Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the role of the Constitutional Council, in Paris on January 6, 2014.

France François Hollande · President of France

6 January 2014 · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed the Constitutional Council in Paris on January 6, 2014, during the traditional New Year ceremony, reflecting on the Council's 2013 activities and its constitutional role.
Main themes
Constitutional Council's role and activity, constitutionality review of legislation, rule of law and fundamental rights, secularism and constitutional principles, electoral disputes and campaign rules, tax fraud legislation and proportionality, marriage equality and social evolution, verbosity and quality of legislation, priority question of constitutionality, 55th anniversary of the French Constitution, separation of powers, personal freedoms and human dignity
Duration
~12 min
42nd percentile
Words
1,440
42nd percentile
Sentences
65
43rd percentile
Readability
43
44th percentile
Grade
12.4
50th percentile
Syntax
3.03
52nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
50th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 83%83%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

65 sentences in 32 paragraphs

Madam Minister of Justice,

Mr. President of the Constitutional Council,

Ladies and gentlemen members,

I thank you for the wishes you have addressed to me and, beyond myself, to all those who exercise public responsibility, at a moment that you have chosen to qualify as difficult.

I return these wishes in turn, to salute the institution that is yours, and the role, the place, that it now has in our country. To uphold the Constitution and its fundamental principles.

Beyond these principles, it is the stability of the law and the guarantee that must be given to our fellow citizens that they will not see their most fundamental rights called into question.

Your wishes were accompanied by recommendations that I will not fail to convey to the Government.

I want to return to your activity. As you reminded us, Mr. President, the year 2013 was particularly busy.

There were electoral disputes that added to your traditional activity. From this perspective, the year 2013 is of a particular, exceptional nature. We must also ensure that these disputes are fewer in number and that we can, in this regard, have clearer rules. I have raised this, notably with the President of the National Commission for Campaign Accounts and Political Life, so that we make efforts not to create doubts or misunderstandings for candidates.

But, above all, in the year 2013, you were the judge of the constitutionality of almost all the laws that were voted on.

The opposition, as you said, is - in this regard - constant, regardless of the alternations. And you yourself believe that you must go beyond the means that are presented. This means that your control is both general and thorough. This should not sadden the legislator, but lead them to be even more vigilant.

I also want to note that your task has become increasingly difficult, as your last decision of December 29 on the finance law contained 155 considerations.

I draw several lessons from this. The first is that your control is indeed thorough. But above all, that the law, and notably the finance law, can be excessively verbose, especially when it contains amendments that are sometimes drafted in haste and in the final moments of the debate, which further burden the text.

You have also, beyond this control, to consider laws that have passed. This is the priority question of constitutionality. It is a considerable success, much greater than what could have been imagined by those who are the authors of this reform.

2013, as you also reminded us, Mr. President, was the year of the 55th anniversary of our Constitution and therefore of the Constitutional Council. I want to commend your initiative to make this ceremony - which could have been mundane, a republican gathering event - which is quite rare in our public life - and which allowed a number of personalities who had held eminent ministerial positions to come together.

This event also allowed me to salute the plasticity of our Fundamental Law, to recall the principles that unite us and that are inscribed in the constitutional block: equality before the law, personal freedoms, respect for human dignity, secularism, and the separation of powers. And, these values, these principles, you are their scrupulous guardians. You made it a point in 2013 to demonstrate this once again.

I take a few examples. Your decision of February 13, 2013, proclaims that the principle of secularism implies the neutrality of the State, the free exercise of religions, the absence of remuneration for ministers of worship. But, it notes that the Constitution did not intend to call into question the specific provisions prior to its entry into force applicable in Alsace and Moselle. Your interpretation of the law has thus reinforced the principle of secularism without calling into question its exception.

Several times in 2013, you reminded the legislator of the strength of the rule of law, and you did so recently with the law relating to the fight against tax fraud and serious crime. Of course, you are as committed as we are to combating behaviors that aim to evade taxable income, that is to say, to exempt oneself from the common contribution whose necessity is recalled by the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen. But, as you perfectly pointed out, there are proposed means that can be excessive, notably the 96-hour police custody.

Similarly, you deemed that the requirement of proportionality of penalties, which stems from Article 8 of the Declaration of 1789, opposes sanctions in tax control that are out of proportion to the seriousness of the offenses punished. Here too, let us avoid creating a climate of suspicion towards taxpayers in our fight against fraud, who must have the trust of the State. Let us also avoid weakening the attractiveness of our country.

You have also ensured to accompany the evolutions of society in respect of the law, and you highlighted this, Mr. President, regarding the opening of marriage to same-sex couples, reminding that mayors were responsible for executing the laws and regulations and that they could not invoke their convictions to refuse to celebrate a marriage. You thus ensured the effectiveness of the law - which, by the way, is now applied without creating any particular disorder.

The year 2013 saw the adoption of the law on the transparency of public life, which is an important text for our democracy as it will establish a declaration of patrimonial and interest situation for elected officials and for the senior civil service, and which created an institution that will be endowed with real means of control to ensure this verification.

You nevertheless corrected this text in order to ensure the strengthening of guarantees of probity and integrity of public office holders, while also ensuring the protection of private life.

Finally, in 2013, an important reform came into force: it concerns the shared initiative referendum. The Constitutional Council will play a role in this new procedure as it will be responsible for controlling the object and the conformity of the proposed law to the Constitution and will therefore rule on the admissibility of the initiative. The procedure is eminently complex, but there too, there can be surprises.

For the year 2014, there will also be bills that will necessarily be submitted to you. One concerning the territorial organization of our country and the bill ending the accumulation of parliamentary mandates with a local executive function, which should normally be adopted in February. This is an important text that will undoubtedly change many operations in our democratic life.

I also know that we will have to resume, and Madam Minister of Justice will have the responsibility, the debate on the constitutional reform concerning the independence of the Superior Council of the Judiciary, its role in the appointment of the hierarchy of the judiciary and the public prosecutor. We will need to build a broad parliamentary majority since this is an essential constitutional reform if we want this council to be truly independent.

2014 will also be the shock of simplification, and you were right, Mr. President, to ask us to simplify first what we produce, but you are also, in a certain way, responsible for simplification since you ensure the intelligibility and accessibility of the law.

In the first Council of Ministers of the year, I asked for fewer laws and shorter laws.

You also had strong words to demand that Article 62 of the Constitution be imposed, as is indeed stated in the text of the fundamental law, on all public authorities. The drafting of bills must respect your jurisprudential recommendations and the hierarchy of norms. This is an obligation that the Constitution imposes on all public authorities and that must not be overlooked by reintroducing provisions that have already been censured.

Ladies and gentlemen members of the Council, you are the undisputed interpreters of the Constitution. It is up to you to state the real constitutional law and to make this law predictable so that no one is under the impression that there are fluctuating jurisprudences.

There was a time when the decisions of the Constitutional Council were highly contested, criticized. There was even a suspicion of a government of judges when it was not a politicization of the institution itself. Today, note that there is rather silence, which I do not interpret as restraint, but as consideration for the institution that is yours and a deep respect for your decisions.

It is this message of confidence that I wish to renew to you once again this year on the occasion of this ceremony of wishes.

Thank you.