Joint press conference of Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, and Mr. Mario Monti, President of the Council of Ministers of the Italian Republic, on the situation in the Eurozone and Franco-Italian relations, in Rome on September 4, 2012.

France François Hollande · President of France

4 September 2012 · Joint press conference of the President of France and the President of the Council of Ministers of Italy · Rome, Italy

Context
Hollande met with Italian PM Monti in Rome on September 4, 2012, to discuss Eurozone economic governance, bilateral relations, and the Syrian crisis.
Main themes
Eurozone stability and economic governance, Franco-Italian bilateral relations, European growth strategy, sovereign debt markets, Syrian crisis and political transition, high-speed rail Turin-Lyon, European Central Bank independence, EU institutional coordination, post-Assad transition planning
Duration
~37 min
88th percentile
Words
4,396
88th percentile
Sentences
165
84th percentile
Readability
48
56th percentile
Grade
13.0
57th percentile
Syntax
3.22
74th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
22nd percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

165 sentences in 36 paragraphs

Mr. Mario MONTI -- It was an interesting, fruitful, and entirely positive meeting. We were accompanied by our foreign ministers, ministers of economy, finance, and European affairs. We were also able to make observations. We verified and noted once again the affinity of our viewpoints regarding bilateral relations, regarding the climate that should be restored in order to revive the European economy within the stability of the euro zone, and regarding a number of particularly delicate aspects at the international level.

Regarding bilateral relations, we are pleased that a number of complex bilateral issues have been resolved, thanks to the goodwill of our two countries. The next intergovernmental bilateral summit has been scheduled. It will take place in France this year, and Mr. President HOLLANDE will confirm this to you.

I am personally happy to learn that this summit will take place in Lyon, and in this way, I believe we will give even more concrete signs that our two countries intend to realize the high-speed train from Turin to Lyon.

We discussed in depth the economic situation of the Eurozone, and I can say that since the election of President François HOLLANDE and therefore from our first meeting, we have noted the affinity, the identity of our viewpoints. We have acted in a coordinated manner, and we have found that we have the same objectives in pushing the European Union towards a path of greater growth without inflation and that does not rely on the imbalance of public finances. We have also developed a synergy between us. As for the suggestions for stability regarding the euro zone, like everyone else, we are currently witnessing what is happening operationally in the different states of the European Union, the European Central Bank in its full independence, for example, and the national governments with their policies.

Finally, the activity is very intense in order to implement the deliberations of the European Council of June 28 and 29. So today, each of us is engaged on this path, on the path of economic and financial policy, each in our own country. The task is not easy at the moment, but we are today more confident as we see that the Eurozone shares this vision that President François HOLLANDE and I hold dear. We have discussed this several times with Mrs. MERKEL, with President RAJOY, and of course with the hierarchy of the community institutions: President VAN ROMPUY for the Council, President BARROSO for the Commission. It is with particular attention that we have also focused on what is happening these days and what is currently being developed regarding the stabilization of markets, sovereign securities, and sovereign bonds of the Eurozone, and we have contributed together, and we are pleased because this has been, in my opinion, an important step on the intellectual and political level, namely the realization that doing one's homework is necessary but not sufficient. It is also necessary that as a country makes progress in its economic policy, there are guiding principles established at the European level. At the same time, there must be recognition from the European Union. We must take into account how the markets operate to ensure that barriers and obstacles do not persist in relation to disparities and differentials that would be completely disconnected from economic reality.

I am sure that President HOLLANDE and I, our two governments have ensured this within the framework of the community institutions to fully realize what we have conceived in Brussels.

I conclude by saying that among the various international themes that have been addressed with the help of our foreign ministers, we have also raised the issue of Syria, and this with increased concern for the evolution of the Syrian crisis, which has displaced hundreds of thousands of people and caused an ever-increasing number of victims. It is necessary to go beyond the deadlock currently faced by the Security Council. We continue to collaborate with all our partners to facilitate a phase of genuine political transition. The appointment of Mr. BRAHIMI is a positive development, and we agree to support these efforts in light of the increasingly precarious situation of Mr. ASSAD's regime, weakened by increasingly evident high-level absences. We have begun consultations on the post-ASSAD period. Italy, last week in Rome, hosted a meeting of the "Core group" to lay the groundwork for the development of a common strategy.

We reaffirm our exhortation. It is about strengthening the cohesion of all democratic forces in Syria for the transition, and in this sense, we particularly appreciate the national pact and the common political vision for the transition. These are two files, as you know, that were approved by the opposition conference in Cairo on July 2 and 3 under the auspices of the Arab League.

It is with a strong sense of gratitude, sympathy, and true friendship that I now invite Mr. President HOLLANDE to speak.

THE PRESIDENT -- Ladies and gentlemen, this is the third time since I became President of the Republic that I am here in Italy and in Rome. It is a sign of the trusting, serious, and at the same time strong relationship that we have been able to establish between our two countries, Italy and France, and between Mario MONTI and myself, and once again, we have demonstrated this. We find ourselves in convergence on the major issues affecting the Eurozone, the construction of Europe, its future, but also on the main challenges of current international affairs. We share the same concern, that of growth within stability. We have the same will to advance Europe on a path that I call that of solidarity-based integration, but we also have relations between our two countries that require us to meet, and that will be the case in Lyon at the beginning of December. It will be the 30th Franco-Italian bilateral summit. The first took place between François MITTERRAND and Giovanni SPADOLINI, so we are in continuity, and at the same time, situations have changed, personalities are no longer the same, but the friendship has remained.

We also discussed the situation of the Eurozone, and we have three steps: the first step, we are there, is to implement the conclusions of the European Council of June 28 and 29. We worked on this together, and we have had a direction to address the issues of the Eurozone, both for the growth aspect and for the stability aspect, which must now be fully applied and implemented. That is the first step.

The second step that we now have to take is to resolve the question of Greece, which has been pending for months and which, after the troika's report, will allow the European Council on October 18 and 19 to continue, at least that is the hope I have, as the Greeks have demonstrated the credibility of their policy, so that we can continue the plan as it was intended to keep Greece in the Eurozone.

We will also always have in this second step to address the question of Spain, as Spain has requested the recapitalization of its banks and that Spain will want to participate, if it wishes, in such or such program. It is at the European Council that we must find solutions, and we are on the verge of making them appear for Greece, Spain, and thus move to the third step, which will take place at the end of the year and which will be the banking union and the deepening of the economic and monetary union. Europeans must know that we are committed to this process and that we are addressing the questions that were posed to us a few months ago: the growth pact, stability, intervention mechanisms that allow support for states that, if well managed, can have interest rates that are deemed excessive, finding definitive solutions for Greece, responding to requests, particularly from Spain, and moving towards deepening and the banking union that is essential if we want to establish supervision and support.

This is the meaning of what we are doing, and that is why I am very attached to these steps being clearly outlined and taken by the upcoming European Councils, as the conclusions of the European Council of June 29 will be fully implemented. It is true, and I have heard once again what the President of the Italian Council of Ministers said, it is true that there are interest rates that are too high in a number of countries on sovereign debt, even though all the conditions exist to demonstrate the quality of the plans that have been implemented and are being applied in the countries concerned, particularly in Italy. So it is the role of all those who are meant to intervene in the Eurozone to contribute to this, and notably the European Central Bank, which will once again make decisions in accordance with what its President has already said, and I do not want to comment further on this.

We also discussed, and I thank President MONTI, a number of international situations, first Syria. We know what is happening there, massacres, a regime or more precisely a clan that is motivated only by its own future, that is, the preservation of its interests even as it knows it is condemned. We must therefore promote political transition. That is why I ardently wished for an alternative government to be formed.

At the same time, Foreign Minister Laurent FABIUS has, at the United Nations Security Council, allowed for an awareness of what is happening there and for humanitarian aid to be provided, and we must also mobilize all assistance.

Finally, we must be attentive to the fact that, as soon as there are refugees, as there are areas that can be cleared, we provide the necessary protection and support as soon as the request is made to us.

Finally, there is a subject we addressed, which is the dialogue between Europe and the Mediterranean, what is called the "5+5," a complicated formula that allows us to understand that on both sides of the Mediterranean we can come together, and precisely at the beginning of October, Mario MONTI and I will be present at a summit organized in this framework to clearly mark our commitment to this dialogue between the two shores of the Mediterranean. That is why, once again, I truly appreciate the quality of the relationships we have, the relations that exist between our two governments represented here, and for the issues that concern France and Italy, we will address them at the Lyon summit, as well as for the questions of the Eurozone, its deepening, its consolidation, its integrity, we find ourselves on common positions. Fortunately, we are not just the two of us on the same positions, and we are indeed, through all these meetings that we have multiplied, Mario MONTI and I in recent weeks with Chancellor Angela MERKEL, in very great convergence so that we can indeed resolve, during the upcoming European Councils, the questions that concern all Europeans because we must, once and for all, provide answers for the Eurozone. If we want growth to return, we have taken measures in this direction, if we want to instill confidence, then we need to ensure that there is no doubt about the Eurozone. I believe that by the time of the European Council in October, you know that there are a number of deadlines approaching, the Karlsruhe Court, knowing what the Spanish request will be, if it comes, the troika's report on Greece, all these elements will allow us to act, after an Eurogroup, at the European Council on October 18 and 19. These are the steps, they will be for Europeans as many responsibilities, but I believe we have well prepared them.

Mr. Mario MONTI - Thank you, Mr. President.

QUESTION -- Hello Mr. President, I work for TGA. This is a question I address to both of you, and the issue I would like to raise concerns both countries, it is unemployment, although the figures differ from country to country. President MONTI will meet with political parties, but I know that President HOLLANDE has also made commitments during the electoral campaign, and the unemployment rate is very concerning. What do you both plan to do to reverse the trend and to realize the words that have been heard repeatedly, which are the words of growth?

Mr. Mario MONTI - As far as Italy is concerned, I did not make any promises during my electoral campaign regarding employment, as you know, and yet my government is well aware that the issue of employment and unemployment is a central problem for the Italian economy and society. I thank you for your question, as it gives me the opportunity to emphasize the fact that, on the European level, what we discussed today, President HOLLANDE and I, apparently rarely mentions the word "employment," but all our reflections are aimed at creating conditions for better employment because if we talk about growth, we also talk about jobs for all, as a country taken individually could only achieve results in an illusory manner. Therefore, if we talk about stability, we are talking about something without which the mechanisms of the economy break down. If we talk about the "spread," and the Central Bank is working on that, we are talking about mechanisms that ultimately serve to prevent the treasuries of states and companies from paying high interest rates, which would worsen the situation of competitiveness. Of course, growth is a great phenomenon that requires a series of necessary and conducive conditions and also requires that the different stakeholders, the different economic actors, each make their efforts. So, as far as Italy is concerned, I can say that we have implemented a series of targeted reforms aimed at making growth easier, simplifications, liberalizations, labor market reform. We have also implemented reforms that, if they had been designed a few years ago, would have ensured that today young people would have worked more, such as the pension reform practically, and tomorrow, as you just mentioned, a cycle of meetings will begin, meetings with social partners on both sides of the labor market. These meetings aim in particular to draw the attention of social partners to the dynamics of production and competitiveness. With the help of Parliament, the government is constantly trying to improve the productivity of the country as a whole, but at the same time, it is necessary for business representatives to also increase their efforts. The time has come to work together to create jobs.

THE PRESIDENT - Europe is marked by a high level of unemployment, too high, unbearable, which exceeds 10% of the active population in most countries, if not more, as in Spain, so there is a responsibility. And it is because Europeans have been aware of this that, at the European Council at the end of June, there was this growth pact that both mobilized funding and marked a shift, a new direction. Our will is to implement this growth pact as quickly as possible, so that the funds that have been released, 120 billion euros, can be mobilized everywhere for projects that can be immediately useful for growth and for employment. There are also structural growth policies in each of our countries, we are committed to this regarding France. And it will take the necessary time, but that is the course that has been set. Then, if we want growth and thus to fight against unemployment, we must ensure that Europe is seen as a stable area where confidence can return; it has been lost for a time. And for confidence to be there, we need budgetary seriousness; Italy has proven this, France will demonstrate it once again with the finance bill we will present at the end of the month because it is budgetary seriousness that allows us to reduce debt and give credibility. I remind you that France can borrow in the short term for its debt at rates close to zero. Just yesterday, a number of funds were raised at negative interest rates in the short term. We are aware of this privilege, which is not, unfortunately, shared by all, but if we want to maintain this ability to borrow at low rates, we must show seriousness and give confidence. Then, if we want growth for employment, we must have competitive economies. This does not mean austerity; competitiveness means the ability we can give our companies to face large markets with conditions that allow them to win the competition through innovation, research, product quality, cost control; all of this must be engaged for growth. But, it is true, we cannot wait; there is urgency, three million unemployed in France, 14 consecutive months of rising unemployment. I have been president for three and a half months; I take France as it is; I do not have to invent figures; they are there; they are stocks! When I say stocks, it is actually a sum of people who are currently seeking employment, so there is an urgency to intervene. And that is why, regarding France, I have asked the government to act quickly, especially for young people through these future jobs, the generation contract, in short, what I presented during the campaign because I had the chance to campaign to be elected afterward. But it is true that everyone must do what they think is most useful in their country, but we will only get out of this together. Because that is also the lesson; it is Europe that must show that it can be a zone of growth, competitiveness, stability, and confidence, and thus of jobs. That is the challenge we share.

QUESTION - You just mentioned the avenues of the upcoming budget law. You are welcomed in a country where Mr. MONTI has committed to a drastic austerity plan, notably through cuts in public employment. Is this an example for you to follow? Is this what we should expect in the next budget for France, or on the contrary, will you not go down this path?

THE PRESIDENT - But the situation of our countries is not the same. Here, in Italy, there was, I say there was, because the efforts have already borne fruit, a level of public debt that was particularly high. Even if the deficit was less significant in Italy than in France. Everyone must provide their answers; for us, it will be reflected in the next budget for the year 2013, there will be stability in public spending and stability in the number of public servants and a reduction in the deficit.

QUESTION - A question for both presidents. You have noted several times that you wish for a complete application, a full implementation of the decisions of the European Council in June. The president of the ECB spoke yesterday of severe conditions for anyone who may request assistance from the European rescue mechanism due to the "spread." Do you think we should stick to the decisions of the European Council according to which additional measures would not be requested, and do you think that the decision on conditionalities belongs to the Eurogroup, that is to say, to the government that finances the rescue fund, or to the ECB?

And finally, in case the Troika's report on Greece is not negative, do you agree to give more time to Athens to meet the commitments made with the Troika? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - Regarding the ECB, I think the best comment I can make is to not make one, because my position is that of the European Council of June 28 and 29, which is to allow there to be, through the stability mechanisms that we know, and which will be confirmed once the Karlsruhe court has rendered its verdict, and for the European Central Bank to intervene together. It is up to the European Central Bank to set its orientation; it has already given it through the statements of its president, the principles, and for the European mechanisms to intervene quickly, as soon as they are called upon. After that, the conditions can only be set by those who are in charge when it comes to a European mechanism. Regarding Greece, I indeed consider that if the Troika's report goes in the right direction, that is to say, confirms that efforts have been made, that others will come, that there are credibilities that have been demonstrated, then, without the need to release funds, it can be planned to apply the recovery plan and thus keep Greece in the eurozone.

Mr. Mario MONTI - While President HOLLANDE was answering this question, I listened to him with particular attention because I wanted to see if by chance I could disagree with him on a few points. But there is no point on which I do not agree with President François HOLLANDE.

QUESTION - Mr. President, Moody's has just downgraded the outlook for the European Union from stable to negative and does not rule out downgrading this rating itself in the medium term. How do you interpret this view of the situation and more generally the multiplication of bilateral summits in Europe, like the one you are participating in today? Is it really likely to reassure the markets? Are these summits sufficient, and in a way, are they not a bit worrying or even counterproductive?

THE PRESIDENT - If I were to answer yes, you realize, what would I have done since this morning? And I would take the first plane out of here, but I will stay a little longer. No, I consider that these bilateral meetings are very useful, provided they lead to conclusions during the Eurogroup and European Council meetings. That is what I have pointed out. It is not simply about having discussions or talks or meeting on vague principles. We have to prepare decisions. European Councils are meant to make decisions; at least, that is how I see it. We are gathered so that, very quickly, decisions can be made once a number of obstacles that are still in our way or questions have been lifted. I mentioned the verdict of the Karlsruhe court or the Troika's report on Greece.

So, once these events have taken place, we will have to make the right decisions. We have prepared them. As I had prepared them with Mrs. MERKEL regarding Greece and other issues, as Mario MONTI has done with other heads of state and government. I myself was in Spain a few days ago.

Then, should we not change our decision-making modes, our meeting rhythms? I am not talking about the bilateral level; I want to talk about the eurozone. I believe so. But for now, it is too early to make changes. I am not today in the intention to overturn everything. That would indeed be the worst way not to decide. But it is true that we can meet more regularly and all together and with a eurozone that is more organized. That is the whole challenge of what we are going to do with what is called the roadmap that has already been presented and will be approved and specified during the European Council at the end of the year. That is the idea of deepening the economic and monetary union that I completely share, to have greater decision-making capacities and decision-making modalities that are simpler and easier.

And regarding Moody's, I tend to take the position of not commenting again on the agencies. Because what it signifies is a concern, a doubt. And so it is up to us to provide answers. We do not have to make comments; we have to provide answers. What is the doubt? It is both about our ability to decide; we will demonstrate precisely that we can do so very quickly on the issues of Greece, in particular, and other countries if necessary, and at the same time about growth. Because it is growth that will also allow countries to meet their budgetary commitments. So, budgetary seriousness, stability, growth; all of this must happen in the same movement.

Mr. Mario MONTI -- I would like to add a word to respond to your question about European summits. We must realize, and Mr. HOLLANDE has just mentioned it, that the European Council, which we owe to a predecessor of President HOLLANDE, namely President GISCARD d'ESTAING, was conceived by him. It is certainly a summit mechanism, but with a whole series of constraints and limits. There are 27 people who meet between 5:00 PM and 7:00 PM normally, and it is expected that, before the end of the evening, possibly 5:00 AM if necessary, conclusions are presented in several languages to the journalists. Fortunately, there is a little bit of preparatory work nonetheless. I would like to cite, for example, the meeting that took place just before the European Council, right here with President HOLLANDE, Angela MERKEL, President RAJOY, and myself. We had the opportunity to prepare our positions, which are not identical, but came closer during the meeting. At the end of that meeting, I called on behalf of the three colleagues to President BARROSO, to President VAN ROMPUY to inform them. And so, there are many steps in a long decision-making process. After that, there are also other types of meetings; for example, at the end of July, you may remember, I went to Helsinki for a discussion with the Finnish Prime Minister. It was not so much about preparing a decision at that moment, but it was a no less important mission. That is to say, it was about understanding each other, explaining ourselves, because sometimes the public opinions in our countries do not understand each other, which then creates obstacles for the head of government when it comes to negotiating.

So that is the typology of these meetings. And finally, with all due respect to journalists, do you not perhaps use the term "summit" a bit too frequently? Of course, we have with us the President of the French Republic, but I notice that as soon as I have a meeting at Palazzo Chigi with my Minister for Economic Development and the Minister of Labor, journalists immediately talk about a summit. Perhaps we should also give the word its true meaning.

Thank you.