Press Conference by the President of the Government and the President of the European Commission
José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Zapatero held a joint press conference with European Commission President Barroso in Madrid on February 22, 2010, during Spain's EU Council Presidency.
- Main themes
- Spanish Rotating Presidency of the EU, Lisbon Treaty, economic crisis and recovery, Europe 2020 strategy, EU-Latin America relations, community method, energy policy, internal market, digital agenda, gender equality, civil society development, EU-Spain cooperation
- Duration
- ~43 min
- Words
- 5,115
- Sentences
- 178
- Readability
- 43
- Grade
- 14.3
- Syntax
- 3.24
- Vocabulary
- 2.03
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
178 sentences in 76 paragraphs
President of the Government - Good afternoon.
First of all allow me to say how pleased I am to be attending this press conference with the President of the Commission, José Manuel Durao Barroso. You know, of course, that the Government of Spain and the Commission have a very positive working relationship; and a unique relationship with the President of the Commission.
And you are well aware, today is an important day for the Spanish Rotating Presidency of the European Union. We have had a meeting of the Commission and the Government of Spain and we are going to continue with this over lunch. Furthermore I should emphasise the fact that all twenty-seven members of the Commission were present, which has given them the opportunity to have the first photo taken of this new Commission with everyone together and I am pleased that this first photo was taken in Spain.
Very briefly I would like to add some conclusions from the developments of the working day so that the President of the Commission can then give us his impressions.
Firstly we are in a period of changes in the European Union: the Lisbon Treaty, which is a new political architecture seeking to move the European Union towards greater unity and more efficiency. The fundamental role to see a more united European Union, in order for the common policies to gain space and for cooperation among the twenty-seven to be even better and progress, lies with the European Commission.
To be pro-European is to progress with Community methods and the Community decisions are within the power of the European Commission. Therefore, I have told the President and the Commission as a whole, of Spain's firm commitment in this period, and this is what we are doing, and how it is going to be in these six months, to strengthen the Commission's role so that in this, the first stage of the Lisbon Treaty the Community method should have some guidelines and a precedent that are gradually consolidated in the future.
Secondly, the economic crisis, economic recovery and the new economic model that has to stimulate Europe following the crisis are the top priority of these six months and they are set out in the 2020 Economic Strategy that the Commission is going to present very soon. Work has been focused on this in the preceding weeks.
You know that we have raised some points for economic recovery and especially regarding the main issues that represent that our recovery, the Union's recovery, leads us to more competitive and innovative growth. That is why the aspects relative to economic cooperation, to energy, to the common energy policy; the aspects relative to the development of the internal market, to the digital agenda and to the policy in favour of an industry that cooperates and coordinates in emerging sectors, such as the electric car, are fundamental issues that we have to tackle together.
Apart from that, you know that of top priority of the Union's foreign policy are the agreements with Latin America in the Summit to be held here in Madrid. There are some significant economic agreements with Central America, with the Andean Community and with MERCOSUR, the latter, without a doubt is the one that is going to require the greatest effort from us.
I want to express my gratitude for the Commission's support and interest to reach these agreements. You know that for Spain - and for Europe, but especially for Spain - it is very important to open up a new economic-trade area with the whole of Latin America, or at least practically the whole of Latin America.
Lastly, although it affects other aspects, we have as you know placed emphasis on what we could call a development of civil society in the European Union area and of principles of civil society: equality between men and women, with that desire to encourage an equality action plan and with initiatives that the President of the Commission has discussed with us, that we support; and also the popular initiative as one of the topics in that development effort for a civil society that we are considering, that we have promoted and that we hope we can approve in full collaboration with the Commission in this period of Spain's Rotating Presidency.
To the Commission - to this young Commission - which I have seen has vitality and energy, Spain renews its offer of loyalty and support. For us, to say Europe and to say European Union is the same as saying that we back and support the European Commission, the guardian of the Treaties, which is the owner of the initiative and to whom we must give our support to consolidate those Community policies that have given good results to the European process and that benefit all the countries.
Thank you for all your hard work and as always we are going to continue to collaborate very closely.
Mr. Durao Barroso. - First of all I have to thank the President of the Government, José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero, for receiving us here in Madrid today, and for the excellent collaboration during almost two months of the Spanish Presidency of the European Union.
As we were already doing at the beginning of January, in a more limited way, today we are dealing with the priorities of these six months, one of which stands out above all others: our absolute and shared priority is the economic recovery together with the creation of employment.
The 2020 European Strategy, whose most basic pillars we presented at the end of last year, will provide the goals and the instruments to advance towards a more sustainable economic growth model, more based on knowledge, a creator of employment and even guaranteeing the viability of our social systems, which are unique in the world. In other words, Europe must aspire to more than just getting back on its feet after this crisis; the European economy must move in a new direction and not allow itself to be left behind.
The Commission is presenting the formal document for the new 2020 Strategy on the 3 March, with detailed proposals to summarise the discussions: initiatives in the field of energy, the digital economy and an action plan for innovation or for energy, to name just a few.
I would like to take advantage of this occasion to highlight the exceptional contribution of the Government of Spain, and of its President, Prime Minister Rodriguez Zapatero, with specific ideas for this new Strategy. The question of energy, the digital issue, the specific plan for the electric car - these are all contributions for which we are indebted to Spain - being political and intellectual contributions that are essential for the proposals that the Commission is now going to present and discuss. I hope that the European Council is able to take the necessary decisions based on these proposals on 25 and 26 March, because there is no time to lose.
We have also discussed putting the new Lisbon Treaty into practice, the new rails on which the European locomotive is running since 1 January. The Lisbon Treaty also strengthens our capacity to face up to the economic and financial crisis. It gives us the foundations to promote a closer coordination of the economic policies of the Eurozone countries, an idea that appears in the political orientations for my second mandate and an idea that I know is also essential for the Spanish Presidency: that is the strengthening of the mechanisms for economic governing in Europe, especially in the Eurozone.
The fight against climate change, energy security, the threats from organised crime and terrorism, immigration…, in all these areas, the new Treaty opens up possibilities for us to bring European responses to threats that know no boundaries. Furthermore, for the first time the Treaty provides a citizen's initiative, the popular initiative by which one million citizens from various Member States may directly ask the European Commission to present an initiative that they consider is appropriate within the European Union spheres of competence.
The Lisbon Treaty reinforces our capacity for action and influence at an international level with the creation of a European External Action Service. It is a major challenge since we must demonstrate to European citizens that the European Union talks and acts with a single voice, and that it listens at an international level. I therefore also want to mention the top priority, which we know is also a priority for Spain and for Europe - the Summit with Latin American and the Caribbean. I hope that in that Summit we can reach agreements with Central America and with the Andean Community and I also hope that progress can be made in negotiating an agreement with MERCOSUR.
I know that in respect of all these issues I can count on the effective and determined support, indeed with the exceptional support of President Rodríguez Zapatero and of the Spanish Government as a whole to successfully carry out these tasks.
I want to once again express my gratitude for the pro-European conviction of Spain and of its Government through the President of its Government; the conviction in the Community method, the reinforcement of the Community method as a guarantee of the application of the Treaties, of the Lisbon Treaty and of the advances in our project for European construction.
I should like to finish by quoting the great philosopher Ortega y Gasset. He said that "it is only possible to progress when one thinks about the bigger picture; it is only possible to advance when one looks to the future". Spain, when it thinks about Europe, it is thinking about the bigger picture and therefore once again, I would like to say thank you very much indeed. Q. - I would like to ask the President of the Government if you are considering back-tracking or reconsidering your proposal to delay retirement age, after the rejection we saw yesterday in the Toledo Pact Committee, and after this afternoon, and for the first time in six years, the Unions have called for industrial action against your Government.
I would also like to ask the President of the European Commission about the same issue. Delaying retirement age is not only an issue in Spain; it is also an issue in other European countries. Do you think that it is a necessary measure for the sake of guaranteeing, as you yourself said, the European social system?
President of the Government - As I already said yesterday, and I'm going to repeat it today, that the proposal about the future of pensions is a proposal for dialogue, agreement and consensus. And, of course, amongst the players I am going to invite to the consensus and to the dialogue are the stakeholders; they are decisive.
If the Government had wanted to do something else, it would have produced a Draft Bill, or a Decree. No, it has made a proposal in a document at the Toledo Pact and the proposal is going to be useful, without a doubt - we hope there will be others - for us to channel a debate. The debate is that I want a system of social protection or for robust, solid pensions for Spain, not just for the next decade, we have to continue improving pensions, but rather for within twenty or thirty years.
We can do this between all of us and with agreement. You know full well that Cándido Méndez and the General Secretary of Comisiones Obreras will do it by agreement, because it is in the interests of all citizens and because, by agreement with the workers, with the unions and with all the parties, there is no doubt that confidence in the future of the pensions system will be much stronger, and here I insist this is in the long-term future.
But the Government would not be acting responsibly if it did not raise the issue, as it has done, of the perspective of the demographic evolution of our country, fortunately for the aging population. I say fortunately because the expectation of life is the longest or one of the best in Europe and the world. And we have to face up to this situation by doing our homework today so as not to have problems tomorrow - by tomorrow I mean the day after tomorrow - and we are going to do it by consensus.
I know that those who have called the demonstration and those who are going to demonstrate know that this Government listens and listens to them. It is going to listen to them, it is going to hold talks and I am convinced that we will reach agreement on progressive reforms for our pension system.
We all have the same interest. Is there anyone who can have so much interest as this Government in that pensioners' rights should be guaranteed and that pensions should increase? Why? Because this is the Government that has raised minimum pensions the most in the whole of the democracy; the Government with the most sensitivity; and this is a Government that has been meticulous in managing the Social Security system so that we have a Reserve Fund today of 62,000 million euros to give security to our future pensions.
But one has to think about next year, and the next, and the next, when we will continue raising minimum pensions, improving them and also in twenty, twenty-five and thirty years time, as, if anything characterises the pensions system, it is inter-generational solidarity.
Those of us who have the responsibility today for leading the country, we have to try to improve the lot of those who have worked, who have given their all and who today have a pension, so that they have a decent pension; but we also have to think about those who are going to retire in fifteen or twenty years' time, because at that time there will be many more of us who are going to live longer - or so we hope.
And as we are talking about the long term, the debate is a debate that we can have calmly. It has nothing to do with the circumstances of the crisis, or with the economic situation. Also as a country, the same as for other countries, we can and we must sit down and work to face the challenges of the future.
I believe that some of the problems we have today in the Spanish economy should certainly have been faced some time ago with insight. We have that possibility today and we are going to do it calmly.
Therefore, for those who disagree, this is a Government that listens. This is not a Government that has been, nor is it going to be one that passes legislation on labour relations and even less likely to do so on social protection, that are subsequently declared unconstitutional. No, this is a Government for social agreement, dialogue, a government that thinks about the future. Therefore we shall reach an agreement.
Mr. Durao Barroso .- I wasn't expecting that question. I'm not very clear about commenting on a Spanish issue that is for the Spanish authorities, however, I would like to say something general about Europe.
The sustainability of our systems is also an issue that we are discussing under the 2020 Strategy. In fact, there is a problem in Europe. If we are going to look at the demography, reforms to the pensions system in general will have to be made. Many countries have already made them and others are working on them.
One recommendation from the Commission, if we can quote it, is quite clear; to do it within the framework of social dialogue at a national level, and also at a European level, where there is discussion between the European Trade Union Confederation and the Confederation of Business Owners (BUSINESSEUROPE), the European Employers' Association, which is also very important when we look at the demographic situation in Europe, which is obviously good because people live longer, but there is a sustainability problem.
We have to think about pensions today, but also tomorrow and the next day, about the future. So, we at the Commission are encouraging the various Governments to be responsible in social dialogue, to promote the necessary reforms for the sustainability of that system that we want to maintain. And precisely because we want the European model of society with a high social commitment, reforms are necessary in order to be sure that in the future we are going to have our European system of social security and pensions.
Q. - A question for President Rodríguez Zapatero. Portugal and Spain are signing a new Memorandum of Cooperation today to fight terrorism. How do you see the recent operations against ETA and what comments do you have about its current capacity to continue attacking, even from Portugal?
And to President Durao Barroso, two short questions. Firstly, when do you think support for Madeira will be defined?
Secondly, do you feel there is enough consensus in the European Union to reach agreement on the security policy, especially on that referring to issues such as airport security and, in particular, the question of body scanners? There have been differing positions between Governments and I would like a comment from you on the subject.
President of the Government. - You have asked me about Portugal and my first words are to express my utmost solidarity with the inhabitants of Madeira; my condolences to the families who have lost their loved ones; my commitment to support and we have offered it, to Prime Minister Sócrates' Government, and I also want to say I am pleased that one of the issues that we dealt with in the meeting was President Durao Barroso's commitment to the situation in Madeira.
In connection with the fight against terrorism and police collaboration in favour of security between Portugal and Spain, relations are excellent.
Cooperation is excellent, as has been demonstrated by the actions against ETA. I am deeply grateful to the Government of Portugal, and to the Ministry of the Interior for the diligence and effectiveness it has shown in dismantling what the terrorist group ETA had intended as a logistics and support base.
Terrorists and ETA know that the pursuit, investigation and the task of our State Security Forces to reach all places where they intend to hide, to seek supplies or to act are permanent, constant and effective. We have made a high number of arrests of members of the terrorist group ETA; the latest two were only last night. The work of the State Security Forces is impressively effective and of course, that means that democracy, the law, is stronger every day and that we will not stop until these violent people are definitively overcome.
Mr. Durao Barroso . - Regarding the question of cooperation between Portugal and Spain, I cannot say any more than I fully support that cooperation.
As far as Madeira is concerned, as the President of the Spanish Government has said that we have talked about it and I had the chance to tell him, as I had already told him in Portugal, that the European Union, through the Solidarity Fund, has various ways of dealing with regional disasters and a special method for outlying areas; it may support the reconstruction if the Portuguese authorities makes its application in a period of ten weeks.
So, certainly, this issue will be considered and dealt with explicitly by the European Commission. From what will be our analysis of the damage caused, you can be sure that we are going to be able to show wholehearted European solidarity with Madeira, with a region that has been horribly affected by a tragedy of these dimensions.
Concerning the last question you asked me, I obviously hope for an agreement between the Member States on the anti-terrorist measures, as it seems to me that it would be difficult to accept that in the European space, not just in the Schengen Area, we should have enormous differences among the various airports. It would not be useful, not from the security point of view, nor from the point of view of the movement of people, nor from an economic point of view either. It would, I believe, be counterproductive for there to be different security systems in the various airports. So, the Commission will do whatever is necessary to provide, as far as is possible, a common approach to the preventive measures that must be taken in the European area.
Q . - A couple of specific questions, one for the President of the Commission and another for the President of the Spanish Government.
For Mr. Durao Barroso. I don't know if you have heard the statements by the General Secretary of the OECD this morning, who said, in Madrid, that the Spanish debt is fully solvent and that it is manageable. I would like to ask if you, as the President of the Commission, who knows things about other countries, consider that by these statements, and by others that are already known and other details, if the debt or the temptation to compare the Spanish situation with that of other countries that are on the minds of all could be completely allayed.
To the President of the Spanish Government, I would like to specifically ask you one thing. Following the thread of an earlier question about the union demonstration this afternoon, does it seem logical to you that a socialist Member of Parliament, who was at the Commission yesterday on employment and defended that proposal about retirement age, at the same time as saying that if he could he was going to the demonstration this afternoon? I don't know if it is logical or illogical. How do you see it?
Mr. Durao Barroso . - Regarding the economic question, I would like to say that we should not start making any comparisons. In Europe we have different economies, with different problems and therefore I do not usually make comparisons because there is always some risk attached to making comparisons.
What I would like to remind you about is that there are now twenty-seven countries in the European Union with excessive deficits. We have a process underway to return to healthy public accounts in the coming financial years. Some will take longer than others, but the important thing is to progress towards consolidation.
Spain presented its updated Stability Programme on 1 February. The Commission services are studying it and will be making a recommendation to the Eurogroup and to ECOFIN at the right time, as with the other countries, under the excessive deficit procedure.
I am not going to add my speculations to those of the speculators and hence I shall make no further comments to that end. With one exception, and that is that I have true faith in the Spanish economy. There are many difficult situations throughout Europe and beyond its borders, which is why we must act in a coordinated manner to face these difficulties bravely and with determination. These are not situations belonging to a specific country or region, but rather they are generalised.
President of the Government . - In respect of your question, it is perhaps symbolic of what is going to happen. And what is going to happen? What will we do together to tackle the pension reform; of course, the Government, the Socialist Party, together with the main unions and I hope together with the other political forces, will prepare a work program within differing timeframes - since we are talking about a long-term project which must reflect the evolution of our main demographic figures.
President Durao Barroso has already expressed it: demography is one of the main problems deriving from an ageing population, from life expectancy.
Furthermore, Spain is one of those countries where life expectancy is still on the increase. As a country and as a people we are lucky that this is so. We are about to overtake Japan as regards increased life expectancy.
There is a second feature that differentiates us and which is going to affect us in the coming years: the generational end of one of the concepts with the most development in Spain - what is known as the 'baby boom', whereby that generation is now close to retirement. Until now, there have been generational strata, or generational caps of a not excessive number of people as a result mainly of the Spanish Civil War, until not long ago.
This is a reality that we cannot stop thinking about as a specific event and which will take place around 2025-2030. The current reality is that we have one of the most robust Social Security and pension systems funded by the public purse from our GDP and which has a surplus. 2009 has seen eight thousand million euros contributed to the pension system and this was, economically, a poor year.
Therefore, I would say that this is a mature, strong and serious country in which we can have a mature, responsible and serious debate. There are few Spaniards, or perhaps none at all, who do not wish for a system of social protection, a public pension system that is strong and which offers the best pensions possible. And we can achieve this if we all make an effort, based on responsibility and laying our ideas out on the table.
The Government feels that it is its responsibility to open this debate. It is not a debate seeking applause but rather a debate for the country, for confidence in the future of the Social Security system, it is a debate to work together calmly; I hope that we tackle the future of the pension system in the Toledo Pact and in our dialogue with the unions with this attitude. We will do it as a joint effort.
Q . - Mr President, you have said that some of the economic problems of Spain should have been tackled some time ago. You yourself have opened a two-month window to reach an agreement with the parliamentary groups and I would like to know whether, given your conviction that these agreements are now indeed necessary, albeit within a very short time-frame available to you, you do not now repent, to some extent, of now having made this offer previously.
I would also like to know to know to what extent the actions of the Head of State have influenced you to take this step.
President of the Government .- We should mark out the limits on some of these aspects. When I spoke about problems of the Spanish economy that are evident today and which have had such a clear impact, I was referring to the real estate bubble that was the subject of conversation at the beginning of the decade, of the century and that then disappeared from sight. Was sufficient diligence imposed or not, what were the causes…, what is clear is that the most negative effect of the financial crisis in Spain took place as a result of the situation of the over-development of the real estate sector. This has been generally accepted.
I thus feel that this problem should indeed have been tackled. What is certain is that nobody could imagine that the crisis was going to be as severe as it was and with such a negative impact, on employment in particular. The loss of jobs in this process of economic crisis is undoubtedly the most complicated and difficult characteristic of the crisis and the one which will require the most effort from the Spanish people. Other countries have suffered other repercussions.
As regards agreements. During the course of the work done to tackle the crisis we have reached agreements, for example the agreement on how exactly to support the financial system and subsequently the agreement on how to restructure the financial system. This was extremely important and an issue to which I give great political value. And a great many of the measures to tackle the crisis have received the support of a majority of the parliamentary groups.
We now need to make a special effort. Why? Because recovery is close, we know it is only just around the corner and that agreement and reforms are at their most useful precisely in the start-up phase of recovery; this includes both political and social agreements because they stimulate confidence. That is why the present is such a crucial moment.
I can assure you that we have tried to reach agreements on more than one occasion. Or do you think that the Conference between the President of the Government and the Heads of the Autonomous Regions in order to reach agreement with the latter on an austerity plan, on fiscal consolidation or on a reduction in the public deficit was not an endeavour to reach agreement? Unfortunately some of the Autonomous Regions did not support this plan to reduce the deficit or to achieve fiscal consolidation.
Despite this we will try again. We will lay another proposal on the table. Why? Because this consensus of efforts is a very positive attempt to aid the country to exit the crisis and to favour economic recovery. The best measure of confidence.
We have set a deadline of two months to tackle four fundamental aspects to boost recovery towards more healthy economic growth. With the political will and ideas, proposals and initiatives from all parliamentary groups, as well as from the Government, of course, this may all be achieved within a period of two months, since we have already debated - I believe up to eight times now - the major issues and we are all aware of what they are: unemployment firstly and most importantly; then credit, a reduction in the deficit and a more competitive Spanish economy. A whole raft of ideas and proposals have been made, brought to Parliament on many occasions by the parliamentary groupings and by the Government; we are now endeavouring to prioritise them and apply them urgently with the maximum support.
In fact, not only do I not repent, bur rather I wish that this endeavour at such a propitious time reaches its final destination. And, of course, the instructions I have given to the three people, to the three members of the Government who are working tirelessly since the debate and who will represent the Government in the negotiations on the following Thursday, are to employ dialogue and negotiations with all the parties, and in particular with the Popular Party (PP), to its very limits and its very ends.
Thank you very much