Speech by President Javier Milei at the ExpoEFI Argentina 2025

Argentina Javier Milei · President of Argentina

30 April 2025 · ExpoEFI Argentina 2025 · Congress

Context
Milei addressed the ExpoEFI Argentina 2025 conference on April 30, 2025, presenting Argentina's economic stabilization achievements and outlining the path toward growth.
Main themes
Economic growth, fiscal adjustment, inflation stabilization, fiscal deficit reduction, monetary policy reform, Argentine economic crisis, Central Bank balance sheet cleanup, history of Argentine economic crises, government economic program
Duration
~98 min
98th percentile
Words
11,700
98th percentile
Sentences
477
98th percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
11.1
34th percentile
Syntax
3.13
64th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 75%73%
  • Institutional 10%10%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

477 sentences in 55 paragraphs

Good morning. Thank you very much to the authorities of Congress for allowing me this opportunity to be with you. Today's talk is about economic growth. In other words, it is time for economic growth. We have completed the stabilization phase. This does not mean that things are perfect, but we have indeed concluded the stabilization. Specifically, when we arrived, we were on the brink of the biggest crisis in Argentine history, as we combined, on one hand, the monetary imbalance prior to the Rodrigazo; in fact, the money overhang was double what we had before the Rodrigazo. For those who are younger, the Rodrigazo occurred in 1975, after years of price controls, fiscal deficits, monetary issuance, all kinds of controls. And one day a man named Celestino Rodrigo came along and had no choice but to liberalize, devalue, and that led to an acceleration of the inflation rate by 6 times, going from 30% to 180%, and the number of poor people multiplied by five; it went from 5 to 25. We also combined - in this inheritance we received - a Central Bank imbalance three times worse than what existed before the hyperinflation of Alfonsín in 1989, an episode that ended with wholesale inflation around 5,000%.

Specifically, we had four monetary bases maturing in one day, and therefore - in the face of any complicated event - the amount of money could have quintupled in one day, which was also fuel for hyperinflation. And as if that were not enough, we had social indicators worse than those of 2001. Therefore, we faced the worst economic crisis in history, and that is why I always have great gratitude for the entire Government team, for the courage to accompany me in this truly heroic endeavor and - especially - to the one who sat in the worst of electric chairs, the best Minister of Economy in all of history, Luis “Toto” Caputo.

From there, we, with “Toto,” with whom I sincerely have a symbiotic relationship - basically - shared the diagnosis that while inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon, the origin of that issuance was due to the fiscal deficit. Probably, one of the most impressive talks was the first talk that “Toto” gave at the beginning of the Government, when he announced the characteristics of the program and showed how - in reality - the whole problem was fiscal. The regulations come from the fiscal problem; all the issues of the Argentine framework are the result of not wanting to correct the true cause of the problem, which is the fiscal deficit, basically putting patches elsewhere. That is to say, fiscal deficit financed with monetary issuance. So, it generated inflation. What did they do? Price controls. Shortages appeared; Supply Law. Reserves began to dwindle; capital controls were imposed. The central axis is always fiscal balance. In fact, there is a memorable graph that the professor Espert, president of the Budget and Finance Commission of Congress, who fights so hard against the orcs and is present; thank you, professor, for being here, used for a long time.

The professor showed - for example - the Argentine crises; the Rodrigazo exploded with a fiscal deficit of 14 points of GDP; the exchange rate table with 11; Alfonsín's hyperinflation with 8, convertibility with 7. Well, we inherited a fiscal deficit of 15 points of GDP: 5 in the Treasury and 10 in the Central Bank. And, in that context, we revved up the chainsaw and initiated the largest fiscal adjustment not only in Argentine history but in the history of humanity. While they said it was impossible to make an adjustment of 1 point of GDP, we managed to make a fiscal adjustment that, in fact, at the beginning was 7 points of GDP, then the allocations were rearranged, and it ended up being 5 points of GDP. And - after 123 years of always having a fiscal deficit - it was the first year we had fiscal balance in a year, and we achieved it in just one month. But also, as “Toto” recently brilliantly explained, that was not enough. That is to say, we could have made the fiscal adjustment and still fallen into hyperinflation due to the situation we had in the monetary market. And that is when what is called stage 2 of the program began, which is when we started to clean up the balance sheet of the Central Bank, and in 6 months, thanks not only to “Toto's” work but to the enormous work of Santiago Bausili and his entire team, in coordination with Pablo Quirno, they managed to eliminate the quasi-fiscal deficit in Argentina in 6 months. Therefore, we made an adjustment of 15 points of GDP in 6 months; that is indeed something for the Guinness World Records.

And from there, the inflation rate, and I usually talk about wholesale inflation because it did not have the strong contamination of the relative price problem as a consequence of the price suppression that the previous cave government did, and the inflation, which was at 54%, ended the year around 1%; the last wholesale figure was 1.5%, which still had the crawling peg of 1%, so one could say it is an inflation of 0.5% monthly. This means that inflation went from traveling at levels of 17,000% annually to 6% annually. That is indeed a miracle as well.

And that, moreover, was done without expropriations, that is to say, we avoided hyperinflation, which makes stabilization programs simpler because everything gets liquefied and it becomes easier; we, precisely, what we tried to avoid was that, since that was what they left us planted so that, with all the machinery of Peronism, by December we would no longer be here, by the end of December, when the holidays arrived. But not only that, but also, it was done without expropriating. For example, we did not implement a Bonex Plan. Everything we did to restore the balance of the Central Bank was done respecting property rights. Not only that, but there were also no price controls; the exchange rate was not fixed, and despite that, the speed at which inflation fell was much faster than what was achieved in the case of convertibility when you look at it in dollars.

But, of course - when we started to stabilize - first, it was that we were not lowering inflation… Ah, and we also did it by recomposing relative prices, in a context where tariffs only covered 20% of the cost or the aberration we had in the Central Bank, that we only had… just from the SIRAs we had more than 40 billion dollars in debt, so we were on the brink of an external commercial collapse; an internal financial collapse, and moreover, only 15% of imports were being paid. And, in that context, first, they said we would not be able to lower inflation in the first months from 30 to 20%; then that we would not be able to lower it from 8; then that we could not lower it from 4; then that we could not lower it from 2. And the reality is that - when one starts to look at the data from the last year - cleaning it from the effect of the crawling peg, it was an inflation that was traveling at 1.5. There is a special chapter on what happened in March; not only because of the issue of seasonality, which in fact in González Rozada's estimation shows that that 3.7 corrected for seasonalities is 2.6. But I am not here to complain, but the most serious problem was that stupidity of a law, that the idiot, incapable, and underqualified Guzmán passed, which forces having to pass a program from the International Monetary Fund through Congress. That is to say, the place where the fiscal degenerates are.

Look, I am going to tell you something that happened to me when I was a deputy, and it is an interesting anecdote because it includes both Professor Espert and me. Let's see, the Budget when you have… the democratic construction is no taxation without representation. So - consequently - the Budget has to enter through the Chamber of Deputies, because they are the representatives of the people, let’s suppose. I don’t know why he is laughing. Well, but follow my argument. You see? Then I talk about the republican nerds and I am right, if I just said this and they laughed at me. So, it is interesting because it is the initiating chamber of the Budget, because - deep down - money has to be forcibly taken from the taxpayer to finance public spending. That is to say, it is the place where budgetary restraint should be breathed, and Argentina has had 123 consecutive years of fiscal deficit, so they should be breathing with scuba masks, I don’t know. But beyond that, it is interesting because when you are there and a project is being presented and a law is discussed, we were assigned time, we were assigned time; I am now in another power, but we were assigned time. And this is very interesting because - except for José Luis (Espert) and me - every Deputy who was assigned, I don’t know, 5 minutes, spoke for 10; if they were given 10, they spoke for 20; if they were given 15, they spoke for 30. That is to say, how could one expect them to comply with budgetary restraint if they could not even comply with the Budget restraint, which implied complying with the amount of time to speak…

Imagine - if on top of that - they cannot draw a zero, not even with a glass, of course, that is why we systematically had fiscal deficits and the disasters we had. Now - once inflation started to go down - what did the beasts with Keynesian genes tell us? That we were going to fall into a great depression. The truth is that adjustments of half the size generated GDP drops of 15%, so they had something to say, I am not going to get… imagine that when you are in the electric chair pragmatism has a significant dose, you do not stop looking at the other side of the library. That said, then they said that - when the economy started to rebound around April, they began to say that this was going to be an L and that we were going to stabilize, but that the level of activity was going to remain fixed there. But it turns out that activity began to grow, the seasonally adjusted figures began to show positive rates. So, they started to say that we were going to have a Nike swoosh, but very soft. Then it was the Nike swoosh; then they began to understand that it was indeed a V or - as I said - we are going to rise like a scuba diver's fart and we ended up having a tilde.

And that is indeed the case. When one takes the seasonally adjusted EMAE, it ended 6 points above the level of December of the previous year. So, not only did we make the largest adjustment in history, but it also ended up being expansive. You bet this man “Toto” Caputo deserves a round of applause.

And then they started to cry to us about the social issue, and they said that we did not have a heart, what do I know, about those things they say. And the reality is that - for the past 11 months - real wages have not stopped rising; the unemployment rate did not increase, and, between the work done from macroeconomics, the enormous work of Sandra Pettovello cutting off the scam to the managers of poverty, and with Patricia Bullrich maintaining order on the streets, that improvement in activity, improvement in employment, improvement in real wages made poverty - measured in monthly frequency - which is also in González-Rozada's work, the methodologies are all similar, they only change in the temporal frequency they are measured, and that number, which - when we made the economy honest - jumped to 57%, is now at 35%. This means that poverty fell by 22 percentage points. That is to say that the heartless liberals who do not care about people lifted 10 million human beings out of poverty, something that had never happened in Argentine history with such strength and in such a short time.

Finally, in light of so many achievements - they always had something to criticize - and the sanateros of the delayed real exchange rate started; it seems they did not understand that the logic of the model had changed, that we were working and there were those who said: “I have seen this before.” No, you have not seen a damn thing, literally. Basically because you have never seen fiscal balance, you have never seen a fixed monetary base. So it was: “no, well, but why don’t you open up?” Well, there was a problem of stocks; and we said that as soon as we could solve the stock problem, we would open the capital controls. Moreover, we had said that - in any case - the capital controls would end on December 31, the 25th.

So, obviously, the political misery and incompetence of a large part of the local economists said that we were not going to lift the restrictions in an election year; that we were going to wait for the elections to pass. And, as a result of the damn Guzmán Law, we announced on March 1 that we were going to make a program with the Fund, that we were going to clean up the balance of the Central Bank, something we had been working on since August/September of the previous year, when we began to see that the economy was not going to have monetary input and, in that context, when we announced, on March 1, that we were going to reach an agreement with the Fund and that it had to go through Congress; something that had never happened in history because that restriction was not there before, until Guzmán imposed it. Therefore, all those who made agreements with the Fund without that restriction and who complained about the way we masterfully handled the politics, and who hurt because everyone expected that we would not be able to pass it through Congress, began to cry - as always - the republican crybabies; who, by the way, I honestly do not care about their feelings, I play within the law, I am a Bilardista and within the field, everything is allowed, everything that the regulations permit… was it allowed in the regulations? Yes, well, let them go look for it, it’s inside. And then, all the doomsayers began to say that the exchange rate was lagging and that this had to soar through the clouds and all that mountain of nonsense and, during March and mid-April, we had a confidentiality agreement with the Fund and we could not talk, and while we remained silent, while the idiots in the media said that we were not talking because we were scared. But we did not talk because we could not release information. And that, all the enemies of the Argentines, because it is no longer a problem of being enemies of the Government, but they are the enemies of the Argentines, those who have profited over the last hundred years with this impoverishing model, whether they are patronage-seeking businessmen, corrupt politicians, bribed journalists, union bosses, or professionals functional to this group of sons of bitches who ruined the country.

And, in that context, they predicted the worst of results when we wanted to open up, they said that this was a symptom that we were acknowledging the problem of the lagging exchange rate… And we opened up, and, nothing, the laboratories that sell Adermicina are happy with so much pain in the monkeys. So… it’s incredible that there are still some who talk about a lagging exchange rate, in a context where the exchange rate is free. Not only was the apocalyptic scenario that it would break 1,400 and go who knows where not given… the truth is that it is getting closer to the lower band. And as time goes by and we continue to have a fiscal surplus and take pesos out of circulation and when we make the placement of the BOPREAL and take out more pesos and when the dollars from abroad start to come in… Oh, how it will hurt them. But, all this and it’s like I made a catharsis, and now the reality is that from now on, the only note - in the margin - that I will add is, well, but you could tell me: “inflation is still high.” Yes, it is still high. But I want to tell you that inflation - by the middle of next year - will end. And, basically, it is because monetary policy acts with a lag that ranges from 18 to 24 months. We fixed the amount of money in the middle of last year. That means that inflation has a date of death, and it is in the middle of next year. So now is the time to start thinking about growth.

So, before we start talking about economic growth, there are two reflections that - for the talk, for me - are very important: one that has to do with crises, which is a phrase from Murray Newton Rothbard, the inventor of anarcho-capitalism, because this is central, this is central, and he says: “The crisis is not economic but ethical. Although its manifestation is material, its root is spiritual; we are immersed in a despicable philosophy, a philosophy that puts the individual at the service of the State, exposed to the shadow of coercion.” This is not a minor issue, you know that we are in an election year; yesterday we had a great rodeo festival in two places, because that giant I have as Chief of Staff, a great coordinating minister and who is the great responsible for the acceleration that the reform took in the second half of last year, and that makes this Government travel at a stellar speed. We recently celebrated 500 days of Government, with how many structural reforms? 2,000. We are the most reformist Government in history. We made a structural reform 8 times larger than the one Menem made, only if we take DNU 70/23 and the Base Law. But - in the year - we also included 900 more deregulations, we have already reached 2,000 structural reforms and, in addition, we have lowered the inflation rate faster than in Menem’s Government, therefore, whether our detractors like it or not, this is the best Government in Argentine history.

And why do I cite Rothbard and the issue of why the crisis is ethical in nature? The best example is the restrictions. You know me: for years I have been a liberal-libertarian, and that has not changed one bit. And, in that sense, the restrictions are a monstrous tool because - basically - what it does is not allow you to choose how you want to save, which not only has negative effects on the present but also has negative effects on the future. That is to say, it produces enormous intertemporal damage, where basically, you, with the restrictions… think of someone who, in December 2001, had 1,000 dollars and 1,000 pesos, if they had stayed with 1,000 pesos - today - they would have one dollar (if we were at the floor of the band, which we believe we will reach at some point, if not a little less). But clearly, it would have gone very badly for them. So - in that context - that generates a big problem, it generates a big problem also of macroeconomic discoordination because when you set a price generating excess demand, the counterpart is an excess supply, in the rest of the system. That is, the excess demand for foreign currency implies an excess supply of bonds. That is to say, low bond prices and high interest rates, therefore excess supply in the goods market, so the economy does not grow, it stagnates. So, that generates an excess supply in the labor market; wages are destroyed; you have more poor people, more indigents and, consequently, the State thinks it has to intervene and spend more, which creates a vicious circle.

But, in addition, it has another immorality. You end up having more money than you want to have, the famous “money-overhang” and that means that it is a tax increase, where you are increasing the tax base of the inflation tax, a total immorality, a robbery, a scam. And the reality is that we - as liberals - could not allow that, but we also could not be so irresponsible as to let the issue of stocks explode. And in that context, we had done the math and the reality is that, with 12 billion dollars, we could get out, so I said: “that if I got 15 billion dollars I would open up.” And then they started to say: “that we were not going to open up because it was an election year, that we were not going to take risks, that we were not going to accept paying the cost of exchange rate freedom” and the package ended up being a package of 42 billion dollars; if you want to add the early renewal of the Swap with China, it’s even more. But we had 20,000 cash and, contrary to what the econochantas and politicians said, we opened the restrictions because freedom is not negotiable; we got the stock; we cleaned up the Central Bank and we opened because the policy - in this Government - is guided by ethics, it is guided by moral values and that - inevitably - will generate a better Argentina.

But - now - it is time for growth and I would like to share some stylized facts about growth so that - more or less - you can understand or assimilate the way in which we think about these issues. When one studies the growth books, the vast majority of them start with something that those of us who are used to the literature call: ‘The hockey stick’. It is a series of per capita GDP, from the year zero of the Christian era until the year 2000, where basically you see that until the year 1800 it is a straight line and, suddenly, it takes a turn and starts to accelerate. In fact, if you want to break down the GDP, in all that period it multiplied per capita by 13.8 times. However, in the span from the year 1 to 1800, it only increased by 50%. That is to say, it multiplied by 1.5. And all of it concentrated after the discovery of America. While when you look at what happened between the year 1800 and the year 2000, it multiplied by 9.2 times. That is to say, we are living in a moment that is the best moment in the history of humanity. I don’t know where the leftists see that this is the end of capitalism, truly these kids use one that is really good.

You did well yesterday, Manuel, when you said that if a leftist insults you and calls you a “ñoqui” it is a compliment and when you said that you didn’t even want to listen to the other leftist, the truth is that… and also, thank you for so much rodeo, thank you, Manuel. Don’t laugh because it’s not just the ridiculous leftists; there are others who share a program with the Nazi Biondini, who self-identifies as a Nazi and wants to persecute people on social media. The worst of all is that there are other spaces that propose the same thing and would not assimilate them that way or people who want to go for Universal Basic Income, which is something very, very socialist; or people who want to put controls on the interest rate and subsidize it, while saying that the size of the State should not be touched, in a State that has quadrupled. Let’s talk about other things better.

What is interesting? What happened with the growth rate in that period. In the period between the year zero and 1800, the world economy grew the per capita GDP at a rate of 0.02%. That is to say, to double the per capita GDP it took 3,500 years. Between the year 1800 and 1900, it jumped to 0.65%. That is to say that we went from needing 3500 years to needing 107 years to double the per capita GDP. If we take the first half of the 20th century, the growth rate jumped to 1.1% and it took 66 years to double the per capita GDP, and if you take the second half of the 20th century, the rate is 2.1%, which means it took 33 years. If you take the latest numbers, we are at 20-something years. So, what do you see? The growth rate is also accelerating. That is to say: the hockey stick is becoming steeper and steeper. The consequence, the counterpart of this is that, while in the year 1800 there were about 1 billion human beings living (a number that was reached exactly in the year 1810, the day of the May Revolution, which had a few anarchists inside, so there’s a reason we love the May celebration so much), 95% of the population lived in extreme poverty. That is to say, with less than 1 dollar a day.

If you looked at the data in 2020, before the disaster of the pandemic, that number had fallen to 5%. Moreover, that number is constantly being adjusted to modify the figure because it has become almost irrelevant, that is to say, that free enterprise capitalism - despite all the attacks made by all the States in the world - has managed to lift 90% of the population out of extreme poverty.

Now, faced with such evidence, for those who are familiar with the microfoundations - what you will see is that this behavior of production, and if you take it in terms of the increasing population, that means that there are what are called: “increasing returns.” That is to say, for each unit of labor that increases, production rises more than proportionally and there is a problem that economic theory does not get along well with the issue of increasing returns. And that is something that is very important to understand the logic of how we think about the problems of economic growth.

I am not going to bother you with the entire history of economic growth theory, I will work with very basic models that you can access and know. But if one thinks about the modern theory of economic growth, in the neoclassical approach, the first article in that family is that of Solow and, in parallel, that of Trevor Swan, which is known as the Solow-Swan Model, and that in 1957, Robert Solow went and tested it. Basically, the problem is that this model explained only 15%. That is to say, a model that only explained the evolution of per capita GDP with the accumulation of per capita capital stock explained only 15%. So, to put it another way, empirically it was quite poor. Obviously, various ways were attempted to fix this problem but one of the most interesting criticisms that appeared was the criticism from the director of the Department of Economics at Chicago at that time, who was George Stigler, who told him: “your problem is that you did not incorporate human capital.” In that sense, two lines of human capital were born inside the University of Chicago: one is the microeconomics line, which was developed by Gary Becker. And the other, very important for all of us, is the line - in terms of economic growth - that was developed by Hirofumi Uzawa, and who was the tutor of, without a doubt, one of the greatest economists in the history of Argentina, who was Miguel Sidrauski.

However, when the profession decided to take a path, it chose not to go that way and decided to adopt the idea of placing technological progress in an exogenous manner. Thus, all growth within the model was explained by hand, which means that it is not a model. This obscurantist relationship found light back in 1983 when Paul Romer, in his doctoral thesis, developed the first endogenous growth model based on human capital, whose thesis advisor was Robert Lucas, who was basically following the works of Uzawa; and thus the theory of endogenous growth emerged, where the hypothesis with human capital gained greater relevance. A very strong debate began during the late 80s and throughout the 90s until the year 2000. And in all that debate, Gregory Mankiw, David Romer, not Paul Romer, David Romer, and David Weil proceeded to empirically test that model. That model shows that when they incorporate human capital, the model explains 85% instead of 15%, meaning that 70 percentage points of the explanation for economic growth is human capital. Therefore, one of the very relevant things within our policy is human capital. So much so that I am not saying this now because the time to grow has arrived; it is such that today we are admired around the world, and Sandra Pettovello, from the Ministry of Human Capital, is traveling the world explaining the Argentine case; we already saw it the day we arrived.

In fact, in Human Capital, we made a very interesting partition, which is that the Ministry was divided into four units, if you will. One is Childhood and Family, basically to catch them when they arrive because if the child does not develop their intellectual capacity when they are young, it becomes very difficult to work later. So, we increased the Universal Child Allowance; we increased the Food Card. Moreover, in the first phase, we were able to double it without spending an extra peso, and that was when they came at us and staged the first march, and that is when Dr. Bullrich implemented the Anti-Blockade Protocol that was not approved in her previous administration, and from that point on, we took back the streets from the criminals, and Argentina is a country without blockades.

The other area is health because you can feed them, but if people get sick, they cannot study either. So, we must ensure first-generation human capital. Obviously, the other part relates to education and retraining. Education is for those entering the educational system, and retraining is for those who have been left out of the system and have the will to return. And that area is linked to work, and that is where all the labor flexibility issues come in; there is a part in decree 70/23; we continue to advance in making reforms in the labor market to provide more flexibility and achieve that 40% in the informal sector moves to the formal sector, and once the labor market has the appropriate format, only then can we start to think about the solution to the pension problem. The rest is demagoguery.

On the other hand, we also launched a new Literacy Plan. But the issue of human capital, we have been addressing it from day one. Another issue that is extremely important to us is economic freedom. And what do you see? That those countries that are freer grow at a speed that is double that of repressed countries; not only that, those countries that are freer have a per capita GDP 12 times greater than that of repressed countries; and they have 25 times fewer poor people in the standard format and 50 times fewer in the extreme format. Therefore, all reforms that make the economy free will mean that as we advance in economic freedom, we will have a higher per capita GDP. And basically, I had pointed out the issue of reforms: the DNU 70/23 which includes 300 reforms; the Bases Law, 500. There you already had 800, and with that, you were already 8 times larger than what Menem had done. But, in addition, we included 900 more in the second half of the year, meaning we ended the year with 1,700 reforms.

It is important because, recently, the people from the Heritage Foundation, who calculate the index of economic freedom, came to congratulate us because no country had ever made such a significant leap in terms of economic freedom. And what was most interesting about all this? That it only considered the first half of 2024. That is to say, the reforms implied by the Bases Law and the 900 deregulations made by Dr. Sturzenegger are not yet included. Therefore, we will not yield; we will not stop until Argentina is the freest country in the world. I will tell you a very interesting anecdote, which shows the reformist spirit of this Government and how wonderful it is to work with the team I have, because they work together, it is truly a pleasure. But there is something very interesting; in the first half of January, I told them to take vacations and return for the second half of January, when we would go back to work. As you know, I like to work from Olivos because it saves me from traveling, and I get up at six in the morning, seven, coffee in hand, and I work until ten, twelve at night, so… Yes, I walk around in a jumpsuit because if I have a moment, I will go see my four-legged children Conan, Murray, Milton, Robert, and Lucas Junior, but aside from that, Federico Sturzenegger writes to me, and he says, “No, no, I have to talk because I am very worried.”

Well, then Federico comes to Olivos, and he says to me, “I am having a problem; the reforms are coming out very slowly. The reforms are coming out very slowly; I feel bad; this has to go faster.” Imagine that I read all of Federico's tweets every morning, and it is aaaah, it is like that all the time. So, I felt bad because I thought: in the end, I am a fool; I am getting happy with little. So he suggests making some modifications to the legal structure so that the reforms could advance more quickly, to give more to that brilliant, extraordinary woman who is María Irrazábal, who is the legal brain behind all the reforms, and he says: “No, give her more resources,” because she also has political clout when it comes to making laws, so she is a person of great talent; María is to our government what Liendo was to Cavallo, so you can visualize it. So, I start to look at everything… now, I grab and ask for a recount of what we were doing. Does anyone dare to think how many reforms Federico had implemented in just half a month? Because we were doing poorly, according to Federico, 65, that is, the equivalent of 130 monthly reforms. We are talking about 1,560 annually. That is what I want you to see. This is the most reformist government in history, and we will not stop until we are the freest country in the world. But the issue does not end there; there is another topic, now comes the part, if you will, rougher or harder in terms of economic theory, which is… I have already talked about the role of human capital; I talked about the role of economic freedom… Obviously, within economic freedom, there is a chapter that has to do with openness. That is to say, there you have three pillars.

By the way, from a huge job that Manuel Adorni did, the tamer of Abasto, because let’s say the City Canal, the one that should be closed, is in Abasto; I was a neighbor there… One of the things we did, we had a very ambitious Government program, and everyone said it was impossible. And one of the things that started to happen when we looked at social media, people said: “This is more than what I voted for.” So, we said: “Well, let’s test how we are doing.” And the reality is that Manuel started to gather information on what we had promised and what we were doing. Everyone said that what we were going to do was impossible, so if we had not fulfilled anything, we would be in line with any politician, but if we did it – linearly – we should have fulfilled at least 25% of the campaign promises. Well, we ended the year fulfilling 97% of the campaign promises, and since we have already lifted the currency controls and there is competition among currencies, we have done everything we promised. So, it is the first time in history that in less than a year and a half, you have a Government that is absolutely demanding with the goals that everyone said were impossible, and we have already fulfilled them all. That is to say, we are dedicated to making possible what everyone says is impossible.

And now I will go to the core of growth, which is the less traditional part and with which we are traveling around the world explaining to everyone the core of Argentine growth. Basically, there are some indications of this in my recent book called “Capitalism, Socialism, and the Neoclassical Trap.” And it is the issue of the role of increasing returns, but to understand the problem of increasing returns, one must understand the nature of neoclassical economics. Now, if I look at the increasing returns that, for those who know about general equilibrium, the literature calls “non-convexities,” concentrated market structures, up to monopolies. In that context - according to neoclassical theory - unconcentrated structures or monopolies are bad, and someone can explain to me why if - in the last 250 years - we went from extreme poverty of 95% to 5% in a world that multiplied its population by almost 10 times. Can someone explain to me why that is bad? Today, an average citizen of a reasonable country lives better than any emperor did.

Can someone explain to me why that is bad? Why are economists so arrogant that - when the model does not map with reality - we call it a market failure? No, it is not a market failure; it is a problem with the model that is garbage. So, now where do we get that some of these things are bad, and there, as could not be otherwise, it comes from someone who was a bit leftist, named Wilfredo Pareto, so… that is to say, when in the equilibrium problem, we originally studied whether it exists, whether it is unique, and whether it is stable… up to that point, things were not so skewed. The problem is when we wanted to introduce the Pareto Optimality, the Pareto efficiency. We had to choose between “the pin factory,” that is, increasing returns, or the invisible hand, and then we opted for a mathematical view of the invisible hand that involved throwing increasing returns out the window, and it turns out that the economy that supposedly was born with Adam Smith, I mean, there are some reflections from Xenophon that are worth renting balconies, but, I mean, that is…, and they are from 350 years before Christ, but it does not matter, what I mean is that we threw “the pin factory” out the window, we threw increasing returns out the window, and we cannot explain economic growth, and supposedly Adam Smith's book, what is it called? An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, and what it tries to explain is economic growth. That is to say, due to a matter of misinterpreted mathematical priceism, we are left without explaining economic growth. Because if you have constant returns to scale, you cannot explain economic growth. And that is because of the damn Pareto Optimality. So, it is important that we understand well what the Pareto Optimality is. The Pareto Optimality is a situation where it is not possible to generate any type of improvement without harming another individual. That is to say, when is there a Pareto improvement? A Pareto improvement is when you can improve someone without screwing anyone's life. So, you do it, and that is a Pareto improvement, and when those possibilities for welfare gain are exhausted, you are already at the Pareto Optimality. That is to say, those possibilities are exhausted.

But there is another more complicated part; it is as if you were inside the production possibility frontier, and then, how do we get to the frontier? But there is also another discussion that is along the frontier, and that any allocation at any point on the frontier, that point is Pareto optimal; hence the two theories more of welfare economics. The first says: “that every competitive equilibrium is Pareto optimal,” there is a whole discussion about how we define free competition; you can imagine that as an adherent to the Austrian School of Economics, that term does not sit well with me, but I do not care because we are discussing different things, not so much, but well. But the second theorem is worse. The second theorem is aberrant and says: “that it is independent of the distribution of income,” that is to say, you can achieve Pareto optimality regardless of the distribution of income; that sounds very nice, but it is a tremendous mistake. If you have to define an economy, when you study general equilibrium, you study Brett. So, how does Brett define an economy? Then he defines an economy of private property; what does it have? He says: E={U, that is, the utility function, the preference; T, to reflect technology, has Ω, to represent initial endowments, and Pi=1; that is, the benefits remain entirely in the private sector.

According to this, it is independent of the distribution, and then by the theorem of the second welfare theorem, I can throw Pi out the window, it doesn't matter to me. And I am left only with preferences, technologies, and endowments. Do you realize the nonsense I am saying? Does no one realize, does no one stand up and say: “damn it, you leftist piece of trash”? I mean, are you going to tell me that living under capitalism is the same as living in real socialism? Let me tell you that - in 1989 - the Wall fell and it was a failure economically, socially, culturally; they killed 150 million people. It is not the same. It is wrong. It is false. Why? Because socialism is impossible. The second welfare theorem is nonsense, it is wrong. Basically, why is socialism impossible? Well, for a simple reason: without private property, there is no economic calculation. You exchange goods and, at the moment you exchanged the goods, let’s suppose there is money, then we can discuss what money is, what does that do? It marks a price. I give you my glasses in exchange for X amount of money. So, you take that, it becomes a mechanism for transmitting information, it coordinates: some will be buyers; others will be sellers, and it generates an adjustment, because if supply and demand do not match, the price will vary. If you do not have private property, you do not mark the price; if you do not mark the price, the system is adrift. That is why, in socialism, it would be the same to build a road or a bridge of gold, crystal, or cement, since there is no price, someone else pays anyway.

That is why part of what the communist spies did was send people to see what the prices were. The other is impossible because knowledge is dispersed, this is what Hayek said about the use of information in society. Knowledge is dispersed and the only mechanism that humanity invented, which must be one of the most wonderful inventions that humanity has had and that no one invented because it was created by spontaneous order, was the price system, where each one with their willingness to buy or sell transmits information. And for that, it does not need to be anything decentralized; it does not need a centralized organism to do that. In fact, no one can do that. And there also appears the argument made by Israel Kirzner and Jesús Huerta de Soto, about the impossibility of socialism and the role of information that must be created and discovered in this whole process.

If I have a company A, which produces a certain good and has waste; well, it wants to get rid of the waste, it will have to pay to get rid of the waste. But it happens that there is a company B, which produces another product, that needs - as an input - the waste from the other. So a guy can appear in the middle who says: “wait, wait, I can pay this one to take the input and sell it to the other and in the middle I make money,” that is, he discovered a business opportunity and was applying it. Consequently, there I have a gain in welfare, but that can only happen if there are prices; if there are no prices and if I want to engage in that activity, they will steal the results from me, it will not happen. So the coercion that the State generates makes that impossible. That is why socialism always generates misery, because it does not have the coordinating role of the price system and, moreover, it breaks any intention to do something; aside from the fact that there is an incentive problem that if the one who works well gets the same as the one who does nothing, then why would they work?

So, you have static problems and dynamic problems. That is, the first is how do you collect all that information. Let’s suppose you invent the mega-computer, that it could do it, even then you will not be able to do it. Do you know why? Because much of the information you need to act is tacit, it has to do with know-how. The other day, in a talk, I made a joke with my friend Mike Boggiano, I said: “Well, I call Michael Jordan, I tell him to tell me how he makes the ball go through the hoop.” Nothing, no matter how well Michael Jordan could make it go in, which I doubt he could do, but if he did, Mike cannot do it, he does not measure 1.98, imagine if we ask Shaquille O’Neal, who measures 2.30, even less. So, that makes it impossible. But one more thing, the market is a process of discovery and as it is a process of discovery, the information you need to act is information that is created at the very moment you are acting; however, that information can never arrive in time and form to the control body that needs that information to solve the allocation problem. Therefore, it will never arrive in time and form. When the information arrives and decisions are made, they are always wrong; it could only work by chance.

Not only that, but also how did people survive under real socialism? By making transactions in the illegal market, in parallel markets. That is, the only way socialism had for people not to starve was to allow people to evade controls, that is, it is an oxymoron. That is, for them to function, they had to stop doing controls, that is, they are contradictions in their terms and they do not realize it. Notice that the first year, I mean, when you start the year, they have to put a year, for example, “this year is the Year of Reconstruction.” But last year, what did we call it? “The year of Life, Liberty, and Property,” that is, we were precisely thinking about this so that the economy would start to grow. Hence, I have repeated - to the point of exhaustion - the definition of liberalism by Alberto Benegas Lynch (h): “Liberalism is the unrestricted respect for the life project of others, based on the principle of non-aggression and in defense of the right to life, liberty, and property.” Notice that this shows something about how the system should function and that when we get to the auction…, I am close, believe me I am not that far, you will see that it will make total sense. And in that regard, when we start to compare the damn Pareto Optimal against what happens in reality and when reality gives something else we call it: “market failure”; and there are four market failures: which are basically non-convexities, that is, monopolies; externalities; public goods and information failures that, on the one hand, we have all the work of Contract Theory, with problems of adverse selection, moral hazard, and signaling or coordination failures. That is, it is basically a problem of game theory. Did anyone realize what the prisoner’s dilemma is? Why does the prisoner’s dilemma work? Who blocks the information? The captors. That is, coordination failures, in the economy, are the result of the existence of the State blocking communication between agents. The State is always the problem, never the solution. That is why we have reduced the size of the State by 30% by making the adjustment we made, which mainly fell on the public sector. And that is what made the adjustment expansive.

But I am not going to get into each of the discussions about the so-called market failures. I will stick to the issue of non-convexities and the issue of technical progress. The first thing that will happen with the damn Pareto Optimal is that they cannot explain economic growth, they cannot explain technological progress. Let’s go and put ourselves in this situation: we stand at the end of the 19th century, and there was a group of happy people producing candles. Then a gentleman - named Thomas Alva Edison - came and invented the light bulb. How do you imagine the candle producers felt? Almost as hurt as the baboons. But they had something worse: I don’t know if they had Adermicina. That said, the first thing you have to understand is that this is not Pareto Optimal. I mean, technological progress is not Pareto Optimal, because one won and others lost. So, the question is: “hey, would you like to go back to the candle era for the fucking Pareto Optimal?” Aren’t we better off now with light, with air conditioning, all this, computers, phones, and everything we have today?

I think you are not hating the Pareto Optimal enough. I’m not saying it’s as bad as journalists, but the Pareto Optimal is bad. In that sense, there is a wonderful book called Economics in One Lesson, by Henry Hazlitt, the latest reprint of the book has my preface, where I tell what happened to me when I met the book, and it has a chapter called: ‘The Hatred of the Machine’, which basically mocks the Luddite fallacy, and which is basically a problem of equilibrium…, let’s say, Henry Hazlitt separates the first lesson, the lesson is… what is the difference between the good economist and the bad economist? The bad economist is the one who only looks at partial equilibrium, who only looks at one market and does not look at the consequences this has on other markets and the impacts in the future. I mean, he is a fool who makes a partial equilibrium model of a single period. There are plenty of those, don’t laugh. And on the other hand, then, the good economist is the one who looks not only at this market but also looks at the relationship with everything else and does not just look at this period, but also considers the impact on the future. That is, a guy who does intertemporal general equilibrium. So, the reality is: “No, well, but the machine is going to leave people unemployed.” That person who creates this technological progress, why does he do it? To make money.

Now, what does he do with the money he makes? Look, if he takes it and spends it, he will generate jobs where he is spending it. The alternative is that…, well, no, now he is not going to spend because he is a son of a bitch and he is going to save it. Imagine if he saves it, that finances investment elsewhere, which will generate growth and jobs elsewhere, in addition to more productivity. But let’s suppose he doesn’t, so if he consumes he does well; if he saves he does well; then he has to be more of a son of a bitch; he has to take that money and put it in the ground, he has to hide it in the earth. Well, they are taking money out of the economy, therefore, the price level goes down and it benefits everyone. That is, when you think in terms of general equilibrium, all these nonsense fall apart. But there is one, who the other day said: no, the minimum wage has to be 2 million pesos; idiot, why not make it from a green million? If it were that easy.

But the economy, then, tried to see how the hell to fix this problem. So, the first thing it did, well, let’s put a patch on the Solow model, then the first patch appeared, put by Edmund Phelps, called: “The Golden Rule.” So, he tried to find a maximization of consumption, it was a patch, like a patch, a patch does not fix the problem. Then they said: “no, well, the problem is that this model is not optimal,” that is, it was the problem of dynamic efficiency, let’s fix the problem of dynamic efficiency. When we want to fix the problem of dynamic efficiency, two authors, one Cass and the other Koopmans, separately; one in continuous, the other in discrete, start to review and find that - in 1928 - there was a kid named Frank Plumpton Ramsey, who had an excellent relationship with John Maynard Keynes, but not in the academic sense, extra-academic, I don’t know why you are laughing, bunch of machirulos. So, in that context, what happens? He had a model of optimal savings, so they rescue that model and it is what today - in the literature - is known as the Ramsey Model, it is not exactly because Ramsey had a problem of how to set the discount, he considered it immoral, there was a whole discussion there, but well, here it does not matter a damn, they needed to constrain the set, they put a rate of intertemporal preference discount greater than the population and constrained the utility function and they were able to solve the exercise.

Beyond that, of mathematical issues, what is the problem with this model? Well, yes, now it is optimal, everything, and what is the result? When it goes to the steady state, it collapses, the same result. Because what ends up dominating is the budget constraint, and the budget constraint is the production function. So, if you work with this neoclassical production function, which has constant returns to scale or diminishing marginal returns, you will have Pareto Optimal, it will allow you to achieve a maximum. But what is the problem? They cannot grow. Very nice for the Pareto optimality of the general equilibrium model, but we cannot explain economic growth. What do we do? Well, what we did was explore a work, which was what converted me to the Austrian School of Economics, called: "Monopoly and Competition," by Murray Newton Rothbard. And where basically what it says is: "Let’s see, monopolies are not bad, unless they are monopolies according to the original definition of Lord Coke, who said that a monopoly is when the monarch made sure that - within that place - only one type was sold, and if he did not do it, he executed anyone who wanted to compete.”

Fortunately, customs have changed over time and today, you could have a company, I mean, I don’t know, the mobile phone market, ten different companies, and one appears and makes a phone at a better price, with better quality, what do you think will happen to the other nine? They will go bankrupt. And you would say that this guy is a bad guy, he is bad because it’s a monopoly… why don’t you get angry with the nine that went bankrupt? Not with this one. This guy is a hero, he is a social benefactor. Because now you can have a phone of better quality or better price and on top of that, that money you save, you can spend on other goods. You live much better. Therefore, no jobs are lost, nothing is lost, and everyone lives better and has greater productivity. Therefore, monopolies are not bad. It is a problem in the minds of neoclassicals. Now, what is the problem? If I think in neoclassical terms, what will happen is that I will do what, when I see a monopoly: I will regulate it. And when you regulate it, you will regulate it so that, surely, based on capital or if you want to impose a price cap, let’s say, it always ends up collapsing because you have to map it with the capital base, which means you end up regulating based on capital. What does this mean? That it is a rule of average cost, and if you have a flat bottom in the average cost or it coincides with the marginal cost, consequently, that gives you a result that is, according to the literature, Pareto Optimal. And if you think in terms of contestable markets, and the average cost curve has a flat bottom, it doesn’t matter, it will also yield a Pareto Optimal, and if not, it will give you a second-best solution, which by the way, then, when you do that and regulate, what are you doing? You are making the competitive equilibrium assimilable and, therefore, you are assimilating it to a situation of constant returns to scale, and the day you assimilate it with constant returns to scale, you kill economic growth.

Do you want an example of this? The most regulated area in the world, Europe, is stagnant, it is not growing. Therefore, a central axis of our policy is deregulation, because - to the extent that we deregulate - we free up increasing returns. When we free up increasing returns, we start to grow, and that is the task that Federico Sturzenegger is carrying out and that is being admired by everyone; which is why Kristalina Georgieva incorporated him as an advisor to the International Monetary Fund to advance in all these matters, and it is a policy that is inspiring everyone. So, thanks to Toto and thanks to Federico, when my term ends I will be able to live peacefully, giving lectures.

And now yes, the last theoretical pill, and it is this issue of dynamic efficiency. I emphatically recommend reading either the original article or the book by Huerta de Soto. But there is a phrase that seems phenomenal to me, because dynamic efficiency is defined as that institutional arrangement that makes the production possibilities frontier expand as strongly as possible, that is, it shifts to the right, as God commands. But also, remember that I am a paleolibertarian, I am an anarcho-capitalist, who believes in God, that is, an anarchist, as God commands. But there is a phrase that seems fabulous to me, which is something incredible - I mean, it’s incredible - because if you understand this definition you may not know a thing about economics and make the economy go on the dynamically optimal path. And it says: “justice and efficiency are two sides of the same coin; what is just cannot be inefficient and what is efficient must always be just.” Notice that - at some point - I talked about how the policy in our government is guided by ethical and moral criteria. The general framework of that ethics and morality that this government carries out is the definition of liberalism given by Alberto Benegas Lynch (h). Therefore, I can put the economy on the dynamically optimal path, without knowing anything about economics, just by doing what is just, because what is just is efficient. That is, the only system that meets these characteristics is the system of free market capitalism.

There is a beautiful book called “Creativity, Capitalism, and Distributive Justice,” by an author named Israel Kirzner - with a z, not with a ch, please -. And one of the things that Israel Kirzner raises is something truly dazzling, for he says: “the capitalist system is labeled as unjust”; and he says “you know what? If the system is unjust, it is not worth defending. I don’t care if it is more productive, I don’t care if it is more efficient; if it is unjust, it cannot be defended. It is a giant with feet of clay and - therefore - does not deserve to be defended.” If I am defending these ideas with such fervor it is because the book progresses and using Locke’s principle of appropriation and Hayek’s idea of the market as a discovery process, plus everything I talked about before regarding entrepreneurship, all that conjunction demonstrates that the only system that is just is free enterprise capitalism. I emphasize: free enterprise capitalism, not crony capitalism and buddies of power.

Therefore, we return to Rothbard’s phrase: “the crisis is a problem of an ethical nature,” if we bring 100 years of moral decay it is obvious that this country was going to fall apart and the only thing that could get us out of all this is a revolution, which is not only economic, but is - essentially and above all - a moral revolution and that is why we are rising because we have lifted the values of the West again and that is why we are growing and we are going to become a world power, in 30 years.

And now yes, there is only this left, because it all seems very interesting, but…, come on, I need meat, I mean the skeleton is fine, but… Good. Why are we going to grow a lot? The last data showed 5.7% year-on-year, the seasonally adjusted 0.8%, that annualized says that we are traveling at a speed of 10%. The first quarter will be around 6%; the second at 8%; José Luis Daza himself says: “Argentina will be the country that grows the most in the region in the next 30 years.” Toto Caputo himself says, “we are going to stop talking about Chinese rates and we are going to talk about Argentine rates.” In fact, in the World Economic Outlook of the Fund, we are already second in the ranking. India comes first, then us. So, based on what do we say we are going to grow? Point one: fiscal adjustment. The fiscal adjustment of 15 points of GDP was 15 points of GDP of savings that the public sector was consuming and now it has been returned as income to Argentines, who can consume it or invest it. That, whether you like it or not, will generate greater expansion. When you save more, more is invested and more grows. The second point, which is not minor, is the issue of zero deficit.

The zero deficit means that you do not take on new debt… Rolling over debt is not taking on new debt, please, because if some Kirchnerist appears with an IQ below that of a primate “no, you are taking on debt.” So it’s like, sometimes, the discussion with those people is complicated.

Well, yesterday you had to deal with “Santongo”; Well, but he feels ashamed to be a Kirchnerist, how well you hit him there, “Manu.” Now, the flip side of this is that - then - if the economy does not grow or grows little, the debt-to-GDP ratio is then decreasing, if the debt-to-GDP ratio is non-increasing or saying that it remains constant or falls means that Argentina is solvent intertemporally; if Argentina is solvent intertemporally, inexorably, sooner or later the Country Risk must collapse, Argentina is one of the five countries in the world that have financial equilibrium, therefore, sooner or later, Argentina will be investment grade.

I make a clarification, because I see so many shortcomings in the topic of international monetary economics, of people who worry about the accumulation of reserves when there is a flexible exchange rate. I don’t know, the books I read didn’t bite. Besides, we recapitalized the Central Bank; we are going to go out to the markets, because the country risk is already below 700; we also have a put that the American government gave us. Can you really look for ghosts? Aside from that, I warn you that the fall of the Country Risk will lower the interest rate; when the interest rate falls, be careful that the countries that lower the interest rate, do you know what happens to the external accounts? Since internal equilibrium implies a higher interest rate, it generates a current account deficit. But since that current account deficit is generated by the private sector, it is a problem of the private sector and is resolved in the exchange market. Don’t be swayed by the “no, I saw it, the current account deficit…”. The problem of the current account deficit is if it is generated by the fiscal deficit; if it is a private problem, it is a problem between privates. Please, start to get rid of the chips of those idiots who sank this country. Or the others: “People are going on trips.” I mean, what do you want us to be a bunch of miserable people, who can’t even move from the house? What do we do in summer, put a basin of water to cool off? Yes, man, we are going to be rich and as part of that we are going to travel all over the world, yes. What’s the problem if I take it out of my pocket? Many laundered money and that money they laundered, which comes in as capital income, yes, they went and spent it, in another country on vacation. What’s the problem?

Please: try to identify the apes, well, no, the Planet of the Apes is smarter than these beasts. But beyond that, there is a wonderful work by Juan Pablo Nicolini that says: “the zero deficit guarantees me a per capita growth floor of 4%.” I can assure you that I am strongly committed to maintaining fiscal balance, in fact, in the face of the deterioration of external conditions, we only need 1.3% of primary surplus and I decided that we pass it to 1.6%; and to have a magnitude order, from what we are doing because there will be no shortage of the idiot who says: “no, but last year it was 1.7%.” First, if GDP expands and the interests are the same, it’s less money, but then in terms of GDP it’s less, but beyond that there is a data that they are not considering is that we removed 16 taxes; one of the taxes we removed was the Country Tax which is 1.5% of GDP, so we are going to an equivalent of last year of 3.1%; do you realize what happens, what happens is what we said, that to the extent that the economy grows we are going to lower taxes. The economy is growing, what do we do? We lower taxes, we are the first Government in history that lowered taxes.

But as Professor Juan Pablo Nicolini says, that work they did only contemplates fiscal balance. But that fiscal balance you could have achieved by raising taxes. We did it by cutting spending, therefore we have more to grow. And it also does not contemplate structural reforms. Therefore - I repeat it, and I will say it in Latin - the Argentine economy is going to rise like a diver’s fart. Not only that, but we are also going to end inflation, therefore the distortion of relative prices that killed economic growth will also disappear. In addition, we are planning to make a tax reform that generates competition among the different provinces, that is, that people start to vote with their feet. Look at how in the United States - for example - one was in California, went to Texas. Galperín did it too. So, basically we are going to generate fiscal competition. For example, we are going to collect our VAT - the national VAT -, the provincial one that the provinces sort themselves out, and let them compete. Do you want, let’s say, more investments? They will have to charge less taxes. Enough of the lack of fiscal correspondence. I mean, there will be fiscal correspondence now. Do you want to spend more? Charge taxes. And put the local and show it to your people. And that those taxes have a counterpart in spending. Because if not - probably - you end up in the bonfire. With luck.

So, and to all this we add what we are doing, in Human Capital, deregulation… until we become the freest country in the world. And also, an increase in economic openness. Consequently, dear ones: welcome to the New Argentina, because we are making Argentina great again. May God bless you, may the forces of heaven accompany us, and long live freedom, damn it!