Words of the President of the Nation, Javier Milei, before investors, from the New York Stock Exchange, USA.

Argentina Javier Milei · President of Argentina

23 September 2024 · Reception with investors · New York Stock Exchange, New York, United States

Context
Milei addressed investors at the New York Stock Exchange on September 23, 2024, presenting Argentina's economic turnaround and reform agenda.
Main themes
Fiscal consolidation and deficit reduction, economic crisis inheritance, inflation and monetary imbalance, Argentina's economic recovery, zero deficit goal, libertarian liberal governance, debt and Central Bank liabilities, pension reform veto, investor confidence, structural adjustment
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,183
87th percentile
Sentences
125
73rd percentile
Readability
43
44th percentile
Grade
14.8
74th percentile
Syntax
3.53
95th percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
45th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 69%67%
  • Social 12%12%
  • Institutional 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

125 sentences in 25 paragraphs

Hello everyone. Thank you very much for this reception. It is a great honor for me to be in this house, sharing the experience of the Argentine case.

When we arrived in government, Argentina was basically on the brink of what would have been the worst crisis in its history, as it combined the elements of the three largest crises in Argentine history. In addition, we had a monetary imbalance that was double what we had in 1975, prior to the Rodrigazo; we had a situation in the Central Bank that was much more precarious than what we had in 1989, before Alfonsín's hyperinflation; and we had social indicators worse than those we had at the end of convertibility. Therefore, everything was set for a true explosion to occur. At the same time, Argentina was showing twin deficits equivalent to 17 points of GDP. You know that the literature on early crisis indicators states that a 4-point twin deficit, in terms of GDP, is a yellow alert; in the case of an 8-point GDP deficit, it heralds a tremendous crisis. So imagine what it was like to face 17 points; of those 17 points, 15 were generated from the national public sector, where 5 corresponded to the fiscal deficit generated by the Treasury and 10 points corresponded to the quasi-fiscal deficit, that is, the deficit generated by the Central Bank. This, moreover, in a context where the Central Bank had negative net international reserves of about 12 billion dollars; we had debts with importers of 50 billion dollars; we had pending dividend payments of 10 billion dollars; we had debt maturities - in pesos - equivalent to 90 billion dollars; debt maturities, in dollars, of 25 billion dollars, mainly with multilaterals, but we had the agreement with the International Monetary Fund fallen due to the successive defaults of the previous government. And, in addition, we had - within the balance of the Central Bank - remunerated liabilities equivalent to 4 monetary bases that were due in 1 day. In short, everything was set for a true catastrophe. However, we never complained about the inheritance; we only described it, because we must also be honest that - under normal conditions of pressure and temperature - I would not be president; under normal conditions, there would be no libertarian liberal presidents, and that is why there have never been any in the world. That is why I am the first libertarian liberal president in the history of humanity.

In that sense, at the same time, inflation was running - when one looked at the first week of December - at a rate of 1% daily. That is about 3700% annually. In the first fifteen days of December, it was already running at a rate of 7500% annually, and the wholesale inflation - for the month of December - was at 54%, which annualized gave 17,000%, which was absolutely feasible, given all the monetary imbalance that Argentina was showing and that, under normal conditions, Argentina would have validated monetarily. Therefore, to avoid the catastrophe that would have caused hyperinflation, we needed to quickly cut monetary issuance. In that sense, the first thing we undertook was - on the Treasury side - a strong fiscal adjustment, and we set the goal of achieving a zero deficit. The zero deficit goal - in financial terms - implies that the debt does not grow anymore; if the debt does not grow, the debt-to-GDP ratio is non-increasing, therefore, the country becomes a solvent debtor and, consequently, worthy of credit.

That task that we set out to achieve in the first year of management, everyone told us it was impossible, that it was impossible for us to make an adjustment of 5 points of GDP, that only, in the best of cases, an adjustment of 1 point of GDP could be made. Moreover, in the last 123 years of history, Argentina showed a fiscal deficit in 113; and in the 10 years it had a surplus, that surplus is misleading because Argentina was in default and did not pay interest. And surprisingly, and thanks to the enormous work of my great Minister of Economy - who is Luis "Tota" Caputo, who is here - we achieved financial balance in the first month of management. Today, we have already had 8 months of financial surplus; we have managed to reduce the country risk from levels of 2900 points to 1300 and with a trend for it to continue to decrease and with an unbreakable commitment to public accounts. In fact, a few days ago, I was forced to veto an irresponsible increase in pensions by Congress, where - incredibly - while during the previous administration pensions lost about 40% in real terms, and during our government, they have gained more than 5% in real terms, they voted for a law that implied an increase in public spending of at least 1.2% of GDP. Furthermore, they had not proposed any financing mechanism, which made it an absolutely irresponsible situation, and that - in dynamic terms - implied increasing the debt-to-GDP ratio by 67% of GDP. That is to say, it directly implied exterminating the future of young people with an absolutely unpayable debt.

Therefore, our commitment to fiscal balance is unbreakable, and we are not willing to negotiate - under any circumstances - fiscal balance. This fiscal balance - as the months went by - allowed us not only to save the program with the International Monetary Fund but also, at the same time, allowed us to build a curve of pesos, and in that context, we began the cleaning up of the Central Bank, since two-thirds of the deficit was generated from the Central Bank, and that implied endogenous money creation that also fueled inflation. We had already cut the Treasury's issuance channel; so now we had to start cutting the issuance channels of the Central Bank.

And that task that no one mentioned, that no one dared to point out how it was resolved, in a gigantic effort, worthy of a cyclops, our Central Bank president, Santiago Bausili, in 7 months, managed to eliminate the quasi-fiscal deficit, along with an enormous task done by our Secretary of Finance, Dr. Pablo Quirno, and - from now on - Argentina will no longer issue money to finance the Treasury or to finance the quasi-fiscal deficit. Therefore, we were in a position to move forward, not only now, towards a situation of zero deficit but we were in a position to move towards a situation of zero excess money supply. This meant that we were in a position to issue only against the purchase of dollars, and in that context, basically, what we considered was that this issuance had as a counterpart the demand for money and that - consequently - this would not lead to a loss of purchasing power of the currency, and therefore would work well to lower inflation. However - as we progressed - we realized that, in fact, given the capital controls that still persist, that although it is much less than what we had when we started, just to give you an order of magnitude: when we arrived, only 15% of imports were paid, and today, 95% of imports are paid.

And, in that sense, we still have stock problems to resolve, and that has consequences in the design of monetary policy, which I will explain shortly. But one of the things we realized is that - when one has free capital mobility - those who bring dollars are buying pesos and those pesos are bought to make transactions, and that is why it does not generate inflation. However, when you have capital controls, that operation is not so much buying pesos, but selling dollars because they are obliged, and those pesos that you are issuing now do not necessarily have demand for money and - therefore - the remainder is what is generating inflation. Faced with that situation, we decided to radicalize our monetary policy and directly go to a level of zero issuance; that is, the amount of money remains constant.

Naturally, this has already brought consequences and can be seen, because wholesale inflation - today - is at 2.1%. This means that from traveling at an annualized inflation of 17,000%; today we are at levels of 2%, which means 28% annually. Which is a true feat because we have done this without fixing the exchange rate; without controlling prices; without a prior hyperinflation that allows the reconstruction of the demand for money and facilitates stabilization; without violating property rights and in the meantime, also restoring relative prices of prices that had been suppressed by the previous administration. That is why I always say that my Minister of Economy, of whom I am so proud, Dr. Luis "Toto" Caputo, will be remembered as the best Minister of Economy in history because what he is doing is truly an enormous task.

That said - in the face of this new monetary policy scheme - we were questioned about the intervention in the market and we were questioned about the accumulation of reserves. Regarding the intervention, given that we still have capital controls, what I can say is that the level of intervention - now - has decreased because in a world without intervention… what would the world be like without intervention? The exchange rate would be free; the variation in the amount of money would be zero and the variation in reserves would be zero. In that context, the parallel exchange rate is free in Argentina, not only that, but also before - as we forced exporters to liquidate their dollars - for every 3 dollars we bought, we were intervening for three. Today - as we keep the amount of pesos constant - at the beginning we basically returned 2 dollars, which means that the intervention had fallen by a third and today that the gap is much smaller and basically the levels of intervention continue to fall. Therefore, far from having more intervention, there is less intervention.

At the same time, we are questioned about the accumulation of reserves, and the truth is that it is a rather ridiculous and conceptually poor argument because the question is: if that argument were true, it would mean that all countries with a free exchange rate would enter into default, which is an enormous nonsense. Basically, our argument is that - the dollars to pay the debt services - must be bought with fiscal surplus; they must be bought with fiscal discipline; with fiscal savings and not with monetary issuance, because when you buy them with monetary issuance, in reality, what you are doing is defrauding the citizens, because - on the one hand - you buy dollars; inject pesos, but those dollars that the Central Bank has - bought with the issuance of pesos, then the Government places bonds on the Central Bank. In fact, the largest creditor of the national state is the Central Bank; in the last administration, the Treasury robbed the Central Bank, and - therefore - the Argentines, 45 billion dollars, and therefore we are not going to enable that fraud.

The moment has ended when the Argentine state defrauded - mainly - good Argentines and their creditors. Therefore, dollars will be bought with fiscal surplus and not with hidden inflation tax. That said, we have not only worked on stabilizing the macro, as another of the great demands that my shock description had, as president, was not only to tame inflation, which is on the way, but also - in addition - we had on the agenda to reduce insecurity. Argentina seemed like a lawless land; it seemed impossible to control marches, blockades, and all those illegal activities that obstructed the possibility of working peacefully for good Argentines. And in that sense, I also want to recognize the enormous work of my Minister of Security, Dr. Patricia Bullrich - who is also here with us - where, in the face of the first march, she developed the Anti-Blockade Protocol, and - from then on - no street has been blocked in Argentina. In fact, we have gone 4 months without a blockade, meaning they have completely given up. And not only that, but also - in the province of Santa Fe - the city of Rosario, a hotspot that is often a victim of drug trafficking; last month, there were zero homicides, and since the implementation of the Bandera Plan, there has been an 80% drop. Therefore, we are also fulfilling that part, which required the shock description to end insecurity.

Not only that, but also, from the very campaign, we have had a clear international position. Moreover, we have always said that we would be allied with the free world, that we would be against autocrats. Even as a deputy, I had expressed my support for Ukraine in the face of the Russian invasion, and moreover, my alignment with the United States was so clear - regardless of who would be governing the United States - because it is a strategic decision to be an ally of the United States, as a representative of the free world; we also said that we would align with Israel; we also pointed out that we would align with the free world and that we would flatly reject the 2030 agenda and everything related to the woke catechism.

In that sense, yesterday, my great chancellor, Dr. Diana Mondino - who is here - gave a true lesson on why the United Nations should not stray from its original goal of maintaining peace and should stop embracing the entire socialist agenda, which only leads to impoverishment. Therefore, yesterday, we also demonstrated strong evidence of our alignment not only with the free world but - moreover - with the ideas of free market capitalism.

Naturally, we are also questioned about our social policy; they say we have no heart. I would say that those who make that comment have no brains. In fact, they did not like the last post I made on Instagram about the KU-K12 virus. But beyond that, the only budget items that grew significantly - during our Government - were those related to social containment spending. We knew that making the largest fiscal adjustment in the history of humanity would put social conditions at risk, and there we not only doubled the allocations. In fact, regarding the two most important programs in Argentina, which are the Universal Child Allowance and the Food Card, not only were they doubled and more, but today they cover the entire basic basket. Therefore, that represents a substantial improvement compared to what the populist government, so concerned about the people, only covered half. But not only that, but also, in the meantime, we ended up with intermediaries, with the managers of poverty, that is, with those who kept part of the money that was supposed to go to the most vulnerable sectors. And, obviously, touching those privileges; touching those thefts generated many press operations against our Government; press operations that are also overstimulated by the simple fact that we cut their advertising budget. We believe in true freedom, not in a Government having to bribe journalists to say what one wants; if they are so good, let them compete in the market and earn the favor of the consumer, as all good companies earn their market.

But that is not all, as we also initiated a set of structural reforms, promoting the Basic Law and sending a Decree of Necessity and Urgency, where we managed to pass these reforms, with 15% from the Chamber of Deputies, and with 10% from the Senate, and it is incredible that they still question us about the lack of management; in this, I must also deeply thank Dr. Guillermo Francos, who is in Buenos Aires, for his management regarding the political issue and for achieving such results.

Why are these reforms important? First: because these reforms are 8 times larger than the reform that Carlos Saúl Menem made in the 90s; considering that Menem's reform had been the largest in history. Today, the largest structural reform in history is the one we are carrying out, and we did it in just 6 months.

This will mean that Argentina will climb nearly 80 places - in terms of economic freedom - and that, in terms of system functioning, we will start to resemble countries like: Germany, Italy, France. But that is not enough for us. We plan to be the freest country in the world, and for that, we still have 3,200 structural reforms pending that, when we finish them, will undoubtedly make us the freest country in the world. In this, I also want to highlight the enormous work being carried out by another of my great ministers, Dr. Federico Sturzenegger, where - day by day - we are deregulating and removing obstacles to the economy. Therefore, do not doubt that we will give everything to make the country the freest in the world, because those countries that are freer are 12 times richer than the repressed, have double the growth rate; have 25 times fewer poor people in the standard format and 50 times fewer in the extreme format. Therefore, if Argentina wants to get out of the pit - that socialism sank us into - what we need is to embrace the city of freedom again. Something we already did, as - Argentina - embraced the ideas of freedom in 1860, when the Constitution of Alberdi, from 1853, was put into effect. And from being a country of barbarians - in 35 years - we became the world's leading power. So with a more integrated world, better communicated, and with many more technological possibilities to accelerate convergence, why wouldn’t we do it now? All we need is courage, and - believe me - if there is one thing I have in abundance, it is courage to do it.

Finally, the question is how will they grow? The first point is that growth or expansion will have two parts. There is a part that will have to do with what is cyclical recovery; in fact, today, when one looks at the economic series, 80% of the series are starting to show positive results. That is to say, the map of Argentine activity is starting to be painted - almost entirely - green, and that is partly due to a cyclical recovery; for 5 months, wages have been systematically outpacing inflation, meaning we have an improvement in real wages; this also applies to pensions.

At the same time, lowering inflation is eliminating that distortion that inflation generates in the functioning of the price system. In fact, I also want to mention something, because the Argentine experience also shows something interesting in terms of stabilization, and that is that the healthy way to correct inflation is not by raising interest rates, but by stopping the printing of money. Because what needs to be understood is that the interest rate exists - independently - of whether money exists. The interest rate exists because time exists, not because there is a Central Bank printing money. And that was a very important element because when we did not heed the recommendations to raise interest rates as a stabilization mechanism, we would have had a monetary liabilities relationship, in terms of monetary base, of about 10 times today and we would be discussing the characteristics of the Argentine catastrophe, and not how Argentina managed to end inflation.

But sometimes it is necessary to return to the roots, we must go back to reading the authors of the 19th and early 20th centuries, before the aberration of 1936 appeared, called: “General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money,” by that sinister being who was John Maynard Keynes. That said… I am Milei, what did you expect? That said, we also have an element that plays in our favor, which is the recomposition of stocks; therefore, the Argentine economy had been overstocked in the last part of the Kirchnerist government, in case hyperinflation broke out and to be protected with real assets. And those stocks were depleted - in the first part of the year - and, therefore, today the stock cycle plays positively, just like the recomposition of demand - via wage increases and pension increases - and this is manifesting in that the level of utilization of installed capacity is increasingly rising in the different sectors of the economy, but - clearly - that contributes to the cycle.

But that is not all, there is more, and there are more things that will favor economic growth. First, growth is generated by investment, and you need to finance investment, that is, you need savings, and basically the fiscal adjustment we have made has returned 15 points of GDP in savings to Argentines. That is to say, while - in December of last year - we were discussing the characteristics of hyperinflation; today we discuss the existence of thirty-year credit and how thirty-year credits are structured. Therefore, this shows that banks have stopped being an office to indirectly finance the treasury - and have had to start working as bankers, which is what we wanted them to do. On the other hand, this will be a great element for economic growth. At the same time, we will lift the capital controls. We will lift the capital controls when the inflation rate, which the macroeconomic program has, is zero; basically, you have an observed inflation in the consumer of 4%, and an inflation induced by the program - given the capital controls, given the crawling peg and international inflation - of 2.5%, therefore, that inflation is now at 1.5%. When that 1.5% has disappeared, it will occur in a situation where the LeFis have also disappeared and the monetary base - in the traditional format - coincides with the broad monetary base. At that moment, the money overhang will have disappeared and we will be able to open - without any problems - the capital controls because there will no longer be bullets to load the weapons that could undermine macroeconomic stability, because the excess pesos within the economy will have been eliminated.

At the same time, our fiscal discipline will mean that, inexorably, the Country Risk will fall. In fact, when we discussed the impacts of what Congress is doing, we noticed that every time the Country Risk rises by 100 basis points, GDP - in dollars - falls by 1.8 and falls by 0.6, in pesos. This means that, for example, if we were to return to the ways proposed by the fiscal degenerates in the National Congress of Argentina, it would mean losing a third of GDP, it would mean losing about 200 billion dollars. I will not allow it, I will veto all the excesses they want to commit when they want to attack the fiscal result.

And the consequence of this will be that - inexorably - the Country Risk will fall; the interest rate will decrease and, consequently, we will accelerate capital accumulation; productivity will increase and the Argentine economy will grow and recover its wages. And one last note on the capital controls: unlike all other experiences that exited by going from the official exchange rate to the parallel, we are demonstrating that it can be done from the parallel to the official. When we launched the zero emission program, basically what we were facing was a situation where the parallel exchange rate was at 1500, where analysts' forecasts said that - in the coming weeks - it would go to 2000. Today the parallel exchange rate is at 1200, in some measurements at 1190, while the official exchange rate - corrected by the Country Tax - is around 1100. That is to say that today, the gap is compressing to less than 10%. Therefore, when we said that the gap would close, from the top down, we are fulfilling it, and the day we finish lifting the capital controls, the excess demand for foreign currency will close and, therefore, the excess supply in the bond market will close and, therefore, the price of bonds will rise; the interest rate will fall; the excess supply in the goods market will close; there will be an additional expansion in economic activity; the excess supply of labor will also close and, therefore, there will be higher wages with more jobs and, consequently, fewer poor and indigent people.

Therefore, I want to tell you that - Argentina - is getting back on its feet, embracing the ideas of freedom. We are committed to making the best government in history; we are committed to being a beacon of light for the ideas of freedom, so that everyone sets aside socialist ideas and returns to embrace the ideas of freedom, and we are convinced that we will achieve it.

So thank you very much! Long live freedom, damn it!