Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the reform of the State, in Paris on January 7, 2014.

France François Hollande · President of France

7 January 2014 · Statement on the reform of the State · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed French government officials and senior civil servants at a New Year gathering in Paris on January 7, 2014, to outline priorities for state reform.
Main themes
State reform, role of the state in France, national unity, republican values, public administration, decentralization and competency overlap, civil service, rule of law, fight against racism and antisemitism, European construction, social solidarity, intellectual and moral reform
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,250
87th percentile
Sentences
246
93rd percentile
Readability
52
68th percentile
Grade
10.3
24th percentile
Syntax
2.84
26th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 57%57%
  • Economic 15%15%
  • Social 12%12%
  • Ceremonial 10%9%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 2%

246 sentences in 72 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister,

Ladies and gentlemen members of the government,

Mr. Vice President of the Council of State,

Ladies and gentlemen,

You reminded us, Mr. SAUVÉ, that we are reconnecting with a tradition that allowed the President of the Republic, along with the government, to gather at the beginning of the year those who make the State function. In the great bodies of the administration of our country - they are represented here - but also in all the central administrations. The high authorities that have become independent and that also participate in a mission of general interest are associated.

There are also representatives of the judiciary at the highest level, military authorities because it is this human ensemble that makes what we call the State function.

You have sent me wishes of hope, and I accept them. I return my own to you with the very words you used: lucidity, commitment, honor for the year 2014.

Through you, Mr. Vice President, I extend my wishes and my gratitude to all civil servants, regardless of their place in the hierarchy, for the work they have accomplished in service to their fellow citizens.

Mr. Vice President, you recalled the importance of the State in our country. You then opened a vast field for our reflection by mentioning RENAN and Marc BLOCH for an "intellectual and moral reform." This will undoubtedly take us more than the year 2014, but we are ready to commit to this path.

France has indeed been built around the State and from the State. According to the beautiful expression of Pierre NORA, the State is "the operator of national identity, the instrument of consciousness, and the hearth of the permanence of the Nation."

The State is indeed the property of all. It generates legitimate multiple demands for solidarity, protection, and intervention. It is always towards it that the French, beyond even their sensitivities, turn when they are destitute, tested, and it is the State that appears as the ultimate recourse in the face of natural disasters. And today, our country is experiencing serious ones that strike populations seeking support and solidarity. In the same way, it is always towards the State that citizens turn when they face economic shocks even though the State is not necessarily at fault and we are in an open economy.

But, at the same time that it is solicited, it is the paradox that we know well in our country, the State itself is judged to be too heavy, too slow, too expensive. It is true that its organization appears increasingly mysterious with its agencies, its operators, its authorities, with the question being asked: but where is the decision made?

It is also true that the entanglement of competencies, with local authorities, seems increasingly indecipherable. Who does what?

It is also undeniable that European construction, which is an opportunity for our country, is seen as an increasingly competing source of law against the State and which can even, if not controlled, appear as a limit to the action of the State.

Thus, we must respond to the questions that our fellow citizens are asking. Who does what in our country? Who is responsible for what? And who pays in the end? And let us agree that the answers are not always provided clearly.

So, the State, in the broadest sense of the term, has two challenges to meet:

The first is its primary function, which is to guarantee the permanence of values in a society that is undergoing technological, economic, demographic, and cultural evolution.

At the forefront of these values is national unity.

The State is its guarantor. This unity allows us to ward off many dangers that other countries may face, not so far from us: fragmentation, separatist threats, communitarianism, but also division between social categories, competition between territories, confrontation between generations.

How to preserve this unity? By respecting the law. It must be the same for all. It must apply everywhere, across all points of the territory, without weakness, without restriction, without exception. Everyone must be able to consider that they are treated in the same way even if their situation is different, and this is equality in access to rights. But it is also a reminder to everyone of their duties. In the face of all attacks on the principles of the Republic, in the face of racism, in the face of anti-Semitism, in the face of public order disturbances caused by undignified provocations, in the face of the humiliations represented by discrimination, I ask the representatives of the State, particularly the prefects, to be vigilant and inflexible. The government, with the Prime Minister and the Minister of the Interior and the Keeper of the Seals, has issued instructions and developed a circular so that no one can use the spectacle for purposes that would be provocation and promotion of openly anti-Semitic theses. This is not a matter of circumstances or a question of individuals. It is primarily the principles of the Republic that must be constantly recalled. Those who must enforce them are those who hold authority. I mentioned the prefects, but I could also have said, in certain circumstances, the directors of central administration and the judiciary, which must uphold the rules in our Republic. Let us also ensure that when penalties have been pronounced, fines also decided, these sanctions are fully executed because it is a matter of the very credibility of justice and the authority of the State.

The unity of the State is also equality between territories.

In the neighborhoods of our cities, this involves a different distribution of resources. This is what the government is doing, particularly for schools: 30% of class openings have been made in neighborhoods that were the most in difficulty. The reform of priority education will, in 2014, be an opportunity to take a new step, notably with a new organization of work for teachers working in these difficult areas.

The distribution of resources, according to the difficulties faced by territories, we must also demonstrate, and it is the task of the government in policies to combat unemployment. I would like to remind you that for future jobs, 100,000 by the end of last year, no diploma requirement was set for young residents of these neighborhoods, meaning that even those who had experienced, and good for them, academic success, diplomas, could not be denied access to future jobs for having made that effort. Similarly, we must have an even stronger presence of public services in these sensitive areas. Next month, a Pôle Emploi agency will open in Clichy-sous-Bois; it was about time. It is indeed curious that until now we have not thought that Pôle Emploi agencies should be located where there is the most unemployment. In this city, which, unfortunately, has experienced particularly painful moments and is recovering, there will be this inauguration. A symbol in Clichy-sous-Bois.

But contrary to many preconceived ideas, it is in the suburbs that we find the strongest dynamics for business creation. The Minister of the City is watching and will watch even more in 2014 to ensure that new incentives can be provided to promote this movement.

Equality between territories also means taking rurality into account. Everyone is aware that there are areas that feel abandoned, populations that believe that because they are far from decision-making centers, they are no longer considered or respected. We must act, and the government will propose to fragile territories contracts that, in the manner of what exists for urban policy, will direct State funding in the areas of housing, health services, or jobs for young people.

Finally, equality means preventing new fractures from appearing in our country. I do not know if the word is still in vogue: "fracture." But today, when it is pronounced, it is notably to mark the digital divide, that is to say, the risk that a part of the population may not fully access new technologies. A plan has been launched "France very high speed for all," involving the State, local authorities, and deposit funds within the framework of the future investment program. I commend its commissioner because it is very important to achieve this result so that everywhere, in a few years, technologies can be offered to both individuals and businesses. It is a condition for the attractiveness of these territories. Here is one of the values of the State: equality.

There is another, and you highlighted it, Mr. Vice President, it is impartiality.

The year 2013 was an opportunity to take a step forward, another step because this movement has been ongoing for years. Today, there are laws on transparency: they have precisely defined conflicts of interest, organized a strict system of recusal to protect all public decisions from suspicion, and finally created the High Authority for Transparency in Public Life. Its president is here, Jean-Louis NADAL. This High Authority will be responsible for receiving, controlling, and sometimes publishing the declarations of patrimonial situation and interests of government members, which will be done shortly, members of Parliament, major local elected officials, cabinet members, and holders of certain public jobs. The High Authority will receive no less than 20,000 declarations. It is a considerable task that awaits you. It must therefore have the means to verify, control, and also sanction. The duty of probity and honesty is indeed one of the foremost obligations imposed on holders of public mandates. And citizens must now know that there will be no tolerance, no protection for those who are meant to serve much more than the State, democracy.

Impartiality is the independence of the judiciary. I am, by the Constitution, its guarantor. The Keeper of the Seals has ensured that individual instructions are ended. From now on, the opinion of the Superior Council of the Judiciary is systematically followed for appointments to the Public Prosecutor's Office. And I have asked the Keeper of the Seals to resume discussions to build a broad parliamentary majority to reform the Superior Council of the Judiciary, as this reform must take a constitutional form.

2014 will indeed be an important year for justice as there will be penal reform and the establishment of new means to combat recidivism. The security of citizens, which is a fundamental right, will be strengthened without the need to reduce or weaken the rule of law.

Finally, there is a value that must also prevail in the organization and functioning of the State, which is secularism.

Secularism is freedom in the private space and neutrality in public service places. But the blur of certain boundaries, the multiplication of organizations that can pursue missions of general interest, may have led to certain questions.

The Council of State, seized by the Defender of Rights, produced, at the end of last year, a particularly thorough but also precise and useful study.

It recalled the demanding rules within the public sphere. It emphasized that this principle also applies to private individuals responsible for managing a public service, such as social security funds, and in a proportionate manner, also to private structures that carry out a mission of general interest as long as there is oversight by a public authority, for example, nurseries.

As for public service users, those of the courts, those of hospitals - they cannot invoke their beliefs to exempt themselves from the common rule. These are the principles that have been recalled and that must be strictly and fully respected.

In the school of the Republic more than anywhere else, secularism must be imposed without restriction. So that students know and understand its meaning, the government wanted, with the Minister of National Education, that the charter of secularism be displayed in all establishments. And that is the case. There remained a question to be resolved, school outings. A circular was published in the middle of 2012; it bears the name of the minister who drafted it, Mr. CHATEL. This circular, the Council of State has admitted, could legally prevent manifestations, by accompanying parents, of their religious convictions. It will therefore continue to be applied by education professionals as it has been until now, that is to say, with discernment and in a calm manner. On this point, a law is not necessary.

Here are the principles, here are the values that unite not only those who serve the State but all the French people who expect the State to ensure that these principles are factors of cohesion, of gathering, and that will allow us to live together.

But the State cannot simply be a factor of cohesion, gathering, and unity. It must also be at the service of the Nation.

Perhaps, as the Vice-President of the Council of State encouraged us, we should take a step back.

I wanted us to engage in a reflection on what France would be like in ten years. Every country must ask itself this question, is asking this question. There are countries for whom this is obvious. In ten years, they will be even more numerous in terms of demographics, even more emerging in terms of economy. The only question they ask themselves is whether the pace of production will keep up with that of the population. There are other countries that simply manage their foreign trade, considering that this is the essence of their independence.

But we, we are France, always with this nagging question that haunts our fellow citizens: can a great country, with a great history, with a beautiful language, with a recognized culture still count in globalization?

Have we perhaps missed our turn? Have we not become spectators of a world that moves faster than we do? To these questions, we must respond that France must always be a leading country in globalization, that it must seek excellence, that it must also sometimes, without arrogance, be able to set an example. Not just in political and diplomatic terms: we do that. Not just in terms of security and defense, where we take our responsibilities, but also in economic, industrial, technological, and cultural terms. We must continue to move forward, because we are in a world where competition and rivalry have now become the norm, where there are no longer borders to protect us from commercial movements, even monetary movements.

We must therefore ensure that we are better prepared, better trained, better supported to win this battle.

That is why the reflection on France in ten years is not simply a prospective exercise in telling ourselves that we will simply be a little more numerous, which is the case, that we will have undoubtedly corrected our public accounts, which is desirable. It is about arming ourselves to be, in ten years, a Nation that will know what its destiny is. The decisions we have to make are not in ten years; they are today. Why ten years? Because it is ultimately the duration in which we can conceive and act. Sometimes, we can conceive and not act until much later. Some act without conceiving; that is possible.

Ten years is the time that allows us to mobilize a country around achievable objectives. Let us beware of overly distant planning. In fifteen years, twenty years, one can promise anything. Sometimes there are programming laws that have had this tendency, where, as if by chance, the credits are reduced at the beginning and generous at the end. Especially when one is no longer there.

We must, over ten years, be able to set objectives that are far enough away to mobilize society and close enough to engage us, even beyond political alternations.

To prepare for its future, France must be clear-sighted. I said it must be proud, but that does not preclude clarity. Clear-sighted about our handicaps; we have them. Public accounts that have been deteriorating for a long time, a structural trade deficit, losses of competitiveness that have accumulated over the last ten years. We also know the inequalities that have widened, the unemployed who will have been out of work for two years, three years without hope of finding a job if we do not put things in order, not on their side because they only want to work, but on the side of those who do not want to employ them because they have been excluded for too long. We know our handicaps, including territorial inequalities. I have mentioned them.

Let us also look at our strengths. The excellence of our research, industrial performance, technological prowess. I do not want to list them all here. We have launched 34 industrial plans to prepare for the future, precisely. Starting from what exists, not inventing a virtual industry.

We also have a dynamic demographic. We are, moreover, one of the European countries that knows this paradox of being rather pessimistic about its future while having particularly vigorous birth rates. But this is part of the contradiction that is only apparent, where the French have confidence in themselves and sometimes doubt the collective. Hence the importance of what we have to do.

The reform of the State must be conceived in this perspective. Not to weaken it but to strengthen it. Reforming the State means making it more efficient. To be efficient, the State must spend less. It is a question of sovereignty for our country if it wants to control its debt, but also an issue of purchasing power if we want to avoid that the recovery comes through additional levies. It is therefore no longer through taxes that we can reduce our deficits but through savings. We will make them wherever possible.

The Prime Minister has launched 60 evaluations of public policies. 50 billion euros in savings must be achieved by 2017. Everyone must take their share: the State, the operators, the social organizations, the local authorities.

Reforming the State means putting it in motion.

Too many decisions still come from Paris while the decentralized services have all the competencies to decide close to our fellow citizens. Too many circulars come detailing the implementation of legislative and regulatory texts, increasing the burden on everyone. Too many financial resources are retained at the Paris level, causing an incomprehensible loss of time. We saw it again with natural disasters. Too much information is requested. I do not know if the figure is true; it still surprised me: 6,000 indicators are requested from decentralized services each year by the offices of the ministries. 6,000! But what do they do with them? Probably statistics, and we look at them with interest. But while we are making statistics, we are not changing reality. What matters is the reality and its measurement. It is this movement of decentralization that we must engage.

The second movement is decentralization by assigning exclusive exercise to each type of local authority, giving municipalities, departments, and regions, within the scope of their exclusive competencies, a power of local adaptation, encouraging them to come closer together.

Finally, the State must guarantee the stability of the rules, particularly fiscal rules. Everyone must know what to expect in the long term regarding the nature of their contribution.

The Constitutional Council, which I received yesterday, reminded me of two principles that I consider binding on the State. The principle of non-retroactivity and the principle of protection of legally acquired situations—which is a legal subtlety allowing for the application of the first principle if it were to be circumvented, which is always possible.

Why? Because if we want companies to invest, if individuals are to embark on projects of equipment and consumption, there must be this framework of stability. In the same way, the responsibility pact that I proposed to companies with countermeasures is to ensure that employment is first considered as the sole priority.

Similarly, the overhaul of taxation, which has been initiated by the Prime Minister, is to ensure that we have this stability of the tax rule for several years.

Reforming the State means simplifying it. It is easy to say, easy to announce shocks. It is another thing to translate them into action. In this regard, I must say that four laws have been developed, three have been voted on allowing recourse to ordinances. On housing construction, on relations between citizens and administrations, and on the life of businesses. 200 simplification measures have been taken, which I will still detail in the coming days. Innovative legal principles have been adopted. I will mention two. The principle of prior trust to eliminate, in certain circumstances, supporting documents. This is a debate that has existed for a long time in administration. Do we trust or do we consider that every citizen is suspect? Let us start from the principle of trust; we will save time. This does not mean that we will not catch those who have committed wrongdoing. But it means that as long as there is a principle of good faith, we save time. The second principle: silence means consent, meaning that a lack of response from the administration will equate to consent. We will also need to give this a full dimension.

I want to continue this task of simplification because it is a social issue. Too many of our fellow citizens who could claim social aid, benefits, give up because of the number of papers to fill out, forms, procedures. For example, for the RSA resumption of activity, which is a good principle, a good reform. We have noticed that a large majority of those who could resort to it ultimately do not take the step. Not because they lack money—they do lack it—but because for them, it is an additional complexity. I have asked the government to work on a simplified application file for the main social benefits (minimum old age, RSA, CMU). All of this must be simple to then be controlled afterwards.

It is also an economic issue. Too many business leaders, faced with too many social declarations, give up hiring. The government—the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Social Affairs—will experiment with a new procedure: a single paper, or a single click, for all declarations.

Simplifying means providing security. I mentioned the fiscal issue. There is a procedure called a rescript, which allows a company or an individual, before embarking on a project, to ask what their tax situation is and if it were to change, they are protected since they have, through this process, clarification of the rules at the time they presented this project. It is a good procedure. This technique should be extended to other areas: in social matters, in urban planning, in environmental matters so that we can create this security.

Finally, there is the reduction of standards. It is unfortunate that the constituted bodies have not met in this form since 2005, but I imagine that all my predecessors would have insisted on the reduction of standards. There are even more arithmetic formulas. There should be two standards that disappear when one standard is created. Proliferation has continued unabated. It seems that the standards themselves have become capable of multiplying without any intervention. I have therefore wished that this reduction of standards could be a priority everywhere. I ask the Council of State, if it is possible in a secular society to undertake this approach, to resolutely continue the work of codification that allows for the repeal of a number of texts that have become obsolete.

There you go, Ladies and Gentlemen, that is what I wanted to tell you on the occasion of these wishes.

You represent here the general interest; you know what it means in a country like ours, which, it is true, is always tempted by particular interests, which tries to understand what each one gains or loses in the collective game and where, at the same time, our fellow citizens are aware of the fact that what we have together is the general interest. You are its representatives here.

To be true to itself, to its missions, to its values, to its principles, the State must change. It must not change for the sake of change; it must change to be useful to the country.

This requires two demands. The first is exemplarity. Not to be in breach of the rules of ethics. Not to be late in the application of the law, not to lack rigor in the management of public funds.

The second demand is its modernization. Not for itself, but for the country.

The State is not an end in itself; it is an instrument at the service of the Nation.

The State must be useful for progress in the missions we have to accomplish but also for society as a whole. For scientific progress, for technological progress. We must believe in progress.

But believing in progress is not a conviction, and even less a religion. Believing in progress is a will. It is a choice. France has always been associated with progress, with the progress of sciences, with social progress, with the progress of rights, with the progress of culture, with the progress of education. And if I had to retain just one word to say what the State is for: for progress. It serves progress obstinately and allows France to maintain its rank, even to take the lead in a number of challenges that we have set for ourselves.

Ladies and Gentlemen, you have chosen to serve the State, and you serve France remarkably. That is why I express to you, along with my most sincere wishes for the new year, my full gratitude.