Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the opening of the Bellevue Forum "What Holds Europe Together?" on November 26, 2013, in Berlin:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

30 November 2013 · Bellevue Forum "What Holds Europe Together?" · Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed the opening of the Bellevue Forum in Berlin on November 26, 2013, to discuss the foundations and challenges of European unity amid ongoing economic crisis.
Main themes
European unity and identity, European financial and economic crisis, European integration, sense of collective European identity, democratic legitimacy, solidarity and trust, nationalism and Euroscepticism, institutional reform, intergenerational perspectives on Europe, Germany's responsibility in Europe, economic convergence in the Eurozone
Duration
~12 min
41st percentile
Words
1,387
41st percentile
Sentences
85
55th percentile
Readability
51
67th percentile
Grade
10.1
22nd percentile
Syntax
2.75
17th percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
41st percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 26%26%
  • Geopolitical 25%25%
  • Ceremonial 20%20%
  • Economic 16%16%
  • Social 13%13%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

85 sentences in 19 paragraphs

A warm welcome to Schloss Bellevue!

Today, we will once again witness a transformation, as we often do here. Suddenly, the castle becomes a forum, a place for open discussion, a meeting of people who have something to say. You may well imagine this under the concept of the Agora. It may look a bit different here than in a marketplace, but today, neither origin nor hierarchy matters in our encounter. It is about arguments, about the better argument. We want to exchange opinions and develop ideas. And we want to learn from each other.

Reflecting on Europe has a tradition in this house. I began this winter in this room with a speech on Europe, and we have given further space to the topic by meeting here with students to discuss the perspectives of Europe.

The echo of my speech and the event with the young people made me feel that the European Union does not leave people completely indifferent. Many feel that there is a total distancing from Europe as a great unifying project in the crisis. But that is not the case, even though we are in a difficult phase. By the way, I am pleased that I will meet some of the young people again later. There will surely be a continuation of some of the conversations that have begun.

The topic we have set for today is indeed challenging. And it is as complex as it is relevant: What holds us together in Europe? But what also drives us apart? Is there already something like a sense of "we," a "we-identity" of Europeans? On what normative and cultural foundations can we build if we want to shape Europe together? What responsibility does our country, does Germany, bear in this process?

Today, we will address more current issues that have emerged anew in the crisis. Because one thing is clear: The European countries cannot agree on one comprehensive reform concept. That is quite evident. There is also no single European narrative that all Europeans could agree upon. This element of a common, identity-forming narrative, which is so important for many peoples in determining their identity, we do not have for all of us together, at least not yet.

The European Union is viewed from very different perspectives, varying from generation to generation, and also from country to country. Among the ambassadors who are our guests this evening, some represent countries that have been involved from the very beginning. Others represent countries that joined late but have been part of it for more than ten years now. This is an example of these different perspectives. By the way, personal experiences with limitation and unboundedness also play a significant role in how we relate to the project of Europe.

The financial and economic crisis has posed the greatest challenge to the European Monetary Union. This has become a truism, but we are not done with this problem when we name it. Even if there are some positive news from certain crisis countries, where very tough reforms are being implemented or partially implemented, we must say: The crisis is not over. It would even be reckless to claim otherwise. Because banks, state debts, and the competitiveness of the Eurozone will continue to occupy European governments and societies.

There is still much to be done, both at the national and European levels. We actually need a new beginning. But since there is no vision accepted by all peoples, we currently stand at a threshold, we are stagnating. We need, as we all see, new jobs in Europe, we need sustainable growth, we need progress towards lasting economic convergence in the Eurozone. And we face the difficult problem of how we can strive for common European solutions while the willingness for further European integration decreases, not only among the rulers but mainly among the populations. One thing is clear: Without the populations, it simply cannot work.

We must take economic and political concerns seriously. If we do not, skepticism towards the Euro and Europe will thrive all the more intensely. Already, in some states, anti-European parties have emerged, which have varying degrees of support. Nationalistic resentments, which we thought had long disappeared, are resurfacing from the depths of history.

I know that what I am briefly hinting at and sketching here is only a snapshot of a picture. While some complain about the distant "spaceship Brussels" and turn away in anger, others are engaged in further steps towards integration, for ambitious institutional reforms that are meant to enable both: effectiveness and democratic legitimacy. This is how it is today in our Europe: fear and rejection, courage and enthusiasm exist side by side, often in close quarters.

We Europeans must not let ourselves be discouraged. We all, the citizens, not just the politicians, bear responsibility for strengthening what unites us. What I wish for is empathy and mutual interest. Only in this way can trust grow, and only in this way will solidarity remain possible. What I wish for is that we discover and productively utilize the creative energy that arises from our diversity.

We Europeans should also not let ourselves be unsettled. Despite all upheavals, we stand on the firm foundation of a common history. Our deep cultural ties act as ligatures, as Ralf Dahrendorf once expressed it. Human and civil rights are not only binding; they also connect us. Economic relationships have grown just as much as private friendships. The common law of the European Union also gives us a solid framework. In addition, there is the shared conviction that we need effective political structures beyond the nation-state to solve cross-border problems.

When we discuss Europe here, it is of course not an end in itself. Next year, as we all know, a new European Parliament will be elected, so important European political decisions are on the agenda. I thank you for wanting to get involved and trying to help shape Europe, each in your own way!

And I would like to explicitly encourage you to continue to patiently explain the procedures and institutions of the European Union and to actively participate in the discussion about any necessary corrections. I know this is exhausting and laborious and fraught with controversy. But it is all the more necessary the more complex the political structures become. And it is worth it if we want to achieve our goal, which I described in my speech in February: a democratic Europe that alleviates citizens' fears and grants them opportunities for participation, in short: a space with which citizens can identify.

Those of us who work professionally with Europe, such as politicians, journalists, scientists, or teachers, also bear a bit of a responsibility – and I do not exempt myself from this at all: We all have to advocate for Europe, and we have a lot of educational work to do. Europe must not become a project of the technocratic elite.

Now to this evening: I am pleased that we have five renowned intellectuals as our guests, who are not only creative but can also articulate their thoughts vividly and understandably. They come from five very different member states of the European Union: Bulgaria, Germany, France, Greece, and Italy. So we have, if you will, a European public sui generis here. What unites these five scholars, publicists, and politically engaged individuals is their passion, their eagerness to contribute. And I am particularly fascinated by the diversity of their ideas.

Ivan Krastev, for example, has dealt with the question of what Europeans can learn from the collapse of the Soviet Union. Angelo Bolaffi advocates, referring to Antonio Gramsci, for a hegemonic role for Germany, whatever that may mean. Loukas Tsoukalis calls for a New Grand Bargain for Europe. And Sylvie Goulard has co-authored a book whose title deliberately alludes to Alexis de Tocqueville: De la Démocratie en Europe. And Daniela Schwarzer, finally, wishes for, among other things, an effective economic government for the Eurozone.

Our moderator is Ms. Petra Pinzler. I am very much looking forward to the discussion, and I am sure that I can learn a lot from you. Perhaps others here in the hall feel the same way. Therefore, I will now hold back, I will sit down and listen. The presidential monologue is over, the Bellevue Forum is open!