Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the reception for the Presidents of the Constitutional Courts of the Council of Europe member states on May 4, 2023, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

6 May 2023 · Reception for the Presidents of the Constitutional Courts of the Council of Europe member states · Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed presidents of Constitutional Courts from Council of Europe member states at Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, on May 4, 2023, discussing climate change as a constitutional challenge.
Main themes
Climate change and constitutional law, climate protection litigation, intergenerational rights and fundamental freedoms, rule of law and judicial review, network of constitutional courts, Paris Climate Agreement enforcement, indigenous peoples and climate impact, international climate policy complexity, European Court of Human Rights, comparative constitutional jurisdiction
Duration
~16 min
54th percentile
Words
1,898
54th percentile
Sentences
91
58th percentile
Readability
36
28th percentile
Grade
13.4
61st percentile
Syntax
2.92
37th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
46th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 56%37%
  • Geopolitical 16%11%
  • Environmental 15%10%
  • Ceremonial 10%7%
  • Social 3%2%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 33%

91 sentences in 17 paragraphs

I have rarely had so many judges as guests. A warm welcome to Schloss Bellevue! As unusual as your visit here is, the topic that occupies you this year is all the more prevalent: climate change. More specifically, "climate change as a challenge for constitutional law and constitutional jurisdiction."

There is no doubt that the fight against climate change must be intensified. We will need greater efforts, especially at the international level. I have just returned from a trip to Canada, which also took me to the Inuit in the Arctic region. This indigenous group is literally threatened in its livelihoods and way of life. It may be small, but it shows us today what threatens all of humanity tomorrow if we do not halt the trend of global warming. Climate change is a global phenomenon and not a challenge that a single state can address alone. The conditions and requirements for successful climate policy are internationally extremely complex and demanding. They cannot be resolved through a simple enforcement of laws.

Therefore, the question of whether and to what extent courts can review the fight against climate change or even act as actors themselves is particularly pressing. The Federal Constitutional Court has already dealt with climate protection several times—once with very broad public resonance when it issued its climate protection ruling on March 24, 2021. You all must have read the decision with great interest.

The protection of natural livelihoods, enshrined in Article 20a of the Basic Law, the fundamental rights of the Basic Law in an intertemporal dimension, and German legislation for the implementation of the Paris Climate Agreement—these are the constitutional points of reference that the Federal Constitutional Court chose. According to the Federal Constitutional Court, the Basic Law obliges the legislator to secure fundamental rights-protected freedom over time and to ensure a proportional distribution of freedom opportunities across generations. The Basic Law obliges the state to take action. It obliges the state to "handle the natural livelihoods with such care and to leave them to future generations in such a condition that subsequent generations can preserve them not only at the cost of radical self-restraint."

The climate protection ruling has not only, but predominantly, found approval in the German public and has motivated many individuals and non-governmental organizations in this country to sue the federal government, state governments, or even large corporations in order to force them to comply with the requirements of the Paris Climate Agreement and to achieve the 1.5-degree limit. Just in November 2022, the state government of Baden-Württemberg was ordered by the Administrative Court of Baden-Württemberg to adopt a climate protection concept due to a lawsuit from the German Environmental Aid. Further climate lawsuits are set to be heard soon before the Higher Administrative Court of Berlin-Brandenburg. Climate lawsuits are also pending in other countries. In the Netherlands, a climate lawsuit was successful as early as 2019 when the Supreme Court in The Hague upheld the decision of the lower court that had obligated the government to increase climate protection.

Other courts outside Germany are more skeptical of climate protection lawsuits. The European Court of Justice in Luxembourg has already condemned Germany and France for failing to comply with European air quality directives—however, it rejected a subjectivization when it dismissed a lawsuit from a Paris citizen for 21 million euros in damages in December 2022. Many lawsuits are now pending. The European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg was approached last autumn by young people from Germany and this spring by 2,000 "climate seniors" from Switzerland. The topic you are discussing at this year's conference concerns people—transnationally, intergenerationally—and they are using the instruments that the law provides.

The possibility of suing for more climate protection in courts depends on a legal avenue for such matters. The ability of individuals to turn to courts is a central element of the rule of law. In Germany, the right to a hearing is characterized by the Federal Constitutional Court as the "fundamental right of man." The European Convention on Human Rights guarantees it in Article 6 as the right to a fair trial. Without these rule-of-law guarantees, climate protection and compliance with climate protection goals could hardly be adjudicated by courts.

The Federal Constitutional Court summarizes the cooperation of constitutional courts in Europe, the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, and the European Court of Justice in Luxembourg with the term "network of constitutional courts." This term is not found in the European Convention on Human Rights nor in the law of the European Union, and we certainly do not find it in the law of nation-states either. Nevertheless, it is convincing. It describes a development of constitutional jurisdiction in Europe that has so far expressed a considerable degree of consensus, a common sense. A consensus that the exercise of political power must be democratically legitimized, must be accountable in recurring democratic elections, that the exercise of power is bound by the constitution, and that this constitutional binding is subject to independent judicial and constitutional review. Despite all the differences between the member states of the Council of Europe: This is our common constitutional tradition and the foundation of our shared European political tradition.

We live in turbulent times, in times of uncertainty and upheaval, in times of crises. And this has not started only with the unlawful and criminal invasion of Russia into Ukraine. This attack, however, is the most visible expression of the attacks to which our democratic way of life is exposed.

Particularly the people in Ukraine fight daily to defend freedom and democracy. But even we, who are not at war, have long been confronted with active, sometimes aggressive rejection of our liberal, democratic, and rule-of-law convictions. This challenges our democratic and rule-of-law societal form even within our community of states. Freedom, human rights, democracy, and the rule of law are under pressure: Even some of those who have gained political power democratically openly or covertly restrict fundamental rights, limit or eliminate minority rights, and attempt to silence political opposition and bring independent media under government control. All to eliminate the risk of potential loss of power.

In the face of all these threats, we must make it clear: It is one of the fundamental and indispensable rules of our democratic and rule-of-law system that individual freedom imposes constraints on political design. This applies particularly to politically relevant freedom of opinion and assembly or to the rights of the media that criticize and control politics. This applies to rules regarding elections that temporally limit the exercise of political power and ensure that the government can always be held accountable for its political actions by the voters. And this applies especially to the review of political actions against the standard of the constitution by independent courts! The states of the Council of Europe, from which you all come, have agreed on this fundamental canon. We must stabilize our democratic and rule-of-law systems and, where necessary, further develop them. And where democracy and the rule of law have been restricted, we must return to the fundamental and indispensable rules and thus to our common fundamental values.

As constitutional judges, you bear a particularly heavy responsibility. For: The independence of the courts is a great good, but also a great responsibility and obligation. Jurisprudence can easily come into conflict with the political will of the government. This is inherent in constitutional binding, and courts must not only endure this. They must also make it clear that this is precisely their task: to administer justice not according to the dictates or expectations of politics, but solely according to law and justice. The rule of law aims to limit and bind state power—not least to guarantee individual freedom.

Anyone who reduces the understanding of democracy to the recurring holding of elections, who does not recognize individual fundamental rights, press and media freedom, the rule of law, and minority protection as fundamental conditions of democracy, is departing from the family of liberal democracies. Democracy is either liberal, or it is not democracy. The assertion of illiberal democracy paves the way for the tyranny of the majority. For me, part of the understanding of democracy is that the will of the majority is curbed by the separation of powers and fundamental rights, by minority protection, by rule-of-law guarantees, and constitutional review by independent judges.

It is no surprise that authoritarian governments often make an attempt to restrict or eliminate not only press freedom but especially judicial review by independent courts as one of their first measures, by filling the courts with compliant party loyalists or by changing the legal framework for decisions. Such illiberal and authoritarian currents have existed for some time. This should concern us, especially when it comes to states where people have long lived in unfreedom under a totalitarian ideology. But not only there are people fascinated by the seemingly simple solutions of authoritarian politics. We must not allow this development! On the contrary, we must repeatedly make it clear: There is no freedom for all without democracy and the rule of law!

A fundamental characteristic of the legal culture in our European societies is the limitation of power by law. The respect for the law has been and remains decisive. Our societies agree on the idea of living together on the basis of law. A law whose application and enforcement is controlled by the constitutional courts, the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, and the European Court of Justice in Luxembourg. Europe is a community of states that have repeatedly been hostile to each other throughout history. We look back on fanatical nationalism, devastating wars, and millions of victims of violent rule. We all know the role Germany played in the 20th century in this degradation of humanity and contempt for the law. In this memory, it is of particular importance for my country to appreciate and defend the progress of freedom and the rule of law. Today, we see ourselves in Europe as partners, based on shared values and a common legal tradition. Europe has become a legal community within the European Union, but also in the Council of Europe, that protects the rights of individuals and places the strength of law above the law of the stronger.

That this basic consensus is being questioned in some states should also make those of us whose rule of law is not exposed to such dangers reflect. I appeal to all of you to advocate for our common convictions and fundamental values. With your jurisprudence and your attitude, you can make constitutional binding, power control, and power limitation visible. Freedom through law, that is what people experience through you, as you help the weak in your societies to their rights.

Our common legal conviction becomes visible in your cooperation, in your exchange of thoughts and experiences. Gatherings and meetings are a sign of the Europe-wide validity of the principle of law; they promote mutual understanding of each other's legal systems, of the differences and commonalities. Moreover, personal relationships and friendships arise—and this should not be underestimated. With your work, you make an indispensable contribution to the integration of Europe, to the development of our common legal culture, and to its consolidation within the framework of the Council of Europe. This deserves the highest recognition and respect. I thank you all for that!