Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the festive event for the opening of the exhibition at the Humboldt Forum on September 22, 2021, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

22 September 2021 · Festive event for the opening of the exhibition at the Humboldt Forum · Humboldt Forum, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the festive opening of the Humboldt Forum exhibition in Berlin on September 22, 2021, reflecting on its national significance and contested history.
Main themes
Humboldt Forum opening, German national identity, colonial collections and restitution, self-critical democracy, Berlin's historical center, cultural dialogue, ethnological collections, historical memory, architectural controversy, world cultures in Berlin, museum landscape
Duration
~29 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,524
82nd percentile
Sentences
178
86th percentile
Readability
51
66th percentile
Grade
10.9
32nd percentile
Syntax
3.05
54th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
42nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 54%50%
  • Institutional 19%17%
  • Ceremonial 15%14%
  • Geopolitical 12%11%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

178 sentences in 29 paragraphs

So, now it stands here! And now? The rebuilt Berlin City Palace, the Humboldt Forum, it is undoubtedly the center of the new Mitte of our capital – both architecturally and symbolically. In the grand project of reinventing this center of Berlin, it is the architectural keystone and yet, in terms of content, more of a beginning. This palace and this forum are – not least due to their location, history, and self-imposed mission – a place of national significance. But this place raises more questions at the moment than it provides answers. The open questions that this place poses to us are open questions of our nation, questions directed at our nation.

Can we endure this? Some find this palace, precisely because it raises so many questions, unsatisfactory, worthy of criticism. Some wish it had never been built. But it stands here now. After all the many years of bitter debates, after rejected, new, and approved plans, it has been completed. The people of Berlin, guests from all over the world, are already taking possession of it. They stroll through the courtyards, sit outside in the sun, visit the exhibitions that are already on display. We just heard: One hundred thousand have already been here. And yet it is provocatively unfinished. Therefore, the question: Can we endure this?

I have always been grateful to accompany the growth and development of the Humboldt Forum: architecturally up close at the Foreign Office and also in terms of content. I remember well a balmy summer evening in 1999 in front of the Chancellor's Bungalow in Bonn, when Klaus-Dieter Lehmann presented the idea to the then Chancellor to redesign the entire Berlin Museum Island. A grand vision! I was fascinated and excited. And I was equally fascinated by the proposal to include the Ethnological Collections from Dahlem in the redesign of the Berlin Mitte. "The world cultures belong in the center of Berlin," you, dear Klaus-Dieter Lehmann, were convinced. Instead of a German-German navel-gazing, the opening towards the world – that convinced me back then as well.

Now the world cultures have arrived. I am very pleased to be here today and I thank you, dear Mr. Dorgerloh, dear Mr. Parzinger, dear Mr. Koch, very much for the invitation. The Ethnological Collections and the Museum of Asian Art are now on display here, here in this forum. And for that, I would like to congratulate you warmly – while being aware of how controversial some aspects are and remain.

This forum is not yet finished, but from today it is a centerpiece in the museum landscape of Berlin. A great step, for which I am grateful. But it is only a beginning. It is not the conclusion; it is the beginning of a project. Just as our present is clearly a time of upheaval and beginnings. Here, in this forum, not only should science, art, and culture meet. It should become a place of international dialogue, of critical and self-critical thinking, and of engagement with the world and with the world.

One need not worry about a lack of criticism. There has been much struggle and debate over this place. This building, by its sheer size alone, confidently claims to fill a void left by German history. This new old Berlin City Palace wants to be nothing less than the new old center of this city, the republican heart of the new old German capital: a monument of democracy with baroque facades. Can this succeed?

You can sense it; I too am driven by several questions. And I want to confess to you right away: I will not be able to provide an answer to everything today, and certainly not satisfy everyone. But perhaps it is precisely this questioning and doubting that offers us visitors a good approach to this building. This is, one might say, not a place of self-assurance, but of self-questioning. And in a very productive sense: A place that does not let us rest, such a place can indeed become a democratic place.

A brief look back at history hints at the ambition, the longings, the lust for power that this place has awakened over the centuries: monastery, residence of princes, kings, emperors, parade ground and palace of the republic, mocked as "Palazzo Prozzo" and at the same time a popular excursion destination, seat of the only freely elected People's Chamber and an asbestos ruin destined for demolition, stage for artists, Humboldt Forum. This place reflects like few others our history, the errors, the abysses, the tyranny, and the reconstruction. And it reminds us: For only a fraction, just three decades, our history is the history of a reunited, free, and democratic Germany.

Back then, after the Peaceful Revolution and reunification, the Berlin Mitte once again became the crystallization point of our location as a nation. A nation that was not only architecturally searching for its lost center. Renovation or demolition, new construction or reconstruction, modernity or baroque: The palace dispute raged with the force of a religious war until the idea of reconstruction prevailed. "A republican promise," as the FAZ put it, or a "monument of historical amnesia," as Die Zeit saw it? A completion of history? Or rather this: a revision of history, a symbol of the failure of the idea of socialism, as Joachim Fest, one of the most significant advocates, justified the reconstruction?

The battles of that time have been fought. Nevertheless, it is not the case that a stone-carved, cross-crowned reminiscence of Prussian dominance explains itself in the reunited democratic Germany. This palace, this Humboldt Forum must first find its identity and its purpose in democracy. What that purpose is, this question presents itself today differently than it did thirty years ago. Today we see more clearly that reunification was indeed an endpoint – the German division was overcome, the German question resolved – but much more so a beginning. The beginning of a process in which not only Berlin but German society as a whole was to change more radically than most could imagine back then – and not only in the East but also in the West. And this process is far from complete.

On the contrary: Just as our democracy is not yet permanently finished and complete more than thirty years after the fall of the Wall and reunification, so too is this forum not complete. But the world beyond our borders, that world has also changed. Today we are a society that is globally connected and has become more diverse and pluralistic.

Here in the Berlin Mitte, this is visible every day like under a magnifying glass. It has changed in the last thirty years in a breathtaking way, and I do not only mean the architectural side but also what has changed behind the facades, both old and new. The world cultures have arrived, but in a double sense: here inside the Humboldt Forum and out there, in front of the monumental facades. Here in the Berlin Mitte, today the world is not just a guest. The world is at home here – it may sound like a nice advertising slogan, but it has brought about profound changes. People from Turkey, Italy, Greece, Spain, and Portugal, from Iran, Iraq, Afghanistan, and Syria, from Nigeria, the Congo, and Somalia, from Asia, North and South America: People from all parts of the world live in Germany today, many have become Germans. They are part of what "German" means today. They are part of our national identity, part of an active citizenship that engages in debates. They are not people with a migration background – we are a country with a migration background! So what can, what should this forum, which bears the name Humboldt, be in this changed country, in this changed world?

As a first answer, I want to say very clearly: I can think of no better name for this place. The Berlin Mitte bows, together with Humboldt University, doubly before the two great scholars. Perhaps it is one of the many ironies of our history that Alexander and Wilhelm von Humboldt are said not to have particularly loved this Berlin, their hometown, and only reluctantly returned from abroad. Yes, this name is a bow to Wilhelm von Humboldt, the constitutional lawyer, linguist, and Prussian envoy to the Vatican, who founded the first Berlin university after his recall by the Prussian king in 1809 and whose bold vision of the unity of research and teaching, whose ideal of comprehensive education still shapes our universities and our education system today. And it is a bow to Alexander von Humboldt, the great naturalist, explorer, and philosopher, to whom we owe invaluable insights into the then-unknown so-called New World. His self-understanding as a universal scholar, as a researcher was a radical counter-program to colonial conquest, exploitation, and enslavement – a counter-program to mere measuring and cataloging. He, who is now revered as the second discoverer of America, gave us the modern insight that everything is interconnected on our planet: "Everything is interaction," he wrote in his travel diary. What a fitting motto that could be for this forum – indeed not a forum of self-reflection, in which we Germans do what we like to do: discuss ourselves, but a forum in which we engage with the world, a globalized world, in which today more than ever everything is interaction. Everything is interconnected.

Whoever takes the naming of the forum, this homage to Prussian Enlightenment, at its word knows: The name is a commitment. Enlightenment means bringing the existing before the tribunal of reason, as Golo Mann expressed it. We Europeans are rightly proud of the achievements of the Enlightenment: the respect for human dignity, reason, and freedom. Those values on which our modern liberal democracies are founded. But if we take the claim of the namesakes seriously, then this forum must not only celebrate the idea of Enlightenment, but it must also enlighten itself. And that means critically questioning the historical reality of the Enlightenment, the political history of Western modernity – and uncomfortable questions arise: On whose shoulders was Western modernity built? At what cost, with what contradictions, what injustices? With what consequences extending into our present world?

It is these questions that are currently moving to the center of our debates with great force and urgency. They are the voices of those who have long had no voice in Western discourses. They are the stories of those who lived and often still live on the shadow side of Western progress history. Black Lives Matter, racism, discrimination, global justice, colonial looted art: All these debates are being conducted in the countries of the so-called global South and now also with us and in the USA. And I believe that this is urgently necessary. In my view, it is as historically wrong as it is politically dangerous to dismiss these debates as identity politics – as a struggle for recognition by disadvantaged groups, as a means of social exclusion, as a "we" against "them." No, these questions are, in the spirit of Enlightenment, universal questions. They concern us all. Because they relate to our shared history, and – if we believe in the humanistic project of Enlightenment – even more to our common future.

"The truth is that the universal does not belong to any one group," you, esteemed Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie, once said to American students. I am very pleased that you are here today and will speak shortly. The story of every person has the potential for the universal – that is your credo. The truth is, however, that far too many stories have so far neither been told nor heard. Here, in this forum, in these collections, they should be. If that succeeds, then we will have come much closer to answering the question of its purpose.

Today we celebrate the opening of the centerpiece of this forum. No doubt, the Ethnological Collections still have an enormous fascination: The world cultures come to us and we look at the unfamiliar. We learn, and perhaps we even understand, very much in the Humboldtian sense. Researching, being curious, collecting: For the brothers Humboldt, this also meant a self-liberation from the confines of Prussian provincialism. And in a way, it still is today, a – in the best sense – world experience.

But there is also – as Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie reminds us – a very different perspective: that of many African states, for example, which today rightfully claims new recognition for itself. Particularly the countries of Africa have lost an immense part of their art – also through the plundering expeditions of Europeans. "We grew up without an important part of our historical heritage," said the Nigerian artist Emeka Ogboh to me in a conversation. A sentence that occupies me, that must occupy us.

We know today that the origin story of many of the artworks and cultural objects from Africa, from Asia, from Latin America, that are displayed in our museums, remains obscure or has not yet been disclosed. Worse still, many were not lawfully "acquired," and behind them lies a history of subjugation, plundering, theft, and murder. Little is clear – and how much research is still needed here is exemplified by the debate surrounding the wonderfully crafted Luf boat.

A Federal President is not a museum maker. But museums that not only present artifacts but also seriously confront the history of colonialism will have to look different from traditional museums. The "how" is being debated in Dresden, Stuttgart, Brussels, Paris, and London just as it is here in Berlin. And it cannot be otherwise. Ethnological collections are no longer shown merely for their own sake, but they make the history of our relationship with the places of origin a topic. Not least, they trace the footprints of these relationships in the here and now.

And this goes far beyond the question of how a museum must be conceived. It is about our self-understanding and our responsibility towards history. We – and by that, I mean Europeans as a whole – will have to overcome certain patterns of thought and perceive and allow other perspectives. This also means that we must seek dialogue: with the countries and regions from which these artifacts originate. And we will find that the simple solutions claimed by some are often no solutions at all. I add: Despite all criticism, the conversation has begun and shows initial results. The return of significant Benin bronzes, negotiated together with Nigeria, is a signal of change, and I am grateful to the Prussian Cultural Heritage Foundation, the Humboldt Forum, the State Minister, and the Foreign Office for their commitment to this process. The discussion about origin and return, about new forms of museum cooperation, including assistance in building their own museums, will have to be conducted with these countries, not just by us Germans, but by all European countries with colonial histories. This process will be painful, that much is certain. But we Europeans have a responsibility towards this history: each country for itself and we as Europeans together.

What is the measure of our responsibility? It is tiny compared to the history of the colonial empires of the French, British, Spanish, Portuguese, Dutch, or Belgians. So many believe. But as Federal President, I say clearly: Even though the German Empire sought its "place in the sun" only late, there is no reason for a good conscience. And precisely for this reason, this resurgent castle must also serve as a reminder and admonition: of militarism, of nationalism in the German Empire, and also of German colonialism. The truth is: When it comes to the colonial era, we Germans, who are otherwise so historically conscious, have far too many gaps! We have blind spots in our memory and our self-perception.

Here, in the heart of Berlin, the so-called Berlin Conference took place in 1884/85, better known as the Congo Conference, where, at the invitation of Chancellor Otto von Bismarck, the European great powers and the USA effectively divided the African continent among themselves. The truth also includes that German colonialism was by no means only a matter of monarchical ambition, but large parts of the population were in favor of colonial conquests – just think of the disputes before the Reichstag elections in 1907, which have gone down in German history books as the so-called Hottentottenwahlen.

In our collective memory, the German colonial period has long been either glorified or completely forgotten. Perhaps we preferred not to know too precisely at which of these distant places in what was then German South West Africa, in German East Africa, in present-day Cameroon, in Togo, in Kiautschou in present-day China, in Papua New Guinea, and the South Sea islands, Germans as colonial masters oppressed, exploited, robbed, and killed people. Shedding more light on this darkness is not only a task for historians. The injustices committed by Germans during the colonial period concern us as a whole society. Because in our country, even today, in the midst of everyday life, there is racism, discrimination, devaluation of those perceived as foreign – up to physical assaults and terrible acts of violence. I remain convinced: We will only understand and overcome the deeper roots of everyday racism if we illuminate the blind spots of our memory, if we engage much more than we have so far with our colonial history!

Germany's entanglements in the colonial period – what could better illustrate this than the example of Namibia? There, in what was once German South West Africa, German so-called Schutztruppen committed the first genocide of this bloody century at the beginning of the 20th century. It took far too long – a whole century – to even acknowledge this crime on the part of Germany. The crimes of that time continue to have effects today. To this day, the suffering shapes the descendants of the victims, and many of them still live in bitter poverty. And to this day, it torments many Herero and Nama that their ancestors have not found a final resting place and thus no peace. A few years ago, negotiations began between the Federal Government and the Namibian government and the descendants of the Herero and Nama about a reconciliation agreement, in which the crimes of that time are to be referred to as what they were: a genocide from today's perspective. I sincerely hope that these negotiations will come to a consensual conclusion.

Jürgen Habermas has outlined in a new essay that the memory of "our recently repressed colonial history" is an important expansion of our political and historical self-understanding – without diminishing or losing the significance of the memory of the Holocaust. I am convinced: The memory of the civilizational break of the Shoah is and remains unique in our national memory. It is part of our identity. I do not say this as a historian – the discipline of history has its own professional debates about uniqueness and comparability – but I say this as Federal President. I only add: The memory of the Holocaust does not stand in opposition to the empathetic and conscious remembrance of other injustices, other suffering! On the contrary: The brokenness that the Shoah leaves us hopefully opens our eyes to our responsibility towards history. The dignity of man, on which our constitution rests, is indeed the dignity of all people.

The crimes of the colonial period, conquest, oppression, exploitation, robbery, murder of tens of thousands of people, need an appropriate place in our memory. We must confront our responsibility for this part of German history. Because it is about our future, about our coexistence in a country where the world's cultures are at home and want to be. If this forum truly becomes a forum, a place where these debates are held and where we actually come closer to answers to the many questions that this castle raises, then the question of its purpose will have been answered.

I have great confidence that you, dear Mr. Koch, Mr. Parzinger, Mr. Dorgerloh, and your staff have precisely this in mind and will do everything to make it happen. I would like to sincerely thank the three of you today for your courage and determination to stand in and often against the wind. Your task is truly difficult; it is easy to criticize it. But if we want to set sail for new shores, if we want to find a different, enlightened understanding of the artifacts and their history, an understanding that intensively engages with the culture and social reality in their regions of origin, then we need people who take on this task and this responsibility – people like you! And therefore, my special thanks!

At the beginning, I said: So, now it stands here. And now? The answer is: Now it is our turn! It is up to us to fill this building with meaning, with life, with debate. If I wish for something today, it is this: May you succeed, may it succeed for the visitors, may it succeed for all of us together!