Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the memorial event for the 50th anniversary of the attack on the Israeli Olympic team on September 5, 2022, in Fürstenfeldbruck:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

5 September 2022 · Memorial event for the 50th anniversary of the attack on the Israeli Olympic team · Fürstenfeldbruck, Germany

Context
Steinmeier spoke at the 50th anniversary memorial for the 1972 Munich Olympic massacre in Fürstenfeldbruck, honoring the eleven Israeli athletes and one police officer killed.
Main themes
Munich massacre remembrance, 1972 Olympic attack victims, German responsibility and failure, grief and mourning of families, terrorism against Israeli athletes, Holocaust legacy, German-Israeli relations, security failures, Olympic Games history
Duration
~17 min
58th percentile
Words
2,052
58th percentile
Sentences
138
77th percentile
Readability
56
80th percentile
Grade
9.1
12th percentile
Syntax
2.64
9th percentile
Vocabulary
2.45
94th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 33%31%
  • Ceremonial 31%30%
  • Geopolitical 23%22%
  • Institutional 13%12%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

138 sentences in 47 paragraphs

David Berger

Anton Fliegerbauer

Ze’ev Friedman

Yossef Gutfreund

Eliezer Halfin

Yossef Romano

Amitzur Shapira

Kehat Shor

Mark Slavin

Andrei Spitzer

Yakov Springer

Moshe Weinberg

We come together to remember and to mourn. We mourn for twelve people who lost their lives in a horrific manner 50 years ago in the worst terrorist attack in the history of the then-young Federal Republic. We mourn for eleven athletes and one police officer. Eleven Jewish athletes, coaches, and referees who had traveled to Munich as part of the Israeli team, with great ambitions and great hopes. All hope ended in a nightmare.

Eight heavily armed members of the Palestinian terrorist group "Black September" entered the Olympic Village completely unhindered in the early morning of September 5, 1972, and took the eleven Israeli athletes hostage. They murdered two of them brutally in their quarters at Connollystraße 31, while the nine others were killed here at this place, where the rescue operation by the German forces catastrophically failed. It ended in a bloodbath. Eleven Jewish athletes were dead, murdered in Germany. Of all places, in Germany.

Dear guests, today is a day of mourning, remembrance, and reflection. I am deeply grateful that you, the families of the victims, are here today, and that you, esteemed President Herzog, are here by my side. Without all of you, without the relatives and without the presence of the State of Israel, I could not imagine a dignified commemoration. I thank everyone who contributed in recent weeks to make a joint remembrance possible today.

Dear relatives, we cannot fathom the suffering, the pain you have endured. We can only begin to imagine what the loss of your sons, husbands, and fathers has meant and still means to you.

How does a young woman continue to live after just having her first child, whose father will not return? How does one continue to live with the images of the room marked by the traces of the murder, with the knowledge that the husband or father had to endure hours of terror in that room?

How does one continue to live with the memory that the husband, after being shot, had to bleed to death in front of his colleagues in indescribable agony?

How does one continue to live when receiving two postcards from Munich, in which the now-murdered son wrote that everything was wonderful and that he was looking forward to coming home?

I know: The suffering, the pain, the trauma, they continue to live on in your families, to this day. Nothing in your life is as it was before 1972. Nothing is as it could have been and should have been. This gnawing pain has lasted for five decades.

The Munich Games were supposed to be very different from the last Games in Germany, those of 1936, which the Nazis staged as a bombastic propaganda show, shamelessly and unscrupulously abusing the Olympic idea for their purposes. Munich 1972 was meant to be a counter-program to Berlin 1936. The young Federal Republic wanted to present itself as an open, liberal society that was respected and esteemed among democracies – and that it was aware of its responsibility to history and acknowledged this history.

Yes, there was the ambition to present "cheerful games" in a Germany that had left behind the Pickelhaube and goose-stepping. But there was also the responsibility of the host for athletes from all over the world, especially those from Israel. That Israel, which has been threatened from the very first day of its existence, surrounded by hatred and enmity.

In Israel, it was known and is known that the Jewish state must be strong and resilient. In Germany, the athletes from Israel were our guests. Their safety was entrusted to us. What a huge act of trust it was to participate in the Olympic Games in the land of the perpetrators after the crime against humanity of the Holocaust. Among the athletes and their coaches were also survivors of the Holocaust.

The sad and painful truth of this commemoration is: We wanted to be good hosts, but we did not live up to the trust that the Israeli athletes and their families placed in Germany. They were not safe. They were not protected. They were tortured and killed in our country by terrorists.

We in Germany were not prepared for such an attack, and yet we should have been – that is also part of the bitter truth. We were not prepared for the fact that this time foreign terrorists would abuse the Olympic idea, cold-bloodedly and ready for any form of violence. We were not prepared for a terrorist attack deliberately staged before an international television audience.

The effort in 1972 to present Germany as a peaceful, friendly democracy tragically failed in Munich. The Olympic Village became an international stage for the assassins, an international stage for hatred and violence against Jews. And that should never have happened.

"We stand aghast before a truly heinous crime," said the then Federal President Gustav Heinemann, struggling for composure himself. Yes, it was a truly heinous crime. But that is not enough to explain the catastrophe of Munich.

Many later said that this catastrophe was "unimaginable." For those who were there at the time, that may have been the all-consuming feeling. But: Shouldn't we – especially we Germans – have known that the idea of the unimaginable is a fallacy that can have terrible consequences? "Unimaginability" is meant to protect from questioning. It distracts from the real question: Why could what should never have happened occur?

When we remember today, we must remember sincerely and truthfully. This memory is painful. It is especially so for you, dear relatives. But it must also be painful for us in Germany.

The events in Munich 1972 have left deep, dark scars in the lives of the relatives. The trauma of Munich has etched itself into the collective memory of the people in Israel. The attack has also left deep, dark scars with us, in the city of Munich, in the Federal Republic of Germany.

This commemoration today can therefore only be sincere if we are willing to face painful insights. If we acknowledge that the history of the Olympic attack is also a story of misjudgments, of terrible, of deadly mistakes, yes, of a failure. And this acknowledgment is long overdue.

No, the perpetrators did not come from Germany. The responsibility for these murders lay with the Palestinian perpetrators and their Libyan accomplices. It is very bitter that no word of sympathy, no word of regret comes from today's political representatives of these countries. It was they, the perpetrators and their accomplices, eight Palestinian attackers and their masterminds, who brought their hatred and terror to Munich. They bear responsibility for the act. But that does not free us. We also bear responsibility: the responsibility of the host for not having prevented what we should have prevented; the responsibility to protect the lives of the hostages who were in the hands of terrorists.

Today, 50 years later, many, far too many questions remain unanswered. The Games continued on the day of the memorial service: "The games must go on." And politics also did everything to return to normal as quickly as possible. The attack was followed by years and decades of silence, of repression, years of growing indifference towards the fate of the survivors. Years of callousness. That too is a failure.

How could all this happen? We must ask ourselves this question and seek answers. We must finally want to find these answers. Why were the surviving perpetrators deported so quickly and never prosecuted? It is hard to bear that one of the perpetrators still boasts of this crime today and assures on camera that he would act the same way again.

What were the exact connections of the perpetrators to German right-wing extremists and the Red Army Faction? Why were the German security forces so poorly equipped and overwhelmed? Did Germany ignore warnings from Israel – and why was Israeli assistance in the rescue rejected? Why were files kept under wraps for decades or even denied their existence? Why was there not even a parliamentary inquiry?

We are talking about a great tragedy and a threefold failure. The first failure concerns the preparation of the Games and the security concept. The second encompasses the events of September 5 and 6, 1972. The third failure begins the day after the attack: the silence, the repression, the forgetting!

I expressly welcome the fact that the federal government is now proposing the establishment of an Israeli-German historians' commission. I hope that the commission will succeed in shedding more light on this dark chapter. A prerequisite is that it receives as comprehensive access to documents as possible and that it is supported in its work to the best of our ability.

The experts from both countries bear great responsibility: Their work will perhaps uncover painful, uncomfortable truths, and it must uncover them. But we must process the history of Munich '72 – and, moreover, the history of its non-processing.

An important lesson from Munich '72 is: We must decisively combat any form of anti-Semitism in our country, of anti-Semitic hatred, and especially of anti-Semitic violence. That is and remains our responsibility to history.

Another important lesson: We must be resilient as a democracy. Freedom and security are not opposites. They are mutually dependent. A free society can never fully protect itself from terrorist attacks that aim at one thing: freedom itself. But we must be vigilant against the enemies of democracy, both internal and external. For we live in a time when liberal democracies are being challenged more than ever, from within and from without.

And one more lesson that Munich '72 teaches us: Only if we know the truth, if we acknowledge our mistakes and omissions, can the wound that our rule of law also suffered in 1972 heal.

Dear guests, it is of course not about us, and certainly not just about us. It is primarily about those who lost their lives back then. It is about you, the relatives. You have a right to finally know the truth. To finally receive answers to the questions that have tormented you for decades. And that includes the question of why you were left alone with your suffering, your pain for so long.

It took 45 years for a dignified place of remembrance to be established on the Olympic grounds. At the opening five years ago, the then Israeli President Reuven Rivlin and some of the survivors were present. We mourned together, we remembered together. But it would take another five years to reach an agreement on appropriate compensation.

Dear guests, dear relatives, dear President Herzog, we are united in silent remembrance of the twelve people who lost their lives back then. We are united in pain. But we should not forget: It is your pain, the pain of the relatives. It is your pain that we have not sufficiently acknowledged for far too long. And I also know: The understanding reached now will not be able to heal all wounds.

I therefore address the following words explicitly to you, whose lives have been dominated by loss, mourning, and pain for fifty years: We cannot make amends for what has happened, nor for what you have experienced and suffered in terms of defensiveness, ignorance, and injustice. That shames me. I ask you, as the head of state of this country and on behalf of the Federal Republic of Germany, for forgiveness for the lack of protection of the Israeli athletes at the time of the Olympic Games in Munich and for the lack of clarification afterwards; for allowing what happened to happen.

It is my duty and my need to acknowledge our German responsibility – here and today and for the future. May this day lead to you, the relatives, feeling seen in your pain, that you sense that we take our responsibility seriously.

The friendship, the reconciliation that Israel has granted us is nothing less than a miracle. May this day also lead to us Germans proving ourselves worthy of the most precious good that is the foundation of this friendship – that good which was so damaged at this place fifty years ago: trust.