Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the reform of the State, in Paris on January 8, 2013.

France François Hollande · President of France

8 January 2013 · New Year greetings to leaders of major administrations, public institutions and the highest magistracies · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed senior French civil servants and public institution leaders at a traditional New Year gathering in Paris on January 8, 2013, outlining his vision for state reform.
Main themes
State reform, civil service, public administration, deficit reduction, state coherence, foresight and strategic planning, decentralization, public services, national cohesion, economic competitiveness, administrative modernization, new year address
Duration
~26 min
78th percentile
Words
3,166
78th percentile
Sentences
171
85th percentile
Readability
48
58th percentile
Grade
11.1
33rd percentile
Syntax
2.90
34th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
43rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 67%67%
  • Economic 16%16%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

171 sentences in 53 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister,

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

Mr. Vice-President of the Council of State,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I would like to first thank you, Mr. Vice-President, for your remarks, their elevated nature, and the sense of state that you have recalled.

This morning, we are renewing a happy tradition, one that consists of bringing together at the threshold of the new year leaders from major administrations, public institutions, and the highest magistracies of the country, so that the President of the Republic can extend, beyond you, his wishes to the servants of the state. That the head of state presents his wishes to the state—allow me this formulation—what could be more normal?

But the state is not an abstraction. It is made up of women and men who have chosen a profession rather than just a job, a vocation, I know, who have decided to serve the public interest and who have remained steadfast in that commitment against all odds. I know they are justifiably proud of their missions.

Public services in our country, as you reminded us, Mr. Vice-President, are both indispensable to economic and social progress and inseparable from national cohesion. And I wish to reaffirm here today the respect and consideration I have for those who animate them, that is to say, the civil servants.

They ensure, regardless of their levels of responsibility, the continuity of the state, and I am grateful to them for having been able to accompany the first steps of the alternation desired by our fellow citizens. The French chose change last May, and it is my duty to create the conditions to translate that choice, but it is also the responsibility of the administrations to make the decisions of the state applicable and enforced.

Our common task is to restore France in unity and even in calm, to control its debt, to give businesses the margins and means to regain their competitiveness, to restore, as much as possible, the attractiveness of our country so that it can once again be a space for job creation, wealth, and trust for younger generations.

In this vast adventure—because it is one—efforts are required from everyone, and therefore first and foremost from the state. The reduction of our deficits is inscribed in the finance law for 2013 and in the three-year trajectory set by the Prime Minister. This year, we must achieve 10 billion euros in savings from the state budget while preserving priority sectors: employment, education, justice, and security.

To achieve this, the broadest mobilization is required. First at the highest level, which you represent. The secretaries general of the ministries, the directors of central administrations, and the regional prefects are particularly responsible for this. Together with the Prime Minister, I will meet with them regularly, once a quarter, to monitor the implementation of major public policies across the national territory.

But the state also wants to reform itself to always be worthy of the great attachment the French have for it. Our nation, as you have once again mentioned, Mr. Vice-President, is unique in Europe. It has been built around the state and by the state. It is the state that, in glorious periods as well as in more painful times, has been able to guarantee the rules of social life and preserve the republican pact.

But to remain fully at the service of our fellow citizens, the state must constantly adapt. And this imperative of change, of renovation, but also of permanence, encompasses four requirements.

The first is that the state must know how to anticipate. It is its role to foresee the changes in France and the world in 5 years, in 10 years, in 15 years. It is up to it to carry a coherent vision of the future. This is the spirit behind the creation of a General Commission for Foresight and Evaluation, which will be announced in the coming days. It will involve social partners, the best experts from society, and thus from the administration. New technologies, the promises of biology, climate challenges, demographic imbalances, geostrategic evolutions, cultural changes: all of this will be debated, and every opportunity must be seized, every change must be prepared, and every risk must be identified. This will be the function of this new institution. It will be associated with the investment strategy that I have asked the Prime Minister to prepare to outline France by the horizon of 2020. We need to know not just what is going to happen but what we must do as a state, as a nation, to put ourselves forward.

The state must then ensure its coherence. Various considerations, some of which are undoubtedly respectable, have led in recent years to the multiplication of what are called the dismemberments of the state. Today, there are 38 independent administrative authorities, as well as 1,200 operators or agencies. The result is a certain devaluation of central administrations; it is also a dilution of the state, a loss of political impetus. This trend must not only be interrupted but reversed.

I have asked the government to be both more restrictive in the creation of autonomous bodies, which many are once again asking it to multiply, and to seek their regrouping whenever relevant. And being independent does not mean being independent of the missions that can be assigned to all administrations. The Court of Auditors will remind us of this as often as necessary.

The state must also modernize. For the first time in its history, at least its administrative history, our country will conduct a thorough evaluation of its major public policies. It is the entirety of public action that will be examined—not just that of the state, but also that of local authorities and major social operators.

Let us be clear about this modernization of public action: it is not a new RGPP, which has had a bad reputation, and which would resurface under another name. It is also not a logic of suspicion, that well-known ease across all sensitivities, which would claim to place only market activities in the positive column of the national balance sheet while public services would be considered a burden. I would like to remind you that among the primary factors of attractiveness of France in the eyes of foreign investors are the density and quality of our public services and our major infrastructures.

Evaluating public policies does not mean contesting them; it means, on the contrary, giving them all the means for their effectiveness and even their legitimacy. Because when I learn that in certain areas we are achieving poorer results than our neighbors while we are allocating more resources to them, I conclude that an examination is desirable, if not indispensable.

For example, there are more than 7,000 different aids for businesses. Are they aware of them? I am not sure that their satisfaction is commensurate with the number of aids that are intended for them—80 billion euros—which also deserve to be evaluated to be even more relevant. It will also be necessary to look at the management costs of certain schemes, of certain aids to economic or social sectors, and to measure each time their utility and relevance in relation to what was the will of the legislator or the government.

We must identify the windfall effects—there are some—organize to provide public services at the best cost, and seek how we can further improve our results. I am not inventing anything; in the 1960s or 1970s, there was already a procedure, the rationalization of budgetary choices. We were, however, in a period of euphoria, which did not prevent reason from prevailing. There had even been particularly bold economic research on this rationalization. Curiously, as difficulties arose, we lost the tools, the relevance, and even the logic of this evaluation.

We must return to this. This exercise of truth is one of the keys to the recovery of France because it allows us to be smarter, stronger collectively, and not simply to apply mechanical ratios that discourage because they have no meaning, no relevance, no foundation. This evaluation method has already been initiated by the Government. It concerns forty public policies, and there will be others.

Finally, the state must simplify the lives of our fellow citizens.

To simplify means to make things simple, and we all have a tendency—we know it—to make things rather complicated to show that we are smarter than others. We must reverse this trend, too, of our national temperament. This applies to everyone.

Every year we keep an accounting that can sometimes reassure us but should worry us because our country accumulates texts: 2,000 laws and 26,000 decrees in the last 10 years, 16,000 pages of circulars per year. Have we read all this? Including among the constituted bodies? Every creation of a new norm will henceforth be accompanied by the elimination of another. Again, I am not inventing anything; I have heard this so many times! This incantation has not found its translation.

So we will have to show a certain obligation, even coercion. First towards the Government and the ministers, who, regardless of the alternations, and especially when there is an alternation, want their law to leave their name in history. Sometimes, this is unfortunate! So fewer laws, shorter laws, less verbose, less confusing. But this also applies to regulations, the implementing decrees that always take time to come. Often they are published when a new law has come into effect, rendering them obsolete. How do we expect our fellow citizens to recognize themselves in this?

I would also like to emphasize a regrettable method that, in the name of environmental law, has led some groups to file abusive appeals motivated by purely financial interests. We must therefore ensure that they are sanctioned. In the same way, we must reduce a certain number of norms while pursuing the same objective for environmental and urban planning law.

Simplifying public action will also require remedying the piling up of consultative bodies created often on a case-by-case basis. One hundred commissions, whose utility is not demonstrated, will be abolished in 2013, which is 15% of the total; this is ultimately quite little. I am told that this percentage will be raised to 25% by June. We must maintain the pace.

Simplifying, always simplifying, should be seen by public agents not as a new constraint but as a positive value, as a guarantee of clarity, as a condition for efficiency.

France needs a state, a strategic state that anticipates; a coherent state that brings together all administrations around the same objectives, the same goals, and the same perspectives; a modern state that adapts to circumstances; an efficient state, that is to say, simple in its methods and that puts all its means—and there are means in our administrations—at the service of the French people.

To serve this purpose, our public services must, in all circumstances, be examples. They must therefore respect the principles that serve as their foundation, foremost among which are impartiality, neutrality, and secularism. These are general rules that cannot tolerate any exceptions. They apply in all circumstances, on all subjects, and in all establishments under public service.

We will celebrate, during the year 2013, this summer, the thirtieth anniversary of the status of the three public functions. This will be an opportunity to enshrine the ethical rules that apply to public agents and to implement the recommendations of the report from Lionel Jospin's Commission and your own report, Mr. Vice-President, on the prevention of conflicts of interest.

But beyond this precaution and this wisdom, the administration must also make an effort to be more diverse, more representative of the society of which it is the expression: diversity of origins, training, paths, territories, neighborhoods. Preparations for administrative competitions must take this priority into account to the greatest extent. I also wish—there is still some effort to be made—for an exemplary administration, at all levels of the hierarchy, on the issue of parity. The appointments made every Wednesday at the Council of Ministers take this requirement into account. It is not a matter of obligation but a necessity to ensure that our administration resembles French society at all levels of the hierarchy.

Finally, I expect the services of the state to be ever more attentive to the aspirations of users, which also change with technology. Information must be more transparent; procedures more intelligible; and citizens more involved in decisions. These "new technologies" allow us to respond to this desire for dialogue. I invite you to exploit all possibilities, which you are always doing more.

You mentioned, Mr. Vice President, the situation of justice. You recalled these rules that are so obvious and yet have not always been respected. There is no justice without the separation of powers; there is no justice without the impartiality of those who have the heavy task of making decisions "in the name of the French people." There is no justice when the executive allows itself to interfere. I am, as head of state, and you have once again emphasized, the guarantor of the independence of justice. I will fully assume this requirement. And I will therefore engage, with the Government, in the spring, under the responsibility of the Keeper of the Seals, a reform of the Superior Council of the Judiciary. With two objectives: to completely, I say completely, remove this institution from any political influence and to enshrine its role in the appointment of the hierarchy of the public prosecutor's office, as well as the judiciary.

Public action is not simply that of the state. It is also that of local authorities which, as everyone knows, represent more than 75% of public investments.

Many measures launched by the state can only be implemented if the local authorities themselves or other actors participate. I am thinking of future jobs, housing policy, but also employment policy. That is why I have great confidence in all public service agents, particularly those in local public service, to pursue the objectives that may be common to us.

Parliament will examine in the spring a text that will allow the history of decentralization to take a new step. This law will lay the foundations for a gradual transformation, necessarily gradual—too slow for some, too fast for others—of the map of our territories. Its principle is simplification. Too many overlapping interventions, overlapping competencies, and layers of bureaucracy have excessively burdened the rules of the game for economic and social actors and even for citizens. Competencies will therefore be clarified; the role of regions and metropolitan areas will be strengthened; mutualization, even integration, between certain local authorities will be encouraged. For each type of competency, a leading authority will be identified.

I hope that this new step will inaugurate new relations between the state and local authorities, based on respect, complementarity, but also the obligation to implement more limited means to achieve greater results.

Public power is one; it is not indivisible, but it is one. There is the state, social administrations, and local authorities. Each of these levels has its own responsibilities, its own competencies, and its own freedoms. They must be respected. But everything must converge towards the same objectives.

2013 is a year in which we will need to show tenacity, will, and even—I will use the word—patriotism.

We need the support of all public service agents. They are the ones who must set the example. We need all those who, well beyond public services, love their state, their nation, their country, and who are convinced, like you and me, of its immense strengths, its great resources, its capacity to bounce back, and therefore of our possibilities to succeed.

We also need good examples: history offers us beautiful and enlightening ones. A few days ago, I was in the city of Louviers, in Normandy, where Pierre Mendès France was elected for many years. I wanted to associate myself with the tribute being paid to him on the occasion of the thirtieth anniversary of his death. His lessons remain relevant today. What are they? The truth without which there can be no adherence of a country; and also the will without which there can be no transformation of a nation.

He did not have the opportunity to govern for long. Those who are in charge of the country today have duration. This duration must not be neglected; it is an asset. Everything must be done within the time given by universal suffrage to act. The administration has no time limit. What you represent is worth more than those who govern. It is you who will allow, through this permanence, this constancy, and this will that animates you, for our country to meet the rendezvous of history.

Challenges change with each era. Nothing repeats itself. Even exits from crises are not alike in any way. Everyone knows the context of the crisis today: a Europe emerging from the eurozone crisis, a world still uncertain with signs of recovery but also concerns given the instability of a number of markets.

But one thing is certain: the state in France must fully play its role. And if not everything depends on it, it is towards it, each time, that the French turn for their protection or for the preparation of their future. And it is towards the head of state, for the exercise of responsibility, that the French also turn because there is only one responsible party: the one who is elected and who must be accountable.

I have set our principles and priorities for 2013: reversing the unemployment curve by the end of the year. It is difficult, and it is because it is difficult that we must set this objective; it is because it is not guaranteed in advance, I am often reminded of that. If it were guaranteed in advance, it would not be an objective.

We are all aware that if our country still experiences this rise in unemployment, which seems inexorable for a few months, it will not be able to regain confidence in itself. So, let us seek growth; there are means for that, and I trust economic forces more than any other instrument! Let us seek investments because it is necessary for the preparation of the future! Let us seek means to invent policies, particularly for youth employment, for the integration of the unemployed! Let us trust social partners: in a few days, in a few hours, a very important negotiation will conclude! And then let us implement! That is the first priority.

The second is the preparation for the future through a new generation of public and private investments.

And finally, the third is the means given to youth to build their destiny.

Ladies and gentlemen,

I know I can count on the established bodies that clearly represent what they stand for: a force for France, provided you trust them and mobilize around a great task that is also a great hope: the success of our country. Thank you.