Speech by the President of the Republic - Permanent Mission of France - UN - Internet Terrorism

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

21 September 2017 · Permanent Mission of France to the UN, Internet terrorism event · Permanent Mission of France - UN

Context
Macron addressed internet company leaders and government officials at France's UN Permanent Mission on September 21, 2017, to advance a joint declaration on fighting terrorist propaganda online.
Main themes
Counter-terrorism on the internet, removal of terrorist content, online radicalization prevention, government-tech company cooperation, speed of content detection and removal, algorithmic confinement, collective responsibility, legislative pressure, G7 and Franco-British initiatives, protection of citizens
Duration
~12 min
41st percentile
Words
1,405
41st percentile
Sentences
48
31st percentile
Readability
35
24th percentile
Grade
15.7
81st percentile
Syntax
3.15
67th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
53rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Technological 43%38%
  • Institutional 29%25%
  • Geopolitical 12%10%
  • Ceremonial 12%10%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 13%

48 sentences in 19 paragraphs

Madam Prime Minister, dear Theresa,

Mr. President of the Council, dear Paolo, dear Ken WALKER,

Ladies and gentlemen,

What Theresa MAY has just said, I can fully subscribe to, and indeed, particularly following the attacks that Great Britain has suffered, the initiative taken in Taormina, under the Italian presidency of the G7, and then the initiative taken in the extended Franco-British joint declaration to our European partners, have marked this collective will we have to move towards an agenda for a greater and more effective fight against terrorist propaganda on the Internet.

What is it about? The Prime Minister has just reminded us, it is about our collective effectiveness in protecting our citizens. And it is a challenge that we share, governments and Internet operators, let there be no mistake, if in today's world, with contemporary communication technologies, we no longer have the ability, we governments, to guarantee the protection of our fellow citizens against what endangers them, against those who kill our children, then either we change civilization, or we will move towards much harsher rules.

And we have already lost a lot of time on this issue because for too long some have believed that it was solely the responsibility of governments to protect our citizens. And it must be said, the world of the Internet is a tremendous opportunity that revolutionizes our imagination, that allows us to be more effective, that creates a new continent of opportunities, but there is also, unfortunately, the worst that plays out there. And so the question is how collectively we take our responsibilities so that the worst no longer plays out there.

In this regard, today's declaration is a step, is it a sufficient step? No. Is it a satisfactory step? In a sense, since it improves the situation we were in. Does it call for other meetings and further progress? Resoundingly yes.

Because if we cannot make progress in this form, we will have to make it in other forms, under the pressure of events, and we will do so through legislation, whereas we collectively believe it is smarter to proceed as we are doing today.

The first effort, the first direction adopted by this declaration and the approach we have collectively taken for several weeks is the removal of content that glorifies terrorism and calls for violence. The speed of detection and removal of potentially terrorist or hateful content is improving. The Prime Minister has just reminded us, every hour counts, every hour because it is young people or less young people who have access to this propaganda, who can suddenly fall into situations of great fragility, we know this, it has been documented.

Not all content is identified, and I do not underestimate the difficulty of identifying content that is purely terrorist. The most brutal and violent scenes are easily identified, but there are speeches that are more insidious, and we therefore need to work even harder to better identify them. Moreover, removed content can reappear, and some content is not even removed due to the difficulty of detecting it.

And faced with a modern army of terrorists who use asymmetric modes of action, states and companies must adapt their strategy. First, it seems to me that the large companies represented here have committed in the joint declaration that we will publish to increase the resources dedicated to the removal of content. This is a necessary commitment that I want to acknowledge here. We need more investment in research, more human resources, more automation to achieve rapid, definitive, and complete removals.

It is also necessary that the efforts made by large companies to identify and remove illegal content benefit smaller companies as well, so that this content does not reappear on lesser-known social networks and does not follow parallel paths. I also note that with its Redirect project, one of the companies in the forum is addressing a particular risk, that of algorithmic confinement, that is, the risk that an individual surfing the Net is only exposed to content that reinforces their radicalization. This is an absolutely essential approach, and I believe that in this regard, the declaration is not sufficiently precise, and it is essential that all operators can move forward in the direction of this effort.

It must therefore be pursued, developed to offer the person on the path to radicalization content that is likely, on the contrary, to encourage doubt and questioning. We must collectively have a strategy that is adapted to our deep purposes, which is to bring these individuals on the path to radicalization or fragility back to common sense.

We must now set ourselves a first ambitious but by no means unattainable goal, that of removing propaganda content within less than an hour of its posting. It is in the first hour that everything is at stake; within an hour, the content must be identified, analyzed, and removed to limit the possibilities of massive re-dissemination. Our experience shows that this is possible, and I sincerely hope that our teams, all three of us, as well as all the members of the teams represented here, can work with the operators in a precise, concrete manner and by making sustainable commitments.

On incitement to racial or religious hatred, we must also progress more quickly; commitments have been made at the European level with companies within the framework of the code of conduct to combat illegal hate speech disseminated online.

We have already said that if we do not achieve tangible results, then it will be up to us to legislate and put in place more binding rules, because we have no choice, because it is our responsibility towards our fellow citizens, because in my eyes it is the responsibility of all those who are sitting in this room.

The second strong axis of our effort must focus on civil society discourse, and this is a subject on which, in particular, the Prime Minister has committed from the beginning, and I want to acknowledge her leadership here. The anti-terrorism message must not be carried solely by states, and many other actors are already doing so. Numerous projects led by civil society have thus undertaken to disseminate on the Internet a discourse that denounces that of terrorist groups, a discourse based on facts, on our humanist values, on an enlightened reading of religion. And our collective role is to help these independent voices to be heard, whether they are moral personalities, religious leaders, or young people speaking to their peers; we must not interfere with the content or form of this alternative discourse, but we can, on the other hand, allow it to reach the greatest number. This counter-propaganda is absolutely essential because part of the battles won by jihadists is fought on the imagination, on their ability to propose heroes, to offer stories in which our young people or less young people can identify.

We must therefore bring forth this counter-propaganda with a discourse that is not an official discourse that governments have to emit, but which, disseminated by the operators, will allow for the proposal of positive models and a positive imagination consistent with our values. Important initiatives have been taken, but I call on the large companies represented here to further develop their action to support civil society actors in disseminating a credible and legitimate response to the propaganda of terrorist groups.

I therefore wish, dear friends, that we can from today continue to work concretely to go further so that the essential commitments I have recalled and that we had at one point believed possible in the short term can materialize as soon as possible, that additional commitments be made, that we can also together develop public lists of operators who decide to engage in this line, because we must now move towards a policy of name and shame on this subject if you allow me this anglicism. We must value the operators who decide to play the game and, by contrast, denounce the operators who decide not to play the game because in this battle against terrorist propaganda, there are not three camps, there are only two. There are those who fight for our values, the freedom and security of our fellow citizens, and there are those who, by their actions, choose to play into the hands of terrorists. One must choose a side; ambiguity only serves one of the two. Thank you for your attention.