Words of the President of the Nation, Javier Milei, at the event for Industry Day, at the Argentine Industrial Union (UIA)

Argentina Javier Milei · President of Argentina

2 September 2024 · Industry Day event at the Argentine Industrial Union (UIA) · Argentine Industrial Union (UIA)

Context
Milei addressed industrialists at the Argentine Industrial Union on Industry Day in September 2024, debunking economic myths about state-led industrial policy.
Main themes
Industrial policy myths, state overprotection of industry, agriculture vs. industry false dichotomy, import substitution failure, fiscal deficit, economic liberalization, private sector development, exchange rate distortions, inflation, formal employment stagnation, macroeconomic stability, crony capitalism
Duration
~40 min
90th percentile
Words
4,770
90th percentile
Sentences
159
83rd percentile
Readability
45
49th percentile
Grade
14.2
69th percentile
Syntax
3.35
86th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
35th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 91%90%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Institutional 3%3%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

159 sentences in 27 paragraphs

Good morning everyone. To begin, I want to greet all the entrepreneurs present here on their day and thank them for betting on and continuing to bet on the country. Producing in a country with so many chronic problems - like ours - is undoubtedly a task worthy of recognition. I also want to thank the President of the Argentine Industrial Union, Dr. Daniel Funes de Rioja, for inviting me to speak before all of you on this very important day.

I want to take this opportunity to debunk two great myths that - for decades - have been used by politics to meddle deeply in the industrial sector and enrich themselves at the expense of all those who produce; myths that - to the detriment of all Argentines - were so successful that they became dogmas in public debate: the first is the one that labels the simultaneous development of the industrial sector and the primary sectors of the economy as incompatible. As I have said on another occasion - for 100 years, politics sold us the story that, in order to have a thriving economy, industrial development had to occur by trampling on the dynamic and exporting sectors, especially agriculture. But this has not always been the case, and I refer to the evidence, because the period of greatest industrial expansion in Argentine history was precisely during the agro-export model, and not - as some say - with the failed import substitution model backed by the state. It was the economic development generated by the private sector that was the origin of our first industrialization. The same happened - in the 1930s - when the Argentine market - naturally - developed to supply the demand that Europe, devastated and depleted after the crash of '29, could not meet, but - at some point - averaging the middle of the last century, politics decided that for the country to develop everything had to be produced here and began to arbitrarily manage the relationship between the different sectors of the economy, robbing one to give to others for social justice.

The industry became subordinated to the overprotection of the state, in the form of credit, subsidies, tax exemptions, customs barriers, and tariffs of all colors to compete in the local market. They said it was to industrialize the country, that the industrial sectors needed help to compete with imported manufactures. They promised that, over time, they would be able to compete genuinely, on equal terms, and that this would create more and better jobs. But - paradoxically - they became increasingly dependent on the state, which, in turn, depended on agricultural exports to finance all those benefits. Thus, a vicious relationship of tutelage was generated with the state, which we carry to this day. The consequence is that - to protect the industry - the agricultural sector was robbed, and that protection only generated an industrial sector addicted to the state. This is one of the roots of the structural economic crises we have suffered for so many decades.

One hundred years of insisting on these ideas ended - first of all - by ruining our export potential; punishing agriculture with obstacles and taxes and directly preventing the development of other exporting sectors, in which we should be global protagonists, such as the copper industry.

Secondly, they harmed all Argentines because they forced us to pay more for lower quality products, increasing the cost of living and reducing the capacity for savings and - consequently - the capacity for investment for all. And, finally - despite so much talk about industrial policy - they ended up directly harming a large part of the industry itself. Because, behind all those supposed good intentions that justified alchemies and experiments, which resulted in 113 years of fiscal deficit out of the last 123, they restricted the free buying and selling of foreign currency, suppressed the exchange rate, suppressed tariffs, and destroyed the relative prices of the economy, and were - along with Maduro's dictatorship - the only countries in the region with more than 20 points of year-on-year inflation for the last 15 consecutive years. Who can win in a country like this? No one. And the results are evident: Argentina has - practically - the same amount of formal private employment as it did fifteen years ago. Ultimately, no sector can do well if the whole of society is doing poorly; except - perhaps - for the political caste. What is worse, so much misery ended up imposing a different business model on many sectors, as it was no longer about thinking about how to produce more, better, and cheaper, but about seeing how to access the greatest number of advantages and perks possible from the state to survive. What I am trying to say with all this is that - the supposed sectoral development policies, at the expense of a shattered macroeconomy - are doomed to fail, and worse still, they are doomed to produce even more of the underlying problem. This point is central to understand, both for you who are in the trenches and for the economic analysts who live off commenting or asking for a development plan: everything that Argentines are used to hearing - in economic matters - is plain and simple a scam, that only serves to benefit a few; to the detriment of all.

I emphatically recommend a comment that is going around, from the brilliant Claudio Zuchovicki, about "The Man Who Counted." Don't miss it because it will clarify a lot about the scam that politicians have sold. Taking from some to give to others is not an economic policy, it is a theft that, on top of that, destroys the economy in the long run. So know that when someone talks to you about boosting industry while issuing money - by 13 points of GDP in a year - while suppressing the exchange rate, to a third of its market value; while authorizing imports, despite the lack of dollars, that person is not pro-industry, that person is a scammer, period. I tell you: do you know what the best industrial policy is? Having a good fiscal and monetary policy; honoring debts and recovering the country's credibility so that - from abroad - they trust that if they sell to us, we will pay them. Do you know what the best industrial policy is? Ending inflation, recovering economic calculation, and giving back to Argentines the gifts of stability.

We must return the future to ordinary Argentines; the possibility of looking ahead and planning, of saving and being owners of their own economic decisions. That is the best industrial policy. Think about how you prefer your buyers to be: families with saving capacity, who progress and can buy more and better, or impoverished families who have to advance consumption by buying the first thing they find - in 24 installments - because stocking up on goods is more profitable than saving in currency? Only if the whole of society does well can the industry do well sustainably. Moreover, you know that - for those who run a business - stability means freedom, or is the constant accounting of a regime of high and unstable inflation not a prison? It is a tremendous waste of energy; that energy that you spend today overcoming the obstacle of instability, tomorrow you will be able to invest in thinking about how to sell a better product at a better price. If the value of a company is measured according to the present value of its future cash flows, stability is a sine qua non condition for your company to be worth something.

There is no value without stability; there is no profit without stability; there is no growth without stability. I told you I wanted to dismantle two myths. The second is the worst of all and is adjacent to the previous myth: the myth that freedom in the economy is harmful to industrial development. No country has collapsed by opening up to international trade; all those that did have actually progressed, who could think of such nonsense? And the only thing that is harmful to industrial development is having a gigantic state riding on their backs. This administration is determined to reduce the Argentine cost in the entirety of the national economic life to improve the competitiveness of all productive sectors. We came to shrink the state to enlarge your pockets. Since we are talking about myths: the Argentine cost is like a mythological monster with many heads. The first of these is the financial cost, that is, the ability of economic actors to access cheap credit.

Do you know what the main factor affecting the financial cost is? The Country Risk, that Country Risk, which was around 2400 points on the day of the runoff, and - today - is around 1400 points, thanks to the monumental work being done by ‘Toto’ Caputo, Santiago Bausili, the giant Pablo Quirno, and all their team, who, by the way, last Friday launched their own online channel, where they comment on the country’s economic path and its objectives, in case anyone is interested in going to the sources and stopping depending on the information invented by envelope journalists. In that same Country Risk that rises every time the fiscal degenerates in Congress pass unaffordable laws without saying where they want to get the money from.

The first thing we did upon taking office, and against the opinion of the econochantas, was to align local interest rates with the international interest rate, adjusted for risk, which, obviously, given the devaluation jump, implied a negative real interest rate in pesos, and which allowed - in turn - the dilution and dismantling of the remunerated liabilities, which - by the way - regarding the fiscal feat we have accomplished, because we inherited a consolidated fiscal deficit of 15 points, between the Treasury and the Central Bank. They told us that making a 1 point adjustment of GDP in the Treasury was impossible. When we said we would reach zero deficit in the first year, they told us it was impossible, and - that group of giants in the Ministry of Economy - achieved it in a month. They certainly deserve credit for that. But since that was not enough, and there were 10 more points to resolve in the Central Bank - a topic that no one was talking about and that also seemed impossible to resolve - we solved it in 7 months. That is to say: in 113 years, out of the last 123, we always had a deficit; the ten years we had a surplus was because we were in default. What no one achieved in 123 years, which is a robust and real fiscal surplus, we achieved in the first month. And something that had no kind of solution in sight, which was the problem of remunerated liabilities and that everyone believed would end in an expropriation or hyperinflation, we solved in the market, in 7 months. Now that is what I call management.

Naturally, this made banks have to return to working as banks and lending capital to people and companies, instead of placing their capital in the Central Bank, further inflating the issuance of money to collect interest. Thus, all types of credit returned, including mortgage loans, generating an unprecedented boom in the real estate sector. A year ago, thinking of borrowing capital for 30 years seemed crazy, and - today - in the new Argentina, it is a reality. That is to say, when we started the government we talked about hyperinflation; today we talk about mortgage loans for 30 years and the return of credit; it seems unbelievable everything we have done in such a short time. The second head of this monster, which is the Argentine cost, is the labor cost. No company can compete in the world with these labor costs; labor costs that stem from outdated regulations that supposedly aim to protect workers, but all they do is destroy jobs.

Let’s see if it is understood once and for all, there is only one sustainable way for workers to be better every day: a state that protects the value of their money and a thriving sector that demands work. It doesn’t matter how many regulations they want to invent to protect workers, any regulation that undermines the value of the currency and the private sector's ability to generate wealth only generates more poverty. It must be understood once and for all: labor laws in Argentina are for the worker what the failed Rental Law is for tenants. I still remember all the criticism we received when we deregulated the rental market, but no one mentions, among all those econochantas, how the supply of properties offered exploded and how - in relative terms - the price of rents ended up falling dramatically. Could it be that they find it hard to assimilate, understand, or accept how powerful the market is?

The third head of the monster is somewhat misleading, as it is difficult to quantify because it is the invisible cost of the State: the bureaucracy, or - in other words - the cost of the machine that hinders; the opportunity cost represented by leaving work to waste time in an office and pay a nonsensical amount of fees; having to wander through the halls of public administration asking for stamp after stamp in order to be able to produce. Taxes are a clear demonstration of this phenomenon: in Argentina, we have about 190 taxes, of which 10 collect more than 90% of the total revenue. This means that there are about 180 taxes that do not even collect 10% of the revenue. These taxes cause us direct economic damage; their effect is almost marginal, yet they create obstacles, delays, paperwork, and a myriad of procedures that hinder economic activity in a country where making money is already an impossible task. Not to mention the kiosks that this implies.

That is why the task being carried out by the giant Federico Sturzenegger is so important, dismantling all kinds of regulations. From minute one, we are deregulating what we can, knowing that the path is filled with potholes and stones. Just last week, we announced the elimination of bureaucratic obstacles for the importation of steel, aluminum, and construction materials, and we have just eliminated bureaucracy related to the plastic and synthetic yarn industries. We are simplifying export procedures, such as the Temporary Admission Regime and the repo stock. In addition, we eliminated all discretionary controls for imports, including the SIRA system, which was a mechanism exploited by the previous administration to extort bribes from importers. In the new Argentina, no one has to bow down to any bureaucrat to import something, and we do all this in order to continue improving the competitiveness of our economy. Because those who produce must focus on producing and thus maximize their time, so they can then dispose of the fruits of their labor as they wish.

The fourth head, the most grotesque of all, because it represents the direct cost: taxes, that is, the State's incidence on the price of goods and services. This morning, we reduced the dreadful Country Tax by 10 points, a tax - created by Kirchnerism - under the pretext that it would be temporary, and yet they systematically extended it. It is interesting because many times, in Argentina, taxes have been created, it has been said that they were temporary, and then they were never lowered; welcome to the historical moment when an administration said it was creating it temporarily, and today it is being realized that this reduction has taken place, it is the first time in history, and not only that, but - in December - the dreadful Country Tax will be eliminated.

There is a phrase by Milton Friedman that said there is nothing more permanent than a temporary increase in public spending. And in reality, as you have to finance that, and this is interesting, I will quote an economist whom I do not find sympathetic, with whom I do not agree on everything he says, but this phrase is interesting. What Keynes said is that all public spending is always paid for. That is: either they will pay for it with monetary issuance, generating inflation and an inflationary tax, or they will pay for it with debt, which are future taxes, that is, defrauding future generations, our children, our grandchildren, and so on; or they pay it with explicit taxes, but it is always paid for. Therefore - given Friedman's phrase - there is nothing more permanent than a temporary tax, unless it is a liberal government that says it will lower taxes and - effectively - lowers them. That is, with us, that is over. Just as we lowered it by 10% this morning; in December, we will eliminate it completely, thus driving down the prices of imported products.

It is worth noting that among the imported products is a myriad of productive inputs, meaning that this measure helps to lower operational costs, improving the competitiveness of our industry. The geniuses of import substitution never realized that 80% of imports are productive inputs and that artificially raising their prices is only detrimental to the Argentine population? We must put an end to the creativity of bureaucrats, as all they achieve is to turn Argentina into a tax hell and a multiplication of kiosks. Just as we lowered the Country Tax, we have also eliminated export taxes on more than 5 categories of meat, we have also eliminated export duties for the automotive industry, and we have lowered the tax on automobile transfers; we reduced import tariffs on essential goods for various productive sectors, and we are just getting started; imagine what we are capable of if we improve our competitiveness. The list of scams, kiosks, and bureaucracies that complicated, and continue to complicate, the lives of Argentines is endless. Among them is the fifth head of the monster, which we have come to combat; the cost borne by all Argentines to protect the businesses of the friends of power.

A clear example is the case of Starlink, whose entry we allowed as soon as we took office, improving connectivity throughout rural Argentina at zero cost. Or the case of the vaccine against foot-and-mouth disease, whose importation we enabled - a few weeks ago - guaranteeing better competitiveness and cost reduction in meat production. But, just like the hydra of Greek mythology, when you cut off one head of this monster, another appears.

The sixth head of the monster - would be - what we call the cost of forced representation, that is, the State imposing a representation to which you must pay tribute, such as SADAIC, from which we cut off the scam last week, or the unions that move in luxury cars with drivers at the expense of their constituents who cannot even afford the bus, or the managers of poverty - who administered social allowances for the most vulnerable - and forced them to march for their own interests, under the threat of cutting off their benefits. I could spend the rest of the week enumerating things that need to be corrected, but I want to focus on the most important cost of all: the main head of this mythological monster that we have come to destroy: the fiscal deficit, that is, the great hidden tax.

Why a hidden tax? Because if the deficit is paid with monetary issuance, it ends up being paid with an inflationary tax, while if the deficit is financed with debt, it ends up being paid with future taxes, that is, a burden for future generations. If there is one thing we have made clear and will never tire of repeating, it is that we came to lower taxes, not to raise them, and that fiscal surplus for this administration is non-negotiable. That is the pact I made with the Argentine people and among ourselves when they elected us in the last elections, and that is what we have come to fulfill. That is, we are going to lower taxes, we are not going to negotiate the fiscal result, the subtitle is: we will continue to lower public spending. And what seemed impossible... public spending, in the National Treasury, in real terms - so far this year - has fallen by 30%. That is, to find cuts and adjustments - like what Argentina has done - can only be observed after World War II, and even so, our adjustment remains the largest in history. We still have a lot of work ahead, knowing that every step - no matter how small it seems - represents a burden we lift off the private sector. I would like to emphasize that none of this would be possible without the titanic work being done by the teams at the Ministry of Economy and the Ministry of Deregulation, who, like Hercules, accepted the heroic task of exterminating this multi-headed monster, this empowered Leviathan, which has been the cause of all our woes as Argentines. The only difference is that, instead of a sword, I have given them a chainsaw.

Little by little, all these efforts - both in correcting the macro and in structural reforms - are translating into tangible improvements in economic activity. Not to mention, last July was a record month for car sales; the highest sales recorded since 1995. In the energy sector, we have already reversed 13 years of deficit, with very encouraging projections for the coming years. The first 6 months - of this year - marked the highest trade surplus in a semester in the history of the country, and - in July - exports grew by almost 20% compared to the previous year.

If you want to see a clear example of what happens when the Argentine cost is reduced and freedom is increased, look at the Large Investors Incentive Regime (RIGI), which was regulated - a few weeks ago - despite having only 37 deputies and 7 senators, and we are already expecting investments of more than 50 billion dollars. Moreover, we improved payments to importers and - currently - we are paying 90% of imports versus the 15% that was paid in November 2023; that is, in 8 months we solved a record trade debt problem without global precedents. We could even say that we saved the sector, and still - to this day - with so many positive announcements, we have to listen to some fiscal degenerates talk about industricide. All this is nothing more than the skeleton of the most ambitious economic reform in history, and its most incipient consequences, but - I assure you - there is still much more to come. Remember that the largest structural reform in history was the one Menem did at the beginning of the 90s; the one we passed with the RIGI, plus the DNU, is 8 times larger than what Menem did, and we did that with 15% of the Chamber of Deputies; with 10% of the Senate, come and tell me if that is not political management... what skill, Francos. I want to take a moment - especially - to recognize and thank those present here for the generosity and good faith they have shown towards our country project. They have been patient, enduring these 9 months of government, which I know have been arduous, and they have been brave in supporting - along with the rest of the business chambers - when we celebrated the May Pact in Tucumán. Because they chose to support a deeply liberal program, and the principles to which they subscribed indicate an absolutely profound change of course. It also implies leaving behind harmful economic ideas and regulatory architectures that are deeply rooted in the Argentine productive and commercial fabric. And at this point, I believe there must be few people with doubts - for better or for worse - that what we say, we do. Ultimately, this great undertaking, which we call the war against the Argentine cost, will necessarily imply a transformation in the industrial sector. And many times, great transformations generate uncertainties and even fear, but we should not be afraid of change. Because 100 years of collectivism taught us something: that Argentines have the ability to draw water from stones and undertake, even in the worst conditions.

Or do you think it is a coincidence that, despite being the country in the region with the least foreign investment in the last 15 years, we are at the same time the one with the most unicorns per capita? If they can persevere in adverse conditions, with exorbitant taxes, absurd regulations, and extremely high costs, imagine what they can do without the boot of the State on their neck. I tell you: dare to innovate and compete because there is no force of nature greater than an Argentine wanting to make money, and with the increase in competitiveness that will come from the deep reforms we are undertaking, there will be a genuine industrial boom that we cannot even imagine yet. Does this mean that everyone will win? No, no, because that would be lying; in fact, Schumpeter spoke of creative destruction, so when these processes appear, some progress; others adapt, and it is true that some also fall by the wayside, but the system provides opportunities for reconversion, whether to seek revenge or to join elsewhere. Here we have to be honest; we are few and we know each other well. Many have enjoyed for too long the blessings that the Argentine people granted them in subsidies, exemptions, and tariffs against competition.

They had decades of hunting in the zoo, sheltered by the story of preparing their productive matrix and business model to be able to compete under their own law. Guys, if that wasn't enough, how much more can we demand from all Argentinians, who - at the end of the day - are the ones who pay with the sweat of their brow for those privileges? The change, for many, will mean - as President Menem used to say - learning to ride a bike without training wheels. Most will surely find their balance, precisely because the reduction in Argentine costs will offset the elimination of benefits that were harmful to society as a whole. Reality itself will separate the wheat from the chaff, or to put it in plain terms, those who are not in the game or who do not need the hustle to sell will do well. On our part, you have the commitment that we will do everything possible to ensure that the transition from the model of decay to the model of freedom does not leave any companies or workers behind. We will not leave you stranded. We will open the economy, when the structural conditions are right, so that competitive companies can be as competitive as possible. As I always say: our economic program has stages, which are assigned by the fulfillment of objectives, and we will not rush the timing of any decision if the conditions for that measure to succeed are not first in place.

To conclude, know that you will find in me an ally of the private sector. It is you, along with your effort, who push forward, generate wealth and jobs; the State does not generate either wealth or jobs; when the State generates wealth, it does so for politicians; when the State generates jobs, it does so for its friends. The only ones who generate wealth and jobs are entrepreneurs, betting their capital to obtain a profit, and when they achieve profits, it is because they are solving people's lives. When a businessman makes money, he is a social benefactor because he is solving people's problems, and the more money they make, the better, because it means they are truly social benefactors.

What we can do, and - we are already doing - is remove all the obstacles that stand in the way, with the vision of making Argentina the freest country in the world, because Argentina, Argentinians, and their companies have everything necessary to compete on equal terms with the best. We know how to do it, and I have no doubt that we will achieve it.

So may God bless the Argentinians and may the Forces of Heaven accompany them. Long live freedom, damn it! Thank you very much.