Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the Central Final Appeal in Honor of the Bundeswehr's Mission in Afghanistan on October 13, 2021, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

13 October 2021 · Central Final Appeal in Honor of the Bundeswehr's Mission in Afghanistan · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a central commemorative ceremony in Berlin on October 13, 2021, honoring Bundeswehr soldiers for nearly twenty years of service in Afghanistan.
Main themes
Bundeswehr mission in Afghanistan, honoring veterans, fallen soldiers and sacrifice, Taliban resurgence and evacuation, camaraderie and personal sacrifice, Afghan civilian partners, PTSD and veteran care, civilian-military engagement, German national gratitude, duty of protection to Afghans
Duration
~22 min
70th percentile
Words
2,617
70th percentile
Sentences
138
77th percentile
Readability
54
74th percentile
Grade
10.4
25th percentile
Syntax
3.00
48th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
42nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 39%38%
  • Ceremonial 31%30%
  • Institutional 16%15%
  • Social 13%12%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

138 sentences in 28 paragraphs

It snowed in Berlin on January 2, 2002, when the first German soldiers landed in Kabul. "Enduring Freedom" and the International Security Assistance Force, "Resolute Support" and the military evacuation operation – for almost twenty years, the Bundeswehr has been deployed in Afghanistan. Twenty times spring and summer and autumn and winter in Berlin and in Kabul, in Calw and in Kunduz, in Wunstorf and in Faizabad, in Mittenwald and in Taloqan, in Seedorf and in Isa Khel. Twenty years, almost a whole generation.

For twenty years, the Bundeswehr, you have been in Afghanistan – and yet Afghanistan has remained a distant place for many of our fellow citizens, which was occasionally mentioned in the evening news. I have the impression that only in these very last months, only with the victorious advance of the Taliban and the evacuation operation, has Afghanistan come back into focus for most Germans, even to the center of attention.

But for you, dear soldiers, who have served there over the past two decades, Afghanistan has been and is something different. For you, Afghanistan is a part of your life, your life story. For you, Afghanistan is camaraderie, field post address, and homesickness. For you, Afghanistan is the endless day in the field camp – and the seemingly endless second in combat. For you, Afghanistan is hope and disillusionment, heat and dust, deprivation and fear. For many of you, Afghanistan also means the memory of injury and death and grief.

More than 90,000 soldiers of the Bundeswehr have served in Afghanistan, more than 150,000 times they had to say goodbye to partners, friends, and families. At times, more than a quarter of the Bundeswehr was primarily engaged in the mission. Some of you who are here today were part of the first contingent, others of the last. Many of you have been deployed more than once, some thirteen, even seventeen times, some for a thousand days of their lives and more.

This mission has shaped you, and this mission has shaped the Bundeswehr like no other mission in the more than 65-year history of this army. We are here today to remember your service, to honor it. And one thing is without a doubt, without ifs and buts: The Bundeswehr has fulfilled its mission. 76 contingents with the most diverse mandates and a mission constantly adapted to the situation: The Bundeswehr has carried out everything that politics has assigned to it – the Bundeswehr can be relied upon! Dear veterans, this is your great achievement and solely your merit. I thank you on behalf of our country – our country is proud of you!

We are also indebted to other citizens. Germany did not only engage militarily in this mission. The networking of military and civilian engagement was our aim. Therefore, our country's thanks today also explicitly goes to the employees of the Federal Foreign Office, the Federal Police, and the Federal Intelligence Service, the many development workers, the members of non-governmental organizations, and all others who have served and worked in Afghanistan over these twenty years.

And our country is indebted to the brave Afghan men and women who worked for German entities and who therefore must fear for their lives in their homeland today. Many of them you were able to bring to safety, but many others are still in Afghanistan. I know that many Germans, especially many veterans, are concerned about these people – and they rightly expect that our country continues to seek all possible ways and means to fulfill its duty of protection towards these people as well.

Today we remember the 59 German soldiers who lost their lives in Afghanistan. They paid the highest price that a soldier can pay in the service of his country. We are deeply indebted to them. We bow our heads in memory of those who fell and died in service – and we are aware of our everlasting duty towards their relatives, some of whom are with us today. The Federal Republic of Germany and the Bundeswehr had to learn over these twenty years how to honor soldiers who have fallen in combat. At the Bundeswehr memorial, we have laid wreaths today to commemorate them. We will not forget them.

We honor all those who have been affected by the mission, who were injured and wounded, physically or mentally. I remember well many discussions I had as Federal President with experienced soldiers, in which we talked about bravery and injury. I know that for many soldiers it is a long road back to life. Some are still fighting today. It is good to see how far the Bundeswehr has come in terms of caring for those affected by the mission, and especially that we have brought the mental health of veterans out of the taboo zone and into the center of concern and care.

In one of my conversations, I met Sergeant Major Tim Focken, who was injured in 2010 in a firefight in Afghanistan. His operation lasted 17 hours, and to this day he is paralyzed in his upper arm. Tim Focken now refers to his injury as the "fight I was not prepared for." He told me about his thoughts at that time, when he was plagued by feelings of guilt, thinking that despite his serious injury, he had let his comrades down.

It is important that we know these stories – his story and your stories. It is important that our country is there for the men and women who were wounded in service. Combat and bravery, trauma and death, German soldiers with weapons in other countries – we Germans like to suppress that. We talk about it far too rarely and only reluctantly. This makes it difficult for you, the veterans of foreign missions. We should take the end of the Afghanistan mission as an opportunity to overcome this silence – and my impression is that we have already succeeded to some extent during the military evacuation operation.

The soldiers of the Bundeswehr are our fellow citizens, our neighbors, our friends. They are citizens in uniform – and the stories of the Bundeswehr are our stories. They deserve to be heard.

Sergeant Major Focken is now a sports soldier. A few weeks ago, he was a shooter in the German Paralympic team at the Games in Tokyo. Once again, he flew halfway around the world for our country. Afghanistan has shaped him – Afghanistan has shaped all of you, and Afghanistan has shaped the Bundeswehr. The Afghanistan mission will stick with this army and with us Germans for a long time. In short, we must talk about Afghanistan!

Twenty years after September 11 and two months after the fall of Kabul, many people who have served and suffered in Afghanistan are asking questions. Questions about the purpose of this mission. These are difficult questions, bitter questions. They are directed at the parliament and the governments that sent the Bundeswehr to Afghanistan. Why were we unable, despite all the personal efforts and all the resources deployed, to establish a stable, self-sustaining political order in Afghanistan? A new order that the very different groups from Afghanistan had urgently demanded at the Bonn Conference twenty years ago? Why did the Afghan leadership and the armed forces, into which we invested so much over so many years, collapse in such a short time? Was the withdrawal of international troops, as it took place, the right decision? Are the suffering, our efforts, all the injuries to body and soul, all the lost lives of the past twenty years in vain? And above all: What do we learn from this bitter experience for our actions in other mission areas, in other countries of this world, from which risks to our own security arise?

You, the veterans of Afghanistan, but also the citizens in this democracy are asking these questions, and they expect answers. These answers are owed to you by us, by politics – and they should not primarily be quick, but honest and thorough.

Soldiers: Germany deserves a security policy that draws lessons from twenty years in Afghanistan. This is a task that goes far beyond these days and weeks – it is a task for a new federal government and the new Bundestag, which will be constituted this month.

For me personally, the path to this podium today has not been easy. From the very beginning and for a long time, until almost five years ago, I bore my share of the responsibility for the mission in Afghanistan – as a member of parliament and as a member of several governments. I am far from saying that we did everything right over the years. But I can assure you: German politics has never taken Afghanistan lightly – in any party or any constellation. The decisions about new or changed mandates were often accompanied by heated debates.

I am convinced that it was the right decision in 2001 to invoke the alliance case – for the first time in NATO's history – to show solidarity with our partners, especially the USA, and to go to Afghanistan in alliance. We achieved our military goal, namely to defeat those who brought terrible terror from Afghanistan against our allies twenty years ago and who were also a threat to us. But we did not achieve our broader goal of establishing stable state structures in Afghanistan. The military mission, your mission, created the space and time for this political transformation process over many years. However, we did not succeed in this, neither for ourselves nor for the Afghans.

Just as Germany could only go to Afghanistan in alliance, the withdrawal from Afghanistan was also only possible in alliance. In the years in between, there were many rounds of evaluations, assessments, and political debates. There were doubts – and often sharp criticism – but there were always good reasons why we remained in Afghanistan.

The bitterness of these weeks does not stem from a sudden awakening moment that reveals all our mistakes in the rearview mirror. No, what is bitter is primarily that despite all self-examination, despite all struggles for goals and priorities, despite all changes in mandates and approaches, despite all efforts and despite all sacrifices, we stand here today and have to ask ourselves these bitter questions. For me, it is clear: The fall of Kabul was a turning point. We stand at a crossroads that forces us to rethink our responsibility in the world, our possibilities, and their limits in a new and self-critical way. I hope that in twenty years we will not look back at this crossroads and say: Resignation and withdrawal was the answer to Afghanistan. That would be the wrong lesson!

Because we Germans do not live isolated on an island – in 2021, by the way, even less than in 2001. Germany is the most populous country in the European Union. Germany is the fourth largest economy in the world. Germany has weight in this world. More than that – Germany is respected worldwide and increasingly sought after. I have experienced this for decades on my visits to all continents. The world does not remain indifferent to what Germany does and what happens in Germany. And in light of our history, but also our interests, Germany must not be indifferent to what happens in the world.

Therefore, withdrawal from the world must not be our answer. We must face the world as it is, while at the same time maintaining the ambition not to leave it as it is. I am convinced: German foreign and security policy after Afghanistan must become more honest, smarter, and stronger. We must be more honest when we explore our possibilities and our limits. We must realistically define our foreign policy goals and interests – this means, on the one hand, being more modest, with less sense of mission and missionary zeal, and on the other hand, being bolder when we know we are needed. Germany must learn to grasp and utilize its own strength – while also knowing its limits.

In a democracy, this can only happen if the political parties and the media, if experts and practitioners, if we all discuss together, even controversially, without ideological prejudices or blinders, what our interests are – and what our country can and wants to stand for! We must be smarter when we decide where we engage with which means. We must expand our capabilities and better network our instruments – diplomatically, militarily, civilly, humanitarily, in development and economic policy. If we have learned anything in Afghanistan, it is the necessary networking of our means, so that development workers and soldiers, politicians and diplomats do not step on each other's toes on the ground, but pull together. This requires more coordination and cooperation, more clarity and transparency, and less departmental thinking and friction losses.

And we must become stronger in our capabilities, including in the military. It is the most important task of our state to protect its citizens. In these unstable times, Germany is investing more in its defense – and that is the right thing to do. The Bundeswehr needs good equipment and functioning structures because our country needs a functioning Bundeswehr. For both go hand in hand: negotiating strength and defense strength. Our advocacy for a strong, rules-based peace order, our concrete efforts to defuse conflicts cannot succeed from a position of weakness, at least not in the reality of this world. In short, we need a strong Bundeswehr – our partners expect it, and our army deserves it.

Yes, we are aware of the heavy burden of our history – and no one knows this better than the soldiers of the Bundeswehr. The knowledge of places like Babyn Yar, where I spoke exactly one week ago, the knowledge of events there and in other places, especially in Eastern Europe, reminds us: The Wehrmacht in National Socialism does not establish a tradition that we can invoke. Therefore: The Bundeswehr is not an army like any other. Beyond command and obedience, the commitment to one's own conscience and the principles of Internal Leadership guide our armed forces. The values of our constitution are the unshakeable foundation of this army of freedom, law, and democracy. We Germans can rely on the Bundeswehr – and we can trust it!

"As an equal member in a united Europe to serve the peace of the world" – this is how the preamble of our constitution demands it, succinctly and precisely. This is what German politics stands for, this is what German society stands for, and this is what this Bundeswehr stands for. But what this demand concretely means must be answered anew by each era. And now a new era begins again, a new chapter. I am sure our children and grandchildren will not measure us by military strength or by the billions we have spent, not by the number of deployment days, the number of development workers or diplomats; rather, they will measure us by whether we were able to solve problems and conflicts.

The problems and conflicts in the world have not diminished, and many of them touch our German and European interests. The call for a foreign and security policy that draws lessons from twenty years in Afghanistan cannot be ignored. Let us take this call seriously. The citizens of this country expect it. They deserve good and honest answers. And no one deserves these answers more than you, the citizens in uniform, who are ready to give everything for your country.

You are committed to your country, and your country is committed to you. This agreement must hold – and it does!