Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier on the 175th anniversary of the German National Assembly in the Paulskirche on May 18, 2023, in Frankfurt am Main:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

23 May 2023 · 175th anniversary of the German National Assembly · Paulskirche, Frankfurt am Main, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a ceremony at the Paulskirche in Frankfurt on May 18, 2023, marking the 175th anniversary of the first German National Assembly.
Main themes
1848 German Revolution, Paulskirche National Assembly, democracy and freedom, parliamentary history, civic courage, national unity, historical memory, pioneers of democracy, women's rights and equality, Jewish emancipation, European unity, democratic heritage
Duration
~21 min
68th percentile
Words
2,507
68th percentile
Sentences
116
70th percentile
Readability
42
41st percentile
Grade
12.7
53rd percentile
Syntax
3.09
60th percentile
Vocabulary
2.26
65th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 41%41%
  • Geopolitical 25%25%
  • Social 20%20%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

116 sentences in 36 paragraphs

It was a wonderful spring. And the people in 1848 understood this not only meteorologically. It was a political, a social spring, a time of great hopes and expectations, but above all, it was an enthusiastic new beginning. A beginning in which almost daily new ideas were thought, spoken, wished for, demanded, and attempted. Christopher Clark calls this time a "revolutionary spring," in which the entire atmosphere was filled with a desire for change.

The revolution of 1848 and the first German National Assembly here in the Paulskirche were unprecedented events for Germany at that time. The hope was great, and the willingness to overthrow the old and dare the new had captured many.

We, the descendants, know how many dreams initially remained unfulfilled, how long the struggle for the realization of the ideas and motives of 1848 would last. But we also know: Here, brave people, inspired by the best motives, set something in motion that was an irreplaceable step on the long road to democracy and freedom in a united Germany. It was the moment, it was the year when subjects became citizens. When a spirit of freedom was awakened that, at least in the long term, could never again be suppressed.

And we know that we still live off much of what happened in 1848. That we are still heirs of the March Revolution and the Paulskirche: heirs of the civic courage of the barricade fighters and the political commitment of the representatives of the National Assembly.

1848 is a decisive year—and it must remain alive in our memory. The March Revolution and the Paulskirche are significant and consequential events in the history of German freedom and democracy. We have every reason to celebrate this—by the way, also as a sign against those who despise our parliamentary democracy.

"We have the greatest task to fulfill"—we just heard this sentence from Heinrich von Gagern. It probably captures the feeling and awareness of the vast majority of representatives who gathered here in the Paulskirche 175 years ago.

"We have the greatest task to fulfill"—this can be a burdensome awareness. But it can also generate courage, momentum, and confidence. It is indeed still astonishing how quickly the representatives back then invented and further developed so much of what still constitutes parliamentary activity today.

What stood before them was also what they carried in their hearts: the longing for national unity and for freedom and participation of those who lived together in this nation. This longing, indeed the promise that this National Assembly already represented within itself, was symbolized by the colors black, red, and gold.

The men of the National Assembly—there were indeed only men at that time, which is the democratic deficit from today’s perspective—were nonetheless pioneers and trailblazers of ideas that are taken for granted today. There was Robert Blum, who had been elected to the National Assembly in Leipzig. He was not only a passionate democrat but also a pragmatic parliamentarian. He had an eye for the social question because he himself knew poverty and had grown up in poverty, and he was an early supporter of the women's movement.

There was Gabriel Riesser from Hamburg, this brave fighter for the equality of Jews. His struggle against discrimination and for equal rights would not go without success: he was the first Jew to be appointed a judge in Germany.

There was Arnold Ruge from Breslau, who spoke out against German nationalism here in the Paulskirche. He fought for the restoration of Poland and was a visionary of diplomacy and understanding. He proposed to this house a "Congress of Representatives of Free Peoples for the Peaceful Settlement of Their Affairs." At that time, he was ridiculed for his proposals, but the European Parliament and the United Nations today are indeed also realizations of his ideas.

And so it becomes clear: The minorities of yesterday are often the majorities of tomorrow—and it always takes people who think further and ahead. We owe much to the revolutionaries of 1848, and therefore they deserve our remembrance and our respect.

I want to point out a few aspects that are particularly important to me today. Most importantly for me: Revolution and Paulskirche belong together. Without the determined civic courage, without the revolutionary movements in many places in Germany, there would not have been a preliminary parliament and not a National Assembly in the Paulskirche. This National Assembly was the result of a democratic, freedom-seeking awakening from the people. It is good that the memory of the inseparable connection between revolution and the awakening of parliamentarism has remained alive, especially in southwestern Germany, even in times when it was pushed into the background in the rest of Germany.

Meanwhile, the cemetery of the March fallen is no longer ignored in Berlin; there, too, the popular uprising of March 1848 is confidently and publicly remembered. It becomes part of our collective memory that these uprisings made elections and the National Assembly possible. March 18 with its barricade fights and May 18 with the beginning of parliamentary work: these belong inseparably together. And because they belong together, my appeal: Let us respect the right to free elections! The right to vote was fought for with the sacrifice of lives. And let us respect our democratic institutions, the parliaments, the freely elected parliamentarians. Those who today mock parliaments, constantly speak of the system, of Gleichschaltung and opinion dictatorship, are in truth mocking those who fought for freedom and democracy.

Another important point: For this democratic awakening, a public sphere was necessary that became increasingly aware of itself—through the formation of associations, through assemblies, but above all through an increasingly powerful journalism. This societal self-understanding, this public and collective search for the right path, in freedom and in respect for one another, is and remains an indispensable foundation of democracy—just as is honest debate and the ability to compromise.

1848/49 were difficult years of learning for democracy. For at that time, the counterforces were also unleashed that still pose challenges to us today. With the parliaments, a counter-movement emerged: a populism that despises institutions and claims to represent the supposedly true will of the people alone. The idea of the nation democratized the state—and yet also brought forth exclusionary nationalism. Equality before the law was a revolutionary achievement—but it remained an empty promise for many because deep social inequality shaped the country and the region.

Today we know: The seemingly insurmountable contradictions between the so-called "democrats" and "liberals" at that time are also among the causes of the failure of 1848/49. Even if the terms have gained somewhat different meanings today, one lesson from that time remains: Democracy and liberalism belong together. A democracy is liberal, or it is not a democracy. A democracy without liberalism would allow the majority to become despotic and ultimately take away the rights of the minority. And a liberalism is only truly democratic when it concerns the well-being of all; when not only elites but everyone can claim their rights.

One more aspect is important to me: The political spring I spoke of in relation to Germany in 1848 was in reality a true spring of nations. For everywhere in Europe, the longing for freedom awakened simultaneously.

Christopher Clark points out in his new book "Revolutionary Spring" that the revolutions of 1848, in their combination of intensity on the one hand and geographical expansion on the other, were truly unique in European history. "From Switzerland and Portugal," he writes, "to Wallachia and Moldavia, from Norway, Denmark, and Sweden to Palermo and the Ionian Islands. This was the only truly European revolution that ever took place [...] The Austrian Chancellor Metternich fled from Vienna, the Prussian army had to withdraw from Berlin, the kings of Piedmont-Sardinia, Denmark, and Naples issued constitutions—everything seemed so simple—this unanimity was intoxicating."

At the same time, Christopher Clark draws attention to a strange but telling contradiction: "These revolutions were experienced as European upheavals—but in retrospect, they were nationalized. The historians and memory keepers of the European nations transformed them into individual national histories."

This is still the case today. I believe: It is time to tell the common European history together. On the way to a European identity, which no one can reinvent, we need this memory of a shared history of the struggle for freedom and democracy.

In addition, what John F. Kennedy shouted to us Germans and the world almost exactly 60 years ago, right from this podium here in the Paulskirche: "As long as freedom does not flourish in all countries, it cannot thrive in a single one. [...] And the spirit of the Frankfurt National Assembly must [...] be alive in many hearts and nations if it is to remain alive at all."

In light of Russia's criminal war of aggression against Ukraine, nothing could be more necessary and more current than this solidarity of democrats in Europe. Russian violence targets freedom and democracy and the right of the Ukrainian people to self-determination. That freedom, as Kennedy said, cannot be possessed solely for oneself is not only a matter of moral stance and self-respect. When freedom and self-determination are threatened or attacked anywhere, all free people and nations are threatened. That is why we help the attacked people in Ukraine, and we support the few brave ones who rise up against the oppressors in Russia.

How contagious the struggle for freedom of one can be for others, how much the will for freedom can be transmitted over decades from one to another in a "transnational relay handover," is recently told by the British historian Timothy Garton Ash in a small but moving story in his new book "Europe": "In 1968, the Catalan singer Lluís Llach wrote a song titled 'L'Estaca,' the stake, in which an urgent refrain states: 'the stake to which we are all bound' will 'fall, fall, fall.' In the last years of General Franco's rule, the song became an unofficial anthem of the anti-fascist resistance in Spain. 'L'Estaca' impressed the Polish singer Jacek Kaczmarski so much that in 1978 he wrote a Polish version titled 'Mury,' Walls, which is based on the same melody. In the years of Solidarity, this version became the unofficial Polish opposition anthem. And now, in 2020, the baton was passed to a Belarusian version of 'Mury,' which was taken from the anti-communist Polish version, which in turn was based on the anti-fascist Spanish version."

This is, I think, a highly symbolic story of the delicate but resilient, unwavering will of people for freedom. They want it, freedom, but ultimately not only to sing about it but also to possess it.

A similar "relay handover," as Garton Ash called it, is also part of the impact history of the Paulskirche. I mean the very concrete text that this first German National Assembly adopted as a constitution. The unification of Germany through a federal constitution, on a democratic basis and with fundamental rights for the German people—this made the Paulskirche ahead of its time. Much of this has been, sometimes literally, incorporated into the Weimar Constitution and our Basic Law.

Similarly, it happens with the colors black, red, and gold. From the Hambach Festival through the Paulskirche and the Weimar Republic, they are now our colors, the colors of a united democratic Germany. They are inseparably linked to the free constitution and the Basic Law. Therefore, today, no one who stirs up new nationalism and propagates authoritarian thinking can claim black, red, and gold. To be clear: Those who despise our democracy have no right to black, red, and gold.

How can the democratic legacy remain alive? How can the history of the March Revolution and the Paulskirche remain in our consciousness so that we can look back on our history of freedom with pride—and that we can draw lessons from it as best as we can?

It is good that important places of revolutionary history are now receiving more attention and appreciation. I think of Offenburg and the new Salmen, now a vibrant place of remembrance and democracy; I think of the cemetery of the March fallen in Berlin and the documentation center that will soon be established there; and I think of the fact that the city of Leipzig has established a Robert Blum Democracy Prize, and much more.

I wish for this place, the Paulskirche, to become even more than it has been a vibrant site of remembrance and learning for democracy. A place that, together with a future House of Democracy, serves three purposes: remembrance, education, and democratic debate.

In the summer of 2020, I gathered representatives from the federal government, the state of Hesse, the city of Frankfurt am Main, and a number of scholars in Berlin. An expert commission that emerged from this has since submitted recommendations on how a place of democracy could be established here. I am very grateful to all who contributed for their truly nuanced analysis of the history of construction and commemoration, and also for their very concrete proposals.

I believe that these recommendations are more than a good foundation for the further decisions that are now necessary. What is important to me is that their proposal outlines the way in which the Paulskirche can uncover the roots of German democratic history and make them tangible for a larger and younger audience. Everyone who visits the Paulskirche in the foreseeable future should gain a strong and lasting impression of the significant historical event that took place here in 1848/49. The Paulskirche is a treasure of national significance that we should bring to shine together.

And I hope that this can also become a place for engagement on questions of the present and future of democracy. That the federal government and the state want to commit financially is an opportunity for the Paulskirche and also for the city of Frankfurt – and I hope that this opportunity will be seized together. The memory of the German Revolution and the first National Assembly should be worth it to us – and I hope I have you all on my side in this.

In conclusion, I want to give voice to one of the actors from that time, the representative Georg Friedrich Kolb from the Palatinate. In his memoirs, reflecting on 1848, he wrote: “How many new efforts, sacrifices, and sufferings will it still cost the German people until it achieves that high goal, which will finally be considered again: to be free and happy within; not merely feared outwardly, but to be a refuge of national brotherhood!”

Yes, the Paulskirchen representative Kolb was right: the history of our democracy is not a straightforward success story. We do not suppress its dark sides and must not do so. But we also remember good times and courageous role models; today, we remember the revolutionaries of 1848 and the representatives of the first German National Assembly.

The pioneers of unity, justice, and freedom deserve this remembrance. We honor them on this day and commemorate them with great respect.