Interview with the President of the Government on TVE-1

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

7 March 2010

Context
Zapatero was interviewed on Spanish public television TVE-1 in March 2010, addressing Spain's economic crisis, unemployment, and recovery strategy.
Main themes
Unemployment and job destruction, economic crisis response, social protection measures, political dialogue and consensus, economic recovery, productive model reform, government accountability, unemployment benefits, competitiveness and productivity
Duration
~65 min
96th percentile
Words
7,809
96th percentile
Sentences
278
94th percentile
Readability
48
58th percentile
Grade
13.2
59th percentile
Syntax
3.16
67th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
9th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

278 sentences in 102 paragraphs

Pepa Bueno .- President, good evening. Thank you for attending the public broadcasting service. Mr. President, have we lost two years in combating the crisis because you did not see it coming, or did not want to see it, or did not grasp its magnitude?

President .- We are facing the most severe international economic and financial crisis in eighty years, whose basic origin was a crisis in the financial system, primarily in the United States, which spread worldwide. A crisis of this magnitude, such a severe recession, has three phases: a phase of economic decline and intense job loss; a second phase of stabilization of that economic decline, even though jobs are still being lost, which is the phase we are in; and a third phase, which will be one of economic growth and job creation, which is undoubtedly the most important problem.

It is true that I could not foresee the magnitude of the economic crisis, and it is true that the vast majority, if not all, of the governments and international organizations in the world did not foresee it either. It is not a consolation for me, but I have always been sincere when explaining how I saw things, just as I am today.

Ana Blanco .- Mr. President, good evening. You mentioned one of the most serious consequences of the economic crisis, unemployment, and we all have the latest data in mind. According to the EPA, there are 4,300,000 unemployed, and in these two years of crisis, unemployment has increased by 2,300,000, and I quote the EPA data. You have often said, "the worst is over," but it is difficult for citizens to share that impression when unemployment continues to rise, and analysts say that this is the trend for this year. How are you going to stop the destruction of jobs?

President .- Undoubtedly, the most serious consequence of the crisis is job loss. I feel responsible for each and every person who has lost their job. I know that my responsibility is to confront this grave effect of the crisis; to propose measures; to mitigate, to the extent that we can -- I insist, in a crisis that is the most severe in eighty years -- job loss and to have the horizon of being able to recover jobs. We will do this when the economy begins to grow again, and that goal should be set for the end of this year and, of course, for next year, 2011.

To achieve that goal, that is, growth and job creation, we need to bring together the maximum number of forces: political parties, social agents, business owners, and trade unions, one, to mitigate now the most serious consequences that the crisis may have had on employment, and that is why we are in a dialogue process with measures to create jobs; and two, to improve our productive model in the economy of our country so that we can logically grow with more productivity and more competitiveness, as the vast majority of citizens expect from us.

I must, however, remind you that, knowing the severe impact of the crisis and the tragedy of losing a job and having few expectations at the moment of finding another job, the Government has made a great effort for social cohesion and has made a great effort for social protection and support for unemployed individuals. Today we have 3,100,000 people receiving benefits, and we have extended unemployment benefits. I know that 420 euros for a person who has lost contributory benefits or assistance benefits is a minimal amount, but it is a solidarity effort that we all make so that that person does not end up in a situation of extreme difficulty, so that they do not end up on the sidelines, and can receive help from the State, help from the Government.

We have therefore fought the crisis with the greatest effort of social protection that we could for a country like ours.

Juan Ramón Lucas .- Mr. President, good evening. You speak of dialogue, the need for agreement, and sacrifice. Public opinion is calling for a State Pact on the economy, but it seems that both you and the Popular Party are not willing to make political sacrifices for the common good and that the dialogue you have started in Parliament, from the Government, seems to have more noise than substance.

President .- Since the Investiture Debate -- tomorrow marks two years since the last general elections -- I have offered agreements to all political forces on economic and social matters; I have done so on six occasions in different parliamentary debates. Now we have a dialogue process, which is more necessary than ever because we are close to economic recovery. We are on the verge of starting to grow the economy again, albeit slowly, and although we cannot yet say that we will create jobs immediately.

This effort to achieve recovery as soon as possible, to bring it about as soon as possible, if we combine agreements from the parties, will build confidence, and confidence in the economy is fundamental: confidence for companies to make investment plans and confidence for consumers to have an expectation of increased consumption.

The proposal for an agreement is very serious, and at this moment all political forces, certainly the Government, must focus not on disqualifying each other's proposals, but on listening to each other's proposals, on making a contribution to the dialogue, and, of course, on seeking that agreement that I hope can be reached on important issues.

It is extraordinarily important for the economy of this country, for example, the proposal that the Government has made to facilitate loans of up to two hundred thousand euros to small and medium-sized enterprises through the ICO, because many self-employed individuals and many small business owners who are listening to us know very well that the greatest difficulty they have faced during the crisis is the difficulty of financing, of being able to obtain credit; viable companies. We have been making efforts through the ICO, and now we want to make a greater effort because the ICO is going to launch a plan to provide financing of up to two hundred thousand euros to small and medium-sized enterprises, assuming one hundred percent of the risk by the State.

This, without a doubt, if we do it together, just like the plans for the rehabilitation of homes with tax deductions that did not exist until now, or the plans to achieve more energy savings in public buildings, which can generate a lot of jobs precisely where a lot has been lost, which is in construction; if they have the support of all political forces, they will come out strengthened, be more useful, and provide more confidence.

A. Blanco .- Mr. President, I would like to insist on this point you mentioned. One of the major problems of this economic crisis, which citizens complain about, especially small business owners and the self-employed, is the lack of credit. Today, the Bank of Spain provided new data on the granting of loans, and both the number and the amount continue to decline. January may not be a reference month, but that trend continues. You spoke of that initiative related to the ICO to expedite. Why was this measure not taken earlier? Is it still timely?

President .- The ICO has taken measures, and I will give you a figure: last year, in 2009, we granted ICO loans amounting to nineteen billion euros, which reached three hundred thousand companies, self-employed individuals, and families. But I must emphasize that this is public money, taxpayer money, and therefore, it is lent with a certain risk. The Government cannot simply facilitate loans; it must have guarantees and must evaluate projects so that the losses from defaults are not excessive.

Now we have taken a step of greater risk, of greater commitment, which is for the ICO itself to evaluate the projects, the loan applications, and to cover the risk one hundred percent for projects of up to two hundred thousand euros. Obviously, as the economy improves, the State will have more guarantees to recover as much money as possible from that loan, which under the best possible conditions will be in the hands of the companies.

But, since you asked me this question, allow me to emphasize the fundamental nature of the crisis. The crisis, the great crisis, the economic depression we have experienced, has its origin in a financial crisis. That is to say, a part of the international financial system, primarily in the United States, was made of cardboard, was rotten, and that caused a crisis in the financial system.

And what is the most serious consequence of the financial system crisis? The credit crisis. In the autumn of 2008, there was no credit; banks were not lending to each other, banks were not granting mortgages, and banks were not lending to companies. Private economic activity practically came to a halt because the financial system was severely damaged, and then one bank does not lend to another because it distrusts that bank having serious problems and not recovering its money, or to companies, or to individuals. That is why we supported financial institutions.

You will remember that this was a major debate because we said: we are going to guarantee banks with tens of billions and we are going to, above all, guarantee citizens' savings. And there were many criticisms because it was said that we were giving money to banks. To this day, and time has passed, the public money we have committed to support has meant that the Government, that is to say the State, that is to say all citizens, have received 1.6 billion euros from banks, from the fees we have asked them to support them in their debt issuance, as they ask other banks.

Thanks to that measure, which all governments coordinated as never before in history in the G-20 and in Europe, we sustained the financial system. If that support for the financial system had not occurred, we would have faced an economic catastrophe.

P. Bueno .- Two years have passed since then, Mr. President, and, as Ana Blanco pointed out, many citizens have lost their jobs, many others have not; but all, whether employed or not, are very concerned about the economic situation. Do you believe that your Government has conveyed a coherent and clear message to citizens?

You just acknowledged publicly that you were slow to see the crisis. There has been, at the very least, a constant, permanent image of improvisation; there have been public contradictions, some very evident and two very recent: when you sent the Stability Plan to Brussels a little over a month ago, it included a paragraph proposing the possibility of extending the number of years for calculating pensions, and then it was said that it was just an example, but that paragraph was removed; or, when a week ago a Secretary of State pointed out the possibility of reviewing the salary agreement with civil servants, two Vice Presidents immediately came out to deny it.

Your credibility, Mr. President, has declined, and all polls confirm this. If, as you pointed out, confidence is essential to overcome the crisis, do you believe that your Government is in a position to convey confidence?

President .- You have asked many things at once and provided many examples. I must insist on a fundamental idea: we are experiencing the most severe crisis in eighty years, a financial and economic crisis of great magnitude.

I said before and reiterate: no one, not even I -- it is not a consolation for me -- could anticipate the magnitude of the crisis; but that has not diminished our capacity to make decisions to the extent that we have been able to cushion, in the first phase, the crisis, the magnitude of the crisis; in a second phase, as we are now, to prepare for recovery; and in the third, we hope to see economic growth and job creation. Why? Because if private credit, bank credit, is closed off, as it was and there was no credit for several months, it causes a spectacular crisis in the economy, in activity, in investment, or in consumption. The Government has the capacity it has to facilitate credit and to counteract such intense job loss, and we made a package of measures in the first phase of the crisis to mitigate the effects.

I will give you three examples. The Car Aid Plan: without that Plan, which involves two billion euros in loans, guarantees, or direct subsidies, the automotive sector in our country would likely have disappeared. Thanks to a plan, we can say that we guarantee the factories, which is very important for some Communities, and for our external sector, because it is one of the most productive sectors.

We implemented a plan for activity, employment, and maintenance of companies through the Local Fund. It amounted to eight billion euros, maintaining employment for four hundred thousand people and, what is almost as important, fourteen thousand small and medium-sized enterprises were able to survive when construction, private construction activity, practically ceased to function in our country.

And, thirdly, we had, as I mentioned earlier, an extraordinary plan because never, since time immemorial, had the public sector facilitated credit for working capital, not for investment projects, to small and medium-sized enterprises. Did it not reach everyone? I know perfectly well, and that it only reached part of them.

But the volume of the challenge we faced has been extraordinary, and the Government's capacity to respond, especially in that first phase, was focused on that; in addition, of course, to guaranteeing maximum protection and social cohesion.

I must reiterate that, unlike what some governments have done in other times and in other places, all the social policies and all the cohesion and social protection policies that we have implemented have been maintained by the government.

Q. Well .- But, Mr. President, I was not asking you about the government's actions; I was asking you about the discourse and the confidence that must be conveyed to a society that, as you pointed out, needs… A year ago, you and your entire team were emphasizing social protection, that it was a priority, and that, therefore, it was not important or relevant that we continued to incur debt. And now, recently, following doubts about us in the financial markets, whatever the cause, there has been a sudden conversion to budgetary rigor, to austerity plans, and to complying with the criteria set by Europe regarding the deficit.

President .- I understand that citizens have a high degree of concern because we have had, and still have, a serious economic crisis, with very serious consequences for employment. But I must reiterate that the government has taken, since the crisis began, 137 economic measures; 137 --I have provided some examples here, but they cover many sectors, providing support, assistance, and facilitating economic activity-- and if we had not taken those measures, the effect would have been much more negative.

It is true that there is now a concern following what has happened in recent weeks, especially in the week of February 4, regarding the solvency of the Kingdom of Spain, of public accounts. This was an unjustified debate, and I refer to the evidence. There was one day, which was February 4, with an impressive stock market crash that did not respond to objective reasons regarding our debt situation and our ability to meet commitments and maintain reasonable economic activity from the public sector.

What is the evidence? The evidence is that today the stock market is already above the indices of the day before that unjustified crash; just as it was unjustified to question Spain, or to compare it to Greece. Today the Director General of the IMF has stated emphatically, as was evident, that Spain is not a problem, because we have public debt twenty points below the European average. When the crisis began, we had it at 33 percent and now we have it at 55 percent. It has grown, and we must control the deficit.

Why do we have a deficit? Because we have had to make a large public investment for the automobile sector, for public works, to support credit, to maintain social spending, and to pay unemployment benefits, which was fundamental and, therefore, to resist and mitigate the worst effects of the crisis. Now that we have a reasonable horizon of slow recovery, we must reduce the deficit because it is not good; we cannot have such a high deficit for many years. And we must do it in a harmonious way: we must gradually withdraw public investment and public spending while we see positive signs in the economy.

J.R. Lucas .- The problem, Mr. President, is that, indeed, public spending must be curtailed, but that will also mean that public spending towards the economy is curtailed, and there are experts who believe that if we add tax increases, particularly an increase in VAT, which can also dampen consumption, we will have more difficulties in taking off.

President .- At this moment, we have a tax burden in Spain of 30 percent; 30 percent of the country's wealth goes to public coffers. The European average is around 38 or 39 percent, and countries like Germany or France are at 40 or 42 percent. We have that tax burden.

The government I preside over has had a trajectory in which tax cuts have been much more present. I eliminated the Wealth Tax, we reduced the Corporate Tax by five points, we lowered the Income Tax, and we made a refund of four hundred euros, although we have now corrected it for higher incomes. And now we need to improve revenues to reduce that deficit, and indeed, we have approved a two-point increase in VAT.

I must say that this is one of the avenues that, in our opinion, does the least damage to economic growth. Why? Because it does not affect the Personal Income Tax and does not affect work, therefore, and it does not affect the Corporate Tax, the activity of companies. Furthermore, I must say that we have one of the three lowest VAT rates in the European Union. We will have it at 18 percent, and most European countries are above that. It does not harm our exports. It is a certain increase, but it is necessary. I will give you a piece of data: with what we will collect from VAT from June until the end of the year, we can pay the benefits of five hundred thousand unemployed people.

J.R. Lucas .- Will the VAT be modified, Mr. President, in certain sectors? Just as it has been done for construction works, will it be modified or not touched, or lowered, in sectors like automobiles or tourism? Is that a possibility?

President .- We have limitations due to European regulations. Now what we are considering is a reduction in VAT for housing rehabilitation, which would have a VAT of 8 percent. This, along with a 10 percent deduction in the Personal Income Tax, will provide significant tax savings for those who decide to rehabilitate their homes.

Spain has 50 percent of homes that are over thirty years old, and therefore, there is a great potential for activity in rehabilitation. With that rehabilitation, if, in many cases, it is a rehabilitation to save energy, we will be making a great investment while also having the capacity to generate employment, because it is very labor-intensive, in the sector where the most jobs have been lost, which is the construction sector.

Q. Well .- Regarding the proposal to extend the retirement age, I would like us to put ourselves in the place of the worker who is watching us right now from home, who has worked all his life and is being proposed to retire a little beyond 65 years, while in the morning he leaves home and leaves his 25-year-old son in bed who cannot find a job.

President .- In terms of pensions, I believe that the government can present a fairly positive track record. Why? Because this is the government that has raised minimum pensions the most in all of democracy. We have raised minimum pensions by more than 30 percent in recent years, to very low pensions that have gained purchasing power.

What do we want for the future? We want to continue having increasingly dignified pensions. When we talk about the debate on the future of retirement, more than about pensions, we do so not thinking about the people who currently have a pension, whom it does not affect at all and whom we want to continue improving every year, especially minimum pensions; it does not affect those who are 55 or 60 years old; we are talking about the generation that is 35, 40, or 45 years old. We all know that our life expectancy has increased, we all know that pensions are gradually improving and will continue to improve, and we all know that we increasingly have the capacity to reach a reasonable age to remain in the workforce.

It is true that not all jobs are the same. One cannot talk about retirement at the same age for a person who works as a bricklayer on a construction site as for a person who is, presumably, in an administrative office performing advisory tasks. That must be very clear.

What do we want? We want to plan for the future, with maximum social and political agreement, so that our pension system continues to have the opportunity to improve pensions over the next twenty or twenty-five years. Among other measures we have proposed --I repeat, we have proposed, because it has not been a decree or a bill; it is a proposal for the Toledo Pact, because it requires consensus-- is that the actual retirement age approaches the legal one, because today we have a legal retirement age of 65 years but, however, the actual retirement age is 63 years and some months.

Therefore, we must start taking measures. One is the one proposed by the government for discussion and debate, and, of course, no one is more interested than this government… I believe it can be considered a proposal, not thinking about now, it is not a proposal of political or partisan interest; it is thinking about twenty or twenty-five years from now, because today I can say, with full satisfaction to all citizens, that we have a Social Security system in very good financial health. This year 2009, with the economic crisis, we have had an eight billion surplus and we have a Reserve Fund of 62 billion euros, which is a solid Reserve Fund.

Therefore, we are thinking about the future of our retirement to ensure that everyone has more dignified pensions, and the measures that need to be taken will be taken with consensus. The government has made an open proposal for other proposals.

A. Blanco .- I would like to return to the present to talk about young people. Youth unemployment in Spain is nearing 40 percent; it is the European country with the highest number of young people unemployed, and Pepa mentioned the contrast between those nearing retirement and those who have not yet found a job. The negotiations of the social dialogue between employers and unions were interrupted, but they have now resumed, and the government has given a deadline until April for them to reach an agreement. If that agreement is not reached, will the government do anything?

President .- We are going to reach an agreement. I believe that the willingness of employers, unions, and the government to carry out a labor market reform that facilitates, helps, and contributes to creating jobs is very strong. It is true that young people have been affected like no one else by job losses, especially young people with less qualification, because we have experienced in our country a phenomenon characterized by excessive construction of housing. I will give you a very significant piece of data: from 1997 to 2007, in ten years, we built in Spain the number of homes that we should have built in twenty years. This meant that we had many young people working in the construction sector who left school early because they had job opportunities; a number probably double what it would have been in a reasonable process of constructing a number of homes in Spain, around three hundred or four hundred thousand, and we reached eight hundred thousand.

My greatest concern is for those young people who left school or their training early, who went to work in sectors like construction or sectors related to construction, and today have more difficulties. We are going to dedicate the main measures in the social dialogue agreement with unions and employers to them. For them, the young people with that lower qualification, who have come out, especially from the construction sector; for them, the measures in favor of rehabilitation and the measures in favor of that investment program in two thousand public buildings for energy savings, which costs us nothing, which will save us three billion euros for the whole country and will generate employment; and also all the reform of Vocational Training that we are doing to improve employability.

Without a doubt, it is the greatest concern, the most serious problem we have, the employment of young people. But self-employed workers also have many difficulties.

A. Blanco .- Regarding young people. You said you want to support employers but without harming workers. Is it possible that in those plans that line could be crossed, which you have said you were not willing to cross, which is to make dismissal cheaper? Do you maintain that law?

President .- Yes, I maintain that principle and I maintain that it is possible to facilitate things for employers in hiring without harming workers' rights.

There are formulas that we are studying and formulas that we are working on in social dialogue, which, as you know, is a dialogue that normally has a technical work component, which we hope can see the light in a reasonable time frame --I would like it not to be more than two months-- and that, especially now, at this moment of recovery, where the future of the economy may have a more favorable perspective in a few months, contribute to creating jobs intensively.

The Spanish economy has demonstrated that when it grows, it creates jobs very intensively. It is true that now we have been the ones who have destroyed the most jobs, but it is no less true that in the previous years, from 2004 to 2008, we were the country that created the most jobs in the European Union.

Q. Well .- Tomorrow marks two years since the elections, since your last electoral victory. Mr. President, do you feel strong for these remaining two years of the legislature? Do you have the spirit to face this period that presents itself as very difficult? You will probably have to make tough decisions that may cost you votes.

President .- Yes, of course I feel strong and with a high sense of responsibility, especially regarding the consequences of the serious economic crisis and being able to offer results as soon as possible, especially for those who have lost their jobs to have a new expectation.

When will that be? When we move from negative growth to positive growth, when we move from destroying jobs to creating jobs. That will be the moment when we can say: we are in a different moment, we are coming out of recovery, while we have to work for the new foundations of our productive model, a model that must be based much more on efficiency and energy savings, on the deployment of Information Technologies, on innovation, on all the capacity to generate development, research..., that is to say, on productive activities.

I must say that we have many and that we have very competitive sectors in our country in the field of Communication Technologies, in the services sector or in the financial sector. What has happened to us, and this is an explanation, is that we had too much construction sector, we had an industrial sector that must grow -- and that is one of our objectives -- and other productive sectors that also need to expand their size.

That is the task that now corresponds to the Government. If we do it with all the political forces and if we renew our productive model towards the future, we will do it with more certainty and we will achieve it sooner because Spain, the Spain of the 21st century, has good foundations. We have improved extraordinarily to reach, as never before, historical quotas of training, education, innovative capacity or talent. We are at the best figures for the number of patents we are capable of generating and we are at the best figures for investment in Research, Development and Innovation. Never before have more Spanish companies succeeded in many sectors around the world and we must know that all that we have achieved we must enlarge, we must make it grow and not fall back into the mistakes of allowing a development of construction, of housing, which is much less productive.

A. Blanco .- Mr. President. You tell us that you have strength, that you feel encouraged for those two difficult years...

President .- Above all with responsibility.

A. Blanco .- ...and you talk to us about what you want to achieve. Will you do it with the same team? There has been much speculation about the possibility of a change of Government when the Spanish Presidency of the European Union ends. I am not going to ask you if José Blanco or Teresa Fernández de la Vega will be in this Government, but if there could be fewer Ministers.

President .- It is not in my plans. I am happy with the government team I have. I must say that it is a government team that is working under very difficult circumstances. An economic crisis like this fortunately happens every so often and, of course, not only they, but all the senior officials and civil servants have worked with great intensity.

I was asked earlier if there had been any contradictions in the measures. I gave the data and I remember: we have taken 137 measures to fight against the economic crisis. If in two or three there has been some insufficient explanation that may have seemed like a contradiction, I think it is understandable. It is absolutely understandable because the effort is being very great for many people, working in the Administration and in all the Ministries, because we know the responsibility we have. We know that there are people who are having a hard time, it is our main concern and we know that all the work we do will be little to overcome the crisis.

J.R. Lucas .- So, Mr. President, do we understand that there will be no government crisis when the Spanish Presidency of the European Union ends? I say this because, if someone has the temptation to make predictions, they might think that someone who would not be changed would be the Minister of the Interior, Mr. Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba, because in the Government's record in the fight against terrorism, in the fight against ETA, there is something very important: collaboration with other countries is working and in two years ETA has been decapitated five times, which is no small matter. However, there are issues in the opposition..., and some media are emphasizing a matter that I do not know if from your point of view tarnishes all this and it is the issue to clarify of Bar Faisán, that supposed leak. Does that worry you, Mr. President? Do you think it tarnishes the Government's fight against terrorism, the successes in this matter?

President .- The truth is that the Government has worked very, very intensively in the fight against ETA, in seeing ETA's end as soon as possible. I will give you some data: since we have been in Government, there have been 831 arrests of members of ETA or of "kale borroka"; since the end of the truce, of the peace process, 464 arrests, and so far this year, 32 arrests, and the leadership of ETA has been dismantled five times. Of course, I believe that public opinion knows very well, and the Government knows it too, that ETA is going through one of its worst circumstances and that we are closer than ever to the end, although I must warn that ETA can always harm us, it can always make us suffer.

It is very difficult for someone to try to tarnish that reality. I already experienced in the last Legislature a criticism on such a State issue, so for everyone, as is the fight against terrorism, and I already experienced many criticisms and disqualifications. I lived that we surrendered to ETA and, however, it has been proven that we fought to end ETA as soon as possible and effectively.

However, I would like that the climate of unity that the fight against terrorism demands would be the climate that presides over the relations between all political forces and that today, with perspective, we can conclude that the peace process was a process that has done a lot of damage to ETA and to the violent, and has made democracy much stronger. My gratitude to all those who are in the fight against terrorism is very great.

And on that issue you raise -- I have said it many times -- there is a judicial investigation and let us respect, as always, the actions of Justice.

J.R. Lucas .- Mr. President, one more question on this. Have you given up your dream or your legitimate ambition to end ETA while you are in charge of the Government?

President .- I believe that this is an ambition of every Spaniard and, of course, of every President of the Government. You know that the greatest aspiration that this society can have is to see the end of that scourge that is ETA. What I can affirm today is that in these six years that I have been at the head of the Government, the result is being very favorable on the path to seeing ETA increasingly diminished, with less capacity, with less support and with fewer followers, and to see, as we are seeing, democracy increasingly strong in the defense of freedom, thanks, to a large extent, to the work of judges, police and civil guards, which I want to emphasize here today.

P. Bueno .- Mr. President, I have to ask you about another contradiction. Regarding the investigation being carried out by the National Court about the alleged relations between ETA, the FARC and the Government of Venezuela, it was first mentioned to ask for explanations; then, that what was requested was information and this weekend we witnessed the signing of a joint document with a Government, one of whose ministers subsequently criticized the Spanish justice that is investigating precisely that alleged relationship.

President .- Let us not complicate matters. I have heard that it is said that there were contradictions. To inform, one must explain and that is what the Government of Spain has done in response to a ruling from a judge to which everyone must lend their cooperation; of course, the Government of Spain, which will do so, and, of course, the Government of Venezuela. The Government of Venezuela has denied its possible collaboration in that link between the FARC and ETA, that has been expressed in a public statement and has expressed its condemnation of ETA and its absolute rejection of terrorism. That was the joint statement.

We heard yesterday some statements from the Minister of Foreign Affairs, which I do not consider acceptable, criticizing the judge and the former President of the Government. It is not the first time that I have come to the defense of former President Aznar precisely also in relation to Venezuela. I have done it outside of Spain in other circumstances and I do it now. That said, I want to tell Mr. Rajoy, because I heard a statement from him this afternoon, I believe, or at noon saying that I had backed Judge Garzón and not the judge who issued the ruling on the relations between ETA and the FARC. I must say that I believe there has not been very good faith because, evidently, my statement was yesterday and it was before the statement from the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Venezuela was known, which, I insist, does not seem acceptable to me.

The objective of the Government with Venezuela, with Mexico and with all the countries where there have been and are members of the terrorist band ETA is to have permanent collaboration to follow their steps, to achieve extradition and to ensure that they have no support. And I can assure you that one of the fronts we have worked most intensively on in these years -- it is true that it is discreet work -- has been the front of reducing support, coverage, or even understanding, for ETA or its supporters around the world; in many countries. We could make a very extensive list and I will tell you that it has yielded great results. One of the reasons for ETA's great weakness is that it has practically no one in the world, not only who supports it, but not even who listens to it, when this was a front that they worked on.

Now we have to work with Venezuela more intensely to prevent any of the members who are there or sympathizers of ETA from having any type of support or coverage. I hope to count on the support of the Government of Venezuela, to which I ask, of course, for respect for the judicial institutions and respect also for former President Aznar, once again.

A. Blanco .- You just mentioned Baltasar Garzón, who has several pending cases in the Supreme Court, and you referred to the words he dedicated this weekend, to the defense he made, highlighting his courage in the fight against terrorism. Mariano Rajoy believes that those words, apart from what he mentioned about comparing the actions regarding the two judges, were a pressure on Justice, and the General Council of the Judiciary has also called for respect for its work. What do you have to say to those reactions that have provoked your words?

President .- I have emphasized that Baltasar Garzón has done a brave job, as a judge, in the fight against terrorism, just as judges, prosecutors, police and civil guards have done, and I have emphasized that on other occasions. This is indisputable and I will do it whenever necessary, while I made it clear in my statement yesterday in Granada that I respected, as I always do and as the Government always does, the actions that any person may have of responsibility before Justice, in this case of Baltasar Garzón.

But I must say that defending the work of Baltasar Garzón in the fight against ETA, which I have experienced as President of the Government, and his effort -- just like, I insist, other judges; I am not going to name anyone because surely the list would be very long -- I believe it is my obligation and my responsibility, and that does not imply absolutely any type of interference in anything or anyone.

He, like all citizens, if he has to respond before the Law, will respond if there is an open judicial procedure. So, we should not confuse the terms and, therefore, I must tell Mr. Rajoy that he is simply wrong, that he is wrong. Just as on other occasions I have heard leaders of the Popular Party praise Garzón's work in the fight against ETA, I believe that we should say that about him and about all those who do it; otherwise, it would be unfair and it is independent of the judicial matters he may have in any jurisdictional body.

J.R. Lucas .- Mr. President, we are already finishing this dialogue but, of course, we cannot fail to mention the date, March 8, International Women's Day, and I would like to raise two questions: on the one hand, today the European Union has adopted a Spanish initiative within the Presidency of the European Union on gender violence, which seems to me to be remarkable; at the same time, on the eve of this day yesterday some Spanish capitals were filled with protests against the reform of the Abortion Law. I would like to know your opinion on the first and, regarding the second, do you think that Spain is divided on this issue?

President .- One of the great axes of the political project that I carry out is equality between men and women. The most advanced and modern societies are those societies where women have a role of full incorporation and full rights. That is why we made an Equality Law, that is why we have made many measures in favor of reconciliation and incorporation, and that is why we have much left to do, especially in terms of wage equality.

Today, indeed, there has been a very important decision by the European Union to adopt as a major European policy, which was the objective of the Spanish Presidency of the Union, the fight against gender violence. And we have approved a new Law on Voluntary Termination of Pregnancy, a law that simply aims to make things safer for women and to prevent any woman from going to jail for having a voluntary termination of pregnancy, while it is also a more preventive law against unwanted pregnancies.

I have to say that there is hypocrisy among some leaders of the Popular Party, because they governed for eight years, there was a very high number of abortions in our country with a law that proved not to provide sufficient guarantees, which had a regulation that left much to be desired so that the very hard and difficult process of voluntary interruption of pregnancy gives guarantees to women, and now I hear them say certain things that are not comparable to what center-right represents in the European Union.

This Law that we have approved in Parliament, on Voluntary Interruption of Pregnancy, is a law that is in line with the average of European countries where, as is known, center-right parties often govern and where they have been proposed and supported by center-right parties. Honestly, I think it places them in an ultra-conservative position, alien to what should be an understanding of the difficult ordeal that is voluntarily interrupting a pregnancy.

It is about ensuring that no woman goes to jail -- it is a commitment I have expressed many times and is already in the Law -- that no woman feels intimidated, that she does not feel intimidated or threatened by what the Penal Code may say or by any action, and, of course, that it is respected with more guarantees and more security. I hope and wish that this Law also serves to prevent unwanted pregnancies.

Q. Well .- Let's talk about the Spanish Presidency of the European Union. You are now in a perfect vantage point to tell us. What is happening with Europe, President, because the Lisbon Treaty was approved so that Europe would have more weight in the world and we were left out of the Copenhagen climate agreement, Obama has taken us off his agenda, the representative of European diplomacy is practically missing? What is happening with Europe and with the application of the Treaty, and what do you intend to remain when the Spanish Presidency ends?

President .- A nuance to your question: Europe did not remain outside the climate change agreement; moreover, Europe has been the political union, the region, that has done the most for the progress that we would have liked, which would have been greater, in the fight against climate change and that has adopted commitments with more strength to reduce the emission of polluting gases.

Europe has undergone a process of enlargement. Many countries have integrated into the European Union and that has forced us to change the rules of operation. That is the Lisbon Treaty. It has just come into force so that the European Union functions more effectively, is stronger, has more unity, and weighs more in the world. Let us not have that perspective of our weight; we have a great weight in the world as the European Union.

Now, at this moment, the priority of the Spanish Presidency of the European Union, of the rotating Presidency, is to combat the economic crisis and set a strategy, the Strategy called 2020, for the next ten years, in which Europe wins the battle of competitiveness, wins the battle of innovation, and wins the battle of employment.

In March, this month, we are going to approve that Strategy 2020 which will allow for a horizon of economic growth for Europe. For this, more European economic governance is necessary; more economic union; strengthen and expand the internal market; make more common policies in energy matters; make more common policy in digital development, and make more common policy in Research and Innovation. And we will undoubtedly ensure that Europe gains the capacity to compete with the most advanced regions of the world, such as the United States, and with those that are emerging with great strength, like China, India, or Brazil.

Q. Well .- Would it be a golden touch, President, for the Spanish Presidency to have a Champions final in Spanish?

President .- Yes. As long as the Spanish teams, and it is true that in football we are currently at a very high level, can compete in a final, it is a good golden touch for everything, right?

Q. Well .- And one last thing already. Will we see you in the Barça box now that they have lost the lead? To cheer them on, I mean.

President .- If the circumstances coincide at some point, I would like to. I have seen Barça in the Champions finals, I have gone to see them and, of course, as everyone knows that they are my favorite colors, I have had a lot of satisfaction. Now the League is quite exciting, but we will see.

Q. Well .- We finish, colleagues.

A. Blanco .- We have no more time. Thank you, President.

President .- Thank you very much.