Press conference by the President of the Government following the European Council meeting

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

16 December 2010 · Press conference following the European Council meeting

Context
Zapatero addressed reporters after the December 2010 European Council meeting in Brussels, summarizing decisions on eurozone stability and crisis mechanisms.
Main themes
Euro stability, permanent crisis resolution mechanism, Treaty revision, European economic governance, fiscal consolidation, European Central Bank capital increase, Eurozone competitiveness, EU trade relations, Spain-Germany bilateral summit, monetary union, eurozone reform
Duration
~37 min
89th percentile
Words
4,456
89th percentile
Sentences
163
83rd percentile
Readability
45
50th percentile
Grade
13.6
63rd percentile
Syntax
3.25
77th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
10th percentile
Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 37%36%
  • Institutional 25%25%
  • Social 16%16%
  • Ceremonial 14%13%
  • Geopolitical 8%8%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

163 sentences in 66 paragraphs

President of the Government . Good afternoon. I would like to report on the progress made during this European Council; a Council at which important decisions have been adopted to strengthen the Euro and the monetary stability of the European Union, and, in particular, of the Eurozone.

Above all, there is a political will behind these decisions and these commitments that have been made. The political will is that the Heads of State and Government, together with the European institutions, have expressed and ratified that they will do whatever is necessary to guarantee the stability of the Euro, a currency that has demonstrated its strength since it became legal tender, and which has undoubtedly been a great success in the European project, and which, moreover, symbolises this European project to a great extent.

You are aware that the specific decisions adopted in this Council are related to the so-called Permanent Crisis Resolution Mechanism and the corresponding revision of the Treaty, which is necessary for its implementation. The Council has set the bases for this mechanism, which had been agreed upon, as you are aware, in the Eurogroup meeting, and this Council has established that the European stabilisation mechanism will not be employed until it comes into force in 2013. As regards its fundamental characteristics, we have approved the principles approved in the Eurogroup without any amendments thereto.

In addition to setting up the mechanism of a permanent nature in response to a crisis situation and this revision of the Treaty, the Council has adopted the decision to proceed with the coordination of European governance. It has underlined and strengthened the commitment of the Member States to the stability of the Eurozone through the reaffirmation of the fiscal consolidation plans and the reform programmes to increase productivity and the competitiveness of the economies in the Eurozone.

In summary, we have taken a major step forward in this new phase of strengthening the Euro and the financial stability of those countries that make up this economic area.

Moreover, the Central European Bank plays a major role in this global commitment to the Euro and to the European monetary system. The Council has expressed its support for the independence, autonomy and actions of the Central European Bank. Furthermore, the Council has expressed its satisfaction at the decision of the Central European Bank to increase its capital, to double its capital, which will undoubtedly strengthen its capacity to act. A strong central bank, made even stronger today, is a guarantee of stability for the common currency and for a shared monetary system.

The European Council has also asked for work to be intensified in order to complete all those areas pending their final definition regarding European economic governance by June, which means that this Council, in the same way as we have seen in the European Councils held since 2008, has taken another step forward in common governance in economic matters in Europe.

And, from my point of view, we are going to see significant steps forward that will affect key policies from an economic viewpoint in the short term in this process of integration.

What lies behind this? Undoubtedly an ever-increasing shared awareness that this is a single currency project, a shared monetary system project, which also requires a shared economic policy in certain essential aspects such as those related to fiscal policy, employment policy and competitiveness policies in order for this raft of factors to result in increased stability and a future of economic growth for the European Union.

In addition to the economic aspects, the Council has also assessed this morning a report from the High Representative of the Union for Foreign Affairs regarding the EU's relations with its main strategic partners, and it has expressed its priority objective to foster more in-depth commercial relations between the European Union and different regional areas and countries in the world, convinced that the opening-up, the extension of trade relations and the fostering of trade relations, are undoubtedly a key area for economic growth and the recovery of our economies.

Finally, I should also highlight and inform you, aside from the European Council but still focused on relations with other countries, that I have agreed with Chancellor Merkel to hold a bilateral Spain-Germany Summit in Madrid on 3 February 2011; this will be a summit with a high economic value. This will include participation from German and Spanish business leaders, as well as German and Spanish workers' representatives and trade unions. As I said, in Madrid on 3 February 2011.

Q . I would like, Mr. President of the Government, for you to tell me what point you reached in the debate. It would seem that during the working dinner yesterday there was a debate on the possible issue of Eurobonds upon a proposal from the President of the Eurogroup, Jean-Claude Juncker.

I would also like to know whether this common economic policy you announced for the whole of the Eurozone will be marked by the France-Germany axis or whether it will be a policy designed and shared by all members of the Eurozone.

President of the Government . Firstly, regarding the debate on the Eurobonds, I would say that there have been certain comments made, rather than proposals. Hence it is not on the agenda nor is it forecast to form a part of the scope of the European Union or the Eurozone.

We have two basic instruments at hand to strengthen our sovereign debt situation: firstly, each country must implement measures, and put them into practice, relating to fiscal consolidation, both in the medium and the long term. We are talking, of course, about fiscal consolidation and the strength of sovereign debt, particularly as regards the long term, although we are currently seeing more tension on many occasions in the short term.

Secondly, this strength of the monetary system and of sovereign debt is related to the role played by the Central European Bank, which, in my opinion, is a well-played role. I should remind you of a phrase quoted publicly by Jean-Claude Trichet at the last meeting, after holding the Governing Council, when he announced, as he usually does, the Bank's decisions; a phrase which in my opinion has a very high value. Jean-Claude Trichet said that the markets should not underestimate the capacity of reaction by the European institutions in defence of the Eurozone. I believe that the central European Bank is strong, yesterday it became stronger and this is a guarantee for us all.

Hence, these are the two constants or the two channels at our disposal to guarantee the strength of the sovereign debt. Secondly, the process of European construction is a shared process. The best evidence of this is that all the major decisions require unanimous approval. The importance of France and Germany is clear, they are the two strongest economies in the Eurozone and consequently their opinion is fundamental, but fortunately we belong to an organisation of democratic countries and democratic institutions where arguments, proposals and debate all count.

I am going to say something about a specific matter, which is my perception from the last few years. You are aware that Spain and its ruling Government have always defended a more pro-European approach from the European institutions; it has always defended greater European Community policy and it has always defended greater integration in a specific manner regarding economic policy. Let's say that this vision was a less ambitious vision not long ago of European countries and of these very important European countries. From my point of view, this vision today fortunately opens new doors and yesterday we spoke for the first time, at a fledgling stage, about fiscal harmonisation.

This is undoubtedly an important piece of news, which will need to be developed and which will take time; but this is the direction we are moving in and this is very positive for the future of our economies and, of course, for the economy of the European Union.

Q . Mr. President of the Government, we could see yesterday how you talked with Chancellor Merkel at the start of the meeting. We don't know whether, in addition to setting February's date for the upcoming Spain-Germany Summit in Madrid, you had the opportunity to discuss any other matters.

I also believe that both you and the Portuguese Prime Minister, Jose Socrates, explained the fiscal consolidation measures being implemented to your counterparts and those that you are prepared to implement. Along these lines, I don't know whether you brought up or explained the reform of the pension system as a long-term measure - you just said it was important, particularly in the long term - and whether the Government is prepared to bring out the pension reform on 28 January and include, in spite of the lack of consensus, the extension to the retirement age.

President of the Government . I believe that is five questions in one. That was a very clever speech!

I mainly spoke with Chancellor Merkel about the Summit. We have spent days preparing the date, the content and the format, above all regarding the participation of business leaders and trade unions, which, in my opinion, will be significant. We had already done this a few days ago in a lengthy telephone conversation that I held with the Chancellor. We didn't tackle any other specific issue except the Summit.

Secondly, at the dinner, as I said a few moments ago, there was a very interesting debate, in my opinion, about the current situation; yes, it is true, about the tensions regarding debt, about the economic crisis, but above all, about the future of greater economic integration, which has a very high value in my opinion.

All the Governments expressed our commitment to fiscal consolidation and the reforms, which are the two areas that almost exclusively occupy the debates.

Of course, in an area of this nature, it doesn't seem appropriate, for reasons of time and due to it being a debate dinner, to bring up the pension reform, although it is a very important matter, and we have to and will carry out this pension reform.

The Toledo Pact has issued a report, which is a basis for consensus. It seems correct to me, but the responsibility for drawing up the text and the changes in our pension system, both in the medium and long term, as is appropriate, are a matter for the Government. We have committed to a certain date: it will be passed by the Government on 28 January. From now until then we will be in contact with the various political parties; but I should say that the debate on our pension system and the reforms that we will make to our pension system are crucial. It is a debate in which we must have a vision of the future, a sense of responsibility and a capacity for commitment from all the political parties, as well as a wide-ranging social debate that the Government will foster to explain the sound and positive reasons for the reform of the pension system.

I don't wish to go on about this but there are countries which already reformed their pension system in the nineties or the first decade of this century. We, as you are aware, have fifteen years ahead of us of reasonable stability in the Social Security system, but as of fifteen or twenty years we will start to hit problems.

Those countries that are able to anticipate these difficulties and lay out a roadmap so that everyone is aware that there won't be any problems in the next fifteen or twenty years are the countries that are going to be in a better position. I am not going to list the countries that have increased the retirement age to 67; among others the German bono, since we almost always talk about a bono in relation to Germany. We are obviously not talking about Bono, the President of the Lower House, although it's true that we have a president of our Lower House who is almost as strong as the German bono.

All countries are undergoing the same debate and Spanish society has one factor that should be in its favour in this debate. And we know that if we do this now, we will do it progressively. We will do it without the situation worsening and without taking drastic measures if we do it now.

There is another option: to do nothing. Of course, for this Government, and we are talking about fifteen or twenty years from now; this could be the easy option. We could leave it and when we hit problems, two or three years before the Social Security system has a serious problem in dealing with pensions due to our demographic evolution, it could be sorted out then.

But that is not what a country like Spain, a serious, forward-thinking country that seeks to be amongst the best, should do.

We all know, because it is well-known, that there are two factors that we need to deal with, I repeat, during the next fifteen to twenty years: firstly, the demographic boom of the sixties, which is the most populous Spanish generation, who will of course reach retirement age within fifteen or twenty years; and secondly, the phenomenon of the growth of immigration, which will also mean that there are many people who are going to retire in Spain, more than ever. We will go through an unheard of period of new pensioners in our country.

Let's do things now. Perhaps, in other areas we should have also done other things in the nineties or at the beginning of this century.

I always give the example of the major reforms carried out in Germany at the start of this century.

Yes, the Government maintains its proposal to increase the retirement age to 67, with certain flexibility. That is our proposal, but we obviously want to talk this through with all the political groups.

Q . The President of the Commission has just said that there was a commitment from the leaders to finish the clean-up of the European banks. I would like to know, in relation to this, if opinion is in favour, as the Bank of Spain proposed, of the savings banks communicating in detail the state of their finances by the end of December and what could be expected as a result of this attempt at transparency.

President of the Government . I should remind you of a previous issue: the stress tests in the month of July were made public as a result of a Spanish initiative. The stress tests for the Spanish banks and savings banks were the most extensive carried out, because they included all the banks, and with more stringent budgets and requirements than for any other financial system, and the results were positive. I would remind you of this because it is sometimes forgotten and I can see this when I hear certain analyses and certain observers. And that was only back in July, only a few months ago.

Furthermore, as you are aware, the Government and the Bank of Spain have established that the banks and the savings banks should provide periodic information in such a way that the market will receive standardised additional information on the development and construction portfolio and the residential mortgage portfolio, with a specific breakdown of the guarantees behind them: the relationship between the loan and the value, together with its corresponding guarantee, the state of payments and the cover established to deal with any possible impairment.

The savings banks will start to implement this at the end of this year while the banks will implement this as the same time as they issue their 2010 annual reports. Consequently, all the information will be provided by March 2011 with the same level of disaggregation as was used in the recent stress tests.

We are convinced that this process will help to dispel any doubts, to clarify things and that some of the analyses made of the financial sector, in particular of the savings banks, in the same way as happened before July, whereby what they said was not true as was evidenced by the stress tests; in the same way as with our new offensive, this will allow calm analysis and ensure that no-one gets carried away by the rumours or suspicions, it will be clearly seen how we are managing the whole process of our financial system, which I should remind you, in any event, has only received a cash injection from the FROB of a little more than ten thousand million euros, which is one of the lowest amounts, if not in fact the lowest, of all the major European countries.

Furthermore, you know that we have set a date, 24 December, to complete the whole process of restructuring the savings banks so that the size of the Spanish financial system is adapted to the size of the market, which is now, as a result of the crisis, more limited in size. On 24 December, the whole process of merging the former 45 savings banks in to the 17 that will remain in Spain will be concluded.

Q . Mr. President of the Government, of all the ideas that there have been on the debate held during yesterday's dinner - the extension of the Fund, the Eurobonds and the relaxing of the Fund's requirements - could you perhaps specify as far as possible what is Spain's position, because it would seem that no decision will be taken by the Council until circumstances start to develop; but I imagine that Spain already has a clear idea of which option would seem to be the most suitable.

President of the Government . Spain's position is the position taken by the Council's decisions; that is the position. When the Council's unanimous position is made clear, that is the position: the Permanent Mechanism in 2013, with those characteristics that are already known; a Provisional Mechanism as regards the amount, for the time being, and as regards the Eurobonds, I have already expressed myself. This is not the time to open this debate.

It will not be in the short term, nor probably in the medium term, beyond any intellectual or conceptual position that can be held regarding the Eurobond.

Do we have enough instruments available? Yes, to guarantee the strength. Some correspond to individual Member States and others to the Central European Bank and to the European institutions.

That is Spain's position, a position which contributes, as always, to unanimity and to the consensus of the European institutions, and which in regard to our interests, in this case as a specific country, we consider to be sufficient.

Q . Two questions, if you will allow me, Mr. President of the Government. Firstly, data has been published today by the Bank of Spain indicating that the autonomous regions have increased their borrowing by 27%. I would like to know if you are concerned by the fact that the effort at fiscal consolidation being made by the Central Government is being prejudiced, in some way, by the autonomous regions.

Secondly, at last night's dinner, was the subject of making the current Bailout Fund more flexible brought up or commented on? President of the Government. As regards the second question, the answer is no. The current Fund was not really under discussion. As I said, the dinner, above all, was a dinner to talk about the economic future of the European Union.

As regards the first question, it is normal that there has been an increase in the levels of borrowing by the autonomous regions. But I should add that the autonomous regions will meet the deficit objective set for 2010 which, as you know, is set at 2.4% of the Gross Domestic Product. Next week, the Vice-President for the Economy and the autonomous regions will release the figures.

Moreover, I should say, because it is one of the other things commented on by observers and analysts, quite probably through ignorance, that the autonomous regions in Spain are subject to a control process overseen by the Central Government. No autonomous region can issue debt without the authorisation of the Ministry of the Economy and the Treasury, and of the Government. I have seen this in some of the analyses made. And I will say that this is not authorised and that if an autonomous region is authorised to be in a more negative deficit situation, certain measures are required. And hence, we have the ability to control this situation.

And I would add something that seems very important to me: from our data, from the data of the General State Intervention, whose strength and credibility is well-known, it can be deduced that the public authorities in Spain, the vast majority of the autonomous governments and the local authorities, are taking joint responsibility for endeavouring to reduce the deficit and to moderating the debt. This is extremely important because, as you are well aware, on many occasions the debts on our fiscal consolidation have arisen, in part, because it is known that half of the public expenditure is in the hands of the autonomous regions and local authorities, and this generates debt.

But let's clear this up once and for all, because it's very important. What is very important is, firstly, the good will, the positive approach of the autonomous regions, which, as you know, have unreservedly accepted to provide periodic information, in the same way as the Government of Spain, on budgetary performance; and secondly, the Government of Spain obviously has the capacity to control the development of the deficit and the debt of the autonomous regions.

Everyone is meeting their targets, 99% of the autonomous and local government authorities are meeting their targets, and those who are not are obliged or will be obliged by the Government to meet them. I am not going to cite any recent example, but I could mention one autonomous region or another.

Q . Mr. President of the Government, I wanted to ask you a couple of questions, although you have already commented on one of them in relation to the pension reform. From what you have said, you are prepared to maintain the limit of 67 years of age, but is the Government prepared to pass this pension reform by itself, taking into account the rejection from all sides, even from the report of the Toledo Pact, but also from other social stakeholders out there, and to assume, in some way, the social cost that this reform is going to have, or that it will foreseeably have?

Another thing if you will permit me, very briefly. As you have mentioned, the President of our Lower House of Parliament, Mr. Bono, and the strength, without going into the debate on the leadership succession, Mr. Bono spoke two nights ago about the peacemaker in your Government. Who is the peacemaker in your Government, Mr. President?

President of the Government . The truth is that I am not an expert in these matters.

As regards the first question, which seems important to me, the Government is going to present the proposal of the pension reform system that Spain needs, that the workers and all citizens need and who should have a future imbued with confidence and security as regards their pensions. I repeat, today's forty- or fifty-year old workers, because we all know that this process doesn't affect those who are already receiving a retirement pension. This Government will do this with all the consequences and it will take responsibility for it. We have to take responsibility for the future of our pensions even if it's in fifteen years' time.

I have said that a far-reaching social debate would be highly suitable because I am convinced that, by means of a debate clarifying figures and measures relating to pensions, the vast majority of Spanish citizens, who realise what is at stake in this matter, will understand the reform.

As regards the political forces, each one demonstrates its own level of responsibility, its sense of responsibility and its sense of commitment. Of course the Government which I preside over, when the future of our pensions is at stake, which means the future of our key system of social protection and of our fiscal stability, of our expenditure, cannot be dependant nor will it be dependant upon electoral expectations, of one set of elections or another. No, this is something much more important.

I believe that all our citizens are aware that we are at a historical crossroads in the future of our economy, of our prosperity and our well-being, because tackling the seriousness of the economic crisis that we have suffered and are suffering means taking measures that are going to be historic. If we take them today, although this is not easy at present, we will be able to say in the future that we did what we had to do, what was done was what had to be done.

Countries go through critical times every so often. There are historic moments. We have been through some, which have been even more important for our coexistence in general. We are now faced with a critical time of great magnitude, a historical moment in time, and all the reforms we are making, all the changes we are making, the whole modernisation of the Spanish economy and all the planning to guarantee our solvency in the future, and that includes pensions, means making an effort and sacrifices today, but tomorrow this will means confidence, prosperity and employment. That is what, as the Government, we must explain time and again.

I am fully convinced that the main political parties are facing a moment of great responsibility. Do we expect to convince them?

Yes, because, moreover, as I said before, the proposal of increasing the retirement age to 67 will incorporate factors of reasonable flexibility. Not all situations are the same for all workers facing retirement, as is to be expected, nor is the time that they have worked or the work they have performed during their working life the same; but we must make changes and we have to extend their working life. The current average retirement age is 62.6 years of age. That is simply not sustainable in the long term.

That is the reality, the same as in Germany, France, England, Sweden or Denmark; so it would seem sensible that this is the reality in Spain, although, I repeat, for us it is a more long-term reality. But if we do this now, so much the better.

Thank you very much.