Interview to the President of the Government in Cuatro

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

10 February 2008

Context
Zapatero gave a television interview on Cuatro ahead of the March 2008 Spanish general election, discussing polls, his record, and economic challenges.
Main themes
2008 Spanish general election, electoral polls and voter loyalty, economic policy and growth, social legislation, Iraq troop withdrawal, minimum wage increase, parliamentary mandate, mortgage crisis impact on Spain, social dialogue and peace, democratic values
Duration
~70 min
97th percentile
Words
8,397
97th percentile
Sentences
334
96th percentile
Readability
52
70th percentile
Grade
11.8
43rd percentile
Syntax
3.16
68th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

334 sentences in 141 paragraphs

President .- Good evening.

I. Gabilondo .- Are you going to win the election?

President .- It is citizens who should decide, but I think, I wish, I hope I will win, of course.

I. Gabilondo .- Are you ready to lose?

President .- Sure. A democrat should always be ready for anything. Accepting one's defeat is one of the features of a truly democratic temperament, of a truly democratic attitude, and I would like the different leaders and the different parties to share this feeling, because it would be really good.

I. Gabilondo .- When you take a look at the polls and see that the People's Party is getting near, what do you think?

President .- Polls can always be interpreted in different ways. I remember that four years ago polls said that the People's Party would win and, instead, it was the Socialist Party that won. I hope I will have a broad majority, and that's what I am going to ask citizens to do; a more solid majority, so as to implement our project with autonomy and so as to place Spain on the right track, in order to achieve full, stable employment, sufficient salaries, more social protection and also in order to know that our country has the necessary resources and strength to face all those challenges.

I. Gabilondo. - I asked Mr. Rajoy about certain polls a few days ago, the polls that show that there is a standoff and that Mr. Rajoy is in the fifth position, what is happening?

President .- I see that you are really interested in polls, but I think that the analysis should be carried out after the election.

I. Gabilondo .- Don't you read the polls? Aren't you worried about them?

President .- I do, but they should be considered a mere piece of information. They cannot be taken for a forecast; if anything, they can be considered an analysis of the main opinions of citizens; but one must trust one's project, one's ideas and, of course, those things one wants to do in Spain and those things one wants to offer to the Spanish citizens.

I. Gabilondo .- But, you might be interested in a fragment of one of the polls I have here now. A fragment that states that only sixty something per cent of those who voted for you four years ago are going to vote for you again now, can't you hear the voice of some of your previous voters telling you "you've let us down"?

President .- I wasn't acquainted with that piece of data. The data I know, in fact, show that our voters' fidelity is even higher now. Citizens will logically decide next 9th of March; but I can tell Spanish citizens and I can tell those who voted for me that I have observed my main electoral compromises: from the very first day, withdrawing our troops from Iraq, and even one month ago, raising the minimum salary to 600 Euros, or raising pensions; or implementing the Equality Act, the Dependence Act; promoting our economic growth, employment, social dialogue -for, this has been the period with the highest social peace in our history- and, of course, I have always governed with respect and through dialogue, promoting coexistence instead of division.

I. Gabilondo .- How many times have you thought "I should have listened to those who had told me to hold the election in October"?

President .- I have always thought that one should observe one's compromises with citizens. My compromise, my contract, lasts four years and in our system, if you have parliamentary support, if you have projects -as was our case- until the end of the Legislature, with several important laws, you must stay until the end. I think citizens would not have been glad if I had carried out an early dissolution of Parliament in order to call elections just out of political interest, just because it was better to call them at that time and not a few months later. The mandate lasts four years and after that period citizens will have a say, unless you lose the parliamentary support, which has not been my case.

I. Gabilondo .- But, last October or September you already expected some economic trouble.

President .- There were certain symptoms that proved that there were difficulties back in August. These difficulties were caused by the crisis in the mortgage sector in the United States. The United States usually influence world economy whenever they have a problem, and this has affected Europe, of course, and also us; yet, now, as a country we are as strong as ever, because we have more workers than ever, more than twenty million workers, because our growth has been solid and because our economy is improving, it is growing with more technological strength and it depends less on the construction sector. We have public surplus, and this does not happen in any of the biggest countries, for we have saved 70,000 million Euros over the last four years and there will be 60,000 million Euros in the Social Security Reserve Fund by 2008.

Thus, our message is: of course, if I am elected President of the Government anew, if citizens so decide, our economy will keep growing and it will keep on creating employment, and this Government will provide guaranteed support in order to face difficulties to those who are facing difficulties. I have already proved this by raising the pensions, by raising the Minimum Salary and by implementing social laws through dialogue and social agreements.

I. Gabilondo .- But, Mr. Rodriguez Zapatero, when the data about the crisis were published, you - and you have just admitted this - you had a look at the data on macroeconomy and you knew what was coming next, as you have just said. Didn't you forget about taking a look to that part of reality that does not have anything to do with macroeconomy, that is, to microeconomy? Didn't you perceive that people were starting to feel unrest? Didn't you forget about that?

President .- We have worked on microeconomy from the very first day, because the most important part of the evolution of a country, what provides a greater welfare, is employment, stable employment. We have turned one million temporary jobs into indefinite jobs thanks to the social agreement and we have raised the minimum pensions more than any other Government during our democracy. See, when I entered the Government, there were almost four million pension holders receiving less than 500 Euros, half the amount that a "mileurista" (one thousand-euro earner) gets; but we will soon have only one million left in such situation. Thus, we have made three million pension holders progress steadily.

We have supported housing, we have provided aids for housing, for rentals, for young people; we have implemented laws such as the Equality Act, the Dependence Act… This Government has kept its social compromises with employment, with stable employment, with the unions and with the businessmen; in favour of new, advanced social policies in order to improve the welfare state, from the very beginning and until the end; the last more famous one is that for the first time in our country parents will get 2,500 Euros per birth.

I. Gabilondo .- I meant that, when difficulties arrived, you didn't seem to realise that people were starting to worry and you just provided several data that were true - just like you are doing now - but you did not share that real concern about everything becoming so expensive, and so on.

President .- Unrest ins mainly a consequence of the fact that the interest types have raised, which has provoked the increase of mortgages, and this has been the reason why many families have had to make greater efforts, and prices have gone up as a consequence of the cereal crisis and of the rise of the price of oil. But we have already taken measures and we will keep taking measures.

I have undertaken to give money back, to deduct a certain amount from the Income Tax, namely, four hundred Euros, to employees, pension holders and self-employed workers too, so that economy may improve, so that this may boost up economy and so that citizens may have a higher income.

I . Gabilondo .- Does this mean, President, that during this period of prosperity, with such high rates in the construction sector, say… You must have often thought that it wasn't possible to keep selling one million flats forever.

President .- Of course. We all knew that.

I. Gabilondo .- Have you been trying to adjust and consolidate our economy all this time?

President .- In fact, yes. We have, because…

I. Gabilondo .- Mr. Rajoy, a few days ago, told us that you hadn't done anything.

President .- That is perhaps because Mr. Rajoy has a tendency to say the same thing all the time, but there are certain things citizens should remember.

In 2002, there was also an increase of unemployment and the reaction of the Government at that time, Rajoy's reaction, was the "Decree" (less rights, automatic dismissal and the elimination of the Plan to promote Employment in the Countryside), which brought about a general strike. Instead, my Government has established social agreements and social improvements, to face unemployment and favour stable employment. In fact, if I get citizens' confidence, after the election, my Government, my compromise and my policies will focus on support, coverage, dialogue and social agreements.

I intend to propose a new social agreement for the next four years with the following contents: reinforcement of the economic growth, employment, stable employment, sufficient salaries, social policies ranging from social security coverage to the raise of minimum pensions and of the Minimum Salary, Dependence Act, development of the Equality Act and facing challenges such as climatic change and sustainable development.

This is the agenda that we, businessmen and unions will implement. The Right has faced difficulties by enforcing a "Decree". I propose to provide support, coverage and agreements between unions and businessmen.

I. Gabilondo .- Is Mr. Solbes tired?

President .- No, he isn't. He is fine and, besides, yesterday, those who saw him at the meeting in Vistalegre, can attest that he is really fit. Solbes is a very solvent person for Spanish economy, but he also has an amazing international reputation, and his management during this period has been very good as far as saving and administering the money of citizens, the money that comes from their taxes, is concerned.

We are the country with a highest surplus as compared to the other countries that form part of the eight industrial powers. When did Spain even dream of such a solvent situation? We are the country with a higher debt reduction over the last few years and our Debt amounts to 34 per cent as compared to the Gross Domestic Product, which gives us a great financing capacity and makes society feel calm, because our prospects, given the fact that we have such a low debt, are that fiscal pressure is going to evolve positively.

I. Gabilondo .- I see that you are satisfied, therefore, with regards to this, even though this issue is a matter for concern for many Spanish citizens. There is something I think that you must be really upset with. Your expectations with regards to the solution of the question of ETA have collapsed. Was it a mistake, Mr. Rodriguez Zapatero, to carry out such a task?

President .- If there is one single possibility to bring violence, to bring the drama of terror to an end, we must always go for it. As President of the Government, I wouldn't have forgiven myself for not having tried to.

I think that all the different Presidents have gone through this, all of them, and they have all tried to solve it.

But, once you have tried to solve it and since, once more, ETA has kept resorting to violence and to insane terror, I must say that democracy has not lost, it is ETA that has lost, and it has lost twice, because ETA has lost its chance, the new chance that democracy was offering, because ETA is not stronger now and because the end of violence is not more distant now than a few years ago. Instead, it is nearer, in my opinion, mainly because their social support is decreasing.

Eliminating ETA, bringing it to an end involves, in the first place: a strong, constant action of the State Security Forces and Bodies, with the support of the Government and with the support of the different parties; and in the second place, and this is very important, a progressively more reduced social support, and now, ETA does not practically have any support in the Basque country. 99 per cent, that is, most Basque citizens have seen that during this time, under a Government that has made great efforts, that has made its best so as to bring violence to an end, ETA, imbued of criminal madness, has lost its chance and has frustrated so many hopes.

I. Gabilondo .- When we look back in time and see that Mr. Jose Jon Imaz, who had faith in this process, has grown tired of it and left; when we see that Mr. Arnaldo Otegi had believed in the process and still he is in jail; when we see that the Abertzale Left, which you wanted to integrate, is right now rioting, and since you are - say - cornered by certain sectors of public opinion, couldn't we say that it wasn't worth the effort after all, Mr. Rodriguez Zapatero?

President .- We could say that the State is strong, that democracy has not lost, I insist, that ETA is weaker and has less social support. What I doubtlessly regret, and very deeply too, is the fact that the opposition, the People's Party, has been opposing the antiterrorist policy during this Legislature. The only thing it shouldn't have opposed to, and yet, it has based its opposition on it, after four years, during which I, as leader of the opposition, supported their antiterrorist policies constantly, systematically, everyday and regardless of the circumstances.

In fact, that is a strategy to bring about division in our society; that is what Mr. Rajoy and the People's Party have been doing. They brought about division with the war of Iraq, they brought about division with terrorism, they brought about division with the reform of the Statutes, launching anathemas like "Spain is falling apart", and each of their most relevant policies and each of their most relevant speeches are intended to spread division, in fact, when this country wants and needs coexistence, coexistence based upon respect, coexistence, so that - be it from the Government or from the opposition - one may be faithful to the principles of the State and to one's values. This is what I did when I was in the opposition and this is what I am doing now that I am in the Government, and I am sorry that Mr. Rajoy has not done it.

I. Gabilondo .- In the fight carried out by Justice against terrorism and its supporters, have you used different criteria? Has Justice been tailor-made, with a time for tolerance and a time for implacability? The Supreme Court of Justice said that the illegalisation process could have started before. What do you think about the last events?

President .- No, it hasn't said exactly that, it said that it could have been foreseen. But if you know our legal system and if you take a look at the different laws you will see that forecasts are not proofs.

The State Security Forces and Bodies have been carrying out their duties, informing about what was going on and watching. Thus, as is logical and normal, the proofs and the data have been gathered after a time, because the Basque Nationalist Action (ANV) had very few representatives at the beginning and now we have been able to prove that it was linked to and coordinated with Batasuna, that it was the continuation of the already illegalised Batasuna. This brought about the different actions, both penal and civil, to apply for its illegalisation.

Anyway, Justice carries out its actions with independence, in our country, in many cases, and this is something that I will always tell citizens, as President of the Government, because I have lived this personally, and this is extraordinarily positive and it generates great confidence in the democratic system.

I. Gabilondo .- But, in the future, say, you would like to integrate the independentist movements into the Statutes, both the Catalan and the Basque Statutes. That did not turn out well, so far. I would like to know the drawbacks of this decision in the case of ETA, for instance.

President .- We must make a difference between the different realities.

I. Gabilondo .- Yes, but let me go back to this here and now. Are you definitively going to refuse any possibility to set up a dialogue with ETA or, instead, according to a poll published a few days ago and as most Spanish citizens think, are you going to set up a dialogue with ETA once more if you win the election?

President .- I have said it on many occasions and I will say it again: there are no expectations whatsoever to set up a dialogue or to start a negotiation with the terrorist group ETA. ETA's only destiny, its only way out, its only decision, is abandoning violence for good.

Once, Mr. Toni Blair told me that being a terrorist was a difficult task, for it involved killing, putting bombs and damaging the lives of others; but he also told me that it was nearly so difficult to stop being a terrorist, because criminal madness, the means to try and obtain political objectives, becomes the very purpose, eventually.

But I am positive about it: democracy will bring ETA's violence and terrorism to an end. I think that we are approaching the end, but, as many other countries in the world, either in the past or at present, this is a long road and it involves zeal, persistence, and it sometimes triggers expectations and, yet, some other times, it is frustrating; but we have a clear aim: ETA knows that democracy brought about its defeat time ago, that it has nothing to do, and we are in an impasse between the victory of democracy and the elimination of ETA.

They can still hurt us but, anyway, democracy will overcome and it will stand up under any circumstances.

I. Gabilondo .- But, let me insist, just to pinpoint something: during the next Legislature, if you win the election, you will not open up a new dialogue process?

President .- There are no expectations of a new dialogue process during the next Legislature. Only the end of violence is to be expected.

I. Gabilondo .- Does it make any sense not to do away with the Resolution of the Parliament that could open up that possibility anew?

President .- The Parliament issued a Resolution for that, specifically, of course and, besides, it was done on demand, given our particular circumstances at that time. Still, once more, we didn't want to encourage debate as far as the People's Party is concerned because they would use it to prompt division in an issue such as this one, an issue about which all good willed persons, all democrats, all Spanish citizens agree: namely, that the most repulsive thing in this country is terrorism and violence. We all want to fight against it, we want to bring it to an end and, being democrats and since we have been living and suffering together for many years, for decades, we should always be together. Unfortunately, we have gone through a period of confrontation.

I. Gabilondo .- But I was saying that, since your assertion that there is no room for dialogue so far is being constantly questioned, this Resolution has become a sort of clue, in a way. What is it about? Is it an open door for ETA just in case you may decide to leave the fight definitively or in case you may decide not to give in to the PP doing away with the Resolution?

President .- It is intended not to favour a debate that brings about division and confrontation, because it is made up of reproaches, reproaches that must be refuted, which is something I have always tried to avoid; and not just now that I am the President of the Government, but from the beginning, ever since I was appointed leader of the Socialist Party already.

I never asked a single question about ETA or the antiterrorist policies. I was informed about those things the Government deemed necessary and that was fine with me. I always said yes to the measures put forward by the Government, I always supported their actions, because I always thought that as far as antiterrorist policies were concerned and beyond political ambition or opposition or criticism, the most important thing was my own compromise and my loyalty to democracy, to the values of freedom and to Spain.

Besides, I am absolutely convinced that in the election four years ago, when I received the support of most Spanish citizens, that was also taken into account. My unconditional support to the Government of Mr. Rajoy and Mr. Aznar during four years was also taken into account.

Moreover, I lived very funny situations with Mr. Rajoy, because, as all those citizens that are watching me right now will believe, at a certain point Mr. Aznar refused to talk to me on the phone and it was either Mr. Rajoy or Mr. Arenas who phoned me on different occasions in order to talk or to set up agreements. Mr. Rajoy phoned me to deal with the Political Parties' Act and to illegalize Batasuna, and I told him: "go ahead, go ahead. You have the information, you decide whether or not this is the right time, under whatever circumstances. You know that you have a blank cheque". I told them they had a blank cheque as far as we were concerned.

I. Gabilondo .- Therefore, has the People's Party been unfaithful this time?

President .- They have indeed. And the worst thing about such an attitude is the fact that it divides the Spanish society with regards to an extremely delicate matter, when most citizens want - and of course ETA does not like this, it does not like this at all - to get together and, of course, ETA does not like to see the opposition supporting the Government's antiterrorist policy, either with or without dialogue. For this strengthens the Government and weakens ETA, as anyone can see.

I. Gabilondo .- Although briefly, I said before that you had surely suffered some disappointments, like this one you've just mentioned, I'm sure you had great hopes about it, and another disappointment is that one regarding the incorporation of the independentist movements to the Statute reform. This has been possible neither in Catalonia nor in the Basque Country. Have you learnt any lesson from this?

President .- Let's see. There has never been a reform of the Statutes of the Basque Country, in the Basque country, over the last four years, we have recovered dialogue between the Basque Regional Government and the Government of Spain. We have achieved important agreements as far as infrastructures are concerned, the Basque railway system known as Basque Y, the renewal of the Quotas, technological infrastructures. Dialogue. Disagreements? The Plan Ibarretxe. We don't agree about it, we discussed it and we voted against it.

In Catalonia there was a reformed Statute, a Statute created in 1979, which improved the self-government, and it was supported by most political parties although some did not, in my opinion, because they didn't like the way the agreement for the Statute had been carried out. But Catalonia has more self-government today; the transfers are now taking place in Catalonia, the transfer process, the transfer negotiation process is taking place; therefore, Catalonia will soon have more capacity to rule its own destiny and Spain is now where it should be.

And the thing is that this has been a very serious issue during this Legislature, because the People's Party has been promoting division in this regard once more in different parts of our territory under the anathema "Spain is falling apart", instead of having also proved a capacity for dialogue and consensus; and then they have behaved deceitfully, for in Andalusia they have voted in favour of a Statute whose articles, to a great extent, are the same as those in the Statute of Catalonia.

I. Gabilondo .- I know that Catalonia and the Basque Country were different. I talked about dreaming of integration, and in one of the cases there was a Statute while in the other one ETA had put forward a solution. I mean, of course, that Spain has not fallen apart, obviously enough…

President .- No, it hasn't, in my opinion Spain is stronger now.

I. Gabilondo .- …but Republican Left and Convergence and Union are angry with you because they say that you have deceived them, the People's Party says that you have deceived them and the Catalan Socialist Party is also extremely upset. One thing is sure, namely, Spain is stronger now, but everyone complains about that Statute.

President .- We are striving through the electoral campaign. I understand the fact that the rest of the political parties are not supposed to praise me, right? What I can tell you is that I have made an effort so that the self-government increase could give way to the reforms of the Statutes of Autonomy, which involve an increase of self-government in the Autonomous Regions and a greater recognition of their identity.

Now I think that those reforms of the Statues can be carried out in other Autonomous Regions, since they have not been carried out everywhere, and, of course, given that the door is open, I think that such reforms come to complete the decentralisation process and the self-government process in our country, and that our main aim over the next few years should be strengthening the cooperation between the Central Government and the Autonomous Regions, and implementing the reform of the financing system of the Autonomous Regions, mainly so as to reinforce their chances as far as education and health care are concerned, for the management of these two areas falls within the responsibilities of the Autonomous Regions.

I. Gabilondo .- Let's have a look at the social aspects during the next Legislature. Everyone knows the changes that have taken place in this area, for they have been many, but there are still some doubts about how is this going to keep evolving, because you are being criticised for being excessively radical by some and for being excessively - say - compliant by others.

President .- From the economic point of view, my policy has been a social-democrat, modern policy and, besides, I think that it has been an example for any country trying to compare to Europe over the last four years, given the results of the more positive decisions.

It is a social-democrat, modern policy and it is modern because we have been able to innovate and to introduce different parameters in our economy and also because we have supported companies as much as possible, lowering the Corporate Tax, we have opened our markets and we have taken our companies to different countries. In 2006, Spain was the third country in the world as far as investments were concerned, the third one, and 2007 concluded with the highest rates of direct foreign investments in Spain, with more than 70,000 millions Euros. And it has also been a social-democrat policy.

My main aim has been to sign the agreement between businessmen and the unions so as to create stable employment. The laws implemented by this Government have all been related to social rights: the Law on Personal Autonomy, against Dependence, which has become one of the main pillars of the Welfare State, and the Equality Act, with new rights for parents at work. And then the decisions affecting the lowest incomes, namely, the increase of the Minimum Salary so as to boost up the purchasing capacity of citizens, the increase of minimum pensions and the aids to housing.

This has been a modern, social-democrat project, a 21st century social democracy.

I. Gabilondo .- Are you going to modify the Termination of Pregnancy Act?

President .- I have already said that we are going to reflect upon it in order to evaluate its results during these twenty years and, if necessary, we will reform the Act, always with the widest consensus.

Anyway, I would like the different political parties to be prone to achieve a consensus as far as this debate is concerned, and to analyse it objectively before issuing an evaluation. I can tell you that certain campaigns that do not seek the application of the Law, but the derogation of the Law, are going on, and the Government is going to protect the right to women's privacy and, of course, we will enforce the application of the Law. And, if it has been wrongfully applied in some case, Justice will intervene.

I. Gabilondo .- It seems rather improbable for you to achieve a consensus in order to modify the existing Act, because it seems that this one is already causing certain resistance. Euthanasia, are you going to deal with it or not?

President .- We haven't undertaken to deal with euthanasia, but I would like to express my support to all those who work in that area, to the doctors who, from their professional dignity and honesty, are providing palliative care to those who are in an irreversible situation in order to relieve their pain, with the consent of the families.

In my opinion, it is very worrying to see that a campaign was set forth in Madrid, in particular, in the Community of Madrid; this campaign was supported by the Government of the Community of Madrid and now that the Courts have acquitted the defendants, they don't have the honesty to apologise, at least, to preserve the honour of those involved. This, in my opinion, has been a very negative debate.

We all trust our public health care system, which is one of the best in the world, we all trust our doctors and we all know that they do everything in their hands to save lives, but we also know that, when families consent, good doctors must also observe the deontological code, which also admits the prolongation of pain and sometimes denies dignity to the dying.

I. Gabilondo .- In your opinion, such attitudes you have just referred to issue from insensibility? Is that a moral question? Is there an underlying intention to play with the Public Health Care System, as some of those who have been affected by it say? What do you think about it?

President .- There is a purpose to all this - and this does not happen only in Spain, it also happens in other different countries- and it is linked to ultra-conservative positions, to the attempts to attack the rights, the freedom and the meaning of individual freedom and of all those things that have been conquered in the different democratic countries, in Spain too. Not only with regards to this, but also with regards to those situations that affect the rights and the freedom of people. We all can see it and I'll say it bluntly: I have a compromise to defend individual rights and freedom, the progress that Spain has achieved, for no one has the right to impose one's moral code, on the contrary, everyone must respect every single moral code and freedom; I have a firm, total, absolute compromise in this sense.

I. Gabilondo .- You now defend a very delicate thing, a lay State, and thus I have to ask you about the relationships with the Church. To start with, have you already had that lunch with the Nuncio?

President .- No, I haven't, but I will do it this very week. We will meet next Thursday night and I am going to tell him what I have already said in public, and also what I think, namely, that bishops, the Bishops' Conference and certain cardinals have said certain things that I do not consider fit.

I. Gabilondo .- Of all their declarations, which is in your opinion the most inadequate one?

President.- There are three in fact: two of them were made by two cardinals, last 30th of December, during the meeting in favour of the traditional family in Colon: number one, the laws intended to expand on the rights of citizens have made human rights recoil in Spain and, number two, the laws that our Government has approved of have weakened democracy. That is inacceptable. I cannot accept it because, of course, that involves questioning the legitimacy of a democratically elected Parliament whose function is approving of different laws. That is the very essence of our coexistence.

And, the third one was that reflection concerning terrorism that the Bishops' Conference made through a press note, because all the previous notes before the elections - and this is something that they have always done, in fact - referred to terrorism too, just to condemn it; whereas this time, for the first time, they referred to the legitimacy of the dialogue set forth in order to bring terrorism to an end, of the dialogue with ETA.

Why did they not make any such comments in the press note before the election in 2000, when Mr. Aznar had also opened up a process of dialogue with ETA? This is what I would like them to explain some day, because, besides, I must say that I have always tried to keep a correct relationship with the Spanish Catholic Church, observing, of course, my electoral programme and my compromise to implement laws in order to expand on our rights, which is why I obtained citizens' confidence. I hope that my conversation with the Papal Nuncio will turn out fine.

I. Gabilondo .- Anyway, the Church is consistent with its ideals. Are you consistent with yours? What is restraining you from revising the existing agreements with the Holy See?

President.- My loyalty to the Constitution. I don't say that such agreements cannot be revised, but our Constitution says: this is a non-denominational State, Spain is a lay State, which I like to proclaim, and we must keep a special our relationship with the Catholic Church because that is the religion of the majority in Spain.

So far, that special relationship, as the Constitution establishes - and that's fine with me - has been defined through economic and legal agreements. I think that this is an adequate model. We have moved towards self-financing in this Legislature and, logically enough, we will keep on carrying a revision; but do not expect my reaction to be an answer to the attacks against me, which are the consequence of people's opinions and impressions on what they think has happened, namely, the fact that they have asked people to vote for the People's Party. No. For me, it is the general interest, the global perspective that is more important, not letting myself be carried away by this situation, but taking into account the Constitution and setting up a dialogue. If there is something to reform, we will do it, but through dialogue and calmly.

I. Gabilondo .- There are so many things to talk about and so little time that this is a bit too much, for we have immigration too, which is such a big issue. But I will just ask you a specific question: Are there 1,100,000 illegal immigrants, as Mr. Rajoy told us a few days ago? I asked him "what would you do with them if you won?" and he answered: "I would not legalize them, we would analyse each case separately". I am asking you directly: if you win the election, what will happen with those 1,100,000 immigrants who are currently living here?

President .- In the first place, there aren't 1,100,000 illegal immigrants in Spain. Those are false figures. What we know for sure is that, when I entered the Government, there were at least 700,000 immigrants working illegally, with no rights or duties, and that started to build up during the Government of Mr. Rajoy, who was Minister of the Interior for two years and Vice President too. Thus, he has no credibility when he talks about illegal immigrants, for he holds the record of illegal entrances in our country.

I. Gabilondo .- But, what about now? From now on, what?

President .- Wait a minute. Over the last four years we have experienced a considerable change: we repatriated 150,000 illegal immigrants more over the last four years if we compare with the previous Legislature and we also improved control to prevent the entrance of illegal immigrants. I defend a strict defence of legality, for not a single illegal immigrant should enter Spain; but I also am, I must be, committed to defend the rights and duties of those immigrants who are legally working here. Thus, we have carried out an active diplomatic policy, especially in Africa, because probably no country in the world is carrying out so many repatriations as Spain, mainly towards Sub-Saharan Africa. No other country.

We are carrying out thousands and thousands of repatriations, all those who entered by boat, those sadly well-known boats, where many immigrants die; and also those who come from Morocco by boat. And even France has asked us to collaborate with them in order to carry out the repatriations, because Spain has carried out a great political, diplomatic task. And the proof is that after the high amount of boats coming to Spain, we have been able to control this situation.

Therefore, there are many illegal immigrants less, many less, thus, those who are taking municipal registers as a reference are wrong, because those registers include EU citizens, students and temping workers. Thus, this is merely false demagogy.

Then, that whole thing about the contract is absolutely… It is absolutely useless. In fact, let me put it like this, it is pointless. I don't even dare call it an idea. The contracts of those immigrants who come to Spain to work, and they can only come legally, must observe our laws: the Foreigners' Law, the Foreigners' Regulations, and, of course, the Penal Code, the Civil Code, the Workers' Statute… In all cases. Citizens from other country who come to work here have rights, but they must observe our laws and I can guarantee that this Government sees to it that laws are observed, including those laws that say that whoever is here illegally will have to go back to his country.

When Mr. Rajoy says "I will make them go", he is deceiving people. In order to make them go back to their countries, those countries must let them in. That is what we have been doing, and now Senegal and Mali admit repatriations and Morocco is cooperating with us. And we have also reinforced our borders.

I would like to say something about immigration. Immigration is changing our demographic look, and it is contributing greatly to our economic growth. The taxes paid by immigrants every year serve to pay for the pensions of nearly one million Spanish pension holders. That is a considerable amount.

And our speeches must promote coexistence. Once more, we have seen that the speech, let alone the philosophy, of Mr. Arias Canete is a clear explanation of their opinion and of their feelings about immigrants, which is not racism for me, but classism, and what he said about waiters and other things... That is not the sort of speech that joins people, it is a speech that promotes division, and what we need with regards to migration is a speech promoting coexistence. Consider, for instance, the question of the veil. We haven't had almost any problems about the veil in Spain, thus, why giving way to a debate right now, if we have already solved the problems we have had, which were very few, and if we haven't had major social conflicts due to immigration?

Spanish citizens must know that coexistence is guaranteed through the Law and also through a speech promoting serenity, common sense and support to integration.

I. Gabilondo .- I must ask you a few questions put forward by our spectators, so that they do not get too upset. And, please, be brief.

Spectator .- President: where are the 180,000 houses or housing solutions for young people that you promised four years ago?

President .- Well, we have increased the amount of social houses by nearly 180,000 during this Legislature. In fact, in 2007, that is, last year, nearly 100,000 social houses started to be built and, when we entered the Government, we didn't even have 50,000. What happens is that the number of social houses is not enough, of course, and there are many families that want and have the right to have a house. We are going to promote one and a half million social houses over the next ten years. We must make long-term plans as far as the real estate sector and construction firms are concerned. And let me remind you of the fact that we have also supported an emancipation plan for young people, granting aids to rentals, namely, 210 Euros, and we have also re-established rental deductions.

Spectator .- I would like you to tell me whether your daughters are attending a public or a private school and why did you choose either one or the other.

President .- They attend a public school, because I believe that the public teaching system in Spain works properly and that we have wonderful teachers. I respect subsidized private education and private education too, but my daughters attend a public school.

Spectator a.- President, if my husband is provisionally moved to Catalonia, for work reasons, can you guarantee us that our son will be able to study in Spanish in a public school?

President .- I can in fact guarantee that you would have my commitment and my support and that I would do everything in my hands, taking into account the competences of the Government. Because your son has the right to get support to study in Spanish.

Spectator .- I am 31, I am a photographer, I vote the left but I don't agree with that digital fee because I think it is not fair. Are you considering a solution for this problem in the future, a fairer solution?

President .- To start with, the digital fee has been going on for many years. Now it has changed because technologies have changed. It is applied in most European countries and, when we have a reasonable alternative solution I will be prone to consider it, of course. Yet, so far, no European country has considered or proposed any such thing. We will surely get to it, but, for the time being, we must defend our creators and our artists.

I think that this country must value the wealth that the different artistic creations represent, in the first place. In my opinion, that is a gesture of patriotism. Those countries with a higher national feeling support their culture and the people belonging to the world of culture more than any other country. That is why I am so amazed at the fact that some of those who wave the Spanish flag and call themselves patriots are putting down those who work in the world of culture, those who, to a great extent, promote the image of Spain throughout the world and contribute greatly to our development.

I. Gabilondo .- I would not like you to think that this is a trap, but this happened when Mr. Rajoy was here too. A question about history: tell me the date of the foundation of the United States and the dates of the French and the Russian revolutions.

President .- 1776, the USA; 1789, the French Revolution and 1917, the Russian Revolution. I had to explain this during my classes of Constitutional Law, that's why I remember.

Spectator .- Have you got into the Moncloa mood, say, over the last few years?

President .- It is the others that should say it. I remember the election night very well, when I said: power won't change me. I think it hasn't changed my convictions, my ideals, my way of life. Yes, I am four years older, but I am even more eager to do things than four years ago.

Spectator .- Are you going to expel those immigrants that have committed a crime, like the People's Party?

President .- That is what we are doing already. If the laws haven't changed in this regard and if judges observe the corresponding sentences. Thus, this debate is rather pointless too, for this is already happening, judges are doing it and it is contemplated in our legislation. Just like the contract that has provoked this rather absurd debate. Someone might think: we will make every single immigrant entering our country sing a contract. Right, and then, what? For the only thing we have to do, if that person breaks the law, is letting Justice act; letting the Administration act and letting it provide the adequate answer through the mechanisms provided by the State.

By signing a contract, which guarantees do we get? It is really absurd and, besides, that would involve too much bureaucracy. We would have to appoint officers to make sure that all legal immigrants sign a contract, and, by the way, the legal immigrant flow has increased because we have signed more agreements and that is how such things can be achieved. There are more legal immigrants, more than illegal immigrants.

And, by the way, all the immigration policy has been carried out taking into account the businessmen and the unions, which are the main two pillars of the labour market, which is where immigrants are, of course; and we have promoted an integration policy together with the Autonomous Regions and the Municipalities, and it is granted with funds that were inexistent so far. When Mr. Rajoy was Minister of the Interior and Vice President of the Government, the Government of Spain did not devote a single euro to integrating immigrants. Now we devote two hundred million Euros per year, so that in those Municipalities with a higher amount of immigrants they may learn Spanish, they may find a job and, of course, so that they may respect the rights of all Spanish citizens.

Spectator .- I would like to know if you have ever smoked a joint.

President .- No, I haven't. In fact, I have never smoked a joint. That's the truth.

Spectator .- Can you do something so that Mr. Villar does not remain the President of the Spanish Football Federation forever?

President .- Federations are autonomous entities and there is a decree that guarantees the renewal of certain federations that have not fulfilled certain objectives. Of course, that is not in my hands. I have not appointed him and I cannot dismiss him. We must respect the different laws and rules.

I. Gabilondo .- Just to finish now. When Mr. Rajoy was here, I asked him, to conclude, what he would do in the first place if he won the election. He said: "the first thing I would do if I won the election would be phoning Mr. Rodriguez Zapatero and establish a definitive agreement about several issues that affect all Spanish citizens". I would like to know whether you would do something like this if you won the election.

President .- Well, he could have done it during this Legislature. I phoned him on nine occasions, six more than Mr. Aznar, for he only phoned me on three occasions. I did set up agreements with him, because setting up an agreement is something remarkable when you are in the opposition. And, why? Because agreements are always important, of course, for the Government, for they provide more stability and calm.

I simply don't believe him. He has never proved to be willing to set up an agreement, he has never been willing to establish any pact, yet, he has been willing to provoke division. I believe, honestly, that Spanish citizens know this and they also know that my compromise to set up a dialogue and to set up agreements and to promote understanding is valid, it has been valid in his case, in the case of Mr. Rajoy, on every occasion, and it will always be valid in all cases, regardless of the person, from next 9th of March on.

And they have even criticised my tolerant character, something which, for me, is essential in order to govern a country that wants to achieve understanding, that wants to coexist, that wants to look forward to the future and that does not want to face division or social unrest.

I. Gabilondo .- You mean, if you win. If you lose, though, will you remain the leader of the opposition or will you go home?

President .- I think I will win. Yet, one should always be ready for anything, of course, if that is the decision of citizens I will talk to the members of my party and then make a decision. I think that we should not anticipate decisions; I think that we should reflect and think things over, of course; yet, I am a convinced democrat and I would not try to seek for justifications.

That is, I would not do what the People's Party has been doing over the last four years, trying to find justifications or fiddling about with reality instead of assuming my defeat.

The truth is I hope, I want to, I intend to win, right?

I. Gabilondo .- Mr. Rodriguez Zapatero, thank you very much, good evening.

President .- Good evening.