Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier on the change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court on April 17, 2023, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

18 April 2023 · Change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier spoke at the ceremonial change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court on April 17, 2023, in Berlin, marking Judge Britz's retirement.
Main themes
Judicial service and retirement, Federal Constitutional Court, constitutional law, fundamental rights protection, academic career, energy law, cultural rights, minority rights, German legal scholarship, public law
Duration
~16 min
56th percentile
Words
1,975
56th percentile
Sentences
89
57th percentile
Readability
44
47th percentile
Grade
12.4
49th percentile
Syntax
3.08
57th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
47th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 59%57%
  • Ceremonial 24%24%
  • Social 16%16%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

89 sentences in 24 paragraphs

Dear Ms. Britz, I have been told that your last months, weeks, and days at the Constitutional Court have been extremely exhausting. Your goal was to leave behind as empty a desk as possible. And as I know you, you have achieved that. Now you will pass on your knowledge and experience to the students at the University of Gießen. You have been teaching "Advanced Studies in Fundamental Rights Protection" there since April 13 – a particularly exciting topic when a constitutional judge speaks about it.

That you continue without pause where you left off twelve years ago is characteristic of you. In any case, your biography reflects a scientific meteoric rise without noticeable breaks. The impression of ease that arises for the observer, you once relativized yourself: it was in 2019 when you spoke in an interview about the time after your habilitation. The uncertainty about how things would proceed weighed heavily on you as you applied for nearly every position in this republic, competing with so many other newly habilitated lecturers. With your words, you likely spoke to the hearts of many younger, aspiring scholars who feel exactly this uncertainty. However, in that interview four years ago, you also said: "In hindsight, since everything has gone well, I am […] also glad for this experience."

Dear Ms. Britz, the field of law was by no means a given for you. There were no familial legal predispositions, and even in your circle of friends – as you reported – there were no lawyers. But you had a pronounced interest in politics and society, and you were also moved by the question of justice, which was often raised at that time. The realization that law also has to do with politics led you to the field of law. Even during your studies in Frankfurt am Main, you were particularly fascinated by public law, while civil law sometimes raised doubts about your choice of study – how familiar that sounds! However, you later learned that this subject can also be highly interesting and politically contentious, as we will see.

After the first state examination in 1992, you became a research assistant at the Chair of Public Law, Environmental Law, and Administrative Science at the University of Frankfurt am Main. And just a year later, you completed your doctorate on "The Significance of European Community Law for Local Energy Supply with Special Consideration of Municipal Design Options." For this, you were awarded the Baker McKenzie Prize for outstanding writings in the field of commercial law in 1994. You have remained loyal to energy law to this day. The commentary on the Energy Industry Act, for which you were co-responsible, is now appearing in its fourth edition and is considered a standard work.

After your doctorate, things progressed quickly: Following a stay at Harvard at the John F. Kennedy School of Government, you completed your legal clerkship and passed the second state examination in 1997. With a habilitation scholarship from the state of Hesse and another stay in America – in 1999 at Yale Law School – you habilitated in 2000. The German Research Foundation awarded you the Heinz Maier-Leibnitz Prize for your work on "Cultural Rights and Constitution." The topic shows your great sensitivity to significant and also profound issues, as the discussion about the constitutional content of cultural identity is fundamental and remains relevant for our constitution and society today, and will, if I see it correctly, raise many – also constitutional – disputes.

At the age of 33, you were appointed as one of the youngest professors of public law and took over a chair in Gießen, located on the first floor of Hein-Heckroth-Straße 3, which I remember fondly. Your broad interest, your intelligence, and your energy led you to many research fields: the rights of religious and ethnic minorities as a core issue of modern immigration societies, electronic administration, environmental law problems, or fundamental rights issues such as the right to self-representation, to name just a few. In addition, you were involved in the self-administration of the university, for example, as dean of the law faculty, but also outside the university: in 2001 and 2002, you were a member of the United Nations Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination.

In 2011, you were elected as a judge of the Federal Constitutional Court. At 42, you were also the youngest person to be elected to this office up to that point.

In the first senate, you were responsible for family law. According to our traditional dogmatic understanding, it belongs to civil law, the very area of law that was particularly dear to you during your studies. The fact that constitutional judges in Karlsruhe are not regularly assigned to areas in which they are already recognized as experts has a clear reason: personal agendas should not be implemented in Karlsruhe. And the unobstructed, fresh perspective on legal issues allows for a new reconsideration of old questions. The family law community was confronted with such a fresh perspective – your perspective.

You were responsible for family law in Karlsruhe for seven years. As a reporting judge, you shaped many fundamental decisions and thus contributed to the adaptation of family law to modern societal realities. The decision on "successive adoption by registered partnerships" was part of that. The ruling was, as could be expected, controversial in public: the Federal Constitutional Court, it was said at the time, was assuming legislative powers. Similarly controversial was the debate surrounding the decision on the "third gender." Also noteworthy are the proceedings regarding the recourse claim for putative fathers and the decision on the isolated declaration of descent claim. You once reported that the more than one thousand child law proceedings, which were essentially issued as chamber decisions, were particularly important to you. You emphasized that these decisions must be made particularly quickly to avoid unnecessarily prolonging the painful situation of children in their parents' legal disputes. Any violation of fundamental rights is one too many, you once said.

The fact that many decisions you prepared were issued unanimously is attributed to your excellent expertise, your charm, and also your persistence, as well as your clear language and strategic skill.

Dear Ms. Britz, in the last five years of your term, you were also responsible for environmental law. And in this field, you have also made history: the climate protection ruling is likely the decision that will remain permanently associated with your name among the more than 5,200 cases handled in your department. The protection of natural living conditions, enshrined in Article 20a of the Basic Law, and the fundamental rights protection in an intertemporal dimension are the constitutional starting points. You recently emphasized the overriding importance of the climate protection mandate of Article 20a of the Basic Law, especially in decisions of the legislature, in your ruling on the – ultimately failed for other reasons – constitutional complaint against the legislative omission of introducing a general speed limit on federal highways. These groundbreaking rulings also demonstrate the long lines underlying your engagement with the relevant legal questions. Early on in your academic work with Rudolf Steinberg, who wrote about the "Ecological Constitutional State" and who, according to your own account, strongly influenced you, you came into contact with this topic. The climate protection decision is described as a "great gesture, brilliant moment, constitutional flash." It has sparked discussions and shaped developments.

I imagine the discussions and considerations in the judges' collegium to be very exciting, especially since your colleagues in the court, as well as your research assistants, praise your enthusiasm for debate and your openness. "She is a constitutional judge you can approach," said one of your assistants about you, someone who grants freedom, practically promotes equality, seeks and demands conversation, who unexpectedly stands in the doorway for a discussion about a legal question.

"I am not fit to be a role model for young female lawyers," you once said. Dear Ms. Britz: I would like to doubt that! In my impression, many young women are looking for concrete role models on how to reconcile demanding professional and private life perspectives. You have achieved that, in my view. Therefore: even if you do not want to be a role model, you set an example for younger people who are seeking orientation. And I think: a good example!

Dear Ms. Britz, from today on, you may "once again say what you want" – this is how you described the perspective for the time after your judgeship. The mandate of judicial restraint now applies only to a limited extent. For this reason, I am convinced that we will still hear many wise contributions from you regarding the legal and political situation in the country.

I would now like to invite you to come forward for the presentation of the certificate of discharge.

You have rendered outstanding services to our country. As a visible recognition of this, I may now award you the Grand Cross of Merit with Star and Shoulder Ribbon of the Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany. Thank you once again and congratulations!

Dear Ms. Messling, the Bundesrat elected you as a judge of the Federal Constitutional Court on March 31, 2023. I sincerely congratulate you on this!

You come to the Federal Constitutional Court after a career that marks you as an excellent jurist. In Karlsruhe, parity is easily achieved because we have excellent women in justice, legal practice, and legal science who qualify for the highest offices through outstanding suitability, performance, and capability.

Dear Ms. Messling, after studying in Trier and Münster, you completed your doctorate in 2001 on the topic "Resolution of contractual obligations in German and Italian private law," perhaps a reminiscence of your school visit in Italy. Subsequently, you were already at the Federal Constitutional Court as a research assistant to Renate Jäger from 2002 to 2005. In a way, you are also taking on the legacy of Ms. Jäger: she was also a federal social judge before her election.

In the social jurisdiction of Baden-Württemberg, you worked at the social courts in Karlsruhe and Freiburg, with secondments to the Administrative Court of Mannheim and as a personnel officer in the Baden-Württemberg Ministry of Justice. After your appointment to the State Social Court of Baden-Württemberg in 2012, you were elected as a judge at the Federal Social Court in 2016. There, you became presiding judge in 2021 and vice president in January 2022. You were actually designated to succeed President Schlegel. Your previous president is quoted as saying: "She was simply the best."

In 2022, the German Social Court Day elected you as its president – as an established social law expert who has also made a name for herself through her scientific publications in the areas of basic security for job seekers, social assistance law, social long-term care insurance law, statutory health insurance, and the specifics of the Corona legislation.

Even if you will not be responsible for social law in your new position – that will be Mr. Wolff – I find it important that a judge from the specialized jurisdiction has been elected to the Federal Constitutional Court. If I counted correctly, only three judges have come from the Federal Fiscal Court, two from the Federal Labor Court, and before you, two from the Federal Social Court to Karlsruhe.

You, dear Ms. Messling, have many different professional experiences, both in the judiciary and in administration. But you are not only considered high-performing but also a team player. I am sure that with all these experiences and qualities, you will be a great asset to the Federal Constitutional Court and your colleagues.

I would now like to invite you, dear Ms. Messling, to come forward for your appointment and oath. I wish you every success in your new position!