Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the European fight against illegal immigration, the situation in Libya, and the death sentence of a French citizen in Indonesia, in Brussels on April 23, 2015.

France François Hollande · President of France

23 April 2015 · European Council · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Hollande addressed press following an emergency European Council in Brussels on April 23, 2015, responding to deadly Mediterranean migrant shipwrecks.
Main themes
Illegal immigration in the Mediterranean, European emergency response, search and rescue operations, Frontex and maritime operations, human trafficking networks, Libya situation, UN Security Council resolution, asylum rights and border control, African development cooperation, refugee crisis from Syria and Iraq, counter-terrorism financing
Duration
~32 min
84th percentile
Words
3,804
84th percentile
Sentences
205
89th percentile
Readability
48
58th percentile
Grade
11.2
34th percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
36th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 52%51%
  • Ceremonial 20%20%
  • Social 17%17%
  • Institutional 7%7%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

205 sentences in 77 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC

Good evening,

I had requested that a European Council be held as soon as possible, following the tragedies that occurred on Sunday.

Matteo RENZI, the President of the Italian Council, also insisted that this Council take place today. I thank Donald TUSK for having, together with the European Commission, prepared this meeting, so that decisions could be made and that Europe could rise to the occasion in the face of this tragedy.

Europe cannot be responsible for everything. However, it must be capable of providing answers to everything, including the most heinous acts, namely the transportation by boats, which we know will not reach their destination, of populations that we know may or will die.

Thus, the European Council first wanted to show that it was capable of tripling the capacity that, until now, through the Triton and Poseidon operations under Frontex, Europe was implementing in the Mediterranean. Tripling means going even beyond what existed in an operation called Mare Nostrum, which aimed to save human lives while also ensuring border control.

France must take its share and even more than its share, because it is its honor and its duty. That is why I announced to the European Council that we would double the number of experts made available for these operations, deploy a patrol vessel also at the service of Frontex - and thus of the operation - and a tugboat in the open sea. Other countries have also made commitments, which will allow for the deployment of maritime resources, but also aerial resources. France will also provide two surveillance aircraft for the operation.

What is the objective? I reiterated, a humanitarian objective: to prevent ships from running aground or capsizing, and thus to save human lives. At the same time, to deter, as much as possible, a number of traffickers and ensure that there is control, so that traffickers are not encouraged to engage in their trade. Especially since this trade often finances terrorism.

A second decision has therefore been made, and it will be up to Madam MOGHERINI to implement it, within the framework of international law. This will involve presenting all options for the ships, the vessels used by traffickers to be destroyed or seized, so that this trafficking cannot be encouraged by maritime rescue operations.

This must be within the framework of international law. What does international law mean? I will return to the request of the Libyan government; everyone knows what the situation is in Libya. Therefore, this can only be done within the framework of a resolution of the Security Council, which must therefore be seized. France, a permanent member of this Security Council, will take the initiative, along with others, since the United Kingdom is also involved in this will. It is then that operations, if the Security Council grants the right, can find their place.

The third decision: to help the countries facing these migratory flows. I am thinking of Italy, Greece, and Malta, which must be able to welcome, but at the same time be able to distinguish between what falls under the right of asylum, which requires registering those who may be concerned by this right, and also to push back irregular immigration. This means that individuals who are welcomed, if they do not qualify for the right of asylum, must be returned. This will be within the framework of the Frontex operation. Resources must be allocated so that this irregular immigration, by definition, can be treated with humanity, dignity, and at the same time with the necessary firmness, so that there is no migratory flow that can be amplified. The system will therefore be one of registration for beneficiaries of the right of asylum and return for those who cannot fit into this framework.

A new decision was expected, and I wanted it; I proposed it, along with others. It is that we can help African countries control their borders. Because we need to act on the very causes of the phenomenon we lament, namely migratory movements. Most of those on these makeshift or rather unfortunate boats are migrants, people who are primarily seeking economic salvation and who are not necessarily being persecuted in their countries.

We must therefore help African countries to control their borders and also to have development projects. This will be the issue of a meeting between Europe and Africa that will likely take place in the coming weeks, by summer, in Malta, and which will allow us to act together so that there is a long-term policy, but also an emergency policy in relation to what we are witnessing today. Development projects, cooperation, border control.

In another way, we will also have discussions with Turkey. This again relates to what we observe regarding the movements of refugees coming from Syria or Iraq. We have begun to discuss, particularly regarding what is known about refugees, but also regarding the control of foreign fighters. Therefore, there will also be from the European Union an opening of discussion or a continuation of discussion with Turkey.

Finally, there are the deep-rooted causes of the problem. I will return to two countries.

The first is Libya, not because Libyans are coming to Europe, but because Libya today does not have a state system. Unfortunately, after the intervention that took place in 2011, the state has not been reconstituted. There are today factions, fractions, separations; there are even two governments, two parliaments. There is therefore a need to support, deepen, and accelerate everything that must be done so that a political agreement can be found, so that there can be a government, a state, and means to act.

Because if there is nothing in Libya, what happens? Candidates for immigration come to Libya to leave and then seek boats to take them to Europe, and that is where traffickers come into play. There is all the more urgency to do this because in Libya, Daesh, the terrorist group that is already active in Syria and Iraq, has established itself and is committing atrocities, the latest being the murder of Ethiopian Christians, but also committing actions aimed at destabilizing what is still in the process of state-building.

The worst, if nothing is done, is that there could be a terrorist state that could one day establish itself in Libya. At that point, it would not just be boats; it would be, unfortunately, terrorists coming from Libya to Europe. There is therefore an urgent need to act. It is not just Europe that can do this; it is the entire international community, particularly the countries that have, at one time, taken their responsibilities.

The second country is Eritrea, a country that is poorly known, where unfortunately a population is fleeing, and we must have real pressure and initiative with the representatives, the authorities of Eritrea. We cannot allow a country to empty of its population and have migratory flows that both weaken the resources of this country and at the same time threaten the entire region and, beyond that, have migratory consequences.

It is on all these issues that the European Council has initially provided responses. There will be others; there will be other steps, for example, on the question of welcoming refugees and the sharing of what this duty should be. When it comes to people who fall under the right of asylum, we cannot conceive that it is always the same countries that are called upon and that others in Europe escape this solidarity. Therefore, the European Commission will have to make proposals so that there can be a contribution from each country to ensure this duty of solidarity; I am thinking particularly of Syrian refugees.

I will conclude by mentioning two subjects that were not, of course, addressed at the European Council, except that I made a statement on one of them and also requested an expression. This subject is the risk of the execution of our compatriot Serge ATLAOUI in Indonesia. Europe has abolished the death penalty; all European countries are mobilizing to ensure that this abolition can be established globally. Today, Madam MOGHERINI also intervened to ask the Indonesian authorities not to carry out the sentence that has unfortunately been pronounced. I intervened at the European Council to call for this same solidarity, for this same duty that should be that of all democracies, so that there is no longer any death penalty pronounced, but above all no more executions.

The second subject is that of the meeting I had with the Greek Prime Minister on the issues we know, so that there can be progress in the discussions, so that the Eurogroup can decide, when the time comes, to resolve what can be resolved, namely that Greece must continue to provide the necessary information and show that it has made decisions regarding reforms.

I can answer your questions, but I will be quick because I have to go to Armenia afterwards.

Thierry ARNAUD, BFM TV

Good evening, Mr. President. Two days ago, you said that this Council could not be an ordinary Council that produces ordinary decisions. When you compare the magnitude of the decisions made today to the magnitude of the tragedy in question, are you disappointed? If you are not, in what way are the decisions made today extraordinary?

THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC

Tripling the resources that have been used until now is already stepping out of the ordinary.

Being able to define a migration policy and especially to implement it, that is to say to be able, in the countries facing it, to register, welcome, and organize returns, yes, that is no longer extraordinary because it must now be the migration policy implemented by Europe.

Being able to decide, and it will require further actions since it is the Security Council that will be seized, to render inoperable ships that, in any case, should not even be on the seas, yes, in this sense, it is an extraordinary decision.

Is it sufficient? Is all of this enough? If it is not, there will need to be even more resources within the framework of Frontex, and it will be necessary that not only Europe but the entire international community also takes its responsibilities. That is to say, there must be action on the causes; I have mentioned them, what is happening in Libya, what may exist in Africa. I remind you that among those who were on that death boat, who were at the bottom of the holds, locked up, many were Africans coming from the Sahel. Therefore, we also have to help African countries coordinate their efforts. France has long taken its responsibilities, in terms of security, humanitarian aid, but also economically.

That is why I insisted, it is an important decision, that there should also be this summit between Europe and Africa. It is not an extraordinary summit solely for urgent decisions, but also for long-term decisions. I am all the more interested in the organization of this summit as there is the Climate Conference and we must also show solidarity with Africa regarding what we can conclude in Paris. Climate actions are not without consequences on migratory movements. By acting on climate, we can also act on immigration.

Béatrice HADJAJE, RTL

I have two very concrete questions. Can you specify what the resources you will all dedicate to Frontex will be used for? Frontex will serve in the Mediterranean only; that is already a lot to save shipwrecked individuals in case of shipwreck. But Frontex will not have the right, if I understand correctly, to board a ship or destroy it. Can you tell us precisely?

And then, I have a second question. You tell us that Frontex will be able to return all migrants who do not have political asylum. Does this mean that all migrants coming from war-torn countries will be allowed to stay in Europe? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC

Within the framework of what is called Frontex, there is the Triton operation for the Italian and Maltese coasts and the Poseidon operation for the Greek coasts. In this framework, the boats and planes are put at the service of saving lives, but they are also there to deter departures of boats, vessels coming from Libya that should not approach and be turned back. Therefore, Triton must have the role of intervening when human lives are at stake - which is happening today and what happened yesterday - but at the same time to deter, to turn back, to push back, and to bring back to the Libyan coasts.

Afterwards, there needs to be a repatriation, which follows other modes of transport. The people who come, some even from war-torn countries, can be refugees, while others may not necessarily be. For example, there are people coming from Nigeria, not necessarily from war zones, who are not threatened, but who want to come to Europe. Therefore, there will necessarily be work done to register those who may qualify for asylum; afterwards, we will see if they can obtain it, and to identify those whom we know from the outset fall under irregular immigration and who must therefore be repatriated.

Mamadou Moussa BÂ, BBC

Mr. President, good evening. We know that international migrations from the South to the North have long been driven by former colonial powers in search of labor. I was in Paris yesterday and visited the Museum of Immigration. I was fascinated by the contributions of migrants in terms of culture, architecture, sports, and many other fields. Today, a country like France needs uranium from Niger, you need copper from Katanga; I can cite several examples.

My first question: why, as long as there is free movement of goods, can human beings not move freely? Why not simply legalize migration?

The second question: are you considering military intervention in Libya? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC

Two different questions, and I understand both. Immigration has been a contribution to our country, France, over the past decades. What makes France what it is today is because of these successive immigrations and then the children born to those parents who came to work, to give their best, and who are now French and can contribute, in turn, as French citizens, what they have to offer.

But in order for us to live together, we need to manage migration phenomena. There is what pertains to asylum, which has always been a right regardless of the periods and economic situations. When a person risks their life, even if there are difficulties, there is a duty for our country to welcome them. This is part not only of our tradition, our culture, but of the duty of every nation towards those whose lives are threatened.

And then, there has always been immigration control, and it must be done at the European level. That is why there is a European policy regarding our common borders. And this policy must be made and carried out in solidarity, meaning all European countries must have the same rules. This is why, for entry into European territory, a distinction must be made between what pertains to asylum and what pertains to migration when it is not authorized. Sometimes it can be authorized; in this case, it is not.

Regarding Libya, everything must be done to first seek a political agreement among the stakeholders. This effort has been ongoing for weeks, if not months, with the United Nations special representative, with discussions that seem never-ending. The international community must exert much stronger pressure, and the Security Council must be seized of this matter.

But it must also be seized of these traffickers, often linked to terrorist groups, who have organized themselves and lead entire families to their deaths. You have seen the testimonies of survivors and what happened in Libya even before these families were on the boat: there have already been abuses and deaths. Are we going to let this go on any longer? If the Security Council passes this resolution, there will first need to be a European policy that can act on the boats, on the vessels.

Renaud HONORE, Les Echos

Hello. You just explained that it should not always be the same countries that host and receive refugees. Does this mean that France is in favor of revisiting the Dublin II rules at the European level? Is the second step, which you mentioned earlier regarding the reception of refugees, contingent upon a revision of this convention?

THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC

The perspective is that there should be a sharing, and not simply countries deciding from a purely voluntary standpoint. The principle is one of voluntarism, but solidarity must also be the rule. We will therefore work on the next steps.

JOURNALIST

Mr. President, what happened in Sicily occurred under the circumstances of a tragedy foretold. Public opinion in Italy is asking why you need 900 deaths to act; how do you justify this delay?

THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC

Since the beginning of the year, there has been a considerable increase in the number of victims. Just in the last few days, 1,100 deaths have been recorded. This is not the first time; you mentioned what happened in Lampedusa, which took on a tragic and deadly dimension, given the number of victims since the beginning of the year, and we cannot let Italy handle this situation alone. I stand in solidarity with Matteo RENZI; we must help Italy to welcome and then - I will not repeat my reasoning - what pertains to asylum must be shared, and what pertains to irregular immigration must be repatriated. We must also ensure that there are not tens of thousands of people coming tomorrow because that is a possible risk.

Because if Libya is still not controlled, people will continue to want to leave. If we do not challenge the traffickers, they will organize themselves industrially to carry out their dirty work. Therefore, we must act on the economic causes of what is happening in a number of countries, to provide these countries with the necessary support for their development and for the control of their borders, and we must act against the traffickers. This is the meaning of the decisions of the European Council.

JOURNALIST

Good evening, Mr. President. You mentioned earlier the case of Serge ATLAOUI. The Indonesian government has indeed ordered preparations for the execution of Serge ATLAOUI. Does this mean, first, that there is no longer any hope, and second, have you had any contact with the Indonesian authorities? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC

Until the last moment, we must do everything to prevent the execution from taking place. We are multiplying contacts: Laurent FABIUS has intervened several times with the Indonesian authorities, and I myself had a discussion with the Indonesian president. Today, there must be this appeal for the execution not to take place. There is not just one French national involved, even if today in Europe he is the only one. There is also a Brazilian, an Australian, and others of different nationalities, and the abolition of the death penalty is an essential principle for us. In the case of Serge ATLAOUI, especially regarding what he has done, which has been acknowledged, death cannot be the punishment.

Nicolas GROS-VERHEYDE, OUEST-FRANCE

A question about the maritime operation for which a mandate is being given to the high representative. I wanted to know when you estimate or think it could be operational, whether it would, for example, enter Libyan territorial waters or not, and how we will convince certain partners, particularly Russia, at the UN Security Council, who, as soon as they hear "Libya," see red a bit "red"?

The Russian representatives, if I remember correctly, always said they would not agree to any other international action until there had been an investigation into NATO's intervention in Libya. Is this something that could be part of the bargaining chip?

I had a small question about the 5,000 refugees as well, those that France would take charge of. Is this figure confirmed, and will France take a share, and where would they be taken from?

THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC

First of all, this is not about repeating an intervention. Secondly, there cannot be a European operation in terms of the destruction or incapacitation of a number of vessels or ships except within the framework of international law, that is to say, under a resolution from the Security Council.

You are right to say that it is necessary to convince all members of the Security Council, especially the permanent members. Tonight, I am leaving for Armenia; I will meet President PUTIN on the occasion of the centenary of the Armenian genocide. We will discuss many topics, as you know, and I will talk to him about what Europe intends to propose in the context of a possible resolution from the Security Council.

I believe he can understand that this is not about repeating an intervention, but about ensuring that traffickers cannot lead to the death of a number of people who are far from Libya and who are not involved in the Libyan conflict since they are economic migrants or refugees.

Therefore, we need this resolution. To be very precise, once this resolution can be voted on by the Security Council - this is a timeframe that should be relatively short - Madam MOGHERINI will need to prepare this operation and present it, of course, as much as possible in contact with what remains of the Libyan authorities. Hence the importance of ensuring their gathering, their reconciliation so that there can be effectiveness. Last question.

THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC

When the figure of 5,000 was made known or public, France said, and I confirm it here, that it would take its share, meaning for France between 500 and 700. These will be primarily Syrians.

François BEAUDONNET, France 2

Mr. President, good evening. A question specifically about the Security Council resolution. What is the probability, in your opinion, that Europe will obtain this mandate? Are you ultimately optimistic?

Second question, if Europe does not obtain this mandate, will it not ultimately be a way for it to say, "You see, we tried, but we could not because we did not have the UN mandate"? Thank you very much.

THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC

I think that if we want to have this mandate, we must be very clear about the objectives and the means to achieve them. Any confusion, any idea of intervention would, in my opinion, be the best way to condemn the very possibility of a resolution. Therefore, it is indeed about ensuring that traffickers and the vessels they use, which have the disastrous consequences we know, are addressed.

Thank you.