Press conference of the President of the Government after the United Nations High-Level Meeting on Climate Change.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

22 September 2009 · United Nations High-Level Meeting on Climate Change (press conference following it)

Context
Zapatero addressed a press conference at the UN General Assembly in New York on 22 September 2009, following a high-level meeting on climate change.
Main themes
Climate change, economic recession and recovery, Millennium Development Goals, Middle East peace process, multilateralism and global governance, Barack Obama's UN leadership, energy transition, development aid, Copenhagen climate summit, Alliance of Civilizations, poverty reduction, 0.7% technology investment proposal
Duration
~41 min
91st percentile
Words
4,967
91st percentile
Sentences
181
87th percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
12.9
56th percentile
Syntax
3.22
74th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

181 sentences in 67 paragraphs

President.- Good morning. I would like to make an initial assessment of the development of the United Nations General Assembly.

This General Assembly is perhaps the most relevant and significant since the one held in the year 2000, in which, as you know, the General Assembly approved the Millennium Development Goals in the fight against poverty and misery in the world. And it is significant because we are living in a historic moment as a result of the changes that the economic recession will bring to the international order and global governance, and also because, as we have seen in this morning's session, there is a fundamental change, which is the presence and presidency of Barack Obama at the helm of the United States of America, the world's leading power.

These are two highly relevant facts that place this General Assembly at a decisive moment. For what purpose? To address, above all, three major issues, three great challenges that we have:

The first of these is the exit from the economic recession, which is directly linked to the response that the world gives to the challenge of climate change and the factors of energy and respect for environmental sustainability.

Secondly, stability and security. In the 21st century, in this first part of the 21st century, it depends, above all, on the strength of multilateralism, on the strength of international cooperation, on recovering the leadership of the United Nations, on placing the value of understanding, cooperation, and the Alliance of Civilizations, of peoples, of cultures, above any other situation. And in the landscape of the major problems for stability and security, the Middle East remains the great issue, the great pending assignment for the world to strengthen its stability and security.

And thirdly, in a year we will evaluate the fulfillment of the Millennium Development Goals, that is, what the world, the nations, the states, have done in these ten years to meet the Millennium Development Goals and progressively win the fight against poverty and misery. Hence, all the milestones that we have this year in the international arena, including, of course, the presence of the European Union through my country, will have a strong imprint linked to accelerating and reaffirming commitments around the Millennium Development Goals.

These are the three major themes that we are debating in this United Nations General Assembly. These three major themes have a whole development ahead; the first, the new economy in the world, Copenhagen; the fight against climate change, a great appointment. Copenhagen and the fight against climate change cannot be seen as something difficult, as something that will require efforts, sacrifices, and difficulties from countries; no. The energy transition for climate change is a great opportunity for a better economy in the world, with more equal opportunities, more democratic and more sustainable, which, ultimately, will be the great effort.

The Middle East has a transcendental appointment, and I am pleased that President Obama has dedicated a large part of his speech to the Middle East, and I commend his faith in peace, that expression he emphasized that he will not waver in the fight for peace in the Middle East. Certainly, Europe and Spain will support and share this offensive in favor of peace in the Middle East.

You know that some know, because it has been made public—I will be going on a tour of the Middle East right after my meeting with President Obama on the 13th. Starting on the 14th, I will be in Israel, in Palestine, in Syria first, and therefore I will have the opportunity to share with President Obama, after hearing his great speech today, the actions that from Europe and from Spain we can support and accompany in that direction.

Thirdly, we do have the appointment in a year to fulfill the Millennium Development Goals, and Europe, as the largest donor, must take new steps this year, despite the economic crisis, to maintain its decisive commitment to development aid.

These are the three major themes of great depth that are in the General Assembly and that are in the debate. From here, I prefer to answer your questions.

Q.- Mr. President, you proposed yesterday a 0.7 percent investment in technologies to combat CO2 emissions, but what guarantee is there that this 0.7 percent will be fulfilled when the other 0.7 percent, that of development aid, is still not being met?

President.- I must say that, in relation to the 0.7 percent, there are many countries that meet the 0.7 percent; almost all are European, almost all are Nordic, and in that sense, they are exemplary, and others are fulfilling the commitments made. We will meet the European Union's requirement for this year 2010 to be above 0.5 percent, exactly 0.56 percent, and we must ensure that those developed countries that do not comply, comply.

Why the idea of a 0.7 percent for technological innovation for alternative energy sources, renewables, or emission reductions? Because we must have some ideas clear. The reduction of emissions that we have proposed to prevent the temperature from rising and causing the effects we know in the environment must be done with emission reductions and advancing in technology.

In the end, we have seen how renewables have gained competitiveness, profitability, and production capacity in a very short time. Fortunately, today we have a potential for scientific development that was unpredictable a few years ago in all fields, and I think of the field of desalination, with the profitability that today comes from the reduction in the cost of desalting seawater.

Therefore, to the extent that we channel more resources into research, we will undoubtedly be complementing and reducing the demand and cost of emission reductions. Certainly, I believe this debate must be opened. I insist, the fight against climate change is not an isolated debate from the economic recession, from the serious economic recession; it is at the heart of the economic recession, it is behind it. It is one of the causes that motivates the economic recession, and therefore we will not be able to make an adequate, intelligent orientation out of the economic crisis, out of the economic recession, if we do not address energy and environmental issues.

Q.- Spain is one of the countries promoting the Alliance of Civilizations, with Turkey, which aims for dialogue and working together with people of different religions. Why is Israel not included in this Alliance?

President.- I believe it is included, and there are already people from Israel who have participated in the forums of the Alliance and will continue to do so. They will do so, specifically, in the next one we have in Brazil in May. Therefore, all cultures and all religions are invited. There is a very high number of countries that are friends of the Alliance, and of course, Israel is always invited, and I hope it considers it and that it will be present in a more official manner.

Q.- Beyond his political style, in his speech, Gaddafi has called for the democratization of the UN and has asked that the expansion of the Security Council be done differently. He called it the "Council of Terror," because it only dares to confront weak and small countries. I would like to know your position on that awaited reform and how you think this new Security Council should be shaped.

President.- I have not heard the speech of leader Gaddafi, and I will not make any assessment, because it is true that upon entering again, I was in a meeting at the Spanish Mission at the United Nations, and it seemed to me that he was still speaking. Therefore, I will have to dedicate some time to read it, and I will read it.

Regarding the United Nations, the United Nations needs a reform, without a doubt; a reform in the Security Council. We are in the Group of Friends of Reform, although at this moment, with the economic recession we have and with the historical demand to take steps and make decisions on climate change, those are priorities for me, without a doubt, over the reform of the United Nations.

I have no doubt that if now the leaders were to dedicate ourselves to trying to change the Security Council, which is improvable, which must be expandable, and which, indeed, responds originally to a historical situation following World War II... But well. Now what we have ahead is the perspective of ordering the world economy for decades, in what we are undoubtedly living, which is a profound change in a moment of transition from one productive model to another productive model.

Q.- Mr. President, one of the current issues these days is Honduras. Yesterday, Foreign Minister Patricia Rodas, from the Zelaya government, met with Mr. Moratinos, and she held a press conference requesting that all the ambassadors who left Honduras in condemnation of the coup return to the country as a show of institutional support for the Zelaya government. I do not know how the situation is from Spain, if you are considering this possibility, and if Mr. Moratinos is conveying this message to the countries of the European Union.

President.- Today, at five-thirty, at the Spanish Mission to the United Nations, there is a meeting on the issue of Honduras with the OAS and other countries, in which the Minister of Foreign Affairs will be present. Among other issues, the situation of the ambassadors will be discussed, as well as how to strengthen and relaunch a new diplomatic initiative for Honduras, which implies a democratic restoration of the government in Honduras and a negotiated, peaceful, and stable exit. The statement made by President Obama today regarding Honduras has been significant, and the overwhelmingly majority reaction in the room supporting that position is even more significant.

Q.- Mr. President, you mentioned that you will be traveling to the Middle East on the 14th. I would like to know what the primary objectives of that trip are.

If I may ask a question about national politics, we understand that you have summoned the representative of Esquerra Republicana de Cataluña for next week to negotiate the Budgets. Considering that there is very little time left for them to be approved, will you explain to Mr. Ridao that proposed tax increase, specifically the VAT? Will you also inform other groups, for example, the PNV?

President.- Regarding the first question, the objective of that trip is to strengthen the position of the European Union and, of course, of Spain, always keeping in mind the horizon of our Presidency on January 1, 2010, to contribute to this new moment for peace in the Middle East; a new moment that Barack Obama has solemnly underscored today, which yesterday had an initial step with the meeting between the Prime Minister of Israel and the President of the Palestinian Authority, and where Spain can contribute a lot, and of course, the European Union has the obligation to do so. That is the objective of the tour.

Regarding national political issues, I will sit down for a coffee with Mr. Ridao and have a meeting, as I occasionally do with political leaders from all groups. We will undoubtedly talk about financing, the Budgets, and many other issues; but the action of presenting the Budgets and dialoguing with the different Parliamentary Groups to seek the necessary agreements for a majority backing of the Budgets is carried out by the Second Vice President, the economic Vice President of the Government, as is natural.

Q.- I wanted to ask you about the recession, but from a somewhat Spanish perspective. Today, the President of the Banking Association spoke about the risk of a collapse in employment and the poor state of public accounts. I would like to know if you have a response to those statements and, beyond the specific case, linking what he said today with what you said over the weekend about having defeated the powerful or the criticisms from the Minister of Economy regarding business bonuses, do you think that this type of debate filled with tension is healthy at this moment, or if at some point the Government is considering some kind of political initiative to neutralize it or to reduce the tension?

President.- The Government does not neutralize any public debate. That would be the last thing in a democratic society! Rather, the Government is one of the actors that receives public debate and is promoted from many instances, among others, the media, as is normal and logical in a democracy.

I do not know the statements of the President of the AEB, as I have only seen a message on my mobile; but I believe that all economic sectors must contribute to confidence, and contributing to confidence means making a rigorous analysis of the situation. The economic situation is serious, it has serious difficulties because we are in a recession and with a high unemployment rate; but the country has great potential, and we must value the assets we have. It is normal that at times the Government coincides with some business sector and at other times, it does not. I find it an absolutely normal debate in democracy. The relationship is fluid, and sometimes we agree with the trade unions, quite often, and at other times, we do not. It is absolutely logical, especially at a time when the economy occupies a place of debate.

What seems most important to me is that the Government supports all business sectors and has been doing so with all its effort. That effort also implies effort in public resources. Look, where we started a year ago to provide support was precisely to the banks, with a very significant volume of loans to sustain the financial system, as is known, after the fall of Lehman Brothers, and from there to all business sectors. We are logically trying to support the automotive sector, etc.

I stated this a few days ago and today I reiterate it: Spain will come out of the recession, it will come out like the rest of the European countries, and the obligation of the Government, and what the Government is working for, is for two objectives: for the Spanish economy to emerge strengthened and for the economy to function for employment as soon as possible. This is the great objective, and I hope for the collaboration of all social sectors in this.

Q.- Mr. President, I would like to continue on this topic, because there are increasingly more voices, not only political but also economic, warning that a tax increase could severely penalize consumption and thus hinder those green shoots we were seeing... I would like to know if you have already quantified that effect of consumption retraction that a rise in indirect taxes, like the one you announced, could imply, and if you have also studied the possibility of establishing some kind of measure to mitigate it, such as announcing a VAT increase, but postponed, that is, to come into effect in a number of months.

President.- This debate is and will continue to be. There is no direct relationship between what could be a fiscal measure upwards or downwards and the evolution of the economy in a moment of recession. There are examples for all hypotheses, especially when we are talking about moderate upward or downward movements in tax pressure, which do not represent more than 1 percent upwards or 1 percent of lower tax pressure. That does not alter the substance of an economic cycle. In that cycle, we are still in recession, although the worst has already passed.

Why are we making this upward fiscal move? Because we want to maintain social protection. We want to maintain social protection, we want to maintain productive investment, we want the Spanish economy not to slow down in terms of investments in infrastructure and highways, and we want municipalities not to close. And it is very curious to see some political parties that say "no to tax increases, lower taxes" and at the same time are asking, and say they are going to demonstrate, for more money for municipalities. That is not coherence, it is not a project, it is nothing.

Just like the regional presidents of the PP. The PP, yes, the party that says not to touch taxes, well, its regional presidents, in the model of regional financing, all asked for more money. So, how can this be understood? There is no rigor in some debates that are raised.

We have said it clearly. I mean, there are governments that raise taxes and hide it, there are governments that say they lower taxes and it was not true, because the elimination of the IAE was not compensated to the municipalities at the time, and then there are governments that are clear and say: yes, we are going to raise taxes on citizens, we will explain for what and why.

This has a certain value in political coherence, but what has no coherence or value is to say, on the one hand, "lower taxes and increase spending for municipalities, or lower taxes and increase spending for the Autonomous Communities." And we will see in the budget debate, because they will say "lower taxes and build more kilometers of highway and more spending on high-speed." We will see it.

That is in fiscal policy and regarding the possible modification of VAT and the moment of entry into force, it will be the Economic Vice President who will announce it next Saturday at the press conference after the Council of Ministers.

Q.- Mr. President, returning to that new 0.7 percent that you propose, I would like to know if after launching the proposal you have obtained the support of any country or some of the participants, or others. And also, insisting on a previous question, do you not see it utopian that countries are willing to pay that 0.7 percent when the vast majority do not pay the other 0.7 percent of development aid?

President.- Let's see if we understand the proposal well. It is not about another 0.7 percent of development aid for one matter, no; it is about all countries dedicating at least 0.7 to innovation and technological research in alternative energy sources to combat climate change. These are two things. I don't know if it is clear now. Why? Because the 0.7 percent of each country is a very important volume, and every time a country works and achieves research and innovation in this field, it is making all economies and all countries have more opportunities to join that effort.

If we all make a commitment, which could be 0.7 percent, to put the figure that was already there and that is very emblematic for the other 0.7 percent... Undoubtedly, the volume of GDP of developed countries dedicated exclusively to innovation in the field of alternative energy sources that do not produce CO2 emission effects is a large volume, and I have no doubt that as soon as we start to convey it and propose it, it will have a positive consideration, because a good part of the fight against climate change, as I said before, is not only to reduce emissions, but to increase research and technology. Sometimes, we are not aware of the great technological development that exists in this area where, by the way, Spain occupies a very prominent place in the international concert.

Q.- Why has Spain not yet recognized the independence of Kosovo as other members of the European Union have done? Is Spain going to change its position or does Spain see something different from the other 62 countries around the world that have recognized it?

President.- The question could also be reversed: why are there more than a hundred countries that have not recognized Kosovo and why do those sixty not see what the other hundred see? We have had a coherent position and we are not going to change it. The recognition of the birth of independent states requires respect for the procedures of international legality and, consequently, from our point of view, the recognition of Kosovo is not a success. It is not a success, and we are not going to change our position regarding Kosovo.

Q.- Mr. President, regardless of whether the Vice President provides more details next Saturday regarding the tax increase and the budgets, I wanted to ask if, as a proposal, even if it is more moral than quantitative, the Government is considering reforming the taxation of Sicavs, of Collective Investment Companies, in which large fortunes are sheltered, so that the effort you have asked of society is more equitable.

I also wanted to ask if the Government is considering taking any action to prevent the fact that some European countries are coming out of the recession before Spain from leading to an increase in interest rates by the European Central Bank that could hinder Spain's exit from this recession.

President.- These are two different things. First, I refer to the Economic Vice President on Saturday. I will say, I can advance, that the maximum effort in terms of tax modification, the fiscal modification, will be made by high incomes, and that will have a clear translation in the reform proposal that we will take to Parliament. But they are the ones who will make the significant effort. Without a doubt.

Second. Your question contains an assertion, in fact, that I cannot accept at the moment, because I also believe that we need to have sufficient perspective. When the quarterly growth data of some countries and others are produced, we are seeing two things that we must keep in mind so that we see that we must take a certain value away from the debate and some assertions: one, that not all countries started with negative growth in the same quarter, and therefore, the comparison must already be different; some started in the second quarter of 2008 and others in the third. First, since not all started the same, the comparison of when they come out will have to be the time and the number of quarters they have been in negative growth.

First factor. Second, we must also take into account how much GDP has fallen in each country and how much it will fall in that period of recession, for example this year. It is not the same to exit an economy that has fallen by 6 or 6.5 percent than if it falls by 3.7 percent. The important thing is to see, when we are all already in positive growth, how much GDP each country has lost. That is the measure of things, and that will be the moment to make an assessment.

And then, let us also put that perspective because that the third or fourth quarter of 2009 one country is at -0.1 percent and another at +0.1 percent in economic terms says very little.

I believe that we are not going to have that problem regarding the exit to growth and regarding the global GDP loss in the recession stage. Our problem is unemployment, employment. There we do have to gain time over time and make the economy, as soon as it is reactivated, capable of creating jobs. Hence, all economic measures, and especially the Sustainable Economy Law, are designed to achieve the recovery of employment as soon as possible, which is our particular issue, but it is not the issue of economic growth. Really, it is to focus on where it is sincerely not. Yes, it is on the issue of employment.

Q.- Mr. President, it seems that even Gaddafi shares the enthusiasm of having Obama as President. Certainly, his speech today has been very encouraging, but yesterday's left us a bit empty due to the lack of announcing any kind of commitment regarding emission reductions. It seems that something so urgent is placed behind the internal problems that the United States may have in other matters, such as health care reform, etc. Are we all giving Obama a pass because we are very enthusiastic about him, despite what it means in terms of conflict for Copenhagen that a country like the United States does not have this?

On the other hand, regarding taxes, I wanted to know what you consider to be the highest incomes in terms of the possible tax increase.

President.- That trust that the General Assembly gave, and it was noticeable, to President Obama, and which of course I fully endorse and a little more, is because he deserves it. He has made today a narrative, in the first part of his speech, of actions he has taken and decisions. There has been a first statement that, made in the United Nations Assembly by the President of the United States, has enormous value, and I would say that it has enormous historical and moral value, and it is that the first thing he did when he took office was to order that there be not a single torture in his country, in the United States of America, the country where a good part of our democracy and our freedoms was born and grew; the freedoms we know from the democratic world. Or closing Guantanamo, or the commitment to multilateralism, or to enter into climate change, I believe he said a phrase, if my memory does not fail me, and I believe it does not fail me, according to which the United States has gone from being an observer of climate change to being a leader in the response to climate change in nine months.

We all understand what that change means, we all do. There have been other countries, not with as much economic power as the United States, emerging countries, that have also taken time, and fortunately, yesterday we saw important proposals and commitments from a country like China.

I believe that at the G-20 and Copenhagen we must have sufficient understanding, while also demanding, from the great industrial powers, namely the United States, so that we can reach a sufficient agreement, and hopefully we can, in this time leading up to Copenhagen, extend the conviction that the fight against climate change is not something that will harm countries, economies, companies, or industries, no; it is an investment for the future. The more we reduce, and in less time, the more prosperous our economies will be. And this costs, because it is a change of thought and mentality. It is a new paradigm, but President Obama is fully committed to it.

Therefore, of course we are going to give him, of course. The success and good results of President Obama are so important for the world that I have said on some occasions: it is not about waiting for what President Obama can do for us, but about seeing how we can support President Obama because, if he succeeds in his presidency, in the presidency of the United States, the world will succeed.

Q.- Regarding taxes, what are these high incomes for you?

President.- On Saturday, the Economic Vice President will provide the specific details of the fiscal proposal. I do not know if those affected would understand that it was announced from the United States.

Q.- I recalled President Obama's words that on his first day in the White House he made public his stance against torture, and on his first day in Moncloa you withdrew the troops from Iraq. I wanted to know if the time has now come to send troops to Afghanistan.

President Obama has said in his speech that he will never feel ashamed to defend his country's national interests here at the UN. I wanted to ask you what you believe are the national interests of Spain that need to be defended here at the UN.

Lastly, I wanted to ask you why you did not stay to listen to Gaddafi.

President.- The last point is because I had an appointment with Jeremy Rifkin, who is collaborating with us on the entire project and the policy of sustainable economy. But I insist, I will read the speech, although it will take me a long time.

Afghanistan. I am not sure if I understood your question correctly, but we have just announced, and Parliament will decide, the deployment of more troops to Afghanistan to strengthen security, just as many other countries have done in recent months. Our commitment is for 220 more soldiers, and we will be around a thousand, in a stable manner, in Afghanistan. We are also working and sending personnel from our country to contribute to the training of the Afghan police, because we all wish for security in Afghanistan, which is going through a moment of great difficulty as a result of the electoral processes, to be in the hands of the Afghans as soon as possible.

What are Spain's interests to defend at the United Nations? I will summarize it for you: the United Nations. For a country like Spain, which has a multilateral vision, which has an open view to its European position but with deep relations in Latin America and Africa, what is beneficial? It is beneficial that this house is strong; that the United Nations leads; that it serves as a channel for understanding; that it fulfills the original Charter, the aspirations of the founders, that guarantee of peace; that it addresses health in the world and the fight against poverty, and now that it becomes the great forum for the energy transition that the world needs in the fight against climate change. Hence, I support the proposal to create a World Organization for Climate Change that some leaders put on the table yesterday afternoon and evening.

Thank you very much.