Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the role of the Constitutional Council, in Paris on January 7, 2013.

France François Hollande · President of France

7 January 2013 · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed the Constitutional Council at its New Year's wishes ceremony in Paris on January 7, 2013, outlining its role and announcing planned constitutional reforms.
Main themes
Role of the Constitutional Council, constitutional review, separation of powers, QPC priority questions, treaty constitutionality, European Union governance treaty, decentralization, judicial independence, institutional reform, fundamental rights and freedoms, parliamentary legitimacy, exemplary Republic
Duration
~10 min
36th percentile
Words
1,215
36th percentile
Sentences
63
41st percentile
Readability
40
37th percentile
Grade
12.4
50th percentile
Syntax
2.78
20th percentile
Vocabulary
2.34
82nd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 84%84%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

63 sentences in 32 paragraphs

Mr. President,

Ladies and gentlemen,

I thank you for your words and extend to you my warmest wishes, for yourselves and for your Institution.

In 2012, the activity of the Constitutional Council was particularly intense.

You ruled on the regularity of the presidential election and that of the legislative elections, on which you have already judged almost all those that were the subject of protests.

Under the QPC, more than 170 questions were submitted to you.

As for the pre-promulgation review, it concerned almost all the bills adopted during the extraordinary session and the autumn session. As if recourse to the Council had now become automatic.

You also had the opportunity to render several notable decisions. It is not for me to comment on them. They have the absolute authority of res judicata. What I can confirm to you is that the government will take them into the greatest account to present, when the time comes, to Parliament, under different modalities with the same objective, the censured provisions.

Another of your responsibilities took on particular importance this year. I want to speak about the preventive review of the constitutionality of treaties under Article 54 of the Constitution. The decision you rendered on August 9, following my referral, regarding the Treaty on Stability, Coordination and Governance within the European Union clarified for France the choice that was offered to it. It was followed by the adoption of an organic law relating to the programming of public finances and the ratification of the treaty itself. It opened the way to a new stage in the construction of Europe, without the need to change the Constitution.

These reminders illustrate the prominent place that your institution occupies within the Republic.

That is why I wished, for my first wishes of the five-year term, to reconnect with a tradition - that of the ceremony of wishes at the Constitutional Council. I do not know why it had been suspended.

You know the importance I attach to an exemplary Republic, in which the separation of powers is respected, the competencies of each preserved, and the defense of our values firmly assured.

You contribute greatly to this.

You first ensure respect for the rights of Parliament. You have always recognized that you do not hold a general power of appreciation and decision of the same nature as that of the legislator. Making the law in the name of the general interest is the mission of Parliament, whose legitimacy comes from universal suffrage. Judging the law in law is yours, based solely on the principles of which you are the interpreters.

The place of the Constitutional Council is the result of a patient construction that has been progressively enriched over time.

Indeed, your competencies have continued to expand, from the widening of your mode of referral to parliamentarians in 1974 to the creation, in 2008, of the priority question of constitutionality. As a regulatory body of the Constitution, you have become a constitutional court, regarded as such by other constitutional jurisdictions in Europe.

The values of which you are the guarantors are the most essential of the Republic: the equality of all citizens before the law, respect for fundamental rights and freedoms, secularism, respect for the dignity of the human person, social rights such as the right to health protection or the constitutional rights of workers. These rights and freedoms, you have sanctified in a "block of constitutionality" - alongside the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, the fundamental principles recognized by the laws of the Republic, those stated in the Preamble of the 1946 constitution, and even those more recently inscribed in the Charter of the Environment. Throughout your decisions, you have continued to strengthen them.

You are also concerned with territorial power. And the inclusion of decentralization in the Constitution has made you the guarantors of the freedom of local authorities. It is in this context that I wished for a new act of decentralization to be initiated, which will contribute to simplifying, clarifying, and rationalizing the competencies of each territorial level.

I also intend to promote the democratization of our institutions. Following the report submitted to me by Lionel Jospin, I will initiate a constitutional reform aimed at consolidating the independence of the High Council of the Judiciary and enshrining its role in the appointment of the hierarchy of the judiciary and the public prosecutor's office, abolishing the Court of Justice of the Republic, amending the status of the head of state, and recognizing the role of social partners.

I hope that these provisions will be adopted by Parliament convened in Congress in the coming months.

I also intend to end the status of ex officio member of the Constitutional Council for former presidents of the Republic. I will therefore propose to put an end to it, but only for the future.

Finally, I have asked the government to prepare a bill to improve the conditions for financing presidential campaigns and to relax the rules for candidates' access to the media, particularly during the so-called "intermediate" period.

As for the proposal regarding citizen sponsorship for the presidential election, the consultation I conducted ultimately convinced me of the difficulty of its implementation.

Mr. President,

The year 2013 will mark the completion of the mandate of Jacqueline de GuillenSchmidt, Pierre Steinmetz, and Claire Bazy-Malaurie. I thank them for their contributions to the work of the Council. Be assured that care will be taken to ensure that future appointments distinguish merit, competence, and independence.

The year 2013 will be a year of sustained legislative activity. I have warned the government. The law must be useful, clear, and normative, your jurisprudence imposes it. It must be a source of security and clarity, not instability and uncertainty, as your decisions remind us. I will ensure that these principles always inspire the making of the law.

The year 2013 will constitute a new step in the use of the priority question of constitutionality.

This reform is a success. Litigants ask questions, the courts refer them, the Constitutional Council decides them, and, in some cases, repeals legislative provisions whose unconstitutionality tainted the rule of law.

In two years, nearly 300 decisions have been rendered. The most symbolic of them is obviously the one censoring the crystallization regime of pensions for foreigners, an unequal measure if there ever was one. But there have been other advances in rights and freedoms: the repeal of articles of the Code of Criminal Procedure on common law police custody; the repeal of the travel document for travelers; the unconstitutionality of the previous regime for lifting the involuntary hospitalization of criminally irresponsible persons.

The government of Jean-Marc Ayrault immediately drew the consequences from this. This was the case for defining, in accordance with your prescriptions, the offense of sexual harassment.

Today, the government and Parliament have to make choices that correspond to their commitments to the French people. They have received a mandate through the ballot box. I know that they do not see the intervention of the Constitutional Council as an impediment, but as a reminder of the fundamental principles of our Law.

And it is this message of confidence in our institutions that I wanted to convey to you on the occasion of this ceremony of wishes.