Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the premiere of the film "The Wannsee Conference" on January 19, 2022, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

20 January 2022 · Premiere of the film "The Wannsee Conference" · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier spoke at the Berlin premiere of the film 'The Wannsee Conference' on January 19, 2022, reflecting on the Holocaust's bureaucratic origins.
Main themes
Wannsee Conference, Holocaust bureaucracy, banality of evil, language as a tool of murder, Nazi administrative machinery, genocide and state regression, democratic safeguards against extremism, collective responsibility and complicity, historical memory
Duration
~10 min
36th percentile
Words
1,241
36th percentile
Sentences
56
37th percentile
Readability
42
40th percentile
Grade
12.9
55th percentile
Syntax
3.09
59th percentile
Vocabulary
2.43
92nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 48%43%
  • Social 36%32%
  • Ceremonial 10%9%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 11%

56 sentences in 18 paragraphs

It is an impressively good film that we are about to see – and a hard-to-bear, a disturbing film. What begins with discomfort turns into horror, at least that was my experience; a horror that lingers even after the credits have long rolled and the screen has gone black.

Whoever then – like us today – steps out of the cinema onto the street or watches the news program that follows on television, notices: For an irritatingly long moment, one's own familiar language seems unfamiliar. One becomes distrustful of it. It is unsettling that the administrative German spoken in the film uses the same words that one also hears in the here and now, on the street or on television.

Where does this discomfort come from, where does the distrust stem from? The film shows the working meeting of high police and administrative officials of the Nazi state, which will later become part of German history as the "Wannsee Conference." It shows them as it might have taken place, for we do not know what and how exactly each individual word was spoken.

Heydrich had summoned to a "meeting with subsequent breakfast" on behalf of Göring. There was talk of killing, eliminating, destroying, and Cognac was served, as Adolf Eichmann noted in his later interrogation in Jerusalem. Matti Geschonneck's film is a word-for-word adaptation, perhaps the most accurate adaptation of the protocol of the Wannsee Conference in many passages.

What we see and experience is a smoothly functioning administrative machinery, departmental coordination, templates, and processes that, apart from the content of the meeting, differ in no way from those that still exist today in ministries and authorities. It is precisely the ordinary, the familiar, that shocks and unsettles us. What Geschonneck achieves is a staging of the banality of evil.

The Wannsee Conference is a historical snapshot; it shows the administrative background of the Holocaust. The legal historian and jurist Hans-Christian Jasch understands it as a warning to our modern, division-of-labor societies, whose bureaucratic and political structures are only protected against their misuse as long as a stable democratic constitution stands between a similarly stable government and administration on one side and the ideological abyss on the other.

Where these abysses opened up can be read primarily from the language in the protocol of the Wannsee Conference. Language is a means of identification as well as of distancing. One can align oneself with a matter through words or distance oneself from it. In the protocol of the Wannsee Conference, this happens in a different way, perhaps even more radically. Here, every word denies its actual function. It wants to name or designate nothing. It seeks to obscure facts and dissolve responsibility in homeopathic doses.

Thus, the meeting, as it is recorded in the protocol, becomes a strange, at times even grotesque, fencing with words. Whoever speaks up here wants to stand out. He wants to assert and promote his value, his significance, and that of his authority for the Nazi state with his own ideas and concepts – and yet simultaneously keeps his words at a distance from what he is talking about and what he is participating in.

The participants of the Wannsee Conference knew just as well as we do today what they did not want to articulate at the time: that the subject of their discussions was the "complete elimination of the European Jews," as Joseph Goebbels noted in his diary after reading the protocol, the meticulously planned murder of eleven million people; they had long since begun this undertaking and by the time of the Wannsee Conference – especially after the beginning of the war of extermination against the Soviet Union in June 1941 – had already put it into practice hundreds of thousands of times.

Anyone who considers a modern state and its administration as a regulating and balancing instance for civilizational progress must conclude that the fifteen pages of the "result protocol" document the well-articulated regression of a state into barbarism.

It shows how language itself becomes a tool of murder. It serves both to abstract and to obscure the actual undertaking, so that genocide becomes "administratively communicable," writes Hans-Christian Jasch, and thus "manageable for the administration." It enabled the many nameless individuals – from administrative officials to employees in the Reich Chancellery and the Foreign Office, from police officers to train conductors – to participate in the deportation and murder of millions of Jews, while simultaneously alleviating their consciences. It also made millions of Germans silent accomplices. The protocol of the Wannsee Conference is a weapon of action. The traces it left behind are still traceable today.

Matti Geschonneck allows his protagonists to act; not as caricatures of Nazi henchmen, as one knows them from many other relevant films, but as what they were before 1939 and, after all, two of them remained even after 1945: jurists and administrative officials.

Gerhard Klopfer, for example, head of Department III in the Party Chancellery, one of the most influential officials of the Nazi state at the intersection of party and state. In the Wilhelmstraße trial, he claimed that only the "emigration of the Jews" was discussed at the Wannsee Conference. In response to the prosecution's objection, "it seems, however, that you were told exactly what was to happen to the Jews," he replied: "I know nothing of it." "I was not aware of it" – how often was this answer given after 1945.

Anyone who asks what kind of people the fifteen men of the Wannsee Conference were will, according to the current state of research, come to the conclusion: men who had made careers in public service, a representative cross-section of the administrative elite. Ten were academics, nine of the fifteen had a legal or political science education. Eight held doctorates.

Their self-understanding as jurists was perfectly compatible with the Nazi racial ideology, for the goal of law and the ideology of the Nazi state were not the equality of all before the law and the protection of the individual. "Law is what benefits the people" – this aimed at exclusion, this aimed at a "racial selection."

The administrative elites underwent the necessary denazification for their careers and advancement after 1945 often without consequences and protected each other from prosecution – this is a distressing chapter in German legal and administrative history. Thus, today some very elderly henchmen of the Holocaust still stand trial, while many of their superiors were never held accountable for their actions throughout their lives.

How could the murder machinery of National Socialism function so perfectly? And what does personal responsibility mean in a dictatorship? This was one, perhaps the life theme of Hannah Arendt. She shows that totalitarian systems do not only collude with absolute evil, are not only driven by demons and monsters, but that in these systems so many small cogs interlock until the responsibility of the individual becomes unrecognizable and no sense of wrongdoing exists anymore. The banality of evil is the soulless bureaucracy of a dictatorship, the rule of no one, as Hannah Arendt writes.

That the same does not repeat itself is the intention of every remembrance of the crimes of the Nazi state. In our democratic state, each individual bears responsibility, including officials in a hierarchically organized administration. Let us not be no ones. Let us not shy away from responsibility. Not even the responsibility to say no where justice and humanity demand it.