Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the cooperative of Master Dairy Farmers of Cotentin, in Meautis on November 3, 2016.

France François Hollande · President of France

3 November 2016 · Visit to the Cotentin Master Dairy Farmers cooperative · Meautis, France

Context
Hollande visited the Maîtres Laitiers du Cotentin cooperative in Meautis on November 3, 2016, to celebrate the construction of a new dairy factory and praise the cooperative's model.
Main themes
Dairy cooperative model, Maîtres Laitiers du Cotentin, cooperative governance and values, milk producer prices and agricultural crisis, vertical supply chain integration, French agricultural exports, Chinese market partnership, factory investment, rural economic resilience, food quality and traceability, international market development
Duration
~21 min
68th percentile
Words
2,502
68th percentile
Sentences
110
67th percentile
Readability
47
53rd percentile
Grade
12.2
47th percentile
Syntax
3.05
54th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 72%68%
  • Ceremonial 11%10%
  • Institutional 8%7%
  • Geopolitical 6%5%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

110 sentences in 34 paragraphs

Gentlemen Ministers,

Ladies,

Gentlemen elected officials, parliamentarians,

Mr. President,

Mr. Director General,

Ladies and gentlemen representing producers,

Producers who are gathered here because I wanted to demonstrate through this visit that there is both an exemplary company and at the same time the creation of an exceptional factory - the two being indeed linked to one another. It is because there is an exemplary company that there is this capacity today to create a factory that is of the future.

So, I would like to first congratulate those who initiated this, namely the president, the director general, but also the cooperators, because the Maîtres Laitiers du Cotentin is a cooperative, which reconciles, as you very well said, Mr. Director General, the respect for the producer, who is your owner, with the satisfaction of the consumer, because that is your client, and at the same time a capacity for international development, because you understood - perhaps earlier than others - that there are new markets that will allow us to guarantee prices here and to sell products of excellence abroad.

I come back to it, you are a cooperative, created 30 years ago. Cooperative means that it is the principle of one man, one woman, one voice. It is the principle that there is no shareholding, and therefore you will have to finance your investments by yourselves, that the results will be shared among you, but with the constant concern for the future. A cooperative is this ability to structure itself, not to remain alone, to federate, to come together, in the face of competition which can be ruthless because it uses other means, other resources, and has other relationships with producers.

You wanted to remain true to your tradition, because it is a beautiful story that of the Maîtres Laitiers du Cotentin. And at the same time, you wanted to be a major French, European, and today global player. You wanted to bring together cooperative producers - there are 1,260, as you recalled the figures - and you also wanted to collect the largest number of millions of liters of milk per year.

So, how to explain your success, and can it serve as an illustration, a reference, an example for others? First, you wanted to create your own distribution structure, so that producers could also be distributors, mastering the chain, so that your company, France-Frais, could ultimately be in control of the entire chain, and that is what you have achieved through your 117 subsidiaries. You have thus been able to take control of the entire chain, from the producer to the final customer in the store, that is your strength.

Next, it is because you had this strength that you were able to pay milk producers the best price, and this requirement has been maintained throughout all the difficulties that the sector has gone through, and here, I know that in this region, in this large region, many farmers have been hit by this crisis, with the abandonment of milk quotas, overproduction, and prices that have collapsed. And even in this very trying period, you were able to maintain a price level, undoubtedly never sufficient for producers, but 40 euros higher than what was offered by the competition. If there were producers who were able to hold on during this period, they owe it to you.

You also succeeded, to achieve this result, in reducing the number of intermediaries. This is a very important point: controlling the entire chain, from production to distribution, paying the producer, but there is no miracle, it is essential to reduce the number of intermediaries between upstream and downstream, especially in the food sector. To achieve this, you created your brand, Campagne de France, and you made sure to highlight products from French agriculture at prices accessible to the greatest number. This demand for quality, traceability, and safety for your products has been the means to conquer new markets. Because a brand does not impose itself by itself, it is not enough to say "Campagne de France," France itself must be able to have confidence.

You also made a choice, which surely did not come naturally: to export, to go to external markets. Today, 20% of your production goes to new markets. Last year, you signed a contract with a Chinese group, SYNUTRA, which ensures the majority of infant nutrition in China. You committed for 10 years, this duration was necessary, because without this duration it was not possible to make the investments. I could understand the producers' concerns: is it really our role to supply milk to countries, with the modes of transport, with the risks also for prices, and with the amount of investment that needed to be released, and your cooperative structure could have been an obstacle. How to finance when you are a cooperative, when you are not supported by a large financial group? Nevertheless, you made this choice, to invest, and here we are in Méautis, and we see a factory being built, preparing to produce starting in March.

You will create 200 new jobs. You already had 700, which means that you are making a considerable leap. You will create a state-of-the-art factory. I have seen everything that is being prepared to welcome, process, enhance, and then provide all the safety and quality of the food that you will offer, and you will also be able to sustain your subsidiaries, thanks to this structure. So, you demonstrate, there too, that there are financing possibilities that we can find together.

When I wanted there to be a reorientation of Europe, I wanted it to focus on future investments. Among these future investments - we know them - there is everything related to digitalization, to the digital world, also to energy transition, I will come back to this since tomorrow there will be the implementation of the climate agreement. And then there is everything that can relate to food and health, well-being, which gave rise to the Juncker Plan.

The Juncker Plan is an abstraction - well, it is an abstraction and a name, since it is the name of the President of the European Commission - but for many, what is the Juncker Plan? Sums, money, billions of euros. But if there had not been the Juncker Plan, there would not be this factory today here in Méautis, because you were able, on the 110 million euros that your investment represents, to obtain half from the Juncker Plan through the European Investment Bank.

For those who still question Europe - there are some - and I imagine in this department as in this region, as everywhere, thinking - and sometimes there are just reasons - does Europe protect us enough? Does it ensure our security effectively, especially at the borders? Is Europe really up to the task when we expect it to further stimulate investment or employment, or to train the youth? I hear this, and I myself make sure, in European Councils, to carry this position and to express these priorities.

But at the same time, when Europe is capable - and it has been - of releasing a massive investment plan: 350 billion euros, and perhaps even more, 500 they say, - maybe even more tomorrow, because that is what we must do for the reorientation of Europe - we see its translations, but there cannot be financing if there is no project, it is a very simple rule.

Often it is said that we must find resources. Yes, surely, and it is one of the obligations of public authorities. You asked: "What can the State do?" Accompany you, facilitate procedures. They have been facilitated and I also thank the state services along with local elected officials who all contributed to this project. But the State can also create financial instruments to facilitate investment. This has been the case for France with the Public Investment Bank, which also intervenes in agriculture, and this is the case with the European Investment Bank.

But beyond these financings, there must be projects, and these projects must belong to what makes the strength of France. What is the strength of France? It is what explains your ability to convince countries that seem distant to us but that actually watch us very closely: China, India, others, Africa. What makes the strength of France? It is a tradition, it is a history, it is know-how, it is quality - here, it is represented and it is a modernity, it is an innovation.

For us, there is a necessity to always show that we can put at the service of the future what makes our history. Our history is never fixed, it is always ultimately a flag to carry our companies or our vital forces, our fellow citizens towards new conquests. We also have another lesson to draw, it is the long term. You would not have been able to carry this exemplary company if you had been constrained to short-term profitability. Because your shareholders would have asked you to distribute a certain number of products that you would have generated.

You would not have been able to make this heavy investment if you had not had the duration, ten years. We must inscribe ourselves in the long term and ensure that the choices we make can be translated and realized in a time that is sufficiently long for us to achieve results.

Finally, there is always this necessity to reconcile the local and the global, which is never easy. We are always tempted to lock ourselves into what may appear as a local identity or as a territorial solidarity that is necessary. I know that elected officials ensure this territorial solidarity at the level of municipalities, intercommunalities - since now our territory is a territory covered by intercommunalities that have the necessary size - of the department which ensures a proximity solidarity, of the large region today, Normandy.

It is necessary to have this local anchoring which is decisive but it is also necessary to have a global vision. Maîtres Laitiers du Cotentin, if you had been told one day that you could work with China, many would have smiled, but it is ultimately your destiny to not abandon anything that makes your tradition, your history, your roots, your anchoring and at the same time to be in the great global market.

There are those who fear the global market. There are those who try to protect themselves from it, to lock themselves in. Who tell us that we must be withdrawn behind our borders. But what would be the future of a company, of a cooperative like yours if there were no global market, if there were no Europe?

Finally, I want to say that your most beautiful project - and it is the one you highlighted, Mr. FORTIN, at the end of your speech - producing is necessary. Ensuring marketing, satisfying customers, that is to say ultimately those who trust you, is your obligation. Being able to have investment and therefore to project ourselves into the future, to generate results because if there are no results there is no possibility for investment.

And at the same time, what you have succeeded in doing is also to distribute, to make a pact that can be both productive and redistributive. That everyone has their share: the producer with a remunerative price, the consumer with a price that corresponds to the quality offered to him, the necessary margin for the company itself, in this case a cooperative, to have the necessary resources to prepare for its future, but also that there is this fair distribution. If there is no justice, if there is no distribution, which appears as the remuneration of work, there cannot be a solidary country, there cannot be a collective project.

There are not many examples - the cooperative is one among others - where it is possible to reconcile all interests. However, for a nation, it is essential to be able to federate all interests in the name of the general interest and to be able to show that, even if we may have our differences - I am not just talking about the sensitivities sometimes between producers, consumers, investors, financial institutions, we can mobilize for a collective project.

That is the example I wanted to give. That is a factory of the future. The factory of the future is not simply in the fields of digital technology as is often imagined by saying: "There is a new economy, too bad for the old one." Here, it is the very example of the most traditional economy, agriculture, milk, to make it an instrument of high technology in its transformation, in its enhancement and for export.

I cannot conclude without mentioning the situation of dairy farmers, of milk producers. They have endured in recent months, not to say in recent years, a trial with the end of milk quotas. A terrible trial that has been marked by collapsing prices, and all of this because production had not been controlled, was no longer controlled. Because in Europe, we had abandoned this regulatory tool. So today, for several months now, we have been working at both the European and national levels to reintroduce regulation, to ensure that producers who agree to put less product on the market can receive compensation for it.

We are only just beginning to see the effects, but I want to tell them that we will not cease to stand by their side and to add to what has been decided at the European level through a premium, another way to support this regulation of production. But I can also understand that for some producers, it is complicated to tell a producer who is trying to do their best to achieve the best yields to give up what is ultimately the very essence of their profession. Hence the issue of exportation. Without exportation, there could be no compensation.

So, ladies and gentlemen, this is what this visit means. It is true that it is also based on friendship; there are ties that have been established here, but that alone would not be enough. There is this example that you can provide, at a time when many believe that this dairy sector is in difficulty - and it is: how can we organize ourselves to face crises, to overcome and surmount them? It takes time, perseverance, and a strategy. If there is no strategy, there cannot be a response that meets expectations and what your production or what the country expects.

This strategy is to come together, to unite, to control, to invest, to export. This is what you have done, because there is here a model, an exemplary model. It is that of the cooperative, but France can also be that model. A productive model and an economic model, but also a social and redistributive model. This is the symbol of what you represent, dairy masters of Cotentin. Thank you.