Words of the President of the Nation, Javier Milei, at the dinner of the Libertad Foundation.

Argentina Javier Milei · President of Argentina

25 April 2024 · Dinner of the Libertad Foundation

Context
Milei addressed the Libertad Foundation dinner in April 2024, presenting his economic vision on combating inflation and explaining monetary theory to a prominent political audience.
Main themes
Inflation in Argentina, monetary theory, nature of money, central bank criticism, barter and indirect exchange, nominal anchor, monetary policy, exchange rate, Keynesian economics critique, economic reform
Duration
~56 min
95th percentile
Words
6,696
95th percentile
Sentences
338
96th percentile
Readability
66
95th percentile
Grade
8.8
10th percentile
Syntax
2.95
41st percentile
Vocabulary
1.97
8th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 81%74%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Institutional 5%5%
  • Social 5%4%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

338 sentences in 35 paragraphs

Hello everyone. If not, it’s not me, well good evening. Thank you very much to the Libertad Foundation for allowing me to be part of this meeting, which is also honored by so many personalities such as President Macri, President Lacalle Pou, President Aznar, Dr. Bullrich, genius Patricia. So, obviously, when one has to choose a presentation, I say one has to get used to and adjust to the needs of the moment and the place where one is, and given the discussion that is so present in Argentina today about the issue of inflation, about the discussion of the exchange rate and those kinds of issues, and given that I am in front of a qualified audience, an audience that is used to receiving economic analysis, the intention of this talk is basically to tell you how our vision is on how to face, attack, and exterminate once and for all the problem of inflation in Argentina, which has a clear starting date, which is when that nefarious institution was created that is at Reconquista 266 called the Central Bank of the Argentine Republic.

Therefore, the presentation is called “Money, Prices, Monetary Policy, and Inflation.” Another thing I discovered in my interaction with various local economists is that the vast majority of local economists, professionals and renowned, have no idea about something so important in this, which is the problem of the nominal anchor and because they basically do not understand what money is. That is to say, Keynes in that nefarious treatise called “The General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money” caused such great damage that we are still, let’s say, inheriting some problems of conceptual framework definition, which makes us economists make mistakes so much and so often. In fact, just in the car, we were reviewing a joke that said, “In the last five recessions, how many did economists predict? Nine.” I mean, beyond the jokes about this, it is essential and key to understand what money is. I mean, what one realizes is that they discuss the problem of inflation and do not understand what money is.

There is the colossus of, there is Federico Sturzenegger. What a pleasure, I just saw him. Thank you, Federico. So, basically what I am going to do is an introduction about what money is and from there, let’s say, I will derive the monetary nature of inflation, I will demystify some types of issues that are going around, and then I will discuss the current situation, about the enormous work that Luis Caputo, Santiago Bausili, and all his team are doing, of whom I am truly, deeply proud.

So, the first thing is, if there were no money, how would the economy be? Well, the economy would be a barter economy where goods are exchanged for goods. Now, in a tiny society, that is not initially a problem, but in a larger society, it is a problem. Because you have a problem called double coincidence, that is, you have to find someone who wants to buy what you have and at the same time, let’s say, match, that is, also want what you have.

Therefore, that process becomes very, very difficult. But aside from the fact that this process is extremely difficult, a second problem arises, which is the problem of indivisibility. Because yes, I may want to buy bread, the baker wants to buy the service of economic analysis, but let’s say, the amount of kilos of bread that he has to give me for me to talk to him for an hour about economics does not match, at least today and after my time in the presidency much more, because I have to keep working afterwards. So now, in the face of that situation, man did not stay crying. I mean, it’s not that he sat down to cry in a corner, saying and crying about the problem of double coincidence and indivisibility. He found a way. And he found a way and discovered that there were goods that were exchanged much more than others. That is to say, it is not that he bought those goods that were exchanged a lot because he initially wanted to have them, but that he acquired them to be able to use them as an indirect means to buy other goods.

That is to say, the idea of the good of indirect exchange. That is to say, and when the good of indirect exchange appears, what is appearing there is, precisely, money. That is to say, that good that serves as an indirect means of exchange, precisely there we find the appearance of money. So, for example, when man was nomadic, what was the first money that appeared? Livestock. Why? Because livestock was what they ate and as they were nomads, it allowed them to move with the livestock. Consequently, they used livestock as currency. Then man became sedentary, so they discovered that there were other more efficient ways to use money. One of the things that man consumed a lot was bread. So what did they start to use as an indirect means of exchange? Wheat. So it is not that they bought or sold wheat because they were interested in wheat per se, but that, in reality, they used it a lot because it was a good of indirect exchange. Now, not only that. Then, for example, when one says the term salary. And why was it salary? Because it was basically paid in salt. Why was salt so important? Look, if there were people who did very well in ancient times, it was the people who carried spices everywhere, because it allowed food to have flavor. Have you noticed what it is to eat food without any seasoning? It’s disgusting. I don’t know what’s funny about it, but try doing it. It’s a horrible thing, especially notice what happens when you go on a diet. There are some diets that are a little more complicated, especially the one about public spending.

More than applause, I say, we should be rejoicing that for the first time we are hitting hard on public spending, we are fulfilling Rothbard’s dream. It’s incredible, isn’t it? I mean, a real drop of 35% in public spending, come on guys, that’s getting the State out of the way. I mean, the real fiscal pressure is the size of the State. If we hit such a cut, come on, I’m giving you back freedom like crazy.

Moreover, going back to the topic of salt, why the tradition of giving salt to the other person, of putting it and not giving it directly into their hand. Because they say that if not, it would be bad luck. And how was the payment issue, I mean, the guy would come with a sack, imagine, then he would pay with a sack of salt. Imagine if when you were handling the salt, it fell and it was bad luck. It was an instant loss for sure. In that context, that’s why, let’s say, they supported the salt and weighed it and there the exchange was made. There have been other currencies, such as tobacco. Moreover, there is a story that Milton Friedman tells in one of his conferences, that says that in Germany, let’s say, after the Second World War, when hyperinflation came, they used nails, they used cognac and he says that it is the definition of liquid money that he had ever known. I mean, he had found the true M1. I mean, jokes from economists, don’t worry about it. Next time I’ll come with subtitles.

Now, what was the problem with all those types of money that had appeared? That they were commodities, that is, they had a use value as a commodity, but they also served to make transactions, and so that served as money. Or let’s say, when we work in microeconomics and we start in general equilibrium, we talk about numeraire.

Now, what is the problem with that type of currency? Well, one does not live in a single period. I mean, they could serve as a unit of account, they could serve as a generalized means of payment, but what happens? It did not preserve value. And as the economy, let’s say, fortunately is not of a single period, but is intertemporal, which includes several periods, it degraded over time. That is to say, as if it had a negative interest rate. So what is it that man discovered? Man sought metals. And that is how two currencies appeared, which are gold for large transactions and silver for smaller transactions. So, see that the most important thing about all this, I mean, why I tell this whole story of why money appears, how money appears, to understand that money is a good of indirect exchange.

And being a good of indirect exchange, what does it mean, that its demand is a derived demand. That is to say, I do not demand money to take it to the wooden suit, I demand money to make transactions. And basically, I want to use that money to finance a consumption path throughout my life. That is to say, that’s why I use money. Now, if I then the money has that connotation, that characteristic. What does the demand for money depend on then? And that’s where we start to encounter these problems. Because if I am defining it this way, the demand for money has as its counterpart the intertemporal consumption path. That is to say, my consumption program throughout my life. Now, and if I start to derive the demand for consumption of each of these goods, which is what will determine how the demand for money is countered, what does that demand for consumer goods depend on? And in the end, that demand for consumer goods will depend on what, may he rest in peace, Robert Lucas Jr. said, which depends on the deep parameters.

That is to say, it depends on preferences, it depends on technology, and it depends on endowments. I mean, therefore, if the endowments are given, the preferences are given, and the technology, let’s say, is a case, let’s say, without making any assumption about technological progress that is also given and if you want to assume it, let’s say, you will put it inside the model. In the end, as a physicist would say, under normal conditions of pressure and temperature, the demand for money should be something absolutely granite, which has as its counterpart my intertemporal consumption path that depends on the deep parameters that are given data.

This is, this is a very interesting topic because, I mean, what happens. Because, if then the real demand for money, which is this that I just said and that without the presence of that nefarious entity that issues little papers, I mean, should be something quite hard, granite. And that should equal the real balances. That is to say, the amount of money divided by the price level. So, notice that there you find the monetary theory of inflation, because you are going to determine that the price level will be given by the quotient between the money supply and the demand for money. And there when you increase the amount of money, what you are going to do is determine the price level. It is what is called the problem of the nominal anchor. Moreover, when you derive the demand functions for each of these goods, as they are homogeneous of degree zero, you determine the relative prices and by determining that money is the numeraire, what the Central Bank does is that all prices are determined in money. That is to say, it determines the nominal scale of the economy. That is to say, the famous nominal anchor. That is to say, the way in which I am anchoring the price level is by fixing the amount of money.

So, since we took office in December, the monetary base has been constant, despite the fact that we bought 15 billion dollars, despite the fact that our puts skyrocketed, despite the fact that we had to pay the remunerated liabilities, the contraction by BOPREAL and the contraction by fiscal surplus has been such that it compensated for all that and left the monetary base constant, that’s why inflation is decreasing. Later I will continue with the topics related to the present, but, I mean, when some professional economists say, I assume that some, let’s say, out of ignorance, others out of resentment, others because, let’s say, if they wanted to commit suicide, the best thing they could do is throw themselves from the highest point of their ego. I mean, they would end up like a fried egg, down. “There is no stabilization plan,” and how is it that the inflation rate is decreasing? What is it, magic? No. We kept the amount of money constant.

Moreover, I mean, when you configure a stabilization program, it basically has three central elements: you have a fiscal policy, you have a monetary policy, and you have an exchange rate policy. In the exchange rate area, we find ourselves with a gap of 200%. It’s incredible, because some economists appear saying “the exchange rate lag,” those same ones who say there is a problem of exchange rate lag are the same ones who said that the dollar should be set at 600 and had a higher inflation hypothesis. We set it at the equivalent of 1000 and we have less inflation. I mean, they could at least, I don’t know, be coherent to be not so intellectually dishonest.

That is the first, one of the things. The other part is the fiscal policy, zero deficit, what did they say? “No, it is impossible to achieve zero deficit in 2024” and we started to look at the numbers and said and we talked with Toto and he told me, I think we will reach zero deficit in March. For what. I got nobulis. Poor Guillermo Francos suffering. How are you Guillermo, how are you?

Throw the Basic Law away, do whatever you want, after all, with this, let's say with the program, we are going to achieve all this despite politics, and indeed we are doing it. And what do we find? That what was impossible we achieved in the first month. In January, we reached financial balance, that is, we had a primary surplus and we also paid the interest, so we achieved financial balance. So, what did the bunch of blunderers say, instead of recognizing that they messed up, "Nah, well, it's very little chainsaw and a lot of blender." I mean, ask what happened with public works. Ask what happened with discretionary transfers. Ask what happened with the intermediaries of the plans. Ask what happened with the number of public employees.

I think the chainsaw is a little bigger, in fact, most of the adjustment is chainsaw, and I will tell you something, I mean, sometimes the blender, if it becomes permanent, also in chainsaw, I mean, let that be clear then. The final chainsaw is a matter of time, until we finish stabilizing. Moreover, to those who say: "No, well, but you are not liberals, you raised taxes." Ah, did we raise taxes? I usually use a very interesting example to understand the theft that is monetary policy, which is the case of an economy that makes transactions in gold. Let's suppose we have an economy that makes transactions in gold coins and now a couple of my friends show up, a physicist and a chemist, and they bring me the formula to turn plastic into gold, so what do we start doing? We start buying plastic. So, what do we start doing? We start counterfeiting gold. The question is, if I had that gold stored in my house, or I have a self-esteem problem and then I want to brag that I have a whole house of gold and it is not gold, let's say it is fake gold, then I go and do all that. I mean, up to that point, there is no problem because I am not committing any fraud, up to that point there is nothing, I mean, the only thing I am doing is counterfeiting.

The problem arises when that fake gold, I put it into the economy as if it were good and when I do that, what is the problem? I am increasing the supply of gold and by increasing the supply of gold, the purchasing power of gold falls, that is, all prices expressed in units of gold rise, what is that called? Inflation. That is to say, where the real fraud is not inflation, the real fraud is seigniorage. It is the monetary issuance that is the real fraud, because I ask you, if you had a growing economy and the Central Bank issues according to the growth of the demand for money as a consequence of the growth of the economy, assuming that consumption was a constant fraction of income, I mean, everything is perfect in terms of the structure I used.

So, what happens? Inflation is zero, is there no fraud there? Yes, there is fraud, yes, there is fraud. So, I mean, of course when they want to calculate the inflation tax it doesn't add up. Because when they calculate the rate, it gives the inflation rate divided by one, plus the inflation rate. So, since it is zero, then it doesn't add up. In reality, there is fraud. Why is there fraud? Because if they had not issued, there would have been deflation, that is, deflation is something healthy. That is to say, deflation, I mean, in fact, for the classics who dedicated themselves to watching all day what was happening in the economy and then wrote, for them it was not a problem. That is why I emphatically recommend a wonderful book by Philipp Bagus, called Defending Deflation. What happens is that when there is deflation, there are some who win and there are others who lose. Well, yes, let's say, those who lose have more exposure and well, of course, I mean then, deflation is bad. But it is not bad because it actually derives from economic growth, it implies returning resources to the people.

This means that the real fraud is monetary issuance. This is very interesting, because the delinquent government that preceded us, in the four years of government issued 28 points of GDP, a bunch of thieves. Not only that, because of those 28 points of GDP, in the last year they issued 13 points of GDP. And if you consider between, let's say, direct issuance and indirect issuance, and if you consider that the monetary base, not the broad one, but the basic monetary base is 2.6% of GDP, they left us implicit, just in that a multiplication of the price level by five times. Not only that, they also left us a bankrupt Central Bank, where there was a ratio of remunerated liabilities of four to one. Not only that, but they also left us monetary surplus. Of course, when you did all the basic calculations, that gave that we were going to find ourselves with an inflation around 15,000%. I mean, that kid, the Soviet one, the one in the Province, "That was an exaggeration," he said, "that doesn't happen." And the reality is that when we, let's say, entered December, in the first week, prices were growing at 1% daily. That annualized gave 3,700% annually.

They say: "No, but if I add 1 plus 365 times, it gives me 360." I mean, they don't even know the calculation of how inflation works, which is exponential. That's how we are. Then when you take the first two weeks, because the previous government had left a lot of price controls and released them all just before we took office. There inflation accelerated to 7,500% annually. And there are some shameless people, there are colleagues, intellectually dishonest, who deny that there was inflation, a planted hyperinflation, who deny that there was a potential for hyperinflation around 15,000%. And when you take the wholesale inflation, the wholesale inflation for the month of December was 54%, that annualized gives 17,000. That is to say, we assumed with a wholesale inflation rate running at 17,000 percent and that inflation that was running at 17,000 percent, that is to say at 54% monthly, given the enormous work that my entire team is carrying out, today that wholesale inflation is 5%. That is to say, we reduced it by 90% at the rate at which the inflation rate grows and do not doubt that we are going to exterminate it. So, I had a whole part where I fought with Keynes, but I will omit it. Yes, because, let's say, I get a little dense, intense. I will try to maintain the forms. So, the first thing that is interesting.

Because, clearly, we have a stabilization program, a disinflation program. Because for some reason inflation is decreasing. It is not that it decreases by magic. Moreover, there is another central element of why the inflation rate decreases. One of the enormous things, which is worthy of admiration, is the work that Santiago is doing at the Central Bank and all his team, Santiago Bausili. Why is this so important? Because, look, when you have a bankrupt Central Bank, that is to say that the liabilities are worth more than its assets, the only way you traditionally correct the bankruptcy is through a tremendous inflationary flare, so that the monetary liabilities shrink. And the more bankrupt they are, the higher the inflation rate you need to balance the net worth. So, to the extent that you have a price level today, to the extent that you go to a bankruptcy of the Central Bank and need to liquidate that, it implies higher prices, higher inflation. So when you take the price level that leaves the balance of the Central Bank in equilibrium, regarding the price level it has today, you connect that, it gives you a line and the slope of that line is the inflation rate. So, as you start to clean the balance of the Central Bank, what you are lowering is the inflation rate. This is a very interesting topic. That is to say, the work that the Central Bank does is fundamental, the cleaning is fundamental to lower the inflation rate.

But what do you want me to tell you if there was one who said "you can't dollarize, if there are no noodles and no sauce, and you invite me noodles with sauce." He was wrong, but it is easier to throw garbage trucks of dung than to admit the mistake. In fact, one of the things, one of the things, look, let's say if those who are murmuring ate the glass, I'm sorry. Life is like that. In fact, notice that we had several proposals for dollarization. As we were advancing some fell off, others remained standing. The only one that remained standing is the one we proposed, which was to take the assets of the Central Bank. Sorry, to take the assets of the Central Bank and turn them into market securities, which obviously have a huge discount, yes, and with those securities put them against the dollars, and making all the corrections that those securities would rise in price and that offered a huge business. Well, I inform you that when we took office, the bonds were at 18 dollars, let's say 20 to round it off. Today the bonds are above 60, we received the country risk at 2900 today we are at 1150. That is to say, in addition, we are making a drop in country risk like few times seen in Argentine history. And you know what? That predicts that going forward the economy rebounds. That is why, let's say, they are so nervous. That is why they use noble causes to try to destabilize a government because they know they are going to lose and they won't come back.

Therefore, notice that when we received that monumental deficit of 15 points of GDP, 5 in the treasury and 10 in the Central Bank, today, between the adjustment we made in the treasury and the adjustment that the Central Bank has made, from 15 points we have reduced it to 13. Not only that. When the year ends, we will have returned to the private sector 15 points of GDP in savings. Do you want to know how the economy is going to grow? It is going to rise like a diver's fart. "But there is no nominal anchor," thank goodness. Well, that, let's say, there is an anchor, let's say the case of the nominal anchor that when you fix the amount of money. Obviously, it is not the only way to anchor. There are things that truly seem fun to me, no. Because economists come and say "no, well, because there is no comprehensive plan, because you should define the productive matrix for the next, let's say, I don't know, 5 years." What do you want, a five-year plan? I am not Leontief, I am not a communist. I am a libertarian liberal, I believe in freedom, I believe that this should be determined by entrepreneurs, not a fatally arrogant bureaucrat from an office. Or when they say "no, well, but you should set the path of prices, wages." I mean, again guys, I am a liberal, I believe in the price system. That is to say, you to determine, to be able to know what the price vector is, you should, again, know the preferences, the technology, and the endowments.

But if you also want to do it intertemporally, you have to do it from today until the end of history. And also, with which you have to know how the population is going to move, how preferences are going to move, how technology is going to move. Moreover, things that you previously thought were not in the endowments become endowments, or look if we, let's say, conquer Mars and bring back resources from Mars, there are a lot of issues. To be able to get all that right, one would have to be omniscient, omnipresent, and omnipotent. That is to say, you should be God. I mean, look, no matter how much it weighs on politicians, they are not God. I would tell you that they are worse than the average human being. Because when, look, when I entered politics, let's say, and after a while, a journalist asked me, somewhat aggressively, he said "well, but you who entered politics and keep complaining about politicians, what do you think now," then I told him that I was wrong, he said "you see that in the end they were not so good," no, no, I was wrong for the worse. They are much worse than I imagined. That is why the system of freedom works much better, because, let's say, to say that they are monkeys with knives is to insult monkeys. So, how am I going to be setting prices? "No, you have to set the path of prices," they are crazy. I am a liberal. It gives me hives to do that.

So, not only that. Not to mention, I imagine they could start looking for the reports they receive from many professional economists who said that the interest rate should be set at a positive real rate. Today, the ball of interest-bearing liabilities, we would have issued in the last three months, four monetary bases. The problem is when the ball explodes, Federico wouldn’t have appeared with the LEBACS, then with the LELIQS, and now it would be the interest-bearing liabilities. Which, by the way, the previous government was so friendly that they left us all the interest-bearing liabilities for one day. As you can see, it was easy. It’s so easy from the stands. The other day I was talking with Professor De Pablo and I acknowledged a mistake of mine, I mean from some time ago, and the mistake was, I had entered my Rothbardian Path, so I was intense. And every time we talked about economic policy, I would get angry because I saw it as very condescending. Professor De Pablo interviewed all the ministers of economy and presidents of the Central Bank since the mid-20th century onwards. That generated a very particular situation for me. In fact, from having lunch three to four times a month, we became somewhat more distant, to preserve the friendship. Even though we had watched World Cups together, we had spent holidays together. Professor De Pablo wisely surely said, “go, learn and come back.” And the other I acknowledged my mistake, because one of the things I always tried to do as an analyst was to try to incorporate the constraints. Well, now I discovered that there are more. I mean, it’s a little bit more difficult. So, I say, from the stands it’s quite easy. Because there’s something interesting, which is, you know what, look, you’re going to see a match of Argentina, the Argentina match is very nice, the flags, the chants, everything you want, it’s fabulous. But the goals are scored by Messi. That is to say, if you want to win, let’s say, you have to start scoring goals. I mean, and the truth is that I feel that I have several Messis inside my team. I feel that Toto is Messi, I feel that Patricia is Messi, I feel that Sandra is Messi, I feel that Diana is Messi, I feel that each one, I think Guillermo Messi, that all of them are a Messi in their position, to put it in some way. The truth is that I am very happy with the excellent team we have formed.

Let’s say, to do this you have to get involved. You have to get involved. Otherwise, the orcs will govern us. And another thing I recommend, let’s say, to keep in mind that the orcs understand it perfectly, but it seems that we liberals are not so smart and don’t realize, power is a zero-sum game. If we have it, they don’t. And that, yes, they understand. They can have López’s bags and they will continue to deny it. I mean, you’re going to find them stealing and they will deny it and we start “no because in reality” as an idiot said, “this is not a liberal government because it didn’t liberalize drugs.” Or that we didn’t lower taxes and it turns out that we are returning to Argentines 15 points of GDP in terms of no seigniorage. That is to say, well, if there is a substitution of taxes, but let’s say in the net, let’s say, public spending in real terms is falling. Let’s say what Rothbard would say, the true pressure of the State is falling. That is to say, I say, I am collecting less. Let’s say, I mean, in the end I will have fewer taxes because I have a smaller state. The other way to have a nominal anchor is by using what is called an inflation targeting system. But, I say, there, let’s say, the anchor is a more complicated thing, because in rigor, if you want to think about it in terms of the amount of money, you don’t have it. Because what is the problem? Because if I am fixing the interest rate, then I do not fix the amount of money, and if I do not fix the amount of money, I cannot fix the price level. So, I have what is called a nominal anchor problem. And that is resolved, in what way. When I have inflation expectations, by having, let’s say, determined expected prices, then if the expectations are anchored I can determine today’s prices, I can determine the demand for money and by determining the demand for money I determine the amount of money and the system is anchored. That yes, let’s say, you have to have the expectations anchored. Look, I believed that having a Central Bank that did things right, let’s say, was possible. Moreover, my great illusion was that when we had the best Central Bank in history, which was the one presided over by Federico, I believed that we could have a Central Bank until December 28, 2017. Let’s say, that they took it away and that was what wore down the return of Kirchnerism. So, in that sense, for me, let’s say the Central Bank, it’s just a matter of time, I will catch it.

Beyond this, what I want, then, now is basically to finish with what we have done. How we are managing to lower the inflation rate and basically again, as I said before, a zero-deficit program, where we attack public spending head-on, where, obviously, in the first part we overreacted and the equivalent adjustment. Did you hear the other day about the puppet? It was incredible. Saying “oh what an insignificant adjustment.” He left a deficit of more than 5 points of GDP, we brought it to zero two positive and if you take it in annualized terms, we made an adjustment of 7 points of GDP, and the shameless one says “insignificant result.” I tell you that, in the last 123 years of history, Argentina had a deficit in 113. This means that what we are doing is not so easy. On the other hand, the cleaning up of the Central Bank made that from having a quasi-fiscal deficit of 10 points of GDP, let’s say, today it is already at four and is on its way to three. That is to say, when the next inflation rates come and we lower the rate again, we will throw in another point.

So, when you compute what we adjusted in the Treasury and what we seek in the Central Bank, we have already adjusted 13 points of the 15 points. There is no historical record in the history of humanity of an adjustment of such magnitude in three months. But not only that, but if you look, both analysts and the International Monetary Fund, when we arrived were expecting an inflation of 250%. I mean, for Argentina. In an optimistic case. Well today the Fund expects that Argentina’s inflation will close this year at 150%. For it to close at 150% by the end of the year, the average inflation has to be 5.5. That is to say that by the end of the year it is clear that the inflation rate, given where we started, will be well below 5%. That is to say, we are achieving it. We are ending inflation. Moreover, not only that, but also, the Fund is usually very aggressive in projections. This time it fell short with the adjustment and fell short, let’s say, with the issue of inflation because it is falling faster. That is to say, whenever they seemed to be the bogeyman of the things they proposed, we are doing it much faster. On the other hand, there is another digression, let’s say, that has to do with the real exchange rate.

At the beginning of the presentation, I mentioned the issue of some who are very intellectually dishonest, saying that the exchange rate should be set at 600 and the inflation rate was higher. And now they complain about the exchange rate of 1,000 and they start “no because there is currency appreciation.” There is also, let’s say, a response to this, let’s say, also with much wisdom from Professor De Pablo. One thing is to do economics, another thing is to do arithmetic. And there are many people doing arithmetic and little economics. I warn that not everyone makes this mistake. Let’s say I spoil the result, what Arriazu says is right. Now I will explain. Arriazu says that Argentina, if it stabilizes given the fiscal structure it has, will coexist with a very appreciated currency.

In that context, this is not minor, if we have to coexist with a very appreciated currency because as international prices are given as long as the treasury does not want to get out of the way, the consequence is that it will be paid in terms of lower real wages, therefore if we want to raise and improve the quality of life of Argentines we have to attack the fiscal deficit, we have to attack public spending and not only at the national level, we have to attack it also at the provincial and municipal level, we have to sweep the treasury in all dimensions. This is, the source of our impoverishment, the source of people not having enough money, the source of so many poor, so many indigents and that there are a lot of Argentines starving is the fault of the damn politicians who do not want to lower public spending.

Going back and to close to the problems of the real exchange rate, which is a discussion that everyone likes to have, I say, the first problem is if, let’s suppose we look at the series, I say, what you are going to see is that, let’s say, the series looks like a roller coaster, but an endless roller coaster, I say the first thing I would say is, a series that has so much volatility, goes up and down, let’s say, it looks like the electrocardiogram of a guy who is running a marathon, I say, the first problem is, hey can someone explain to me what value it has to take an average measure? I say with all that standard deviation and with all that volatility can someone explain to me what sense it makes to take an average measure? It’s already a serious problem.

The second serious problem of that is to fix it at a moment in time and who said that was the equilibrium one? I mean, you realize that, before we talked about fatal arrogance because you had to know the price vector, that is to say, you had to know the price vector of that moment, for that we had to know the preferences, the technology and the endowments of the entire economy from today to eternity. Well, now incorporate the world economy, that is to say, now it is no longer enough to know all that for Argentina, I mean you have to know it for the whole world. That is to say, you cannot be so fatally arrogant and not only that, the nonsense, let’s say, is crowned in a superlative way, when also, let’s say, that would give you the power to explain the conditions of supply and demand of all goods in the whole world at a moment in time, this means that you can tell me, I don’t know, what the real exchange rate was on the date, I don’t know what is the one they use the most in the reports now? to say something, 2007, I say randomly, I don’t know, 1997, 1985, whenever you want, the question is: are the supply and demand conditions of all goods in the economy identically the same as they were at that moment to say that the real exchange rate has to be that same one?

I mean, we fall into the problem of fatal arrogance or we fall into the problem of furious imbecility, I don’t know, do you like idiotic centrism so much? Because since you want it, let them apply it and do it that way or let’s say what I suggest, take all the neoclassical theory, a lot of pieces, it has to be thrown back and we have to embrace Austrian economics again which truly embraces the ideas of freedom. So, thank you very much and I will tell you something, you know what? Despite the politics, we will achieve it! Long live freedom, damn it!