Speech by President Javier Milei at the 42nd Annual Congress of the Argentine Institute of Finance Executives (IAEF)

Argentina Javier Milei · President of Argentina

14 May 2025 · 42nd Annual Congress of the Argentine Institute of Finance Executives (IAEF)

Context
Milei addressed the 42nd Annual Congress of the Argentine Institute of Finance Executives (IAEF) on May 14, 2025, presenting his government's economic achievements and outlining dollarization policy.
Main themes
Endogenous dollarization, inflation stabilization, structural reforms, fiscal adjustment, Argentine economic history, crawling peg exchange rate policy, Central Bank balance sheet, comparison with Menem government, property rights, government performance
Duration
~88 min
98th percentile
Words
10,508
98th percentile
Sentences
669
99th percentile
Readability
67
96th percentile
Grade
7.7
3rd percentile
Syntax
2.79
21st percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 87%85%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Institutional 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

669 sentences in 53 paragraphs

There I was listening to the talk being given by the best Minister of Economy in Argentine history.

What I want to say is: we are indeed making the best government in history. Because there is a work of… sorry, I’m a bit agitated, but this jumping around, going here and there, let’s say I’m not in the best state, because you can imagine I have a somewhat demanding job - there is a work by Gerardo Della Paolera, Bozzolli, and Irigoin, called “Passing the buck” and with the macroeconomic pressure index developed by Robert Barro, it basically compares all the governments in Argentine history and shows that the best government in history was Menem's first government. Until we arrived. Basically, if one had to describe Menem's first government, it is the achievement of convertibility to lower inflation and the structural reforms.

Basically, when we arrived, we had the characterization of the three worst crises in Argentine history. We had a money overhang that was double that of the period before the Rodrigazo. We had an imbalance in the Central Bank's balance sheet in terms of interest-bearing liabilities against the base that was worse than what we had before Alfonsín's hyperinflation. And we had social indicators worse than those in 2001. I mean, truly, not only Toto, but also the whole team, we were all in an electric chair. And the imbalances were even greater. But to make the most direct comparison with Menem's first government, first: we, the wholesale inflation... inflation was running at more than 1% daily when we came to power. The wholesale rate had reached 54%. Annualized, that gives 17,000. And last year, the wholesale rate ended below one, and if you clean it from the crawling peg, in dollars we were in deflation. That’s because I said we lowered inflation much faster than convertibility. And some ill-intentioned fool made a comparison of the CPI inflation of convertibility with what our government has been running, and among other things forgot to subtract the crawling peg. At least, to be critical, one shouldn’t be foolish, right? I mean, not to be so exposed. I’m tempted to say the name, but well, it doesn’t matter, I’ll try to contain myself.

Now, the most interesting thing is that we always work and talk about the wholesale rate because it is one that leads. That’s why we focus so much on the wholesale rate. But even so, the program is better basically for several reasons. First, because we did not receive the economy or the country after hyperinflation. When you have hyperinflation, the characteristic of it is that you end up liquefying all assets and, therefore, stabilization is very easy, because the demand for money easily recomposes, and that facilitates the inflation rate to drop much faster. The second point, not minor — and this is why I always also praise not only Toto's work, but I also strongly praise what Santi Bausili does at the Central Bank, here is Vladimir too, and he does it in conjunction with Pablo Quirno, is: we also managed to stabilize without expropriating. That is, we did not apply a Bonex plan. That would have been the easy way. We cleaned the Central Bank's balance sheet without having expropriated, respecting property rights. We did not screw anyone over.

Not only that, we also did not fix the exchange rate. We did it with a crawling peg. Not only that, but we also did it by recomposing tariffs, because in other programs one of the things they did was to put all the adjustment upfront and then come and show the post of that adjustment with the adjustment of tariffs. That is to say that this program has a set of characteristics never seen before, and yet inflation has dropped faster. Because if you correct for the exchange rate, for the crawl, we are clearly much lower. That, on one hand. On the other hand, what Menem's program had were structural reforms. We, basically, with DNU 70/23 and the Bases Law, made a structural reform eight times larger than Menem's. And when we add the reforms that Federico has carried out — another giant that I have the privilege of having in the cabinet — the number of structural reforms means that we have done 17 times more than the reforms that were made in Menem's government. Moreover, the other day, when we reached 500 days, we reached 2000 structural reforms. And not only that. When we campaigned, we had a program that was profoundly successful, which everyone said was impossible to achieve, and after a year and a half we fulfilled all the campaign promises. Therefore, there is no doubt that we are the best government in history, and that is thanks to the giants I have as ministers.

Having said all this, the central axis of today’s talk… in fact, I previewed it in a conference I gave a few days ago - I had been giving conferences on growth, but the situation led us back to the discussion of endogenous dollarization. And basically what I’m going to do today, I’m going to talk about endogenous dollarization and the talk basically has three parts: it has a part that seems quite evident, that everyone understands and believes they know, and I realize that economists have some truly gross deficits in monetary training that make us not understand many things about how the monetary market works. Therefore, I will work on what is the origin of money and what is strictly the demand for money, because it is key to understand well what the demand for money is.

Once we have closed the concept of demand for money, we will move on to discuss the endogenous money models. And once we see the passive money models as Julio Hipólito Guillermo Olivera would call them, in fact, the work is called “On Passive Money,” and there is the Spanish version called “El dinero pasivo.” And once we reach what he calls the external standard, that is, when you fix the exchange rate, that allows us to see some other issues that make one able to discuss the topic of endogenous dollarization, and that is where we will address this topic.

The first thing we should understand is the nature of money; that is, what an economy without money looks like. The economy without money is what we study - in fact, those who have taken good microeconomics courses, the part when they reach general equilibrium - is what is called the economy of pure exchange, or also barter economy. Now, the problem with that barter economy is that it is very interesting to analyze it in theoretical terms and has a lot of very positive elements to understand some problems; but the central problem is: what is real life like? Because translating it into real life has an operational problem, a functioning problem.

The first problem you will encounter is the problem of double coincidence: that is, the good you have to offer, not only do you have to find the one who sells what you want, but also the one who is going to sell what you want has to want what you have. And that is a huge problem, because the problem of double coincidence is a problem that would cause many transactions to fall through. Moreover, don’t be alarmed, I haven’t changed, but I’m going to quote Joan Robinson, which believe me I haven’t changed, but it’s worth it. When Joan Robinson said: all analyses of the neutrality of money are all wrong. And she is right in what she says, it is a stupidity all the analysis of the neutrality of money that is done. Because the reality is that if money did not exist, a lot of transactions would fall through. So one must be quite careful with all that is literature and when talking about the neutrality of money and all that kind of stuff. You see? If you read the Austrians, that kind of thing won’t happen to you for sure. Now, beyond the issue of double coincidence, there are other problems, which is the problem of indivisibility of goods. That is, I may want to eat bread and the baker may want to listen to me give a lecture; now the problem is how many kilos of bread am I going to take for giving a lecture. The truth is that my expectation, if we continue like this, is that I can… a number of kilos that I won’t be able to eat in a long time. What do you want me to say? With the ministers I have, what do you want, that I’m not bullish?

So, faced with that situation, what happens is: look, human beings did not sit idly by crying, saying “The State is present...” Human beings: a problem arises, if you don’t mess with them, they go and try to solve it. I mean, that’s what humans do. So, in that context, one of the things that humans discovered was that there were goods that were exchanged more than others, obviously linked to what? to food. Moreover, the first money that existed, the first currency that was used, or the first good that was used as money, in fact, was livestock, because man was nomadic and carried livestock with him. So, since he fed himself with that, the first currency that was used was livestock. That is to say, if you look, what you find is a good that works as money, but it is a good of indirect exchange. Moreover, this becomes more evident when man stops being nomadic and begins to settle in places. So, for example, it is obvious that these are things linked to food. Why was one of the currencies wheat? Because, basically, they made bread from it.

So, what happens? Since wheat was traded a lot, they did not buy wheat because they wanted to have wheat, they bought wheat because wheat served them to buy other goods. That is to say, I want to emphasize this idea of indirect exchange. Because if we understand indirect exchange, the only thing that should be clear to us is that we are not going to take the wooden suit with the bills. The bills only serve to facilitate the exchange. So, in that context, wheat appears, or for example the issue of salt. "Salary," in fact, comes from there. Moreover, why when salt falls do people say that it is bad luck? Because if you were paying and went with a sack of salt, and you were going to pay the other and you gave the sack of salt to the other, what was the problem?: that if the sack fell, or if the salt fell, what was the problem? It was an instant loss of capital. Clearly, it was bad luck. So, what was done? The sack of salt was taken and placed in a place where it was weighed and manipulation was avoided, so that the one who dropped it was the one who lost. Or, for example, another type of money that was used was tobacco, linen. There is a very funny reading by Milton Friedman that talks about the hyperinflation in Germany. And he says: well, they used nails. And at one point he says: and they also used cognac, which according to Milton Friedman was the definition of the most liquid money he had ever known in his life. He said: clearly, more liquid than... it was a liquid directly.

Or for those who are older… I warn you that I don’t watch series, so I don’t know the series, movies or prison series - but those who are over 50 like me, will have seen prison movies. And the money in prison was what? cigarettes. So, what I want to focus on is this: that money is actually an indirect exchange good, it is a good that serves to make other transactions. Later we can see what different types of goods will appear or not, but at first what I want to point out is that it is the mirror demand of what is happening in the goods market. I will put it in other terms: if you see in a macroeconomics book or you ask an economist “can you formulate the money demand function for me?” According to traditional macroeconomic manuals, what are you going to find? That it will depend on income and the interest rate, right?

Okay. Well, that is wrong, it is wrong: it should depend only on consumption. Now I will develop that idea. I left you speechless. So now we have the indirect exchange good, then I will explain why it is wrong. We already know that it is an indirect exchange good, that it is a mirror demand, what is called a derived demand, that is reflecting the counterpart of the goods market. Now, what is the problem? That those goods, although they fulfilled the function of unit of account, that is, you could set prices in salt, in wheat, in tobacco, in whatever; and it was also a generalized means of payment, had another problem: that it was not a store of value. Example: would you use ice cream as money? Why wouldn’t you use ice cream? Because it has a negative interest rate; no one thinks of saving in ice cream, it degrades. Well, I do it with an example that is easier. But then what you found was the problem that those goods over time, what happened? They degraded, so they did not constitute a store of value. Again, what do you think, that human beings started crying? No, they took it and solved it. And thus appeared metal coins: gold was used for large transactions, silver was used for smaller transactions, or bronze was used.

So, there you find yourselves with what you are, we have now moved from the commodity money model to the metallic standards. And that allows it to also be a unit of account, a generalized medium of payment, and a store of value. Now, what is the problem with metals or precious metals, with these metallic moneys? There is an evident problem, which is portability. Carrying these things around is somewhat heavy, to put it one way. And there is another thing that has to do with risks, and obviously, until I find a better example, I will keep using it. Therefore, surely many of you already know this example of a character that I love: it’s Zorro. I love Zorro because he is a character who is anarcho-capitalist. And basically, Diego de la Vega lived… where did he live?: in Los Angeles. And basically, what did the city live on? On the exchange with the people who came from the port. And so they came and brought goods, exchanged. But what happens when a foreigner arrives with a new cart? He gets off the ship and gets into a cart. The guy had a sign on his forehead that said: "I have gold, I have gold, I have gold, I have gold," right? So, what happened? The thieves would come and attack him. So, what did Zorro do? Zorro would beat the hell out of him, right?, he would kick him in the butt, of course. But why was this interesting? Because if the criminals — I say it like this, I don’t know, don’t feel bad about the word — if the wrongdoers… Professor, we want jail or bullet, but well, it doesn’t matter, well... Zorro would hit them with his sword.

That said, it is not a minor issue, because in fact we... achieved the approval of the reduction of accountability. Something that no one had done before. But well, aside from that, what Zorro did was... if you, the thieves, were successful, what was the problem? The problem was that Los Angeles would have been isolated. There is a wonderful example that Federico makes in one of his popular books, when there are those who want to close the country. So he says: well, then we close in Argentina, we close in the province of Buenos Aires, we close then in La Plata. When you reach the extreme, how long are you going to close? Until you reach the situation of autarky. I will say it in Latin: living in autarky is a nightmare. Can you imagine if you have to make your own shoes, your own socks, your own clothing, you have to take care of getting food every day, it’s a horrendous life. The life of autarky is a horror.

So, in that context, Zorro respected property rights and commerce. But not only that; also, who did he fight with? He fought with Monasterio, who was the State. So Zorro was a wonderful character, because what did Monasterio do? He collected taxes. So let’s go for Zorro. But the good thing about all this is that clearly you had an enormous risk. And again, what did the man do? Did he stop trading? “No, then we are going to autarky because a guy is going to rob my cart.” No, the man found a way; so when he found a way, what did they create? Deposit institutions. So, you would leave the gold, silver, or bronze deposited and take a certificate. And with that certificate, what did you do? Transactions. And when you finished making the transactions, on the other side there was someone who did the clearing and that was it. Now, what was the problem? The problem was that there was always some clever person who said “hey, wait, I can issue certificates against nothing.” So they started issuing certificates against thin air and what started to happen? As more certificates began to circulate, which is basically paper money, inflation started to occur.

So people became aware and went to get their deposits and that’s when chaos ensued. And the State, instead of taking action and sanctioning those who were basically defrauding others, said “hey, wait, this is a great business; now I’ll take care of doing this.” And that’s where we messed up and the State got involved with the currency. In fact, the different feudal lords, the different principalities, kingdoms had their coins and when they were metallic, they were exchanged. But what had they also discovered? Even using the coins, they had discovered seigniorage. What was seigniorage? They would take the coins, put them in a sack, shake them, and everything that fell out of gold and everything, they would make new coins; and that’s when inflation would start again. So, basically what happens? The coins would degrade, so they had a problem with trade with other coins. So, what did they start imposing? Legal tender: that is, legal tender is the counterpart of “I want to break the… the red part of the mandrill, let’s say, with inflationary tax.” I can already see the whiners: “Oh, Milei’s anal obsession.” They cry about everything. How nice. This is a great government, it keeps making the leftists cry, it’s wonderful. Just for that, it’s already great.

So, obviously, that starts a whole debate, especially after the discovery of America. Where do you think the quantitative theory or the beginnings of the quantitative theory were discovered? It wasn’t Hume, those who discovered the quantitative theory were the School of Salamanca. Why? Because, where did the gold from America enter? It entered Spain. And then, as the supply of gold increased, the value of gold fell. That is to say, all prices expressed in terms of gold rose. So, Spain became expensive and, consequently, generated a trade deficit with the rest, and the gold flowed from Spain to the rest of Europe. And there the prices leveled out. You realize, right?, the inefficiency of the situation. Because in the end, the relative prices didn’t change. Basically, what happened? They made a huge effort to take the gold and, what happened?, all prices went up. And in the end... it’s incredibly inefficient.

But of course, it’s a typical case of the prisoners' dilemma. But why did they do it then? Because the one who received it first won. That later is what is also the basis of the Hume-Cantillon effect: the one who receives the money first benefits. So, based on how prices move over time, that’s why, for example, why is devaluation so unpopular? Why are the enemies of the Government always asking for devaluation? Because it is an absolutely unpopular measure. And why is it unpopular? Because when the exchange rate jumps, first the exchange rate jumps, then the price of tradables jumps, then wholesale prices jump, then retail prices jump, and finally, wages. So, in the meantime, the working sector gets completely crushed. Since they are the majority of votes, obviously, it’s incredibly unpopular.

So, in that sense, that’s why the guys are always encouraging all these calamities. They don’t care that they have been messing up for a year and a half, but they keep insisting on the same thing. I mean, to see the level of stupidity, right? The exchange rate is free and they keep talking about exchange rate lag. I mean, I would be embarrassed. The exchange rate is free and they keep talking about exchange rate lag. They are pathetic. But, aside from that, a whole debate begins between what was known as the Currency School, which basically was the one that raised the point of the monetary nature of inflation. Of course, all the gold from America came in and they found that their inflation rate had accelerated. And then there was another school that was the Banking School. And so a whole debate begins that concludes in 1844 in England with what is called the Peel Act, which is the basis of the financial system we have today, where, basically, in terms of monetary policy, there was a fixed exchange rate — that is, gold standard — and, on the other hand, a fractional reserve financial system. What always happened happened: the State sought to be financed, and when everyone started to doubt the solvency of the State, runs would begin, assistance would start, pressures would start to be seen, central banks would start to lose gold, and then, what did they do? They devalued, raised the exchange rate to a higher level and thus, basically, corrected the situation.

But after that, that standard persisted until 1973, when the world witnessed one of the biggest scams in history, which was the end of Bretton Woods. In Argentina, we also had one of those great scams. One of those scams was the end of convertibility. Don’t forget that the pesos issued by the Central Bank are a liability to the private sector, and that liability was backed by dollars. When you look at the convertibility bills, they said “convertible legal tender.” It was recognized that this was a debt and that, moreover, it was settled one to one. But since politics did not want to make the adjustment, it decided to defraud Argentines. At that time, there were about 14 billion dollars in the Central Bank, which today would be… the friends of Clarín, Duhalde, Alfonsín and company, those who overthrew De la Rúa, basically ended up defrauding Argentines for 30 billion dollars. Can you imagine that, by saying all these things, I then have to deal with the headlines I get in the great Argentine rag? But well, someone had to come and put the balls on the table, and I say it to your face.

Therefore, the most important thing about this is to understand that money, the demand for money is that of the demand for a good of indirect exchange. And therefore what determines the demand for money is that demand for the goods with which one buys goods. So, if I want to understand where the demand for money is, the demand for money is fundamentally in my intertemporal consumption path over time. That is, the vector of intertemporal consumption over time, of all goods at each moment under analysis. So what I have to do is see what the demand for goods depends on. This may seem silly and it is not, largely because of Keynes. Keynes only took one six-month economics course at Cambridge. Keynes was a mathematician, his doctoral thesis was about probability, it’s the “Treatise on Probability.” And basically, he dedicated himself to investments; and the reality, contrary to what they say that he was a great investor, was that he was a terrible investor. And he went bankrupt, he went bankrupt tremendously. And since he was left without work and broke, he needed his father, John Neville Keynes, to throw him a lifeline. John Neville Keynes was very close, but very close, to Alfred Marshall. So, to young John Maynard, who was down and out, they got him a job in Cambridge so he could survive. And basically, all he had to do was take a course, so he took an economics course with Marshall, so he literally studied economics for six months.

This does not mean that he was not brilliant, I am not saying that he was not brilliant, he was a genius of evil. But he had some glaring shortcomings in terms of economic theory. When you, those of you who have done microeconomics, will have seen that when you derive consumer demand, you have two different exercises to derive demand: the one you usually see traditionally is what is called the derivation of Marshallian demand functions, which are partial equilibrium demand functions. And those partial equilibrium demand functions include all prices and income. Now, the less studied ones, but which are in some textbooks, only that they are called… that Marshallian demand function, you derive it from maximizing utility subject to the budget constraint. But there are other demand functions called Hicksian demands: which are basically minimizing expenditure subject to a level of utility. Why are these demand functions important? Because they are expressed only in terms of prices and utility.

So, why is this important? Because when you take a general equilibrium model, in a general equilibrium model, the excess demand functions do not enter. You were waiting for the rough part: this is the rough part. Everything I am talking about is all mathematical, so try to focus a lot. What happens? When you derive the general equilibrium system, it is only expressed in prices. Income does not enter. Because your income, where do you derive it from? You derive it from the sale of your endowments. The most conventional sale of endowments is in the sale of leisure in the form of work, and the other part of your income comes from what? From the share you have in the profits of companies. That is, from the profits of companies. And what do the profits of companies depend on? On prices. Therefore, the quantities disappear from the functions, both of supply and demand. That is, they only remain as a function of prices. That is why the excess demand functions depend only on prices. That is to say, in a general equilibrium system, income does not enter in any way. There is no quantity variable. The quantity variable arises if I have the equilibrium price vector. By definition, that vector makes supply coincide with demand. And supply and demand, there the quantity comes out, but it is a result of the model, it is not an explanatory variable.

So, in that context, in fact, when you demonstrate existence, you do it over the price vector. So, in that... Moreover: the construction of the derivation of the existence of equilibrium is also important. Because you have the excess demand functions, which are functions that go from prices and determine quantities. Now, the demonstration of an equilibrium is done with a fixed point theorem: Brouwer's, Kakutani's, whichever you prefer.

Now, it happens that the functions that enter into systems of those characteristics are functions to the same set; it would have to be from prices to prices. However, what do we have? That the excess demand function, what is it like? From prices to quantities. So, how do we correct that? You may have heard of something called the Walrasian auctioneer. What did the Walrasian auctioneer do? If at that price there was more demand than supply, he raised the prices, and if not, he lowered the prices. Well, that function, now, what is it? It is a function that goes from quantity to prices. So, you make the composite function of the excess demand of the Walrasian auctioneer. And now what do you have left? A function that goes from p to p. Consequently, if the characteristics are on the set that is closed, bounded, convex, with continuous functions in the case of functions that are also applications to points; then now equilibrium exists, is unique, and is also stable. Bingo! Having said all this, then do not even think about putting income into the money demand function. Because if it comes from a general equilibrium model, it does not need income to be there. It also does not need the interest rate to be there. And even less should you think about determining the interest rate in the money market. And I will explain why. Because the interest rate exists. It exists because time exists, not because money exists. The interest rate makes sense because there is a tomorrow. The interest rate is a mechanism of intertemporal coordination between the present and the future. What is saving? Saving is future consumption. What is investment? Future production. That is why, when you look at Wicksell, the saving-investment schemes are intertemporal models where the interest rate is a mechanism of intertemporal coordination between saving and investment. But fundamentally, it is nothing more than the relative price of today with respect to the future. Example: we have already removed the income effect from the equation, so the demand functions only have what? Substitution effects. Now, there is no income effect if income is not in a general equilibrium model. Consequently, the substitution effect is always negative. That is why Hicksian demand curves always have a negative slope. In the case of Marshallian curves, they can have a positive slope, which is in the case of Giffen goods, which are inferior goods where the income effect outweighs the substitution effect.

So, having said this, how long has it been since I taught micro? It has been a long time, but everything came together today. It showed up -. So, in that context, what you have is that if the price of one good rises, the other will have to fall, because there is only a substitution effect. When the interest rate rises, it means that the price of present goods is higher than that of future goods. Therefore, you will demand fewer present goods and more future goods. That is why, when the interest rate rises, saving increases.

Or put another way... why does investment increase when the interest rate falls? Because if future goods are more expensive than present goods compared to an initial situation, what is convenient for me: to sell more today or tomorrow? Tomorrow. So, I send production to the future. That is why, when the interest rate falls, investment rises. That is where it comes from. So, if the model is intertemporal, you do not need to put the interest rate, because, basically, what do you have? It is the relative price of present goods with respect to future goods. And when will they be arbitraged? When that relationship is the same across all goods. And that is where the equilibrium interest rate comes from.

Having said all this, I have just destroyed Keynes and everything that came after Keynes. But not only that, but the most interesting thing is that you will have excess demand functions that only depend on prices. Now I ask a question: fundamentally, what do all these functions that I have just derived depend on? They depend on what Robert Lucas Jr. called deep parameters, which is the way you describe an economy. Look at everything I am doing to describe the monetary nature of inflation. You do not realize: it is tremendous. But I will get there.

So, basically, an economy, what are the deep parameters? Preferences, technology, endowments, and the property scheme. In principle, all those parameters today, how are they? They are given. And if all those parameters are given, my intertemporal consumption path, how is it? It is given. And if that is the case, since the demand for money is a mirror of that function, of that intertemporal consumption vector, the demand for money is a granite rock. That is to say, under normal conditions of pressure and temperature —which is not what has been happening in Argentina since 1935 onwards; if you want to be more precise, if I am not mistaken, March first... was it March first or May first? I think it was March first when the Central Bank was created. Under normal conditions of pressure and temperature, the demand for money is a granite function; in fact, the classics understood this perfectly.

Do you think the classics were idiots? They were people who lived looking all day at what was happening in the real economy; they were watching all day. So, what do you think? That putting a fraction of income is because they were idiots? No, it was because under normal conditions of pressure and temperature, the demand for money is a granite rock. In fact, they had a gold standard, so they could not do much either. Having said this, now put in these terms, now the real demand for money is a granite rock, which is the mirror of the general equilibrium system on the real side. And in equilibrium, the real money supply, that is, the amount of money divided by the price level, must be equal to the demand for money. And this is the interesting part. And there arises the monetary nature of inflation, because the price level of the economy is the quotient between the money supply and the demand for money, which we have already said is fixed. So, as the amount of money rises, prices rise. Hence the famous phrase by Friedman: “Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon, generated by an excess of supply, either because the supply rises, or because the demand falls, or because both things happen at the same time, which causes the purchasing power of money to fall and, therefore, all prices expressed in a monetary unit to rise.” But as you will see, getting here involves a whole journey to understand that. Now, all of that is what is behind our thoughts on monetary matters.

At the same time, if you look, you have the issue of the nominal anchor. And this the vast majority of economists do not know, only a few. Those who have read Olivera in depth, in this work "On passing money," when he does the credit standard, he perfectly explains the problem of the nominal anchor. But what is the nominal anchor? That I fix the amount of money, for what? To park prices. I mean, does this discussion seem minor to you? This is the discussion that occurred after we lifted the exchange rate controls. All the bunch of monkeys, econochantas, from mandrilandia said: “The exchange rate is going to skyrocket, they are going to lose reserves, at 1400, it is going to be a disaster, the inflation rate is going to skyrocket.” What did we respond? “No.” And why? Because the amount of money has been fixed since the middle of last year. Moreover: if the lag of monetary policy is between 18 and 24 months —I tell you again— by the middle of next year, there will be no more inflation in Argentina.

If you look, during those days, both what was the announcement by Toto and Santi Bausili, what was the national broadcast, what were the presentations in different places by Fede Furiase, or what we were trying to push with Federico and in my case, was to explain that the exchange rate did not have to jump. And if it jumped, there was no reason for inflation to occur. Because there is something called the Hume-Cantillon effect. When I generate the problem of excess money supply and the exchange rate jumps —that is, it translates to the foreign exchange market and the exchange rate jumps— the exchange rate rises, then the tradables rise, then the wholesale prices rise, then the retail prices rise, then... of course, Argentines have seen that model for 90 years. So, Argentines believed that if the exchange rate rose, then prices rose. That is wrong, because it is prices determining prices. It does not work that way. Because if it worked that way, I would not need to put the Law of Walras inside the general equilibrium model. If my problem is that I have prices determining quantity and I needed a mechanism for quantities to determine prices, I did not have price to price. Therefore, it is an inconsistency. It is a theoretical inconsistency to believe that the exchange rate was going to determine prices.

So, there was a whole communication effort to explain to people that the exchange rate did not have to jump and that the price level did not have to jump either. And that, if the exchange rate jumped, it did not have to go to prices. Why did we explain this? Because if you had the exchange rate jump and people were furious about buying things, and buying dollars, and the dollars —let's suppose it had gone to the ceiling of the band— those goods would have become more expensive. So, you would have spent more on those goods and, therefore, would have had to spend less on others, and consequently, prices would go down. And why were we so confident about that? Because the only way that can happen is when you have the amount of money fixed. When you have the amount of money fixed, there is no monetary validation. With no monetary validation, if one price rises, the other must fall by force. That is why we were confident. We did not fight with reality. If people want to form prices looking at the exchange rate, and there are 90 years that give them reason, well, what we have to try to do is show people how this works. That is why it is fabulous when Toto is told: “No, I have seen this before.” Bullshit! You have never seen it! Because you have never seen fiscal balance conjugated with fixed money supply and free exchange rate. You have never seen it! “I have seen this before.” No, you have seen nothing. You have seen nothing. You lived in an illusion, trapped by the Hume-Cantillon effect. I mean, for it to happen to people who are not trained in economics, that is not a problem. The problem is that it happens to the idiots of economists; that is the serious part.

So, there was a whole effort to try to make the model now resemble rational expectations: the price level has to do with what? And, with the amount of money. So I remember journalists saying: “No, the inflation rate is going to be between 5 and 7.” The great Argentine rag encouraging the crisis. Of course, because after the last crisis of 2001-2002, they did very well, because they diluted and messed with all the creditors, right? In exchange for covers and protecting the Duhalde government, they messed up the lives of all Argentines, but they managed to get the cultural goods law so that those actions they had pledged would not be executed. And since that was not enough, because when they went to the bankruptcy, the percentage was not enough, they then modified the bankruptcy law so that it could be done with 51%, instead of two-thirds. And there they left the creditors defenseless and screwed them all, and that is how we lived... these pauteros, corrupt, who ruined Argentina and who are extortionists. And what they try to do is pressure governments with covers.

But aside from that, what I want to point out is that we are already clear that then, in addition, we liberated the foreign exchange market and the exchange rate did not rise. Moreover, what would economic theory have said? Suppose I have a controlled price, a maximum price. Generally, a maximum price is set below the equilibrium level. This creates an excess demand for foreign currency. And the truth is that, during all of March and half of April, we lost a lot of reserves. And also, we could not defend ourselves because we had confidentiality due to the agreement with the Fund, while the idiots of the journalists said “Oh, they are scared and hiding!” and predicted all kinds of catastrophes. But there was also a parallel. And what does economics say when you have a situation like this? That if you open up, not only are there more quantities, but also, what happens? That the exchange rate goes to the middle ground. To the misfortune of the econochantas and the doomsayers, the exchange rate is at levels similar to those we had for the official exchange rate. So, all those who talked about exchange rate lag and all that, again found themselves offside. But now it is in the market. The other criticism they make is that no, it is not a market because there are bands. Another stupidity. Now I will explain the bands.

The first is the following: today we - Toto said it before I entered - if we wanted to rescue the entire broad monetary base, we could do it at 900, 911 pesos if I'm not mistaken; that is, below the level of the band. Do you realize the obscene level of coverage that the peso has today? I mean, we can rescue all the pesos at 911. And if we had to do it at the ceiling of the band, we can rescue all the pesos and we would have 15 billion dollars left over. Do you realize, right? So, now I ask, why the bands and those things? There is a talk I gave on Fantino's show, which I had titled those papers “Learning to Float”; and that was what we were trying to communicate at that moment. Moreover, it doesn't matter if the exchange rate fluctuates being free; what matters here in terms of inflation is that we do not issue, that there is no monetary issuance and the amount of money has been fixed since mid-last year. “No, well, but there is inflation.”

And because inflation has a lag. That is, the previous beast issued 13 points of GDP in one year: what did you want, for there to be no inflation? Well, we started to fix things, but that money is on the street. So, in that context, I am now going to give a technical explanation for the issue of the bands. When you work, because there is a group of idiots that says: “the exchange rate is not free because you actually have bands,” look, the truth is that inside the band it is free. I mean, the problem would be, you can question whether it goes to the ceiling or the floor of the band, but within the band there should be nothing to question. But now I am going to enlighten the idiots who say that. When you study general equilibrium, you have the two most used fixed point theorems, which are Brower's and Kakutani's. Brower's theorem is for functions, they are point-to-point applications. That is, you have a price, it responds with a quantity. The fixed point theorem of Kakutani is a correspondence, they are point-set. That is, you throw a price, it responds with a set of quantities. But, whether you work with functions or with correspondences, in general, you always work with bounded sets. But, what is interesting? The interesting thing is that some brilliant guy came up with working with unbounded sets. This is interesting because working with unbounded sets, you have some problems with optimization issues, you have a problem in finding an optimum.

So, where do you get the functions that are optimal? So, when you work with unbounded sets, what is done to demonstrate the existence of equilibrium is to work with artificially bounded sets. That is, what do you do? You put an artificial bound wherever you want, and given that bound where you want but that exists, that is why it is called artificially bounded, you derive the equilibrium. And if that restriction is not effective, that equilibrium now exists and has all the properties under which we regularly work.

Therefore, what did we do? What was the problem? People came with 90 years of being scammed with a model that monetarily validated fiscal deficits and so on. People, again, since they lived in a world where we always lived with fiscal deficits and monetary issuance, it is clear that they have a chip that, go explain to them that a person who believed that the exchange rate determined prices was wrong and for 90 years it gave him reason. I mean, they take and say: “no, well, the only period when there was no inflation was the 90s, the exchange rate was fixed.” But, how do you explain to the person who thinks that is wrong? And the guy who says “haha” Do you know what? This is the same as another discussion that, for example, there is in growth. If you take history from the year 0 of the Christian era until 2000, let's say, the first 1800 years the per capita GDP is practically constant. Which is what is called the Malthusian era. And then it starts to grow phenomenally.

One of the things that Adam Smith does with the idea of the invisible factory of pins says that the returns are increasing. And Malthus laughs at him, he says: “look at the empirical evidence, kid, you are delusional.” If we had done econometrics in 1801, who would econometrics have endorsed? It would have endorsed Malthus. What does the empirical evidence say when one takes the last 250 years? The one who was right was Adam Smith. For me, Adam Smith is to economics what Gauss is to mathematics: a guy who lived 250 years ahead of his time. So, here it is the same. I mean, go explain to someone who lived with 90 years of fiscal imbalance or with monetary issuance that the model does not work that way. “No, well, but in reality it is that it is a financial asset.” People don't care a bit! So, that is why the effort to communicate that what matters is the amount of money for the determination of prices. And that there can be changes in relative prices, yes. And why did we put the band? To artificially bound it. But, since it is inside, that's it, the problem is over. I swear it is hard for me to believe that they are so stupid. It is something that truly surprises me.

Now, having said that, the mechanism for controlling the money supply is not the only mechanism. There is another control mechanism, there are other models of money supply that are those of endogenous money. For example, there is one that is the commodity standard. So, that makes the price determined exogenously and what is determined endogenously is what? The amount of money. So, this is very typical for those programs that try to control prices. So, you set the prices and the amount of money adjusts to that. A relative of this is what? The model of distributive bidding, which is the wage standard. So, prices are an alpha of wages. So, wages move, prices move, then the amount of money is modified and is monetarily validated in that way. And the other model is the external standard model, where you set the exchange rate. By fixing the exchange rate, the anchor is the exchange rate. Why? Because the local price level is the international price level given and the exchange rate is also given because you fixed it. So, you set the price level and the amount of money is determined based on what: on the demand for money. So, when the demand for money increases, people go and the Central Bank sells pesos to those who bring dollars. Why? To expand the amount of money. The phrase is not trivial, it is not said. I mean, people go and buy pesos. This is not minor, because when they go with dollars and buy pesos, that money is being demanded. So, since the process is driven from demand, the growth that there is in supply means that there is no loss of purchasing power of money, because that demand and supply are mapped. This is not minor because it is precisely what happens in this model that we are working on.

Moreover, notice that when you have this situation, if you normalize the exchange rate to one and the international price level to one, credit, the money supply or the monetary base, will be composed of two elements: reserves and domestic credit, and that will have to equal what? To the demand for base, to the demand for money. See that, if I have the demand for money and leave reserves here, and pass domestic credit to the other side, I have the demand for money minus domestic credit. If the demand for money increases, what happens? Reserves go up. But if domestic credit increases, I lose reserves. Who experienced that? Kirchnerism. It made fiscal deficits, financed it with monetary issuance and, by financing it with monetary issuance, what happened? It lost reserves. How did it correct it? Did it correct it by devaluing? No. How did it correct it? With the cepo, with restrictions. Why? To have an adjustment of quantities without touching prices, believing that what was going to determine inflation was that the exchange rate moved, which generated a brutal excess of demand in the foreign exchange market that translated into an excess of supply in the rest of the economy, which implied that the demand for bonds fell.

Therefore, the prices of bonds were low, high interest rates, high country risk - when we won, the country risk was at 3000; that generates an excess of supply in the goods market, with which the economy was stagnant since 2011, at the same level of GDP, in per capita terms, 15% down. Not only that: that excess supply in the goods market translated into an excess supply in the labor market. The number of formal jobs has been stuck since 2011 at 6 million jobs. And how was it compensated? With an increase in the public sector, under that stupid aberration that is “governing is creating jobs.” No, governing is making people live better. Why is that phrase “governing is creating jobs” a nonsense the size of a house? Because then, what do I do? I create many public jobs. We are going to blow up. That is what Kirchnerism did. In reality, governing is making people live better and that jobs are created... I mean, I put it to you with a ridiculous case: what happens if the number of people in the economy is constant, the birth rate equal to the death rate? What am I going to create jobs if the number of people does not change? What are you talking about? I mean, governing is generating well-being; that is, lowering inflation, making the economy grow, improving real wages, and having fewer poor and fewer indigent people. By the way, we, the heartless liberals, reduced poverty in less than a year by 22 points.

That is, we took 10 million human beings out of poverty. How heartless the liberals are! Therefore, now we are in a position. Now we have all the necessary elements to understand the problem of endogenous dollarization. If we thought of this in terms of quantitative theory, the price level of the country would be the amount of money divided by K times Y, right?, the fraction K of income that is required as money, the income. And that could also be valid for whom? For the reference country with which you want to fix the currency, called the dollar. So, the international price level or the price in the United States would be the money supply in the United States divided by K times Y of the United States. If I have that the local price is the exchange rate times the international price, the exchange rate is given by the quotient between the local price and the international price. When you replace the price equation —amount of money over K times Y— you will arrive at something called relative monetary conditions. Therefore, to the extent that the money supply in the United States grows more than that of Argentina, our currency appreciates, which makes sense, because in the United States, the United States does issue money; we do not issue money. And I tell you something else: we take money out of the game, either through the fiscal surplus and either through the placement, for example, of the BOPREAL.

Thus, that makes us take pesos out, and therefore, the exchange rate tends to fall. We do not do magic. I mean, Toto is a genius, but he is not Copperfield. I mean, a magician is a liar. Remember that a magician is a liar. The gentleman is a true crack. So, the exchange rate falls because he is taking pesos off the street. Now, is it the only mechanism that makes the exchange rate appreciate? No. Argentina comes from absolutely overflowing levels of inflation. Therefore, the demand for money was very low. The K factor of Argentina was very low. The proportion of money in terms of GDP was literally a mess. It was around 2% of the base when we arrived. I mean, that number should be, the broad monetary base, around 14 or 15 points of GDP. Today it is at six and a half. That is, Argentina still has what? An enormous potential for remonetization.

Consequently, if we lower the inflation rate to levels of international inflation rates, what is going to have to happen? That relative remonetization will make the exchange rate have to fall. And, in addition, Argentina has everything to start growing and start converging. In fact, in the first half, it is interesting because, after having made the largest fiscal adjustment in history, 15 points of GDP: 5 in the Treasury, 10 in the Central Bank, everyone predicted a catastrophe, that at least GDP would fall by 15%. Then they started with the L: it was falling, but it remained fixed; or they started with the Nike little pip very faintly. And we talked about the V recovery and they mocked us. Then they started with the Nike little pip, but already more in a traditional format. Then they had no choice but to admit that the short V. And the truth is that it ended up being a tilde. Because, basically, when you take the seasonally adjusted EMAE, December against December, it rose 6%. That is, we made the largest fiscal adjustment in the history of humanity, in the shortest time possible, because we put 5 in the Treasury in the first month, and we added 15 in 6 months when we fixed the Central Bank; we lowered the inflation rate from levels of 54% monthly to 1, less than one, to 0.8%, with which we went from 17000 to 10%. And if you take it in dollars, deflation, moreover, because if you subtracted the crawling peg of 2%, we went to deflation in dollars.

And with all that, respecting property rights, adjusting tariffs, without hyperinflation or anything, GDP grew by 6% from peak to peak. Moreover, GDP in the first quarter expanded by 6%. In the second quarter, it is growing at 8%. Not only that, but the latest seasonally adjusted figure of 0.8 implies that Argentina is expanding at 10%. I remember that at some point, the idiots who championed form complained because I said that the Argentine economy was going to rise like a diver's fart. Guys, welcome, because bubbles are everywhere.

Now, then, what is the point we find now? That we have a fixed amount of money, but we have a contracting supply. The demand factor is rising, economic growth, what is the problem? The demand for money is skyrocketing. So, as long as there is still excess money, the economy will be able to continue functioning at this speed, while the inflation rate decreases. This is something interesting: as we clean up the money overhang, you will see that the economy continues to expand strongly with decreasing inflation rates. Now, what is the problem? The problem is that when we finish exhausting the money overhang, the exchange rate will have to drop very quickly to the bottom of the band. Because that is where we just start to monetize. And what is the problem? That this speed may be much faster than the speed of the real sector, and that could send many companies into bankruptcy due to adjustment speed issues. That is to say, we now have an economy that should have a deflationary contractual structure.

We need a contractual structure of an economy with deflation, and the contractual structure of Argentina is a contractual structure of an economy with inflation. There is a wonderful book by Professor Philipp Bagus called "Defending Deflation," in which he explains the entire debate on deflation in the history of economic thought. Now, what is the problem? The problem is that I have a contractual structure that is not prepared, and since I do not have the contractual structure prepared, if it drops very quickly to the bottom of the band and I clean up the money overhang, but in that transition I do not have the contractual structure adjusted, I could be sending companies into bankruptcy. So, one of the things we are doing is, well, how do we monetize the economy without issuing money? And now everything I explained at the beginning makes sense.

Because, deep down, who determines the amount of money within the economy? The real amount of money in the economy is not determined by the Central Bank. The Central Bank can determine the nominal amount of money, but not the real amount of money: the real amount of money is determined by, who? It is determined by individuals. What is it, what? The mirror demand, the derived function, that is, the derived demand that comes from the goods market. That is to say, the real amount of money within the economy is determined by, who? The agents. And why is this important? And hence the endogenous dollarization. We have allowed, and it is allowed today, for all individuals to make transactions in whatever currency they want. That is to say, I fulfilled the campaign promise. You can make transactions in the currency you want. So, the question is, why don’t you do it? Well, because deep down, do you know what the reality is? They are afraid of getting their fingers burned. And that ARCA will go after them. And no matter how much I swear to you that ARCA will not go after you... they say, “well, but there are other governments that did it.” So, what are we doing? We are working together, ARCA with the Ministry of Economy and the Central Bank, to relax all those rules so that no one persecutes you for using the dollars you have under the mattress. That is to say, a true monetary revolution of freedom, because we consider that those who fled with the money are not criminals, they are heroes who managed to escape from the sons of bitches of the politicians who wanted to screw them with the inflation tax.

I ask a question: I was lucky enough to meet someone who escaped from Cuba, but I ask a question, if you have a situation of a person escaping from the prison island that is Cuba, according to Cuban laws, what would that be? It would be a crime, right? I ask a question. And the one who manages to escape, would you then go and catch them in Miami and kill them or take them back to Cuba? Sometimes what is legal is not necessarily licit. It is not licit that the sons of bitches governments have imposed controls, the currency exchange criminal law is not licit. You can save in whatever you want and no one can arrogate the right to say what you can or cannot save. If in 2001, instead of keeping a thousand dollars, you had kept a thousand pesos, today you would have one dollar. The shitty politicians would have stolen 999 dollars from you. Is it wrong that you want to protect yourself from a thief? Those people who have money under the mattress are not criminals, they are people who escaped from an oppressive regime that wanted to scam them.

Therefore, restoring freedom also means that those people can put their money back into the system without anyone chasing them. And hence we are promoting and working for people to be able to withdraw their savings and not be pursued by the State, because they have already been pursued enough with a currency that had to have 13 zeros taken off, and that, if you look today, we could take off three more. Therefore, what is the process of endogenous dollarization? That individuals, based on what they need to demand, monetize the economy without having to go through the foreign exchange market. So, you will have the amount of money fixed, unless you reach the bottom of the band; and, on the other hand, what will you have? That as individuals need to make more transactions, they will be able to use, what? The dollars from the mattress. And what is the result? The result is that there will be more and more dollars, and there will come a time when there will be so many dollars compared to pesos that, that day, if we feel like it, we can close the Central Bank and free them from the thieving politicians for eternity. Thank you very much.