Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on social policy within the European Union, in Paris on September 29, 2015.

France François Hollande · President of France

29 September 2015 · Opening of the congress of the European trade union movement (ETUC) · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed the European Trade Union Confederation congress in Paris on September 29, 2015, speaking on social policy and the refugee crisis.
Main themes
Social policy in the European Union, European social dialogue, trade union rights and movement, refugee and migration crisis, austerity and economic crisis, European solidarity, competitiveness versus social protection, Val Duchesse agreements legacy, free movement of persons, Syrian conflict and displacement, full employment agenda, European institutions and citizenship
Duration
~32 min
85th percentile
Words
3,861
85th percentile
Sentences
172
85th percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
12.5
51st percentile
Syntax
3.14
66th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 31%30%
  • Geopolitical 21%21%
  • Social 17%17%
  • Institutional 17%17%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Environmental 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

172 sentences in 53 paragraphs

Mr. President of the European Commission, dear Jean-Claude JUNCKER,

Mr. President of the European Parliament, dear Martin SCHULZ, - I want to express myself in the language of Victor HUGO, I will not make comparisons, but it was already the voice of a European! -

Madam Minister, Mr. Minister,

Madam Mayor of Paris, dear Anne HIDALGO,

Mr. President,

Madam Secretary-General,

Ladies and gentlemen who represent the entire European trade union movement.

I wanted to be present here at the opening of your congress - international transport means allowed me to arrive on time. I wanted to be here because I wanted to pay tribute to your movement which brings together 90 organizations, which is present in 39 countries and also to the millions of members. To remind that trade union rights have been fought for, won, and that if there have been advances and progress over the past century, it is mainly due to the battles that have been fought, the struggles that have been waged, and thus the tireless work of trade unionists, everywhere in Europe and in the world.

I also wanted to pay tribute to Bernadette SEGOL, not because she is French, but because she led your organization for years and was able to unite and bring people together.

I imagine that diverse sensitivities run through you, if I only consider what exists at the national level for the French trade union landscape. I wonder how she managed at the European level, but she succeeded. She succeeded because she highlighted what should mobilize you: a conception of Europe, a vision of solidarity, a demand to negotiate what could be negotiated at the European level. She was able to show that united, you were stronger against employer organizations that had themselves gathered at the European level.

Europe consists of institutions, that is to say, bodies that have to make decisions, European councils, councils of ministers, a Parliament, it is also economic and social actors. There can be no advancement of Europe if the Europe of citizens - and you represent them - is not directly associated with the choices that are made.

Europe also consists of rules, budgets, a market, a currency, but it is also regulations, it is also protections, it is also social institutions, and it is you who make them advance.

Thirty years ago, at the initiative of Jacques DELORS, the Val Duchesse agreements were concluded, marking the launch of social dialogue at the European level.

In the 1990s, this European social dialogue made serious advances, with agreements on parental leave, part-time work, and the fight against precariousness. In the 2000s, other agreements were concluded, still in the same process on stress or violence at work, on gender equality, on the labor market. Undoubtedly due to the crisis, surely also due to a certain conception of Europe that already prevailed, this momentum lost intensity and content. There was, however, the Lisbon agenda which, I remind you, aimed for full employment, yes, full employment - and it was the 1990s - and provided for the convergence of special regimes: this agenda did not yield the expected results, far from it.

Not only has social dialogue gradually exhausted itself, but increasingly numerous voices have been raised within the European Union to challenge certain achievements of social Europe, with all the risks of dislocation that could and can still result.

Governments have called for social regulations to be reviewed, even abolished, so as not to weaken the competitiveness of companies and economies. As Europe sank deeper into the crisis, more and more renunciations were demanded. Austerity was supposed to necessarily lead to prosperity.

We see others at this moment, demanding the application of free movement for their nationals and notably for work - this was indeed the foundation of the Union - and who today close their doors, erect walls against refugees fleeing war or persecution.

You wanted, Mr. President, Madam Secretary-General, that international migrations be addressed in your congress; the President of the Commission, like the President of the European Parliament, like the Mayor of Paris, have returned to this issue. Europe - and this can happen to it on other occasions - has been slow to take the measure of what has been at work for many months in the Middle East.

We thought that the dramas, the tragedies occurring there would not have consequences for Europe. We were saddened, for some of us mobilized, that was the case for France. We highlighted what a dictator can do when he is not stopped in time, we took stock every day of what a terrorist organization can do, massacre, kill, pillage, rape, and we did not realize that four million Syrians had fled their country, eight million were displaced.

We looked with pity at Turkey, Jordan, Lebanon taking on the full burden of welcoming refugees. Certainly, we made sure to prevent those crossing the Mediterranean from facing a tragic fate. We had strengthened what is called Frontex.

Then at one point there were too many fears, too many anxieties, to stay where the refugees were, and so they began to cross in large numbers.

Europe, I said, was slow, but it also made decisions as early as June to distribute refugees. The numbers were probably not up to what was going to happen, it had to be revisited, even in recent days in a European Council more peaceful than it has been said, probably due to the awareness, surely also because words had been spoken outside that could not be spoken inside.

Then the President of the European Commission, the President of the European Parliament wanted significant aid to be provided to the countries that welcome refugees. I am not talking about European countries, I am talking about countries far from Europe. Several billion have been allocated, and we will have to do even more.

Some member states are making more efforts than others, I salute them, and those who do not welcome refugees here must contribute even more to aid for refugee camps and host countries. This will be the case for France, which has decided to unlock 100 million euros for the food aid program and to support the efforts of the Commission.

We will also have - and you will be directly concerned - to socially and professionally integrate these refugees, to educate the children, to provide language training for the parents, a qualification - they often have a high one in their own country - and finally to allow them to access employment.

This refugee issue has raised many debates in Europe that we thought were buried long ago. Some believe that national withdrawal is now a solution to any crisis that occurs, the same believe that the euro, the single currency is the cause of their misfortune and that we can return to the borders of yesteryear. But that would no longer be Europe, it would be what prevailed before Europe and we are there today.

The great political issue that will arise in each of the nations that make up Europe is that of openness or closure, of sovereignty or, on the contrary, an end to federalism that we must assume. If we are in between, in half-measures, then it is the sovereignists who will prevail, because it is always easier to say that among ourselves it is better, that before it was the golden age. There will always be those to tell the poorer that it is first within our borders that we can find solutions.

We are facing this threat: this extremism, this populism is gaining countries that until now had been - if I may say - immunized, spared, perhaps because of the war, perhaps also because of what we believed to be a thought that had been established, a form of welfare state, of social democracy, of freedom that was taken for granted. No, it is a struggle to want openness, it is a struggle to want freedom and democracy. And when this struggle is no longer fought, it is lost.

There are others who believe that growth requires putting states and workers in competition and that Europe must be reduced to a market and even to a vast labor market, but again it is Europe, but it is not the Europe we wanted.

That is why we must affirm, those who have to make decisions or those who have to formulate proposals or demands, a number of priorities. Investment, which is the very condition for growth and progress, the integration of young people, which is the obligation for any society to give a future to the coming generations, a eurozone that must be stronger, therefore more solidary, and a social dialogue at the European level.

The first priority is employment, necessarily employment.

Everything has been said, one in ten active people in Europe is unemployed, one in five young people, and whatever is said, no member state is spared. France wanted there to be an investment plan, it had not imagined that it would bear a name, dear Jean-Claude JUNCKER, it fell on you, but you are not to blame. Because you wanted Europe to have a financial instrument capable of mobilizing 315 billion euros - I wish for more - so that we can not only improve the lives of our fellow citizens but also anticipate the technologies of tomorrow, launch major infrastructures, prepare the digital economy, anticipate the energy transition.

This plan must be implemented quickly. It is up to all states to make proposals. The French state recently submitted a list of projects and what I expect from Europe is not simply the display of a figure - it is impressive, even if related to European wealth, it may seem low - it is that it goes quickly, because for job seekers, for young people, for entrepreneurs, for entire sectors, there is no time to lose.

What we can also ask since you are here and the European Parliament votes on the budget, is that we can further amplify this program and ensure that year after year and based on experience, we can renew a number of funding and investments.

The question of the stability pact remains. Europe is a champion of words, in the face of stability there is flexibility, which allows for a compromise, some would say a synthesis motion, some looking at stability to reassure themselves, others hoping for flexibility to find leeway.

But let everyone understand that if we want a return to budgetary balances, and it is desirable to avoid the spiral of debt, the best way to achieve this beyond the disciplines that each country must respect, is investment and growth. If investment is stifled, growth will be hindered and public deficits will not be reduced as hoped. Moreover, when an event occurs, refugees, a crisis, a humanitarian disaster, what does Europe do? It adapts, it relaxes its rules.

And if the greatest disaster was unemployment? And if what threatened us the most was sovereignty and extremism? Then, would it not also be time to modify our rules to achieve the objective: to keep the European spirit?

Europe, it is always fashionable to blame it, and sometimes even those in responsibility are the best at prosecuting it. I will therefore avoid, myself, having been present for three years at the European Council, falling into this register. Europe has been able, beyond what has been done to give the eurozone more stability guarantees, beyond what we have been able to do on banking union, beyond what we have been able to initiate to combat tax optimization, to introduce new instruments for the integration of young people.

There have been three summits of heads of state and government on this very subject. We have been able to propose an Erasmus for First Employment. That is to say, for all young people seeking their first integration, to allow them to discover other countries to ensure this first experience. An envelope of six billion has been allocated for 2014-2015. I also hope that we can implement these credits quickly and amplify them as much as necessary.

In France, we seized this opportunity with the Youth Guarantee. This Youth Guarantee is aimed at those who are neither employed nor in training. It is, based on experience, one of the most effective mechanisms for integration. We have 50,000 young people in this program, and we have set ourselves the goal of 100,000 by 2017. In the same spirit, we must do for long-term unemployed individuals what we have begun to implement for young people, because there is a suffering that is perhaps the most terrible, that of many active individuals, as they are active workers who, for months and months, sometimes years, have been excluded from the labor market, placed in a category, referred to a social system, and who lose not only hope in themselves but hope in any political initiative and thus in Europe. In relation to these long-term unemployed individuals, we must have mechanisms for integration and inclusion, which requires a European plan for vocational training for job seekers of more than one year.

In the same spirit, we also suggest a general plan for training and support for new jobs - you mentioned it - jobs that digital technology, the digital world, energy transition, and new technologies will generate. We are preparing young people, we are also preparing those who are in employment for a major negotiation that we must open at both the European and national levels.

Mobility is also mentioned. Mobility is part of the principles of the European Union. Eight million European citizens are engaged in activities in a country other than their own. We must guarantee the rights of workers who lead their professional lives in several member states. Portability of rights, convergence of social security systems, and the fight against fraud and abuse, particularly concerning posted workers, are essential. We accept posted workers because it is the very principle of freedom of movement, but when excesses, abuses, and fraud use posted workers to engage in social dumping, to harm the balance of our companies, especially the smallest ones, to undermine the rights of employees, then all extremist deviations are possible. We have, in France, strengthened the fight against abusive posting, verified its application, and called for harmonization. A solidarity mechanism must also be extended to all subcontracting in all economic sectors, and we ask that Europe once again take up this issue through the directive on posted workers.

I have said that we must prepare for the jobs of tomorrow. There is always a confrontation in every society, and Europe is no exception, between fear and hope. It is when fear dominates and hope fades that the worst is to be feared. Therefore, the role of politicians, but also of trade unions, is to make hope credible and to push back fear. We see this through these new technologies. Everyone uses them, including to get here, but at the same time that we use them, we measure the effects they can produce on jobs themselves, including our own. We must try to evaluate the consequences of this digitalization of the economy and see what can be progress, opportunity, or risk. Not to prevent technology from spreading but to organize it, to anticipate industrial changes.

In France, we will open negotiations on the question of the jobs of tomorrow through digital technology and, more generally, through new technologies. So that workers can be prepared, that companies can anticipate, and that a number of abuses can be avoided. There are those related to individual freedoms - a law in France will address this, but there are also the distortions of competition and the changes that some so-called traditional sectors will have to organize. I also wish that this negotiation can find its place in the European social dialogue.

The same goes for the energy transition. You know, and I imagine that is why you wanted your congress to be held in Paris, to stay until December and participate in this great climate conference, I just returned from New York where there were many discussions about the chances of reaching an agreement in Paris. Things are progressing, nothing is certain, everything is possible: a minimal agreement or, on the contrary, an ambitious agreement. A minimal agreement would actually change nothing. An ambitious agreement would provoke public policies, corporate behaviors, evaluations in financial institutions that would contribute to significantly modifying our economic organization and moving towards a decarbonized economy: zero carbon, zero poverty, that is the slogan.

But if we succeed, then there will be new choices, new decisions to be made in companies, a new organization, different transport systems. Thus, the sustainable enterprise, I know that it is also one of the topics of your congress, will become the theme of all negotiations that will take place in the aftermath of the Paris conference. That is why I wanted the social conference, which will bring together the government and all the trade union organizations in our country, to take up this subject. In any case, we must prepare Europeans for these new jobs, for this new economy, and ensure that they can seize them as opportunities for growth.

But as the boundaries of work begin to blur, what is the role of the entrepreneur? What is the role of the employee? What is the role of the service provider? What should be the responsibility of the individual or the responsibility of the company? We must unify social regimes, guarantee rights, and define with great precision what work is and what employment is. Hence the importance of economic governance in the eurozone, hence the importance of European social dialogue.

I have made proposals on governance, not to change the institutions, I want to reassure Jean-Claude and Martin, not to separate those who would be in the eurozone from those who would not be or who would not come, but because we need an impetus. We also need coordination, we need harmonization, we need convergence. There is convergence for competitiveness, there is convergence for public deficits. There must also be convergence in terms of social rights, in terms of wages, in terms of social protection. It is this convergence that I am calling for, and it is what, together with Germany, we are beginning to work on so that we can have finance ministers' councils with social affairs ministers, together, and that we can imagine in the near future having a social Eurogroup as there exists a monetary and economic Eurogroup.

We also need convergence in social matters and in labor. The coordination of social policies, new decision-making processes, that is what is expected in the next stage of European construction: a foundation of social policy and a capacity through social dialogue to enrich fundamental rights. Hence the importance of your organization, dear Bernadette, which brings together all the unions. That is why the European Trade Union Confederation is not a secondary actor in the European process. It is you who also have to make Europe, who have to build it. Europe is a story of progress and solidarity. Of progress because, beyond peace, if countries have united, it is to be stronger together. It is to carry a model that could be seen as an example in the world. It is surely to be stronger economically. This was already in the spirit of the post-war period: to rebuild economies to be able, through the economy, to avoid conflicts.

For progress, for the economy, there was the principle of solidarity. Of solidarity between nations, and we have illustrated this so much. When the Berlin Wall fell, there were still two Europes. It would have been easy, convenient for the heads of state and government at that time to say that those who had remained on the other side of the wall could wait. We considered that Europe was one, and from there it had to be unique. Beyond the walls that have fallen, a whole has been created. Let those who have been welcomed into Europe remember what this choice was. Let them not forget that solidarity was also made to erase the traces of history. There was a union that greatly contributed to bringing down the wall and to bringing Eastern countries into the European Union. This union was called Solidarity. This solidarity must still be manifested by all.

Solidarity is also when a country faces a serious difficulty. When it is overwhelmed by debt. When it seems incapable of securing its future by itself. The solution is not to push it away; it is not to ask it to wait in the waiting room for major surgery, nor is it to provide it with the last rites. It is to provide it with solutions, to ask it for efforts as well, and that is what we succeeded in doing with Greece. It is true that some who can always look critically at what we do, if we had let Greece go, they would have accused us. We proposed a plan to it, we dominated it, it is the Greek people who responded in the best way. It is they who said they wanted to stay in the eurozone, and it is they who gave a mandate to the one who negotiated this plan to continue his action. I believe that when we want to listen to the people, we must first listen to those who are most confronted with difficulties; they have once again given the best response.

Solidarity is also that which we must provide to future generations. I return to the climate conference. It is not made to obtain immediate advantages, but to ensure that our planet is livable by the end of the century, and it is also about profoundly changing our model of development. I am not sure that all those who display - and I do not complain about it - ambitions in the fight against greenhouse gas emissions have sufficiently realized - but that is good - that this is generated in decisions and choices. A different economy will be born, and it will have very important consequences in terms of technology, investment, and well-being. You must be part of this challenge and this issue.

So, ladies and gentlemen, this is what I wanted to tell you here: that Europe is a struggle, that this struggle is that of solidarity. Solidarity is not simply that which heads of state and government can imagine among themselves and sometimes with delay. It is a civic struggle that must be led by responsible actors. The European Trade Union Confederation is precisely one of those actors who can not only speak to employees and workers, to tell them that Europe can also be their future, a framework that can be redirected, changed. The European Trade Union Confederation can especially contribute, thanks to the European social dialogue that we have the duty to relaunch, to produce rules, institutions, that will ensure that Europe moves forward and that progress remains the only path we must take. Thank you.