Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the state of public finances, the restoration of budgetary balance, and the role of the Court of Auditors, in Paris on September 7, 2012.

France François Hollande · President of France

7 September 2012 · Palais Cambon (Court of Auditors), Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed the Court of Auditors in Paris on September 7, 2012, to discuss France's public finances, structural deficit, and the court's oversight role.
Main themes
Public finances, budgetary balance, Court of Auditors oversight, structural deficit reduction, public debt, fiscal responsibility, democratic accountability, economic crisis in France and Europe, transparency in public spending, social accounts imbalance
Duration
~24 min
75th percentile
Words
2,933
75th percentile
Sentences
148
80th percentile
Readability
45
49th percentile
Grade
11.8
42nd percentile
Syntax
2.96
43rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
57th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 44%44%
  • Institutional 40%40%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

148 sentences in 46 paragraphs

Madam,

Ministers,

Mr. President of the Court,

Mr. Attorney General,

Ladies,

Gentlemen Presidents,

Ladies and gentlemen magistrates,

It is with a mix of emotion and pride that I return to the Court of Auditors, the Palais Cambon. Thirty-two years ago, I was welcomed here as an auditor, and in this very room, I took an oath promising to conduct myself in all things as a worthy and loyal magistrate. I have tried to adhere to this line of conduct.

I come before you today as President of the Republic to emphasize the major role that your institution plays, which, as the President of the Court reminded us, has been significantly modernized as its oversight has expanded and become more precise.

I also want to take this opportunity to greet your new Attorney General, Gilles JOHANET, on the occasion of his installation. I know him well. He served in the 5th chamber and had eyes for social security that were both tender and vigilant. He has not changed, just as you have not changed, dear colleagues, as if the Court protects you from the wear and tear of time, but your institution has changed.

The Court of Auditors has the eminent mission in our Republic to independently verify the use of public money, that is to say, the resources of citizens, their property, the product of their labor, and their efforts of solidarity. The French people know this, and they expect a lot from the oversight authorities and from you, and they are grateful for your reports and your vigilance. Your role is to ensure transparency, without which accountability does not exist. The Nation needs independence and impartiality for democratic oversight. The Nation also needs truth and will for action; these are the two principles that guide me as I take on the responsibility of the Presidency of the Republic.

Truth, because the crisis in which France and Europe find themselves is long, too long, and deep. To overcome it, we must first understand it with relevance. This crisis is partly global, but it is also, and above all, European. It is exacerbated by our weaknesses: weak growth when it is not nonexistent, excessive financialization of our economies, degraded competitiveness, and very high public debt, too high.

Mr. President of the Court, you have once again reminded us, and the report requested from the Court of Auditors was clear in its conclusions: the situation of our public finances is concerning, to say the least. A few figures attest to this: in 2001, our deficit represented 1.6% of GDP; ten years later, this same deficit reached 5.2% of GDP, or 100 billion euros. Public debt exceeds 1,700 billion euros, or nearly 90% of GDP. Ten years ago, it was less than 60%. Interest charges amount to 50 billion euros, becoming the second largest budget of the Nation. As for social accounts, they are structurally imbalanced, and social debt has continued to grow. 150 billion euros for the general scheme alone, without the corrective mechanisms being used despite the mandates of the law. I fully agree with the terms chosen by the Court of Auditors itself in its audit. The deficit of social accounts amounts to financing current transfer expenditures through debt, that is to say, through future generations, and this is an anomaly.

How did we get here? Part of this financial drift is certainly attributable to the crisis, but the Court of Auditors has also pointed out: the crisis does not explain everything. Certainly, it can be held responsible for a third of the debt due to the collapse of revenues it has caused, but the degradation of our public accounts is largely of a structural nature. France had a much stronger structural deficit before the crisis than the European averages, and this is still true during the crisis.

The structural deficit today stands at 4% of GDP, compared to 3.2% on average in the eurozone and 0.8% in Germany; that is the situation. It is due to a high level of public spending and the multiplication of derogatory tax provisions. This is the truth that must guide us in our actions. But this truth calls for a firm will if we want to face the situation together and take the necessary measures. It is my duty; I want to preserve the quality of France's signature with respect to the markets to finance our debt at the lowest possible interest rates, which is the case today since the State is financing itself at historically low rates. But can we be sure that this situation can last? We also have this duty to regain the necessary margins to prepare for the future. We are therefore faced with an imperative to rebalance public accounts. I confirm here the commitment made by France to bring the public deficit down to 3% by the end of 2013. This will be the most significant budgetary effort in 30 years. To take the calculations that the Court provided two months ago, this will represent a structural effort of 1.6 points of GDP, or a little more than 30 billion euros, in terms of expenditure cuts and additional revenues.

The current economic slowdown makes achieving this objective even more difficult but makes the success of this exercise even more necessary. The government has already taken corrective measures in the amending finance law, and it is constructing the finance law for 2013 with this objective in mind, while keeping in mind the recommendations of the Court, that is to say, respecting the trajectory of deficit reduction to ensure and preserve the credibility of France's commitments. Once the 2013 milestone is passed, once the effort is made, then the path towards balancing the accounts by 2017 will be greatly facilitated. This is a battle that is being waged, and it must be fought on all fronts. It will mobilize the State, local authorities, social administrations, businesses, and households. France will recover through an effort that must be justly shared. Everyone will give according to their means and receive according to their needs. This is the principle of the tax reform that I have proposed to the French people, and of which a first step will be taken as early as next year, notably with the harmonization of taxation between capital income and labor income. All provisions of the bill will be weighed in due time. The finance law will ensure, as much as possible, growth and, as much as imperative, equity. That is why I refuse, along with the government, a general and undifferentiated increase in taxes on households, which would degrade their purchasing power. Again, those who have the most will have to pay more.

Similarly, regarding businesses, we will need to distribute the tax burden between SMEs and large groups in order to collect better without harming competitiveness. But beyond revenues, the effort will come from strict control of expenditures. For every euro spent, we must ask ourselves the simple question: is it useful? Is it essential? Is it not done by others at another level? Can we make it simpler? Can we make it more efficient? I take this commitment here, before you, magistrates of the Court of Auditors, but also before the French people, that expenditures excluding debt and pension charges will be stabilized in value, which will allow for savings of more than 10 billion euros in 2013 alone compared to the trend. This will require a method; it will no longer be the so-called RGPP method, which, due to its mechanical and purely accounting nature, has shown its limits, both in terms of efficiency for the administration and in terms of acceptability for the agents.

I propose, in accordance with a suggestion from the Court, a new approach. This method will first take into account all intervention expenditures by questioning the articulation between the various mechanisms, the number of which, as you have reminded us, exceeds 1,300. This method will advance the modernization of the State and the deepening of decentralization together. This method will lead each stakeholder in public power—State, local authorities, social administrations—to fully assume their responsibilities related to their area of competence.

A government seminar on the modernization of public action will be held at the end of this month under the authority of the Prime Minister. At its conclusion, an inter-ministerial roadmap will be developed on the State's priority missions. The idea I have of the State, and which can unite us, is that of a strategic State, capable of foresight and anticipation, a protective State when it comes to the essentials, and finally, a State that guarantees social, territorial, and environmental cohesion.

This inter-ministerial roadmap will be followed by a phase of consultation that will be completed by the end of November, at the central level within the framework of the great social conference and at the territorial level under the authority of the prefects. All civil servants responsible for implementing the management of public goods and common resources will be involved.

Regarding what are called partnership policies, those that the State shares with local authorities and major social institutions, I am thinking particularly of housing, vocational training, and transportation. We will not modernize them if each continues to work on its own. It is together that public actors must imagine policies that can then be implemented coherently. That is why I call for a clear distribution of competencies within the framework of the new stage of decentralization. I expect two advances: the first is to lay the foundations for a relationship of trust between the State and local authorities regarding the contractualization of resources. And the second advance is to clarify the roles assigned to the State and each level of local authorities; enough with the overlaps, enough with the additions. It is legitimate and even necessary for local authorities to govern themselves freely and decide for themselves on their projects, but their expenditures must be evaluated. The efficiency of management must be assessed, and the service provided to citizens must be regularly measured. This applies to all public actors as long as an appropriate taxation is dedicated to local authorities.

I welcome with great interest your proposal to involve the Court of Auditors in the preparation of this new stage of decentralization. The observations and proposals that the regional chambers draw from their audits of local authorities will usefully inform the government's and elected officials' reflections. I invite you to make recommendations as soon as possible within the framework of a specific report.

The recovery of accounts is an imperative for France, but it is also a commitment to Europe. Europe has been experiencing a crisis of confidence and a crisis of growth for four years, one leading to the other. Important decisions have been made in recent months at the European Council, and even more recently at the Central Bank level. But these decisions, both to support growth and to stabilize markets, do not exempt us from putting our respective countries' management in order.

Europe bears the burden of the deficit that some countries have allowed to drift and that Europe has not been able to address at the right time and with the expected intensity.

Today, painful efforts are being demanded of peoples, without mechanisms for stability being implemented and without controls being put in place, allowing for the release of funds.

The time has come to close this phase for the countries that are in the most difficulty and to open another, that of growth and budgetary seriousness. This is the global pact that will be submitted to Parliament in the coming days. After the ratification of the budgetary treaty, which the Constitutional Council—I salute its President—has deemed compliant with the constitution.

After this ratification, the government will submit to Parliament an organic law that will set rules that France itself decides to impose on itself regarding budgetary discipline. This law will bring three major innovations: The first is to determine a medium-term structural balance objective, in other words, to achieve balance by the end of the legislature, in accordance with commitments.

The second innovation is to introduce automatic correction mechanisms if deviations appear from the trajectories. But also taking into account the economic situation.

Finally, the last innovation, the draft law establishes a High Council for Public Finances, that is to say, an unquestionable authority responsible for ensuring the monitoring and application of these budgetary rules. But also to verify the assumptions on which budgets are constructed.

If Parliament decides, for it will have the final word, based on the project that will be submitted to it next October, the High Council will be placed alongside the Court of Auditors. It will be presided over by the First President. It will include, at least according to the proposed formula, 4 magistrates from the Court and 4 qualified individuals appointed by Parliament. Its mission will be twofold: on one hand, to verify the assumptions on which the finance laws are based. Too many governments have often, in the past, allowed themselves to be guided by excessively optimistic forecasts that have most often been proven wrong. On the other hand, its other mission will be to pronounce on the respect of the objective stated in the public finance programming laws.

This new institution, this High Council, will be for the Republic a guarantee of credibility, independence, and transparency. The fact that it will sit here, alongside the Court of Auditors, and that the magistrates, if the legislator decides, will be strongly represented, is a pledge of legitimacy.

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I began my remarks by recalling my history, but above all by expressing my gratitude. The gratitude of the Republic towards the Court of Auditors.

But the First President having raised questions, or at least highlighted imperfections, and called for corrections, fulfilling his duty, before the Attorney General makes requisition.

I therefore want, as much as possible, in these final words, to respond to this request for clarification. First, the Court will continue to fully exercise the missions entrusted to it, I would say, since always, and then more recently by the texts of the Republic.

Control of all administrations and all institutions, including the accounts of the Presidency of the Republic, but soon, those of Parliament. This would be a good evolution that would also protect Parliament from a number of prejudices that often divert the voter from the respect they owe to the elected representatives of the Republic.

In general, the Court of Auditors will ensure, as much as possible, the control of the use of every euro raised by the taxes of the French, and, as you already do, by their voluntary contributions.

It is true that the constitutional revision of 2008 extended the Court's competence to all evaluations of public policies. I ask the government to consult you as often as possible during this period when we have to make efforts for recovery, so that you can provide it with all the recommendations for the proper use of public funds.

I have also heard the call for more transparency and more reliability. I share this requirement. It is therefore important that the principle of certification of the accounts of public health establishments, established by the law of 2009, be respected and that the Court occupies its rightful place in this application. I again ask for something so simple that it should already have been done, for the government to implement the law and publish the decrees.

Likewise, I wish for the certification of the accounts of local authorities to be accelerated, at least on a voluntary basis. So that these first experiences can then be generalized.

You have also asked for my opinion on the responsibility of public managers, and you have raised a subject that, beyond the role of the Court of Auditors or the Budgetary Discipline Court, even concerns ethics, the exemplary nature of public actors. The texts will therefore be modified to allow the Budgetary Discipline Court to broaden its intervention, both for incriminations and for the ordonnateurs.

I will again examine, with interest, the reform proposals that the Court will formulate. This is an element of moralization of public life, to which I am very attached.

Mr. First President,

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

The main authorities of the State are here, the magistrates, the people of the accounts, are gathered here. I wanted to take this opportunity during this solemn hearing to, beyond the Court, tell the French that the objectives that are ours, for the recovery of public finances, are called the control of spending, the reform of levies, and the reduction of deficits. Courageous decisions on public accounts are being made, bold tax reforms will be proposed, changes in the organization and levels of public action are planned. A new act of decentralization, of state reform will be undertaken. These are not constraints that we impose on ourselves, to comply with some European or international obligation. It is not to submit ourselves to the market. It is, on the contrary, to free ourselves from it. These are levers that we use to act more effectively, more justly for our fellow citizens. And simply with the perspective of recovery, of justice. But above all of mastering our destiny and preserving what we hold most dear, namely, our social model, but above all our sovereignty. Being serious in the management of public accounts, being bold in the necessary reforms for administrations and for the State, being just in the levies, is ultimately to serve the future of France.

Thank you.