Speech and subsequent discussion by the President of the Government at the Europa Press Forum.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

5 February 2008 · Europa Press Forum

Context
Zapatero addressed the Europa Press Forum in Madrid on February 5, 2008, ahead of general elections, outlining Spain's economic record and future prospects.
Main themes
Spanish economy performance, economic deceleration and outlook, employment growth, productivity and competitiveness, real estate sector adjustment, US financial crisis spillover, economic convergence with Europe, social welfare policy, upcoming March 2008 elections, sustainable growth model
Duration
~84 min
98th percentile
Words
10,088
98th percentile
Sentences
416
97th percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
12.3
49th percentile
Syntax
3.12
63rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
22nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 61%58%
  • Institutional 16%15%
  • Ceremonial 16%15%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

416 sentences in 182 paragraphs

Thank you for this invitation, for this lunch-discussion with all of you.

The objective of my intervention is to analyze the situation of the Spanish economy based on the positive evolution it has experienced in the last four years, to advance its future prospects, and to outline the economic and social objectives I want to achieve in the political period that will open on March 9.

Allow me, in any case, to make a strong initial statement: Spain today has a strong economy, the strongest economy in its entire history.

We have achieved a very good economic legislature of democracy if we evaluate the set of basic references. It also has great growth potential, based fundamentally on the crucial fact that more Spaniards are working now than ever in history. Moreover, it is evolving faster and more directly than ever towards a pattern of growth that is healthier, sustainable, competitive, and based on higher value-added sectors. It now has the capacity, which it has not had in other periods, to absorb cyclical difficulties and the adjustment processes that occur in certain specific sectors. And, I also want to say, it has at the helm a Government that has made it a fundamental axis of its policy to use the good results derived from its management to be in a position to offer support and security to citizens when the economic cycle slows down or decelerates.

The main conclusion that can be drawn from all this is that we can and must look to the horizon with hope and conviction about the capacity of Spanish society to achieve new successes; or, if you prefer to say it differently and more linked to the atmosphere that some want to convey in these weeks, there is no objective or founded reason that allows for an intellectually honest and data-driven pessimistic message, much less a catastrophic one; neither about the current situation nor, even more fundamentally, about the future.

Based on this observation and assertion, which I believe is sufficiently strong, we are all aware, and entrepreneurs more than anyone, that we must go through a period of deceleration that will have limited duration, intensity, and effects, and, with absolute certainty, concentrated in the months we are currently experiencing, and, in particular, in the real estate sector.

We must all commit, the Government first and foremost, to work together in the same direction to quickly overcome the current problems, which, by the way, have their origin beyond the Atlantic, in the crisis promoted in the financial and real estate sector in the United States and which, without a doubt, has been transferred to the entire world economy, particularly to Europe and, therefore, to Spain. We can do it and we must do it, because nothing fundamentally divides us in this area and because what Spain is playing for is not how to better or worse navigate this situation, or what electoral game the situation may provide for some or others; what Spain is playing for, what we are all playing for, is to establish the best starting point to make the definitive leap to an economy based on productivity, with full employment, stable and of higher quality, and with intense policies of opportunities, support, and social welfare.

I am committed and motivated to lead the Government's action in this great endeavor and to continue in a task in which much progress has already been made. And I add that I am firmly convinced that, in the eyes of the majority of citizens, the results of our management in the last four years support us, which are undoubtedly the most powerful argument for confidence.

In 2004, I committed to strengthening our economy, increasing growth, guaranteeing stability, and ensuring savings. And that is our reality today. All economic indicators have improved during this period; I repeat, all economic indicators have improved during this period.

We have grown at an average of 3.7 percent, and in 2007 we did so at 3.8 percent, more than one point above the eurozone and with a more balanced composition, with great dynamism in investment in capital goods and better performance from the external sector. If in the first quarter of 2004 the economy was growing at 2.9 percent, in the last quarter of 2007 it will have grown at 3.5 percent, according to forecasts from the Bank of Spain. Investment in capital goods was then growing at 4.3 percent, and in 2007 it has been growing at three times that rate, at 11.2 percent. And the pace of exports has nearly doubled.

Productivity, which will be the axis of our country's future economy, was subtracting 1.3 points per year from our real convergence with Europe, and now it has added 0.6 points annually. Only in this way have we been able to reach and surpass the average income of the Union, and only in this way can we aspire to be among the top, after having surpassed Italy in per capita income.

Even regarding inflation, whose situation concerns the Government even though its prompt moderation is foreseeable, the average for 2007, with oil at three times what it was four years ago, I repeat, the average for 2007 with oil at three times what it was four years ago, will be 2.8 percent, the lowest since 1999.

And, by the way, all this has occurred without a loss of purchasing power, as with the average salary of the previous Legislature that power was decreasing by almost half a point per year, and now it is growing by almost one and a half points.

According to estimates from the National Statistics Institute, the disposable income of households has increased by nearly 24 percent, a percentage much higher than inflation, as a result, logically, of the three million more jobs we have at this moment, which is the source of the increase in disposable family income.

Public accounts were in real deficit in 2004, and now they show a surplus of over 2 percent of Gross Domestic Product. In four years, we have managed to save nearly 70 billion euros, which contrasts with the deficit of 12 billion accumulated in the previous Legislature. Our debt, and this is one of the most reassuring and secure messages for investment expectations in our country, has been reduced by more than twelve points, reaching levels of 34 percent of Gross Domestic Product. We are the OECD country that has done this with the greatest intensity in these four years and the OECD country that has reduced public debt the most.

Savings, strong savings, that guarantees provision and security for the future. For example, the Social Security Reserve Fund had 15 billion in 2004 and now has 46.3 billion. And today I announce that the Council of Ministers the day after tomorrow will approve a new contribution of 4.7 billion, with which the Fund will reach 51 billion, nearly 5 percent of Gross Domestic Product and practically what was planned for all of 2008. By the end of this year, therefore, our Social Security Reserve Fund will exceed 60 billion euros, thanks to the excellent performance of the System and the collection of Social Security.

We committed to making this a legislature in favor of employment, of more stable employment and of higher quality employment. A historic record has been achieved, surpassing the figure of twenty million employed. Three million new jobs have been created, and with the agreement of social interlocutors, it has been achieved that there are one and a half million more stable jobs, reducing the temporary employment rate by almost four points. These jobs have particularly benefited women, as more than 57 percent have been occupied by them, as well as young people or long-term unemployed.

After having grown nearly six points, we are now close to the employment rate of 66 percent that was committed for 2010 in the National Reform Program and in the Lisbon Objectives. The unemployment rate, despite the recent spike, is at the lowest level in our democratic history: three points lower than in 2004, and that is why I must confess that I was surprised to see some of the headlines in recent days.

In contrast to all the above, which summarizes and highlights objective data on the evolution of the economic situation in Spain, and which undoubtedly represents a trend that will recover and project for the coming years in our country, the latest data we have received, corresponding to the month of January, have been negative in the number of unemployed registered with the INEM and also in what affects Social Security, which has seen a significantly lower reduction than that of the unemployed, around 84,000.

Now, both the registered unemployment data and the affiliation data, as is well known, have a strong seasonal component. When this component is eliminated, unemployment increases by a significantly lower figure, while affiliations, contrary to what has been said, rise by 18,000 compared to December; if we discount, I insist, the classic seasonal factor of January.

It is a concentrated adjustment closely associated with the deceleration of the real estate sector. It is in that temporal and sectoral context where it must be interpreted. I insist, it is a bad data point, but the Government, with social interlocutors, will fortunately implement active employment policies and actions for the retraining of those workers so that reabsorption is possible in the shortest time possible and under the best conditions.

We know that there is a loss of employment in the real estate sector, but we also know that there are many sectors that are demanding employment, that continue to demand employment in our country. Therefore, the public sector must fulfill an adequate role, in collaboration with employers and unions, to mediate so that this readjustment occurs where, without a doubt, training must play a decisive role.

In short, in this summary balance, economic and social of the Legislature, we can say that Spain emerges stronger, more powerful, more modernized, and prepared for the future, with more capacity to realistically aspire and soon position itself among the most advanced economies in the world; with the capacity that is given to it, in addition to the economic growth and job creation we have had and will continue to have, albeit at a decelerated pace, the intense effort in Research, Development, and Innovation whose investment has multiplied by 2.6 in this Legislature; the training of human resources, having practically doubled the budget for education and the provision of physical infrastructures, whose budget has increased by 33 percent, especially in transportation with the execution of the Strategic Transport Infrastructure Plan.

The Spanish economy will continue to grow, will continue to create jobs, and will do so at an acceptable rate, reaching an average of around 3 percent in the next four years. This is what our macroeconomic scenario contemplates, this is what we expect to happen, and in that direction we will work.

We will continue to ensure the stability of public accounts, which yield such good results for society, for families, and for the future of Spain. In two years, we will already be the country with the least debt among all economic powers. Allow me to insist on this data, as surely all those present here, who are entrepreneurs, fully appreciate what it means to be in a situation with a financing capacity like that of the Spanish economy at this moment, the public sector, as a result of such a significant reduction in debt.

I want to say that of the tensions that the European economy is currently experiencing and, therefore, also the Spanish economy, none has a Spanish origin. None is a consequence of any inherent weakness. It is obvious that we are affected, just like all of Europe, and that they have a different impact depending on our original growth pattern, with a pronounced current process of resizing the real estate sector, about which much has been said in recent years, but to which, despite that consideration, a message of support must be sent, as the Government wants to do.

Therefore, confidence and calm. We have extraordinarily positive economic assets, we have a public sector prepared to do new things or more things, if necessary, and, of course, we have companies that have been showing truly outstanding data, balance sheets, and profits for the year 2007 and that have favorable forecasts for 2008.

Those forecasts say that the world economy, which today has many more protagonists than in previous cycles, will continue to grow above 4 percent in 2008. The American economy should positively impact the decisions of the monetary authority and the expansive fiscal measures. In the general context, as information about the accounts of the affected financial entities spreads, confidence should be restored, volatility should moderate, and calm should return to investors.

The European economy, with a less altered evolution scenario but also affected, will maintain growth close to 2 percent. For our part, being already the eighth industrialized economy in the world, we increasingly have a model with greater balance, as clearly shown by the growth data from the last quarter. We have managed to ensure that the productivity of the factors of production begins to equate with that of the most advanced economies.

We will continue to increase the population; we have a wide margin accumulated from our budgetary policy; we have the consistency of our business fabric, with many leaders in advanced sectors; our companies are making decisions, such as investing in capital goods or hiring permanently, which show that they share these favorable expectations, and our entrepreneurs continue to show greater optimism than the European average for this same year 2008, both in terms of sales, investment, and employment.

We have a great solidity in our banking system, some of whose entities lead the world rankings in profitability and consistency.

We are the third country in the world for direct investment abroad, only behind the United States and France. Nearly 80 billion euros in 2007 have been invested outside of Spain by our companies, more than three times the amount in 2003.

All of this explains why we are also the sixth country in the world for direct investment received in 2007, a year in which it surged strongly to 40 billion euros that we received in direct investment in 2007, doubling the figures from 2003. It has been a magnificent year for foreign direct investment in Spain.

Ladies and gentlemen,

An economy that is capable of being the third in investment abroad and is capable of reaching a record for foreign direct investment in Spain is an economy that generates great confidence and an economy that is recognized by entrepreneurs and investors as very solid.

In 2008, we will maintain consistent job creation, with an unemployment rate that we expect to be below 8.5 percent. For the next four years, we are in a position to aspire to full employment and can approach two million new jobs, with an activity rate above 70 percent, reduce unemployment to around 7 percent, and place temporary employment at 25 percent, which has been reduced by more than three points and is currently around 30 percent.

We can achieve this by relying on stimulating decisions on the supply side; with the job creation that will result from the implementation of the PEIT; with the continued increase in investment in R&D+i, which will reach 2 percent of GDP, for the first time in our history, to match the European average; with the expansion of early childhood education for children aged zero to three, which will greatly favor the priority objective for the next Legislature, which is the reconciliation of work and family life for women who are still not in the labor market in our country; with improvements in educational quality or with the effective development of care for dependency.

Economic and social advances will come hand in hand with social dialogue, as has happened in the outgoing Legislature, in which more than twenty agreements have been reached with workers' unions and business organizations, and in which the period of greatest social peace and least conflict has been achieved throughout the democratic era. Of course, I intend, if I gain the trust of the citizens, to renew a great social dialogue agreement with employers and unions on the fundamental aspects of the economy, employment, the labor market, taxation, productivity, and areas related to social welfare or social protection policy.

Advances will also come hand in hand with reforms; reforms to decisively advance productivity, improve our competitiveness, and ensure, as I said, the incorporation of women into the labor market; reforms to address some of the current imbalances in our economy and provide more sustainability to our growth.

To improve competitiveness, we need to reduce administrative burdens for companies and households by 25 percent in the next period, and continue to advance in tax simplification, such as the elimination of the Wealth Tax or the adaptation of our Corporate Tax to that of our international environment.

Reforms and openness to continue improving competition levels in goods and services markets.

Reforms and priorities to improve our educational system, especially expanding Vocational Training, achieving a higher level of university excellence, and promoting research.

Reforms and support to provide satisfactory solutions for access to housing, intensifying the construction of public housing and supporting rental as the two priorities for the next four years.

Reforms and actions to combat climate change, committed to reducing emissions and betting on renewable energies, sustainable mobility, and energy savings, including specific rehabilitation plans for 500,000 already built homes; for energy rehabilitation.

Reforms with agreements. In the labor market, as I said before, we aim to renew a great agreement with social partners to, above all, adopt new measures to improve overall productivity and stability in employment.

Ladies and gentlemen,

That is the objective: growth, employment, and reforms. That is the formula to guarantee well-being, and that is the formula that allows us to develop socially relevant policies, such as fully implementing the Dependency Law in the next Legislature; raising minimum pensions to 850 euros, almost doubling the amount from 2003; increasing the Minimum Wage to 800 euros in 2012; implementing the Equality Law and promoting the construction of one and a half million protected homes in the next ten years, with six hundred thousand of them for rent.

I mentioned earlier that the employment data for the month of January has not been good. I hope no one is pleased about it. I think of the affected workers and those who inevitably fear that they may be affected by the same situation in the future; but objectively, I find it irresponsible to send negative messages without an objective and measured analysis of the reality of our economy, its assets, its potential, and the place it has managed to reach with the efforts of entrepreneurs and workers, and reasonable support from the Government.

It is not intellectually honest to deliberately distort data. Today there is less unemployment than four years ago. This is a fact, regardless of who denies it or claims otherwise. I summarize it in one figure: 8.6 percent unemployment today compared to 11.5 percent when we came to power. Unless in this kind of trend towards losing objectivity, which is often the result of desperation, some consider that it is worse to have 8.6 percent unemployment than 11.5 percent, and it could simply be unprecedented for such claims to be made.

I want to remind you that 2,000 jobs have been created every day during this Legislature. This represents an accumulation of strength for the economy, for families, and for the population that is extraordinarily important. Furthermore, I will also recall that to support workers who may lose their jobs, today we have, as was not the case then, four years ago, when there was much more unemployment, a very different situation, because we have 7.9 billion euros for active employment policies that facilitate retraining and access to employment for workers, and 15.5 billion euros for unemployment coverage policies, which ensure that 80 percent of the unemployed are protected and receive benefits. This represents the highest unemployment coverage rate in history.

Therefore, the current problems of the situation will be overcome, and they will be overcome soon. They need to be explained objectively, and it is necessary to have direction and provide appropriate solutions to continue on that path of growth and job creation that the Spanish economy has decided to pursue and can pursue.

This is not a novelty, but the Government's policies have had a strong component of support for families since the beginning of the Legislature. For 2008, this policy has been intensified with measures to address the slowdown in the international economy that has been warned about to help families with greater difficulties to overcome challenges and also to support the real estate sector.

It is a way of facing the responsibilities of Government. There are others that, objectively, we do not know what they mean. No one knows what they mean if the approval is not explained, or if they are demanded or if "brutal decrees" are in their heads. Certainly, those will not be the response and orientation of the Government and the Socialist Party.

I want to make some reminders. As far as the Government is concerned, the Minimum Interprofessional Wage has increased to 600 euros per month, which means that it has gained purchasing power of 15 percent, compared to a 5 percent loss in the previous Legislature. The salaries of civil servants have increased by 11.3 percent, compared to previous salary freezes, and the IPREM has grown by 3.5 percent. More than three million recipients of minimum pensions have improved their purchasing power by 15 percent as a result of a 30 percent increase in this Legislature.

That is to say, the decisions that are in the hands of the Government, which affect the lowest incomes and the lowest salaries, have had growth and support that have allowed for an increase in purchasing power compared to the loss or freezing of purchasing power in the previous period.

Two million taxpayers, those with the lowest income, have stopped paying income tax. We have deflated the income tax rate for personal minimums and for reductions for work income. Special taxes have been frozen, and we have planned and committed, if we logically regain the trust of the citizens—a new deduction in the state income tax of 400 euros per year for workers and pensioners.

Given the singularities of their tax regime, it is a deduction that cannot be applied in the same terms to the self-employed; but I already announce that I commit to a solution that ensures equitable treatment in accordance with the effort we have made to provide them with a proper and dignified Statute for the first time in the history of our democracy, known as the Statute of the Self-Employed. Therefore, we will provide equitable treatment for the self-employed in the committed tax reduction.

Since the beginning of the year, young people, more than 30,000, have already started to receive a Rent for Emancipation of 210 euros per month for housing rental. More than 200,000 parents have received the benefit of 2,500 euros for childbirth. Many families are already starting to receive care for dependency, and for students, the funding for scholarships this year, 2008, reaches a historic record in our country: 1.247 billion euros.

Entrepreneurs and the self-employed have been able to see how the path was being prepared, reducing the Corporate Tax for the first time in over twenty years; freezing the modules for 1.7 million taxpayers under Objective Estimation; reducing modules for certain agricultural and livestock activities; providing extraordinary bonuses in the Hydrocarbons Tax to farmers and ranchers, and establishing lines of subsidized loans from the ICO to reactivate the fishing sector. 7 billion euros expandable for SMEs through the ICO; 100 million for the ICO-business growth line, aimed at medium-sized companies; 75 million for the ICO line that promotes the creation of new companies; 200 million in ICO loans to improve the competitiveness of sectors such as textiles, footwear, furniture, toys, leather, and wood; 100 million expandable for the ICO internationalization line and 1 billion euros in state guarantees for securitized loan funds for SMEs.

Other measures have included a reduction of 0.25 points in the employer's unemployment contribution starting in July; a 30 percent bonus for thirty months for young people and women who become self-employed, with nearly 300,000 beneficiaries; the possibility for self-employed workers to hire their children with bonuses; the extension of accident and work incapacity benefits to all self-employed workers; the increase of the unemployment capitalization from 20 to 40 percent for self-employment positions, and a 100 percent bonus for Social Security for self-employed women for one year after the birth of each child.

To activate the real estate sector, we maintain the push for public housing with the construction of 100,000 homes this year; we will promote a strong rental policy, with aid for tenants, owners, and developers, and we will extend aid for rehabilitation and urban renewal. We have recently agreed on a line of ICO guarantees of three billion to facilitate financing for the acquisition of public housing, we have prepared a new Ministerial Order for appraisal that clarifies the implications for valuation under the Land Law, and we have ordered the investing Ministries to accelerate public works tenders in order to facilitate the activity of the sector and promote employment.

It is an initiative that has already allowed the approval, in the past Council of Ministers, of files amounting to more than 700 million euros, which will continue in the coming days, and I would like to see that this is also the trend of the rest of the Public Administrations that can undoubtedly contribute to ensuring that the construction sector, in general, maintains significant levels of activity.

Ladies and gentlemen,

This is what we are doing. In the context of the coming years for our country, we must look beyond and raise our horizon, at least until 2012. That is where we must direct our action as a country and that is where we must articulate our responses to the substantial challenges facing Spanish society.

In these four years ahead of us, our economy is playing for its place in the world for the coming decades of the 21st century. Now is the time to act to be alongside those who lead or take advantage of changes, now is the time to show a positive spirit to face problems, and now is the time to take advantage of the many assets we have.

The economic destiny of Spain is, to a large extent, in the hands of entrepreneurs and workers. Their work and their attitude of collaborating and cooperating with the Government is one of the great assets and securities of our economy. We have the capacity to create more companies, for companies to expand markets, to open borders, to innovate, and to take risks.

For my part, I want to commit to putting everything within our reach, if the Spanish people renew their trust in us, to facilitate from the Government the best scenario for the benefit of investment, for the benefit of growth, and for the benefit of business.

This is the best guarantee that the vast majority of society will bring out the best in themselves, contribute their talent and effort, and that we will have that horizon of increased progress and social well-being that Spanish society will not renounce under any circumstances.

Thank you very much.

DIALOGUE WITH THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT

-----------------------------------------------------------------

Moderator.- Allow me to ask a question first. When you spoke about the interpretation of unemployment data and Social Security affiliations, I noted the phrase— you said "simply... (ellipsis), simply (a pause), unusual." I have the impression that you did not mean to say "unusual," but that you meant to say something else. Can you say what you meant?

President.- Yes, I find it unusual that, with three million more people working in Spain, or nearly three million, because one month there is a reduction in what represents employment or what is registered unemployment, there are some statements like the ones we have heard of "dramatism."

So, when we had an unemployment rate of 11 percent, if the situation today with an 8.5 percent unemployment rate is dramatic, what was it like at 11.5 percent? By the way, that was when Mr. Rajoy was in Government. What was it like? To run away? One must have a certain parameter of objectivity. Did January give a bad figure? Yes, but the evolution of employment in Spain has been very positive, that is evident.

Therefore, one cannot say that, having an unemployment rate, the best that Spain has ever had, is a dramatic situation. It is so unbelievable, it is the best testimony of how little there is to say to the Spanish society! If there were something to say, when there are truly serious things to say, one never falls into exaggeration or caricature.

Moderator.- They are asking in that sense if we should get used to that trend for the coming months, how many months we will have to continue studying data on falling unemployment and why the Government maintains that it is a temporary figure.

President.- The Government maintains that January is a figure that has very clear seasonal characteristics. Furthermore, in this context, for some other circumstance, we are surely in a process where the real estate sector is going to have an employment adjustment, which was something that, by the way, had been evaluated; but, as I explained a moment ago, the Spanish economy has many other sectors demanding employment. Now we have to manage well with employers and unions to incorporate training for those people who were basically in the real estate sector—not so much in construction, but in the real estate sector—in a very high number of companies that we have had in recent years in the real estate sector.

I will give you a figure: in the last nine years, real estate companies increased in Spain by 200 percent. It is evident in light of what represented the start, which we had in some years, of 800,000 homes, when there is a fairly widespread consensus that the number of annual homes should be around 450-500,000 for a country like Spain.

Therefore, there is an adjustment process, and we must logically wait to see what extent it has in the realm of what is the construction sector, the real estate sector. It is true that public works are very strong, but we have the capacity, I insist, to incorporate into other sectors where there is a demand for activity.

I just gave the figure: we have an 80 percent unemployment protection rate, meaning that the vast majority of people who may be or who lose a job are protected and must be, logically, willing, and the public authorities must facilitate their reemployment.

Moderator.- Is there a certain, I don't know if to use the word, fear or special concern on the part of the Government regarding the fact that a large sector of those new unemployed from the construction or brick sector, to put it simply, are immigrants?

President.- I believe it will be the same proportion as our labor market, approximately. That is the logical and reasonable thing.

No, there is no special fear regarding that figure.

Moderator.- We change the subject. More questions about the economic situation and growth. They ask the following: in light of the forecasts from major international organizations, wouldn't it be more realistic for the Government to lower its growth estimate for 2008 from the current 3.1 percent to a rate closer to 2 percent?

President.- We only have one parameter to evaluate who has been closer to what has happened in these four years, whether the Government or those who have predicted, who were not from the Government, about the growth of our economy. The Government has been prudent.

Moderator.- Who are you referring to?

President.- To the consensus, to what they call the consensus, and to organizations like the International Monetary Fund, the European Commission, and the OECD.

The Spanish economy has grown by 0.6 percent on average annually more than what was predicted, let’s say, by various international organizations, and the Spanish economy has grown more than the Government's own forecasts, which, being the head of the Department of Economy and Finance someone like Pedro Solbes, should not surprise anyone, because I think everyone will recognize that, if the Vice President of Economic Affairs has any virtue, among many others, it is prudence and moderation. He has always made an economic growth forecast that has been a little below.

Consequently, we maintain that in the Legislature, a tenth up, a tenth down, the potential of the Spanish economy is to be around 3 percent, which is good growth. It is true that in the first quarter of 2007 we were at 4.1 percent, but it is exceptional growth, it is outstanding growth or honors.

Therefore, when there is an international context of a slowdown in the cycle or a halt in the cycle, which has lasted many years of growth in the economy, it is logical that our economy is affected; but it will be affected in very reasonable terms, because, as I have just explained, I believe with considerable detail, we have great assets that we did not have four years ago.

Four years ago we had some deficit, now we have a surplus; four years ago we had debt ten points higher than now over GDP, now we have debt at excellent levels, and four years ago there had not been an investment in R&D+i that has multiplied our technological potential by two and a half times. In fact, in 2006, the last available data, spending on R&D+i was already 1.20 percent for the Spanish economy. Is it little? Yes, in relation to Europe, but it had not risen that much in fifteen years. And the figure for 2007 will be an increase due to the volume of investment we have made in R&D+i and that companies must also accompany.

There are three million more people working. That is facing the situation in better conditions. Our companies have benefits, a situation, and a much more powerful technological renewal. We are gaining market shares worldwide because exports are doing very well, better than in other countries. So we have many assets.

I do not want to refer to the infrastructures, which also matter. Furthermore, as I have reiterated at this moment, we are going to expedite the plans regarding High Speed and regarding highways. We are already at a strong pace of investment, but we will even expedite them to help the entire construction sector or we will launch that kind of Renovation Plan for housing rehabilitation, which will also help the real estate sector.

Moderator.- Speaking of infrastructures, allow me to ask you about a very specific infrastructure, which we have talked about a lot in recent months. Will there be time to inaugurate the AVE to Barcelona before March 9?

President.- It will not be inaugurated. We are already in the electoral call period and there is a legal regime, as is logical, that does not allow inaugurations. I, of course, will not inaugurate it, but I do plan to use it.

Moderator.- We continue with economic matters. They ask: tomorrow the European Central Bank meets in a context of significant inflationary tensions; they recall, 3.2 percent in the eurozone and 4.4 percent in January in Spain. Should the Central Bank take these price increases more into account than the economic slowdown?

President.- As President of the Government, one has great freedom of expression. It is evident that normally, with prudence, one can say almost everything one thinks, but...

Moderator.- One moment, I will pause. Did you say "with prudence" looking at the Apostolic Nuncio?

President.- No, it is...

Moderator.- Did he betray you...?

President.- It is a back-and-forth that the Nuncio and I have.

Moderator.- Explain it to me later.

President.- I wanted to say that one of the things that has always been conveyed to me, and in the end I have verified that it is so, is that where a President of the Government must be most careful is when referring to the European Central Bank. That is to say, this is the "sancta sanctorum." Any insinuation or any request, let alone, is very poorly viewed from all areas, and one must preserve very much what the autonomy and independence of the European Central Bank represent.

That said—I do not say this, the markets say it—the markets say that sooner or later the European Central Bank will lower rates, that it will perhaps start with a quarter, that it will reach half a point, and that this is a scenario, in six months, that the markets— I insist, the President of the Government does not say this—are putting on the table.

Moderator.- There is also a question about inflation, and I suppose it relates to the elections. It says: do you not think that ordinary people vote more based on the price of milk or oil than on the big macroeconomic debate topics?

President.- I have a great opinion of people, and therefore, I do not think so. I believe that people vote for their ideas, vote for the political project that is offered to them before the citizenry, and vote for whom they trust and find most credible. I have no doubt about that. Among other things, I have lived it firsthand.

It is evident that when we won the elections four years ago, there were many aspects of collective life that matter to people as much as any material aspect. Fortunately, we have this country. Furthermore, there is no empirical data, but rather the opposite, that certain food prices are now higher or have grown more than in the previous period. I invite you to compare the evolution of food price increases in these four years to the previous four years, because we might be surprised. But I do not want to put forward arguments that I reserve for another debate.

Moderator.- And why will it be for another debate? You have it... Don’t do this to me, because since you are here...

President.- Because I have two debates ahead with Mr. Rajoy and I do not want to...

Moderator.- Ah! Well. You were referring to those. That’s another matter. In the end, will there be debates? What is going on?

President.- My conviction is that there will be debates. There must be debates. Citizens have the right to have debates. I called for them when I was the candidate, apparently, with the least possibilities against the ruling party, and therefore, out of commitment to my own conviction and ethics, I have offered a debate now that, theoretically, the one occupying the most favorable position is the President of the Government.

I also say: we must, just as with the economy, make a perspective for the future. It would be very desirable that the formula in which we resolve how to hold the two debates to which Rajoy and I have committed would already be a formula that is established in our democracy for future contenders. It would be, as happens in most countries, that, whether by one form or another, by political convention or even by some norm, there is already a model of debates that is not discussed every time there are elections. I believe it would be a step for a democratically mature country.

I express my opinion and with this I leave the debates, because this is a topic that the Secretary of Organization is handling, by the way, today is his birthday and I congratulate him, and I believe it is up to him to articulate it.

My opinion and my position are that in a democratic and plural society everyone has the right to witness and to transmit or broadcast a debate between the two candidates for President of the Government, and that the parties are not the ones to exclude or to choose; we are not the ones. It is the citizens who must have the right to say: I want to see the debate on this, this, or this channel and, of course, through all the means that may be available on the network. This is a democratic principle and here we are in a matter that affects the democracy of the citizens and not any other type of issue; to democracy, which belongs to the citizens. We are not the parties who, either to exclude or to choose.

Moderator.- We return to the purely economic issue. I have many questions regarding the 400 euros, but I will include it in the fiscal chapter and I will combine a couple of questions.

The first one says: will the deduction of 400 euros in the personal income tax be the first measure of a deep reform of the tax? I take the opportunity to ask you what you can reveal about that reform; if the part that is withheld in each of the brackets will be reduced and to what extent. Then, they also ask how many years you foresee, if you win the elections, that you will have to apply that deduction of 400 euros.

President.- The second is easy: indefinitely, until, if applicable, another reform of the personal income tax occurs, which is not on the priority calendar.

The deduction of 400 euros in the quota is a reform of the personal income tax and, therefore, it is a reduction. That is the reduction that will be incorporated as a priority measure as soon as we take office, if we win the elections, just like the submission to Parliament of the Bill for the abolition of the Wealth Tax. These are two fiscal measures that have, logically, importance.

They are measures, both the reduction of 400 euros and the Wealth Tax, aimed at stimulating the economy, savings, and purchasing power. They can contribute, certainly the one that affects the personal income tax, to a dynamization of half a point of the Gross Domestic Product, to the creation of one hundred thousand jobs, and also to help purchasing power after we have had, objectively, a rise in the Euribor, and therefore in part of the mortgages in our country, and also in prices, which everyone anticipates will moderate by the end of the year to below 3 percent.

Moderator.- There is also a question related to the fiscal issue: is lowering taxes a leftist position, as you claimed four years ago?

President.- Lowering taxes, with a progressive orientation, yes. There can be fiscal reforms that are unjust or economically inconvenient and others that are not.

I have an instrumental position regarding taxation, not dogmatic-ideological. Taxation in a democracy is a structural, determining component. Taxes must be defended, they must be defended conceptually and not make it easy for demagoguery. I defend that there must be taxes and appropriate taxes in a country to finance public services, to distribute wealth, to innovate, and to prepare for the future. But, when an economy grows, like ours, and grows strongly, and when we can also present a competitive factor in relation to other countries regarding tax pressure or Corporate Taxes, getting closer to the average or improving it, lowering taxes can often be progressive.

I believe that for some time we should disbelieve in fundamentalism and I position myself regarding fiscal policy as an instrumental factor, depending on what it represents. A society that is capable of having less tax pressure and at the same time more economic activity and having policies to promote social cohesion, I believe everyone would agree to that. It is quite evident.

Spain has a positive differential in relation to the whole of the European Union, it has a lower tax pressure and it is allowing us to make very substantial advances in the Welfare State.

Therefore, taxes, yes; reasonable and doing things well, and they can be reduced. The most important thing for having the confidence that the debate in the future in this country will not be, in a broad time horizon, about raising taxes is how we have the debt, because with such a low level of debt in relation to GDP our financing capacity is very high. Therefore, we can tell future generations that they will live in a country where, surely, they will pay less taxes.

Moderator.- I have many questions related to more "macro" topics and business decisions or business doubts, rather; but I also have many questions related to pure politics, so to speak, if everything above is not, and I will pose them to you now in between.

President.- For me, politics is always pure.

Moderator.- Yes, but you understand me. I will raise these issues and then I will return to the economic topic.

They ask: are you --understood as the Socialist Party-- bluffing when you talk about renegotiating the agreements between the State and the Holy See after March 9?

President.- I don’t know who said that.

Moderator.- Umm!

President.- It is evident that that possibility is always open, always; but whenever it is opened, it will be to do it with dialogue and consensus. Always.

The Nuncio is here and I have…

Moderator.- Take the opportunity to say…

President.- I have affection for him. I have expressed myself and I express myself clearly. There have been some things in recent times that, in my opinion, should not have occurred on the part of some prominent Cardinals and in the note from the Episcopal Conference there are some parts that I cannot accept and that I have to respond to.

I will be very explicit, because I also have the opportunity to respond to some of the things that have been said in recent days by some bishops; with the utmost respect. It is true that in the notes of 2000 and 2004 there was reference to terrorism by the Episcopal Conference, in one line; to a condemnation of terrorism, as could not be otherwise. But it is the first time that in a note from the Episcopal Conference there is a reflection, a general consideration, about dialogue, non-dialogue, legitimacy or non-legitimacy. It is the first time in a note prior to elections.

Therefore, things in their place and, if not, let them review the notes prior to the elections of 2004 or 2000. I say 2004 or 2000, because in both legislatures there were, unfortunately for this country, many terrorist murders. In one specifically, there was a process of dialogue, the one that ended in the legislature of 2000, and, when the elections of 2000 were held, there was no reference in the pre-electoral note of the Episcopal Conference to the limits or to the legitimacy, and under what circumstances, of dialogue with terrorism. This is indeed a difference and this is what seems inappropriate to me, not appropriate at all.

There is another issue, secondly, and I have to say it: if there is one thing that I have not understood, which seems really unusual to me, it is regarding the subject of Education for Citizenship. It is a pure subject, a subject that simply contains educational and training materials about citizenship, about human rights, about the Constitution, about the values of coexistence, of a free Europe, of a free Europe for all and of what democracy represents. Therefore, I have to disagree in a forceful way.

That said, I have always stated that I do not keep quiet, but I do not get angry. It is my way of being for many years and I will always be willing to dialogue; but, logically, the dialogue will have to be based on greater respect: respect for what represents who embodies the popular will, democratically elected, as I have great respect for everything that represents the Episcopal Conference.

Moderator.- In this regard, allow me a couple more questions. The truth is that in the first one the expression has its charm. It says: "Mr. President, allow me the expression: has God come to see you in this campaign with the role that the Episcopal Conference is adopting in terms of mobilizing its electorate?"

President.- The truth is that they install themselves… If I heard it the other day, I even think it was some bishop, certainly some leader of the right, say that we had taken this to… If we reach a point where they say that that note from the Episcopal Conference was prepared, designed, and written by Pepe Blanco. That would be the last straw!

What would be the last straw is that, on top of the fact that we objectively receive an attack with the note, it would also benefit us? No. I would have signed beforehand that that note had not been produced in those terms, just as I would have liked that on December 30, when an event was called for the family here, in Colón, in the capital of Spain, in Madrid, it had not been said by two Cardinals what was said, in relation to the laws that legitimately emanate from a democratic Parliament, that retrogressed human rights or that certain laws dissolved democracy. That is serious in a call for the family, which, by the way, has received more support than ever in these four years. On December 30, which, as I said on one occasion, we were all happily celebrating Christmas and suddenly this event is held.

I would have liked the note from the Episcopal Conference to start and end by talking about coexistence, concord, dialogue, tolerance, solidarity, and peace. That is how I want to refer to the Episcopal Conference: words from dialogue to tolerance and concord.

Moreover, honestly, I believe that the vast majority, the great majority, of Christians in this country and of Catholics want to see that this is the tone of the relationship. With discrepancies? Of course. I understand that there are laws that will not have the backing of the ecclesiastical hierarchy, I understand that perfectly and respect their opinion; but I believe that, out of respect for so many Christians and so many Catholics, the relationship should be more respectful and more of a call to coexistence, to dialogue, and to cooperation. I believe that this is part of the Christian message.

Moderator.- I have the feeling that time is running out on me and I still have several questions to ask you. I will try to speed up.

President.- I am here to prevent time from running out on me, but well…

Moderator.- Each one in their role.

The last question already in this chapter says: when will that little broth with the Nuncio be? Take the opportunity. This is like the radio: I put you with your mother and so on. So, let’s arrange it.

President.- It will not go beyond next week, Nuncio. We cannot… Next week and we will then issue a public note.

Moderator.- Well, that’s it. Then they will say that we in the media are of no use at all.

Next question and a very serious matter as well. I have many questions regarding the issue of illegalizations or proposals for the illegalization of ANV and PCTV, from the Batasuna environment, from ETA. I will ask you some questions about this. It is a bit lengthy, but it frames it well.

It says: "the demands of the Prosecutor's Office and the State Attorney's Office show that the PTCV began hiring members of Batasuna since 2006 and that they even met at their headquarters on the day of T-4. Regarding ANV, it is known that before the elections it was controlled by Batasuna. Was the authorization for ANV to go to the elections not an attempt to save the peace process, especially at a time when, as you yourself acknowledged, new contacts with ETA had been authorized?"

President.- It is true that there is a tendency, when talking about the fight against terrorism and, specifically, about the illegalization of political formations that may be linked to what ETA represents, to draw conclusions based on political indications; but we are talking about a judicial and legal procedure, where political indications are not sufficient nor serve to substantiate an illegalization in the terms that the Constitutional Court has established, which are demanding from the point of view of material evidence and from the point of view of the accumulation of circumstances to reach a conclusion, and that is that a political formation acts by substituting or succeeding the illegalized Batasuna.

One circumstance is not enough, one fact is not enough; an accumulation is required in a work that, as is well known, requires a lot of skill and dedication from the Police and the Civil Guard. The work has been done in time and form. The best proof is that sufficient data has been accumulated to raise the appropriate demand. But we must have respect, both for the ongoing criminal procedure, which is in the hands of Judge Baltasar Garzón, and for what affects the Chamber of Article 61; respect.

Regarding the last issue, concerning the ANV part, everyone knows that ANV is a party that has existed for many years, with practically minimal activity, without representation in institutions, and that in the previous municipal elections emerged with a very high number of lists. For the party to be considered, from a legal point of view, I insist, not political but judicial, as a successor, with all the consequences that entails, of Batasuna, it seems quite reasonable that it has deployed some time its organizational and financial activity. Fortunately, that activity is now known and yields a series of results. But it was very difficult for someone who practically did not exist at a given moment or who simply existed formally but had very little representation to be evaluated for a process of party illegalization. This was stated, by the way, by the Constitutional Court when it had to resolve the demands as a consequence of the illegalization of part of the lists of Acción Nacionalista Vasca.

Therefore, I can understand what the political indications represent, which may be in the minds of many, but in a rule of law, what matters are the indications and the materially and legally proven facts.

Moderator.- Breaking news. Europe Press reports, of course: "Garzón charges three leaders of the PTCV for collaborating with ETA." This was decided a few minutes ago, I take the opportunity.

We change the subject and return to the economic issue. I have, I am not exaggerating, ten or twelve questions, in a thousand different ways, about the topic of Iberdrola. I will ask you several questions. The first: has EDF or Mr. Sarkozy himself informed you of their interest in Iberdrola?

President.- No.

Moderator.- He says yes.

President.- Both the French Government and some other European governments have an interest and have had an interest in entering the Spanish electricity sector, as, by the way, our companies have an interest, and I as a government support it on many occasions, in being present in European countries and in countries from other continents in the electricity, telecommunications, construction sectors, etc., etc.

Does EDF have an interest in being in Spain? Yes. In what specific operation? It corresponds to the companies and, of course, I have no information on what that attempt may be, if it occurs. Therefore, when it happens, to the extent that the regulatory bodies will have to express themselves, we can engage in the debate.

Now, that different electricity companies from our European partners are interested in being in the Spanish market, I say "yes." Since when have I seen that interest? Since I took office as President of the Government. France, Germany, Italy, and some others.

Moderator.- It is evident that if they have an interest, they have it, and there is nothing more to discuss; but the question is whether it is feasible or at least debatable that this interest comes from a public company. That is an important nuance in this matter.

President.- Of course. It certainly is.

Moderator.- And?

President.- We will see.

Moderator.- We will see what? Don't leave it like that. Do you think..?

President.- We will see, one, if it occurs; two, under what circumstances; three, under what conditions. But let’s not jump ahead.

As President of the Government, what do I say? One, respect the rules of the market and the regulatory bodies. Two, my desire is that, logically, we have the appropriate strength in the Spanish electricity sector that suits us for our economy, for our presence abroad. Of course. That, logically, is part of a commitment and I have tried to practice it on more than one occasion. And, three, if there are processes of good understanding, better.

Moderator.- They ask about this, to close this chapter, if the interconnection with France through the Pyrenees is a "political trading card."

President.- I imagine this question is not being asked by a diplomat.

Moderator.- To tell you the truth, it was mine, but if you don’t mind…

President.- The electrical interconnection is a vital necessity for Spain, especially for Catalonia and Girona; a vital necessity for its economy and, logically, its future possibilities. The first papers on the electrical interconnection have existed for more than twenty-five years and now it is going to happen, regardless of EDF's desire, greater or lesser, to be present in the Spanish electricity market. It is going to happen regardless of that.

That said, and although we have different political colors, you know that I have and will preserve the best possible relationship with the Government of France, with the President of the Republic, with Sarkozy, because it is of great strategic interest for Spain.

Moderator.- Last question. Other colleagues have also posed it in many ways, but I will read this one. It says: "Do you mean that those catastrophic messages contaminate the economy and thus hinder investment by companies and consumption by individuals? Is this type of message what is undermining confidence?"

President.- A message out of reality, an exaggerated message, does not help confidence; it is evident. First, in this case, it is out of reality, with the data of the Spanish economy. Second, I believe that the best way to convey confidence is to explain things as they are. And I have said: is there a slowdown? Yes, but under good conditions of the Spanish economy. Where will the slowdown occur? Where will the adjustment be? Clearly, in the real estate sector. Do we have the capacity to absorb what that represents? Yes, and we have it because we have a surplus, because the financial sector is sound and, therefore, it will allow us to continue growing reasonably during the Legislature.

Therefore, the message must be one of confidence to companies, who will appreciate that the landscape of credit difficulties clears up as soon as possible, and I am fully aware of that; but we must be very careful with this issue and, logically, I believe that any exaggerated or catastrophic message does not correspond to reality, nor does it help, nor does it stimulate anyone, neither entrepreneurs nor workers.

Honestly, if I aspired, as I do, but were in the opposition now, to govern, it would be the last thing I would do; honestly, the last thing I would do. If one truly believes that they will have the responsibility of governing the country, of steering the ship, it is logical to have security and confidence in the possibilities of this country, in its entrepreneurs and in its workers.

I, of course, always went to the elections, four years ago, having confidence in what could be done in Spain. Pessimism has not created a single job in history. So imagine some of those who can destroy.

Moderator.- I just want to express my gratitude, truly, on behalf of Europe Press, because we have been very insistent in organizing this event and I believe it has been worth it.

President.- Thank you very much.