Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck on the first Day of Remembrance for the Victims of Flight and Expulsion on June 20, 2015, in Berlin:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

25 June 2015 · First Day of Remembrance for the Victims of Flight and Expulsion · Berlin, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed a Berlin ceremony on June 20, 2015, marking Germany's first official Day of Remembrance for victims of flight and expulsion after World War II.
Main themes
Flight and expulsion of Germans after World War II, refugees and displaced persons, Day of Remembrance for victims of flight and expulsion, German guilt and suffering, humanitarian empathy, population transfer, historical memory, World Refugee Day, homelessness and belonging, Allied postwar policy
Duration
~40 min
90th percentile
Words
4,791
90th percentile
Sentences
211
90th percentile
Readability
44
46th percentile
Grade
12.6
53rd percentile
Syntax
3.15
66th percentile
Vocabulary
2.27
67th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 64%63%
  • Geopolitical 21%21%
  • Institutional 9%9%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

211 sentences in 70 paragraphs

Today, we want to talk about the uprooted.

About refugees and displaced persons, those who have been forced to emigrate.

About the homeless of the past and the homeless of today and tomorrow.

About people who are no longer there and not yet fully here.

About people who miss something and at the same time are glad not to have to live where their longing directs their thoughts.

Today, we want to talk about the uprooted.

About people – regardless of whether they are black or white, young or old, man or woman, Christian, Jew, or Muslim – about people who all share the same painful experience deep in their souls, which the writer Jean Améry, a refugee from Nazi Germany and survivor of Bergen-Belsen, summarized in a simple formula that is comforting for some and oppressive for others: “One must have a homeland in order not to need one.”

For the first time, Germany is officially commemorating on a nationwide day of remembrance the millions of Germans who were forcibly displaced from their homeland at the end of World War II. For the first time, Germany is also officially observing the International World Refugee Day, as it was established by the United Nations General Assembly fifteen years ago. In a very existential way, the fates of then and now belong together – the grief and expectations of then and the fears and hopes for the future of today.

I wish that the memory of the refugees and displaced persons of the past could deepen our understanding of the refugees and displaced persons of today. And conversely: Engaging with the uprooted of today could foster our empathy for the uprooted of the past.

People have been marginalized, persecuted, and displaced since time immemorial. From history, we know the conflicts between settled people and nomads, between locals and newcomers. And in the nation-states of the 19th and 20th centuries, minorities often appeared as potentially disloyal, as foreign bodies to be assimilated or exchanged, to be expelled or even exterminated. At times, politics even viewed population transfer as an effective means of conflict resolution.

The so-called “population transfer” of millions of Germans from East Prussia, Pomerania, Silesia, Bohemia, Moravia, from the Batschka and many other regions in Central and Southeastern Europe also appeared to the Allied leaders Churchill, Truman, and Stalin as an adequate response to the death and terror with which Nazi Germany had engulfed the continent. However, when the Potsdam Agreements in August 1945 created the legal basis for this, facts had already been established: millions of Germans had already fled from the German East, from Poland, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, Yugoslavia, and Romania. And what was supposed to happen “in an orderly and humane manner” had turned into a nightmare in reality.

First, they fled from the war. In icy cold, convoys of women, children, and the elderly struggled over congested country roads and fragile ice, shot at by low-flying aircraft and overwhelmed by the front. Overloaded refugee ships sank in the Baltic Sea after being hit by torpedoes and bombs. Countless women were raped.

Then many of those who remained in the old homeland became victims of hatred and retribution: disenfranchised, dispossessed, arrested, mistreated, sent on death marches, murdered, interned, forced into labor, first seemingly “wild,” then supposedly “orderly” displaced, and deported as “living reparations” to labor camps in the Soviet Union. The last returned only in 1955.

“As long as the conscience of humanity should ever become sensitive again,” declared a great humanist, the British-Jewish publisher Sir Victor Gollancz in 1947, “this expulsion will remain the immortal shame of all those who instigated it or who acquiesced to it. The Germans were expelled, but not simply with a lack of excessive consideration, but with the highest degree of brutality imaginable.”

Hundreds of thousands of people died due to military actions, disease, hunger, rapes, and also due to exhaustion and forced labor in the post-war period. In total, twelve to fourteen million Germans lost their homeland at the end of World War II due to flight and expulsion. The population in those areas that would later be called the Federal Republic of Germany and the German Democratic Republic grew by nearly 20 percent.

We should be particularly aware of this today: flight and expulsion not only change the lives of those who are received but also the lives of those who receive them, not only that of the “new” but also that of the “old” residents of a country or region.

The memory of the flight and expulsion of the Germans has almost always been difficult and emotional in our society. For our attitude towards the suffering of the Germans was and remained intertwined with our attitude towards the guilt of the Germans. It took decades before we could – once again – remember the suffering of the Germans because we no longer ignored the guilt of the Germans.

The path to this was long and not always straightforward.

In the Soviet occupation zone and in the GDR, the founding of independent refugee organizations was prohibited from the very beginning. Memories of the so-called resettlers about the old homeland were long unwelcome. Expulsion was considered a legitimate reaction to Nazi occupation and extermination policies. Criticism of the rapes by the Red Army and the expulsions by Czechs and Poles was suppressed. As early as 1950, the ruling party SED renounced the German eastern territories by recognizing the Oder-Neisse line as the German-Polish state border, which even caused disturbance within the party – and even more so, of course, among many displaced persons in the GDR.

Neither renunciation nor tabooing, nor ideological reinterpretation could, however, dispel grief and trauma. “One does not leave the homeland without tears,” wrote Christa Wolf in 1976 in her novel “Kindheitsmuster.” At the age of 15, she fled from the front, from the East Brandenburg town of Landsberg, which is now called Gorzów Wielkopolski.

In West Germany, the expulsions were initially politically exploited to denounce the advance of the Soviet Union, the atrocities of the Red Army, and the injustices of the so-called “expelling states.” Although the displaced persons' associations had early on refrained from using violence, and the revanchism feared by the Allies largely did not materialize. Yet for both Christians and Social Democrats, it was: “Divided – never.” Even in 1963, Willy Brandt declared at the meeting of Silesians in Germany: “Renunciation is betrayal.”

Germans – and certainly not only the displaced – primarily saw themselves as victims at that time.

A shift in perspective among broader circles only began in the mid-1960s – significantly driven by the East Thinking Document of the Protestant Church and the letter from the Polish Catholic bishops to their German counterparts, which bore the programmatic heading: “We forgive and ask for forgiveness.” With the Warsaw Treaty of 1970, the new Polish western border was de facto recognized by the federal government and – by a narrow majority – also by parliament. The debates at that time in German society were painful, but they were necessary to find new paths.

Many of you gathered here today may still remember the great disappointment, even bitterness, with which many displaced persons reacted to the factual renunciation of the eastern territories. In their hearts, it was still difficult to accept the realities, also because the associations as well as party politicians had defended claims and fostered illusions for many years. Yet “no one can hope today that the lost territories will ever again be German,” as Marion Gräfin Dönhoff said. “Anyone who thinks otherwise must be dreaming of reconquering them by force.” The displaced persons' associations, which took a confrontational stance against the new eastern policy of the Brandt government, appeared to many as troublemakers of a foreign policy reorientation, indeed ultimately as peace disruptors.

Since the 1970s, Germans have increasingly learned to place their suffering in a historical context. What had been done to them was now seen against the backdrop of what Germans had previously done to others. It was indeed Nazi Germany that brought death and destruction to Europe, that made expulsion, violence, occupation terror, and extermination everyday experiences for many peoples of Europe. That other Germany, which had extermination in mind, which developed a “Generalplan Ost,” according to which entire peoples were to be erased from the map as supposedly inferior and partly murdered.

Just as in previous years the emphasis on the suffering of the Germans had served to absolve Germans of guilt, the awareness of the guilt of the Germans now displaced any empathy for the Germans. The loss of homeland was largely accepted as a supposedly inevitable punishment for the crimes of Germans. Many residents of the GDR thought this way, and this is how the dictatorial ruling SED tried to enforce it as a pattern of interpretation.

Today, I, who lived there, cannot think of it without a certain shame. For in the 1950s, I, like most East Germans, was informed about the fates of displaced persons through those around me or through West German media. And when I think back to the long Saturday afternoons of my childhood and youth, I still have the many radio request concerts from the Northwest German Broadcasting Corporation in my ears, as it was called then, I had heard the East Prussian song dozens of times and felt the longing for the “land of dark forests and crystal-clear lakes” within me, even though I was from Mecklenburg. All the more incomprehensible why I then, why we locals later so willingly repressed that others, the displaced, had paid so infinitely more for the violent, cruel war than we had. Why we, who had retained our homeland, began to balance accounts and cited our own bombings and dead to immunize ourselves against the grief of others, of those who came to us. With political theses, we blocked the empathy that was possible for us.

Today I know: those who fend off the feelings of others also fend off their own feelings. Openness to the suffering of others, on the other hand, leads to understanding, leads to closeness. We should also think of this today when strangers are accommodated in our town, in our neighborhood, or are in need of protection. Understanding for the suffering of others is a fundamental prerequisite for humane coexistence.

However, at that time in Germany, even the sons and daughters of the refugees and displaced persons sometimes did not have understanding for the suffering of others. Many of them did not want to hear anything about their parents' lost home, about their flight stories. It embarrassed them when old homeland songs were sung at birthdays late into the evening and tears came to the eyes of relatives. Love of homeland had indeed been discredited by Nazi propaganda, for many also by the romanticizing homeland films of the 1950s, and not least by the rhetoric of some displaced persons' officials. Sympathy for displaced persons was often seen as a relativization of historical guilt, as historical revisionism, as a reinterpretation of perpetrators into victims.

Fortunately, our society has gradually given up its temporary defensive stance since the early 1990s. Politically, there was already clarity: the Two-Plus-Four Treaty and the border treaty between the Republic of Poland and reunified Germany have definitively enshrined the legal validity of the Oder-Neisse border.

Moreover, Europe has come together again. One can travel freely again in areas that had disappeared behind the Iron Curtain for four decades. Hundreds of thousands of displaced persons and their children have stood since the 1990s in front of no longer parental homes, in front of no longer Protestant churches, in front of no longer German school buildings, and in park-like or overgrown areas, where they often searched in vain for the graves of their relatives. And when Germany also took in several hundred thousand refugees from the civil war in Yugoslavia in those years, many asked themselves in shame: on what grounds can we deny our own mothers and grandmothers the empathy that we rightly extend to the raped women in Bosnia? The experience of current injustice has contributed to approaching the long-past with new empathy.

Those who are forced to leave their homeland often feel a lifelong wound that only superficially heals and keeps breaking open. And so we have learned to respect what the cultural scientist Aleida Assmann formulated as follows: “There is such a thing as a human right to one’s own memory, which cannot be easily eradicated by censorship and taboo.”

Günter Grass did not even find the 800 pages of "The Tin Drum" sufficient to write the lost Danzig off his soul. 43 years later, Grass, by then 75 years old, had to stage the downfall of his homeland once again in "Crabwalk." Similarly, Siegfried Lenz had not yet detached himself from his homeland with his stories about Suleyken. Just over 20 years later, he brought Masuria to life once more, and could only part with it violently: he let the "Heimatmuseum" go up in flames along with all the exhibits that had remained after the flight.

Today, there are also many descendants, sons and daughters, who, now having aged themselves, allow the same question to arise that Christa Wolf once posed: "How did we become who we are today?" Thus, decades after the events, we experience something wonderful: the regaining of the empathy available to us. Finally, a deeper understanding among the descendants for the trauma of their displaced mothers and fathers, finally a deeper understanding from locals for their neighbors and friends who once came as refugees and displaced persons. And finally, a comprehensive remembrance of war and post-war, in which there is room for grief, guilt, and shame.

The founding of the Foundation for Flight, Expulsion, Reconciliation in 2008, largely initiated by the Federation of Expellees, Mrs. Steinbach, is for me an important sign of this development: the flight and expulsion of the Germans are entering the historical consciousness of the entire nation, placed in a context that no longer separates us from our neighbors, from the former enemies of war, but enables a new understanding.

For decades, the expulsion of Germans in the states of Central and Eastern Europe was one of the ideologized and politically instrumentalized topics: expulsion was seen as just punishment for German crimes, and West Germany as a bastion of revanchism and revisionism. With these theses, communist governments were even able to bind people to them who otherwise deeply mistrusted them.

Only after 1989, when archives became accessible and ideological barriers fell, when people could exchange ideas freely and the fear of border revisions and restitution claims faded, could Poles, Hungarians, and other Central European peoples take a self-critical look at their own history. So-called ethnic "cleansings" are today discredited everywhere – at least in Europe – as a means of politics, and expulsions in the past are increasingly recognized as injustices. There are impressive testimonies for this, for example:

The Slovak National Council already apologized to the Carpathian Germans in early 1991 for the evacuation and expulsion.

Władysław Bartoszewski, the tireless bridge-builder between Poland and Germany, stated in the German Bundestag in 1995: "The evil done to us, even the greatest, is [...] no justification [...] for the evil we ourselves have inflicted on others."

In Hungary, the Parliament established January 19 as a National Day of Remembrance for the expulsion of the German-Hungarians and Danube Swabians in 2012, after already condemning the expulsions in March 1990 and apologizing to the victims and their descendants.

The Romanian Parliament condemned the deportation of able-bodied Romanian Germans to the Soviet Union as political persecution and recently agreed to compensation payments to Germans who no longer live in the country.

In the Czech Republic, the city of Brno officially asked the victims of the expulsion for forgiveness on the occasion of the 70th anniversary of the so-called Brno Death March. "It doesn't hurt as much anymore when we admit mistakes," said the young Czech author Kateřina Tučková, "on the contrary, we feel this as necessary and purifying."

As long as Europe was divided, it seemed hardly possible what we are now experiencing more and more frequently: the burdensome issues between our peoples are no longer excluded, suffering is no longer weighed against one another. When people tell each other their stories, the loss of homeland becomes tangible as a shared existential experience, as a deep inner empathy with the other, regardless of their national or religious affiliation. And German history has increasingly become a part of the history of Poland, the Czech Republic, Slovakia, Latvia, and Hungary – and in the consciousness of Poles, Czechs, and Hungarians, it is often more vivid than in the consciousness of Germans.

I would like to take this day to express my heartfelt thanks to our neighbors for their sovereign gestures and for their new trust.

Discomfort towards strangers has existed at all times. We experience it today, we experienced it after 1945, even though the refugees were compatriots who were rooted in the same culture and partly in the same national history. Foreign – we learn from this – is always the one who comes newly into an already existing group and is perceived as an intruder. Reasons for distance or rejection can always be found.

The refugees and displaced persons after the end of the war were often also discriminated against and insulted as Polacks, Gypsies, backpack Germans, or have-nots, branded as backward and allegedly having particularly served the Nazi Reich. Thus, the lack of solidarity found a cynical justification.

Not only the insults from the accounts of those years seem strangely familiar to me: almost no one wanted to share their home with the "strangers," locals were preferred in job applications, and cultural differences rarely sparked curiosity and interest. For years, locals celebrated their own festivals and services and wrinkled their noses at foreign dialects and foreign smells.

It took a long time for Germany to become a reconciled country with itself. A country in which some could retain their homeland and others could gain a new one. A country in which some did not feel foreign and others did not feel excluded.

The experience of successful integration of refugees was not an isolated case. West Germany took in almost four million refugees from the GDR over the decades. It has offered a new home to tens of thousands of refugees from the communist states of Eastern and Central Europe, as well as refugees from war zones, military dictatorships, and failing states, whether they were called Greece or Turkey, Iran or Yugoslavia. Germany thus has a lot of experience with refugees and displaced persons, a positive experience that we too rarely draw upon in public discourse. Yet it would do us good to have reassurance as we face new challenges today.

Never since the end of World War II have so many people been uprooted as at this moment: right now, the United Nations has released new, alarming refugee numbers. By the end of 2014, there were 59.5 million people worldwide, eight million more than just a year before. Never before have so many refugees been counted. The vast majority are displaced persons within their own countries: around 40 percent of the population in Syria, hundreds of thousands in Iraq, South Sudan, the Congo, and Nigeria. Half of all refugees are children and adolescents under 18 years – particularly distressing! Even Europe is experiencing a massive increase in internally displaced persons. In Ukraine, their number has risen to almost 650,000.

Many refugees remain close to their homeland because they hope for a quick return. I have met some of them: Syrian families in a camp in Turkey. But more and more people are taking longer, more dangerous, and more expensive escape routes to dare a new beginning: many are striving for Europe, a place of their longing, the continent of freedom and prosperity, which is supposed to enable them and their families to lead a better life without fear, violence, and hunger. I have also met some of them: for example, young people from West Africa in a camp in Malta.

They are on the road for weeks or months, sometimes years, and are defenseless against plunderers, extortionists, and smugglers. They are exploited, robbed, tortured, sexually abused. And they risk their lives when they set out on overloaded trucks through the Sahara and on dilapidated ships and unsuitable rubber and wooden boats across the Mediterranean. Many are deeply traumatized by their flight.

Today's refugees are not only the political descendants of those persecuted during the Nazi dictatorship, nor solely the descendants of the displaced at the end of the war. They are also the spiritual relatives of those persecuted and impoverished people in the towns and villages of the 19th century, here in our region, to which Edgar Reitz, for example, powerfully reminded us in his film "The Other Homeland." We have almost forgotten: Germany was once a country full of desperate, hopeful emigrants. Almost 5.5 million Germans were driven between 1812 and 1912, despite life-threatening crossings over the Atlantic, to an uncertain new beginning in America. They fled from hardship, and they fled from political repression or religious intolerance – just like the refugees and many migrants today.

We face a great challenge, a challenge of a new kind and new dimension. In the last five years, at least fifteen new conflicts have flared up or re-erupted – in Africa, the Middle East, and also in Europe. The state structures of entire regions are threatened with collapse or have already collapsed. The longer civil wars, Islamist terror, armed conflicts between governments and rebels, and separatists last, the more anarchy, poverty, corruption, and hopelessness spread, the more people will leave their families, their friends, and their homeland. The numbers of refugees will continue to rise – even in the medium term.

In light of this dramatic development, we must broaden our perspective. Refugee policy is no longer just domestic policy. Refugee policy extends into our foreign, security, and development policy.

Let us begin with what should be self-evident: in my opinion, it is a moral duty of all European states to save refugees from death in the Mediterranean. We would lose our self-respect if we left people drifting on the water at the gates of our continent to their own devices.

It should also remain a self-evident moral duty of all European states to grant people safe refuge who – as stated in Article 16a of the Basic Law and the provisions of the Geneva Refugee Convention – are persecuted for political, ethnic, religious, and racial reasons. I consider such protection non-negotiable and mandatory until these people can safely return to their homeland or can remain in Germany or elsewhere in a safe place.

Germany has learned in dealing with asylum seekers: today we respond quite differently to the increase in refugee numbers than we did twenty years ago. I am pleased to see how much compassion many citizens of our country show for civil war refugees and politically persecuted individuals, how many take on sponsorships, teach language skills, accompany asylum seekers on official visits, and provide a room. The perspective on the suffering of the other – it has sharpened in our country, and we should be pleased about that, and there should be no end to this process of further learning and development.

In the discussion about how to deal with refugees, much still needs to be clarified. First, we need to agree on the facts. Almost half of the asylum seekers currently come from the Western Balkans, whose countries have been classified by lawmakers as safe countries of origin despite some concerns. The recognition rate for refugees from this area is between 0.1 and 0.2 percent. However, the other half of the asylum seekers in Germany comes from countries where war, terror, or dictatorship prevail – currently especially Syria, Eritrea, and Iraq. The recognition rates for these countries range from 70 to over 90 percent.

Among them are not only many Muslims but also Christians and Yazidis. People who were expelled from their villages, forced to convert or pay protection money. Whose children died of thirst and hunger on the run, and whose women were sold as spoils. There are unaccompanied minors among them, children and adolescents who have lost relatives in armed conflicts or while fleeing. They all seek a free and safe country. A country where they can practice their faith, not be abused, not be violently suppressed. A country where they can determine their lives in freedom.

We know that neither Germany nor Europe as a whole can offer refuge and a future to all those who wish for it. Therefore, refugee policy must extend far beyond the European Union. We must support the immediate neighboring countries of crisis areas more than we have so far. We need to pay more attention to stabilizing the countries of North Africa and especially the Western Balkans. And since the Federal Minister of Foreign Affairs is here, I want to express my full appreciation for the efforts of the German federal government to continually develop political activities in these particularly challenging areas. Thank you for that. Ultimately, we must continue to focus on a more targeted approach to combating the root causes of flight on the ground – all while knowing that everything we do will yield little success as long as governments do not take greater responsibility for building a peaceful, secure, and livable future for their peoples.

So let us primarily consider our possibilities in Germany and in Europe, here, where we have influence and bear direct responsibility. We have indeed strengthened search and rescue operations in the Mediterranean, but many other questions remain unresolved: How do we combat the gangs of criminal smugglers? What do new, safe forms of refugee recognition look like? How will refugees be distributed more fairly in Europe, and how will a similar asylum system be established in all member states? How do we treat rejected asylum seekers humanely? And, not unimportantly: How do we regulate immigration alongside asylum?

In short: How do we ensure that we do more, given the scale of the problem? And by more, I mean more of everything: taking in more and helping more, while also managing better, deciding faster, and yes, also rejecting more consistently – so that we remain capable of receiving those for whose unconditional protection we have committed ourselves and who are in greater need of our help than others.

Recently, the question has arisen again: How many refugees can our society actually bear? A nation lives on the sense of belonging, on trust, cooperation, and compassion among its citizens. Refugees and immigrants, on the one hand, increase social and cultural diversity and enhance the innovative capacity of society. That is why we also speak of enrichment in these cases. On the other hand, we know from recent scientific studies that mutual consideration and the willingness to show solidarity within a society can also decline if, for example, the number of refugees and immigrants in urban areas rises too quickly and too strongly, or if the cultural distance seems too great.

At the same time, we must not overlook the potential of refugees and the opportunities for our society. We must continually remind ourselves of the significant role that refugees and displaced persons played in the successful rebuilding of Germany. I recognize that same spirit, which seeks a new beginning and wants to shape the future, in many of today’s refugees.

Today, we wanted to talk about the uprooted.

About refugees and displaced persons, those who have been forced to emigrate.

And we see: We are right in the midst of a major issue of world politics and at the same time in the midst of a significant political and moral dilemma.

In weighing the ideals of humanity against realpolitik, there can be no ideal solution. In fact, such solutions are almost never found. In politics, we can only choose between good and less good solutions, sometimes even only between the less bad ones. But that is precisely what politics is.

Seventy years ago, a poor and devastated Germany was able to integrate millions of refugees. Let us not think too small of ourselves today. Let us have faith in the strengths that this country possesses. We also need a self-image that supports us. And we will only be able to accept ourselves in the long run if we do everything we can today. Why should a economically successful and politically stable Germany not be capable of recognizing the opportunities of tomorrow in the face of current challenges?