Address by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at a discussion round with citizens on the pros and cons of mandatory vaccination on January 12, 2022, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

20 January 2022 · Discussion round with citizens on the pros and cons of mandatory vaccination · Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier hosted a citizen discussion round at Schloss Bellevue on January 12, 2022, to debate the pros and cons of a general COVID-19 vaccination mandate in Germany.
Main themes
Mandatory COVID-19 vaccination debate, democratic deliberation, pandemic response, public engagement, parliamentary process, social cohesion, rule of law, scientific evidence, Omicron variant, citizens' concerns
Duration
~7 min
24th percentile
Words
828
24th percentile
Sentences
44
28th percentile
Readability
54
73rd percentile
Grade
10.4
25th percentile
Syntax
3.07
57th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
26th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 50%50%
  • Social 43%43%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

44 sentences in 10 paragraphs

Good morning and a warm welcome to all of you at Schloss Bellevue, dear guests! Does Germany need a general vaccination mandate in the fight against the coronavirus pandemic? What are the arguments for it, and what are the arguments against it? This is what we want to discuss together this morning and, if necessary, also respectfully debate.

One thing in advance: As Federal President, I will not position myself in this round on a yes or no to a general vaccination mandate. That is required by respect for the political process, which is to lead to a parliamentary decision in the coming weeks on a law that will ultimately be submitted to the Federal President for review and on whose promulgation he must decide.

So why am I inviting you to this discussion today? The Federal President does not write laws, but he has the task, and I personally believe: also the duty, to demand public engagement with difficult and serious questions. That is the emphasis I want to make today: I am concerned with the "debate" in the vaccination mandate debate.

There is no democracy without debate. And there is also no democracy in times of crisis without debate. The state of emergency of the pandemic increases the pressure for state action, but it does not replace the necessity of weighing arguments and balancing interests. On the contrary: precisely because we are talking about such a far-reaching measure, we must hold its justification to particularly high standards. And all the more so because a vaccination mandate was explicitly excluded for a long time at the federal and state levels. The arguments for the necessity of a vaccination mandate must now be discussed all the more clearly in the public sphere. Parliaments, parties, governments – all are called upon to present their arguments and to discuss them together with citizens, with those who will actually be affected by such a far-reaching measure.

A general vaccination mandate is certainly not a legislative everyday matter for the Bundestag and the Federal Government. Likewise, the process of debate, weighing, and justification must not be an everyday matter. Such an extraordinary measure places our state in an extraordinary obligation to its citizens. In short: a vaccination mandate means a duty to debate!

That is exactly why we are here today: We seek the debate. First: What do the scientific facts tell us, the latest, constantly changing findings? What does the Omicron variant mean, which, although apparently leading to milder disease courses, is spreading significantly more aggressively – as we can see from today's numbers? What does the hope for an effective coronavirus medication mean? And what are the motivations of those who continue to refuse vaccination? How should we deal with their fears and concerns?

As we discuss these questions together, as a kind of example for the many discussions in our country, I hope: We do so with vigor, but also with a willingness to listen. With respect for other positions, but also with respect for facts and reason, which must be our common currency and remain so.

Why is this so crucial for our democracy? There are people who say: We have a "corona dictatorship" in Germany. That is malicious nonsense! For it not only shows contempt for our democratic, rule-of-law institutions, but it is also an insult to all of us! We are struggling month by month through this pandemic, but not because we are being directed and controlled with an iron hand, but because the vast majority is constantly striving to do the right thing, to act responsibly, to be in solidarity. Because people everywhere – in families and among friends, at work and in schools and daycare centers, in hospitals and nursing homes, in town halls, health offices, and parliaments – are wrestling together about what to do. And that is precisely what this democratic struggle is about here in our debate.

The pandemic is not over, perhaps it is still a long way from being over. But the day will come when it is behind us. And on that day, we will look back and ask: What has the pandemic done to our society? Has it driven us apart? Has it deepened the divides that were already there? Or have we come closer together because we can look back and say we overcame this dark time – despite all the disputes, despite all the pain – together?

I am convinced: The answer to this question will also be determined by the debate we are having today and in these days. Not only by the yes or no to a vaccination mandate, but by the persuasiveness of good reasons, by the way we speak and interact with each other in our country. I am all the more grateful to all of you for participating in this discussion today, and I personally am very much looking forward to the next hour and a half to two hours.