Speech by Federal President Horst Köhler at the celebration "60 Years of the Hessian Constitution" on December 1, 2006, in Wiesbaden:

Germany Horst Köhler · President of Germany

4 December 2006 · Celebration "60 Years of the Hessian Constitution" · Wiesbaden, Germany

Context
Köhler addressed a ceremony in Wiesbaden on December 1, 2006, marking the 60th anniversary of the Hessian Constitution and Landtag election.
Main themes
Hessian constitution anniversary, federalism and democracy, German postwar renewal, constitutional order, state constitutions, rule of law, German federal states, self-determination, common good, constitutional reform
Duration
~27 min
78th percentile
Words
3,243
78th percentile
Sentences
130
75th percentile
Readability
35
24th percentile
Grade
14.6
72nd percentile
Syntax
3.27
80th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
37th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 79%55%
  • Social 7%5%
  • Ceremonial 7%5%
  • Economic 6%4%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 31%

130 sentences in 42 paragraphs

I.

Sixty years ago today, the first Hessian Landtag was elected, the people adopted the constitution of the state of Hesse in a free vote, and the constitution came into effect.

The people of Hesse rightly celebrate this as the true beginning of their success story after the Second World War. I am pleased to be here with you on this festive day; and I wholeheartedly congratulate the "flourishing Hesse" and its citizens: All of Germany rejoices with you.

II.

What was it really like, this year of democratic renewal? I leafed through the first volume of the "Frankfurter Hefte," which was published starting in April 1946. For example, it reports: "The city of Frankfurt (...) hopes in the meantime (...) to manage its rubble in five years." Notably, many articles are titled with questions: "Can Germany become an agrarian country?" "Death penalty for black market?" And right in the very first issue: "Is it permissible to make a program?" Yes, was the answer at that time, a program is necessary for the democratic renewal, a program in the "hope of being on the way to where a foundation can once be laid." Hope of being on the way to where a foundation can once be laid – nothing more, and that was soberly considered.

But there was indeed consideration, and with all vigor! For example, "On Democracy and Federalism," the title of an essay by Eugen Kogon. He vehemently opposed the opinion that federalism was nothing more than the German "hereditary evil of discord" from the time "when Heinrich Heine, standing on the St. Gotthard, claimed to hear the snoring of a few dozen monarchs from Germany." And the later federal judge Günther Willms, who studied in Frankfurt and Marburg, worked in courts in Kassel, Hanau, and Fulda, and wrote extensively about the local cities and landscapes, Günther Willms published in the August issue of the Frankfurter Hefte the still worthwhile essay "The German State Constitutions" – even though they did not yet exist.

They did not yet exist, but the constitutional debate had long since begun, in the later "Trizonesien" and also in the Soviet Occupation Zone. Everywhere, there was a strong desire to return to a free and democratic order – it could only unfold freely in the West.

Sixty years ago, the people of Hesse succeeded first in the constitutional renewal. However, many western federal states are celebrating their 60th anniversaries and constitutional days in these months; and the eastern states can rightly celebrate as well, because there too, immediately after the war, democratic life stirred again and because the states in the GDR remained unforgettable until finally the first and only freely elected People's Chamber could fulfill the wish for their restoration.

As delightful as the abundance of anniversaries is, I could hardly be present everywhere, and moreover, new speeches would always be expected! So I am following a single invitation – the Hessian one, as you can easily recognize – and I am speaking here not only about Hesse but also about the question of what condition our federal state is actually in overall.

III.

This brings me to a first observation: Having a constitution and being in good constitutional order are two different things. Hesse provides an inspiring example: The text of its constitution says little in parts about the good condition in which the state actually finds itself. For instance, the constitutional articles sometimes mention the imposition of the death penalty, and had the member states of the European Union studied the Hessian provisions on uncompensated expropriation, who knows where they would have located the European Central Bank. The constitution of the state of Hesse has not only accumulated patina, some critics say, but also rust and cobwebs.

Others find it not so bad: It is even rumored that the University of Oxford has not given up the old privilege of simply executing delinquent students; also, the university statutes contained until not long ago Latin rules regarding whether and when students may carry bow and arrow. Both have never harmed the reputation and atmosphere of the university, the death penalty is no longer valid thanks to higher-ranking law, and provisions like those regarding bow and arrow could even become quite useful again with increasing private armament.

But when it comes to state and constitution, great seriousness is indeed advisable, for it concerns political independence and personal freedom, democratic participation and power control, and good governance. Giving oneself a constitution is truly a fundamental act of self-determination for any people. The constitutions of the federal and state governments are meant to protect the free development of citizens, to set goals and limits for state action, and to contribute as effectively as possible to the promotion of the common good. This establishes their special rank and makes them the center of state legal order. This center should be at rest – constant tinkering with it only harms – but it must not sleep.

Therefore, powerful and responsible politics must also prove itself, if necessary, in the act of constitutional reform. Many western countries have heeded this. Equally important and valuable for the German constitutional system was that the eastern states established modern constitutions after 1990. And even at the federal level, a reform process has begun – one that was long overdue.

IV.

This leads me to a second observation: Not only can real life drift so far from the constitutional text that it is applied less and less; but the practical application of the constitution can also burden coexistence so much that constitutional reform is urgently needed. We have experienced this with our federal constitution, and the reform of the federal order that has become urgently necessary has only just begun.

For whatever one may have thought until recently about the excessive entanglement and intertwining of the responsibilities and actions of the federal and state governments – it was entirely constitutional. The federal government simply increasingly exhausted its legislative powers; it eagerly regulated the administrative organization and the procedure for the implementation of federal laws by the states and accepted the necessity of their consent in the Bundesrat; the first grand coalition incorporated the joint tasks and thus the already long-practiced mixed financing into the Basic Law; and the states increasingly moved towards self-coordination, while the federal government additionally advanced standardization with administrative agreements and financial grants – keyword Golden Bridle – and the political parties in the state office structure aimed for the widest possible nationwide effectiveness of their respective positions, initiatives, and sometimes also blockades.

All of this created an extraordinarily high need for cooperation and consensus; it created many large subsidy pots, tapping into which often became an end in itself; countless players had veto power, and it sustainably weakened what should be the advantages of federalism: its power to separate powers, promote innovation, and foster competition for good solutions.

And on top of all that, an insatiable desire for "uniform living conditions" developed. Everything in the Federal Republic should be as uniform as possible everywhere else in the Federal Republic. Whether in tax, economic, and social law, whether in education or in civil servant salaries: everything should be uniform, please. Many still think this way today – at least I have deeply troubled some contemporaries when I pointed out at the beginning of my term that there will always be significant differences in living conditions nationwide, that these also leave us the freedom of choice regarding how and where we want to live, and that only those who try to level all differences cement the subsidy state.

Excessive entanglement, veto power, and conformity pressure – these were the ingredients that created the reform backlog under which Germany suffered for many years at all levels. That is why I am glad that three months ago the first step towards modernizing our federal order came into effect. Certainly, here and there, more consistent and clearer regulations would have been desirable. But what has been achieved is commendable. It will hopefully prove itself in practice. The responsibilities of the federal and state governments have been more clearly separated again; the number of laws requiring consent is to be significantly reduced; municipal finances and municipal self-administration have finally been protected against encroachments by the federal government; and the autonomy of the states has been substantially strengthened – just think of the area of education, science, and research. I hope that the states will now also use their new opportunities vigorously and responsibly and compete for the best solutions in beautiful diversity and for the common good. Heinrich Heine only heard a snoring from German federalism – nowadays, more is expected!

Of course, what has been achieved is only the first step.

As a second step, a reform of budgetary constitutional law and federal financial relations must necessarily follow. I find it very commendable that the federal government and the states want to face these challenges as well. On the one hand, with a view to the stability criteria of the European Monetary Union, it is about managing the numerous current budget crises and preventing them in the future: through debt limits and debt brakes and hopefully also through a national stability pact. The budgetary provisions of the Basic Law and some state constitutions must gain much more bite – at present, constitutional lawyers already fear that budgetary constitutional law is being so disregarded by some governments and parliaments that it is only a "law of lesser normativity."

The reform of financial relations should correspond to the disentanglement of the tasks and competencies of the federal and state governments and strengthen their capacity for self-responsibility. We should indeed create more autonomy – why not also through more own leeway in tax matters? And as far as the federal-state financial equalization is concerned, the question must be allowed as to how much effort and discipline each state must bring and muster before it demands the solidarity of others.

Such questions already instill fear in some participants. Yet they simply correspond to the rules of common sense. No one can permanently spend more than they earn. Everyone should first make a proper effort to live adequately before they can claim the help of others. And only if all, the federal government and each state, properly exert their strengths and strive for the best possible governance and optimal framework conditions for their citizens, only then can the people in Germany make the most of their ideas and talents. Then the decentralized renewal process that Germany needs will succeed best, and then we will also continue to have the strength for federal solidarity, which no one in our federal state wants to abolish and no one may abolish.

This second step of constitutional reform is, by the way, not only necessary for domestic reasons but also with a view to European integration and globalization. In both contexts, we Germans can best safeguard our legitimate interests only if we demonstrate statecraft and governance. Some believe that globalization will eventually condemn states to insignificance – the opposite is true! It is fascinating to observe how important the quality of public goods provided by the state and the foresight and efficiency of government work are for the well-being of nations. This is by no means only a topic for developing countries. The state and government systems of industrialized nations are also in a constant quality competition. Although top performances and misdevelopments often only become apparent after years, the ability of each society to seize the opportunities of global competition also crucially depends on forward-looking and predictable state action.

First of all, state organs must grasp the dimension of the global political, economic, and social change: There are indeed people behind the mountain – and quite a few billion, and they are industrious and eager to learn.

Then, it is necessary to empower the domestic population through an investment-oriented social state for the new challenges – through a world-class education system, for example, and through a family policy that achieves more than uncoordinated redistribution; through an order policy that incentivizes entrepreneurial action and creates priority for work; and through far above-average investments in research and development. Only in this way can people optimally develop their talents, knowledge, and skills.

It is also important to encourage them. A key part of political leadership is to ensure social cohesion in times of change, to strengthen the awareness of capabilities, and to instill the conviction that a joint effort is necessary and worthwhile, that in order to maintain our good standing in the world, we should play the ball boldly and skillfully forward, rather than anxiously guarding our own penalty area.

Such encouragement, in turn, requires a solid foundation of knowledge and trust. Therefore, it is essential to explain much better than before what is changing globally and in Germany, and it must become much clearer what the elected representatives of the people are responsible for, what they are doing, and what they are actually achieving. This, in turn – and here we return to the topic of constitutional reform – requires proper clarity of responsibilities and areas of accountability and effective accountability measures: Politically responsible individuals should set publicly verifiable goals, explain their strategy for achieving them, and thus provide a standard against which they can truly be measured. A good example of this is the strategy paper on globalization that the Danish government presented to its citizens six months ago. It already shows in its preface the spirit in which they think and act, as it states: "Denmark is doing well. And especially when things are going well, we should make decisions that are crucial for our future. Right now, we should take measures to make our prosperity sustainable."

Clear structures of responsibility and effective accountability exert a beneficial pressure. This increases the likelihood that citizens will receive good quality from politics in return for their money and trust. Within the political system, clearer accountability can also help further improve the processes of communication and decision-making – because everyone focuses on their core tasks instead of wanting to dance on as many big stages as possible, and because veto power and collective decision-making weakness no longer enhance one's own significance, but rather the risk of being punished by voters. Then, in the best case, the reform process begins to sustain itself – until the entire constitutional modernization of the federal order is achieved.

V.

And when we have achieved this – it is still not enough. For, and this shall be my last observation for today: Even the best constitution relies on constitutional friends (Friedrich Schiller) and on the proximity of political processes to the citizens, for which the constitution provides the legal framework.

Constitutional friends – these must be, first and foremost, those to whom the people have entrusted the authority to exercise public power. The state order is essentially an order of offices, and every office entrusted by the people is obligated to the welfare of the whole people. Among the most important duties of office is to handle the constitution carefully and respectfully, for it contains the most important rules that the citizens have given themselves as free and equal individuals to govern one another and to be governed by one another. Respect for the constitution has many manifestations: For example, it should be forbidden for any officeholder – whether a member of parliament, minister, or civil servant – to accept a constitutional violation in legislation or administrative action with the attitude: "it could be unconstitutional or it might not – let’s just see." Unfortunately, this does happen. Similarly, it should be forbidden for holders of state offices – and the parliamentary mandate is, as mentioned, an office – to constantly combat political opponents from other democratic parties with the unfounded accusation that their proposals are unconstitutional. Unfortunately, this also often occurs, leading to the misuse of the constitution as political ammunition in several debates – which does not serve it well.

However, constitutional friends should not only be the officeholders, but all citizens. They should pay close attention to how the constitution is treated, and they should advocate for its values every day; otherwise, these will become mere paper program statements. Our free civil society thrives on citizens doing much more than just going to the polls. It is important that they also take an interest in and engage with our community between elections – in the neighborhood, in the school support association, in the church council, in a political party, in citizen initiatives. Montesquieu already emphasized that the principle of the republic is the common good-oriented virtue of all citizens, and I find it good that recently the Christian churches have presented a doctrine of virtue for democrats in a joint statement. This civic virtue is demonstrated in attentiveness to the constitution and in participation in the political and social events that are organized by the constitution. And then there can be a bit of pride in our free, democratic order and in how we bring it to life.

Of course, political participation in the community also requires good opportunities for participation and influence. Many citizens no longer consider this condition to be given. They feel disillusioned with parties and politics and turn away because "those up there" do what they want anyway.

Therefore, I consider it important to always keep in mind how the proximity of politics to citizens and the political participation of citizens can be strengthened in constitutional reforms. This does not always require constitutional changes. Reform alliances like the "Convention for Germany," which Roman Herzog has significantly shaped, have rightly pointed this out and made many corresponding proposals. These deserve broad public interest and a corresponding debate.

For example, there have been consistently good experiences with the so-called cumulating and panachaging in municipal and state elections – why not more of that? Other proposals suggest that parties should determine their candidates through a referendum of all members instead of through delegate conferences or even allow non-members to participate in the nomination of candidate lists in primaries. The guiding principle is always the same: the assumption that such changes will strengthen the citizen orientation of the representatives.

In short: There seem to be many possibilities to provide citizens with effective incentives to actively participate in political life. This could also positively influence the composition of our currently heavily shaped parliaments by public service and associations, making them more of a reflection of the diversity of our society again. So why not take action? Thankfully, our federal system with its 17 constitutional orders offers excellent opportunities to try out new things and then adopt what has proven effective – just as has already happened with the principle of connectivity ("who orders, pays") and with some elements of direct democracy.

VI.

Aristotle reports that a Greek constitutional draft provided that every citizen who proposed a good institutional innovation should receive a reward.

We are not yet at that point in Germany regarding constitutional reform and friendship with the constitution.

But, dear constitutional friends, democratic virtues carry their own reward. This is shown by German history since the turn from the darkness of the Nazi era, it is shown by the history of the state of Hesse since that difficult yet fruitful year of 1946, and it is shown by the beautiful celebration of freedom that we are celebrating together today.