Interview with the President of the Government on the program "Hoy por hoy," from Cadena SER.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

27 September 2009 · Interview on the program "Hoy por hoy" (Cadena SER)

Context
Zapatero was interviewed on Cadena SER's morning program 'Hoy por hoy' on September 27, 2009, discussing Spain's 2010 budget amid the economic crisis.
Main themes
Economic crisis and recovery, state budget 2010, unemployment and job creation, public deficit and debt management, social protection policy, R&D and education investment, tax increases, fiscal responsibility, government decision-making, Spanish economy outlook
Duration
~78 min
97th percentile
Words
9,403
97th percentile
Sentences
423
97th percentile
Readability
55
77th percentile
Grade
11.0
32nd percentile
Syntax
2.98
45th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

423 sentences in 179 paragraphs

President.- Good morning.

C. Francino.- When was the last time someone told you, "José Luis, you are mistaken"?

President.- I read it today in the press.

C. Francino.- No, no; but from your own, from the Government or the party. Who was the last to say, or when, "Hey! You are getting this wrong"?

President.- It is not an expression that is usually used. We can discuss a decision, debate it, and then, normally, we take it by broad agreement.

C. Francino.- But among your closest advisors, do you have many voices lately telling you, "Be careful!"?

President.- No. Among my closest advisors, what I have is always a voice of encouragement and support, which seems logical in a project that is shared, in a project that depends on the well-being of many people and that, moreover, has had the backing of more than eleven million citizens at the polls.

C. Francino.- For better or for worse, these are the Budgets of the crisis; we can agree on that, but surely a year or a year and a half ago, no one thought the numbers would have to be squared this way. Reviewing data the other day, I believe it was April 29 when you first said, "The worst may be over." Five months have passed, and has the worst already passed, yes or no?

President.- Yes. The G-20 has also expressed it that way. I believe that the hardest moment of the recession occurred in the first and second quarters of this year, and now we still have a great task ahead of us. Certainly, economic recovery should begin in 2010, but the fundamental issue will be the recovery of employment, especially in our economy; and, in the meantime, social protection for unemployment and for all the people who have found themselves in that very tough and difficult situation.

C. Francino.- When will we start creating net jobs, Mr. President? When is it estimated?

President.- It is premature to make a prediction. It has to correspond with a certain growth of the Spanish economy. We hope that in the second quarter of 2010 we can see some positive signs in that regard.

C. Francino.- The Budgets approved last Saturday in the Council and that enter Congress tomorrow have some very clear fundamental lines: that of social policy, without a doubt, which is also a hallmark of your Government, and it always has been, with more than half dedicated to that item. Then there is R&D and Education as stimuli for job creation. Is it known what cut will be applied to the R&D item, or not yet?

President.- No, there is no cut in the R&D item.

C. Francino.- Nothing? Zero?

President.- Zero. It is practically the same amount as last year's Budget. We have made an effort because we cannot stop everything that is our national research system, the plans that exist, to consolidate being the ninth scientific power, as we are already at this moment, and to achieve that we can transfer it to companies and productive activity, which is the great challenge that the Spanish economy faces.

C. Francino.- Regardless of whether the numbers will be met later, because that is never known in economics, the deficit forecast of 5.4 percent for next year is an ambitious target. Does Spain not still have the capacity to incur debt and, therefore, increase its deficit now that the priority is to stop the hemorrhage of unemployment? Shouldn't that come first?

President.- We are going to have a forecast of a State deficit of 5.4 percent, and we will have to add to that the Autonomous Administrations and local Administrations.

C. Francino.- We are going to be close to 10 percent.

President.- No, not that much. That is in 2010, although this year we are also going to have a very high deficit. It is true that someone could say: "Let's stretch the deficit for more years." The problem is that the deficit of each year translates into public debt. We have public debt twenty points below the average of the European Union, and we want to maintain, and I want to maintain, that we are at a reasonable level of debt. Why? Because I feel responsible, as President of the Government, for the present and the future of my country, and I do not want to leave future generations and future Governments a debt that would necessarily force us to either have a significant tax increase in the medium term or cut social spending and investment policies.

That is why in this Budget we are taking measures: one, to save all we can; two, to make a call for citizens to contribute more so that we can continue to maintain social policy and productive policy, without mortgaging the future.

Surely, it would be easier for me to say: "I won't touch a tax, I will keep pulling from debt, and let the future of the country be damned." No. I believe that the responsibility of a leader, even if it means making an unpleasant decision, to tell citizens that we are going to raise taxes, is to do things when they need to be done and also thinking about the future, even thinking about the future when you are not in Government, but thinking about the future of the country.

Our country has a low tax burden, as we are six or seven points below the European average, and therefore, I believe that an effort of one point is manageable.

C. Francino.- Do you maintain that this tax increase will fall on the highest incomes, on the rich, to put it a little more plainly?

President.- There is one very evident fact: the most considerable impact in terms of the wealth capacity of citizens will occur among those citizens who have capital income, which is where the volume of people with the most wealth is concentrated, which are 150,000 or 200,000 people. They will contribute an average increase of about six thousand or seven thousand euros a year. Of course, they are few, because there is a large middle class; they are few, and therefore, the overall result of what we expect to collect from the increase from 18 to 21 percent on savings income amounts to eight hundred million; but that will be concentrated on the wealthiest people in this country, to whom we will impose a considerable tax, I insist, around six thousand or seven thousand euros is an average, because there will be some for whom it will mean twenty-five thousand euros a year.

However, below, as you know, people earning up to twelve thousand euros, those earning a thousand euros a month, the four hundred euros do not affect them; the average worker will have a contribution of the four hundred euros that, I want to remind you, was a measure we adopted at a time when there was a significant price increase, with inflation at 5 percent and the Euribor and mortgages skyrocketing, to help in that situation. It was the only instrument we had as a Government, and that situation has disappeared because today prices are even in negative inflation, and the Euribor has fallen to historic lows. Therefore, the capacity of the people who maintain their jobs, 80 percent or eighty-something percent of the working population, has improved, and now I ask them for an effort.

I will give just one piece of data, and this is the choice of the country we want; just one piece of data: the tax increase represents, in this year's estimate, ten billion euros, and what the Government will have to put to pay unemployment benefits for the year 2010 is fifteen billion euros, fifteen billion that come from taxes. What they contribute through contributions is another similar amount, but that is not enough with contributions. So, we have to put in fifteen billion euros.

I want a solidarity country where, if there is a situation like we have now with unemployment, we have almost 2,700,000 people protected against unemployment, and that can be done thanks to a contribution, we understand, that is moderate in a country with a limited tax burden like ours, from the majority, and especially from those with the highest incomes.

C. Francino.- In any case, let me return to the four hundred euros and the averages, because I remember that when that measure was implemented, we discussed it in another interview. One thing is universal decisions, like the four hundred euros, and another is discretionary; that is, now the Corporate Tax is lowered for small and medium-sized enterprises determined by turnover, number of workers, etc.; and aid is given to the unemployed without benefits of 420 euros, which is a specific group. Don't universal aids end up being unfair in practice? That is, four hundred euros for someone earning a thousand euros a month is indeed a considerable amount; for one of those high or medium incomes, well...

President.- We are talking about labor income, and I have always made an important distinction. I believe that in a modern country, from any perspective, we cannot have the same consideration when treating labor income as we do with capital income. That is why we have now established a progressivity and a notable increase for capital income, which, on the other hand, if one analyzes it, because it is easy to analyze, is where the people who have money in this country, who have significant wealth, are really located.

C. Francino.- No, no; who saves.

President.- Who saves or who has had income for whatever circumstances, or because they have done very well in their businesses, or because they have had a significant inheritance… for whatever circumstances arise, or because they have been lucky, which also happens. The truth is that they have that wealth, and consequently, they must contribute much more.

But I believe that labor income should… The Personal Income Tax already has a clear progressivity, and in an action like the return of the four hundred euros, it was first about having the measure affect everyone because everyone was logically affected by the price increase. For some, it represented, logically, a more relevant amount in relative terms than for others; but we thought that all those who contributed through their work could have it. In other words, and also adding the argument, the inefficiency in management when a universal return is made, trying to do something selective also accompanied this idea.

C. Francino.- Mr. President, who are the powerful people you refer to who do not agree with your economic policy? Who are the powerful? Botín, González, Florentino Pérez, Brufau, Fainé, Polanco? Who are those powerful people you refer to?

President.- I will not name names.

C. Francino.- If not… "The powerful" is such a vague concept… You are powerful because you are the President of the Government, right?

President.- For me, during this crisis, I will say yes, it will be easily understood that they are all those who have been asking the Government to lower the conditions for dismissal and to make a labor reform to restrict workers' rights, while at the same time asking for a reduction in contributions and, on the other hand, every time there is a problem in a business sector, they come to ask for aid, and I don't care if it is the automobile or tourism. These are the powerful, for me; all those whose priority in a crisis like this is different from that of the Government.

The Government's priority is social protection; it is the rights of workers; it is maintaining a country that has a Dependency Law and reaches five hundred thousand people as it is currently doing; it is maintaining the increase in scholarships that we have made to help people with more difficulties; it is maintaining the 140,000 young people who this year will receive housing rental assistance to emancipate themselves for two hundred euros a month, or it is maintaining the effort we have made in R&D+i, where we have almost tripled the investment since we have been in Government to position ourselves as the ninth industrial power.

That is the sense I have of the country, and I believe it is a sense that is closer to the majority of citizens, who do not agree that the crisis should translate into a loss of labor rights and a restriction of social policies. That is the other alternative we would have in those circumstances.

C. Francino.- A labor reform, Mr. President, understood not only as a possible reduction in dismissal costs; a labor reform is necessary. Spain needs it, right? Yes or no?

President.- And it also needs to reform some things in the business sphere.

C. Francino.- And when?

President.- It has to be the result of negotiation and social dialogue between employers and unions, fundamentally, which has given us success. But, let’s not deceive ourselves, when labor reform has been discussed in this crisis, above all, it has been about making dismissal cheaper, about de-judicializing or removing dismissals from judicial review. This has been discussed; that is, that employers have even more freedom and workers have fewer rights. Or, in other words, that there is a transfer of income from workers to companies because, if it costs less, it is evident that workers have fewer rights in the event of dismissal, and less income, and employers would have more.

This is what I mean by "the powerful." I sincerely believe they lack a vision of the country and a certain sensitivity because, when there is an economic crisis that causes such a strong loss of employment, one of the things that a part of the workers who can or are in that situation of losing their jobs has is their severance pay.

What we need in this country is not so much to change labor legislation, which has proven to create jobs during periods of growth like no other country, but to improve our productive system. It is not about having worse contracts for workers, no; it is about having better jobs, and for there to be better jobs, there has to be a part of the economy that is more productive, more modern, and more innovative.

C. Francino.- Mr. President, this speech, which I am sure many listeners who are now listening to the radio fundamentally share, surely, listeners of SER, is almost, almost, I won't say a declaration of war, but something very belligerent against the employers, against the business owners. I don't know if Díaz Ferrán represents all the business owners in this country, I don't know; but this, if one observes from the outside the social dialogue and the possible outcomes...

President.- No, no. Careful! There are many business owners who have not raised issues with me...

C. Francino.- That's what I'm getting at.

President.- ...but there are others who have, insistently.

C. Francino.- So, this is a criticism of the CEOE, not of the business owners.

President.- It is a disagreement.

C. Francino.- Well... A disagreement.

President.- In a democracy, the Government has its project and its option, and there will be others, without a doubt, and we have examples that are eloquent.

In the economic crisis, we have had a great impact on unemployment, which is my great concern. You see, it is easy from the opposition to propose things; well, the Popular Party did not think to propose any further aid to people who were left without unemployment protection, and the Government did it with the proposal of 420 euros for those who lose their benefit for six months with a training course. Why? Because it is not their policy, because they do not care about social policy. For example, eight years in the Government of the PP and not a euro for dependent people in this country. Now we are already at 1.5 billion for the Dependency Law and this year we are going to assist five hundred thousand people.

Well, there will be many people in this country, and I believe many workers, who will say that if to have that model of the Welfare State, which is such a reference for us in Europe, we have to make a certain effort now that our VAT, for example, which is the lowest VAT in the entire European Union... There is only one or two countries below us. It is now at 16 percent and we are going to raise it to 18 percent. It is a small effort from each one, for some more than for others, obviously, but to maintain a country in which we can feel recognized as a country.

What is being a country? Above all, it is being a country that shares the destiny of the majority. How do I want to get out of the economic crisis? There is much debate about whether we will get out sooner or later; but for me, as important as it being a month or a quarter earlier or later is that we all get out together and that we get out with maximum social cohesion and social stability in this country. And for me and for the majority, the concern is the people who have lost that job. First, let us protect them with a benefit while they do not find another job.

I want to emphasize that when we talk about the number of unemployed we have, they are not always the same, as there are people who lose their jobs and then find another job; that is to say, there is a percentage of people who are in that risk situation. When I say that this year we are going to dedicate fifteen billion euros to protect those people and I ask citizens for revenues of ten billion euros, we are, I believe, in a conception of country, which at least I fully share, which is solidarity, feeling like a member of a community and knowing that this community will not leave you in a desperate situation; it will help you. It may be today, one; tomorrow, another.

C. Francino.- The unemployment statistics, the ones we have on the table now, do you endorse them? Are they one hundred percent reliable?

President.- We must respect the unemployment statistics, as is logical.

C. Francino.- I say this because there are some voices, and moreover voices from the Socialist Party or the Government, that do not question them, but say: "careful! We are providing the 420 euro aid and few are signing up." Where are the unemployed?

President.- The only thing we must keep in mind, and it is true that this would deserve an analysis for which now is not the time, is that when it is said "the Spanish unemployment rate is the highest in the European Union," it has always been like that, we have always had a comparatively higher unemployment rate. I believe there is some structural or social reason, but this is an objective fact and, therefore, cannot be wielded.

When we were at the moment of greatest economic growth in 2007, when we reached the lowest unemployment rate in our history, while we were governing, we were at 8 percent and there was a massive influx of immigrants. Why? Because there was employment and yet the unemployment rate was still at 8 percent. I believe we have some structural or social reason and that makes us always have a higher unemployment rate. The truth is that around 1.3 million or 1.4 million jobs have been lost in the crisis, which is a very, very tough, very high figure, and we have to help them today, support them today, and as soon as we can see the recovery, dedicate all our efforts to job creation.

To do this, we need to have budgets that maintain investment in infrastructure, because we are talking about 23 billion euros and we are going to be next year the country with the highest speed in the world and with the most highways; that is future and that is economic progress; maintain investment in R&D+i and make a reasonable transition to a more sustainable economic model.

But, in crisis or in prosperity, that people feel the support of their country if they have difficulties; in crisis or in prosperity that dependents have aid; in crisis or in prosperity that scholarships continue to increase and in crisis or in prosperity that young people have housing assistance.

This is the country and the model we are defending.

C. Francino.- This is your model. At any moment, I am not saying if you have thought about it, at any moment have you seriously tried to reach an agreement with Rajoy; a great agreement against the crisis? Have you really tried at any time, Mr. President?

President.- I am going to give my very clear opinion. I believe that the leadership or the way Rajoy has of doing politics, in what I have seen in this time... He has been disinterested. Rajoy is disinterested in the problems, in the big problems, because he only has one interest, and you only have to listen to him day by day, which is to disqualify the Government. That has been his trajectory and, even so, I am going to try, because I am going to call him in the coming days, at least, so that we can reach an agreement on two crucial future issues for this country, which are education and energy, where we are playing a good part of that economic model, of our well-being and of our wealth.

But, objectively, there are so many disqualifications and so few ideas and fewer proposals, and sometimes with a double game and a certain hypocrisy, because now with taxes he is raising criticism, as I have heard in recent hours...; but at the same time, he says that more money should be given to the Town Halls and, surely, when we have the budget debate, they will ask for more high speed in their territories; and, at the same time, their regional presidents, when we negotiated regional financing, all asked us for more resources for the Autonomous Communities.

So, of course, that is not serious, it is not responsible and, if you adopt a true policy of saying that budget items must be cut, the only response that leads to that, the only consequence, is that you have to say which ones; tell your Town Halls not to ask for more money, not to endorse those theses or tell your Autonomous Communities not to ask for more money, because, I even want to remind you that of what will be the revenues we will have from the tax increase, part will go to the Autonomous Communities and another to the Town Halls: two billion euros will go to the Autonomous Communities and eight hundred million will go to the Town Halls.

So, either one thing or the other.

C. Francino.- I want to ask you something about the Gürtel case. I imagine that listeners can guess what your opinion is on the accusations against the police and prosecutors for using, etc., etc. I want to ask you for a slightly different perspective. Years ago, as a socialist militant, when the "Filesa" scandal broke, what did you feel as a socialist militant? Did you feel shame or did you feel that this could never happen again? This sounds a bit, it reminds a bit, and we will see how it ends. What did you feel?

President.- I felt concern; logically, a sense of responsibility and that when there is a problem in any political party, what its leaders have to do is correct it and face it.

I do not want to prejudge because we are in a State of Law and we must wait for the evolution of judicial decisions, but what does seem absolutely unusual to me, and is good proof of the idea I just conveyed about the style, is always to disassociate oneself, not to assume any responsibility, neither for the big problems of the country, nor, in this case, for what may happen in the party. That is the tone that seems to me, and blaming others I think is the most inconvenient and absurd thing there is.

C. Francino.- I ask you this, and I go back a little to the beginning, and do not prejudge: in "Filesa", if you remember, the first reaction is to deny everything; then, to denounce a persecution; in the third instance, to close ranks as best as possible from the outside and, finally, in one way or another, reality imposes itself.

I get the impression that the "Gürtel" case is going to end more or less the same, but we are still in the third phase, in the one of closing ranks and denouncing persecution. Hey, is this an endemic evil of our system, of our democracy? Is disagreement always prohibited? Do we always have to follow the orders of the leader, the boss, whatever it is and whoever it is? It is a general reflection that I ask you, eh!

President.- I believe that what we have to do is work and make the functioning of political parties as transparent as possible, that judicial actions are respected, to have enough calm to have that confidence in the functioning of our institutions and let them work. Certainly, given how the Popular Party acts or responds, and in my capacity as President of the Government, I must be as prudent as possible. The most prudent thing is simply to make a call for confidence to the citizens that the institutions work well, the State of Law always prevails, sooner or later, and political parties must assume, as is natural, our responsibilities in the different circumstances that may arise.

C. Francino.- And in the PSOE, Mr. President? You know, I know, and many people know that there are disagreements, and you mentioned it earlier: economic policy, the way the tax debate has been handled, etc., etc. Those voices, however, do not usually project in public opinion. A Federal Committee is convened...

President.- Well, it is already difficult, eh!

C. Francino.- I am also surprised, that is why I mention it.

President.- I can assure you because I can assure you that the PSOE is a fairly transparent party. I say this because when we hold a meeting of the party's Executive, then, the next day, I see almost everything that is said there.

In my opinion, the truth is different. I believe that the truth is that the Socialist Party has great support for the Government, for which I am immensely grateful. If there is something I have said on some occasion is that I feel like a political leader who, from the first day I was elected Secretary General of the Socialist Party nine years ago, in July 2000, has had impressive support from my party, from the militants and from the leaders. I have felt it every day, I felt it yesterday and I feel it today.

The Socialist Party is responsible for the situation, supporting its Government in a difficult situation, with a recession that is the strongest, the most serious, in sixty years in the world and committed to two essential ideas: one, while this recession lasts, this Socialist Party, which has values, ideas, and commitments, will help those who have the most difficulties, even if we have to make the effort to ask a part of society for a tax increase, because they are our convictions, our idea of country; two, we are focused on making the Spanish economy grow with more productivity and more innovation, and for that we have been working since 2004.

Earlier I gave you a figure: we have almost tripled investment in R&D+i; it was not reaching three billion and now we are at eight billion euros. Researchers know this well, who surely want more, as is logical.

But the effort in four years is spectacular, as is in social cohesion, and I explained it a moment ago. Notice that today we have a lower tax burden than when I arrived in Government. We are at 33 percent tax pressure, and when we came to Government, we were at 34.5 percent. And, with a lower tax burden today, we have a minimum pension increase of 30 percent; a Dependency Law; a childbirth aid of 2,500 euros; doubling the spending on scholarships; providing assistance to young people for rent and the Equality Law with new paternity leave. It is a remarkable expansion of social policy in four years, and the tax burden is somewhat lower than when we arrived in Government.

Now, with this tax effort that I ask of citizens, we will be at a tax burden similar to when we arrived in Government, with one difference: we have a much stronger Welfare State, we have more social policy, we have more social rights, and we have more help for people, yes; especially for those who need it the most. But that is our political project.

C. Francino.- Mr. President, I return to the internal health, to the internal situation of the Socialist Party, which is the party in Government. Is there anyone in the PSOE under suspicion? I ask you this because a report from the newspaper "El Mundo," which cited sources from La Moncloa, and to my knowledge has not been denied, spoke of a kind of, now that it is fashionable, risk audits on three members of the Government. Is there anyone under suspicion in the PSOE? You in the Executives ask them to look for enemies outside, that the enemy is not within. Is there anyone who sees ghosts inside?

President.- Absolutely not, absolutely not.

C. Francino.- And that information?

President.- I am completely unaware of it.

I reiterate, the PSOE is a party with strength and unity at this moment, in this historical stage, I insist, I believe it is exemplary, because I think that a virtue and a value that a political party must be required to have is that it dedicates itself above all to the problems of the people, and in a time of serious economic crisis and job loss, even more so. That makes the Government's task much easier, and, of course, I have full confidence in the Socialist Party, but full. It has shown me over these years that it is a serious and solid organization, and I believe I know the Socialist Party a little from the inside...

C. Francino.- We assume.

President.- Indeed. ...is very much in agreement with a project that has such a social commitment, because we have learned throughout our long history that politics and the exercise of politics and the public service serve, one, for the general interest of the country and, two, above all, to make an effort for those who do not have everything, for those who find it very difficult for their child to reach the University, which is why we need to increase scholarships; for those who find it very difficult to see their father or mother with a very low pension, because we come from a very poor country and we make an effort to ensure that minimum pension is higher; or for those territories that have traditionally been forgotten and now have the expectation of having High Speed; or for those researchers who until a few years ago felt undervalued compared to European research and researchers, today not...

And now what do we need as a country? We need all the business fabric and all economic activity to feel that capacity to compete. And we can do it.

C. Francino.- You have a knack for always returning to the original message, which today is... It's very good, yes.

President.- It is what I feel.

C. Francino.- Yes, that it is about fighting against the crisis and solidarity, etc., etc.

With the permission of the crisis, there is a matter on the calendar that we have half-forgotten about, and I was going to mention the pesky... Well, the Statute and the ruling of the Constitutional Court. Of course, I am not going to ask you how that ruling will be because we do not know, and virtual debates, just the right amount, right? But, are you satisfied with the entire political process of reforming this Statute, which you somehow helped to promote some time ago? Are you satisfied with how this whole process has gone?

President.- Let's give it a little perspective, as with many things that happen in politics and that have scope; let's give it perspective. Let's wait for the ruling on the Statute to occur, let's wait for the entire financing model, which is largely a consequence of the Statute, to occur, and there we will see how that project of expanding autonomous Spain, of sensitivity towards the Communities, in this case with Catalonia, with a new Statute, with more self-government and with new financing, will produce a positive effect, from my point of view, and that is that it will integrate Spain more and will allow for the consolidation of an idea: that we can share the common project of Spain, while there is a vast field for self-government, as the Statute assumes.

I believe that this is the task that I have had as a reference in this stage of Government. In my opinion, we have agreed on important steps, but there is still a bit of time left for us to have perspective, and I trust that this perspective will be positive.

C. Francino.- Is the Government studying any type of new regulation or restriction for presenting resources before the Constitutional Court? That is, to prevent the Constitutional Court from being turned into a third political chamber: "what I lose in Congress and what I lose in the Senate I try to recover in the Court"? Is the Government thinking about any type of modification?

President.- No, no. The Organic Law of the Constitutional Court is a very important law, and I believe that we must also have a guarantee in the game of the division of powers that the parliamentary minority has the recourse to go to a court, such as the Constitutional Court.

It is true that it is a special situation that a Statute of Autonomy, like the Statute of Catalonia, has a recourse, in this case from the Popular Party, which is practically against the entire Statute, because there are over one hundred sixty articles challenged. What does that mean? De facto, that the Constitutional Court is obliged to carry out an examination, an analysis, of all those articles and of the recourse that the Popular Party presents, which is a situation that is the first time that occurs in our autonomous model. That requires the Constitutional Court to do very intense work, because we are talking about many matters that are interpretable, as happens in Law and as happens when we are talking about the interpretation of the Constitution.

Therefore, let us allow the Constitutional Court to do a calm, serene, and well-founded job. And I add: this country has strong institutions. The ruling will be respected, and, as it has strong institutions and has demonstrated its democratic solidity, I trust that there will be a reasonable ruling. From the Government's perspective, as is known, we understand that the Statute is constitutional, and we express that in the parliamentary majority, but let us respect the work of the Court.

C. Francino.- Mr. President, I suppose you have spoken in recent hours with José Sócrates and Angela Merkel. What is your reading of this double electoral result that is so interesting for Europe?

President.- A reading, in principle, quite clear, and it is that in each country the electoral result occurs due to the circumstances of each country, which we already have experience with in many electoral calls. So, the idea that "there is a favorable wind for conservatives or for socialists" is not true. Each country votes based on its circumstances.

In Germany, it is evident that the SPD has received a punishment, in my opinion, as a consequence of two factors: one, of its own presence in Government in a situation where, in the end, you do not quite define your political identity and your project, and also because its leadership has changed. And in Portugal, I believe there is a clear victory of political leadership. I believe that José Sócrates has clear leadership.

I will speak with them today because they will have many calls in the evening. I spoke with José Sócrates on Saturday; he called us for another matter and was in good spirits. Logically, I congratulate both of them. I work very well with both in the European Council, and fortunately, there will be few changes regarding European policy, which I believe is what should concern us the most.

C. Francino.- Do you work with Angela Merkel as well and with such confidence as to achieve something that avoids what looms over Figueruelas, over the Opel plant, which is not good?

President.- I was talking with her precisely in Pittsburgh about this issue, about the concern we had regarding the future of the Zaragoza plant after Magna's entry into Opel. She committed to me that we would study thoroughly the entire restructuring plan. I insisted that Zaragoza is the most competitive plant that Opel has, and our teams will start working on this this week.

It is another example that I wish to invoke. No one doubts that both Opel, Renault, Ford, and Nissan will receive public aid during this period to maintain our plants; they will receive significant public aid. And I am convinced that we all think that it should be so. And I add: we must all know that this, logically, requires an effort from the whole country to maintain the maximum number of jobs.

Now we have the debate on taxes, which came to my mind because of Opel, because we are talking about very significant amounts that these companies will require in support, guarantees, and financing. Logically, we have to evaluate and measure the availabilities so that we maintain our automobile plants.

C. Francino.- Mr. President, we are talking about Europe. If Felipe González finally gets encouraged, would he be a good President of the Council? Will you support him if he decides to take that step?

President.- He would be a magnificent President of the European Council.

C. Francino.- Do you have the report that he has already prepared or do you not know it yet?

President.- I have some ideas and I will, logically, get to know it in the coming weeks directly with him. In any case, I must clarify that for now there are no candidates. We must be very prudent about this issue because, first, we need to have the ratification of the Treaty of Lisbon in hand, we need to overcome the referendum in Ireland and the situation in the Czech Republic, which is somewhat complicated and may delay what should be the entry into force of the Treaty of Lisbon; and then we will address the Presidency of the Council. But there is no doubt that Felipe González would be a magnificent President.

C. Francino.- When was the last time you spoke about politics with Felipe González, if you have done so?

President.- Whenever I talk to him, I talk about politics, and now I am waiting because he owes me a dinner. The last time I invited him, and I am waiting for him to call me for dinner. And, obviously, when I am with Felipe González, 80 percent of the time I talk is about politics.

C. Francino.- On Friday, we had the opportunity to record with Manuel Marín, the former President of Congress, in Ciudad Real, where we were doing this program. I wouldn't say he was bitterly complaining, because that is not true, but when we asked him, "what is understood as the old guard, in the best sense of the expression, of the Socialist Party, is it sidelined?" he told us: well, yes.

President.- This is one of the things that surprises me the most when it is said because, if I take the composition of my Government and remember that my two Vice Presidents were senior officials with Felipe González, from there on, any debate is probably unnecessary; or that another Minister of the importance of the Minister of the Interior was one of the prominent Ministers with Felipe González, there is not much more to discuss; or that the President of Congress, Pepe Bono, was a very relevant person in Felipe González's generation...

I try, I have tried, and I will continue to try to count on the best without looking at whether they were or were not; without looking at their age, but at their commitment and their ability. And I point out that the average age of my Government at this moment must be around 51 years, which is somewhat higher than the average age of Felipe González's Governments.

However, for you to tell me that in Felipe González's time, which was many years, there were many senior officials who do not have now, that is normal. And there are senior officials now who are younger, newer people. There has been, in my opinion, a process of generational evolution that is quite natural and reasonable.

But to summarize: two Vice Presidents, both were Secretaries of State with Felipe González. These are some of the legends that one hears and that...

C. Francino.- Legends supported by testimonies of the supposed victims.

President.- Of those who think so. If I understand it. The President of the Government, of course, is from one generation, and there are people from the generation that won the Congress of 2000, like José Blanco or Trinidad Jiménez, who are in the Government, and who do it very well, by the way, and other people who were or have been more from the previous stage.

Moreover, I believe we have a very good coexistence. There is no such difference. I do not see anyone as being from Felipe's era or being younger now, no, no; I see their commitment to the project and their ability.

C. Francino.- Mr. President, you come from a very important week on the international agenda and more awaits you. This afternoon you will meet with Gordon Brown, then you have the meeting with Obama on the 13th, the tour of the Middle East...

President.- This week I still have three days in Copenhagen, where we are going to lend a hand to see if Madrid wins the Olympic bid.

C. Francino.- Indeed. We will all be there contributing. What are, as of today, the key ideas of your foreign policy for what remains of your term, with the European Presidency, etc., etc.?

President.- There is one idea that seems fundamental to me, and that is the consolidation of Spain in the group of the most relevant countries in the world, while at the same time being a country appreciated and valued by less developed countries thanks to our great cooperation and development aid policy. That is the position that suits Spain. It is a position that places us at the center, for the size of the country we are, and that makes us decisive and with enormous capacity for influence.

One of the achievements of our foreign policy, and I say this with all modesty and humility, because many people have contributed to it, is being in the G-20. Why? Because the G-20 has become the great forum where decisions on international economic policy will be consolidated and made. There is only a small group of important countries. In other words, we are at the level of the strong, of the developed countries, already at the highest stage; but at the same time, we maintain an enormous capacity for influence in Latin America and growing in Africa, which places us in a very important position.

What is my objective at this moment in foreign policy? A double objective: first, the Spanish Presidency of the European Union, where Spain has to demonstrate to Europe, one, its European vocation; two, its capacity to help overcome the economic crisis; and three, to leave the imprint, the model, of a country that wants a social Europe.

The second objective is to consolidate our position in the G-20. This largely involves consolidating our relationship with the United States of America, because it is the world's leading power, and that also means consolidating what is a good expectation of relationship with President Obama.

C. Francino.- How things have changed!

President.- Yes. Things have changed in the United States.

C. Francino.- Yes, yes. The landscape has changed, it is evident.

President.- We are trying to pursue the same policy. One feels great satisfaction when listening to Obama at the United Nations in a great speech, by the way, insisting on talking about multilateralism, because it is the thesis we have been maintaining: that the current world demands more than ever that multilateralism and not decisions by a few.

C. Francino.- Mr. President, the United Nations, and understand me... You had breakfast this morning with your family, I imagine, right? How are your daughters, Mr. President? Are they cheerful? Are they well?

President.- Yes, they are well.

C. Francino.- Perhaps this breaks the protocol of the interview a little, but I am a journalist. There are many people in this house and in this group who are; I do not intend to give lessons to anyone, but we do not agree that the informative interest justifies certain things. I simply convey that reflection, which is mine, simply.

President.- I appreciate it. It is a relief.

C. Francino.- Independently of this, of this specific matter, I would like your general reflection on the role that you believe the media should play in a democratic state like ours. What is our role within the game, Mr. President?

President.- Perhaps this is the most difficult question you can ask me. I believe that, as always, a medium of communication must be a guarantee of freedom of expression and freedom of criticism, and also a medium of communication develops a role of imprint of the country, of character of the country, of respect for certain values and behaviors. Both things are desirable in the media and, logically, with all due respect to what each one does and what each medium of communication does, in my opinion, those that maintain those principles of respect -- I am thinking of any type of medium -- I believe that in the end they deserve more social recognition.

C. Francino.- And a government, the current government, what role should it play? What relationship should it have with the media, with the market in general? Of neutrality or intervention?

President.- There are two types of media, public and private. In the public media, what we have done, in my opinion, and it is one of the changes I am most satisfied with in this stage of government: to turn public television into plural, independent television, and, moreover, that will not have commercial advertising and, therefore, will be more public service.

Two, the private media. What I have tried to do is to have a positive relationship to facilitate their work and, when necessary, to support the sector, because, like any other business sector, the crisis has also affected and is affecting the media. For me, to any medium of communication that is facing difficulties, if possible, and to do it generally for the media, I insist, as for other sectors, I try to support them, always knowing that there is a relationship of respect. At the same time, of course, the media have their ideological line and their political line; but, in general, I have tried to have an easy relationship with the majority.

C. Francino.- We are not going to disguise, at all, that it is a moment of relationship between your government and this group that I work with, which is not easy, and it is not easy lately due to the urgent approval of the Pay DTT Law. Is that maintaining a neutral position with the market, with the agents?

President.- Absolutely. The Pay DTT is something that has to be installed in our country. We have the digital blackout in April and it seems reasonable that at that moment everything is already prepared for the Pay DTT. And, if we had gone with a Bill, logically a law takes much longer.

That in that context there may be a group that interprets, I sincerely do not share, that their interests may be affected or not... I do not share it because I believe that this is good for everyone; if not, time will tell. It is like those measures that one hopes will come into force and be put into operation. I believe it is good for the entire sector. That is my opinion.

However, there may be a group that interprets that it is not. I respect that and I respect it deeply, and I do not invoke other decisions that may have benefited one group or another, because, I insist, every time a group or the sector in general, especially, has asked for something reasonable we have tried to do it, because I am interested in strong media. I will also add: I have the utmost respect and appreciation for the group where Cadena SER is integrated. Of course! Everyone knows it. However, governing is governing and there are times when one has to make decisions that are for the general interest and, perhaps, at a given moment a decision does not please a specific group; but that can happen in all sectors. One must know how to respect it and distinguish what is a government action for the general interest from what may be a repercussion, even understanding that the repercussion may not be liked.

C. Francino.- Were the two editorials and the three talk shows aimed at us, then?

President.- No, it was aimed at... Well, yes, but it was not aimed at... I respect...

C. Francino.- It is very good that we talk about it, it is very good.

President.- That is why I tell you that I am surprised that the criticisms do not arrive, because I said that behind closed doors. In other words, we are very transparent.

But, why not? Because it could not be that our party's deliberation body was pending at a given moment, in days when a strong criticism occurs, let’s say it clearly, from "El País" and from Cadena SER. Everyone who listens to Cadena SER saw that for a week all the talk shows were giving us a hard time and especially they were giving me a hard time.

C. Francino.- But it was not the first time, huh!

President.- But with that intensity it was... I believe that this to the citizens. People have a lot of common sense and know and criticize, of course. But in one week there was a strong intensity.

I told my colleagues: we have had criticism and we will have it, let us not be affected by two editorials, even if they are from a very important newspaper, the most important newspaper in Spain, but let us focus on our work and our project, because that always produces and can produce. It is like that, but there are editorials that, as is logical, I share more or less, and others that I do not share. That is the greatness of freedom of expression.

C. Francino.- I will tell you that that role of being the bad guys or presumed bad guys with the current government does not bother us, we have lived it on other occasions. I think it is part of the role of the media to be critical of power and does not respond to any business interest. That role does not bother us.

President.- It would be beyond your reach to seek a reference from a statement of mine, neither behind closed doors, and much less publicly, about the role of the bad guys of Grupo Prisa, please. On the contrary.

C. Francino.- You said presumed bad guys.

President.- On the contrary. Grupo Prisa is a group that has contributed a very important value to democracy, which is in the sentiment of all democrats. For me, it will be like that today and tomorrow the same, exactly the same, whether governing or not governing. However, when there is a criticism that may be, in my opinion, somewhat exaggerated, I say "somewhat exaggerated," allow me to think that too, right? It is reasonable.

C. Francino.- Yes, yes. I do not agree, but of course...

President.- When a talk show host, for example... Especially when it is something that is not real, because there were many voices from this media group during those days saying that there was division in the PSOE and that the President of the Government had lost support. That is not true. It is like that.

C. Francino.- But that is something that can be nuanced, Mr. President. I have already told you before.

President.- I accept criticism. As a government, we have rectified at times, I have recognized mistakes, some of them very serious, and I have recognized them; but also a medium of communication can sometimes say "I was wrong by 0.5 percent."

C. Francino.- Yes, yes. I have done it on more than one occasion and you know it.

President.- Nothing would happen. Moreover, that is part of life; not only of democracy but of life, and nothing happens.

C. Francino.- Just the right amount of fundamentalism.

President.- That’s right. Moreover, the richness of this is being able to say, and it often happens to me... I hear your talk show, I hear an opinion from a talk show host and I would like to call, especially when they give a piece of information that is not correct, and it is true that then I reflect and say that not all talk show hosts have to have all the correct data about things.

I insist, I have no feeling of being in any fight, I have never been and much less with a medium of communication, and much less with a medium of communication that I respect. I want to remind you that, in addition, I was a talk show host on SER with Gemma Nierga and, therefore, I have a hidden loyalty in my heart.

C. Francino.- So we will see each other on Thursday and Friday in Copenhagen, right?

President.- Exactly. Let’s see if we can do it.

C. Francino.- Is there a match?

President.- It is difficult, but there is a match because I believe that Madrid has a good candidacy. It is true that many people say that the fact that Latin America has not had any... But, above all, we have a great unity, I have worked shoulder to shoulder and this weekend I was still talking with the Mayor of Madrid, a great unity of the whole country around Madrid's Olympic candidacy, and, in my opinion, we have the most advanced facilities and a modern and sustainable model of the Olympic Games.

C. Francino.- Mr. President, we are finishing. Is there any possibility that you will not be the Socialist Party's candidate in 2012?

President.- That will be in 2012. Notice that there is a quarter of 2009 left, all of 2010, and all of 2011. The last... Not the last, but I must say that I practically do not think at this moment about what we will have to do in 2012 regarding the Socialist Party's candidacy, which will depend on the Socialist Party and will depend on me. We have two hard years of work ahead of us.

C. Francino.- So, there is some possibility that you will not.

President.- No, there is the possibility that I will only talk about that in 2012.

C. Francino.- President Rodríguez Zapatero, thank you very much for being on SER this morning and good luck.

President.- Thank you.