Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on research policy in France, in Caen on November 3, 2016.

France François Hollande · President of France

3 November 2016 · Colloquium commemorating the 1956 Caen colloquium on research policy · Caen, France

Context
Hollande addressed a scientific colloquium at Caen on November 3, 2016, marking the 60th anniversary of the historic 1956 Caen Colloquium on French research policy.
Main themes
Research policy in France, 1956 Caen Colloquium legacy, Pierre Mendès-France, higher education reform, scientific funding and investment, CNRS and research institutions, National Research Agency, young researchers, long-term scientific planning, French Nobel Prize winners, public finance constraints, knowledge continuity
Duration
~30 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,622
83rd percentile
Sentences
167
84th percentile
Readability
44
44th percentile
Grade
12.6
52nd percentile
Syntax
2.95
40th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
35th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 46%46%
  • Economic 23%23%
  • Institutional 13%13%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Environmental 4%4%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Not in focus 1%

167 sentences in 51 paragraphs

Madam, Ministers,

Mr. President of the Normandy Region,

Mr. President of the Calvados Departmental Council,

Mr. Mayor,

Ladies and Gentlemen Elected Officials, Parliamentarians,

Mr. President of the University who is hosting me,

I salute here the scientific community that has gathered to commemorate. But after all, this is indeed the first time that a colloquium is being commemorated. If we were now to organize colloquia on colloquia, we would give the impression of "colloquying" and thus not acting.

Why has this 1956 colloquium in Caen left its mark on History? Pierre MENDES-FRANCE was no longer Prime Minister at the time he delivered this memorable speech during the colloquium held in Caen. He was a former head of government who was undoubtedly destined for greatness. This destiny, which did not manifest itself in terms of state leadership, nonetheless left a mark in History through his thought, his rigor, his reflection, and his broad perspective. If this 1956 colloquium is a reference for the research community, it is because three factors came together.

The first: the personality of Pierre MENDES-FRANCE himself, that is to say, a political leader who had a sense of the times, who was aware that France, at the moment it was embarking on its reconstruction, should not be content with merely rebuilding, but should rethink and project itself into a future that could no longer be that of the pre-war or even post-war period.

The second reason that made this colloquium so significant in the history of scientific thought and the administrative organization of research is the quality of the speakers. I am thinking particularly of the mathematician André LICHNEROWICZ, the professor of medicine Robert DEBRE, and the future Nobel Prize winner Jacques MONOD.

Finally, if this colloquium left such a strong impression on the administrative organization of research, it is simply because it was the origin of a plan, a ten-year plan that was to elevate the scientific and technical level of the country.

If we look now, sixty years later, a large part of the conclusions—thankfully—from the Caen Colloquium have been reflected in the choices made, notably by General de GAULLE in 1958. But many of the questions are still present today: the reform of higher education, the status of CNRS personnel, measures aimed at promoting scientific studies, already at that time, the simplification of systems, the revaluation of certain careers, the construction of large universities, the creation of a national research fund. So, I do not want anyone to think that sixty years later, there have not been major upheavals and that the great decisions of the 1960s have not borne fruit and been followed by others, each decade contributing to further improve French research.

First of all, the organization has changed considerably, the major organizations have brought research to a level of excellence. There have been mergers with universities and there have been major technological achievements. Today, progress is embodied in everything that was launched in the 1960s or 1970s.

But if we want to retain one lesson, just one, from the Caen Colloquium and thus from what Pierre MENDES-FRANCE wanted, it is that we must look far ahead and that we must place research at the forefront of our priorities.

Certainly, the economic period is not the same. The 1960s and 1970s were years of very strong growth, which was, moreover, driven by research and favored research. Then, starting in the 1980s, the periods became more delicate, the resources more limited, the constraints stronger. But it remains that the way out of this weak growth that we are experiencing or the crisis that we have known lies in research. Not simply for economic reasons, but also for social and societal reasons, because it is research that will determine how we live together.

Since the beginning of my term, I have ensured, even in this very difficult period for our public finances, to preserve the means for research. I have been strongly encouraged in this regard, every time I have had meetings with our Nobel Prize winners, whom I want to salute.

I have also wanted to maintain scientific employment at its level. Thus, we have avoided, unlike many European countries, an interruption in the recruitment of researchers and therefore in the chain of knowledge.

The next budget for Higher Education and Research, the minister is here and has fought to achieve this result, will increase by 850 million euros. This is an increase that has never been seen before.

I have also wanted the means of what is called the National Research Agency to be increased and especially that the selection rate of projects be raised to 20%, particularly for the category "frontiers of research," that is to say, research that requires a long time, I will return to this.

I have also wanted a new measure to be dedicated to promising young researchers, those who have not necessarily been selected for European funding, but who must have the support of France.

Finally, there has been the priority given to research in what has been called the "Future Investment Program," PIA 2, PIA 3, with 5 billion dedicated to research, which is half of the funds planned for these investments.

What is decisive, for me, and should be the line to be followed in the coming years, is fundamental research. It is this capacity that the State must provide to teams, to take the time for discovery, for surprise, for the ongoing back-and-forth between the hypotheses we pose at the outset and their verification, which will sometimes fortuitously lead them, after several years, sometimes decades, to research that will completely change our way of life or our understanding of the world.

It is fundamental research that leads to breakthrough innovations. It is fundamental research that must be protected at the state level to avoid short-term trade-offs, the dominance of urgency, the legitimate concern of having an immediate application, an immediate translation, an immediate innovation, which is, moreover, necessary.

In this sense, we must not abuse a good idea, which is that of programming, which is useful in applied research, but which does not necessarily make sense in fundamental research.

The competitiveness of a country lies in its ability to raise the level of qualification, to simplify a number of rules, to have a labor cost that is not burdened by levies that would put us at odds with our main competitors.

But true competitiveness, the only one, in the medium and long term, that will allow us to maintain our rank, or even to rise, is scientific influence, our ability to innovate and push the boundaries of knowledge and attract the best, the best researchers here, but also the best talents from abroad.

France, it is true, has many assets. When the Caen Colloquium took place in 1956, it had been 22 years since a French researcher had received a Nobel Prize. Pierre MENDES-FRANCE reflected on this: Why? How? Fortunately, in recent years, Nobel Prizes have been awarded, the most recent to chemist Jean-Pierre SAUVAGE, there have been Fields Medals, Lasker Prizes. Thus, the excellence of our scientists is recognized internationally.

France is still one of the countries in the world that welcomes researchers. I remind you that 40% of our doctoral students are foreign. One-third of CNRS researchers are also of foreign origin, and 15% of students attending our universities are also foreign. This, by the way, speaks volumes about the desire that must be ours—when we talk about a host country—to attract the best talents, to attract these young people, sometimes coming from emerging countries, other times from countries that may be affected by wars or conflicts, as well as from countries that do not have any particular issues but need to have a very high level of welcome, so that we can continue to be a country of scientific attraction.

But we cannot remain at this level of satisfaction that I have just described. We know well that there is today competition, a competition; there are countries that are investing massively in research. Do I need to mention China and even India? Emerging countries have understood that they must not simply copy, catch up, anticipate. No, they must be drivers in research and also attract, with considerable means, the best talents. We must therefore ensure that the State can provide French research with the means to continue the work that is underway, to respect what is called the law of laboratories, which is the foundation of scientific research, and to make teachers and researchers work together.

France must also play its full part in accessing European programs. A word on European programs. We are asking ourselves many questions about what Europe will be like tomorrow, after the British decision to leave the Union—even if there are still many episodes to come, after what we have experienced regarding the reception of refugees and the fears that have, for a time, settled and remain—about the very loss of meaning that Europe is experiencing among the peoples, what can be the future of Europe? What can give it meaning, direction, a project, an elevation, I speak here in front of the Minister for European Affairs? Of course, we must protect borders, ensure security, show that Europe can be a space of protection and at the same time, a way of life, of quality, of culture; we must clearly make growth, employment, and especially that of young people, the great priority.

But we must above all make Europe through knowledge. Make it a power that serves the world and that, through mobility, through cooperation between universities, through raising the level of research, is capable of having an impact in the world. From this point of view, European research programs must still be amplified. But we, France, must access them more. While we can be satisfied with being one of the top beneficiaries, perhaps even the top beneficiary of European research funds, on the other hand, regarding project calls, known as "H 2020," we are very much behind: only 10% of funding in this regard. What is the conclusion? It is necessary that, like them, universities can equip themselves with the appropriate structures to seek European funding to better utilize these procedures and ensure that more researchers can be supported.

Research, as I have said, is an essential area for France to take its full place, maintain its rank, and play a leading role with Europe. But research is also about improving life. Research, in the field of health, we know well, will be profoundly transformed towards multidisciplinary, translational, preventive, predictive, individualized medicine, and I know that here in the Normandy region, you are working on this.

It will be influenced by massive data, and therefore we must know how to use it. In the field of agriculture and food, it is through the fundamental mechanisms of plant development that we will be able to cultivate plants that resist heat and lack of water. I mentioned this earlier to emphasize how the Climate Agreement will further stimulate research so that we can better meet our commitments.

Tomorrow, the Climate Agreement will come into force. Commitments must be honored. We will be—France—a country that must be ahead, exemplary, and therefore we must, in renewable energies, in energy storage, in the capacity to produce low-carbon electricity, be the best. In the same way, on the major issues of digital technology, ecological transition, demographics, all these changes that will disrupt our society, we must also give a role to the human and social sciences, and I want to emphasize this.

Research is interdisciplinarity. To have an urban policy, I recently spoke before representatives of citizen councils, we must call upon sociologists, anthropologists, geographers, and historians of urban issues. To try to understand what it means to "live in a city" in today's world. How to teach effectively, the teacher training schools are there for that, without relying on the knowledge from the sciences of education and psychology, but also from all that is research on the brain? How to effectively combat terrorist radicalization, extremist drift, if we do not bring together specialists, psychologists, criminologists, and also all those who know what radicalization on the Internet can be? In short, we need science to address the questions of today and tomorrow.

This trust in science does not come without responsibilities. And it is true that public decision-makers need to be enlightened, enlightened by scientists, especially regarding everything that touches on life, human dignity, and freedom. That is why we have a National Committee on Ethics for the Life Sciences. But we also need researchers to be aware of their responsibilities. We currently have proposals on scientific integrity based on a report submitted by Professor CORVOL, which I believe can be a very useful charter.

We know well that there are fears. Fears exist everywhere. They always exist, even regarding science. What is most daunting is that those who fuel these fears want to make us doubt science, the capacity of science, the very idea of progress, to instill the notion that all of this could jeopardize human life. We know well that there are questions that are painful, that are difficult—genetic manipulations—how to ensure that we can conduct research on the genome without it ever benefiting private interests. These perspectives opened by advances in biological and medical fields must and can be controlled. So we must, here too, always find that balance between what is in the realm of science, with the freedom that must be granted to it, and then the principles that we must establish.

Sometimes the precautionary principle is mentioned, and I know what debates it can provoke. The precautionary principle is not a principle of prevention. The precautionary principle is a principle of discernment. The challenge is to allow research by giving it new capabilities without fears for our environment or the foundations of our humanity. And this principle should not be seen as a constraint, as a hindrance, but simply as a reminder.

I want to, and this would ultimately be the interest of this conference, to give my perspective. We must provide a perspective. I said, "research must be at the heart of our societal project," it is not in terms of the number of populations concerned, it is not simply in relation to the community of researchers that I speak. It is in relation to the interest of our country, to all the French people who must consider that research is ultimately what will determine their future and will also be able to provide them with means to live better, and also to have prospects in terms of industrial excellence, food security, the ability to manage the risks of climate change—in short, to be masters of their destiny. Making research a priority is not just about giving France new capabilities, no. It is about giving the French people more freedom and more confidence in their future.

The share of what is called national wealth, GDP, dedicated to Research and Development is currently 2.25%. We must set ourselves the goal of reaching 3% in the next ten years. This increase is possible. It is realistic and achievable. It must be shared beyond political sensitivities, beyond alternations, to tell us that this is ultimately what we agree on. We are capable of doing it on certain subjects—not on all, we have it in defense, Hervé MORIN remembers that—but we must do it with the same determination to achieve it for Research. 3% of our national wealth must be dedicated to it within the next ten years. This will require constant effort, a mobilization that is recalled each time, and a capacity to enforce this decision.

What should we focus our efforts on in the coming years? I see two areas: fundamental research and the means provided to young researchers. Fundamental research: do I need to insist? I did so at GANIL where we had a large-scale experiment, I would say? We need large equipment. We need large research organizations. We need budgets that are incomparably larger than what we could have imagined 60 years ago. We need long-term investments to be a scientific power. We need attractive centers to welcome researchers from around the world. We need to set ourselves objectives in the major fields of biology, physics, and many others: that is fundamental research.

And then, the other objective is to improve conditions for young researchers. The government has undertaken a significant revision of the pay scale for secondary education staff, which was necessary. It is time to engage in the same approach for the salaries of university faculty and researchers from organizations. Priority must be given to the early stages of careers so that younger individuals can find in France material conditions that will encourage them to stay or return when they have gone abroad to study, particularly for a doctoral position. It is this dual priority, fundamental research and improving conditions for young researchers, that will ensure that France, year after year, raises its rank as a scientific power.

There is another dimension that, 60 years ago, was still somewhat nebulous, which is the rapprochement between research and universities. This is where we have made the greatest strides in recent years with these university communities—I know that here you have several illustrations of this. It is absolutely essential to bring together research poles and teaching poles, and France is a country where we must take another step forward.

We have in France a private research sector that has been stimulated by the research tax credit, considerably; I have also ensured that these fiscal measures can be preserved—which means that France has more researchers in companies today than Germany, and far more than it had five years ago. But we must also have the same effort for public research, because we need that in the large campuses bringing together universities, schools, and organizations, we can give full place to public research. Research is both directed towards industry—and that is necessary—directed towards action, especially public action—it is essential—but it must also be capable of finding its own valorization.

I mentioned the place of researchers in companies and in administration. In companies, we need to ensure that PhDs can have their titles recognized in collective agreements—it's been said for a long time! Companies must be able to recruit researchers and give them the place that is rightfully theirs, at very high levels of responsibility. But what is true for companies is also true for administration. We must ensure that researchers are not just researchers in administration or researchers on administration—there is much to be done—but researchers who are executives in administration, responsible for administration—not just to do administration or research—but to be fully active in administration and therefore in the management of major public operations.

In conclusion, scientific research must impose its presence everywhere, in the State, in companies, in schools, in society. It must be part of our culture, of our way of living and thinking; it is this call for collective awareness that I wanted to make and to which this conference can correspond. A call for awareness that research is not just our future: it is our priority.

Pierre MENDES-FRANCE said 60 years ago, "the Republic needs scientists." For him, scientists were what allowed our industry to gain modernity; they were what allowed health, and especially public hospitals, to regain their vocation and scope in terms of research. It was undoubtedly in the energy sector, since he was partly the one who decided to launch us into nuclear energy. But today, the Republic needs scientists more than ever for new discoveries, for new objects, to treat diseases, to combat climate change, to understand society, and also to enable France to be at the highest level of innovation and industrial excellence.

So, Ladies and Gentlemen, Caen will remain, and be proud of it, always a reference in terms of scientific research. Caen and Normandy have this vocation, and I wanted to come here to recall this history but above all to evoke the future. Scientific research, research in general, is what a society can demonstrate in terms of confidence in its future. It is what it is capable of sacrificing in the present to invent the future.

Research is what allows us to think that we will live better tomorrow. Research is the awareness that progress is possible. Research is pushing all boundaries; it is thinking that there is still so much to know and discover. If France makes this choice to give, for the coming years—and I have given this perspective—to research not only these resources but this confidence, then it can have a future for what we represent in the world but also for France to always be at the service of progress, because that is its vocation.

Research has always been closely associated with great commitments. Always remember the conference of 1956: those who were there in 1956 for the most part—essentially—had been resistors. Then many researchers engaged, not in public life in the electoral sense, but for great humanitarian causes because research is inseparable from a conception of life and a conception of humanity, because research is not simply a closed laboratory, isolated from what surrounds us. Research is profoundly a process that leads to the improvement of life, to ensuring that health can be as protected as possible, that life can be as long as possible, and also to ensuring that well-being can be shared as widely as possible. There is no progress in research if there is no progress in justice as well, and it is in this sense that France must be at the rendezvous.

Thank you.