Press conference by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the priorities of European construction, the appointment of a president for the European Commission, and the situation in Ukraine, in Brussels on June 27, 2014.

France François Hollande · President of France

27 June 2014 · European Council · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Hollande addressed a press conference at the European Council in Brussels on June 27, 2014, covering EU fiscal policy, the Commission presidency, and French unemployment.
Main themes
European fiscal flexibility and stability pact, Jean-Claude Juncker's appointment as European Commission president, unemployment and growth in France, structural reforms and deficit reduction, UK-EU relations, competitiveness and labor costs, European solidarity and governance, situation in Ukraine
Duration
~31 min
84th percentile
Words
3,747
84th percentile
Sentences
216
91st percentile
Readability
59
86th percentile
Grade
9.1
12th percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
12th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

216 sentences in 55 paragraphs

QUESTION - Mr. President, you just mentioned the flexibility you obtained at the end of this Council regarding the application of the stability pact. But I believe many of us here want to understand you well. Does this mean that the commitments to reduce public spending by 50 billion will be upheld but that we will no longer tighten the screws in France? Does this mean that taxes will not be increased, even if growth does not materialize? And does this mean, consequently, that the government is taking the risk of allowing deficits to spiral?

THE PRESIDENT - I did not intervene to defend France alone, to make a pro domo plea regarding our own situation. I am, of course, driven by the interests of France. But when I speak of the flexibilities, the margins that are already provided for in the texts that have tightened the stability pact in principles, I am defending a vision of Europe. If many countries, of different political inspirations, have followed us, it is precisely because it is in the interest of all Europeans to have more growth.

If there is more growth, it will be easier to reduce deficits and ensure a number of reforms. On the other hand, what I wanted is that what we are doing in France—structural reforms, deficit reductions, spending cuts, and notably the 50 billion plan—can serve as arguments to justify the application of the stability pact with flexibilities. But I have not been the only one to express this position.

Our Italian friends have argued that when growth is weak and when debt is high, it is also appropriate to use the flexibilities. But all this must be done in respect of our commitments. I did not ask for a breach, I did not ask for a derogation, I did not ask for an exception; I simply asked for the application, the full application, and not for one country, but for all countries that may find themselves in a number of situations.

As for France, the choices we have made—the responsibility pact, the savings plan, measures for employment, tax cuts for households, and the reduction of labor costs for businesses—can all be perfectly coherent with what we have obtained today at the European Council.

QUESTION - A question about the new President of the Commission. How will the United Kingdom be able to work with Mr. JUNCKER, if he is confirmed as President, given that Mr. CAMERON fought so hard against his nomination? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - The United Kingdom is a member of the European Union. It does not have a separate status, no more than France, even if the United Kingdom, France, Germany, Italy, Spain... are large countries that must be heard. When David CAMERON speaks, it is entirely legitimate to give credit to what he may say, including regarding the difficulty for him to pass this decision in his own country. But we must, in Europe, get used to living together with rules and treaties.

We have no other way. Jean-Claude JUNCKER is not a stranger. Mr. CAMERON has worked with him for years. He is a recognized man for having been a long-time head of government of his own country and having been president of the Eurogroup, which is already a responsibility, even if the United Kingdom is not a member of the Eurogroup, since it is not a member of the eurozone! I am sure that Mr. JUNCKER will be keen to work with all countries and therefore with all heads of government and state of the member states of the European Union. It is now his responsibility.

QUESTION - You have emphasized the need for growth in France, to fight against unemployment. What would you say today to the French who doubt, particularly regarding unemployment, to whom you promised, six months ago, the reversal of the curve? How can you give hope today?

THE PRESIDENT - The fight against unemployment is the priority; it is the only one that can be heard and understood as the major requirement for a great nation like France. We have seen a continuous increase in unemployment for now six years. Six years! This means that we have 10% of the active population who find themselves without a job, and if we take the precarious workers, even more... This is not a matter of choice. It is an obligation to stem the rise in unemployment and then to reduce unemployment.

What lessons do I draw? First, if there are no subsidized jobs in a period of low growth, there can be no reduction in unemployment. But if there is no growth—and that is what happened in the first quarter—there is necessarily an increase in unemployment, despite the subsidized jobs we have implemented for over a year now. The third lesson: France must improve its competitiveness and reduce the labor costs for businesses. This is the meaning of the responsibility pact.

In return, businesses must discuss and negotiate so that all the conditions for job creation are implemented and that a number of blockages can be lifted, particularly in favor of young people and seniors. More than ever, given these figures, the responsibility and solidarity pact must not only be voted on but implemented. Everything must be done so that the social conference can open a new phase of negotiations between social partners on all the blockages that prevent job creation. Everything must be done to give visibility to all economic actors, both households and businesses, regarding their own taxation.

As we also have a problem in construction and public works, the Prime Minister and the government—I will ensure this—will take all necessary measures to revive this activity. We have already presented a bill on the issue of energy transition. The tax measures contained in this bill will be applicable from September 1, 2014.

We must show that this battle is everyone's. Even if there are bad figures—and this happened for the month of May—rather than commenting on these figures, we must fight and mobilize: the government, of course, and that is the case; the social partners, and that is the challenge of the negotiations that are opening within the framework of the responsibility pact, both with the signatories and the non-signatories; but also in Parliament, where texts will arrive that will enshrine and translate the responsibility pact.

Now, there is no time to lose. Not that we have lost any. On the contrary, we have implemented a number of policies. But we can see that at the moment when growth resumes, we must put, on the national side, all possible resources, all policies that contribute to improving supply and supporting demand; and on the European level, use all margins and all flexibilities, conduct investment policies for the coming years...

QUESTION - Since the prospective President of the European Commission, Mr. JUNCKER, is appointed, we will move to a second phase, that of the designation of high personalities. This will happen very quickly. Several states have already announced who their commissioner will be. Could you indicate what portfolio you might be aiming for? Or what personality France would propose to the European Commission?

THE PRESIDENT - Let’s proceed step by step. Today, I did not want there to be any confusion or mixing or bargaining. Today is the designation of the President of the Commission, subject to the vote of the European Parliament, probably on July 15.

On July 16, there will be a new European Council to discuss other responsibilities. When I say other responsibilities, I mean the presidency of the Council, the presidency of the Eurogroup, the representatives for common foreign and security policy... There will probably also be discussions about the composition of the Commission and the responsibilities that can be entrusted to such or such Commissioner as soon as Mr. JUNCKER is effectively appointed.

So there are three phases: the phase of the President of the Commission until July 15; the phase of major responsibilities within the European Union; and then the phase of the Commissioners and the composition and organization of the next Commission.

As for France, we want to take an important responsibility in the Commission. I would like for the organization of the Commission—I will discuss this with President JUNCKER, if he is confirmed as President of the Commission—that there be an organization around major vice-presidencies that can themselves have important sectors. It is in this regard that I will ask for a vice-presidency for France.

QUESTION - Do the very poor results of the left in the European elections weaken your position in this discussion? Or, on the contrary, has the emergence of the far right and eurosceptics paradoxically strengthened your discourse on flexibility and budgetary leeway?

THE PRESIDENT - I would not want to answer you by saying that when we have poor results, it helps us! Because voters might think that we need to have poor results again! What is true is that, not just in France, there has been a rise in eurosceptic votes. Sometimes with a far-right character, as in France.

There have also been successes. I am thinking particularly of the center-left in Italy, around Matteo RENZI. But it was the same message, expressed differently. Some wanted to leave Europe or contest Europe; others wanted a new direction for Europe. So I can answer you yes.

What I announced is that if Europe was not sufficiently ardent for growth, for employment, for protection, there was a risk that groups would use euroscepticism for other purposes, essentially for domestic politics. Europe does not interest them, since they want to leave Europe. They cannot even manage to form a group within the European Parliament, given how great their divergences are.

What happened during the European elections validated what I, along with others, asserted about the risks that the European Union would face if it did not respond. Even though it has worked quite well over the past two years to combat the eurozone crisis, it has not delivered all the expected results in terms of growth and employment. That is the least we can say... Perhaps it could not, given the difficulties it faced and the austerity policies imposed on many countries.

But now the eurozone crisis is behind us, interest rates are among the lowest in recent years, including for countries that were still under program yesterday. So, it is true that I have been heard more, like others, to ensure that more priorities are given to growth. Angela MERKEL, for example, in the context of this Council—but I will not speak for her—said: we must say that the recovery is here, that it is probably still hesitant, but it is here. We need to support it with structural reforms; let us not think that countries would have no effort to make. Who can imagine that it is simply through European policies that we will regain growth? Each country must make an effort for competitiveness, for employment.

At the same time, if we have to respect our commitments, we must do so, as I said, with flexibilities. It is true that, from a certain point of view, the message of the European elections has been conveyed and even translated. Except for the message of euroscepticism. It is not with less Europe that we will be able to implement policies that will be more favorable to growth and employment. It is, on the contrary, through European policies, thus through more Europe.

QUESTION - Mr. CAMERON said a few days ago that he wanted a super-British Commissioner position, in charge of a whole "Group cluster" and other Commissioners. Do you think this could happen? Has the idea been somewhat addressed? Do you think we could go in such a direction? You mentioned a position of President of the Eurogroup; is it really necessary to make this decision on July 16?

THE PRESIDENT - First, we have not discussed the composition of the Commission. So, no country, neither France nor the United Kingdom, has made a specific request. Because that was not the framework, that was not the time. And to whom to address? The current President of the Commission does not have, today, the competence for this, and the next one has not yet been designated by the European Parliament... The question of the composition of the Commission has not been on the table.

As for the President of the Eurogroup, yes, that is one of the positions that should be looked at on July 16!

QUESTION The European Court of Human Rights has condemned France for its refusal to recognize children born abroad to surrogate mothers. Will France recognize children born through surrogacy abroad? Are we moving towards the legalization of surrogacy in France?

THE PRESIDENT I have made it clear enough to be heard, even before this decision from the European Court of Human Rights intervened. There will never be any question of legalizing surrogacy as long as I am President of the Republic. Never! Because what is it about? It is about the commodification of the body, of surrogate mothers, those who will be paid abroad to allow a couple, suffering from a lack of children, to have one.

The European Court of Human Rights did not, moreover, conclude that surrogacy should be recognized. It will not be recognized in France. It simply recalled the interest of the child, so that this child, born in the context of surrogacy abroad, can have a nationality. Already, we had ensured that children born in this way could have French nationality, through a circular. We will continue to do so.

QUESTION We learned today that the High Authority for Transparency in Public Life revealed that one of your ministers undervalued his assets by 700,000 euros; I wanted to have your reaction. Does Jean-Marie LE GUEN, since it is about him, still have his place in the Government? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT First of all, there is a High Authority for Transparency. That is what I wanted, that is what Parliament decided, and that is what is now being implemented for ministers, for parliamentarians, for major elected officials, and even for senior civil servants.

This is a considerable progress for our democracy. This High Authority is not simply an organization that takes declarations as they are. It verifies them and corrects them if necessary. That is what it did in the case of a Secretary of State. It asked him to ensure that the evaluation of his assets could be reassessed based on market prices.

That is what he did, and that is what led this High Authority to consider this declaration as sincere and exhaustive. If that had not been the case, he would not be or would no longer be in the government.

QUESTION I return to the European Council; will France respect the 3% target in 2015? Is this target feasible?

THE PRESIDENT France respects its commitments. What would the European Council think of a country that comes, to prepare the next agenda of the European Commission, with a single obsession: not to respect a commitment? No, we respect the treaties. Respecting the treaties means respecting all the treaties, that is to say, the stability and growth pact and the flexibilities it provides.

If growth were very weak, we could precisely use what the treaties provide. If there were exceptional circumstances, again, we can use the flexibilities. But, as I told you, I did not speak simply because France would have a particular problem regarding the deficit. I spoke on behalf of the interest of all Europeans.

But, I will still say a word. When I came to power, the treaties were already in place: the stability and growth pact, for those who know the "six-pack" and other refinements... It was not I who decided them. I am now obliged to take their existence into account. My predecessors left a deficit exceeding 5.2% of GDP, so it is appropriate to have time to reach 3%. That is indeed what we had obtained. I always put myself in this perspective: respect for commitments and use of all possible flexibilities depending on the circumstances.

I will not deviate from this framework. It happens that what the European Council has just adopted allows us to justify this position. We will reduce deficits, but we also have reforms to make, and that is what must be well understood. What is being asked of France today, because no decision had been made for years, is both to reduce its deficits, to improve its industrial performance, and to be more competitive by reducing labor costs. It is difficult!

A country like Germany had more than 10 years in a period of stronger growth to do both successively. We are being asked to do both at the same time, in a short time, and with less growth! I am asking, not for a French exception, but for collective intelligence.

QUESTION I have a question regarding Ukraine. Following the various exchanges that took place and the D-Day you mentioned earlier in Normandy, there have been exchanges between you, Mrs. MERKEL, Mr. PUTIN, and Mr. POROSHENKO. Is Barack OBAMA's approach convergent in parallel? The second part of the question concerns the South Stream Project; the agreement was signed in Austria with Gazprom. I would like to know if this subject was discussed.

THE PRESIDENT All efforts are convergent. They are consistent for both the United States and Europe. When Angela MERKEL and I act, we do so in good harmony with President OBAMA. We have the same objectives: to obtain the extension of the ceasefire for 72 hours, which is done, and to ensure that the ceasefire can be effective at the end of this period. That is why the 4 points I mentioned are essential.

I must emphasize how exemplary the cooperation between Germany and France, between Angela MERKEL and myself, has been. Exemplary for Europe, exemplary for peace. Everything we have done, we have done together, from the preparation of the meeting in Bénouville to today. I believe we will continue. Not just to maintain our relations with President PUTIN and President POROSHENKO (others may also have excellent or at least trusting relations), but so that Europe is fully associated with this process. Just this morning, Angela MERKEL and I had a long meeting with POROSHENKO to achieve this result, to be in the right position, and to ensure that we can find a solution within 72 hours. Finally, that is the purpose of the conference call we will have again on Sunday.

Who could have thought, a few weeks ago, that it would be possible not only to bring the Ukrainian President and the Russian President together in Bénouville in Normandy, but that it would be possible to continue this direct dialogue through several long phone conversations, very long, sometimes too long? It is important that they talk to each other. This has been made possible thanks to the friendship between France and Germany and this beautiful complicity.

Regarding South Stream, these are choices that belong to each of the countries; we will have the result because it is part, you are right, of the energy policy that we must successfully carry out in Europe. If there is sovereignty, each country supplies itself as it sees fit, with logical means, interconnections... It is very important that we also have coordination. That is why I attach so much importance to the European energy policy, particularly with Germany again.

QUESTION Mr. JUNCKER himself did not want, a few weeks ago, to be President of the Commission. Do you think the nomination process is a good process? Will it need to be renewed in five years? Second question: with this flexibility that you obtain, will the dissenting minority of the Socialist Party be satisfied? Third question: the Blues play on Monday; do you have a message for them?

THE PRESIDENT Should we further improve the procedure? A number of heads of state have asked for this. Not to disrespect the treaties, but perhaps to make it clear to the parties that designate candidates within a procedure, before the European elections, that there are consequences in the choices they make. The one who comes first, or the one who comes first, has a strong chance of being the next President of the Commission!

There is surely a need to discuss this in advance, among heads of state and government. Heads of government are often party leaders. This is not my case, but many heads of government are also party leaders. They cannot therefore say: we were not informed! They necessarily were, since they participated in the choice of a lead candidate.

Did Jean-Claude JUNCKER think he would be President of the European Commission? I imagine so, because otherwise he would not have put himself forward as a candidate... Did he imagine there would be a trade-off? He did not know exactly in what context this would happen, but as soon as there was a gap, he was necessarily the best placed to be President of the European Commission.

Is what I did today to favor the political situation in France? No, it is to facilitate the economic situation in France. The issue is not to pay ourselves lip service; it is to ensure that what we obtain in Europe can be useful to the French economy, to French businesses, to French consumers, and especially to French job seekers. The rest does not matter to me.

I do not want to say that I do not attach importance to a dialogue with the majority or with a part of this majority that is more eager than others to achieve results... But it must still be that these results are in line with the political line I have set. If I am not on this political line, how do I make myself heard in Europe? It is because I am carrying out structural reforms with Manuel VALLS' government, because I am ensuring that competitiveness is improved, because we are reducing labor costs, because we are lowering taxes, that we can make ourselves heard in Europe.

Finally, regarding the French national football team, I have no comments to make. There is a round of 16 match; I wish them all the best of luck. But if it is to ask me: am I going to Brazil next Monday? The answer is no. Thank you.