Speech by Federal President Horst Köhler at the dinner to open the 41st Munich Security Conference "Economic Development and Security" on February 11, 2005 in ...

Germany Horst Köhler · President of Germany

19 February 2005 · Dinner to open the 41st Munich Security Conference "Economic Development and Security" · Munich, Germany

Context
Köhler addressed the 41st Munich Security Conference dinner on February 11, 2005, speaking on the link between economic development and global security.
Main themes
Globalization and security interdependence, global poverty reduction, economic development and conflict prevention, human security concept, Millennium Development Goals, failed states and state stability, African development, immigration and refugee flows, global military spending vs. development aid, good governance and rule of law, natural disasters and global repercussions
Duration
~18 min
61st percentile
Words
2,165
61st percentile
Sentences
125
73rd percentile
Readability
43
43rd percentile
Grade
11.6
40th percentile
Syntax
2.94
39th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Munich Security Conference Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 48%47%
  • Economic 27%26%
  • Social 19%18%
  • Institutional 4%4%
  • Ceremonial 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

125 sentences in 26 paragraphs

In the Easter walk of Faust, Goethe has a citizen remark on how interesting a conversation about war is, "when far away, in Turkey, the peoples clash." This comfortable distance is now a thing of the past. Television and the internet bring us disasters from all parts of the world into our living rooms—not only natural disasters but also wars and terror. We are comprehensively informed. But we can also be affected ourselves. The devastating earthquake of December 26 made it painfully clear to us that a natural disaster can have global repercussions.

We must keep in mind: There is no exit from globalization. The natural disaster in the Indian Ocean, the interdependencies in the economy and the environment, but also global terrorism demand a stronger engagement in shaping globalization.

Today, approximately six billion people live on our planet Earth. It has become crowded, and it will become even more crowded; by 2050, estimates suggest that there may be up to nine billion people living on the planet. How is peaceful coexistence among so many people possible when more than half of the world's population already has to live on less than two US dollars a day, that is, in poverty? The crisis is not only pre-programmed; it is already here. And I do not believe that addressing this crisis can consist solely of containing the consequences, especially the consequences in the area of security. Without global poverty reduction, there can be no long-term security for us, nor political stability. And that is why development policy is the best conflict prevention! Therefore, it should also make us all reflect that global military spending amounts to more than ten times the development aid of the OECD countries!

There is a connection between security and economic development. This is almost a truism. Without security, there can be no sustainable economic development. Conversely, experience also shows that persistent poverty among broad segments of the population can threaten state stability. The political stability of a country remains questionable if the population cannot participate in the natural wealth or in political decision-making. There are numerous examples of this, especially in Africa, but also in Asia or Latin America.

The consequences of economic distress or state collapse also affect us in Europe. Just think of the daily attempts of many people, especially from Africa, to reach southern Europe in barely seaworthy boats. This poses enormous problems—socially, economically, but also from a security perspective—for the states on the southern flank of Europe. We can only address this in the long term by sustainably promoting economic and state development in the countries of origin. In the long run, this will be cheaper than turning Europe into a fortress. If we fail to effectively combat poverty in Africa, if even more states become failed states, then we will be dealing with many more immigrants and "boat people" in the future. This will present us with problems of a completely different magnitude. We simply cannot afford to lose any more time!

In fact, we can no longer rely solely on the classical concept of security today. We must redefine it to include socio-economic and cultural factors. The United Nations uses the concept of "human security" here. This encompasses the protection of essential freedoms as well as the protection of people from threats.

It literally states: "Human security connects different types of freedoms - freedom from want, freedom from fear and freedom to take action on one's own behalf." I find it remarkable that this definition also includes parts of Franklin Delano Roosevelt's famous four freedoms, which morally and politically legitimized America's entry into World War II.

Freedom from economic hardship connects the concept of human security with the United Nations' Millennium Development Goals, which were adopted in 2000 by 184 heads of state and government. These development goals include, above all, halving extreme poverty by 2015 and providing all children in the world with the opportunity for a sufficient education. These are good and important goals.

This year, the UN will review how far the Millennium Development Goals have been implemented. This means that the 189 heads of government must assess how far they have come. There has been progress in poverty reduction, for example in Asia, but it is far from sufficient. We must intensify our efforts. Poor and rich countries must work together better. Everyone bears the responsibility for achieving these goals, but primarily the developing countries themselves. This self-responsibility cannot and must not be taken away from them. They bear the responsibility for good governance, for responsible government action, the rule of law, the fight against corruption, and the development of concrete plans for poverty reduction.

During my visit to Africa in December of last year, I was able to see that a lot of positive things are happening there. In the joint development concept NEPAD—New Programme for Africa's Development—formulated by Africans themselves, they have committed to the central task of ensuring good governance and responsible state action. More than 20 African states have now subjected themselves to the so-called "African Peer Review Process." They are willing to critically review their policies with one another. This is an important step to recognize their own problems in a timely manner and to learn from African success stories. Many Africans have recognized that they hold the key to good economic and political development. Now it is a matter of consistently implementing this concept. Many forces can still be mobilized in this regard. Above all, the strong role of women in Africa and the diverse forms of civil society engagement give me hope.

The demand for developing countries to take responsibility for themselves is, by the way, not a neocolonial interference, but an obligation that arises from our shared responsibility for one world.

If the recipient countries take their self-responsibility seriously, the necessary, stronger support from our side can show long-term effects. Then we must hold ourselves accountable. To achieve the Millennium Development Goals, more financial support is needed. Therefore, I will not relent in my appeal to the industrialized countries, including Germany, to allocate 0.7 percent of their gross national product for development aid. They committed to this more than 30 years ago. There is a gap of almost 100 billion US dollars per year between promise and reality. This is necessary to realize the Millennium Development Goals. We must do everything possible to get closer to this goal step by step every year. With regard to Germany, we must not place this responsibility solely on the Federal Minister of Finance, and blaming each other will not get us anywhere. Every single country, every single one of us is called upon to fulfill our responsibility for one world.

At the same time, we must ensure that the funds for development and poverty reduction also reach directly where they are most needed—we owe this to our taxpayers. And we must vigorously promote the establishment of a fair trade regime. Fair trading conditions remain the most important contribution that the international community can make to combating poverty in Africa. We have pledged to make the Doha Round a development round. Here too, we must keep our word! And then we can and must contribute to building domestic structures and, above all, strengthening the private sector in developing countries.

It is in the fundamental interest of every functioning state to provide the private sector with broad opportunities for development. Trade is the best help for self-help. Therefore, we must not effectively exclude the affected states from integration into the world economy, whether through subsidies, protectionist measures, or other trade barriers.

At the same time, we must continually ask ourselves whether our own efforts are effective. Our commitment must be reliable, predictable, and as well-coordinated as possible with all involved partners. If this were the case, we could already achieve significantly more in poverty reduction today—even with the insufficient resources available. For example, I would like to see better coordination and networking of the involved institutions or the standardization of guidelines and awarding criteria. Donors must use their aid in the long term to build solid state structures and public institutions. I am thinking here of rural areas, infrastructure projects, the establishment of rule-of-law institutions, the promotion of the private sector, as well as education and training. The latter is the most important contribution we can make to keep population growth in Africa within limits.

None of this is new. The programs and concepts for it are available; we just need to apply them.

The fight against poverty worldwide is not only a matter of well-understood self-interest but a deeply moral question for all of us. I consider it a fundamental ethical obligation that we give everyone the chance to live their life in dignity in the one world we inhabit. This is part of the spiritual foundations that connect us in Europe and America and of which we can be proud—at least when we also implement them in our daily lives. We can only act within the framework of our possibilities, but we have not yet exhausted those!

The example of Africa also shows us that we must engage more intensively with the question of how we can contribute to lasting stabilization after the end of a conflict. For example, I find it problematic to plan the gradual withdrawal of the UN peacekeeping force in Sierra Leone this year. We need greater assurance that the state institutions of Sierra Leone will be permanently capable of ensuring law and order. I find the British commitment to support the establishment of a functional police force in Sierra Leone over ten years exemplary. For countries that are in the process of rebuilding after a conflict, medium- to long-term support is very important.

Unfortunately, there are no objective criteria for international intervention in crisis situations or for the conditions for their termination. These are inherently political decisions, with all the positive and negative side effects that political decisions can have. In my opinion, we have not yet found the right way here. Therefore, the issues of conflict prevention and crisis management must also be at the center of the reform of the United Nations.

I am convinced that economic development is a necessary but not sufficient condition for more global security. It is particularly important that we also fight for the hearts and minds of people. To do this, we must, not least, respect and honor the cultural identity of others.

This means: We must actively engage in the intellectual confrontation with other cultures—in dialogue. In doing so, we can seek commonalities, but we must also accept and respect diversity. And we must not confuse indifference or apathy with tolerance. In this confrontation, we must take a stand ourselves—actively, emphatically, and above all credibly with our own position. You all know the term "dialogue of cultures," which has almost become a buzzword. This dialogue is already being practiced—inevitably, but only with those who are willing to engage in dialogue. But how do we reach the fundamentalists, the fanatics, those from whom a threat may arise?

Poverty and cultural alienation are often cited as reasons for international terrorism with an Islamist background. However, we all know that, for example, the perpetrators of September 11, 2001, did not come from poor or uneducated backgrounds. It is also true that the environment for terrorists often exists under the impression of hopelessness and an inescapable marginalization. And this is where we must start.

We experience daily the conflicts that arise when different cultures collide. Young people in Karachi, Cairo, Lagos, or Jakarta are incessantly confronted with a initially fascinating way of life that promises the ideals of freedom. However, this lifestyle stands in many ways in contrast to their own cultural norms and ideas. This results in a simultaneity of fascination, frustration, and rejection, which often turns into hatred and a willingness to use violence.

I fear that the struggle for the minds and hearts of people will take a long time and will not always be easy. What is certain, however, is that we must engage in this struggle; otherwise, the efforts for security and economic progress will fall short.

Three weeks ago, I had the opportunity to speak to the representatives of the NATO Council. NATO, whose members are committed to the values of freedom, democracy, and human rights, began as a defense alliance. Today, it faces new security policy challenges that have nothing to do with the threat scenario of the Cold War. I believe that NATO, as a community of values, has not lost any of its significance; on the contrary.

I am also convinced that people today increasingly understand that security always means providing a positive life perspective for those in the poorest countries of the world. A perspective for a life of dignity, for a life free from the fear of survival, for a life in one's own cultural identity. Ultimately, we need a political concept for one world.