Transcript - Speech by the President of the Republic at the Conference on Sustainable Finance (Brussels)

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

22 March 2018 · Conference on Sustainable Finance · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Macron addressed a sustainable finance conference in Brussels on March 22, 2018, urging scaled-up climate investment and reaffirming France's commitment to the Paris Agreement.
Main themes
Climate change action, sustainable finance, Paris Agreement commitments, low-carbon investment, energy transition, carbon neutrality, European climate policy, global temperature trajectories, biodiversity and migration risks, transport revolution, energy efficiency, renewable energy
Duration
~33 min
86th percentile
Words
4,002
86th percentile
Sentences
136
77th percentile
Readability
40
35th percentile
Grade
15.0
76th percentile
Syntax
3.39
89th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
26th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Environmental 44%43%
  • Economic 39%38%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Geopolitical 7%7%
  • Institutional 2%2%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

136 sentences in 32 paragraphs

Brussels, March 22, 2018.

Thank you very much, Mr. Vice-President. Thank you both for your words and for the commitment of the European Commission on this climate issue. Thank you for organizing this conference on sustainable finance, and thank you to Mike Bloomberg once again for being here to carry this long-standing commitment, as well as many other friendly faces found in this amphitheater who, for several years, long before others engaged and before we engaged, have championed this cause, this concern, this determination.

When it comes to climate, there is an absolute responsibility that falls on political leaders, which is to tell the truth. This is normally an obligation for all subjects, but for this one even more so, first, because it commits not only ourselves but all those who will follow us, and secondly because we can no longer say that we did not know or that there were controversies or that some reports said it was not so certain. We know perfectly well; the matter is established. We have made commitments, the Paris Agreement is part of them, and we have collectively reaffirmed our commitment to this Agreement. And yet, things continue to deteriorate.

So I envy greatly and I want to envy our distant successors who, in 30 years, will be able to describe the positive gains for the climate from the policies undertaken. We have to fundamentally change many of these policies and lament that the actions of past policies continue to be seen more and more each week, each month. But since the last time we met, things have happened. While last month in Western Europe, we were falling below seasonal norms, the North Pole experienced, despite the Arctic night, temperatures 15°C higher. It was almost summer up there, and never has the ice cover been so reduced. This was after the One Planet Summit.

The latest assessment of our commitments has shown that, even though we have committed to a limited increase averaging 1.5°C and that some would not want to follow this commitment, we are on a trajectory that would be at least 3 to 3.5°C. And I remind you, a world that is built on the trajectory of 4°C is a world where biodiversity collapses and where countries represented at the United Nations disappear. It is a world where uncontrolled migrations accelerate, where climate disasters will affect, including in our ecosystems, energy, agriculture, and disrupt all the balances on which we have built our policy.

So, despite our efforts and despite the mobilization of our diplomacies and the results obtained at the One Planet Summit on December 12 last in Paris, we are heading towards the irreversible, and therefore this requires a profound transformation of our choices in terms of public policy, as well as private investment. And it is on this point that I want to return here, bringing all of France's support to the initiative of the European Commission.

We must above all rethink our investments and change scale. The beginning of any action is to define credible objectives, trajectories that allow us to achieve them, and that is what we have collectively done in recent years. We have thus defined a carbon neutrality strategy by 2050, the phasing out of thermal vehicles by 2040, and the end of exploration and exploitation of hydrocarbons, as well as the closure of coal-fired power plants before the end of the term. One can always say that 2030, 2040, or 2050 is very far away. That we will not be held accountable. I wish to build during the years I have the responsibility of my country the trajectory and the concrete strategy that will allow us to get there. But already, I have set measurable objectives for the exploration and exploitation of hydrocarbons, as well as for coal-fired power plants, which are currently being implemented.

It is also about resolutely engaging in a transport revolution by generalizing electric and hydrogen vehicles and converting truck fleets to gas. This is a national strategy that we have initiated. It must also accelerate at the European level. It is about massively renovating the energy efficiency of our homes, our public buildings, our businesses, achieving the decarbonization of energy production, whether it be renewable energies, green gas, biomass, or nuclear. These are just a few examples, examples that we all know, but which today must be scaled up at the European level as well as at the global level, and which require redirecting many of our major investments.

If we look at things today as we know them, as the Commission has confirmed in its recent reports, it is more than 900 billion dollars of low-carbon investment that our planet needs each year by 2030. Just in terms of energy, therefore. More than 300 billion dollars to build decarbonized electricity production capacities and around 600 billion dollars in energy efficiency to transform both mobility, housing, and everything that today consumes energy that is far too often poorly produced.

However, in the face of this annual need, we have an investment volume that is there: every year, 6 trillion dollars are invested worldwide. The problem is the direction of these investments, starting with public investments; the allocations are not right. We still have 400 billion dollars each year going towards investments in fossil fuels, which are not only of little use to this transition but contrary to these objectives and which continue to build productive modes that go in the wrong direction. 400 billion dollars a year that serve to build new coal-fired power plants, to continue or accelerate the exploration and production of hydrocarbons.

We must therefore, in all our decisions, whether it be the investment decisions of the European Union in its budget, as well as in our international battles, succeed in conveying the coherence of our messages. This is what I tried to do at the beginning of the year when, during my visit to China, I explained that these New Silk Roads, this One Belt One Road Initiative, must be consistent with support for the Paris Agreement reaffirmed by China. The New Silk Roads cannot be used to open coal-fired power plants in Minor Asia or Africa. And we ourselves, in our development policies and our strategy, must massively finance solar, renewable energy, and new networks in each of these countries.

I note here that public incentives for private investment also go through the regulation of certain markets. And when we talk about redirecting our investments, we are also talking about the regulatory framework that we must build. And I am thinking particularly of the carbon price. It is one of the essential battles that Europe can lead in the coming years. We have made progress with the ETS. We have thus been able to encourage other continents or other major states to follow us, and China was able to announce on December 12 last in Paris, where we were together, its willingness to set up a market equivalent to ours in terms of carbon; but we need to go further because creating a market is one thing, but if we do not have a sufficiently incentivizing price system, we will not change investment behaviors.

So France has made its choice. We will gradually raise the carbon price from 44 euros in 2018 to 84 euros in 2022 on the domestic market. But that is not sufficiently effective. We need to have a carbon market that works at the European level, that is to say, that creates the right incentives to change investments, to encourage some to invest in these new sectors and to take into account this need that I just mentioned and to disincentivize investment in an outdated, unsustainable economic model that still exacerbates the consequences I mentioned a moment ago.

That is why at the European level, we need a European carbon floor price. It is the only way to achieve this objective. I know that it is not easy. We will face resistance everywhere. This is not a discovery; on this subject, we only have resistance. But it will also be the only way to create new economic opportunities because we will accelerate investment in other sectors that will also create jobs, that will allow the emergence of energy that is not only more decarbonized but more decentralized and, often, more intensive in direct jobs.

France will therefore support this vision with a European carbon floor price that will accelerate the transformation of our economies and that must be accompanied, on the one hand, by a support strategy for the territories and economic actors who will have to bear the consequences because we must have a transition policy towards the territories that will be most impacted, as well as for our fellow citizens who will have to live through these transformations, and without any stigmatization that should be made, but with a real support policy and also with a border adjustment mechanism so as not to penalize our companies by our climate commitment. This means that we will also have to implement a border tax when we have actors who decide not to follow the same environmental choices.

There will be no sustainable finance without sustainable projects, and that is why I want us to commit to this path, and it is the one that I will defend, particularly at the European Council in June. Low-carbon solutions are today often financed by public support, which is absolutely essential, but we must increasingly move towards a mix of public and private support. This is what we have done at the French level in terms of housing renovation. This is what we will continue in terms of adapting these homes by 2020 with a public investment plan, but which aims to trigger investment and commitment from the private sector. And to truly change scale, these are the economic models that we must continue to develop at the European level, as well as at the international level.

This is indeed the profound evolution we initiated a few weeks ago, in line with a commitment reaffirmed on December 12 last in Paris, by launching the International Solar Alliance with Prime Minister Modi and more than 20 heads of state and government in India. This International Solar Alliance marks an investment by the signatory states, but behind it, a massive investment from the private sector – institutional investors, companies, and innovators – to precisely support this transformation and create this virtuous circle of green finance. You see, I deeply believe that if we make some clear choices, particularly at the European level, we can redirect our investments and contribute to profoundly changing the model.

The second essential pillar to achieve this is to have a European climate-friendly financial system, and this is at the heart of what you announced a few weeks ago and what President Juncker reaffirmed this morning. There are several avenues to explore and several decisions to be made in this regard. The first is obviously to make the risk profile of these investments acceptable for private financiers. Thus, public actors must bear the more complex risks, and public money must be invested alongside private resources on public interest issues. This is the core of the philosophy I just explained, and it is what will allow us to have new initiatives, such as the one in favor of developing green bond emissions in emerging economies led by the International Finance Corporation and several actors from the private financial system and supported by many public financial institutions in Europe, or the initiative taken in favor of restoring degraded lands led by the United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification, again with the involvement of many private actors.

If we want to build a green and sustainable European economy, we now need a more integrated European equity economy, relying on genuine long-term European investors who can invest in infrastructure and projects for sustainable ecological transition. This transformation is perfectly consistent with what Europe has been driving for nearly 10 years in terms of financing infrastructure for its economy. But today, we need not only to accelerate it, but while fully building it, to affirm its sustainability, to affirm our commitment to the climate. This will be crucial for developing an industrial sector in energy storage and hydrogen or supporting the development of the ecosystem around connected and autonomous vehicles, which are essential for reducing the environmental impact of the transport sector.

Together, we have redefined global governance of financial regulation, essentially after the crisis experienced 10 years ago. However, we have not addressed the core issues that led us to that crisis. Most of the excesses of capitalism that led to the 2008-2010 crisis are still present, and we have become complacent about this regulation. More precisely, we have – and Europe has been exemplary in this regard – regulated very well the already well-regulated actors, but we have regulated very little those who essentially led to what we sometimes experienced at the heart of our countries. This is a reality. We therefore need to resume the fight for financial regulation, but to do so by looking at where the real excesses are, which are much more on the side of shadow banking and the regulation of currently unregulated investors, and align it with our objectives; the issue with this unregulated capitalism is that it does not take into account its own negative externalities, and climate change is one of them.

If we want to fully regulate things, let’s go all the way and take into account all actors to fully regulate them and affirm that they must invest in this model change and consider that sustainability objectives must be integrated into regulatory mechanisms. Today, what we are going to build with all the Member States is the framework that must allow finance to serve the common good and carbon neutrality. That is why I want to commend the work that has been done by the high-level group that enabled the Commission to develop an ambitious action plan for sustainable finance.

This action plan does not concern a niche, an enlightened vanguard of finance, but rather all financial and economic actors. And the regulatory framework it proposes to build rests, in my view, on a few key axes that I want to support here. First, to provide European savers with credible information about the destination of their money through the labeling of sustainable funds. In France, we ensure that savers can easily subscribe to green funds under good conditions and within the framework of the most widespread savings products, and I want all European savers to have access to quality savings products thus labeled without falling into what is sometimes called greenwashing.

We will then impose a requirement for transparency and truth regarding climate risks. Risk is at the heart of finance. Investors must more systematically measure what climate risk is and its financial consequences. Here too, commitments have been made: there was support for the Task Force on Climate Disclosure on December 12 last year as part of a comparable initiative, with companies and partner investors. We must now aim for widespread transparency for all European companies and investors. And since climate risks are a major threat to the sustainability of the global economy and thus financial stability, we must ensure that the prudential regulatory framework fully takes climate risks into account and is consistent with our ambition for ecological transition.

The proposed action plan will also aim to integrate elements of climate sustainability and climate commitments into prudential calculation methods. I believe this is a good measure, and we will support it. Finally, I deeply wish that these regulatory proposals not only be adopted at the European level, supported by regulators, but that they can also be developed at the G20 level and in the bodies we have revived after the financial crisis, but that we can also, in that context, expand our regulatory and oversight mechanisms to all actors who are not subject to the regulations I just mentioned. This is both a coherence with our climate objectives that we must pursue and a regulation of all market financial actors, including those who are currently unregulated. This is the condition for effectiveness without which we will inevitably have a European debate that we know by heart, which consists of already regulated actors, sometimes seeing themselves as over-regulated, saying: "You are going to add rules on sustainable development but you do not impose them on those who do not already have prudential rules."

Let us avoid falling into these internal dialogues and have a renewed determination on the international stage because the climate crisis may be less covered in the daily media than the financial crisis was, but its consequences are more lasting, more irreversible, and compel us to revive the regulatory strength that we managed to find on the international level in 2008-2010.

Finally, to conclude beyond these two pillars – I do not want to be too long here, so I will not be exhaustive – but you have understood, it is indeed a Capital Markets Union integrating the climate emergency that we must build at the European level. It is the coherence of these objectives that we must pursue. Indeed, beyond the European financial system, we must constantly question the coherence of our European economic policy with the climate emergency. We must ensure the alignment of our policies with these objectives because I have spoken about our investments, I have spoken about our financial system, but we can completely dismantle this commitment if, on the other choices we will have to make, particularly in the coming months, we are not consistent with this, and I will only mention two.

We will have to build a budget. The European budget cannot be inconsistent with these objectives or renounce to integrate them into our traditional or new policies. We must fully integrate this ambition into the major historical policies, as well as the new policies we will have to define. That is why we must – and this is to be debated in the Council – set a spending target for the next budget contributing to ecological transition and ensure that no expenditure is hostile to the climate. I think that setting the target of 40% of the budget to allow this transition would be ambitious in light of what is currently measured, but achievable, and it would allow us to set a common rule. And I also wish to create new own resources for the European budget, consistent with our environmental ambition. That is why, for example, the carbon tax at the borders that I mentioned could very well be both a means of financing policies consistent with this transition will and establishing a transition policy by providing own resources to the European Union.

The second major choice we will have to make, which must be consistent with our discussion today, is our trade policy. In times when our collective trade policy is threatened by temptations of unilateralism, we must first constantly reaffirm that we want to respect the rules we have set for ourselves and that this is the basis of multilateralism and the rule of law. And so I am not in favor of any leniency towards those who decide to violate them, because they are our rules, because we have constantly respected our rules in good faith. But in the agreements we have to negotiate, in the trade policy we are developing, we can no longer continue to pursue objectives that are sometimes contrary to our own policy within our borders because we thereby discourage the economic actors and investors to whom we ask for efforts.

This is the heart of the debate we had in France on the application of CETA, which has been the subject of exemplary parliamentary work with a follow-up, a specification that will be shared with all our European partners and which will allow us to monitor, in particular, its environmental impacts. But I wish, for my part, that trade agreements, by somewhat reversing our philosophy and the burden of proof, become a means to disseminate our standards and raise international norms and standards, and that every signatory of a trade agreement with the European Union commits to implementing the Paris Agreement on climate in practice. This is consistent! We have applied rules to ourselves, we sometimes go beyond them, we ask our actors to do so, why would we sign trade agreements that deepen the multilateral framework and go beyond what the WTO provides with powers that declare they do not want to implement the Paris Agreement? But we would be quite foolish! First, I would not be able to explain it to those territories I was talking about, to whom we explain that it will be necessary to close a coal-fired power plant because it is not good and it does not comply with our climate agreements if, on the other side, I allow access to certain goods coming from a country that has said that within its borders it is not that serious.

So common goods are meant to be shared in voluntarism and constraints. And so, let us not have this weak policy that consists for the European Union in always considering that it is subjected to the rules, but that it would somehow be too marginal on a global scale to be able to carry them. We must have an assumed climate leadership, which means that our trade policy, I am in favor of it, I support having an ambitious trade policy, but it must be consistent with our climate objectives, as well as with our social objectives. And it must be a means not to gradually become the marginal players in a world that is fracturing, where authoritarian powers – with the fragmentation of multilateralism – are regaining strength, but to become those who help to disseminate the rules, to disseminate the European model that we have gradually built decade after decade and which is the one that today most clearly integrates the combination of our interests and the common goods of the planet. And so, on this point, I think our statements would be quite vain if, both on our budget and our trade policy, we were not fully coherent.

I will not be longer, Ladies and Gentlemen, my friends, except to reiterate all the support I want to give to the work of the European Commission and, as you have understood, the maximum ambition I want us to have on this subject. We will have other battles to fight in the coming months. I hope that together we can carry and accelerate the work around a Global Pact for the Environment that will build the next step of an indispensable international law to push all private and public actors to lead these transitions and profoundly transform their economy, as well as their society. This Global Pact for the Environment that we presented last September at the United Nations, I hope that we can, with all the Member States of the European Union and with the European Commission, continue its development to convince as many partners as possible and achieve a signature by 2020.

Then, I hope that we can continue on the international level, with the full support of the European Union, the concrete initiatives we have launched with this desire to mobilize the private sector, as well as the public sector. That is why I will organize, with Special Envoy Michael Bloomberg, a follow-up meeting on these commitments in New York next September, on the sidelines of the United Nations General Assembly, which will allow us both to take stock, a sort of review of the 12 commitments made on December 12 last year in Paris, but also to push many investors and other countries, and who knows, Europe, to make new firm commitments in the fight against climate change. Thank you for your attention.