Speech and subsequent Q&A session with the President of the Government at the Progressive Governance Conference
José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Zapatero addressed the Progressive Governance Conference on February 18, 2010, praising Gordon Brown's crisis leadership and advocating for renewed financial regulation and social democratic values.
- Main themes
- Progressive governance, social democratic values, financial crisis response, Gordon Brown's leadership, financial regulation, public deficit reduction, fiscal stimulus, tax havens, conservative ideology critique, economic recovery, role of the state
- Duration
- ~21 min
- Words
- 2,506
- Sentences
- 107
- Readability
- 45
- Grade
- 12.8
- Syntax
- 3.10
- Vocabulary
- 2.01
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
107 sentences in 40 paragraphs
My thanks go to Peter Mandelson for this invitation and to Gordon Brown for allowing me to be here today among this group of friends and colleagues from the progressive world in Europe.
Firstly, I would just like to say one thing; in fifty years time, when they write about and examine events during this economic and financial crisis, as we have done in books and other articles on the crisis of the 1930s, I am sure the analysis of what happened in these first few years of this decade will mention one name, one political leader, who stood out above the rest for the proposals and solutions he put on the table to tackle a crisis unlike any seen before it; a star of the financial system, a beacon to light the way. The first leader, the first person in a position of power with whom I spoke about the possible response to rescue the financial system, public savings and, therefore, the economy, was Gordon Brown.
Gordon Brown is the political leader who has designed the agenda for responding to the most significant financial crisis suffered, or that will ever be experienced, by our generation. That is how we see the situation in the European Council. His model for saving the financial system inspired the whole of Europe and his model for coordinating a global stimulus response inspired the G-20. That is Gordon Brown and the degree of leadership he commands.
However, I must say that my appreciation and admiration of Gordon Brown is not only due to his capacity to provide a response to situations of financial crisis; there are other character traits that I also greatly admire in Gordon Brown. He is an upstanding leader, a good friend, an honest man and one of those leaders who values hard work over short-term easy success. For these reasons, I have an especially high opinion and a particularly fond impression of Mr Gordon Brown.
I believe that his character represents an excellent model for a strong resurgence of the progressive and social democratic movement. Why? Because the first thing that will be done when we exit this financial and economic crisis is determine which values should take centre stage for the new future, for the coming decades, and those values will be used to create policies, and priorities will be taken from those policies. Therefore, the first great question is a question of ideals, of values.
The values that represent social democracy are values of balance and fairness; harmony; cohesion; of equal opportunities; the value of merit; work and talent; restraining overzealous ambition and easy speculation in all economic areas. Those are the values that must carry weight once this crisis is over. Those are the values that must replace the values and ideals that have dominated in previous decades and that gave rise to this serious financial and economic crisis in the first place.
In the financial system? No regulation, more new products, more new instruments… For what? To speculate more easily and get rich even more quickly, unlimited profits and unlimited speculation. These are conservative ideals in the financial system and in other parts of the economy.
Let's free up all the land in a country so there can be limitless speculation, so land values can be re-valued and so there can be more and more construction, so the cost of housing endlessly rises and rises … What ideals does that support? The conservative ideals that say the best thing is for there to be no regulation, not of the financial system, not on land and not on urban planning issues.
What we need to do is rebuild the era of regulation. Dear friends and colleagues, it is now the turn of our Governments to intervene in the financial system. We will gradually step back when things settle down, but we cannot leave things as there were. We are not going to give up on new regulation, we are not going to give up on control over all financial products and subject them to regulation, and we are not going to give up on ending the reign of tax havens. We cannot give up on these things. This must be the commitment made by all progressive nations and policies.
When the markets froze, States and Governments had to spend more and create fiscal stimulus packages to save the financial system and ensure the economy did not sink any further.
It is a somewhat incredible paradox that, as a consequence of the need to make significant public investment and significant public spending, the markets we came to the rescue of are now making demands, examining us and trying to create obstacles.
I would like this panorama to be contemplated by the international bodies that so often pronounce on the solvency of countries: let it be remembered that public deficits are where they are because the theories about the financial system held by those that so vehemently demanded Governments to reduce deficits prevailed.
Such a paradox and such contradiction! The Prime Minister of Norway was absolutely right.
Of course we are going to reduce deficits, but we are not going to reduce regulation of the financial system, nor control, nor supervision. Of course we are going to reduce deficits, but when economic recovery becomes active, not simply to feed the short- and medium-term interests of certain funds. We are not going to fall into the trap set by the ideals of those who caused the financial crisis in the first place. We are going to reduce the deficit, but not at the cost of damaging social cohesion. We are going to reduce the deficit with the highest degree of austerity and in order to invest in a productive economy.
That is the commitment from the progressionists: to support the productive economy, merit, effort, education and talent; but also to apply the brakes hard on speculation, easy money and that part of economic globalisation that wishes to escape all forms of control.
There are two priority policies: for energy to be more competitive; and the Communication Technology development policy. Therein lie the two decisive sources for good economic growth; from where the most productivity can be taken, the most competitiveness and the most innovation.
Finally, progressive Governments and policies hold a view of the world that promotes cooperation, coordination and union. We have a global economy, we have a global financial market that, properly structured, favours prosperity. But we need a global public policy for that to happen because no one State, however strong and powerful, can respond to each and every problem.
Our first field of action and first area for cooperation is Europe. It would be a good idea for there to be scope for regional cooperation in the world and an institutionalised scope for supraregional cooperation, such as the G-20, in these two areas of activity because globalisation has several very regional aspects to it. For example, the European economy is highly inter-related; therein lies the first step on which cooperation policies are fundamental.
That is Europe, and Europe today exists for all; for all the countries that form part of it, the European Union is a powerful builder of hope for prosperity and balance. And also for solidarity, such as the solidarity that, whenever I can, I publicly express for Mr Papandreu, for Prime Minister Papandreu, and for all the people of Greece, because the majority of them, the large majority of them, are in no way responsible for what has happened, much less the Government of Mr Papandreu, who deserves our trust in the steps he has taken and the credibility he is demonstrating. He deserves the trust of the European institutions, he deserves the trust of the markets and he has the trust of every European Government.
Europe is a progressionist response to create balanced globalisation and for globalisation to be governed. This is the most progressionist response we have: to gain values, to promote innovative policies and to join forces and cooperate in the world of the "think tanks", in the world of political parties and, of course, in the world of Governments and societies.
Thank you.
Q&A Session wik the President of the Government
Q. My question is to Prime Minister Rodríguez Zapatero, if we are talking about Government take a step back, how can the Government operate in this area at the same time as give space to civil society and civil organisations? What will happen in this regard?
President of the Government. This question leads me on to something I feel I need to explain. When we talk about the Government, about what is public, I am talking about society, about the general interest. The opposite of that is private interest, which logically lies in the field of private economics, in the natural search for interests, investment and profit.
However, we need to recover an old ideology: what is public is also in the general interest. Now, those who do not much like the idea that I defend the general interest always try to place politics in a negative light.
This is another of the risks that come with this serious economic and financial crisis: the discrediting of policies so that politics, so that Governments, do not have sufficient weight to regulate the markets, enough strength to create order and to ensure the general interest prevails above all else.
Peter pointed something out very clearly when he asked how it is at a meeting of progressionists, that we end up talking about the markets and short-term bonds? I think we need to tell the markets, to tell investors, that they should have a medium- and long-term perspective. They should also be interested in economic recovery, of all economies, and therefore should not be playing the short-term game but rather favour stability and tranquillity in all countries.
This is not only an interest held by Governments but it is rather a collective interest. Governments have had to step in and save the financial system, a good part of the private system, and we are going to step back so that private initiative can continue being the driving force of the economy and for there to be profits and investments. But they need to be asked to look at the long term, not only short-term profit and speculation, as we have seen in recent years in many areas. There is also room for mutual understanding to exist with many of those involved in the management of investments, the large investors.
I believe this is an important message that needs to be conveyed. There need not only be confrontational dialogue between Governments and the markets. That would get us nowhere. There should be a route map with reasonable interests from the markets and responsibility from Governments.
Of course, we must reduce the volume of debt we have acquired and, of course, we must reduce the deficit, but reasonably so, with no huge leaps and bounds; just as Governments are giving the financial system time to reorganise itself, restructure itself, and supporting them in this process. I believe that to be in the common interest and I hope that this can be an idea that, when shared by everyone concerned, is listened to.
Q. My question is for the rotating President of the European Union. Commissioner Almunia this morning described the Lisbon Strategy as being general objectives and good intentions. How can we convert it into something that works better?
President of the Government. Through firm political commitment and new rules. The six months that we have, especially the European Council in March and the European Council in June, are going to be decisive. The 2020 Strategy and the action guidelines are going to be approved.
We have several ideas on the go; we have been analysing them in Brussels and the Permanent President, Van Rompuy, has presented a governance document that amends the current scheme regarding the National Reform Plans that Governments usually present to Brussels, in terms of when they are actually presented. One of the ideas is for them to presented at the same time as the Budgets, in order for there to be greater coherence, and another idea is for there to be more European Economic Councils and, therefore, for the Prime Ministers, the European leaders, to be more involved in European Government.
There are more demanding rules and incentives for compliance with the objectives we are going to define, which we want to be few, in the 2020 Strategy; objectives such as the 3 per cent of GDP for R&D+i. That 2020 Strategy must also include a firm and determined decision regarding development of the Single Market. I think that is fundamental.
This is the great and most successful example of economic cooperation. The domestic market in the European Union has generated competition, innovation and prosperity, an economic sector. I must give you a figure: 40 per cent of productivity growth in an economy, 40 per cent nowadays, comes from the development of the Information Society, the Communication Technologies.
If we build a single digital market in the European Union, we will have built the single largest source of productivity. The countries of Europe are already well-developed digitally, we have important ICT companies and we must have more content; but if we build a digital market of five-hundred million people, we will have made significant progress in innovation.
For example, electronic business, which generates productivity, innovation and competition, is a rare thing among European countries. There is considerable development in every country and, if we harmonise our rules for electronic business, we will be making considerable progress.
Finally, I would just like to say one thing about Governments and the markets. I believe there must be prudent position, one that brings Governments and the markets closer together. There is a difference between the Governments and the markets in the public eye, an important one! - Governments have names and faces, whereas the markets are anonymous entities in this debate. Proof of this fact lies in that we never talk about Mr So-and-so's market… No, but we do talk about Prime Minister Brown's or Prime Minister Papandreu's Government.
The sense of responsibility is very different: the markets assign resources, they are the best method of assigning economic resources, that is clear, and the Governments must stand up for the general interest.
However, there is no need for us to take up positions on opposites sides of the fence; it is good for the markets to have a Government that creates proper order. Order is good for the markets and, therefore, the markets, private initiative, cannot maintain an attitude of distrust towards the Governments. And the Governments must favour ordered private initiative; but at the same time provide equal opportunities, provide minimum guarantees for education, health and retirement, where there is normally less business and more interest, and where the private sector operates in a different manner or, more often than not, does not operate at all.