Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on agricultural policy, in Rennes on September 11, 2012.

France François Hollande · President of France

11 September 2012 · Exhibition on agricultural policy (25th anniversary livestock exhibition) · Rennes, France

Context
Hollande addressed farmers, exhibitors, and agricultural leaders at a major livestock exhibition in Rennes on September 11, 2012, outlining his agricultural policy priorities.
Main themes
French agricultural policy, livestock farming, agri-food sector as economic driver, rural employment, food production and global demand, France's agricultural identity, trade competitiveness, structural challenges for livestock farmers, regional agricultural strengths, government support for agriculture
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,285
88th percentile
Sentences
242
93rd percentile
Readability
48
57th percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
2.83
25th percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
45th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 72%70%
  • Environmental 9%8%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Institutional 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

242 sentences in 85 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Mr. President, dear Jean-Michel LEMETAYER,

Ladies and gentlemen elected officials,

Ladies and gentlemen agricultural leaders,

Ladies and gentlemen exhibitors,

Ladies and gentlemen visitors,

I want to first congratulate the organizers of this exhibition. An impressive exhibition, a challenging one for distinguished visitors, but an exceptional exhibition that calls for both the tribute I pay on behalf of the Republic and the compliments to all those who have initiated and sustained this exhibition for 25 years.

The first in France for livestock, the second at the global level.

Brittany, once again, demonstrates its exceptional qualities. But here, it is not just Brittany.

I am in the leading agricultural region of France, which is at the heart of the great livestock basin that stretches from Normandy to Poitou-Charentes, passing through the Pays de la Loire. But beyond this exhibition, all its visitors, all its exhibitors, I want to address all the farmers of France.

I know them well.

I myself have been elected, or have been for many years, from a rural department, from a livestock department. I heard again today the concerns, the expectations, the hopes.

But I also read in the faces, in the eyes of my interlocutors, a lot of pride and a lot of confidence. This is indeed the paradox we must confront. Trying to break the legitimate anxieties while at the same time relying on all the strengths of our country to move it forward.

I know the current difficulties faced by livestock farmers.

I also recognize what they have done for our country. They, along with farmers, have shaped our Nation, contributed to its landscapes, its gastronomy, its traditions, its identity. The best proof is when we see the number of foreign visitors who come here, to this exhibition.

I also know the contribution of farmers and more generally all those who work around, with, and for agriculture. The contribution they make to the wealth of France. As you reminded us, Mr. President, 250 billion euros in turnover for agriculture and agri-food. The first trade surplus of our country; we do not have many trade surpluses, since we even have a cumulative deficit of 70 billion euros. This speaks volumes about the path we must take to regain balance in terms of competitiveness.

Agriculture, agri-food, you have already achieved your goal, although you must have even higher ambitions.

I also know what this represents in terms of employment, 1.5 million, when counting farmers and all those who work around processing, 3.5 million if we take the entire upstream to downstream of the sector. It is indeed the second largest employer in France.

That is why I am here, in Rennes for this exhibition.

But, in this story, in this reality, in these results, livestock occupies a special place.

It is an asset for France. Livestock is one of the agricultural activities richest in jobs. It sustains territories, even the most fragile ones. It contributes to tourist attractiveness and to the image of our country. It highlights grass, which is a wealth, even a heritage, that must be preserved. But livestock faces difficulties that are no longer cyclical, but structural, which call for both rapid and sustainable responses.

I do not want to pit agricultural activities against each other; that would be a disservice. We need all agricultures, all productions from all farms, from all territories, both plant and animal productions. But at the same time, I know the specificity of livestock and the risks it faces.

That is why the State and all public authorities will take their responsibilities to protect and support livestock.

But I want, here in Rennes, to share my vision of French agriculture and indicate the priorities of the Government's action and the ministers in charge of agriculture and agri-food.

My first priority is to make the agricultural and agri-food sector a driver of growth and an asset for productive recovery. This is the agenda I have set. To restore French production and regain growth, to recreate jobs. Agriculture and agri-food must take their rightful place.

I do not say this as a matter of circumstance.

The global situation is changing. The demand for agricultural and agri-food products is increasing due to the growth of the world population and is transforming with the rise in living standards in emerging countries. In this context, agricultural prices have gradually firmed up, and it is reasonable to think that we have entered a trend of rising global prices, which will not exclude temporary fluctuations and declines, but it is a considerable challenge, a challenge of production, a challenge of quality.

To feed the world, all agricultures from all countries must be mobilized, but ours is our responsibility. We must help other countries to produce more. We must seize the opportunity ourselves, because we are a major agricultural country and less exposed than others to climate risks. Look at what is happening right now. Our agriculture therefore has a major role to play in providing agricultural goods and in balancing global markets. This is the objective I set for it. France must contribute to feeding the world's population and act here for employment and for our territories.

I do not hide the fragilities: It has been recalled that France in recent years has fallen from 2nd to 4th place globally for agri-food exports, and that these, even remarkable, no longer have the necessary dynamics; market shares have been lost. We must reconquer them. This is the challenge of competitiveness.

The government's agricultural policy will therefore be focused on this production objective. Through the diversity of sectors, modes of marketing, through encouragement of all approaches that create value, innovation, quality, and export. Everything must be mobilized to achieve the goal I have set for the Nation. The State will work with the regions because they are the partners in this dynamic. They will be the leaders of economic development, training, and innovation.

Tomorrow, I will meet, with the Prime Minister, all the Presidents of Regions and I will mobilize them around this recovery agenda and therefore, for the development of agri-food industries.

Our asset is also quality. This quality is based on a mode of production rooted in the valorization of a territory. I am thinking particularly of controlled designation of origin for dairy and cheese products, wine, organic productions, and labeled sectors. This exemplary nature will be encouraged.

But there is also the price factor that undermines our competitiveness. I hear the concern expressed just now by President LEMETAYER, and more generally by the profession. Not just by this profession, but by those exposed to international competition, regarding labor costs, when margins are tight and where the share of employment is high, and when there are also competitions that are not always fair. I have committed to proposing to social partners, in the coming weeks, a reform on the financing of social protection because my conviction is clear: we cannot finance social expenditures for the future simply by levying on work. We must seek other contributions from other factors, from other agents, and not penalize what must today be stimulated and encouraged. This discussion will take, with social partners, the time it requires, and the agricultural profession, within the framework of the social conference, will be involved. Decisions will be made before the end of the year to be implemented at the beginning of next year. They will be structural and sustainable.

There is also what we can do with Europe, because there can be no agricultural policy if it is not designed at the community level. Europe has shown a willingness in agricultural matters. It was even a "bold act" in its time. Of course, the common agricultural policy is criticized; it always has been, but at the same time, we know that it is absolutely essential for our future.

So, I say it clearly. I will not accept that it becomes a budgetary adjustment variable in the negotiations that are about to open. Europe is indeed opening a new cycle to set its financial perspectives for the period 2014-2020. Some of our partners, I will not name them to avoid creating an incident, wish that savings in Union funding first affect the CAP. I oppose this. I believe that the CAP is meant to contribute to growth, and I will defend a European budget that maintains the credits of the CAP.

This is also the condition to allow young people to enter the profession with a perspective of providing for their families with dignity. They must be assured of the conditions provided by Europe to invest, to sometimes hire, and to produce. I announce here that under the responsibility of the Minister of Agriculture, the policy for the establishment of young people in agriculture will be strengthened and renovated, that economic strategies will take precedence over heritage approaches, and that land will be preserved.

Because, at a time when resources must be mobilized to produce more, to participate in the provision of agricultural and food products for France and for the world, it is unacceptable to see 100,000 hectares of agricultural land disappear every year. This is a true waste of productive capital, of natural capital. The safeguarding of agricultural land must therefore be carried out with all necessary legal means. Preserving biodiversity means fighting against the excessive consumption of agricultural space, limiting the artificialization of environments. These themes will be on the agenda of the environmental conference that will open at the end of the week.

But I am well aware that regardless of our efforts, regardless of our commitments, regardless of our policies, all of this can be rendered null and void if prices are not controlled, if the volatility of agricultural products and raw materials persists.

My conviction has long been established: agriculture cannot be left to the rules of the market. The crisis has unfortunately demonstrated all the dangers of unbridled liberalism, of globalization without rules, and of financialization without morality. This is even truer for agriculture.

Any climatic accident, as we have in this period, in a part of the world, even limited, immediately translates into brutal price variations. And at the same time, global warming makes such climatic hazards even more violent and more frequent. If, in addition to these climatic uncertainties, which return almost every year, speculation amplifies the fluctuation of prices, then it is a major risk for productions.

That is why I am certain of the validity of a global governance on issues as vital as food security. I have begun to advocate to heads of state and government for the establishment of protective tools against volatility in the form of emergency food reserves. And I will continue to do so. I also advocate, with all the weight of France, for a regulation capable of combating price fluctuations.

We are not starting from scratch, and the heads of state and government of the G20 wished, following the events of 2008, to improve the functioning and transparency of financial and commodity markets. Agricultural bodies have been established to improve transparency and information. As early as July, the French government requested the continuation of these mechanisms within the framework of what is called the "rapid response forum." France will continue to act. We will take a joint initiative with the FAO, and I will meet its director next week. An assessment of the action plan on price volatility will be established, and a new step must be taken.

The position I will defend regarding futures markets is as follows: improve the transparency of transactions and operators in the financial markets of raw materials, strengthen the monitoring of positions, and increase the intervention capacities of regulators.

At the European level, I have asked the Minister of Agriculture to scrupulously ensure the maintenance of supply control instruments in sectors where they still exist, as many of the CAP regulatory instruments have been systematically dismantled in recent years. But let us preserve what exists. The direct aid scheme, as we know, in its current form resulting from the 2003 reform, cannot suffice to compensate for what is happening today. The repetition of the so-called exceptional situations of 2008, 2010, and 2012 justifies the introduction of new mechanisms for stability and solidarity. I therefore propose to reinstate market management and crisis management policies by again establishing strategic [emergency] stocks.

At the national level, the State must also provide farmers with the means to protect themselves from volatility. Throughout my visit to the exhibition, I heard only this from all producers, from all sectors: how can we bear the rising purchase prices of our raw materials without being able to pass them on to the selling price, how can we live, invest if the price of our supplies, of our raw materials continues to rise without any possibility of controlling them? Therefore, we must act, act at the global level, act at the European level, and also act at the level of France.

First, we must improve trade relations on a contractual basis within the sectors. I know that contractualization raises debates; however, it does allow for securing supplies, and therefore I will encourage it. At the same time, we must work towards a collective organization of producers so that the margin is better distributed among the actors from production to distribution.

Next, we must mobilize taxation to smooth out income variations. You mentioned the current mechanism for investment or risk deduction. It no longer meets its original objective. From there, starting in 2013, we will implement a new fiscal system allowing farmers to better protect themselves against risks. It will be more flexible to use, it will be faster, and it will ensure to avoid any windfall effect on the fiscal level.

But there are also risk coverage instruments known as insurance. Again, these instruments will need to be improved, taking into account the specificity of each sector. Concrete proposals will be made as early as 2013.

But I recognize the urgency. There are those who cannot wait. There are even those for whom it is too late.

The rise in raw material prices is undermining animal production, mainly pork and poultry, for which the cost of feed represents a very significant part of the production cost.

I also commend the initiative of the producers of major crops, who have created a fund of 100 million euros to support farmers. This is not the first time there has been this solidarity among agricultural activities. I hope that these mechanisms can be sustained, that the sectors can support each other.

But the State must also support this professional solidarity with national solidarity. This is the purpose of the action plan that Stéphane Le Foll will present tomorrow at the Council of Ministers.

This plan will provide for the staggered payment of social contributions and individual banking support. I emphasize individual for farmers who are facing difficulties. The mechanisms for commercial negotiations will also be activated. You mentioned them, and they particularly concern the agreements of May 2011.

The actors in the beef, pork, and poultry sectors have committed on their side to open negotiations to review the sales conditions following the increase in animal feed prices. The Minister of Agriculture will also organize a round table dedicated to commercial relations.

The goal is to bring together all actors—farmers, processors, distributors, banks, and public authorities—so that we can act together and effectively.

This raises the entire question of the future of livestock farming. This is not just a problem for farmers. This is not just a concern for the affected regions. It is a fundamental question for France, and I raise it with gravity. If the high price of cereals leads to the re-cultivation of lands that were previously dedicated to livestock, then it is the balance of territories, it is the entire capacity for export, it is the quality of our productions that will be called into question. This is not a virtual threat. We are facing this situation. Therefore, we must put a stop to this drift.

I want to make the issue of animal production in our country a priority. And at the same time, I want to tell all these farmers present before me that we have a bright future if we know how to prepare for it.

There are markets that, until now, were closed to us; they are opening up everywhere in the world. Our productions are welcomed. French livestock has real strengths. We also have proximity in raw materials, know-how with our farmers, expertise in selection, processing, research, innovation, a strong connection with the territories, and a recognized image. I have seen very high-quality equipment. I have seen how working conditions have improved, how animal welfare has long been a constraint and has become a lever for producing with even greater performance. There is great attractiveness in the profession, even if we still need to encourage young people to pursue agricultural careers.

There is no inevitability. There is a reconquest to be undertaken. I mention this here in Brittany, with what has just happened, with the collapse of the Doux group, which revealed the most terrible news with the loss of jobs. How can we accept a situation where 40% of our national poultry supply is ensured from abroad when just a few years ago we were in surplus? What has happened? There is, undoubtedly, what relates to poor management by a number of groups whose employees and farmers are now paying a heavy price, but there is more than that. There are distortions of competition. There is poor organization. There is imperfect specialization. Let us learn the lessons from these shortcomings and failures. This is the very purpose of the productive recovery agenda that I have proposed. It applies to all sectors, to livestock, to agriculture, to industry, to our entire economy.

I want the added value to be created in our territories, that we enhance and transform our products here, that we mobilize all imaginations to conquer new markets, particularly in processed products or in the catering sector, that we multiply quality labels, that we invent different circuits, that we can also address labor costs, avoid and combat social dumping. Europe must ensure social, fiscal, health, and environmental convergence. These are the basic conditions for a great market. How can we want to compete if it is distorted? How can we accept that products can circulate if they are not subject to the same rules, the same conditions, the same constraints? This is a challenge. This is a commitment I have made, and that the ministers will be tasked with translating into European discussions.

I am also aware of your concerns regarding the European Commission's proposal on aid for the western region, whose amount per hectare is higher than the average for reasons related to historical choices, which should not penalize you today. Again, I will take up the discussion with the ministers with the European Commission to avoid significant and abrupt transfers of aid to the detriment of certain types of livestock and certain production areas.

Ladies and gentlemen, I want to conclude on the environmental issue, which must unite and not divide French society.

I am fully aware of what farmers have done for years in our country to manage all the criteria related to the environment.

I know that here, in this region, there was a necessity because there had been excesses.

But the collective interest is to be able to combine the necessary economic performance with the indispensable ecological imperative.

The idea we must share is to preserve natural resources, and I think of water, but it is also to anticipate consumer demands and develop new production techniques.

I want farmers to take their full part in the Environmental Conference that will be held at the end of the week. I want a balanced promotion of land management, to preserve agricultural land, to combat soil artificialization. I also want us to mobilize agriculture for energy production and to take all initiatives in renewable energy or energy efficiency.

Producing better cannot mean producing less; it does not mean producing as before either. I believe we must produce better to produce more. That is the whole challenge. It is a form of "double green" revolution that we must undertake. Since we need to both produce more and produce differently.

This will be one of the axes of agricultural policy at all levels. At the European level, the new CAP already intends to give a signal. I want us to participate in this greening of the Common Agricultural Policy, provided that the modalities are adapted to correspond to the reality of our farms. The second pillar of the CAP, France must use it to support the agro-environmental movement while utilizing all techniques, especially the most innovative.

At the national level, the goal is to regain a diversity of production methods and crops; this will be the subject of the economic and ecological interest groups proposed by the Minister of Agriculture.

The idea is to recreate a collective momentum comparable to that of the modernization of the 1960s. It will require the mobilization of all actors: research to bring forth innovative solutions, training and development to ensure that farmers are the primary actors in this evolution.

This will be the purpose of the future law on agriculture and agri-food, which will provide a coherent framework with the objective of creating value and jobs. This is where the status of the operator, the organization of sectors, the adaptation of the Common Agricultural Policy, and taxation will be renovated.

We will achieve this by respecting several principles:

- Listening and dialogue with the entire profession. Within this profession, with the participation of all representative organizations, this is the rule.

- Respect for the long term. Agriculture is not an activity like others; it depends on natural cycles and cannot quickly change its strategies or investment choices. It is therefore essential to set the course, to maintain it consistently, and to ensure that once the line is defined, all instruments are put in place.

- Simplification, shortening of deadlines, and even the easing of a number of controls.

Ladies and gentlemen,

I have announced an agenda for the recovery of France in the next two years. For agriculture, it may take longer.

There is what pertains to restoring public accounts; we will make efforts to find the 30 billion euros that we are missing, as revealed by the Court of Auditors. We will ensure that the effort is shared between savings on the State budget and administrations, between what will need to be called "business solidarity," and what each household will have to do based on its income and especially its capacity to contribute. The most affluent households will necessarily have to pay more than others. And the most modest households will not have to make an additional sacrifice.

In this recovery agenda, there is not only the recovery of public accounts, because our objective cannot simply be to fight against debt. Our objective must be to fight against unemployment, but above all to restore the production of our country, improve its performance, gain market shares, and enhance its competitiveness.

Agriculture is part of this productive pact. I consider it an asset for our country, not only for its independence and food security, which is already significant, but also for employment, for foreign trade, for the balance of our territories, and for the influence of France.

Here is the meaning of my visit throughout the afternoon -- I could have spent even more hours here -- but I knew that you were gathered, and that you were waiting for us. My visit, here, in Rennes, at SPACE was much more than an acknowledgment of the quality of animal production; it was also an act of confidence in the future, that of farming in France, and of agriculture. It was also a commitment to respond to challenges that will involve our nation for a long time. Its food supply, its ability to produce better, to produce more, to be at the highest level in the world. That is the destiny of France, not to simply be carried along, not to be overcome by fatalism, no, to set ourselves the goals of being the best in the world and in Europe. We have all the capabilities for that. Of course, there are trials. I began my visit by meeting with the employees of PSA, who expressed to me their anxiety, their suffering, and at the same time, their expectation of having a new vehicle to be manufactured in Rennes, their desire to innovate, to research, to keep the centers.

I will conclude my visit with a meeting with the employees of Doux, some of whom are questioning their fate, particularly those in the fresh products sector, while others, whose fate is not yet resolved because the commercial court has not yet intervened, are wondering what will happen.

In the face of all these concerns, all these questions, my only message is to say that the State must be present to support, to act, to ensure that in an emergency, we can accompany, find solutions, and at the same time, prepare for the future. Because the only issue that matters, the only cause that can unite us beyond all our diversities, our sensitivities, is the future of France. And today, by being present at this fair, the second largest in the world, (we have a place to gain!), what I wanted to say is that we can succeed together and that farming has a great future in our country.

Thank you.