Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

9 March 2010 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions during a March 2010 congressional control session, addressing Spain's newly approved Immigration Law and its implementation.
Main themes
Immigration law development, irregular immigration management, immigrant integration policy, municipal registration of immigrants, role of autonomous communities and municipalities, social dialogue, immigration model reform, inter-administrative cooperation, employment of foreigners, immigration policy trust deficit
Duration
~21 min
69th percentile
Words
2,558
69th percentile
Sentences
79
52nd percentile
Readability
30
16th percentile
Grade
17.0
89th percentile
Syntax
3.44
91st percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
55th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 34%33%
  • Geopolitical 20%19%
  • Economic 16%15%
  • Ceremonial 16%15%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

79 sentences in 43 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Antoni Duran i Lleida, of the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergence and Union

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Duran.- Mr. President, what measures do you plan to adopt in the development of the recently approved Immigration Law?

President.- Mr. Duran, the Government has already begun the work of developing the Immigration Law, specifically, with the approval of three instructions that regulate its immediate application, and, secondly, with the drafting of the Development Regulation, in which many of the major options of the Law must be specified. As was the case with the current Regulation, the Government wants the social and political agreement that presided over the drafting of the Law to be maintained now, and for that reason, on February 1 of this year, work on the Regulation began in the Social Dialogue Table, to reach a first fundamental agreement: that of trade union and business organizations regarding the employment of foreigners.

Just a week later, on February 9, the Government opened a second area of dialogue: it invited Communities and Local Entities to make any observations and proposals they deem appropriate. As you well know, Mr. Duran, the Law introduces significant innovations, largely driven by your Group, that recognize and expand the role that Communities and Municipalities have in terms of social integration within the framework of the general immigration policy. Consequently, the Government is rapidly promoting the application and development of the new Law.

Mr. Duran.- Thank you, Mr. President, for your information.

From our point of view, the model of immigration policy developed since the year 2000 has not been a good model. Irregular immigration has been an important part of it, and there is no trust on the part of citizens regarding the capacity of the policy, in general, to manage immigration.

On the other hand, you know well that, to a large extent, the economic development of recent years has been based precisely on flows of low-skilled migrant populations and that this model has come to an end. In that sense, we cannot continue to rely on the immigration model that we have had to date. Are there proposals in that regard towards that objective? I do not know of any from the Government.

Furthermore, the Municipalities and Autonomous Communities have been left unsupported. They are the ones who first address the integration of immigrants, which is, in any case, the key to ensuring that there is no problem with the cohesion of their respective cities or populations. In that sense, this Parliamentary Group urges this Chamber through a Non-Legislative Proposition presented, which will be debated in due course, and wants to extend these requests to the Government, to create an important fund. Not simply those created in the various General State Budgets in favor of the Municipalities to make their integration possible; it should also provide Municipalities with legal instruments to control the capacity for registration of housing by immigrant citizens.

You must know, as I do, that in Barcelona, at one point, there were sixteen thousand or seventeen thousand immigrants registered at a single address on Avenida Meridiana, who have since been distributed across different addresses in districts of Barcelona, but always social.

Moreover, recently, following a query from the City Council of Vic --by the way, in parentheses, many harsh words were said against Catalonia and against Vic, which is pure ignorance of what the City Council of Vic and many other City Councils have done--, new problems are being raised, in which the Government will have to respond regarding the registration of irregular persons. Should that registration be communicated by the Municipalities as irregular to the Government? Should they not do so? Should they do it in the principle of inter-administrative cooperation? What should those Municipalities do when they have irregular populations in their censuses and are obliged, according to the institutions, to…?

President.- Mr. Duran, in my opinion, we must make a somewhat more measured assessment of what has been the challenge that Spanish society as a whole and the different Administrations have had to assume as a consequence of an intense phenomenon of immigration in our country. That measured judgment leads me to emphasize that Spanish society has managed this process very well, which has brought important contributions to our economy; that we must always pursue a policy of integration and coexistence, from legality; that, for this, the Government has allocated funds, as determined by Parliament, and that this new Immigration Law, and its development, must clarify some things, certainly everything that affects the municipal register. And, of course, we are willing to consider everything that has to do with increasing the possibilities for greater integration in coexistence, in values, of immigration in our country at the local level, which is the most conducive area.

But let us approach this debate from a positive perspective, distancing any temptation, which is evidently very dangerous in society, regarding what the phenomenon entails…

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josu Iñaki Erkoreka, of the Basque Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, on December 23, the Plenary of this Chamber approved by a very large majority, close to unanimity, a Non-Legislative Proposition in which objectives and priorities were set for the rotating Presidency that you are currently exercising. In one of the first points of that document, related to the trans-European railway networks, the Mediterranean Corridor was mentioned, but there was also a commitment to enhance --this is literally the expression used in the document-- the Atlantic Axis of the Paris-Lisbon railway line, through Bordeaux, Dax, Hendaya, Valladolid, and Madrid.

Since then, we have heard several high-ranking officials from your Government make emphatic statements declaring the absolute priority of the Mediterranean Axis. We have no objections in that regard, but since we have not heard anything similar or even remotely equivalent regarding the Atlantic Axis, I pose the question that appears on the agenda: what measures will the Government take during the rotating Presidency to enhance the Atlantic Axis and the Paris-Lisbon railway line through Bordeaux, Dax, Hendaya, Valladolid, and Madrid?

President.- Mr. Erkoreka, the axis you refer to, which is the so-called High-Speed Railway Axis of Southwestern Europe, connecting Portugal, Spain, and France, has already been designated as priority project number 3 of the Trans-European Transport Network. Its commissioning has the support of France, which is working on the connection with Hendaya, with a section already very advanced between Tours and Bordeaux, and we have established a European Economic Interest Grouping to facilitate the development of the international section of the Atlantic Axis through Irún and Hendaya, and to be able to receive European financial aid.

The total investment planned by Spain in the Axis exceeds 29.5 billion euros, and we have already executed more than 50 percent, practically 16 billion euros. To refer to a specific section, the construction projects for all sections between Burgos and Vitoria are already being drafted, so that in the second half of 2010 we will tender the works, and between Vitoria-Mondragón and Bilbao, thirteen of its eighteen sections are under execution, and by the end of this year, we will tender two more sections. For its part, the Basque Government is responsible for the construction of the line from Mondragón to Irún.

Therefore, Mr. Erkoreka, to your satisfaction, and also to the satisfaction of the Government, I can fully confirm that the so-called Atlantic Axis and the network you are interested in with that question are a Spanish and European priority.

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, you have explained to me why you see the glass half full, and I will tell you why we see it half empty.

During this first semester, you hold the dual position of President of the Spanish Government and rotating President of the European Union, and the issue I am asking you about affects you in your dual capacity. As President of the Government, you will have to explain the delay that the Trans-European Axis is experiencing on the Spanish side. You have just provided absolutely new data regarding the Vitoria-Burgos section, because just two months ago we were officially told by the Ministry of Development that there was not even a project for that section, absolutely no project. I have the responses issued to written questions by our Parliamentary Group.

Therefore, you will have to explain why this delay occurs in the part that concerns you as President of the Spanish Government; but as rotating President, you are also called upon to commit to an Axis that was declared a priority almost sixteen years ago at the Summits of Corfu and Essen, and still the section from Bordeaux to the border is as green, at least, as that of Vitoria and Burgos.

Mr. President, if, truly, as you have just told me, you are committed to this project, take advantage of the European Presidency to advance it and to push it forward definitively. Otherwise, the European Presidency may end, and we will have to regret that you did not fulfill your duties as either the Spanish President or the European President.

President.- I have given you the data on how the sections affecting Spain are progressing, especially those that relate to the Basque Country. Of course, these are the official data, and it follows that there is a great political will and that they are progressing at a good pace.

Regarding the European aspect, I can inform your Lordships that next June in Zaragoza, there will be, together with the European Commission, a ministerial meeting where all support for the Trans-European High-Speed Railway Networks will be ratified and consolidated, and, of course, for the network we are debating today, which, I insist, has no delays, but rather has all the political will to be completed as soon as possible. And I am sure that the Ministry of Development will be able to provide you with all the data, even more detailed than I can in the course of this question.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- On February 24, the prisoner of conscience Orlando Zapata died in Cuba, after a hunger strike. Cuba remains a dictatorship today, there are more than 200 political prisoners in its jails, and it is the second country in the world in terms of the number of journalists imprisoned.

The European Union established a common position on Cuba in 1996. Your Minister of Foreign Affairs has attempted to cancel it, and during his last visit to Havana, he said that changing it was a priority of the Spanish Presidency; not, of course, in favor of the Cuban dissidents who oppose it, as an overwhelming majority of democrats around the world. I wanted to know your position on this matter, Mr. President.

Secondly, I want to refer to Venezuela. Following the ruling of the National Court regarding the involvement of Venezuelan authorities in the collaboration between the FARC and ETA, there was an unacceptable and improper reaction from the Venezuelan President and his Chancellor with insults directed at Spain, the judge, the previous Prime Minister, and his Government.

Your reaction, and that of your Government, was confusing and contradictory --we do not know if you asked for explanations or not-- and ended with a joint statement that explained nothing and, moreover, criticized the Spanish press.

You said on television that all this was unacceptable and regrettable. From that point on, I ask you if you are going to do something or if you are going to remain with those two qualifiers.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, these are two distinct issues in one question. Regarding Cuba, we can agree that the struggle for human rights is a universal struggle and that it is part of an absolute priority of the foreign policy that the Government has been practicing in recent years with one objective: to be useful in that defense of human rights and to do everything in our power for the freedom of political prisoners in Cuba.

We have achieved some success, we continue to work in favor of those political prisoners, we continue to work with some people who are currently on hunger strike, and I hope to count on support in that mission, in that task, in that objective, which we can share.

In relation to Venezuela, just as with Venezuela or any other country, the Government of Spain practices a policy that does not leave any space for support and understanding for what could be terrorist activity, and much more so that which is linked to ETA terrorism. This has been the norm in recent years and with good results, because the international support, the certain international support or the certain understanding that the terrorist group ETA has had has been significantly reduced thanks to diplomatic efforts and the efforts of the Ministry of the Interior, which has contributed to the weakness that the ETA terrorist group currently has.

About a country like Venezuela, every time one of its leaders has made a critical, unacceptable statement, it has been responded to here or outside of here, outside of Spain, by the Government of Spain in appropriate terms, considering it intolerable. That is how we have acted, that is how we will act, and, of course, in everything that concerns the collaboration of the judge's ruling to establish any possible link between ETA, the FARC, and the collaboration of some public servants from another country.

I hope that, as we are dealing with a matter of state regarding foreign policy and the fight against terrorism, your position, Mr. Rajoy, will be constructive, reasonable, and, of course, with the Government's commitment to provide all necessary information.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, my position is constructive, but some aspects of your international policy are absolutely incomprehensible.

As I want to be constructive, I will tell you some things that, in my opinion, you should do and that I believe are shared by the vast majority of the Chamber.

In the case of Cuba, and I will raise it here, I ask that dissidents be invited to the National Day of Spain, October 12, at the Spanish Embassy in Cuba; secondly, I ask that support be given for the International Red Cross to visit Cuban prisons; thirdly, I ask that the European Union's position on Cuba not be changed and that this Chamber calls for the release of all political prisoners.

In the case of Venezuela, I ask that the Minister of Foreign Affairs appear here to explain what happened, because this Chamber has the right to know what has happened, and I ask that the Venezuelan Ambassador in Spain be summoned to express our strongest protest for what has been done here and that a verbal note be delivered to him to ensure that it is documented in writing, because, if not, Mr. President, it may convey the impression that insulting Spain or insulting its Government is free of charge.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, you can ask for whatever you want, of course; but when it comes to seeking a shared and state policy, before asking, one must share and listen. I ask you…