. Essentially, we have tended to use digital technology and the transformations of digital usage in a single way and it has increased metropolitanization in our country. I think that is not coherent, we can very well have agents that we put back on the ground who often live better in terms of quality of life and budget. We know very well the difficulty we sometimes have, for some agents of our administrations, territorial agents, to live well in metropolises where real estate prices have skyrocketed, where it is much more complicated. I also think we need to value this for our agents. But putting them back is a policy of land use planning and life also in our peripheral cities. There is nothing to prevent having agents who will be in the department, in the region, sometimes even in sub-prefectures, who participate in a regional center of expertise and who, through the use of digital technology and the uses we have deployed, have this competence; rather than having all these people concentrated in a service at the region, or even more so, only in the capital, that is what we have done in recent decades. This means that on many issues where we instructed the file, I think, for example, of housing issues at the departmental level, we have raised it to the regional level, I fully agree with that. That is why I am asking you for a revolution in terms of resources and I say this all the more because I have given a lot of responsibilities to the prefect and the ministry. But what I asked the Ministry of the Interior in 2017, we did not do it on decentralization and inter-ministerial cooperation, we did not do it. I tell you, I said the same phrases in 2017, so now it is up to you to do the work, you need to push. It has started on sub-prefectures, gendarmeries, it has started on treasury offices, but we need to go much more massively and in all ministries, you are perfectly right.

Moderator

We now return to the last question which comes to us via videoconference from the prefecture of Isère. The France 2030 funds are intended to be invested quickly. Some project leaders are positioning themselves on major strategic issues through the recovery of industrial sovereignty. Like any land use project, the prefect sets up a project mode optimizing the various procedures according to common law and numerous legal challenges related to it. The process remains long and complex due to environmental procedures. What adaptations to the application of the norm could be considered to combine an exceptional issue and an optimal timeline?

Emmanuel MACRON

This is obviously a good question. It returns to the tensions we discussed earlier. First of all, there is no inevitability and I have a good example. I was alongside several of you last week to inaugurate the Olympic village. Everyone told us it was impossible: we created the largest land use project in Europe in recent years. We did it despite all that, we did it in 5 years, we created thousands of housing units, thousands of square meters of offices in one of the places where it is not the easiest to build, in Seine-Saint-Denis, already very dense and it will be sustainable. There was a text that passed, what we can do for the Olympics, we can do for 2030, so there is no inevitability; we can do it. This is indeed the whole point of what we are going to do and what we are currently doing on these major projects. This is what we did for the 22 national interest operations in housing: simplify, change procedures, and unify. And this is part of the simplifications that will be proposed and carried by the Government within the framework of our industrial and environmental sovereignty for many projects.

Next, I think that in terms of method, we can achieve this collectively, when we anticipate and aggregate. What struck me when speaking to the actors of the Olympic village and those who have some experience with these projects is that we used a few elements of standards that we had modified, but not that much. The exemptions we had set in the Olympic law were not really used by the teams; what was a key factor was having an operator that unifies public action, that is the lesson I took from it and I speak of it for all of us. SOLIDEO, with the help of the interministerial delegate, the regional prefect, the departmental prefects, and elected officials, aggregated all the procedures and assembled the actors, architects, and developers. We stepped out of the game that we know by heart for this type of project that we know for 2030, which is: one goes to see the other. The authorizations, in a way, accumulate and we have a sequential management of projects, which means that when we finish urban planning, we start on the environment, etc., etc., etc., and that is what takes time. So, a single interlocutor, procedures that are all parallelized, and the responsibility of one person; it resembles what we have been saying all along: we decentralize, we simplify, we empower, and we undo administrative complexity. It worked, there are very few exemptions. This is exactly what needs to be done for all our major projects. France 2030, but beyond that, it is a very good method and it aligns with what I just said about decentralization. I am very attached to this method. And so, the responsibility of assembling, that is what needs to be systematized. We will do it for the 22 operations, for housing, I hope we can do it to the maximum.

The last point on France 2030 is anticipation; it is very true about the land we need to free up. That is why we launched, as part of France 2030, a mission to pre-identify the land, with the Caisse des Dépôts, the bank of territories, and precisely the prefects; we are doing a bit of the work that was done — I took the example of Dunkirk. Why does it work very quickly in Dunkirk? Because there was anticipation regarding the industrial wastelands; you had elected officials, prefects, and state services that had anticipated. We had land that was ready to build on, and therefore, all the preliminary delays were compressed. And that, I think, is a very good method. So, we are currently identifying for France 2030 the wastelands that can be eligible — and for that, I thank you collectively for this work on the territory — and exhausting all the procedures we can exhaust, if I may put it that way, before having the final project, when it is selected by the teams of France 2030 so that they can arrive with almost a "turnkey" solution.

Speaker

Thank you, Mr. President. I believe I can speak for many of us to say that we are very sensitive to your focus on administration. You mentioned the expression "We need to turn the pyramid upside down and trust the field." And it seems to me that to enable that, there is also a question of grammar. I believe this is an expression you often use, meaning that ultimately, on the piano of administration, there may be new keys to invent as well. You indeed mentioned the CNR, and I think it would be interesting to mobilize all the intelligence that is here, all the know-how, the new tools, the ways to adapt to this new way of doing things that you invite us to. It is true that we have all been raised on instruments that may sometimes be a bit outdated, and I would find it useful that this invitation to the field, ultimately, we could also embody it through the field, and that we are, in fact, on administration and public policies, a force for proposal to imagine new ways of doing things and to feed a sort of doctrine of action. Finally, I do not want to be excessively restrictive in this way of doing things, but we need to be able to aggregate around good examples. You spoke, for example, about territorial action, everything that has been done at ANCT, on the Actions Cœur de Ville programs, Petite Ville de Demain, the New Deal Mobile. We can see that there are a whole bunch of practices on which we could ultimately capitalize to develop a new way of acting that we could rely on. There you go, that’s a proposal.

Emmanuel MACRON

I fully agree with what you just said, and you were right to highlight the importance of these collective innovations. They actually came from the field: Action Cœur de Ville is a proposal made by a team of senior civil servants who proposed it to Minister MÉZARD at the time, which was then implemented by Minister MÉZARD and later GOURAULT in the previous mandate and which indeed allowed for the emergence of field action coming from elected officials; it played a role of assembly and is a very good illustration of this change in method. I fully endorse what you said: "Dare," take the initiative if you have ideas, whether it is the use of tools; by the way, I was talking about artificial intelligence, a better capacity to involve our fellow citizens, to transform daily action, I am very much in favor of that. I believe our responsibility is to enable the sharing of these good examples and to benefit our colleagues, of course. I think this change in method applies to everyone, so the grammar, I agree with, is the one you mentioned. But really, for me, the few elements we shared this morning are very important and they are key, at the heart of what we collectively have to do. And I say this to you with a lot of strength because you probably see it on the ground with many of our fellow citizens; we see it in the crises we have to manage, the anger that exists, the impatience. And this applies to the overseas territories as well as to the Hexagon; we are no longer given blank checks, that applies to me as well as to you. People no longer trust words; they have a bit more trust in local words than in words from above because they know. And soon, there will come a day when they will no longer trust any words. And so, really, our work is for the act to follow the word as quickly as possible and for it to be coherent, for us to improve things, I think collectively, that is your motivation, that is your vocation. That is why you joined the state service, and that is why I joined it too and committed myself. We have a duty to question ourselves a bit, if I may say so, collectively, so that we can move faster, be more perceptible, and perhaps better involve people in this work; I will not go back over everything I have said so far. At the heart of this very simple message, I feel an urgency because otherwise, they will only listen to anger. It is often a bad advisor, while so many things are being done, while you are doing so much with all your teams, so many things on all fronts. I think these small elements of method, at the heart of culture, grammar, change, ways of doing things, and the demand for results, their effectiveness, are absolutely essential if we want to succeed in bringing people along with us; they only ask for that. There you go, I will finish on this note to tell you how, on a very personal level, I feel the almost burning message that I share with you. It should touch us all; if we do not feel that we have a part of ourselves that is at stake in this matter, it means we are missing something. We can no longer be at ease. So be engaged, proud of what you do because you do it well. In permanent questioning, in kindness with our fellow citizens. And be at ease with me. Long live the Republic and long live France! I trust you.