Transcription of the speech by the President of the Republic at the Early Childhood Conference.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

27 March 2018 · Early Childhood Conference · CNAM, Paris, France

Context
Macron addressed an Early Childhood Conference at CNAM in Paris on March 27, 2018, announcing the lowering of France's compulsory schooling age from 6 to 3.
Main themes
Mandatory preschool education, compulsory schooling age reduction, early childhood development, educational equality, social inequality and disadvantaged communities, French republican education system, cognitive and affective development, overseas territories disparities, historical education reforms, school journey foundational moments
Duration
~30 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,540
82nd percentile
Sentences
85
55th percentile
Readability
33
22nd percentile
Grade
18.8
96th percentile
Syntax
3.77
98th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 73%72%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Institutional 10%9%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

85 sentences in 39 paragraphs

CNAM - Paris – Tuesday, March 27, 2018

THE PRESIDENT: Mr. Minister of National Education, Madam, Mr. Minister, Mr. Rector of Paris, Ladies and Gentlemen Rectors, Mr. Mayor, Ladies and Gentlemen Parliamentarians. Ladies and Gentlemen.

First of all, I would like to acknowledge with you the always somewhat strange nature of these interventions at the beginning of a working seminar; I am not here to conclude them, nor do I come with the foresight of what you will exchange over the next two days. So I come before you with some humility, but also with a few convictions that I will return to, which will be the heart of my remarks, and which are linked to the work that we have been conducting together for several weeks, and which allows, regardless of everything you will discuss and then implement, to set a part of the course.

Moreover, there is always something strange indeed in these opening remarks; it is the frustration, as far as I am concerned, because I will not be able to stay with you for two days, even if the sample I have just had gives me a furious desire to do so. Because it is about entering into the intimacy of the matter of this human matter, both affective and cognitive, which has been described, both by the minister, Jean-Michel BLANQUER, and then by Boris CYRULNIK, who gives all its meaning to what you do on a daily basis, and to what is important to continue doing.

Finally, having this discussion today, here, in this place, is not innocent. Because I would say that this place, Mr. General Administrator, you have perfectly said, was made for this, and in this spirit. It is the place where those who believed in the stakes of knowledge and social progress decided to contribute to the building of our Nation, and which since 1794 has, year after year, laid its stone in the intuitions of Grégoire, as you have perfectly recalled.

Because I must say that the destiny of our country has always been forged, engraved in its educational system, which is not only the exact mirror but also the factory in which it has decided, at every moment, to think about its own future, to shape it, to modify it, and to outline the perspectives. And so there is always something eminently political in the noblest and deepest sense of the term when we indeed talk about Education, because it is there that we build the society we have to create and that we want to see.

It is in this spirit that I came here today to talk about preschool education. For of all the moments in the school journey, preschool remains perhaps the most misunderstood by our fellow citizens, even if, as you recalled, Mr. Minister, it is implicitly, and in fact, widely supported. Almost everyone uses it, but without always understanding its place between daycare and elementary school, and in our republican mythology, preschool does not occupy all the space it should occupy.

So, I came today to try, with you, to change that, and to say that, based on what has begun to be said and what you will fully illuminate over these two days, preschool is and will increasingly be a foundational moment of our French school journey. In this regard, I have indeed decided, and the "captatio benevolentiae" of the minister largely went in this direction, I have decided to make preschool education mandatory, thus lowering the compulsory education age from 6 to 3 years in France starting from the 2019 school year.

So, this decision is not trivial, since this obligation was set at 6 years since the Ferry law of March 28, 1882. Almost 136 years to the day. After centuries of political debate over whether to set a mandatory age. And since then, the age of compulsory education has been modified, but only twice, and each time, in non-innocent periods, if I may say so, by Jean ZAY in 1936 with the extension of schooling to 14 years, and under General De GAULLE, who extended it to 16 years in 1959.

With this decision, I want to continue the work of equality of progress in our educational history and illustrate it. This equality is first and foremost about ceasing to consider preschool as an option; indeed, I hear the voices that say: 97% of children are already enrolled in preschool. But because it is not mandatory, this average figure covers deeply diverse realities and profoundly real inequalities.

Behind this 97% average, there are profoundly different practices from one territory to another, with – as you recalled – overseas territories where this figure is much lower; it is just over 80% in several overseas territories, but with especially disparities throughout the day, which means that it is often in the most disadvantaged neighborhoods, when one or even both parents do not work, that the child will not be sent back to school, often picked up at the end of the morning because they do not want to pay for lunch or cannot afford to pay for lunch, and are not sent back to school in the afternoon.

And so behind this figure, which seems to render insignificant what I am telling you, 97% are already there, why make it mandatory? There is the reality, which is all these inequalities that have arisen in practice, because today, it is neither mandatory nor fully recognized. And so I wish that through this school obligation, starting from the 2019 school year, we can have this real work of building our equality in daily life, and that we can, through the attendance of all, which will concern children from all backgrounds, correct this differential that I have just mentioned, which is no longer acceptable.

And that is why this measure is fully part of the action we are taking daily to combat poverty and its effects on young children, to fight against the creation or reproduction of deep inequalities.

The other inequality we now want to eliminate is the inequality in language. You have just perfectly explained this, dear Boris, which is the key to all learning.

All research, and here I speak with great humility before many specialists present in this room, and Professor DEHAENE foremost among them, many specialists, particularly neuroscientists, but also many linguists have demonstrated that the development of language occurs from these years, and that the brain's plasticity, between 3 and 6 years, is particularly conducive to language acquisition.

However, we find that it is at this moment that the deepest dropouts are created. Indeed, as you recalled, there are those famous 20% of children who, by the end of CM2, do not know how to read or write or count properly and respect others, which was the root of the decision, among other things, to split classes in CP and CE1 in REP and REP+ zones, but 80% of school dropouts, those who will leave at 16 years old without always knowing how to read or count well, are already struggling in CP.

And so, the system can only marginally correct the cognitive inequalities that are created at 6 years, at the moment when we begin to make our system mandatory. So, I believe that what has been initiated throughout elementary school will help improve things, and in particular, improve what we measure in international tests, in CM1 or CM2, improve the figures I just mentioned, but if we really want to prevent this deep dropout that then creates social exclusion, which then creates a separation in society, and sometimes the worst excesses, we need to be able to build precisely this moment where we acquire language, which allows us to arrive in better conditions in CP, and not have students whose path has sometimes been marked by a form of determinism.

Preventing dropout, enabling the success of every child in the Republic therefore requires acting as early as possible, because on average, 4-year-old children from disadvantaged backgrounds will have heard about thirty million words less than a 4-year-old child from a privileged background. And this is a reality that is there, and that can only be corrected by this ability to immerse the young child in preschool in contact with other children, other adults, and in this relationship to language, in this new universe they have entered, which creates both emotions and learning as you have just perfectly described.

Compensating for the social inequalities inherited from birth through school learning is within our reach. We must therefore devote significant effort to this, and much is at stake in preschool. It is a matter of our capacity as a Republic to preserve social cohesion by making school the place where this real equality, which erases the social determinism I just mentioned, can be achieved through education and learning, and in particular, through language learning. In doing so, I am convinced that we will make the good deal you mentioned earlier when referring to our Scandinavian friends, but that we can also get a head start.

The last challenge we must meet with this obligation of education at 3 years is also and inseparably of an emotional nature. Indeed, the three years of preschool are those where affects, attachment, and socialization are created, and on this, the work of Boris CYRULNIK, beyond the remarks he just made before us, is profoundly enlightening. In an increasingly brutal society, where indeed this emotional insecurity, which you recalled, is strong and is all the stronger, by the way, if one comes from a modest background today or from certain neighborhoods of the Republic, where violence has become institutionalized, we must take advantage of these studies to make preschool the place for the establishment of emotional security and affective flourishing.

We thus want to build a school of kindness where the cognitive and the affective complement each other. Because, as you said, everything today allows us to see that one reinforces the other, that indeed, the "at the same time" is verified and that we are not inventing anything, but that it must be supported. And contrary to received ideas that would suggest that neuroscience opposes humanism, it is its foundation; there is no learning without humanity, nor humanity without learning.

I know that to deploy this enhanced ambition and these battles I have just led, we can count on you. We can count on those who supervise, those who teach, on preschool teachers, whose remarkable dedication to their mission all parents know. I know that what I have just said is their daily reality, and that they would like to be able to carry their work even further.

We all also know that society feels the need for an ever more open and richer pedagogy; thus, the vocation of the school of the Republic is to ensure that these pedagogies are accessible to all, and that the means to achieve, from early childhood, the best balance between the cognitive and the affective, which I mentioned, must be open to every child. It goes without saying that in this dialogue between the sensitive and the intellectual, bringing arts, music, and all these forms of awakening that accelerate learning into preschool, as you just recalled, is essential and will play an increased role, which I particularly emphasize.

Other actors are essential to accomplish this work; they are the specialized territorial agents of preschool education, the ATSEM, whose importance you both recalled. In the path I have just outlined, we will need all their skills, all their know-how, because their contact with children is, in the perspective I am outlining, a treasure we cannot do without.

Two decrees, published on March 3, have come to strengthen this recognition of their role within the educational community, and I commend the work of local authorities to ensure the presence of these key personnel in schools. But we know, and this will probably be, I hope, one of the conclusions of your work, we must go even further on this subject, and with mayors, with all the elected officials who support National Education in this work, allow us to go all the way, not only in these recognitions but in training, in the full financial and statutory recognition that must accompany this work, and of which you recalled that some of our neighbors have managed to do.

Preschool is also the moment when the link is created between the school institution and the parents, and this is also a fundamental link that will accompany the student throughout their schooling, and if we indeed want to build this school of trust, which we care so much about, this school of flourishing, this link between the school institution and the parent is essential, and it is from the moment of preschool that it is structured, constituted with its own rules, with its codes, with the ability also to teach parents sometimes how to be parents or to support, continue beyond school time what is done in the institution.

And I indeed call for your work, through practices, to allow us to go further in what has already been done by many. Through this obligation of education and this new ambition for preschool, France is in a position to engage in a third educational path, one that knows how to reconcile the cognitive demands observed, for example, in Asian countries, and the emotional demands seen in the northern European countries.

The French school will succeed – I am sure of it – in achieving this balance by rooting it from early childhood. So not everything starts at 3 years old, I grant you that, and I know all the debates that exist, and that, by the way, you have just shed light on regarding what happens before 3 years old. And we must therefore ensure the continuum between very early childhood, welcomed by nurseries, and the early childhood of preschool; that is also why I wish that, in connection with the Ministry of Education, the experiments conducted in nurseries continue, which allow access to language, at least to support this journey, toddler talk or innovations of this type that have often shown their effectiveness, like all the innovations that we can generalize, build this continuum, also develop the innovations, the organizations that allow welcoming children under 3 years old to preschool.

Imposing an obligation below 3 years old is today almost untenable and not always desirable, because before 3 years old, it depends on the child's progression, it depends on the situation, but what is true is that in the most disadvantaged neighborhoods, under certain conditions, it is sometimes beneficial to be able to open school before 3 years old to young children, and this is precisely for local elected officials, for professionals in the Ministry of Education, to assess, and for the government to provide the means to do so wherever it is useful, where it will further correct these inequalities, and where it will be relevant for the entire community.

Because in these very early years, children play an important part in their future, and the fight we are waging against child poverty requires particular attention to these years whose importance we have not always measured, both in terms of awakening the mind, social integration, and health. It is also in this way that we will make school an authentically inclusive school; we do this geographically when we keep classes open that should close in territories that are sometimes more fragile or threatened by isolation, as we have seen recently.

But we must also show ourselves capable, with this school of kindness, to better welcome and integrate all children in difficulty, and I will return to this in the coming months, but also, children living with disabilities. Let us not be mistaken, among all the issues that concern us today, this issue is fundamental; it is the one that perhaps most radically engages our future, not only as individuals but as a Nation, as a people united by bonds forged from early childhood, as a Republic that authentically takes care of all those who still suffer today from a form of social determinism whose springs we know, and which we must eradicate deeply.

This ambition resonates with everything we have done in Education, to bring real equality to primary school with the splitting of classes in the most fragile territories, with the measure of homework done, which allows students to do their homework at school, with the return of reading and living and ancient languages, with the opening of the baccalaureate to more varied abilities, with better articulation of orientation with higher education, with a redesign of school and extracurricular time around Wednesday; all these stones progressively placed in the school institution, in our edifice, contribute to the same perspective, the same, which is to fully recognize the essential role of school in building a society and allowing the flourishing of individuals.

Each time, the same logic is applied. It is to say that wherever inequality replicates because families are not placed in the same situation, because being able to learn is not possible in the family in the same way, because being able to do homework is not possible in the same way, because being equipped to face the uncertainties of orientation when arriving after the baccalaureate is not equal among families, each time, we wanted the school institution to be able to correct it, to provide a response to build precisely the Nation that we are, to sometimes rebuild it, and to allow each individual to build their own flourishing.

All these reforms have a common horizon and a common root, to make school the place where one builds oneself in and through knowledge, both on a personal, emotional, and professional level, with this new obligation of education, I want elementary education to walk on its two legs to prepare our young compatriots for a more successful and fruitful path. This is how we will continue this social progress of which we are the heirs and which is a living legacy only to the extent that we perpetuate it.

The Republic was invented in and through school, and it is at school today, perhaps more than ever, that the fabric of this common good that is our democracy and the responsibility it gives us towards one another, but also towards the world around us, is woven. Saying this in this week is not innocent either; each time our Nation is struck at its heart, some tend to want to tear it apart by only addressing the symptoms; we have done a lot unfortunately because we have learned a lot by only looking at the symptoms of all the tears in our society.

But what happens there has also been built, and addressing the root cause, a part of the root cause, a part that nestles within us, is in and through school, and it is by building this school of kindness and flourishing that we will build a generation that finds its place in society, that builds its flourishing, that will no longer have to yield to the death impulses that end up fascinating some because they have not built their own future, and that we will also eradicate deeply in our society for the generation for which we have responsibility today; I am unfortunately not talking about the one that has already grown up.

But that we will succeed – I hope, I deeply believe – in preventing the worst. We build a Nation, and we have always built the Republic in school. And I do not mean to say that school must carry and correct alone everything that society has brought in terms of injustices, traumas, or deviations. But it has much to do in this endeavor. And that is why from day one, you have always seen me support it and want with it and for it, because I know one thing: when we abandon school, when we have less ambition for it, when we yield an inch of excellence for every child of the Republic, then we abandon a space, then we abandon a promise, and sometimes we may come to regret it terribly.

So the demand that you carry every day, from preschool to the oldest age, is essential for our Nation; it always has been, but it is today even more than yesterday, because I do not forget the beautiful words of Victor Hugo: "Every time we open a school, we can promise to close a prison," and that is true. Hugo was a humanist, and he was profoundly right; we will not close prisons for those who have already known deviation, but we will avoid opening others for this generation that is in your schools, that enters preschool and that is today our responsibility and our chance.

It is for all these reasons that I deeply believe that our country deserves to be a Nation of educated citizens, of flourishing individuals, and that, as you have understood, my conviction is that the vocation of France is to be worthy of the promise that you carry; I thank you. And good luck.