Speech by President Javier Milei at the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) in Washington D.C.

Argentina Javier Milei · President of Argentina

21 February 2025 · Presentation at the Inter-American Development Bank · Inter-American Development Bank, Washington D.C, United States

Context
Milei addressed the Inter-American Development Bank in Washington D.C. on February 21, 2025, presenting the foundations and results of Argentina's liberal economic model.
Main themes
Argentine economic model, liberalism and free markets, Argentina's economic decline, poverty and inflation, fiscal adjustment, GDP per capita history, private property rights, Austrian economics, socialist policies as failure, economic reform
Duration
~62 min
96th percentile
Words
7,394
96th percentile
Sentences
370
97th percentile
Readability
60
88th percentile
Grade
9.7
17th percentile
Syntax
3.02
51st percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 66%64%
  • Institutional 18%18%
  • Social 8%7%
  • Ceremonial 7%6%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

370 sentences in 26 paragraphs

Good morning everyone. Or as I would say in other presentations of mine: "Hello everyone."

Basically - first of all - I want to thank you for inviting me to speak about the characteristics of what the Argentine model is, and basically, the presentation has four parts: there is a first part that relates to what we call the moral foundation of the model and which are the guidelines on which policy, in general, and economic policy, in particular, are guided.

Once we explore this in abstract definitions, we present as a counterexample what Argentina has done over the last 100 years. And what has sunk it; once one understands this relationship, we find ourselves with the starting data and with the policies we implemented. And from there, we provide explanations on how we believe we will generate economic growth.

In that sense, the foundation of our model is the idea of liberalism, according to the definition of our greatest exponent of the ideas of freedom throughout history, which is Professor Alberto Venegas Lynch (son), who points out that liberalism is the unrestricted respect for the life project of others, based on the principle of non-aggression and in defense of the right to life, liberty, and property, whose institutions are private property; free markets free from state intervention; competition, understood as a process of entry and exit, not in the neoclassical idea, but in the Austrian idea, of the division of labor and social cooperation, and this is a system, since success in economics derives from serving others with better quality goods and at a better price. This system, which seems abstract, actually applies different components from all areas of policy, and - today - we are going to focus on the economic issue. Specifically, what I am going to do now is describe how the Argentine decline has unfolded and in that - basically - I will show how Argentina has systematically destroyed these concepts and how systematically we have moved away from the liberal paradigm, which has turned Argentina into a catastrophe.

Yes, that phone is terrible. It's mine. Let me tell you what’s happening, as we announced that we were going to broadcast it on my Instagram channel, and there is always a born idiot, because the one doing this knows what he is doing and knows that he is interrupting the talk, so it’s not that he doesn’t know, but Argentina is like this: it has a lot of thick-headed people who do this kind of thing in some cases. We call them "head of an octopus," do you know why "head of an octopus"? Because the octopus has its digestive system in its head, so it is full of excrement; so having said this to those nice people who are trying to interfere and annoy the conference… they should know that in a debate I even had coughers, so let’s say, imagine what one can expect from Argentina, there goes the thick-headed person and they are not going to stop because they don’t want this to be broadcasted.

So, basically, what we see as the symptoms of what the Argentine decline was is, for example, seeing how Argentina lost places in terms of the ranking of GDP per capita. If you take Angus Maddison's estimates, at the end of the 19th century, Argentina was one of the three countries with the highest GDP per capita on the planet. It was the land of prosperity, the land of abundance. In fact, it competed - hand in hand - with the United States. However, after gradually embracing ideas of a socialist tint, Argentina became a true catastrophe.

When we came to power, Argentina was clearly below the average of the table. And, obviously, that also translated into a substantial increase in poverty. While official accounts show poverty levels - slightly - above 40%, the reality is that this is a semiannual average. And when a variable is on a rising trend… if you show in December the average of the last semester, you are underreporting poverty. Not because one is lying, but simply due to a methodological issue of averages. And also, another thing that statistics do not reflect is that Argentina, having had price controls, was suffering from shortages and that is not captured in the indicators. So, one of the situations that could happen is that to keep myself healthy, with the statistics, we could have done everything the same; not adjust anything and - in that context - people - statistically - would have been fine but would have starved because they could not have bought anything in the supermarket. So what we decided was to clarify the situation, because - basically in that way - products would return to the shelves, and that clarification implied finding ourselves with 57% of poor people, which is the recorded number, in January '24.

On the other hand, inflation - when we arrived - was running at more than 1% daily and then accelerated more during the second week of December. Wholesale inflation, which is the one that anticipates, was running at 54% monthly. I know there is a whole criticism when I annualize this year and say that this, annualized, gives 17,000, and basically when I do that calculation I make clear the different imbalances we had. We had a money overhang, which was double what we had before the Rodrigazo crisis, which was a situation that multiplied the inflation rate by six. So, at least, we had to multiply the inflation rate by 12 times. At the same time, they left us - at the Central Bank - 4 monetary bases, which matured in one day in interest-bearing liabilities; which means that - in one day - we could have quintupled the amount of money, so quintupled prices would not have been strange at the pace we were going. In addition, we had maturities - in debt, in pesos - equivalent to 90 billion dollars. Therefore, if one takes all those elements, Argentina reaching inflation levels of around 15,000 to 17,000 percent, with all that wave of money, would have been quite simple. And that if the demand for money had not fallen, which you know is not true. So, I cannot be making these explanations in public because, in general, people do not need to know about economic issues, so that is why I always simplify with the annualization of the number.

On the other hand, that situation would also have implied a generalized default because clearly we would not have been able to honor the debt in pesos, clearly we would not have been able to honor commercial debt and, therefore, we would not have been able to honor debt in general, which would have led to a commercial breakdown of the economy and that would have made the situation even more difficult. And also, Argentina was facing a situation of high tax pressure. So the question is how did they get to this disaster? Given that there had already been two hyperinflations before, and there the justification and to start seeing how the model intertwines is what - in the campaign - I called the model of the caste. The model of the caste has two elements. Obviously, it has an aberrant phrase from socialists that says: "where there is a need, a right is born." The problem is that needs are infinite and the right someone has to pay for it, and resources are finite. So we have a problem of infinite needs with finite resources. That is to say, this - for economists - does not represent a problem because we know that through free market economics this can be resolved efficiently. But that is not the solution that politicians like. Politicians prefer to use a much more brutal and violent method, called social justice.

Social justice is an aberration, from a moral point of view and, naturally, as was to be expected, it will generate bad results. That is to say, because justice… The question is, is anyone present here in favor of theft? I see that no one is, clearly, because in fact it is a sin, and stealing is a sin; we already know that since Moses came down from Mount Sinai and brought the tablets and one was "you shall not steal." And the other implies unequal treatment before the law. Is anyone in favor of people having privileges and that some are rewarded and others punished by the law? That is to say, is there anyone who is against equality before the law? Well, social justice is aberrant because it is theft and already implies unequal treatment before the law. That is to say, in front of two individuals: one is robbed of their income, part of their income, and it is given to another. Therefore, there is theft and there is unequal treatment before the law. And that, in addition, generates a serious problem of incentives, because if the one who generates wealth is being punished and the one who kicks and cries that this is unfair is given money, then the incentive is to kick and shout and complain and not work, which generates a system of incentives incompatible with progress.

At the same time, it also has consequences on the quality of life of society, but not only because of its economic damage, but because of the damage to the bond between people. Promoting and enhancing a society of envious people makes the climate - within society - extremely hostile. Society lives confronted, due to a supposed class struggle and, in that sense, the quality of the bond is very poor and there is a lot of distrust, and society becomes hyper-polarized and what reigns is hatred. Because, of course, there is one who produces wealth and it is stolen from them, and there is another who says they have the right to appropriate the wealth of the other. So, it is as if one lived in a permanent war and all for adhering to a bad economic theory. As Hayek said: “If socialists understood economics, they would not be socialists.” Moreover, I would tell you that - the truth - is that Marx was brutally refuted by Eugen Von Böhm-Bawerk, in a book called: “The Conclusion of the Marxian System,” where he proved all the inconsistencies of the system. Marx had already realized, when Menger presented the principles of political economy. And not only that, but also later it was battered by Mises, in the book: “Socialism,” explaining that socialism could not work due to the problem of economic calculation. Hayek demonstrated - in “The Road to Serfdom” - how interventions led to that sinister system. And the reality is that many believe that the empirical evidence that real socialism does not work was in 1989, when the Wall fell, and, in reality, the true evidence that those ideas do not work was in 1961, when they had to build it. So, the question is why do they continue to adhere to this garbage. If they were defeated in the Theory of Value; they were defeated in the design of the structure of the theory; they were destroyed in dynamics, in problems of economic calculation, and they were destroyed by empirical evidence. Why do they continue to uphold it? Because the Theory of Exploitation, by Rodbertus, that is, the theory preceding Marx's theory of exploitation, uses the labor value theory as a mechanism to explain exploitation. And that is the moral basis, from there is envy, hatred, and resentment.

So, now that this is said, what is the consequence of the social justice program? The consequence of the social justice program is that it has to be corrected with the claw of the State. That is to say, they do not believe in the invisible hand of the market. They believe in the claw of the State. They believe in stealing from one person to give to another. That is to say, as if there were some justification. I mean, on what grounds? I want to be charitable to this group... I will do it this way: I want to be charitable to this group, the one on the left, by robbing the group on the right. So, I come, put a gun to their head, and take their money to give it to them. It is an aberrant issue. How am I going to explain to this group that I am robbing them to be charitable? Charity is not done at gunpoint. Charity must arise naturally, not through violence. This can only be resolved by the market, but they do not believe in that. So, when social justice starts, how does it manifest? As a fiscal deficit, as an increase in public spending. And then, now comes the problem of how we finance it. Because it is a bit violent to put a gun to this poor group's head. So, what does a politician do, besides being populist? They try to make someone else pay the cost and make sure no one sees it. Therefore, the first tool a politician uses is what? Indebtedness. And why do they do that? Because indebtedness is future taxes. So, the party of today, which this group is going to enjoy - and do not doubt that everyone is going to vote for the politician who does that, who is also more than this group over here - means that it is profoundly immoral because they are passing the bill for today's party to future generations. That is to say, there are people who have not yet been born and have to pay for this party. That is to say, taking on debt is absolutely immoral. That is why zero deficit is non-negotiable in our economic policy. The zero deficit is not taken just like that. It is a moral definition, it goes beyond macroeconomics, it is a moral issue. You cannot be loading the cost of the current party onto future generations. And in fact, everyone knows, we are working on a program to obtain new financing, but that financing is to repay the debt that the Treasury has with its main creditor, which is the Central Bank. So that the creditors of the Central Bank, the holders of pesos, can escape the scam of the different governments that went and stole the reserves of the Central Bank, undermining the quality of the assets that backed that liability called pesos. This is not minor, because the more insolvent the Central Bank is, the higher the price level required to liquidate that monetary liability. Therefore, the more bankrupt the Central Bank is, the higher the long-term price level is. Therefore, if I take the price level of today and compare it against that price level, that line, that slope is the implicit inflation rate. Therefore, as we clean up the assets of the Central Bank, yes, (which we have been doing systematically), what will ensure is that the asset recomposition, the long-term price level, is lower and, therefore, the implicit inflation rate is much lower. And it is a way to end the problem of inflation forever. The other way to do it is by issuing money, and by issuing money, we generate inflation. For many years - in Argentina - a monstrous stupidity was said that inflation is multi-causal, and we seemed crazy those who defended the monetary hypothesis of inflation. And of course, saying that inflation is multi-causal is like talking about - I don’t know - the obese skeleton, the hot ice cream, the virgin prostitute, I don’t know, things like that. But well, we had to come to prove that inflation was a monetary phenomenon. But that inflation - in the end - ends up being a tax, and it is a tax on the most vulnerable sectors. In fact, one of the things we were absolutely convinced of is that by lowering the inflation rate, we would lower poverty, and indeed, the monthly frequency, poverty fell from 57% to 33%, that is, it dropped by 24 percentage points. That is to say, in just over a year, in 13 months, we lowered and lifted more than 10 million Argentines out of poverty. It was indeed important to defend the monetary nature of inflation. And in the end, when the politician can no longer resort to debt because, in fact, Argentina has been a serial defaulter, Argentina has committed aberrations with its currency, as we removed 13 zeros from the currency; we destroyed five monetary signs; we could remove three more, but there comes a time when it can no longer be done. So, the politician always opts to raise taxes, and that is why we have a country with one of the highest tax burdens on the planet. Basically, that is why Argentina has the problems it has of high indebtedness, high inflation, and high tax pressure. Or for example - and this is very important - without a doubt, the brilliant Minister of Economy we have, who is Luis “Toto” Caputo, who is here and who is undoubtedly the best Minister of Economy in all of Argentine history, in one of his first speeches explained something wonderful: the truth is that the central axis of Argentina, the central problem of Argentina, is the fiscal deficit.

Last year, we were the first government, in the last 124 years, to have a surplus in the financial line. There are others who say: “No, but there were other years when there was also a surplus.” Yes, but we were not paying the debt. I mean, it’s like we weren’t paying the interest. The first time that all commitments were honored was this past year. In fact, Argentina - from 1901 to 2024 - had 22 crises. Of those 22 crises: 20 had a fiscal origin, and the fiscal origin is divided between high fiscal imbalance and extravagant fiscal imbalance. But it is not only the impact that this has on the debt, on inflation, or what it has to do with tax pressure. One of the things that different governments in Argentina have recurrently done is apply price controls. And what happens when there are price controls? Scarcity is generated. So - for example - they encounter the Supply Law; the Shelving Law. The Shelving Law… did it measure the shelves? I mean, how does someone come up with a law like that? It’s like trying to avoid the law of gravity with a law and walking around with a centimeter checking the height at which stones fall. I don’t know, it’s truly, directly aberrant.

Or, for example: let’s suppose the typical populist situation that existed in Kirchnerism, where they created fiscal imbalance; since they were so unpresentable, they could not access the markets. So, they financed themselves with monetary issuance. That monetary issuance began to generate inflation. As it generated inflation - then - to try to prevent inflation from rising, they fixed the exchange rate. And by fixing the exchange rate, they began to lose international reserves. And then, as they wanted to prevent international reserves from being lost, they imposed the capital controls. What we received was a monstrosity, now much, much smaller. But this is interesting because, what is the capital controls? The capital controls is nothing more than a mechanism to artificially increase the demand for money. And see how aberrant this situation is, because, first of all, what it is violating is their consumption set, because - in the end - Argentines also bought dollars to transfer present consumption to the future. I mean, as a form of store of value. But not only that, but you, the rectors, were forced to hold pesos, and that artificially increased the demand for money and, therefore, artificially increased the taxable base of the inflation tax.

So, see how the web of regulations and controls also has to do with the fact that what is always underlying is the fiscal imbalance. And the fiscal imbalance has a moral basis. Therefore, in that sense, when we arrived, we found a consolidated fiscal deficit of 15 points of GDP, that is, 5 points in the Treasury; 10 points in the Central Bank, which generated endogenous issuance. That is to say, even if we had closed the fiscal imbalance - this was also brilliantly explained by Minister Caputo in one of his recent interviews - even if we had put the fiscal accounts in order on the first day, as we did, because - in the first month - we put the fiscal accounts in order and the most interesting thing is that, even so, we would not have avoided hyperinflation, because we had 4 monetary bases maturing in one day. In fact, if we had followed the recommendation to raise the rate - as they were suggesting to us - it would have basically turned into an unmanageable snowball, and hyperinflation would not have been a data point, aside from, as I said, we had debt maturities in pesos equivalent to 90 billion dollars, we had debts with the outside world of 25 billion dollars and the agreement with the Fund had fallen. In addition, we had negative net international reserves of around 12 billion dollars. Furthermore, the previous government not only issued 28 points of GDP of money during the 4 years, and 13 did so during the election year, but also created a monstrous mechanism - called SIRA - that was to obtain import permits. So, that allowed them to access dollars at the official exchange rate. What a coincidence, because the exchange rate was three times higher. There was a gap of 200%, that is, a true scam. And also, we had outstanding dividend debts of 10 billion dollars. And I had already told you how inflation was traveling. In that sense, we - from the first day - decided to implement a shock program. And there the idea was to achieve zero deficit by the year 2024. They told us it was impossible because you could not adjust more than one point of GDP, that politics did not allow that and I don’t know how many more things. And the reality is that, thanks to the excellent work of Minister Caputo's team, in the first month of management we achieved financial balance, despite the fact that in January we paid interest. The original adjustment was 7 points of GDP and 2 points of GDP we used to provide support in the social area. And after 6 months, we also cleaned up the balance of the Central Bank, completing a fiscal adjustment of 15 points of GDP. Here, the enormous task of the president of the Central Bank, Santiago Bausili, and the secretary of financing, Pablo Quirno, was also very important, as we maintained fiscal balance over the months, which allowed us to recover the debt markets and allowed us to remove that debt that was within the Central Bank and take it to the Treasury. Because, in reality, that debt had always belonged to the Treasury and what the previous government basically did was use tricks to place bonds with the Central Bank. And then, the Central Bank issued and then sterilized them elsewhere. And then those huge remunerated liabilities appeared that generated a quasi-fiscal deficit of 10 points of GDP. But, as we stabilized the economy and showed fiscal solidity, it allowed for a reconfiguration of a peso curve and to remove that debt from the Central Bank and take it where it truly belonged, which was in the Treasury. And in 6 months we managed to do that, which is how we made this adjustment. It is also interesting because we took the wholesale inflation of 54% down, and today we truly have all indicators walking towards 1%. That is to say, last month, this month was 1.5%, the wholesale for the previous month was 0.8%, the basic basket is at 0.9%, the basic food basket is also at 0.9%, construction is at 0.9%. That is to say, all the numbers are showing deflation in dollars, given that the crawling peg was at 2%. Moreover, if one takes goods also in the CPI, it is at 1.5%. Thus, all are clearly below the 2% of the crawling peg plus American inflation. Therefore, one of the things they told us is that when we lowered inflation in this way, it would destroy the level of economic activity and that this would cause the level of activity to explode, collapsing it and that the number of poor and indigent people would explode.

The reality is that - when one looks at other historical experiences - adjustments of the magnitude we made have generated GDP declines of 15%. We, in the quarterly frequency, had a GDP with a statistical drag of -2.8%, and, according to the latest data, it is likely that the quarterly frequency will end with a decline of less than 2%. This means that there was expansion during the program. And indeed, that is real, because if I take the GDP data in monthly frequency, which is the monthly estimator of economic activity, from December to December, Argentine GDP grew by 4%. That is to say, we made the largest adjustment in history, lowered inflation, and, in addition, it was expansive. I believe that economics textbooks on fiscal adjustment should have a reserved place for the work that this man, Luis “Toto” Caputo, has done. But as I mentioned, not only that, but also that unemployment did not increase; we are creating jobs, which is something that - in Argentina - had not happened since 2011, but also, wages, in dollars, basically tripled for formal jobs, and poverty has fallen from levels of 57%, in the monthly frequency, to 33%, lifting 10 million Argentines out of poverty. Furthermore, on this, I want to make a note, a footnote that seems very important to me while being in this institution. Recurrently - during my journey to the national deputy bank and my path to the presidency - I have quoted, to the point of exhaustion, a work from this institution on the inefficiency of public spending, which showed that the worst area in the world was Latin America and that the worst of all was Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz Argentina. I say, this must be a mistake. I do not usually quote literature; I usually quote operas. But well, today I made a mistake. But, in that sense, Argentina had technical inefficiency equivalent to 7 points of GDP. In the meeting - that I just had, with Ilan and other members of the institution, they just told me that we have reduced it by half. So you have three and a half points to go down. But I think there is something interesting about this experience that we can tell, and that is why having made such an adjustment was not recessionary. This seems very important to me. And the adjustment was not recessionary, basically, because the adjustment fell on the State. The adjustment fell entirely on the State, and that means that when you have a parasite in the body, you do not kill the body; you have to kill the parasite. Well, we are willing to fight the parasite as much as possible. In that sense, we do not stop believing that the State is a criminal organization that lives off a coercive source of income, which is taxes. In other words, no one pays taxes voluntarily. That is why one of the things we maintain is that, to the extent that we prove that growth is permanent, we will lower taxes. And, in fact, we have just eliminated the PAIS tax, which was a tax that collected a lot. We have lowered the withholdings, we have fully eliminated them for regional economies, we have temporarily lowered them for traditional crops, and, in addition, we have made progress in eliminating many tariffs and taxes. So we are also making progress in that sense. And so, now having said all this, the point is, well, okay, stabilization is on track, and what about growth? It is true that there is a part that is cyclical recovery. Today we are facing a cyclical recovery, where, basically, stocks are being rebuilt, and, with the recomposition of real wages and pensions in real terms, that was driving demand. But there are other elements that contribute to long-term growth. On the one hand, I would say the issue of having made the adjustment we made. Those 15 points that the economy had in fiscal deficit represented a lower level of savings and lower investment possibilities. Therefore, the fact of having made the fiscal adjustment and moving the State out of the way means that, basically, savings are recovered so that the private sector can invest. That is to say, it is false that we need to exit the capital controls to be able to grow. Because, basically, given the fiscal shock we committed, that means there is a lot of savings to finance the private sector. Today banks operate as banks, not as a lifeline for the public sector. Not only that, but we also made structural reforms. The structural reforms we made in DNU 70 and in the Bases Law are 800 structural reforms, that is, eight times larger than the reform that Menem made, which was the largest reform in Argentine history.

That is why, if the Menem government was the best government in Argentina, which was structural reforms and a successful stabilization program like convertibility, we have already carried out, in just one year, with 15% of the Chamber of Deputies and 10% of the Senate, a structural reform eight times larger and, in addition, we have built a successful stabilization program. More successful than convertibility because today we have better results in terms of inflation in dollars; we are in deflation, without having fallen into a prior hyperinflation, without having expropriated, without price controls, without controlling the exchange rate, and, in addition, reconstituting tariffs. That is why I always say that, in addition, this is the best government in history. Not by my merit, but by the merit of the enormous ministers I have, because I am proud of each one of them for the enormous task, where I only have to set the course, but they implement it, which is a pleasure.

That said, but it did not stop there, because - starting in the middle of the year - Dr. Federico Sturzenegger joined the team explicitly, and we created a Ministry of Deregulation. And well, Federico is having a process similar to the one “Toto” has with me. Let’s say we have a symbiotic relationship; the same is happening with Federico. So, in that first half year that Federico was with us, which is the second half of last year, he removed 900 regulations, that is, which are also like structural reforms. That is to say, we did, in truth, 1,700 structural reforms. But that is not all, because now I am going to tell you an internal anecdote. Federico is implementing what is called the Chainsaw Plan 2.0, which is to start addressing issues, to now make another reform of the State. Remember that when we took office there were 18 ministries, which were actually 24, and we brought it down to 9. Now we are at 8 and want to reduce more secretariats and more dependencies. So, in the first half of January, I gave my entire team vacation. They all returned in the second half of January, and in the first days of February, Minister Sturzenegger came to visit me at the Olivos residence. And then, he expressed to me that he was extremely concerned about the slowness with which we were acting. And then, for example, he suggested redefining some legal areas to give more dynamism and agility to the reforms. Federico's argument, being a minister who brings me joy every day with all the things he breaks in the State… So I said: "Oh, how distracted I was, that I did not realize that I was having few joys." So, what did I do? I went and counted how many deregulations he had done in two weeks. Two weeks, how many do you think he did? He was angry because things were stuck: 65. In 15 days he removed 65 regulations and said we were going slow. How can I not be happy with my ministers? They are all a machine for gaining economic freedom all the time. And I warn you that this will continue. There is something very nice, which is decree 25, which just came out a few days ago, where the different ministries are urged to create a digest. This is a work of art. Now, when you see it, you will see the shock. Argentina has 42,000 laws. Is that right, Manuel? Or 47,000? 42,000 laws, 70,000 decrees, and 220,000 resolutions and circulars. Obviously, resolutions and circulars can be eliminated by a ministry, I can eliminate decrees by decree, and some laws, due to the Bases Law and the DNU, I can remove by special powers. So, what we are proposing is that each ministry make a digest of what it uses. And guess what we are going to do when we have the digest, which has 30 days to be made. Everything that is not in the digest will be eliminated. Why? Because you will find that there are things that one does not even know exist. One only knows that there is a beneficiary. For example, it is very interesting what happened to us with scrap. Scrap could not be exported. It was prohibited to export scrap. Of course, then… But scrap has a price. So, that scrap remained in the domestic market, and the price of scrap fell. It was very cheap. Of course, that benefited one company and harmed all those who had scrap. I say, it seems that this is not something in favor of freedom. So, what did we do? We eliminated that regulation. Obviously, now scrap has a market price. But, well, the company that was harmed is a very large company; it is a very large economic group, and it sent its army of economists to demand devaluation and try to destabilize the economic program. Or, for example, I don’t know, the problem of a watermelon exporter, who wanted to export watermelons to Paraguay, and had an agreement with the Paraguayan businessman to export the watermelons. But it happens that Argentine regulations told him how he had to export the watermelons, and that was not useful to the Paraguayan businessman; it was useful in another way. So, what did this man have to do? He had to do it as Argentina authorized, load them onto the ship, and inside the ship, he changed everything to adapt to what the Paraguayan businessman needed. That was total inefficiency. We lifted that regulation, and, obviously, some little kiosks in the middle fell, and some got angry, but the watermelon producers are happy now. And the Paraguayans too. Because now, in addition, they receive them cheaper.

Not only that, we continue to advance in what has to do with tax reduction. And there are, then, two more issues I want to point out. One is how we have changed the paradigm of social assistance in Argentina. We do not have the Ministry… I don’t know what it was called before, but all those names are blocked in my brain.

We decided to create the Ministry of Human Capital. The Ministry of Human Capital has a whole connotation in economic and social terms. In social terms, it is: I am not going to give you the fish; I am going to teach you to fish. And if you have a company that catches fish, even better. And, basically, what it does is provide assistance and care for those less fortunate in the family. That is why there is an area for childhood and family, to provide support when they are born, and that is linked to health, linked to education, and linked to work. So that people regain the dignity of being able to earn their bread with the sweat of their own brow and not by stealing it from others. And this is being a revolution not only because the social policy that has provided support at the most complicated moment of the adjustment is working. In addition to having taken away the thefts from the piqueteros and the managers of poverty. But also because we are returning dignity to the most vulnerable sectors and providing the tools for them to escape this misery. That is to say, it is a Ministry that, when it is fully successful and at its maximum point, disappears.

And the other is the Ministry, which is led by Dr. Sturzenegger, and basically, the central axis is that if you look at the history of humanity, at least since the year zero of the Christian era, GDP per capita increased by approximately 50% between the year zero and 1800. But from 1800 onwards, while the population multiplied by 10, GDP per capita did so by 15 times. Up to the year 2023, which is the latest data from the Angus Maddison series. So, in that sense, the question is that the counterpart of that is increasing returns. Now, if we look at it in terms of microeconomic analysis, that means that if I want to put it strictly technically, I have a problem of non-convex structures. Or if we put it in more understandable terms for microeconomists or those who do general equilibrium, I have a problem of concentrated markets or the most polar case would be monopolies. And the problem lies in that when I regulate monopolies and want to make them resemble competitive companies according to the neoclassical paradigm, what that ends up doing is killing increasing returns and, consequently, by killing increasing returns, it causes the economy to stop growing.

So, to the extent that we pass the chainsaw to regulations, what we are doing is not only gaining economic freedom, but we are also gaining economic growth. And all of this stems from the fact that, from my point of view, neoclassical analysis is wrong. For those who want to see this, I suggest reading the article by Murray Newton Rothbard called "Monopoly and Competition." An article that was very revealing for me because when I read it, I had been teaching microeconomics and general equilibrium for 25 years and I discovered that monopolies are not bad, unless they are armed by the State. That article was so revealing that I not only became a libertarian liberal but also an anarcho-capitalist. Philosophically, I continue to do so. This means I will not relent in bringing the State to its minimum expression and returning freedom to all good Argentines to the maximum until the last day of my government. Thank you very much and long live freedom, damn it!

HOST.- We had a lot of fun, that's for sure, with the examples of the watermelon and the octopus. I thought the octopus was the one with many hands. And that you were going to use it for the State.

PRESIDENT.- I will give you more applications.

HOST.- But the important thing here is to think about how we can use this case here at the IDB for the conversations we have with our 26 countries: a fiscal consolidation, a fiscal adjustment that is expansive, an adjustment that simplifies and gives the conditions for the private sector to enter. And the last point is: how do we ensure that we truly have sustainable growth? Because when we talk to heads of state and tell them: "We are going to make an adjustment of five, six, or 15%," they then tell us: "I won't survive." And they specifically say: "How do I respond to the head of state so that we know that private sector growth is going to come?"

PRESIDENT.- Well, the first point is: the adjustment should not fall on the private sector; it should fall on the public sector. The magic is there. Second, we need to have conviction about this. I will tell you what happened in the first cabinet meeting. I had already agreed with Minister Caputo that we were going to mercilessly pass the chainsaw over the public sector. And, in that context, we also planned the mechanisms for social containment and others for the transition. So, when we went to the first cabinet meeting and I laid out the guidelines, at the back of the meeting were all the lawyers, and they told me: "That can't be done." Well, then I said to them... It was about 40 degrees; I don't know what the equivalent would be in Fahrenheit, but it was very hot. And then I said: "The question is, if I go to the corner and ask the ice cream vendor, what answer will he give me? 'It can't be done.'" So I told them: "The truth is that I don't care what you tell me, and the only answer I accept is for you to tell me how to do it." Because for you to tell me 'it can't be done,' I mean, anyone can respond 'it can't be done.' And I think that changed the way the ministers began to see the situation. And the other very important thing is to make clear the direction one wants to go, and then understand the fallacies contained in economic theory. Can I be rude? That public works generate growth and jobs is bullshit. That is a lie. Because the reality is that, to carry out a public work, I have to finance it. And if I finance it with debt, those are future taxes. I punish our children, our grandchildren, and so on. If I finance it with monetary emission, I punish the vulnerable with inflation. If I finance it with taxes, I punish the present generations. Moreover, not only that, but since I am taxing them, that work that is being done there and that is visible is actually destroying other works and jobs in other places. But also, people's preferences were not to have that road; they wanted to have other things they had chosen. So, I am robbing them. I am giving them goods they do not want. Therefore, I have a loss of welfare, in terms of lower utility. And let's not forget that there is also the problem of public spending leaks. Therefore, what needs to be taken into account is that the Government is part of the problem and not the solution. There is nothing worse than a politician coming and saying: "I am the Government; I come to help." It is horrifying. When you see a politician doing that, run away, because the only thing they will do is rob you. So, the central issue is to understand all these fallacies on which the lie called the State is built. Look, keep this in mind: the State is a criminal organization. That is, you cannot tell me that with more thieves in society you are better off than with fewer. That is, the State is worse than the mafia. Because I ask you: How many times have common thieves robbed you over the past year? None. Well, the State robs you every day when it collects taxes. So, how can it be that something so sinister...? If I take it out, will I be worse off? If I take it out, I will be much better off. Because, on top of that, the State is the stationary thief. That is, and moreover, it is on a larger scale. And it has fewer codes than the mafiosos. So, the day it is unmasked, the day people decide to take the red pill and get out of the Matrix, they will understand that the State is the problem and not the solution. And surely we will have many more anarcho-capitalists.