National Address by the President of the Nation, Javier Milei, presenting the 2025 Budget in the National Congress.

Argentina Javier Milei · President of Argentina

15 September 2024 · Presentation of the 2025 Budget before the National Congress · National Congress

Context
Milei addressed the Argentine National Congress on September 15, 2024, personally presenting the 2025 national budget bill, emphasizing a zero-deficit fiscal framework.
Main themes
2025 national budget, zero fiscal deficit, fiscal balance methodology, state spending restraint, economic freedom, Argentina's history of default, inflation and monetary policy, individual freedom vs. state control, debt and serial default, capital controls, investment and productivity growth, poverty reduction
Duration
~44 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,324
92nd percentile
Sentences
233
92nd percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
12.2
47th percentile
Syntax
3.09
59th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
42nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 58%57%
  • Institutional 27%27%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

233 sentences in 43 paragraphs

Hello everyone. Members of the national government, members of the Budget Commission of the Honorable Congress of the Nation, deputies, senators, and leaders, both from La Libertad Avanza and from the rest of the political spectrum that accompany me today, and all Argentinians watching from their homes. Good evening.

Today we are here to present a national budget project that will forever change the history of our country, so that we can once again be the great Argentina we once were. After years in which the political class lived by putting shackles on individual freedoms, today we come here to put a shackle on the State.

This budget project that we are presenting here today has a methodology that safeguards fiscal balance, regardless of the economic scenario. This means that, regardless of what happens with the economy at the macro level, the fiscal result of the national public sector will be balanced. This fiscal safeguard opens a new page in our history, until now unknown. From now on, Argentina will be solvent, with the consequent reduction of country risk, of interest rates and, consequently, the increase in investment, productivity, real wages, and ultimately, the decrease of poverty and indigence. In fact, I cannot help but mention that we are here today, in this very house where in December 2001, during the presidency of Adolfo Rodríguez Saá, the default of Argentina was declared and applauded, in a full house and amidst enormous jubilation. That default, which was celebrated and applauded by the entire political class, would be the beginning of a populist cycle that has destroyed Argentina.

Some may wonder why I am here tonight, if generally the one who presents the national budget proposed by the Executive Power to Congress is the Minister of Economy. I decided to do it personally for two reasons. First, because I am an economist. And I am proud of that.

I am the first economist president in Argentine history, to be more precise, and as I am an economist, probably due to professional deformation, for me the fate of a people is determined by the economic definitions it makes, because only on the basis of a healthy economy can people truly exercise their freedom. Well, the first and foremost of these definitions is about what the State should take care of and how it will use the money of taxpayers. That, nothing more and nothing less, is the national budget.

Let us remember that, in a sense, modern democracy as we know it today is the offspring of a revolution that was born under the principle that there can be no taxation without representation. The main task of this honorable House, for which it was conceived, is to establish a national budget to define what the State does with the money of taxpayers.

The second reason why I am presenting myself here today is that I come to propose a budget project that is diametrically different from what we are used to. Not only different, but the most radically different in our history, and I have learned firsthand that the deeper the change, the greater the effort must be to fight for it. That is why we are here today, because the national budget is not just another law: it is the law of laws. It is the roadmap under which we will order the priorities in our management in this national hour. The cornerstone of this budget is the first truth of a healthy public administration, a truth that has been relegated in Argentina for many years, the zero deficit.

The first thing to understand is that when governments want to spend and spend compulsively and do not have the margin to keep raising taxes, as happens in Argentina, the only way to pay the bill is by borrowing money or printing it at the Central Bank. Let us briefly recall what has been the historical methodology of our political class: since politicians do not understand budgetary restraint and do not want to stop spending, they generate deficits. To cover that deficit, the first thing they do is take on debt, but since they do not make the necessary adjustments, the debt becomes unpayable. And then, they default. That is how we became the world's greatest serial defaulter. But default is not innocuous; falling into default produces what is already famous in Argentina, capital flight. So, dollars begin to become scarce, and politicians have no better idea than to establish tariffs or export duties to seize the dollars from the private sector. On the other hand, they establish capital controls to try to retain the scarce dollars that the country generates. As this causes Argentina to run out of credit in financial markets, they have no better idea than to print money which, as we already know, generates inflation. Footnote: because inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon, whether people like it or not.

To combat inflation, they impose price controls, which we have known for 4,000 years do not work, and invent regulations that destroy private property, hinder economic calculation, destroy capital, and consequently increase poverty and indigence. This is the sad Argentine story of what politicians and analysts call economic policy, which has been nothing more than the systematic violation of citizens' property rights in Argentina. In other words, the deficit is only covered with debt, which is nothing more than future taxes, taxes on future generations, or with more present taxes or with money printing. In Argentina, there cannot be more taxes; it is the country with the highest number of taxes in the world. And if we add to that the fact that 50% of economic activity is informal, the formal tax pressure in Argentina hovers around 60%. A true absurdity for a country that desperately needs to accumulate capital.

Once the possibility of raising taxes is ruled out, the other way to cover the deficit is with debt, that is, loading future generations with today's waste. This is nothing more than sacrificing the lives of our youth on the altar of populism, meaning the extermination of future generations, who today are already 70% poor. But Argentina, as a result of being the world's greatest serial defaulter, has no access to credit. For now. This disables any type of borrowing, even if it were desirable, when in reality it never is. And when that alternative is exhausted, the deficit is paid by printing pesos, which is robbing all Argentinians through seigniorage. To give you an idea of the scam we have lived through, politics has robbed Argentinians of about 25 billion dollars a year in seigniorage over the last 20 years. And I say robbed not as a euphemism, but in the literal sense, because the more money is printed, every peso that an Argentine has in their pocket is worth less; with the painful addition that inflation, which is a direct consequence of monetary emission, hits those who have the least between 25 and 30 times harder. The problem of the deficit, however, is not new. In Argentina, we have had fiscal deficits 113 of the last 123 years, and those 10 years without a deficit were because everything had already blown up and we were in default. This means that practically 100% of our modern history, governments have failed to comply with this basic truth of economics and have passed the bill to ordinary Argentinians time and time again. It also means that this will be the first year of fiscal surplus without entering into default in all of Argentine history. Talk about management.

It is not a coincidence, then, that we are the greatest serial defaulter in modern history if we have lived a century taking on debt that we cannot pay. It is not a coincidence that we have lived with exorbitant inflation over the last century, having ended the year 2023 with the highest year-on-year inflation in the world, above Venezuela and Lebanon. It is not a coincidence either that, in the last 120 years, we have gone from having the highest per capita GDP in the world to being a country where 60% of the population is poor. The root of all Argentine economic problems, of all of them, which is the fiscal deficit, is the only constant throughout our history. Because debt is a product of the deficit, monetary emission is a product of the deficit, inflation is a product of financing the deficit with emission, and the destruction of capital is a product of the indebtedness generated by the deficit. Therefore, poverty and indigence are products of the deficit.

You may then wonder who could benefit from this model. Well, you know what the mother of the deficit is, the reason why there is a deficit: the inexhaustible compulsion of politicians for public spending, which knows no budgetary restraint. Because only by spending money that is not theirs can they do business for themselves, their clients, and their friends. Friedman already said that there is no worse way to spend than state spending, because there are four ways to spend money: spending one's own money on oneself, spending one's own money on others, spending someone else's money on oneself, or spending someone else's money on others. And since one does not know others' preferences nor is responsible for someone else's money, because one does not know how much it cost to obtain it, the worst way to spend money is to spend other people's money on others, which is precisely state spending.

Today, something that must be made clear once and for all: there is nothing, absolutely nothing more impoverishing for ordinary Argentinians than the fiscal deficit, and there is nothing, absolutely nothing that enriches politicians more than the fiscal deficit. This is the sad role that public spending plays in the model of the caste. Politics has adorned this model with good intentions and bombastic theoretical frameworks. For years, we have heard them talk about social justice, which is not only unjust but extremely violent, because social justice implies taking from some to give to others, based on an inconsistent principle that says that where there is a need, a right is born. But the problem, dear friends, is that needs are infinite and resources are finite. That is why, when the politician asks for more and more and more spending to distribute money that does not exist, what they are really doing is scamming the entire Argentine people. They are playing with the future of everyone to score a few political points with some well-meaning speech along the way. Because the politician knows perfectly well that when public spending increases, they are putting money in one pocket of the people to take double out of the other pocket. That is why we vetoed the public spending increase project that this Congress passed, and that is why we will veto all projects that threaten fiscal balance.

And we do this because we will not be complicit in scamming the Argentine people to adopt a populist measure. The only context in which we will accept discussing an increase in spending is when the request comes with an explicit explanation of which item needs to be reduced to cover it. If not, it will be vetoed. This, which should be a self-evident truth, seems like sacrilege when said in this house, the place from which all the populist measures that have ruined this country have emerged.

The paradox is that they always come out with enormous support, because it is a tacit rule of Argentine politics that the more votes a project has in Congress, the worse it is for society. They have demonstrated this again in this House in recent weeks, because they have something very clear, which weighs more than any harm they can inflict on society: they know that if the deficit ends, many will lose their business.

Unfortunately, this compulsion for spending that politicians have has been a constant during the last century in Argentina. From 1901 to the present, there have been 22 economic crises in Argentina. 20 of those 22 are characterized by a high or directly extravagant fiscal deficit, which has generated profound volatility in the Argentine economy, undermining investment and growth. That said, let us pause to remember what the fiscal picture was like before the crises we remember with the most anguish. In the lead-up to the Rodrigazo, the fiscal deficit was 14 points of GDP; approaching the crises of 81/82 with the exchange rate table, it was 11 points. Before hyperinflation broke out in 89, the national state was carrying an eight-point deficit. And behind one of our last national traumas, the crisis of convertibility in 2001 and 2002, we had a deficit of seven points of GDP.

In this journey, a clear pattern emerges: in addition to the persistence of politicians to spend money we do not have, the country has an increasingly lower resistance to fiscal distortion. Each time crises erupt, they do so with less deficit. And you may wonder why this happens. It happens because, having abused all the mechanisms of deficit financing that exist, both Argentines and the markets are giving us less and less credit. This means that when we address the inherited situation, we are not only talking about the massazo of 2023, but about the accumulated effect of an entire century of recurring crises. It also means that if we do not solve it now, if we do not fight this battle once and for all, the solution will become increasingly uphill and soon turn into an almost impossible task. Well, in politics, in economics, and in life itself, one does not choose which cards to play; one plays with the ones dealt. Fools ignore reality, fools deny it, those who bet on success accept it and resolve it.

The hand we were dealt was nothing less than the worst inheritance in history, both in fiscal and monetary matters, as well as in multiple dimensions of Argentine social life. We inherited a consolidated deficit of 15 points of GDP, of which five points belonged to the Treasury and 10 to the Central Bank. More than any of these crises I just mentioned, but some who claim to be economists, who live by conveniently forgetting things, go on television every day calculating as if we lived in Switzerland. To put it in tangible numbers, adjusting the 15-point GDP deficit meant that we had to cut spending by around 90 billion dollars, which is just another way of saying that we are returning that money to Argentines. In other words, we are not exaggerating when we say that we have made the largest adjustment in the history of humanity. That is why I am not surprised that leaders of all colors and flags frequently accuse us of lacking management. To them, I say: you know what? Managing is not appointing thousands of officials in every corner of the State when half of those areas should not exist. Managing is not having a national director sign a resolution to spend millions of pesos on services that the private sector can provide better and cheaper. Managing is not building roads that lead nowhere, nor overcrowded housing that no one wants. Managing is not knowing how to use the GDE, as former candidate Massa said. Managing is having avoided the hyperinflation that was left at our doorstep.

Managing is cleaning up the balance sheet of the Central Bank and defusing the debt bomb we inherited. Managing is reducing public spending in the way we did, in the record time we did, and without abandoning the most vulnerable sectors of society. Managing is having approved the largest legislative reform in the last 40 years with 37 deputies and six senators, which is why I also thank many who have accompanied us in all these legislative actions. Managing is firing the 31,000 "ñoquis" we have fired in these first nine months. Managing is approving the Single Paper Ballot, a banner of those who talk about transparency but have done little for it.

Managing is eliminating the intermediaries who profited from poverty. Managing is having eliminated the blockades and going more than four months without street cuts in the AMBA. Managing is also having reduced homicides in Rosario by 75%. Managing is removing the endless regulations in all sectors of the economy to make life easier for those who undertake and work. Managing is regaining the trust of the private sector and having them project to invest more than 50 billion dollars, as they have already announced. Ultimately, managing is not administering the State; managing is shrinking the State to empower society.

We are resolving in one year the disaster that our predecessors, through action or omission, generated over more than 120 years. So, when those responsible for the failure accuse us of lacking management, we wear with pride what we are doing.

However, the giant challenge persists, and now we must make the titanic effort made by all Argentines count and give it sustainability for the future. That is why we have decided that part of our legacy is to change forever the methodology through which the Budget is prepared. The deficit has always been a consequence of first thinking about how much to spend and then seeing how to finance it. We are going to do it the other way around, first thinking about how much we need to save to then see how much we can spend. That is why we are proposing an unbreakable fiscal rule for this Budget and for all budgets that come from now on. I invite you to take a minute to clear the X with me to understand what it is about.

You can abstain because you are adding with difficulty.

Look, whether I read or not, you keep adding with difficulty, Martínez. You can still take notes because I am starting now, I am starting now. Let's go.

The first premise we start from is that the primary surplus must equal or exceed the amount of debt interest to be paid, so that if the primary surplus is the result of netting revenues with current and capital expenditures, primary spending must be equal to or less than revenues minus the primary surplus. That is, the level of spending to be incurred will be conditioned by the level of primary surplus to be achieved, which in turn will be conditioned by the observed revenues net of the amount of interest to be paid on the debt. Having said that, let us pause for a second on spending. Current spending is composed of the sum of automatic spending illicitly indexed by law and discretionary spending. Automatic spending is the component of spending that is indexed to inflation and other macro variables. Discretionary spending is not indexed, meaning that regardless of the inflation rate, it remains the same. Under this new scheme we are proposing, if revenues are greater than estimated, automatic spending could increase in line with revenues, but discretionary spending will remain frozen. On the other hand, looking now at revenues, when the increase in collection is transitory, the State will be able to save, absorbing pesos or to cancel debt, which will allow for continued reduction of inflation and/or improvement of the Argentine debt profile. And if permanent economic growth and, consequently, the increase in revenues is structural, the State will be able to return that higher collection to society through tax reductions, as we have committed.

On the other hand, if the economy does not grow and revenues are lower than estimated, automatic spending will also fall and we will reduce discretionary spending until we still reach zero deficit. Therefore, this time it will be the public sector and not the private sector that will absorb the effects of the disturbances that the economy suffers. In summary, our budgetary methodology will achieve three unprecedented objectives: one, it will shield fiscal balance forever, ending the punishment of debt and issuance; it will force the State to take responsibility and absorb the effects of disturbances in the economy; and when there are better times, as will be the coming years, it will force the return of excess collection to society through tax reductions. This means that, if this methodology is maintained from now on, we will not only be able to reduce taxes, but also the size of the State, which is the true tax pressure. I want to repeat it to make it clear and without doubts: this methodology we are presenting in the national Budget shields the fiscal result, whatever the macroeconomic scenario. It does not matter what happens with the economy, it does not matter if our estimates are right or wrong. Whatever the economic scenario, the fiscal result will always be guaranteed.

But for this to be possible, in Argentina we owe ourselves an honest debate about what the national State should take care of and what it should not. We have become accustomed to thinking of the national State as a nanny that has to take care of everything, from feeding to entertaining every citizen. But when a State arrogates tasks that do not belong to it, it ends up failing to fulfill the fundamental responsibilities that do belong to it. This is how we arrived at a State that, in the eagerness to fulfill all the supposed desires of its citizens, cannot fulfill even its basic obligations. This is how we reached 50% poverty, the return of illiteracy, astronomical crime rates, an energy framework that cannot withstand four consecutive days of heat, abandoned armed forces without response capacity, tragically slow justice, and public hospitals without supplies that cannot cure anyone. Meanwhile, billions of pesos were squandered on concerts attended by 300 people, public media serving militants, roads that led nowhere; and they spent the day enacting laws that ranged from ridiculous, useless, and harmful.

As Cicero said, the closer the collapse of an empire, the more foolish its laws become. And indeed, the Kirchnerism has done foolish things.

And worst of all, it left us a system in which 70% of public spending goes to various types of social spending. This, which has been hailed for years as a success by the entire political spectrum, indicates nothing more than a humanitarian tragedy, because it means that more than 20 million Argentines cannot sustain themselves without State assistance; assistance that is funded by robbing a part of society through taxes. If anyone believes that this is something desirable, let me tell you that they are mistaken. Do you think this is unrelated to the State performing its essential tasks so poorly?

That is why it is time to return to the basics and reshuffle and redefine some definitions. The fundamental thing that a national State must do is ensure macroeconomic stability, foreign relations, and the rule of law. Period. Any other issue can be resolved through the market or is the responsibility of subnational governments. To be clearer, I break it down into parts: What is macroeconomic stability? That there is no fiscal deficit, that there is monetary stability, and that, consequently, there is no inflation and economic growth is facilitated. Facilitate because the private sector decides where to invest, not a bureaucrat from a chair who, in the middle, takes something along the way.

Moreover, and that with no inflation there is no distortion of prices, and consequently, people, families, and businesses can regain economic calculation, the ability to project, and ultimately regain their future. What is the rule of law? Security to protect citizens from possible attacks on their lives and property. Justice to impartially resolve conflicts between citizens and punish those who violate the law. And defense to protect us from possible conflicts with other countries or external threats. I repeat, any other issue can be resolved through the market or is the responsibility of subnational governments.

It must be understood once and for all that it is not the State's job to interfere in the economic process. We do not believe in counter-cyclical economic policy or any kind; we believe in freedom, in property rights, and in allowing prices to express themselves freely. If the economic cycle is genuine, that is, if it is of real origin, the State has nothing to do but guarantee macroeconomic stability and the rule of law. If the economic cycle is not of real origin, but generated by the State, it is the same as accepting that a mobster breaks our legs and then comes to offer us crutches. We do not want the State's crutches; we want to live in freedom. We do not want our legs broken.

Just as the deficit is the heart of the problem, reducing spending to achieve a surplus will be at the center of the solution. Why? Because it is the only way to return to Argentines the fruits of their labor that the State is currently taking from them through taxes. A zero deficit will make the debt sustainable, the sustainability of the debt will lower the country risk and reduce the financial cost, contributing to an increase in investment and savings, and consequently, to the rise of real wages, which is the only way to reduce poverty and indigence. In turn, it will imply less future fiscal pressure on taxpayers, which will mean greater incentive to invest. In a globalized economy, and even more so since the existence of the Internet, capital has become nomadic. Today, anyone can open an account in the United States or Paraguay without leaving their home, and they do so seeking better fiscal conditions than those we offer. That is why it is imperative that Argentina becomes attractive again for Argentines. We must put an end to this urge to expel the capital of our compatriots with prohibitive taxes, which only serve to reduce the flow and size of our economy, punishing the country as a whole with more poverty and more exclusion. We want Argentine companies to become competitive again, so that they can hire more workers, pay better wages, and thus stop the exodus of human capital that we have been experiencing for more than 20 years. We must make peace once and for all with the idea that what is best for a worker is an entrepreneur who invests. But the only way to multiply the number of companies is to stop reaching into their pockets and freeing them from the hell of regulations, permits, and exorbitant costs that private activity faces in Argentina. To reach this point, we have proposed the most ambitious structural reform plan in all of Argentine history, which began with Decree 70/23, followed by the approval of the Bases Law passed by this Congress, and continues with all the deregulations we announce daily, adding the bills that we will continue to send to this Congress.

Thanks to this mega reform of the State that we have undertaken, we will be reaching levels of economic freedom similar to those of Germany, France, or Italy. In less than a year of management, against all odds. And we are on a firm course, determined to be the freest country in the world, because freedom will bring us prosperity and make us great again.

However, even if everything goes as we think, this war we are waging against public spending and the Argentine cost is fought in all dimensions of the State and also in provincial and municipal jurisdictions. That is why I tell the governors: fulfilling the commitment to reduce consolidated public spending to 25 points of GDP requires that the provinces, as a whole, make an additional adjustment of 60 billion dollars. We have already fulfilled our part of the agreement; now it is your turn. Argentines, across the country, know very well that for every peso that provinces and municipalities stop spending, they can return it in lower gross income or other taxes. If you comply with this popular mandate, good Argentines will be grateful. But let me say that there is something I am sure Argentines will not allow: when the national State eliminates or lowers a tax, you wanting to raise yours. It will not work. Argentines are a rebellious people, tired of the tricks of politicians. We are living a pivotal moment in our history; do not underestimate it. In fact, when I entered politics, I pointed out that I did not come to guide sheep, but to awaken lions.

I repeat, this does not complicate my conclusion: when I entered politics, I pointed out that I did not come to guide sheep but to awaken lions. And I tell you that, if you have not seen it or do not want to see it, the lions have awakened.

Finally… Finally… Finally… Do it within the Budget and not in a demagogic way, harming all Argentines, exterminating the youth.

Finally, I want to speak to the members of this Congress. This is a pivotal moment in the history of our country; moments where the course of history can be changed do not come often. If it were easy, we would not be where we are today. That is why we have the opportunity, more than the opportunity, the obligation to seize this moment, because remember: the deeper we sink to the bottom of the sea, the more we have to swim to stay afloat. But the only path to progress is to end the fiscal deficit, reduce public spending, eliminate taxes, and trust in the exercise of freedom by Argentines.

Everything that you hate.

If we do things right, we will live in a country with economic stability, where planning a life project, starting a family, or embarking on a profitable business will once again be a reality. If we do things right, we will top the rankings of economic freedom in the world. If we do things right, we will have a country where the State will once again be a servant of its citizens and not their master, as Milton Friedman said. If we do things right, we will reverse the century of humiliation to which Argentines have been unjustly condemned. That is why, honorable members of the National Congress, the present national political hour offers you two options: one is to do exactly the opposite of what we have been doing for more than 100 years, to take off and make Argentina great again; the other is to continue doing the same as always, leaving everything as it is and maintaining this putrid system that impoverishes all Argentines day by day. Those are the two paths. Know this, members of this honorable Congress, that the decision of which side of history you want to be on is yours. Then it will be the citizens who place you on the avenue of the just or on the corner of the miserable rats who bet against the country and against its people.

To conclude, I want to quote again Marcus Tullius Cicero, the great Roman legislator, who said: "The budget must be balanced, the treasury must be replenished, the public debt must be reduced, the arrogance of public officials must be moderated and controlled, and aid to other countries must be eliminated so that Rome does not go bankrupt. People must learn again to work instead of living at the expense of the State." This phrase is over 2,000 years old.

Over 2,000 years, and you have learned nothing from it.

I trust that this honorable National Congress will debate the National Budget project with the responsibility and seriousness that our current situation requires. May God bless the Argentines and may the Forces of Heaven accompany us. Long live freedom, damn it! Long live freedom, damn it! Long live freedom, damn it! Thank you very much.