Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the presentation of results of the project "Ethics of Digitalization" on February 7, 2022, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

8 February 2022 · Presentation of results of the project "Ethics of Digitalization" · Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a Berlin audience at Schloss Bellevue for the presentation of results of the "Ethics of Digitalization" project on February 7, 2022.
Main themes
Ethics of digitalization, digital transformation, democracy and digital public space, artificial intelligence, digital self-determination, social media and disinformation, hate speech and online abuse, platform responsibility, digital education, Russia-Ukraine conflict disinformation, international cooperation on digital ethics
Duration
~13 min
47th percentile
Words
1,614
47th percentile
Sentences
78
51st percentile
Readability
47
53rd percentile
Grade
11.8
42nd percentile
Syntax
3.04
53rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
35th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 29%29%
  • Ceremonial 22%22%
  • Technological 18%18%
  • Institutional 13%13%
  • Economic 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 8%8%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

78 sentences in 21 paragraphs

A warm welcome to Schloss Bellevue – both here on site and connected from many places in Germany and around the world.

When we started thinking about this project in 2019, it was not yet common for most of us to connect via video or phone conferences. Livestreams with the Federal President were the exception, not the rule. And questions were asked by the audience on site, not through digital tools. Since then, the pandemic has given us a significant push towards digitalization, whether we wanted it or not, and with that, we are already right in the middle of our topic today.

Our world is becoming increasingly digital, and many people have experienced in recent years what this can mean for their own lives. Just last Thursday, I attended a conference of works councils organized by a large German trade union. I saw and experienced how the digitalization of the working world was debated there – and that reminded me of the origins of this project: the demand for an ethics of digitalization that should provide us with support and direction in the digital transformation of the economy and science, of debate and democracy, of society and coexistence.

The project "Ethics of Digitalization" arose from this demand, which I have discussed with many people – in Germany and on trips abroad, with trade unions and at a church convention, in conversations in the USA and in China, and on many other occasions. I am convinced: When it comes to artificial intelligence or the question of digital self-determination, when such important ethical questions are open, our perspective must reach beyond national borders.

The debate about digital modernity also takes place in public spaces that are themselves in the midst of digital structural change. Social media, in particular, do not provide an ideal space for debate as long as extreme opinions are automatically given particularly large attention. When groups increasingly isolate themselves from one another and when reason is considered a poorly marketable boredom, then real debates become increasingly difficult.

Yes, the logic of social media is being deliberately exploited from both inside and outside to spread disinformation and propaganda – especially now, around the conflict at the Russian-Ukrainian border, we see a lot of it. But the structural upheavals of the digital public are primarily self-made – due to specific political failures regarding democracy: failures in digital education, failures in dealing with those who turn against democracy using digital means, and failures of the dominant digital platforms. These failures harm the public space – and democracy becomes collateral damage of the business model.

I am glad that the fellows of the project have also paid special attention to these questions, such as the question of automatic moderation of content on large platforms. And, I would like to add at this point, I explicitly welcome the recent decision of the Federal Constitutional Court in the case of Renate Künast. It is a decision that, in my view, complements important legislation of recent years and clarifies the criteria for hate and attacks on the internet. No one should have to endure being insulted and abused online without taking action, not even a politician. Everyone must be able to defend themselves in case of doubt.

This is especially true when digital platforms are misused as safe spaces to incite against volunteer local politicians and engaged mayors, as we have unfortunately experienced all too often in recent weeks and months. When the mindless shouting of a few drives the reasonable majority out of the public space, when the perception of public offices locally becomes increasingly unbearable, then that poisons democracy at its roots. And we must not allow that.

Our democratic rule of law works – that is good. Even better would be if the large platforms finally fulfilled their own responsibility for democracy out of their own initiative. Just because the unspeakable happens daily, even every second, we must never accept it as normality. We must never allow people to lose all protection in the digital crossfire!

For the many efforts in the last two years on this project, I would like to sincerely thank the Network of Centers, the supporting institutions, and especially those involved there. I also thank the Mercator Foundation for supporting the project. And above all, I thank the 151 fellows, the young researchers from 51 countries. They have worked on very different topics during the working phases. The report of results, which will be presented shortly, shows how fruitful the joint reflection of many smart minds from around the world has been.

I do not want to hide the fact that there has also been criticism of this project. Why, some have asked, do we prefer to organize global discussion rounds on ethics instead of addressing digital innovation capabilities here in Germany? The truth is: Yes, Germany and Europe have a digital backlog. When it comes to the data economy, to smart digital business models in the mass market, German and European companies are often lagging behind. There is also much to be done in the digitalization of the state, from schools to health offices. I have spoken about this on many occasions over the past two years.

But it is also true: Few can keep up with German companies in the digitalization of industry and manufacturing. In the basic technologies of digital modernity, in microelectronics and semiconductor production, Germany is part of the global top tier.

However, what is much more important to me is: Ethics and innovation must not be a question of either-or. A good competition for the best ideas, the smartest applications, and the most intelligent products only arises when the framework conditions are clearly defined. Hardly anyone wants to live in dystopian conditions, controlled by algorithms or threatened by autonomous weapon systems, to name just two examples. However, if we want to avoid a global competition towards the lowest possible standard, then we need the debate about ethical standards, and we need it in as many places in the world as possible.

I know that this goal is still ambitious. Differences in digital policy may have become even greater, as the view towards China shows. But I am pleased that the new American government is seeking exchange with Europe. And I am equally pleased that at the European level, with the Digital Services Act and the Digital Markets Act, very concrete, fundamental laws for further shaping our digital future are now on the way.

Europe, it seems to me, is in these days finding its way. What follows from all this when we also consider the perspectives of Asia, Africa, and South America? A woman who can help us find an answer is Malavika Jayaram. I am very pleased to welcome you here with us in Bellevue. You are a lawyer, have researched legal questions of digitalization in Europe, the USA, Brazil, and India. Today, you lead the Digital Asia Hub in Singapore, an institution that has co-designed this project. Who could think better about an international ethics of digitalization than you? Thank you for making the effort to travel here to Berlin to be with us today. We are all looking forward to your results.

I would also like to welcome Sandra Cortesi. She is the director of the "Youth and Media" project at Harvard University at the Berkman Klein Center for Internet and Society. The Berkman Klein Center was the hub of this project across the Atlantic. Ms. Cortesi, you are a psychologist and are particularly interested in the behavior and development of children and adolescents in the context of digitalization. I am glad that you are bringing this perspective to our table today. Welcome.

Almost an old acquaintance is Wolfgang Schulz. You were already here in the summer of 2020, at the – pandemic-related – already hybrid kick-off conference of the project. Your focus is on the normative and legal consequences of the digital structural change of the public sphere. You lead the Leibniz Institute for Media Research and the Alexander von Humboldt Institute for Internet and Society here in Berlin, and you coordinate the project on the ethics of digitalization together with your colleagues at the other participating institutes. It is nice to have you back here at Schloss Bellevue, Mr. Schulz.

Finally, I welcome Carla Hustedt, unfortunately only on screen. Since April 1 of last year, you have been leading the newly created area of "Digitalized Society" at the Mercator Foundation. The Mercator Foundation has financed this project, and the "Ethics of Digitalization" was, so to speak, the foundation's entry into the field of digitalization. Few institutions in Germany have a similarly dense network in science, business, politics, and administration; therefore, I am glad that you are taking on this topic. I am looking forward to your assessment of the project's results – and to the next steps that will follow.

In conclusion, and without preempting the results, one thing is clear to me: Reflecting on our behavior, our limits, and our desires in the digital space is never completed with a project. On the contrary: Reflecting on the ethics of digitalization will – and must! – accompany us for many years to come – just think of the upcoming innovations in the fields of artificial intelligence, virtual reality, or the changing interface between humans and machines.

For the future, I hope that we all continue to engage in this debate – not only at home, in our own societies, but wherever possible worldwide, on the way to a hopefully global understanding of the ethics of digitalization.

Now I look forward to the presentation of the project results and to our discussion.